What if Yoda Went to Mustafar and Fought Anakin? - Star Wars Theory Fan-Fic

Grab your free month now at www.audible.com/starwarstheory
or text Star Wars Theory to 500-500 now.
With an Audible membership, you can download titles and listen offline, anytime, anywhere. The Audible app is free and can be installed on all smartphones and tablets. You can listen across devices without losing your spot. Audible members don’t have to worry about using their credits
right away. You can keep your credits for up to a year-and use them to binge on a whole series if you’d like!
And if you’re not loving your selection, you can simply swap it for another.
_______________________________________________________________________
In revenge of the Sith, we had obi wan fight Anakin, and Yoda fight palatine. Against obi-wan’s wishes, who requested to fight Sidious because he could not kill Anakin, was denied by Yoda and flat out was told that Palpatine would kill him.
This led to the outcome we had, where Yoda lost to Sidious, and obi-wan mutilated Anakin.
What if Yoda went to Mustafar? Now this fan fiction will be incorporating tons of fantasy battle type explanations as we need to understand the actual fight and who would win and then we can discuss what would happen in the galaxy as a result of this fight. In the past I’ve done a similar fan fiction, but this one will be more in depth on their fighting styles.
As obi-wan tells Yoda he can’t fight Anakin. Yoda agrees, and tells him to stay put in the temple and to not engage the emperor at all costs until he returns. This would keep obi-wan alive, and we can focus on Yoda’s journey.I feel Yoda knew where Anakin was, he just didn’t tell obi-wan for whatever reason. He told him to trust his feelings and that led him to speak to padme, resulting in him hiding in her ship as she travelled to mustafar.
Yoda would either travel to Mustafar, since I feel he already knew, or he would just sneak onto padme’s ship without even saying anything to her. It’s Yoda, he’s that stealthy.
Anakin and Padme run their dialogue. Padme doesn’t know about Anakin killing younglings, since obi-wan didn’t tell her. We could say Yoda told her, but let’s just go with the option of him sneaking onto her ship.
Anakin sees Yoda in the doorway of padme’s ship.
He is taken aback. The grandmaster is here. He isn’t nearly as angry as he was when Kenobi showed up. Anakin knows he’s in trouble. And he is about to pay for what he’s done.
Master Yoda…
No! Padme says. I didn’t bring him here.
Anakin looks enraged at her. He chokes her and Yoda uses the force to push Anakin back, tumbling to the ground.
A disgrace, you are, young Skywalker. Betray your friends, you have.
As Anakin gets up, he takes his robe off.
It is you who betrayed me. The Jedi never gave me the respect I deserved.
Entitled, you are. Pay you will, for all you have done.
If it wasn’t for your lack of empathy, the Jedi would still be alive. You are responsible for this.
Yoda shook his head.
Much to learn, you still have. Mistake it was, trusting you.
Anakin: Don’t make me kill you.
Try you will. Succeed, you will not.
Anakin ignites his saber but before he can leap at Yoda, the Jedi grand master was already at his feet, lightsaber slashing at his ankles. Anakin blocks it and realizes how fast the grand master is. He had never duelled him, and yet, here he thought he was a better fighter than him.
The two would fight an incredible duel. As molten lava surrounded them. Anakin would be wary of Yoda’s speed, and his small stature which proved difficult to fight against.
Yoda would need to be cautious of the youthful energy that Skywalker possessed. His stamina was natural, and didn’t require the force to enhance. Whereas Yoda pulled from the force to enhance his speed and agility due to his old age. He couldn’t fight like this forever, regardless how powerful he was in the force.
Anakin used form V djem So. This was a more aggressive fighting style that focused on offence rather than more defence like Kenobi’s form 3 soresu.
Yoda used form 4 ataru, this was also a very aggressive form. So with these two fighting, it would probably be a more intense fight than any other, since they both would be trying to kill one another with each hit, whereas with Kenobi, he was always defending, and blocking looking for an opening, super patient. This battle would just undulate between one being the agressor and the other being less aggressive, until they falter and get the upper hand, switching roles, tumultuously.

[@yamahakid450f]

Anakin: " I HATE YOU"!!!! Yoda: "Give a fuck, I do not."

[@kevinchen3405]

HAHAHAHA 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 LMFAO

[@koop2.1.5]

💀

[@BassBoxTurkey]

Im dying 🤣🤣🤣🤣 LMAO

[@jy2334]

Lmao 😂

[@jy2334]

I'm fkn dead 😂 I

[@KeysofIDproductions]

Yoda *after cutting Anakin's feet off*: Almost the same height, we are *chuckles*.

[@u.v.s.5583]

That's outrageous and unfair. How can you be a Sith lord and have no legs!?

[@SangheiliSpecOp]

"take a seat, young Skywalker" *sets a chair down by Anakin*

[@ricardospaniard9050]

@@SangheiliSpecOp yeah... A wheelchair 😄😄

[@jedaye47]

@@u.v.s.5583 *Darth Maul disliked that*

[@AOV-rv3ov]

@@u.v.s.5583 tragedy of darth sand!

[@yeeticus7206]

Just a small point, padme wouldn’t have travelled to mustafar if obi wan hadn’t told her about anakin so Yoda couldn’t sneak onto her ship

[@zackcross7190]

She could’ve grown worried about Anakin after not returning from Mustafar for several days.

[@yeeticus7206]

@@zackcross7190 why wouldn’t anakin have returned from mustafar?

[@zackcross7190]

@@yeeticus7206 He was on Mustafar taking care of the Separatists. Sidious had also ordered him send to a message to the Trade Federation ships telling them to shut down all the droid units. After that Palpatine likely gave him other tasks to keep him busy and away from Padmé.

[@KoolKeithProductions]

@@yeeticus7206 A bigger problem for me was SWT saying that Padme wouldn't want Anakin around after his arrest. What nonsense. Even after Obi told her that he went to the Dark Side and killed Younglings, she still went to see Ani. And you can say that she didn't believe it, but once she looked into his eyes, asked him about it, and he denied nothing, she knew it was all true. Yet she STILL said lets run away and raise our child together. She would have never abandoned him, no matter what.

[@Anenome5]

Yoda could've told Padme instead.

[@darthjar9117]

Here’s an idea. What if Obi-Wan and Yoda double teamed Palpatine and then went after Anakin?

[@rq4740]

Uhhhhh poor choice of words

[@darthjar9117]

@@rq4740 only for perverts I guess

[@akashvk787]

@@rq4740 double teamed palpatine 🤣🤣🤣

[@jakekitzmiller7065]

I read Padme at first instead of Palpatine. Now I completely understand why Anakin doesn't trust the Jedi.

[@rq4740]

@@jakekitzmiller7065 what if they DID doubleteam padme then go after anakin? 🤔

[@jjfromthebigland781]

Anakin: I HATE YOU!! Yoda: de-feeted you are.

[@skwish_rl]

One of the best comments in here😭

[@VVV953]

😁😁😁🤣🤣🤣🤣👌

[@Zzues]

Nice 😆

[@bikramparmar1642]

UNDERRATED COMMENT

[@itsmealaska9089]

loving this comment

[@andrecoyote13]

Yoda: “Cane I do not need… Health Insurance Fraud i have committed…”

[@nicky21111]

🤣🤣🤣

[@papaofthejohns5882]

Health Insurance? Is this some kind of American joke I'm too European to understand?

[@jasonbergman5781]

@@papaofthejohns5882 probably

[@h5v1y0]

@@papaofthejohns5882 yeah it’s basically lying to the government and exploiting healthcare insurance

[@Blitzkrieg23]

Thanos vs master in Star Wars universe

[@tyyt2146]

“Try, you will” “Succeed, you will not” that sounds good until you realize yoda’s also said “Do or do not, there is no try”

[@LemonCry]

well that can make it sound even better, suggesting that Anakin will not make it with him

[@VeraTepes]

In nearly 2 seconds, Yoda had done 4 spins. 2 Horizonal at ground level, and two jumping vertical, at shoulder level. Anakin had no idea what happened, before he was thrown into the Lava, all limbs completely severed.

[@dirkauditore8413]

Yoda would certainly win but not that fast imo. Anakin was still very talented

[@s1gmaduck]

@@dirkauditore8413 talent is nothing without skills

[@ethanwinters9419]

@@s1gmaduck Anakin was very skilled.

[@pnss3569]

Anakin is faster than Yoda according to the RoTS novel so no this wouldn’t happen

[@UnitedWars]

@@pnss3569 it doesn’t look like it in the movie

[@Mr12Relic]

Obi-Wan: Only a Sith deals in absolutes. Anakin: That's also an absolute statement. Obi-Wan: Precisely shoots force lightning

[@darkdesmond6706]

Haha that was brilliant man! Very underrated comment.

[@MrBluntz]

Comments don’t normally make me laugh, but this was quite funny haha

[@alexandrubaginean7369]

Genius !

[@jondickinson6830]

This is getting out of hand, now there are two of them!

[@pride2184]

Yoda and saying do or do not. Their is no try some shit like that

[@christinajade69]

"until Palpatine would rise from Exegol - just kidding" You almost had me for a second. 😂😂

[@Blitzkrieg23]

Thanos vs master in Star Wars universe

[@gamercore5216]

Yeah everyone knows he's at byss

[@danzydan2479]

I spat out my coffee when that happen. Bastard. LoL.

[@slayerphoenixx6947]

In the subtitles you'll see Mexico instead of Exegol

[@laurencebarnes5361]

@@slayerphoenixx6947 made me chuckle actually

[@davidalan528]

I don’t think Yoda’s faking it with the cane. I think he’s not just using the Force to speed himself up, he’s using it to breathe flexibility into his limbs. He’s Yoda - a totally empty vessel to be filled by the Force, but only when he needs.

[@rltofuiii]

Necroing your comment but you're on the money. Yoda constantly talks about letting go. If he is not fighting, he probably just accepts he's getting slower and slower. Cane? Normal thing about life. No vanity, pride or ego. Just someone in tune.

[@joshuawilford9675]

She didn’t die from “loss of will” , Sidious transferred her life force into Anakin to keep him alive. Sidious is the one who planted the dreams in Anakins head.

[@eatyagrandmasgrapes3858]

Makes sense since palpatine created anakin..

[@darthsion8081]

Nah. Anakin has the force ability known as foresight so he can sense the future

[@darthsion8081]

@@eatyagrandmasgrapes3858 actually Anakin was created by the force since plagueis and Palpatine messing with midichlorians

[@mercifulldestruction6428]

@Jorge Jones not true, in the movie it said that padmes medical condition was alright and that she's loosing the will to live

[@niftypunk7120]

@@eatyagrandmasgrapes3858 Palpatine did not create Anakin. The chosen one was created by The Force itself after Darth Plagueis and his apprentice, Darth Sidious were manipulating the midichlorians for their evil purposes

[@hunterkiller1440]

Obi Wan just needs to stand in the Senate podium to have the high ground while Palpatine is sitting in office.

[@grayski3324]

It's over, Palpatine! I have the high ground!

[@DolchiO07]

Palpatine: *Blasts Obi Wan with force lightning* "Young fool. Your feeble high ground is NOTHING compared to all the power of the dark side."

[@datguy8006]

@Bully Maguire give me rent

[@suiyeethepinkunicorn7780]

Obi wan don’t try it

[@evanhensley1246]

Wish theory would play battlefront 2 campaign

[@SpaceMonkeyBoi]

Yoda on mustafar: "what about his legs? He don't need legs." Anakin: "👁👄👁"

[@floriantinschert5542]

Looks like meats back on the menu!

[@beau.007]

nice little lotr reference

[@AntonioBarbarian]

"To where you are going, need legs you will not."

[@LovesCoffee]

My god lotr and star wars, my brian glitched for a sec.

[@VitunVatiVille]

I understood that reference. Nice one!

[@Axi_osity]

I always wondered why Yoda and Kenobi didnt team up on Vader, like I can see them going to Mustfar, then heading over the Coruscant to wack Palpatine

[@danielboggan2479]

Update says why, Obi Wan will not survive confrontation with palpatine. And even if they did palpatine would be on the move, he’s not an idiot

[@freec1261]

@@danielboggan2479 remember obi wan kenobi master of trolling 😂

[@Tesseract.2012]

Because a double attack one Sith would alert the other one to the Jedi’s survival. Either Palpatine or Anakin can surround themselves with an army of troopers, taking away the Jedi’s advantage of fighting an opponent alone with no interference or backup. Plus both Sith are vulnerable when they’re separated and isolated and it’s smarter to take them out at the same time.

[@wolftal1178]

I think the reason Obi-Wan didn’t stop Anakin from choking Padmé, was because he wanted Anakin to do it himself in hopes of bringing him back to the light side. Yoda on the other hand wouldn’t have been so certain on this point and would have taken more instant action as you described. However you really ought to do a sequel to this, where Vader escapes and Obi-Wan and Luke have to track him down.

[@volf4o]

And I always thought that Obi Wan was afraid that Anakin could snap her neck in a blink of an eye and had to step very very carefully.

[@darthparallax5207]

@@volf4o he was. Obi-Wan isn't that fast. Bluntly, Sidious and Yoda are both fast. Like, stupid fast. Fast enough.

[@sunflow57]

If Yoda worked in a retail store and met a Karen: *"Entitled, you are. Pay for those products you broke, you must."*

[@articusramos808]

Karen: Uhhrrghh... I am entitled...pay....Pay...no..no... yes. PAY I WILL! *Violently slams money on counter*

[@DeathMetalThrasher]

Yoda: A disgrace, you are. Give Karen's around the world a bad name, you do. Commit genocide against the Karen population, I will.

[@drharrybhardwaj893]

Obi wan: it’s over palpatine I have the high ground Palpatine: you underestimate my unlimited power

[@monkey_8227]

Obi-Wan: dont try it Palpatine: *shoots lightnings* Obi-Wan: *blocks lightnings* Palpatine: *gets weakened by lightnings* Obi-Wan: you were my Senate Sheev ... i loved you

[@mymilalyflala4131]

dont try it........palps: argh........obi: swing cut reflect.....both injured but palls falls, while obi retains high ground

[@epiccraftmine4976]

Obi wan: Don't try it. Palatine (does the scream while spinning like he did against Windu and the other Jedi masters) Obi wan (cuts him like he did Anakin)

[@TomKrochock]

Obi Wan: I have the high ground. Palpatine: Flings him into the lava with very little effort Game over.

[@mckenzie-grayeevans5876]

I really want to like this but it has 66 likes.😩😂

[@JoeyGarzaHealth]

It’s so crazy to think how just some choices would make such an impact to the story. The Jedi really did fall because of their own bad choices.

[@MT-UK]

Your voice acting is on POINT! Your creativity is amazing and the passion for Star Wars is palpable. What you could come up with if you were hired by Disney is just mind blowing- you and Jon Favreau would bring a whole new meaning to the ‘Rule of Two’

[@Alroytt]

That palpatine impression blew me away

[@shkotayd9749]

Yoda on the high ground to Anakin: "When shorter you about to become, equal in stature, shall we finally be."

[@DIDCHOI]

You’ve grown too master Yoda…more beautiful I mean…

[@williamwinstead5395]

You win the internet...

[@joestorywrestler20]

I’m so happy Theory is still doing fan fiction, I love sitting down and relaxing after work or college classes while listening to these and could do it all day.

[@adamwhite202]

Frank Garrett can win

[@bamaboi8814]

Same man it’s good to relax after marching band or a lab

[@melkor3496]

Same

[@PHOENiXIlRiSiNG]

well said

[@Promethean_fire]

Me too, that’s what made me subscribe years ago

[@cp368productions2]

The reason for Obi Wan not pushing at Anakin would be that doing so would likely break Padme's neck. Anakin was choking her with the force, not with his hand so force push could have caused her neck to snap, as it would not break the hold but just suddenly shift it. Padme would still die in this because Anakin would have still been a Sith and that is why she lost the will to live.

[@Sjjnish]

I dont think she would die, because she would be able to see him and he would be almost in his intact form just with new feet. It would be a completely different story if he was there as his mutilated form from the end of the actual fight between him and obiwan

[@ammo7276]

SIDIOUS killed her. He used the force to give her life to an akin. He planted those dreams in his mind and drove him to the dark side. She didn’t die because of that. She died because sidious was draining the life out of her for an akin.

[@Kairac112]

@@ammo7276 That completely voids Vader's character though. His whole thing is hating himself for everything he's done, top of the list killing his wife. What I like to think is Obi-wan demands Anakin let her go. It was his choice to let go, eventually.

[@ammo7276]

@@Kairac112 but all the Evil things he did were when he turned to the dark side. He killed the young, the jedi, his wife. Before he started getting close to palpatine he was well on his way to possibly becoming a master. (even though i dont think he would have gotten that rank for a long time). There is plenty of theories of palpatine draining the life out of padme to save anakin from dying. He should have died when he was burned in lava. But he didn't? Why would that be? Did palpatine force heal anakin? Palpatine was to far away for that. Sure he was well connected to the force and it was possible he force healed anakin. She did die full of sadness, regret, and possibly hate. But there is a lot of evidence showing palpatine drained the life out of padme to help keep anakin alive long enough so he could bring him to his ship and fix him. I'm all ears to any of theories or what you believe really happened.

[@crownprincesebastianjohano7069]

Many have asked: "Even with Sidious and Vader dead, how do Yoda et al reverse Order 66 and the Empire?" Well there would be a power struggle for sure. But, if Yoda and Kenobi, working with Organa and a large block of Senators could prove Sidious was behind starting the War, the could easily sway the Senate into passing a resolution reestablishing the Republic and electing a new Chancellor in place of whatever succession plan Palpatine left... That legitimate Chancellor, with the Senate and most of the civil service, and remnants of the Jedi, may be persuasive enough to rally most of the former Republic to the Senate. The Moffs, if they had been established and in power in their systems/sectors that quickly might object and fight, but they would face emboldened planetary governments that were not fully dismantled yet. Mas Amada, if he fled, might try to claim power from somewhere, but I doubt he carries much support. The Clone Army's attitude is hard to discern with Palpatine dead. Would they follow Tarkin and the admiralty? Do certain generals/admirals enter the fray with their own claims to power, or simply seize systems within their immediate grasp? Ultimately we might see a civil war between forces led by the Senate, and probably a majority of the Republic, versus various military factions, big and small, as well small-scale separatism led by Moffs or their own governments. And that doesn't really take into account the large CIS forces still in the field that could easily be reactivated and the unconquered CIS systems. So, long and short, it could become a very messy, multi-factional civil war... and the CIS itself might all of a sudden find itself defeated one day, and the strongest single faction in a new civil war the next.

[@thecourier7964]

Palpatine had the senate so under his grip that I don’t think they would’ve been able to sway the public away from him. The Jedi were enemies of the republic and were already seen as the villains in the eye of the public.

[@mikecambino8295]

The Jedi would go back to Kamino for a way to reverse Order 66. I’m sure there was another failsafe installed in them.

[@S7EVE_]

Disney definitely need to do a “what if” type show for Star Wars, and work with creators like theory who write these fan fictions. This was great, could visualise it all

[@CW0123]

If only they’re weren’t so narcissistic

[@obi-wankenobi5499]

Like marvel

[@benrichardson3031]

@@obi-wankenobi5499 How's marvel narcissistic? It literally gives the fans what they want, with a bit extra? Meanwhile Warner bros. won't fire Amber herd and they still won't make the snyder cut canon. All things considered, I do believe marvel is genuinely a good studio who tries it's best to please everyone. Why? Because the man who runs it all, Feige appreciates fans, respects the comics and is a geek himself with marvel comics. I don't see Kathleen Kennedy being a massive star wars fan, nor having respect for the SW fans.

[@obi-wankenobi5499]

@@benrichardson3031 I didn’t say that I said they do a what if series

[@harmonyovabraxas5556]

@Voldemort beat Grindelwald and Dumbledore I couldn't agree more with you

[@alexlowe4442]

Not gonna lie I found Star Wars when I was in a dark place mentally and I think I’ve found where I belong. And then I came across theory with his positivity and “what people don’t think matter just be yourself” attitude has really helped me be my own person and for that I thank you man. Keep doing everything you’re doing I love all of it 👍

[@youuglymess]

Same, Star wars does reflect our real world, Star wars teached me so much about emotions and our Cosmos,i finished by even believing in the force ☺️💪✨It changes our lives,and i think that the force does exist, Sometimes when i meditate i c an hear a voice that does not speek,A feeling,when im in Trouble i just trust my feelings and it oftenly works 👍

[@alexlowe4442]

@@youuglymess I completely agree when it’s tough time I just say “trust the force”

[@splashnskillz37]

@@alexlowe4442 Well, the positivity here has limits, lots of limits, just the word Sequel and the facade comes crumbling down

[@davids7252]

@@splashnskillz37 are you talking about Theory or the SW community

[@alexlowe4442]

@@splashnskillz37 I agree but I just think people should like what they like and stop caring what others think

[@asolomon9041]

Love this! Would love to see Anakin take on a Revan role using both sides of the force after he’s time in prison.

[@mynameisbub97]

I love your What If's! Your lore knowledge shines and you tell a wonderful story. Please keep it up.

[@actecdc5137]

Anakin: “your with him!!!” *yoda on the ship

[@jeremytoth7635]

What a funny image 🤣

[@warlordofbritannia]

Anakin: "You're with him!" *Jar Jar on the ship "Oh no, thissa bombad time for mesa, yes?"

[@FiqFake157]

Yoda: Over Anakin, it is. The high ground, I have. Anakin: You underestimate my power! Yoda: Try it, do not.

[@quadtrexblaster4577]

Perfect

[@Cyborg_J]

@@quadtrexblaster4577 Imagine having the lowground to someone like a quarter of your size. Fucking rip

[@XVSvideoz]

@@Cyborg_J and who also has lesser midiclorian levels than urs

[@kenb2671]

Anakin tries it anyway and gets his arms legs and head cut off.

[@CKzoidYT]

Same hight we are

[@logiticalresponse9574]

I still wonder if it wasn't for order 66 if yoda could have beaten sidious. It appeared to me that yoda was stronger than Palpatine but lost due to the situation. That scene with Palpatine tossing those senate pods to me was one of the most revealing feats for yoda . Stopping that pod while sidious was pushing it then sent it back so fast that he barely missed having a close encounter with a flying saucer, and the force lightning clash . It was almost like yoda , when being pushed back slightly was like " suprise I'm stronger than you " while leaning back in to the clash before physics was like " aww hell naw , we can't have this , suprise " off you go .

[@lostone9700]

Palpatine was one handing pods and tossing them like popcorn. Also the darkside has no self limitations. He was stronger.

[@Killthesefears]

This one is good but I like the “what if Anakin didn’t take a seat” better. The changes I’d make in this one or the areas I don’t quite agree on are how Anakin goes to jail and stays there. The way it would actually go is forgiveness, of course. The Jedi could never trust Anakin the same way. At least not for a long time, but at the end of the day, Palpatine is gone and the sith are defeated. No need to have him in prison. It would be more like “we need to watch this dude and keep him with us because he a wild card and we can’t afford to just let him go.”The good would resume. If Palpatine can corrupt him, the Jedi can rehabilitate him.

[@ecs2ecs46]

I totally agree with this “theory” playing out this way. I always thought it was a huge mistake to send Obi-Wan after either of them single handedly. I cant even imagine yoda making that grave of a tactical error.

[@mike48931]

Probably would’ve been best to tag team the emperor. That way they could remain on Coruscant afterward where they’d be able to take control of the clone army to stop the slaughter of Jedi and reform the galactic senate under temporary control of the Jedi Order. Anakin would be a problem for another day. He was dispatching the separatists and not a threat to the Jedi at that particular moment.

[@darchangel2136]

Here's the thing tho: Obi-Wan went of his own accord, viewing Anakin as his own responsibility because he was the one who trained him. And besides, he hoped against hope to bring Anakin back. Yoda would have simply been an executioner, as would have any other Jedi besides Obi-Wan. Because Obi-Wan believed in Anakin when NO ONE else would

[@perfectstranger1152]

@Lutumaru I don't know if it would be able to go on that far. Without sidious, I believe any "version" of anakin would have turned back

[@HeSnappedTho]

@@darchangel2136 well obi wan failed because he couldn’t forgive him read the comics when Anakin does and joins them in the force he simply says” I’m sorry “ and they forgive him with qui gon gin saying obi wan needed to learn forgiveness. Obi wan left him for dead because he thought Anakin was dead and could only feel Vader but he was there shown by luke

[@marbabyyy5760]

Right they should of killed the emp then went and dealt with skywalker he prob would of turned back if they did it that way

[@progressinwork7244]

You forgot the legions of clones still killing Jedi at this point, a massive win for sure but until a new chancellor was chosen the clones I’d imagine would still be a hell of a force to deal with

[@reddeaddude2187]

Vote Bail Organa for Chancellor!

[@frank4871]

Bail Organa would get sworn in immediately.

[@AlexPastGrey]

Bail Organa as chancellor would call off the order I think

[@ThePOSM]

You do Anakins voice, really well. (& Yoda, but your Anakin sounds pretty much identical to Anakin) Great video SWT!

[@wilcoxtam810]

Before finding this channel I didn’t care much for Star Wars but now I love it. Your passion for it is infectious

[@BlackWingedSeraphX]

I think the reason Obi-Wan didn't Intervene Sooner when Anakin was choking Padme is because he wanted Anakin to stop on his own. He probably still wanted to see if there was a glimmer of good in him.

[@jerredbosschieter9684]

Thank you and its exactly what awaking did as well stuck between rage and realization of what he was doing. Ironically he choked her because he believed she brought him there. Which I guess you could say obi didn't think he would react that way to his wife but this dude killed children. He could of showed the holotapes of him killing younglings rather than just saying it. A pregnant woman should not of been put in that situation especially

[@Chrislmisl]

For sure. Obi-Wan didn't come to Mustafar to fight Anakin but to rescue him. Anakin just didn't leave him a choice.

[@cadehallman736]

The problem with yoda winning is that he could never get the high ground on anakin

[@johnleeka3282]

He would just have to have the higher ground

[@tommycrompton1054]

still beats him anyway

[@Cegorachthelaughinggod]

Lol the thing about Ataru is that it's all about the high ground i.e aggressive acrobatics

[@wadereynoldsdeadpool5768]

He doesn't need it he's a grandmaster none of my students in taekwondo can beat my ass even in their teenage years cause I taught them

[@user-gg1ud3ie5p]

I dunno what everyone else is talking about, but it's funny because he's short.

[@DJMystrE2]

I don't usually listen or watch videos of this manner, but this was amazing! I completely agree with everything said here and even laughed at the exegol gag. I am a follower of anakin and his beliefs but, as I said previously, this was amazing and I agree with all of it!

[@CeeceeJacobsencc]

PLEASE, the intonation in the voice overs is PERFECT

[@shinycow11]

I love that the sequels are literally a meme at this point with fans

[@thorodinson1933]

The prequels as well. The only trilogy that isn’t a meme or been memed to death is OT

[@olafgurke4699]

@@thorodinson1933 You may fire when ready. It's just that the prequels have so much more meme potential, while the sequels are just a joke.

[@thorodinson1933]

@@olafgurke4699 you ever thought about the fact the only way people get through the prequels is by making fun of the dialogue? That’s what it is essentially. I like the prequels but recently having rewatched them, man that dialogue is a joke.. but we got amazing memes so it’s a small price to pay

[@olafgurke4699]

@@thorodinson1933 Well, maybe the bad dialogue never hit me like that, since I always watched the German version. However, I never once thought the dialogue was bad. It has less memes than the English version, tho. And the memes are god like.

[@thorodinson1933]

@@olafgurke4699 the memes are the best and personally I grew up with them, so I love them. But from rewatching them I think phantom menace doesn’t have bad dialogue but it has useless dialogue in many places. AOTC I think is the worst one, I know anakin is an awkward teen who doesn’t know how to handle talking to crushes, but it would take him never having a conversation almost to talk/act the way he did, he came off creepy and don’t get me started on him killing women, men and children and padme still falling for him. Revenge of the Sith is amazing, no complaints, do people probably have issues with it? Probably. But it’s perfect to me lol

[@reggieziet]

Yoda: Its over Anakin, I got the low, mid and high air.

[@calvinfreeman9231]

Love it! Absolutely beautifully written. Well done .

[@coryschlichting3517]

Duder! That was AWESOME SAUCE! Man though, you had me at the end when you said "until the Emperor rises again from Exegol..." I was going to roll my eyes, but you stopped yourself - LOL! This was an awesome What If. Thank you for all of your hard work and love for Star Wars.

[@08aoc]

*Palpatine twiddling his thumbs in his office* Oh crap Anakin is getting owned by Yoda on Mustafar

[@ccb3500]

Omg I just spit out my coke lol

[@waagwaan]

anakin: chokes padme yoda: *slippity slip, you're getting the whip*

[@gmckayd]

Love this story, the battles would be so awesome to watch! Would love to see it. Also your character voices are on point 👌

[@additive8924]

You took that in an entirely different direction than I was expecting. When I saw the title to the video my thoughts went to Yoda killing Anakin, and the fight with Palpatine never happening.( that would also be a possibility I'd like to see you explore). I really like where you took it. Keep up the good work.👍

[@jennycraigadventures3314]

Yoda: De-feet you I will. /cuts off Ani’s feet Anakin: I thought I could figure out how to beat you, but I’m stumped

[@connor462]

Padme: loses the will to live because there was no anakin around Padme when Anakin is there: well now I’m not being with him

[@meeshmosh2000]

The whole "losing will to live" is the worst character development GL was responsible for. We all agree the Disney Galaxy is for the most part trash, but GL was no saint either.

[@auroa9854]

@@meeshmosh2000 I think the theory that she died because of Palpatine taking her living force to save Anakin makes more sense

[@Geekezf]

@@meeshmosh2000 There's actual case of people dying like that in our reality. It's called Psychogenic death and they're not necessarly related to health problems, sometimes even people with a good health dies because they loose the will of living. (not by suicide, i precise ) Just imagine being the wife of the guy who doom the entire galaxy to a dictatorial empire and that he strangled you near death with his new powers just because you make him a bit upset of being followed. On top of that having the kids of this guy and you, being the sole reason of all of this. Yeah, you would pretty much loose the will to live.

[@georgschlachtenberger8462]

I really appreciate you mentioned the youzhang vong, which was by far my favourite book series. And I was always hoping for this to made into a motion picture.

[@_Toxicity]

Question: With an ending like this...what do you think Ahsoka would do? Do you think she'd head back to Courasant to see who of her former allies survived? Or if she learned Anakin had children? Or would she continue to do her own thing elsewhere in the galaxy?

[@pat17681]

Rebels would play out very very differently

[@williamyochum9211]

Seeing theory's ending, it cements how most of us think the Yuuzhan Vong would have been a better sequel Antagonist. Or in my case, a dangerous Sith from the distant past coming back in a Yhwach-like prophecy.

[@Azure-Spirit]

Exactly! Bringing back palpatine was just lazy story telling and an Ancient Sith would have been epic!

[@owo5869]

@@Azure-Spirit lazy is like they don’t put enough effort. I think they’re just bad at their job.

[@williamyochum9211]

@@Azure-Spirit IF they did, I would have loved to see one of the Pre protosaber era swords.

[@StarAllKungfu]

Disney would have had to pay some authors Royalties. Ain't gonna happen.

[@AtiShard16]

An ancient Sith like Nihilus would have been so cool to see return and wreck havoc on the galaxy.

[@texasham8869]

As a Star Wars fan I love thinking that George sits back watches things like this and realize what a great series he created (regardless of our feelings about the last three) every generation has their own series and that’s awesome! People who dedicate their time to make these aren’t given enough credit!! Thank you for the channel and great series man!

[@grandadmiralthrawn3164]

@Darth Starkiller the prequels are the best

[@davidsegovia7560]

He's just there with cheese puffs chips and getting hammered on a sofa lol

[@chloemcgee3491]

Found you like 5 days ago. Your content is fucking awesome. And 9 times out of 10 you nail the voices spot on.

[@Deyone_Jackson]

2:20 Yoda coming down the ramp like "A Titan, I have become."

[@MRP1516]

I feel like this is the best ending we could've had, keeping Anakin's story as in-canon as it can be

[@397llederson6]

"Skywalker is arguably the most powerful Jedi alive, and he is still getting stronger." Source: Revenge of the Sith

[@10xyourlife65]

He would get bodied by Yoda is said arguably that does not mean he is that means you can argue that is Yoda or mace was the strongest

[@397llederson6]

@@10xyourlife65 What do you mean get bodied the fact its a argument shows you he won't

[@10xyourlife65]

@@397llederson6 you can be in the argument and still get bodied Obi-Wan held his own against Anakin Obi-Wan cannot hold his own against Yoda for a long time

[@397llederson6]

@@10xyourlife65 Obi-wan is outright stated to beat a hungry and conflicted Skywalker. Not a prime Anakin hell Anakin before turning to the dark side was stronger than Obi-wan that is something Dooku and Obi-wan mentioned

[@10xyourlife65]

@@397llederson6 yes because Anakin never reached his prime if Anakin hit his full potential nobody would beat him mace could potentially be him just because of his style but that's only if Anakin's on the dark side.

[@D.M.S.]

Your Yoda and Anakin voices are so spot on!

[@DNTGWANLIKEURSICK]

The voice over get me rolling around every time fam

[@ayden_is_exotic]

You should make a part 2 where Palatine returns from Exagol and Anakin defeats him.

[@issamabou6691]

Yeah agree, but without the ray who bullshit.

[@tricefx]

That'd be awesome, where he redeems himself as the true chosen one.

[@bobbill3701]

Bro can this guy just spit out who wins geez

[@hackman669]

Guys let's just stick with Legends and leave out... the rest, ok.

[@Zabulus]

@@bobbill3701 bro tbh its kinda obvious Yoda has to win in a 1v1 vs Anakin during revenge of the sith

[@meissiah]

I believe Luke would be instrumental in Anakin's getting out of prison, whether that be by facilitating his escape (prior to becoming a Jedi Master) or by lobbying the Jedi Council (after he has become a Jedi Master). Luke has always had a soft spot for his father and if he was able to believe Vader still had good in him, he'd sure believe the same about an Anakin that hasn't committed atrocities on nearly on the same scale as Vader. By that time, I figure Qui-Gon would have reached out to counsel Anakin as well.

[@swpags2024]

I love this theory and timeline! Great job!

[@Uriel77200]

Well done sir. You have always been my favorite SW reactor. I wish this is how it all went down.

[@Batkid20wa]

This needs a part 2. He needs to finish something without a cliffhanger

[@mentalmandolorian5723]

I am always kinda sad when people never mention/forget Grievous's starfighter's name. The soulless one is one of my favourite ships in Star Wars

[@ryanradkowski3058]

Slave 1 … ig-2000, hounds tooth , punishing one. They had good names in the early to mid 90’s . I guess now you can’t say “ slave” in a totally made up universe.

[@AverageHumanityNO.2Enthusiast]

@@ryanradkowski3058 society for you

[@kyletroxell1997]

I don’t know if you need to hear this. But Thank you so much star wars theory for all the work you put into these. You are a master story teller and I am very appreciative.

[@IamthNight]

Your impersonations are on point.

[@snafufans]

Star Wars Theory single-handedly keeping Star Wars alive right now lmao

[@Blizzanity]

I have a suggestion, instead of Anakin escaping, either have the Jedi having very little option but to release him under the condition that if he helped them his punishment would be reduced. Or his son breaks him out or something.

[@rekdyoface4503]

Why would he do that? He would have probably have found out about his crimes.

[@MsLanie]

I sort of like the idea of Luke committing a jail break for the sake of his father, although I don't know why he would do it. Maybe he becomes jaded in this timeline, too

[@matthewendicott3028]

Why the hell would luke break him out?

[@matthewendicott3028]

@@MsLanie careful don’t mention Jade/ jaded because George might kick you out of his office

[@newodavies4324]

@@matthewendicott3028 Mara Jade?

[@karlrice3426]

I always love the endings to your theories. Always catcthes me smiling 😊

[@lucaviani6798]

The voices are beyond good!

[@theanalyzer5396]

I really think Padme would still love and want Anakin back, even the Jedi may forgive Anakin knowing that the dark side is responsible and Anakin would more than likely return to the light after seeing Padme survived and didn't in fact die during child birth

[@bodaciouschad]

The Jedi don't believe in grudges or vengeance. The Jedi Council never cared about the lives of younglings to begin with, as evidenced by their dispassionate response to Asoka's report on herself and a dozen other padowans being abducted by pirates and hunted recreationally. The Council just said the Force was testing them and ignored the clan of padowan hunting pirates. Sadly enough, the Council probably *would* value redeeming one remorseful Annakin more than the lives of the countless younglings he slaughtered.

[@Jjj-zz7bz]

@@bodaciouschad Idk man. Yoda and especially Obi were clearly devastated at the kids being killed. Obi went to mustafar to defeat Anakin, not try to get him to apologize

[@theanalyzer5396]

@@Jjj-zz7bz I think that had little to do with revenge and more of stopping the dark side from Taking over which it clearly did after they failed. The whole original trilogy would have been so different of Anakin didn't get his limbs cut and remained with his immense potential and that meant years of training with Sidious.

[@Jjj-zz7bz]

@@theanalyzer5396 I agree it wasn’t about revenge but idk if they would’ve forgave him. It’s interesting tho

[@theanalyzer5396]

@@Jjj-zz7bz I think it may have taken a while but between him being the chosen one, Qui Gon's force ghost, they would be able to sense the light again as Padme lived through childbirth etc.

[@nyamtserenbatdolgor4222]

I dont think Anakin would escape ever knowing that his family is alive and well. He would accept his crimes and lay imprisoned until the invasion. The Jedi would definitely need the chosen one for this war…

[@g.t.werber4476]

This is your best version of these events

[@AyeitsWood]

love this, thanks for sparing my boy obi wan

[@TeeAiDee]

If I recall, some of the original script of Revenge of the Sith depicted Padmé participating in the early stages of rebellion against the new Empire, as well as a moment where she nearly assassinated Anakin. So for a future fanfiction idea, I would love to see your thoughts on how the story would go down if Padmé and Anakin lived on, to be on opposite ends of the conflict, with Padmé raising Luke and Leia as a prominent figure in the Rebellion and Anakin going on to become the much feared Darth Vader.

[@Hard_Boiled_Entertainment]

YES!!!

[@dnmoscato92]

I honestly don't think anakin would be against padme if she were to live.

[@TyB-BT]

@@dnmoscato92 exactly, Anakin would of eventually cooled down and been a hood guy again if Padme survived

[@dnmoscato92]

@@TyB-BT agreed

[@veevendetta3448]

Anakin was too much of a creep obsessed with Padme to go against her. Palpatine would of been killed by Anakin then instead in Episode 3 probably stabs him through the back with his lightsaber in the fight against a confronting Mace Windu and the other Jedi after Palpatine mows them all down as he did. Then also Mace may of not of been thrown out the Windu and he will forever now have eternal respect for Anakin instead of the obvious disdain he had for him in a more rival esque fashion.

[@moxmox8058]

Your Anakin voice is always sooo good. All your voices are, but that one in particular man, gets all the prequel angst on point.

[@larrylawrence6577]

Except Yoda, Yoda sounds like a kindergartner doing a crappy impression trying to make fun of his teacher because he hates math.

[@evanabbott2737]

@@larrylawrence6577 Aw! C’mon, Larry, the guy tried..!😁

[@RobertsonIsland]

At 4:13 I always thought he knew about Anakin and Padme and assumed him choking her would be enough to snap him out of it

[@RedOctoberCrow]

Your voice acting is so good dude oh my god!!

[@MC-CFC]

Love this alternative story. Only question is wouldn't the clones still be an issue? Just bc the emperor was killed, wouldn't the clones still be under order 66?

[@zeinmets3550]

I think Yoda and Obi-Wan had killed off the clones that were in the temple.

[@mike48931]

I’m sure what’s left of the Jedi Order would work quickly to assume control of the clone army but yeah it’d be a problem until then.

[@Sem07]

In the Star wars: the clone wars you can see in the end that all clones have some sort of tumor in their brain so that they would listen to palpatine, but without palpatine they would be some sort of clueless living beings. Like droids with a working program, but without a purpose. They wouldn't be a problem and would probably just wander arround.

[@herozz4940]

@@Sem07 agreed, cut of the head and the body will flounder

[@TheSerpent21]

See that is most don't realize is that most Clones still had those chips in them. So yes if Yoda and Obi-Wan had beaten them they might have won.....but they in a sense would still have lost because many of the Jedi were already killed by the Clones...those who managed to somehow survive were in hiding or on the run and the Jedi Order itself was more or less all but destroyed and scattered to the wind.

[@USERFRI3NDLY]

“What If?” could so easily be made into a Star Wars movie/Trilogy/TV series. We’d all watch, the possibilities endless. Start with Darth Ridicule (Jar Jar).

[@cosmicconcious]

yoo your yoda voice and anakin voice in on point 😭🔥🔥🔥

[@drewsims3823]

What an amazing fan fic. Great job.

[@falcon7598]

Star Wars Theory, It's been a while since I've watched your stuff, I am very happy you're doing well and your content can't be any better! Your videos still give me the same feeling as they did years ago! Keep it up man!!

[@Luis-jl6oh]

i feel that Padme would have a role in all of this, maybe she took Anakin when no one was looking

[@ruledtrendy5066]

You really got me at 14:30. Well played 😆

[@stevenhay7147]

Been waiting for this one for YEARS

[@ogelpeace2159]

This is an amazing what if story. Love the happier ending

[@J3rs3y_G1rl]

There is an even even better ending than this. Check out the video from Concordia Jedi where Yoda goes to fight Grevious.

[@ianmcclain2122]

Dude it’s insanely impressive how well thought and planned these videos are. I can sit on a lunch break close my eyes and listen to this story and see it happen in my mind. His voice is just unreal and he is an incredible story teller. Thanks for making these videos!

[@matthewsolvescubes]

I do not think padme would've left him behind. She knew there was still good in him on the original timeline. I do not think that changed.Great video though!

[@ShEDDiNgmYSkiN]

Theory has the best "what if" SW stories on the Tube. Gifted storyteller and mad knowledge of the lore.

[@kelbyschultz1877]

I'd love to see a fanfic where "what if Anakin was younger when he was discovered or what if he was discovered at a younger age by the Jedi?"

[@warlordofbritannia]

Yoda: cuts Anakin down to size Also Yoda: "Hmmm, the high ground I have..." "I HATE YOU!"

[@olivieredouard8554]

I would love to hear a part 2!

[@MrQuest321]

Bro your Palatine impression is off the chain!!!!

[@DominickRuocco]

Theory's fan fictions are always amazing and I could watch these for hours. As always I definitely want to see a part to this story. The end to this video is hilarious.

[@MasterAnakinSkyWalker]

"Anakin, over it is. The high ground, I have! Try it, do not!" -Yoda, on Mustafar

[@2tonebishop]

This is easily my favorite channel 🫡

[@ten_smudge8514]

Holy crap your voice acting is spot on