What is the Best Strawberry Spread at the Supermarket?

Tasting expert Jack Bishop challenges host Julia Collin Davison to a tasting of strawberry spreads.
Buy our winning strawberry spread: amzn.to/2TVK8on
ABOUT US: Located in Boston’s Seaport District in the historic Innovation and Design Building, America's Test Kitchen features 15,000 square feet of kitchen space including multiple photography and video studios. It is the home of Cook’s Illustrated magazine and Cook’s Country magazine and is the workday destination for more than 60 test cooks, editors, and cookware specialists. Our mission is to test recipes over and over again until we understand how and why they work and until we arrive at the best version.
If you like us, follow us:
cookscountry.com
/ cookscountry
/ testkitchen
/ cookscountry
/ testkitchen

[@dawnespino]

I was a Smucker's fan for many years, but after trying Bonne Maman I haven't gone back. Bonne Maman tastes as close to my grandmother's homemade jam than any brand I've tried.

[@AnimeshPathak]

My sentiment exactly!

[@georgeidarraga4006]

I agree. Obviously it comes down to personal preference, but it's Bonne Maman for me all the way.

[@ccbowers]

At 4:09 you can see the Bonne Maman "intense" preserves in the upper right jar. Apparently was not picked as the winner. It is good but more expensive than even the regular Bonne Maman

[@marilyn386]

I agree. The intense strawberry is out of this world.

[@LinA-it9vd]

Totally agree. It’s a great jam all around. You couldn’t give me Smuckers for free.

[@ditto1958]

Why was Bonne Maman sitting over to the side but not included It’s the best

[@bedetteb1111]

Bonne maman is top shelf jam…… used widely in Europe and Canada. In Ontario, i can get this wonderful jam in most grocery or specialty stores. Wild blueberry, apricot, orange marmalade, strawberry, raspberry, etc.

[@sassyt1545]

Most U.S. grocery stores carry Bonne Maman and it was included in this taste test.

[@sleeplessmax]

exactly!! I grew up with smuckers, but as an adult, i ONLY get Bonne maman and for years now.

[@Grayald]

The normal versions are kind of sickly sweet in my opinion.

[@tsimoi273]

I bought my first Bonne Maman from France while on vacation and I was very happy to find it in the US few years later. 😋

[@faithnelson6069]

i love their fig jam for spreading on chevre and carmelized onion.

[@jonv8177]

I've tasted, & cooked with most of these brands. I'd have to say Bonne Maman is far & away the best. The Smuckers is far to sweet, I'm surprised they liked it

[@claudia1423]

Agree completely!

[@rikkitikkitavi997]

Agree, plus Bonnie Maman is made with sugar not corn syrup.

[@barcham]

@@rikkitikkitavi997 I just checked my jar of Kraft that I have and it also contains sugar, not corn syrup.

[@Omoloya1]

Exactly!

[@barcham]

@@sandrah7512On their website, they state they use 50% sugar and 50% fruit. I just checked my jar of Red Currant Jelly, and it has exactly the same amount of sugar as my jar of Kraft Strawberry Jam, 13 gr per 15 ml/1 Tbsp of product.

[@tamiwithani]

I'm from Trinidad and Tobago, even though Bonne Maman is 4x the price of 'regualar' jam, i will always buy it because its the best. Smuckers taste like pure sugar.

[@ccbowers]

Except it doesnt have more sugar. Check the label Smuckers has 12g vs 13g. Unless you are comparing different products available to you, or maybe jam or jelly versions

[@SheilaR.08]

@@ccbowers It may not contain more sugar, but it tastes much sweeter to me. Perhaps it's the acidity. I love Bonne Maman.

[@michaelrutledge7048]

I’ll ONLY buy Bonne Maman, and have been for years. My grocery store occasionally has it on BOGO (buy one, get one). When they do, I stock up!!

[@msr1116]

Ofc, I can't know where you buy the French jam that costs 4X more than regular jam, but I just looked up Bonne Maman at Walmart....a 13oz/370g jar is $5.97. The BM also lists sugar then cane sugar---13g is a lot for a 20g portion. My breakfast is typically several slices of wholegrain toast with coffee and 52+ grams of sugar for one meal is too much for me. I've had to stop buying fruit spreads of all types unless they're sugar free or make a jar's worth at home with an alternative sweetener. I think our preferences are being dictated by the fruit's quality and ripeness rather than the sugar content---which seems to be just about the same across these brands.

[@mistabaka]

The "expert panel" did not pass the vibe check. Bonne Maman Is clearly the best.

[@lawrencejensen1240]

Polaners simply fruit best for diabetics and tastes great 👍

[@brookegrinstead]

Absolutely

[@edsmith438]

@@sandrah7512 do we buy it for how it tastes or how it works in a cookie? Actually I use it on crackers and it stays there just fine. That's the Cherry one I like it. I've tried Schmucker's because it's a lot less expensive but to me it's just not worth it. And she's shoving it in with a spoon so she knows nothing about how it would work on toast at least in this test.

[@LL-bl8hd]

@@sandrah7512 I hate how these videos make it look like they only rated 3 products. I think it makes them look less reputable.

[@TheGreektrojan]

@@sandrah7512 Right. These videos are much more informative to give you the factors that vary across brands so that you can made a better decision for your uses/tastes rather than 99% of people fanboying over their preference/getting the ego boost of owning/buying "the best X."

[@allih8021]

2 years late but here to chime in with the proverbial Greek chorus - Bonne Maman is in a league of it's own and this whole thing was a farce. The raspberry is FABULOUS no matter how you use it. On toast. In a pastry. On cookies. On ice cream. It's just the best HANDS DOWN.

[@Seriously778]

It’s based on average American tastebuds which are subpar that’s why Smuckers is ranked first and Bonne Maman is nowhere to be seen…

[@DavidWoods_ca]

I haven't bought a strawberry jam in YEARS. Strawberry freezer jam is so easy to make and because it's not cooked it tastes fresh and so much better.

[@dazekiel]

I came on here to say the exact same thing. When it is less than $1.00 a pound I buy a bunch and stock up for the year. Also great on ice cream

[@borderlineiq]

It was all the rage back in the 70's and 80's, but you don't hear about it as often now. I put back strawberry or peach any time I have great fruit. Both are to die for.

[@jintzie1950jth]

How do you make strawberry or peach freezer jam?

[@borderlineiq]

@@jintzie1950jth It is very simple. Fresh fruit is mashed, sugar added, and pectin. You can find recipes online, or Sur-Jell puts recipes on their pectin. They actually market a different style just for freezer jams. After the pectin and sugar are mixed in the crushed fruit, it is poured into freezer containers and stands on the counter for overnight, covered, finally to be frozen. Keeps in the freezer for months, and in the fridge for weeks. Makes wonderful topping for toast, cheesecake, pound cake, etc.

[@shadowguard3578]

@@dazekiel where do you buy strawberries for less than $1 per pound?

[@markdickson3820]

Really surprised, maybe a cultural thing but even with it being French (as a Brit, they have to overcome an immediate point against just for that reason) but Bonne Maman is far and away the best supermarket jam type product. I’ve tried them all living in the US (products shown in video), Smucker’s is acceptable as a Denny’s level stand-in but for home I would never choose it’s inoffensive & incredibly sweet flavor. I love atk, but I have to respectfully disagree on this one, Bonne Maman walks away with the win in this category.

[@markdickson3820]

@@sandrah7512 I can believe it, it is certainly not lacking sweetness for sure, but whatever they’re doing it works together somehow

[@roberttschaefer]

@@sandrah7512 - sweetness is not about how much sugar but the type of sweetener. The reason so many highly processed foods use HFCS is because, in addition to a textural purpose, we perceive it as being far sweeter than sugar.

[@manikaggarwal2018]

You are spot on my friend ..

[@storyman507]

I agree with you too, Mark. I was using Crofters for a while but then found Bonne Maman at Wegmans. I'm a convert. I was surprised that Smuckers won because the consistency os more like jelly to me. Too stiff.

[@barcham]

Why would anyone choose Brit food over French unless they have no taste buds at all? 😁😋

[@evrimoztamur2192]

Saw Bonne Maman in the thumbnail and was certain it'd make it to the end... man, Americans really gotta' go easy on the HFCS.

[@SheilaR.08]

I buy Bonne Maman, Crofter's, and Dalmatia sour cherry regularly. Smucker's tastes too sweet to me, despite it containing the same amount of sugar.

[@phatbuddha1]

My goto spread is the one sold at Costco. Kirkland Organic Strawberry Spread. Whole chunks of strawberries, real sugar, and can't beat the cost per ounce

[@woodswal]

Sounds 😋. You sold me on the whole chunks.

[@TheNinnyfee]

In French supermarkets Bonne Maman is actually one of the cheapest brands, that kind of surprised me when I was on holiday there.

[@dianaadamo5574]

Well it is produced in France. Perhaps without the import fees and its close manufacturing makes it cheaper in France?

[@bluerock4456]

Less expensive, not cheap.

[@msbarnes1281]

Bonne Maman is amazing and they make an Advent calendar during the holidays with their other flavors… they were all really good. Even flavors that seemed really unique were so good. Full jar worthy.

[@kayo5291]

What a great idea, gotta look for that!

[@michellehawco8981]

Bonne mamas is by far my favorite. While I have tasted their strawberry and liked it, I'm a huge fan of their blueberry jam. Have been buying it for many years. It's the closest I've come to a jam tasting homemade. I'm originally from NFLD where blueberries grow wild so that homemade taste is very important to me. :)

[@claudia1423]

Hi, fellow 🇨🇦! Bonne Mama is my favorite 🍓 & I love their 🫐 too. Don't like Smuckers at all. Hero is another good brand, particularly 🍑. I live in ON but when we're vacationing in the Maritimes ⛵ my husband & I pick wild 🫐 blueberries. And eat lots of 🦞 rolls 😋!

[@BlueHen123]

I also love Bonne Mama for their Blueberry preserves. Goes great with peanut butter!

[@barcham]

I love their Red Currant jelly, which is what I use to go with turkey instead of cranberry. It makes a nice change! Of course, it also goes great with any wild game, such as partridge, grouse or especially pheasant. 😋

[@michellehawco8981]

@@claudia1423 I'm jealous lol, i haven't picked blueberries in a very long time, since the last time I was in nfld 15 yrs ago. I'm also in Ontario and at times I've had to hunt down the bonne mamas blueberry jam because our local grocery doesn't stock it. Luckily I found that Walmart saved the day lol....not a fan of Smuckers at all.

[@claudia1423]

@@barcham You're right about red currant with turkey. Haven't cooked game birds for years. They always turned out dry for me. You sound like a gourmet cook!

[@Cbv1914]

The best by far is Bonne Maman not only bc of taste but look at the ingredients of the others compared to “INGREDIENTS: Strawberries, Sugar, Cane Sugar, Concentrated Lemon Juice, Fruit Pectin.”

[@OneAdam12Adam]

Amen! The ingredients prove it.

[@whitewolfe28]

Dickenson’s is also very good. But if I have a choice it’s Bonne Maman😋

[@brownro214]

Substitute citric acid for lemon juice (basically the same) and the ingredients in Aldi's house brand are the same.

[@whitewolfe28]

@@brownro214 I shop at Aldi’s almost exclusively. Very impressed with most of their products. They are healthier and the produce is mostly organic and fresh 😋

[@hrh4961]

@@whitewolfe28 The other day I bought some Dickinson's Seedless Black Raspberry Preserves. Best preserves I've ever tasted. Pure, clean, heavenly flavor. Use only a little; it's that pronounced.

[@bostonpicker6890]

ATK’s (Cooks Country) canning recipe is BY FAR the absolutely most fab recipe for strawberry jam, well worth the effort to make it every time and well worth the cost of the canning equipment. Nothing better in jam!

[@dlibby2125]

How can you recommend Smuckers Strawberry Preserves???The first ingredient is HIGH FRUCTOSE syrup!

[@florencespinelli2947]

Agreed. Theirs are really full of unnecessary ingredients.

[@Lala.903]

Fage 2% plain yogurt with Bonne Maman cherry preserves stirred in. Healthy treat for the grandkids. 🙂

[@AnimeshPathak]

My favorite is "Bonne Maman"; what did you guys not like in it? Too chunky?

[@cynthiakeller5954]

Nah, they didn't like it bc no sponsership. Bonne Maman is quality in a jar, don't care how much it costs.

[@karldelavigne8134]

Wilkin and Sons from England is the gold standard for fruit preserves.

[@DavidInSugarLand]

Yes, their Little Scarlet Strawberry Preserve is tops!

[@roysreceptive]

I’ve tried making my own jam, but I haven’t been able to find a sieve to catch all the strawberry seeds. The thing about Smuckers is they use High Fructose Corn Syrup + Corn syrup + (more) sugar. All-in-all, 9g of sugar per Tbs. At least “strawberries” is the first ingredient.

[@karenpolansky9097]

Give me Crofters any day of the week. Their cherry one is to die for, although it’s very hard to find here in Canada.

[@dallimamma]

::: Yum! The Morelo Cherry is also my favourite, but, it’s very limited, and seasonal, so, stock up when you see it...

[@SheilaR.08]

I love Crofter's. I got hooked on their superfruit spread years ago, and live the Morello cherry and blueberry flavors.

[@florencespinelli2947]

All day....any of their flavors are healthier.

[@dallimamma]

@@sandrah7512 :::Ha! Really? Like, the organic from the US is any better, legally being watered with “organic” reclaimed toilet water!

[@person-lz5sb]

Where do you find it? I’ve been looking for ages!

[@GrotrianSeiler]

This is a great channel. I buy Bonne Maman, or nothing. Luckily I have a neighbor who makes this stuff all the time.

[@airmanma]

Smuckers uses high fructose corn syrup. No thanks, I read the ingredients before I buy.

[@crismendoza7206]

Crofter's blueberry is out of this world!!!

[@druglaughing]

Wow, I'd say WELL DONE!!! The video helped me a lot. Shared knowledge is of prime importance.one of the most useful contents in my life. ♡ I love all these videos!

[@JustinHEMI05]

Strawberry jam and brie grilled cheese sandwiches are to die for.

[@audreywy1743]

Homemade or the Walls Berry Farm organic strawberry spread from Costco is the best.

[@Kejame]

Bonne Maman is by far and away the best preserves that you can buy! A little pricey ~$4-5 a jar, but so worth it. I replaced Smuckers with this brand and haven't looked back.

[@tamiwithani]

I agree. Bonne Maman is 4 times the price of regular jam in my country but its way better and it lasts me 2 months so its worth it

[@Rayh423]

I make my own jam/jelly and is wonderful. In a pan, in medium heat, I put blackberries, blueberries, raspberries and strawberries with a little bit of water and NO SUGAR. As they get hot I smashed them and stirred them together. After about 10 minutes, I turn off the heat and let them cool. You can stored them like that or blend them a bit if you like and stored them in the refrigerator. Healthy and easy and no added ingredients or sugars.

[@Nyx773]

Thanks, sounds easy enough. How long does it stay fresh in the fridge? Does it freeze well? I’m thinking individual servings from ice cube trays

[@fealubryne]

My mom mostly made her own preserves, but when we were out she would usually buy Polaner's All Fruit, which I like to this day. Also really like Bonne Maman when I can find it. Surprised to see Smuckers win, though I guess it's a well-known brand for a reason.

[@borderlineiq]

We had no shortage of great brands to choose from when I was a kid, but even then, Smuckers was out front. I do think they care more about quality than many companies.

[@johnnyspeed5885]

I was surprised to not see Polaner's out there!

[@doradedham9162]

My favorite strawberry jam hands down is the frozen strawberry jam made with liquid pectin. The recipe is in the Ball Canning Company blue book. Bright and delicious! I think in any jam, the big difference is using real sugar and not high fructose corn syrup.

[@nycalien]

That Smucker's is made out of high fructose corn syrup.

[@recoilrob4765]

It's a little known fact Normy that strawberries are among the fruits most heavily sprayed with pesticides. This led me to switch from Smuckers to Costco's Kirkland brand Organic Strawberry Spread, nothing but strawberries, sugar, pectin and citric acid. Better than Smuckers and about the same price.

[@SheilaR.08]

It's excellent, though I wish they'd switch from a single large jar to a two-pack of smaller ones. It's a challenge when it is less than half full.

[@cynthiakeller5954]

@@SheilaR.08 Can you switch to a thoroughly wash and sanitized smaller jar. I just did with my large jar of spiced apple preserves. Smaller jar is cuter too!

[@florencespinelli2947]

Try crofts.

[@kaywatson6505]

Jellies, jams, preserves, The best one is the one each person reaches for the most. I had a room mate who preferred Knots Berry Farms, I reached for Bonne Maman most often texture is to my liking.

[@XavierKatzone]

Wow, that audience certainly goes WILD for strawberry jam taste-tests!

[@DavidInSugarLand]

Tiptree's 'Little Scarlet' Strawberry Preserve is our family favourite, get it on Amazon since we are not in the UK.

[@pkoceres]

Recently tried this product for the first time and I totally agree! I never thought I'd find one that topped Bonne Maman.

[@acemannotsomeother]

It’s my favourite and James Bond as well.

[@RuthJohnstonaworldofgoods]

As a lifelong former Orrville-ite taste tester at Smucker, it was fun to see it being tasted by professionals. I would always choose it bc, the strawberry flavor is the best. Yup, it's sweet, it's supposed to be.

[@susanbackes4651]

My favorite is Tiptree, followed by Polaner but my kids love the Welch’s natural strawberry spread

[@TheodoraWimsey]

St Dalfour from France for preserve and Orange Marmalade. No sugar. Sweetened with fruit juice concentrate. The blueberry is amazing.

[@flygirlfly]

I'm lucky to have a job that takes me to Europe, quite often. Movenpick brand has the BEST jams -- strawberry, blueberry, black current, marmalade. Outstanding.

[@DD-mn9jh]

Smucker’s is a by far my favourite too! I love how they don’t add colour like a lot of other brands do. I tried to make my own but still preferred Smucker’s . Now I save myself the work and just buy it😊

[@captainamericaamerica8090]

Smuckers' is heavy SPRAYED WITH CHEMICALS= 😤😤😤😤😤😧😧😧😧😧💀💀💀💀🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯

[@DD-mn9jh]

@@captainamericaamerica8090 I would imagine they all are unless they say organic.

[@captainamericaamerica8090]

@@DD-mn9jh we only use Organics.

[@kdnp529]

Tiptree Little Scarlet. Hard to find here in the US, but you can order it on Amazon. From the UK, made up of special tiny strawberries that are whole in the preserves. Try this one and you’ll never go back!

[@maria_caitlin]

Everyone commenting about how Smuckers is "too sugary" compared to Bonne Maman should check the nutrition facts... literally 12g sugar/tbsp of Smuckers vs 13g/tbsp Bonne Maman

[@shanel7707]

Reading the fan comment about Bonne Maman here reminds me of those famous marketing surveys of car buyers, i.e. luxury car owners (say BMW or Mercedes) insisting that they bought their car for their quality of worksmanship and reliability. Why they picked the Smucker's, because it was a blind test. The testers didn't see the nice container with the handwritten style label, a name that reminds you of granny from France. Those things do matter to your enjoyment of the jam. Otherwise Bonne Maman wouldn't have spent all that money to get it right.

[@Mirror1973]

My personal favorite is Bonne Maman, period

[@leogeee1]

My mother and grandmother used to do "canning". Mason jars, Ball lids and caps, Certo or Sure Jell, fruit, sugar and lemon juice. The jarred fruit spread which replicates homemade is Welch's Natural. Read the label.

[@cbboyle5117]

I don’t care for strawberry jellies, jams, etc, but the Bonne Maman Four Fruits Préserves are delicious and are also great in Baked Brie!! Yummy! Fresh is the only way to eat strawberries, IMO! And Louisiana strawberries are the world’s best👍❣️

[@jujub4553]

Why wasn’t Bonne maman brand included???

[@acmeopinionfactory8018]

Juju B It was included, it didn't make the finals.

[@missbeans]

We buy Smucker's for the kids because they go through it so dang fast. For us adults we buy Bonne Maman, it's absolutely the best.

[@debk5325]

Awesome as always

Smucker's : Strawberries, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Corn Syrup, Sugar, Fruit Pectin, Citric Acid. Bonne maman: Strawberries, Sugar, Cane Sugar, Concentrated Lemon Juice, Fruit Pectin. people in america are used to very sweet flavor for the jam. Bonne maman has more acidity so it was rated lower.

[@bobschenkel7921]

I totally agree with the Smucker's Strawberry Preserves choice. If it isn't available at the store, I wait until it is.

[@barcham]

This is one of the few taste tests that contains at least a few products that are also available here in Canada. I've purchased Smuckers and find it a very good product, but my choice here in Canada is either Kraft strawberry jam or, surprisingly, the IGA/Sobey's own store brand which I find to be excellent and contains no preservatives or other additives. All the Bonne Mama products I've tried have also been excellent, if more expensive than most others.

[@claudia1423]

The very best in 🇨🇦: Greaves, made in Niagara-on-the-Lake. We used to live there in a house built in 1817. When they made strawberry jam the whole town smelled sweet. They also make fabulous chili sauce from local produce. The aroma was heavenly. Sadly, the town is now a tacky tourist trap 😢.

[@FreeSpeechisMyRight10]

Believe it or not, the BEST strawberry spread (as well as blackberry and raspberry) I've found is GREAT VALUE brand from Wal-Mart! Only a few simple ingredients: Strawberries, Sugar, Pectin and Citric Acid. No high-fructose corn syrup and it tastes great! Not to mention cheap. I think I paid $1.83 for 17.25 oz. jar.

[@fmih]

The Walls Berry Farm Organic Strawberry Spread from Costco is excellent.

[@MyCleverHandle]

I never met a Bonne Manan I didn't love! The Four Fruits is my favorite!

[@bengaljam4550]

There is an Organic Kirkland brand they sell at Costco that tastes the best to me.

[@bluerock4456]

Costco also sells Bonne Maman strawberry 🍓 jam in a large jar. Quelle surprise.

[@Fossil_]

"Smucker's paid the most."

[@b.powell3480]

I can't get Bonnie Maam at any of the stores I shop at !! Sorry 😞

[@davidfulton179]

The KZbin winner is clearly Bonne Maman! LOL! I was rather surprised to know that it's not actually an "boutique" brand but available essentially everywhere alongside Smuckers and Knott's. I've tried almost every flavor of Bonne Maman and have been impressed, although I think their lemon curd could be better. For my money, it's Trader Joe's for when I want lemon curd on my crumpets! But, Bonne Maman's also has those lovely jars that have so much utility!

[@RGconductor]

Thank you!

[@patriciasamora5600]

I was introduced to Bonne Maman in Paris 1988. The best!

[@1drummer172]

“With a name like Smucker's, it has to be good”!

[@CyclingChefDiane]

What I was surprised to learn in a recent GMM episode is that they found the jam in plastic to have a much better flavour than glass. They found this with all condiments, and actually the packets were the favourite overall. who'd have thought.

[@bondfool]

I’m willing to sacrifice a negligible difference in flavor for using less single-use plastic.

[@jamersbazuka8055]

I wonder if it's a temperature thing. Needing to store plastic at a lower temp vs glass, changing the storage protocols for their respective jams after filling.

[@CyclingChefDiane]

@@jamersbazuka8055 I believe its more because of the air-tight seal, and air exposure. It would especially make sense for the packets.

[@CyclingChefDiane]

@@bondfool Yes, maybe the reusable market needs to change. Aluminum perhaps?

[@OneAdam12Adam]

So said the lobbyist or paid content writer of the plastics manufacturing industry. Give me glass any day over plastic.

[@msr1116]

I've taken to buying sugar free fruit spreads---which have a somewhat gelatinous texture---or cooking a small jar's worth of berry preserves with chia seeds, pectin and an alternative sweetener. Regardless of the common sugar types used, store selections are all over sweetenered in my opinion. I bought Crofters blackberry jam and decided I could do better with my own homemade version--and I did.

[@joshua.alvane]

I wish you had been able to try Lowell brand. That's my absolute favorite!

[@aypues]

What about European brands like D’Arbo and Hero? D’Arbo is my fave!

[@gcvrsa]

Same here. D'Arbo is fantastic.

[@OneAdam12Adam]

Mine too! The strawberry and raspberry both taste great. The strawberry tastes like wild grown mountain strawberries. 🍓

[@Kathleen5429]

I’m not at all into strawberry jelly, jam, or preserves but my fave is Dickinsons preserves for all other flavors… black raspberry or red raspberry preserves with no seeds are the best imho.

[@hrh4961]

Amen!

[@valerief1231]

I can’t shake the feeling that I’m watching a sketch of an original that was filmed in 1978, the wardrobe, the studio audience, and set. Even though I agree with her choice, Smuckers is my favorite store bought Strawberry Jam/Preserves.

[@sharonroy2645]

Remember when their motto was "with a name like Smuckers, it's got to be good"? Damn straight

[@bluerock4456]

Pure marketing, more like.

[@nancybrekke8936]

Did the panel consider Bonne Maman? I suggest you do another taste test.

[@mr.griffingriffin3997]

Smuckers has an “all natural “ version of their jams which matches the ingredients of Bonne Maman. Price is the same. I buy Bonne Maman for the taste.

[@michaelschmidlkofer3979]

Polaner All Fruit is my fav by far.

[@ricoltmetric8156]

Sorry but I go by what has high fructose corn syrup which is mostly always. At least Euro brands avoid that.

[@stillaworkinprogress2147]

I have never liked super sweet jams/spreads/jellies. I have not been a Smuckers fan since I was a little kid (that was the brand my mom bought). I agree with many commenters here that Bonne Maman is far and above Smuckers. One of my critiques of ATK is they love their salt and sugar far more than I do. When using their recipes, I cut back on both of these items, especially salt as folks can salt after the dish is done to suit their own tastes.

[@kayo5291]

True! I once saw them do a review of canned beans. They tasted a "no salt added" variety and declared that it didn't have enough salt. 🙄

[@manikaggarwal2018]

I always use the Strawberry preserve from Aldi. Cheapest and best quality as Smuckers.

[@peterkoska6876]

I like blueberry & Raspberry preserves/jam the best. You can have all jellies. Though I have seen Bonne Maman, I can't remember having any as I didn't have a, "That's the best preserves I've ever had!" response, like so many commenters here.

[@lindagrigsby3699]

I read labels and look for the one with the fewest ingredients, less sugar and fat....there are many good ones. By the time you put chocolate syrup, strawberries or other toppings on them, many are good!

[@donnagoldman7745]

In illinois we don't get other than smuckers. But we get Welches strawberry natural jam and I don't see how a store bought could beat it. It so good.

[@Dashzap]

We're in Illinois and we buy Bonne Maman at Meijers and Jewel.

[@stateniland]

ALWAYS go organic.. way too much sugar in other brands.

[@wanderingi1316]

Smuckers Strawberry Preserves and Crunchy Skippy tastes so great in a PB&J.

[@lillydee5978]

With a name like Smuckers, it has to be the best. (Anyone remember that old slogan?)

[@jerrybobteasdale]

Nope, It's: "With a name like Smuckers, it has to be good."

[@cisium1184]

I hate chunks in my jam. If I wanted chunks I would just eat a strawberry. I like the taste of Bonne Maman but I have to give it a couple pulses with the hand blender.

[@drackar]

Sounds like what you want is Jelly not Jam.

[@cisium1184]

@@drackar No. _Jelly_ is made from fruit juice only, or with the fruit strained out to extract the juice. _Jam_ is made with the fruit left in but mashed up. _Preserves_ are made in much the same way as jam, but the fruit is kept whole or cut only into very large pieces. Note that the winning "jam" actually says "Preserves" on the label. I want jam, with a greater mashitude level than the winning "jam," so that it spreads more evenly and maintains a relatively consistent ratio of jam to butter to toastal surface. Strangely enough, the company that makes the winning "jam," which it calls "Preserves," also makes a jam in precisely the style I desire which it calls "Jam." So not only do I disagree with you, but Smucker's disagrees with you as well. No gratitude need be expressed for my bestowal of this life-transforming information. Just knowing that you may now function in the world as a jam-eating adult is all the thanks I need.

[@Montecitodesign]

Not a fan of High Fructose Corn Syrup and Corn Syrup which are in your Smucker's winner. Currently using Darbo Strawberry Fruit Spread which happens to be from Austria, but seems to be in US stores. Ingredients are 50% Strawberries, Sugar, Lemon Juice Concentrate, Pectin.

[@burbie1342]

🍓Home made is the BEST.🍓

[@MikesVegas]

“With a name like Smucker's, it has to be good!” ™️ 😋👍❤️

[@thecontentedhome9167]

Stonewall Kitchen has the best jams. My favorite is blueberry.

[@roberttschaefer]

All Stonewall Kitchen products are good, but you do have to pay a hefty premium for them. If you can find it, their Maple Chipotle barbecue sauce is amazing, and of all commercial lemon curds, they have the best by a large margin.

[@thecontentedhome9167]

@@roberttschaefer I agree. Fantastic product but high prices.

[@JohnVKaravitis]

Costco has it. The Kirkland brand. :discussionclosed:

[@JK-sh8rc]

I bought a big jar of Kirkland brand last year and it was fabulous! Best I ever tasted! Haven't been able to find it since then though :(

[@dreamervanroom]

Love Julia's hair. And I always love her on-screen too. She's real.

[@MrzorkV]

She reminds me of Dee Williams.

[@ithacacomments4811]

Crofter's Organic is my go to!

[@henrywilson9928]

I have always been a Smuckers fan and I haven’t tasted any other brand that changed my mind.

[@sleeplessmax]

Bonne Maman is definitely the best jam. I grew up with smuckers and always thought it was really sweet. Bonne Maman is just so nice and balanced.

[@johnnyspeed5885]

Winner & still undefeated, haha. The one I grew up on! Reading all these comments though, I might need to try Bonne Maman...

[@Grayald]

The Smuckers is way too sickly-sweet for me. The normal one anyway. The natural one is quite good though.

[@pamyoder6163]

I’m born and raised in the home of the JM Smucker Co., and my father, grandfather, and I all worked there. So it’s a no brainer what I favor.🍓🍓🍓

[@crispybits6737]

Imagine signing up to be in the audience for a cooking show

[@BDCF100]

I agree with the many commenters. Bonne Maman. Quality. Try their Blackberry and Apricot jams. Awesome

[@JYMBO]

Bonne Maman is the best in the UK but i feel like there is a difference between UK & US jams, same way our chocolate has always tasted different so our tastes have evolved to be different

[@isaactobar1206]

U S A here and I agree yuckers way too sweet would love to try your chocolate I have at least 30 empty bonnie Mann jars here in my cupboard use them for storage and drinking glasses 😁

[@paulstewart6203]

Welch's, all-natural strawberry preserves, the best, hands down.