What is the Catholic Church hiding?

Subscribe - / @josharchie
Goonsquadproductions.com
Follow us
Josh Instagram - / joshua_pieters
Archie Instagram - / archiemannersmagic
Josh Twitter - / joshua_pieters
Archie Twitter - / archiemanners
Facebook - / joshpietersyoutube
Enquiries - [e-mail]

[@luxvincunt]

I like how he was forgiven for murder faster than being forgiven for being homosexual. That’s crazyyyy

[@heathengremlin992]

Of course this is a different religion but I grew up Mormon and I was told being gay was worse than murder or rape because "You're still actively sinning" 😬

[@kozmikoblivion]

yeh

[@channelpage]

@@heathengremlin992 disgusting religion mindset..

[@luxvincunt]

@@heathengremlin992 Yeah I grew up Mormon too, it’s crazy looking back on how much mental trauma I carry from being indoctrinated as a kid. Not a fan of Abrahamic religion tbh

[@r45661]

"Okay, is there anything else you would like to confess besides this?" "Uh no, just that" "Okay, fine" absolutely hilarious

[@DanielFernandez]

This one is wild.

[@salembendeck]

Hello big verified channel

[@lyalychee]

the response you got from them was not suprising, but still shocking

[@Tardvark]

Wait until you find out what muslims do to the gays

[@MFPRego]

Why would it be shocking?

[@Tardvark]

@MFPRego cause it was people with accents. Clearly non-native to England which explains their homophobia

[@MFPRego]

@@Tardvark guess only England is right then, and every other country in the world is wrong! Well im catholic, and i believe that homossexualism is wrong, as it always has been! Western world has been imposing to us all for the last 15 years or so that its ok and accepted! Look where it got us to! Now transgenderism is ok and we have to accept it! Now pedophiles have started to come out and sooner or later, we also have to accept them! To hell with all of this! A sense of normality and to be able to distinguish right from wrong is essential for a society to grow and prosper! Not the imposed chaos that we live in nowdays!

[@abdullahal-mamun1053]

@@Tardvark always knew you people were racist 😂😂

[@owenlewis2454]

When the Catholic Church complain about this you should go in again and ask for forgiveness for making fun of them

[@Paula-tc6tj]

bet he wouldn't be forgiven for that one..

[@Dornana]

@@Paula-tc6tj Forgiveness is an integral part of the church's teachings, and he would be forgiven for what he did. However, the confessor's act of lying and recording the confession violates the sanctity of the sacrament, which is a serious matter. Despite this, the church remains a pillar of support and guidance for those seeking repentance, regardless of their transgressions. It is important to note that if the confession was fabricated solely for the purpose of creating content, it holds no value as a genuine act of contrition and undermines the purpose of the sacrament.

[@Veganismdebunked812]

He should apologise, and ask for forgiveness out of his own will, not just because he was told to.

[@caitlinbrennan9039]

He would be forgiven for that as forgiveness is a massive thing in catholicism

[@williamflesher8705]

I think a lot of commenters are quite confused about what is happening here. The whole point of confession is that you're basically guaranteed to be forgiven anyway, this is why Catholics believe Jesus "died for our sins". It would be far more surprising if any of these confessions were refused. This has been the role of the Church and this encounter for centuries. Whether you agree with the implications or not, there is nothing new or controversial here.

[@caitlinbrennan9039]

Exactly, forgiveness I think is a nice part of the Catholic church

[@jungletroll3844]

"dw about having sex with that minor" is the tone i got from that guy and that is certainly controversial

[@DetectiveSmilez]

@@jungletroll3844Fr My guy is literally a pedo, murder, and gay how tf is being gay worse than killing someone or having s- with a 14 year old

[@chesterbless9441]

​@@jungletroll3844That priest was was wrong obviously, but apparently the age of consent is 14 in Italy.

[@jodo2785]

@@jungletroll3844 well he did say "she is too young, she doesn't understand" so I doubt he approves of it personally, but his job as a priest requires him to bestow God's forgiveness or whatever

[@pocketsand76]

Killing a man: woah Sex with a minor: wooah Being gay: wooooaaah 🤯 now hold on there buddy.

[@shalinimahalingam9064]

Not being married to the minor whilst having sexual relations: woah now that's unacceptable

[@emilysmith1000]

​@@shalinimahalingam9064the age of consent in Italy is actually 14

[@ivartheboneless5969]

@@emilysmith1000seriously?

[@emilysmith1000]

@@ivartheboneless5969 yes Google it

[@weouthere6902]

​@@ivartheboneless5969glorious country amiright

[@helenjames6982]

So being gay requires a harmful 'therapy', but murder requires a psalm to be repeated for 30 days? Sums up Catholicism

[@MellowGrub]

how is psychotherapy harmful, I apologise if I'm missing something. Just want to know.

[@ThomasJM]

The confession to murder thing goes against everything that I've ever asked a priest when I've had the opportunity to. They said that we'll they can't report you for it they would ask you to turn your self in for it.

[@helenjames6982]

@@MellowGrub psychotherapy in general isn't. However, when it is used for conversion therapy it is as it involves trying to convert gay people into being straight and is traumatising

[@samshef]

​@@monke4312homosexuality isn't illegal, murder is.

[@ncubesays]

@@monke4312 murder is a past action? how can you be so sure?

[@emilysmith1000]

Shockingly the age of consent in Italy is actually 14 so thats why he wasnt considered a pedo confessing that in Italy and hence the priest asked what the law is in his country

[@NotGoodAtYoutube]

Why would they give full context when they can be bigots trying to say others are bigots

[@DetectiveSmilez]

@@NotGoodAtKZbinong

[@DetectiveSmilez]

only when they’re married 😂😂😂 it’s actually 18 for non married

[@emilysmith1000]

@@DetectiveSmilez really? I haven't seen that information anywhere, do you have a source please?

[@rubz794]

the fact that the girl being 14 wasn't the problem, just them not being married?!

[@FahadFSA]

but it is ok for 14 year old boys and girls to go on like rabbits..

[@rubz794]

@@FahadFSA that's obviously wrong too lol. i never suggested it was right

[@grass____.]

But it is the problem tho, the bible teaches the follow the laws of the land and it is against the law of the land so he would forever be in sin in that relationship until theyre of age and married.

[@emilysmith1000]

FYI the age of consent in Italy is actually 14 (!)

[@grass____.]

@@emilysmith1000 EWWWW WHAT THE FUCK of course the pope is there

[@korina-ellap3867]

I listen to the deathbed confessions podcast and it’s so interesting how serial killers and people who have done awful stuff confess as they are dying so that they will be forgiven by god

[@johnkeo358]

Interesting, can I find itmon Spotify?

[@ailsa7762]

I miss your videos, they never come up on my explore page anymore! Commenting to boost algorithm!

[@natesmith6413]

Same. Had to hit the bell.

[@LouieAblett]

was number 1 on my page for me 😟

[@Michael-Oh]

This one is wild, but also compared to your other videos, this one seemed to be the most straightforward.

[@thelklad7940]

What would the reaction be if the religion of Islam was being mocked and berated in this video... It's strange how Catholicism is the only religion that can receive mockery in our society.

[@TheresaCoughy]

Very telling comment... This isn't mockery. The Catholic Church has a huge problem as all religions do. You missed the points so you could attack Islam in a pathetically veiled way. You are hate. You support hate. Well done, big achievement. The pinnacle of humanity.

[@emilysmith1000]

I agree, except it's any Christian denomination really.

[@ismailkoya66]

so why don't you stand up for yourself? Go out on the streets and protest. Nobody is stopping you.

[@jaygee6447]

You don’t think other religions are mocked?! The reasons they’re mocked is because they’re all made up

[@emilysmith1000]

@@ismailkoya66 the reaction towards persecution or mockery tells you something about the nature of the religion.

[@ashlee5115]

Wow you guys are amazing the response you got was shocking!

[@abdell75roussos]

It is shocking, but what reaction would they get if this was an Iman? These two know too well that could be the end of thier lives, and their families.

[@MomoIsMyHero]

LOL that's so wild Edit: just read the other comments on this video, people are so mad so you know it's gonna be a banger. Good work Archie and Josh.

[@Veganismdebunked812]

Would you condone someone going into a mosque or a Jewish temple, and making KZbin content for fun out of things sacred to them?

[@MomoIsMyHero]

@@Veganismdebunked812 yes

[@jaclynjax8308]

If people are upset over this video then they need to start truly understanding what religion is and what they are a part of. If you felt uneasy before you even watched it then look inside yourself as to why you are.

[@Pia-mf9dd]

Yes very well said

[@FCGLITCHES]

The issue is when they speak about Christainity and label it as the only religion. We seem to be put into one bracket based on christain belief

[@dodgemF1]

​​​​it's all religion, regardless of their marketing. It's all false hope, sold as fact to the weakest of society. In any other environment it would be classed as a scam.

[@MV-vv7sg]

@@dodgemF1 (I’m not an advocate of either side of this debate- I just want to understand your reasoning) What is the different between this and the sort of belief system that is our Justice Systems in Democratic societies? (One can imagine in the future this sort of system is old and replaced but still used by others, in the same way religion is used today - after itself once being a system of justice in its ages of prominence) They (government run Justice Systems) are as arbitrarily synthesised beliefs as religions and so on. They are also at many times abused for money and to protect some and not others. What makes any belief NOT a scam in your opinion? (Just wanting a curious philosophical discussion about your statement - I don’t mean to provoke or advocate of any belief, just want to understand your reasoning) Thanks.

[@JSCHM]

​@@MV-vv7sg I don't think a justice system is really comparable with religion. One big difference would be that a justice system can change (via new laws that are being passed). In contrast, rules in a religion are usually fixed and don't adapt to anything.

[@andremp03]

This is wild!

[@MV-vv7sg]

Not sure what’s better: Josh’s confession / Colm Doherty’s confession in Banshee’s of Inisherin

[@leopardzebra111]

Great video as always!

[@Aiophgy]

Catholic debunking things here And we aren’t hiding anything because you can very easily read the catechism or ask a priest about church teaching. 0:43 Working on Sunday is not a sin 0:45 simply being gay is not a sin, it is the acts that are. We don’t go hunt down gay people. 0:53 they will not report you under their seal of secrecy, but will recommend that you turn yourself in. If they reported you always, no one would go to confession and receive absolution. 3:33 this priest is going about it all wrongs, because I have never heard a single priest I’ve met talk about changing sexualities. Note again, this was one priest out of literally tens of thousands. For all I know you specifically choose the worst one. For all of this forgiving stuff, please understand that the priest is simply a medium for God forgiving you. God will forgive you; he has unconditional love for all of us. However the law is much less forgiving. Confession does not put one above the law. Thank you, have a nice day. If you have questions, ask a priest, read the catechism, or watch Fr. Mike videos cause he’s good at explaining things.

[@jodiemarie9901]

My thought here was obviously that priest hears murder confessions quite a bit

[@cada4533]

loved it so very much! thanks

[@ThatDayDreamer_]

Why did I think the last guy was gonna say "you must go to the police and confess your crime"

[@somebodyisnot4you]

This video is so important, a lot of normal people don’t realize that to homophobes being gay is literally worse than being a pedo or a murderer

[@barteksz932]

How is it worse if there's no difference?

[@mstrmren]

@@barteksz932 Of course someone from Poland said that hahahaha, the joke writes itself

[@someone_idkxd3001]

​@@barteksz932???

[@MB_4ever]

Be homosexual is a big sin in christianity

[@fdddd2023]

@@mstrmren woudn't you do it to muslim, wouldn't you?

[@TheJoeman11]

I am a traditional Catholic of the Latin Mass type. I think Josh and Archie have inquiring minds and a gift for investigative work. I forgive Josh and Archie for mocking the Catholic Church and the sacrament of penance aka confession. "Father, forgive them for they know not what they do" comes to mind in their defense. They can have their fun but imagine a world where we didnt forgive eachother or God held grudges against us and refused to forgive. You may be forgiven many times as it is in the power of the one offended to CHOOSE to forgive but in the end the sinner destroys himself. Forgiveness for sins removes temporal punishment but not the DAMAGE caused. Official Catholic teaching. If you break a window and say sorry, the window isnt fixed - you must still fix it. I hope one day you can infiltrate the Church and expose the Freemasons and communist infiltrators.

[@ELXABER]

Does the Church have the ability to forgive sin? No Is Sunday, the day of the Church proclaimed by a former Pope, the Lord's Day? No, that's considered Sun worship. Does the Papacy proclaim itself the representation of God on Earth? Yes, and that is blasphemy as are the other two. Believe in the Bible, not the Church, and follow the Bible, not Man.

[@freddier47]

@@ELXABERThe bible is my favourite work of fiction

[@TheJoeman11]

@@ELXABER Thank you for responding. In the Bible we see that Jesus Christ founded a Church with actual people. The Bible doesnt claim itself as the only authority because the Bible states that Jesus gives the Church authority. It can be argued that if Jesus made Peter the Rock and said that on this Rock "I will build my Church" then it seems to make sense that Peter became the head of the Church and therefore Christ's representative ie God's representative. If you disagree then you need to explain the correct translation, context and theological understanding to make your point convincing. Remember that God does not play games with ambiguous meanings. Catholics worship God on Sunday which replaces the pagan sun worship. Without the Catholic Church protecting the Bible for 1500 years there would not be any Bible.

[@ELXABER]

@@TheJoeman11 He didn't make them the authority, he made them representatives, and they proclaimed themselves the authority. He didn't give any man the authority to forgive sin, worship the sun, or change the Bible in its most fundamental way by changing the wording of the 10 commandments, it did not give the authority for an all-encompassing religion. Nearly everything the Catholic church has told its followers is blasphemy according to the word, which also accordingly is unchangeable. What does it say about a religion that is accepting of all religions?

[@TheJoeman11]

@@ELXABER The Bible is your favourite work of fiction? But Jesus and Rome did exist. The places are real. How would you know if its fiction or not? This sun worship is another topic, we Catholics love the sun but we dont worship it. If God makes someone a representative then they have authority for the area of relevance IF they present it authentically. Anyone can forgive sins committed against them. Your mother can forgive you for being a difficult child for example. God can also forgive us and since He is in heaven He might want to use representatives on Earth. Can a supreme being set up its own organization? If there's one God and this God claims to be truth then it follows that there can only be one religion in the end without any contradictions in its dogma - its theological doctrine. If there are many Gods then how do we test them to be real? Do we include any religion a person likes or invented? If there is no God then how do we begin to prove that? How do we solve this hot potato? Even atheists dont have any conclusive answers except that they are not sure.

[@kichan117]

This is real quality content. You’re amazing guys!

[@Daniel_Paterson]

This is a really thought-provoking video that is less about making fun of the Catholic Church and more presenting ideas that challenge the actions and ideologies of religions. I really hope some people who are religious watch this video so they're able to assess their own motives in religion. Awesome video as always ^_^

[@lg3889]

how is not being ok with murder an ideology to be challenged? peoples religion is not something to be progressive, if u dont like it u dont have to associate with it but this is disgustingly disrespectful and if your not willing to do this to an islamic leader in a sacred place he should not feel comfortable mocking christianity like this. disgusting.

[@Dornana]

Daniel Peterson, Confession is a sacrament where one confesses their sins and repents. The priest's role is to help obtain forgiveness from God and oneself, and they cannot divulge any information shared during confession. This video is disrespectful as it violates the sacrament's sanctity. Furthermore, the confession likely lasted longer than the edited version presented, and the priest should have encouraged the confessor to turn themselves in, repent, and face the consequences of their actions, which I'm sure he did.

[@pocketsand76]

@@lg3889 they’re ok enough with it not to call the police.

[@tomchapman128]

@@Dornana They murdered someone or sexually abused a minor and thats okay?? But being gay is a sin and they require conversion therapy? How is any of this morally okay?

[@ateyourchips1164]

You can be religious and not approve murder you realize that right?

[@franqu1n]

I enjoy your videos. I stand behind this one as well.

[@abdell75roussos]

You think they should try this with another religion? They are not fools, Catholics are tolerant and harmless.

[@FionaMu]

It's wild that the Father is suggesting you go to a place in Westminster for conversion therapy. Like he's giving you directions.

[@GrowingDownUnder]

Sometimes ya gotta forgot about "secrecy" and all that stuff and say how you really feel and do something about these crimes the people commit. I'd rather be honorable to myself and do something about it then keep a secret and forgive that person

[@AmaraARW]

They can't really, because in most situations police wouldn't be able to do anything about that confession as it would be inadmissible in court. the only reason why confessionals are a thing is because of that.

[@farsan7465]

@@AmaraARW but if they tell the police that they did commit a crime the police can search for valid evidence to get that person sentenced. now all they do is keep quiet about it. like idiots.

[@dodgemF1]

​@@AmaraARWit's a smokescreen to entice the gullible to keep giving the church tax free money for doing basically nothing, it's a brilliant business model.

[@a_plus_luxe3426]

If you told your friend about the time you robbed a bank he would be required in most places to share that with the police then testify against you in court, but for obvious reasons that doesn't apply to spouses, lawyers, doctors, therapist or priests. They can (and should) share privileged conversations when they believe there is an imminent threat to you or somebody else, but otherwise the relationship only works if you believe that the government can't force them to give up your secrets.

[@GrowingDownUnder]

@@AmaraARW confessing to a crime i'm pretty sure is enough to get a person arrested and investigation going. Testimonial evidence is definitely viable in court, not sure who told you it wasn't but it is. And I mean you're only talking about the police, who says I wouldn't personally do anything myself if I found out a person was with a 14 year old girl? no way i'd just let that guy walk away knowing he's a danger to the public and little kids

[@Tizzandor]

i love you guys. fantastic work as always

[@IsabellaJacqueline]

This hits hard for me. I put my own biological father in prison for the rest of his life, about 80 years, because he sexually abused me and other members of my family. As I was making a written statement for the police, he was texting my mom that he's was seeking forgiveness from God at the local Catholic church. My district attorney heard he made a confession and asked if the priest if he would testify, but he didn't want to because it was said in confessional and he has the right. It made me so mad, how could that even be legal? It's actually insane that they can be told such things and simply move on. Last I heard, my father is a minister at the prison, how lovely. Religion to me is just harmful for the most part.

[@Aurora-wb2wc]

I'm so sorry you had to go through that, hope you are doing well now

[@maddychurchhouse4556]

I'm so sorry this happened to you ❤ you probably protected so many people and yourself through your actions x

[@AlphaLama.]

Humans: Do horrible things Atheists: Why would God do this?

[@IsabellaJacqueline]

@@AlphaLama. Humans: God created me to sin and then to be forgiven. So that mean I can sin all I want. Dude gtfo, I took history of religion. All religions, all, have been used to promote and manipulate power and control at one point or another. Especially the Roman Catholic Church. Let’s also not forget King James beheaded people if they didn’t write the Bible how he wanted it to be written. Humans are horrible sometimes, but religion is a tool to be horrible too.

[@IsabellaJacqueline]

@@maddychurchhouse4556 It happens to too many people, unfortunately. I did only what was right and what was necessary for me. He had to face justice, that was my proghtive. It was now a decade ago, weird to say. I was 13 and I’m turning 24 this year. I won’t let me trauma define me, nor will I forget it.

[@Andylf87]

You should do a short of you guys confessing to produce this video😂

[@channelpage]

The truth always hurts

[@Wrutschgeluck]

Actually it's legally FORBIDDEN for the priest to tell someone what you confess in there. It's different in all countries. Example in Germany you can confess everything and the priest can be sued for telling anyone else till 45k€!

[@smilesiel]

I always thought it was weird that they acted as if they were some sort of doctors

[@GorgetStudio]

I love when people just bash things without an educated opinion on it. Makes sense.

[@Gerbsert]

2:00 this music made me think some fucker was behind me smacking maraccas wtf

[@HillierSmith]

Reconmended came in clutch today, this is aboslutely hilarious.

[@theaidanator]

Did not expect to see you here Hayden!

[@Veganismdebunked812]

Would you call it hilarious if people did a video trying to make lite and fun of a Jewish tradition, or Muslim tradition for KZbin content?

[@The_only_subi]

@@Veganismdebunked812 if those religious institutions were also supporting child r_pe, then yes

[@sophiacastano7501]

Woah this is heavy stuff - I’m genuinely shocked.

[@hmul3399]

Lol this was hardly groundbreaking stuff

[@MichaelBrown-lv8kv]

Really???? Do you live under a rock?

[@sophiacastano7501]

Based on the number of comments stating similar reactions such as "This one is wild," "That's crazyyyy," "not surprising, but still shocking," it's clear I'm not alone in feeling unsettled by the video. Just because someone knows about the Catholic Church's beliefs doesn't mean they can't be disturbed by seeing them in practice. Your patronizing comment doesn't help anyone. If you haven't said the same thing to others, maybe take a moment to think about why you're saying it to me. Now tell me, who do you think is living under a rock?@@MichaelBrown-lv8kv

[@shield_maiden_]

This is insane. Amazing video guys. I hope so many people see it.

[@slightlyokok]

Great video idea. I’ve always wanted to troll confession, but I’m a wimp. I’m glad I get to vicariously live through this.

[@ChrisM-bn5vr]

You should go to confession and take a poop in the confession booth while you talk to him. Then next week confess to taking a poop in the confession booth and force him to forgive you for stinking his confession booth up with shit.

[@B3autySparks]

same here but I have yet to find somewhere with a confessional near me. when I do I’m wreaking havoc.

[@STARSH1PPAIN]

Being a "troll" in confession, or at the church and christianity in general, happens all the time. Be original, like, do it to jews or muslims.

[@slightlyokok]

Sure thing Padre.

[@abdell75roussos]

@@B3autySparks Try this with an Iman, or in a Mosque. You and your family may pay the price; cool, don't forget to record.

[@shannsimms9072]

Omg I used to lie in confession when I was in school, but never to murder lmao.

[@NinaWagner-Fors]

forsen's wife and dog dissapeared, he was forgiven

[@AlexNV75]

As a non-practicing Catholic who is baptized and confirmed (I usually just say I’m Christian), I honestly wasn’t shocked by the outcome of the video one bit. I learned pretty early on that the church’s vow to withholding the contents of confessions is one of the strictest things they can’t break.

[@Esteemed_B]

This is what I thought teachers would do whenever they said that it's better to own up

[@bhambhole]

I am gaining more respect for your intentions as i watch more of your videos. Views and subs are important to keep your channel going but intention is of the Greatest value. Continue your path.

[@xMegaVideos]

Shocking, but no one is actually shocked. Right?

[@AdamTheDude1985]

This is insane

[@KingDomsKingdom85]

Wow, what an incredible video. Just found your stuff through your protesting the protestors one, incredible content.

[@mochibear8933]

I have so many thoughts, just wow 😮

[@dropbearzzz]

I knew priests would be homophobic but I had no idea that they could hear a crime and not report it to the police. I thought it worked like therapists, if they heard of harm to someone they had to report. This is so scary. I can’t imagine all the things they have heard and let the person get away. I’m really happy you did this video I wish more people would expose this backward way of thinking

[@AlphaLama.]

They literally can't tell ANYONE about it, that's the whole point, nobody would visit confession if the priest would just tell everybody about it

[@michaelmikeykellymikeydama5405]

It's called reconciliation. Atheists wouldn't understand this. Christians, as well as Jews and Muslims, do this as an act of confession to God, not the police. Clergy are only there to guide them. In fact, clergy are not even required in confession. Clergy do not be a bunch of pricks and tell the confessor to hide their crimes, they would always advise them to turn themselves in if they have committed a crime that deserves jail time and that time has not been served.

[@TheJoeman11]

Homophobic means ' an irrational fear of humans' but has come to mean hatred of homosexuals. To disagree with someone is not hatred of the person. My friend thinks shes the Queen of England and I dont agree with her but I still love her. A doctor loves the patient but "hates" the illness.

[@onba7726]

Actually they have reported these crimes. Not all of them I'm sure, but I'm a bit a true crime nut and I've heard several cases that were solved because priests broke their vows. Also, not catholic, but I believe confession is anonymous so in cities, it's basically impossible to catch someone in report like this. And would you even hear about it anyway? There's also an issue with UK police not caring about serious crimes and only going after easy crimes like mean tweets. Over the pandemic one district even releases 800 pedophiles without trial despite dozens of victims coming forward (it was a gang). In some cases the same men are belived to have trafficked more than a thousand girls over more than a decade.

[@Stbaa77]

@@TheJoeman11 LMAO no it doesn’t. Stop trying to change the definition of words because you don’t like them, homophobe.

[@Cuntsville]

The age of consent in Italy is 14 btw

[@dodgemF1]

Priests don't care how old their victims are.

[@brandon3872]

Just because something is legal doesn't mean it's right.

[@Cuntsville]

@@brandon3872 I never said it was right.

[@Veganismdebunked812]

@@dodgemF1you are generalising too much. Because you are doing it how about I do that? Most priests who have “victims” are gay lefty infiltrators who don’t hold the true faith, I may as-well say gay people don’t care how old their victims then . Silly logic

[@youtubewatcher703]

I feel like if this was against another religion, they could get done for hate crime. Got to be careful these days

[@elliot7981]

Why have I only just found this video

[@chickpea734]

people are mad but you just showed the truth lol.

[@damp9592]

As if people Didn’t know that the Catholic Church considers homosexuality to be a sin… they showed nobody nothing

[@chickpea734]

@@damp9592 tell that to the triggered ppl in the comments

[@ChrisM-bn5vr]

I mean this isn't shocking truth, everyone knows the catholic church is against homosexuality. Also most people know that the priests aren't allowed to talk about confessions outside of the booth no matter what it is, they're sworn to secrecy.

[@GracesGarden80]

Everything wrong with Catholic Church and organised religion in one video.

[@abdullahal-mamun1053]

ok

[@araragio]

ok

[@GracesGarden80]

Ok

[@caitlinbrennan9039]

Enlighten me?

[@bobrob6712]

​@@caitlinbrennan9039you have been enlightened

[@brendatroth3860]

I am appalled that a person/people can go to a priest and ask for forgiveness of ANYTHING INCLUDING MURDER and just have to do a few pentences and be COMPLETELY FORGIVEN to then do it again next week! Something is very wrong here.

[@JSRJS]

Maybe the police should bug the confessionals

[@bencoatesworth7731]

So basically being gay is a big no no and they think torture is the answer but having sex with a minor is ok but maybe get married first. Really says alot about the Catholic Church and their morals

[@Inzersdorf93]

It depends on the priest who is doing the confession duty, really. But those is this video here are really really shocking.

[@JJ-pl5cj]

That’s if this is even real

[@michaelmikeykellymikeydama5405]

The condemnation of grooming is written ALL OVER the Catechism of the Catholic Church, the modern Bible is dumb terms. CCC 2285: "Scandal takes on a particular gravity by reason of the authority of those who cause it or the weakness of those who are scandalized. It prompted our Lord to utter this curse: "Whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a great millstone fastened round his neck and to be drowned in the depth of the sea". Scandal is grave when given by those who by nature or office are obliged to teach and educate others. Jesus reproaches the scribes and Pharisees on this account: he likens them to wolves in sheep's clothing." CCC 2353: "Fornication (…) it is a grave scandal when there is corruption of the young." CCC 2356: "Rape is the forcible violation of the sexual intimacy of another person. It does injury to justice and charity. Rape deeply wounds the respect, freedom, and physical and moral integrity to which every person has a right. It causes grave damage that can mark the victim for life. It is always an intrinsically evil act. Graver still is the rape of children committed by parents (incest) or those responsible for the education of the children entrusted to them." CCC 2389: "Connected to incest is any sexual abuse perpetrated by adults on children or adolescents entrusted to their care. the offense is compounded by the scandalous harm done to the physical and moral integrity of the young, who will remain scarred by it all their lives; and the violation of responsibility for their upbringing."

[@joshuaking2171]

So they support same sex marriage

[@chesterbless9441]

They did this in Italy, and the age of consent is 14 for some reason. Still bad, but not illegal surprisingly. And the penance for gay sex was one Our Father, not torture.

[@danielcarrigan4934]

The pure disappointment in his face when the father suggested conversion therapy was heartbreaking

[@tombensonfilms5328]

Except he didn't. Josh was the only one who mentioned conversion therapy. It feels really disingenuous.

[@MarkN65]

Did I just watch an episode of panorama? 😅

[@charliemitchell7476]

should have tried this with something that weighed on the priest more. like confessing to having 14 kids locked in a basement. see how they react then

[@TheBen1202]

I mean this is not surprising, and nor should they be forced to report such things. This is coming from a non religious and understanding person. Obviously what happened is bad, but the nature of religion literally prevents them from telling the authorities. Even if they did, they believe that the ultimate judgement comes from god. The whole idea of a confessional is quite nice, really

[@LukasWeber64]

One the one hand, I get that the church probably doesn’t want to deter people from confessing (which, of course, might happen if confessing to crimes could expose people to legal consequences.) On the other hand, though, if people are truly remorseful, they should presumably be willing to face punishment for their crimes, and if they aren’t, they’re probably to some degree not truly repentant. Allowing people confess without facing any consequences might encourage more people to confess, but I don’t think it would encourage real repentance-on the contrary, I think it would allow people to assuage their guilty consciences without actually owning up in a real way. Most importantly, though, most crimes have victims. Leave the punishment of the perpetrator up to god, fine, whatever, but protect the victims! How would you feel if you found out that a priest knew that you were being abused but did nothing to get your abuser away from you?? The purpose of reporting is to protect current and possible future victims, and refusing to do this is absolutely awful.

[@caitlinbrennan9039]

@@LukasWeber64it’s not evidence in court

[@LukasWeber64]

@@caitlinbrennan9039 Uh, what? No one’s saying “if someone confesses to a crime, lock them up immediately.” I’m just saying “do what you’d do in any other scenario where someone told you they committed a serious crime”-report it to the police.

[@caitlinbrennan9039]

@@LukasWeber64 and im saying it’s not evidence the police couldn’t do much with it

[@LukasWeber64]

@@caitlinbrennan9039 Have you never heard of mandatory reporters?

[@Hannahwxlsh]

Disrespect towards someone’s religion is just as poor as disrespect towards someone’s sexuality which you were so heavily against. This is very low brow

[@zoid3515]

Religion is a belief and sexuality is a fact, not the same. Also, pointing out hatred in a person's belief is not disrespect

[@zoid3515]

​@@shah6302 Regardless of how many genders you think there are or what you call it, if a person is attracted to someone based on their gender then that is a fact. Would think this is pretty common knowledge but I guess some of us (you) are a little slow

[@JJ-pl5cj]

@@zoid3515 what “hatred”??? The bible says that homosexuality is a sin but lots of things are sins and there’s not a single person in the world without sin so stop with the BS that Christians “hate” gays

[@zoid3515]

@@JJ-pl5cj First of all literally watch the video, and second your own comment proved you wrong lol. The book that is like the center of the whole religion considers homosexuality immoral, if that isn't hatred towards gay people than I don't know what is.

[@JJ-pl5cj]

@@zoid3515 so what? Loads of things are immoral. Christians don’t think they’re better than anyone else they’re sinners too. S*x before marriage is a sin but it doesn’t mean Christians “hate” people who do it

[@Adam-mc5in]

Amazing

[@harriettbanish5285]

this should have a lot more comments,

[@bajanyaoikaizer6902]

Awe, congratulations you two 🌈💪🏼🍀 Do not forgive me father buttercream; for I have sinned. I have a crush on Josh Pieters

[@rusprice]

he’s not actually gay

[@manuel9843]

this is ridiculous

[@thoktrigg3308]

I think the pape response talking to LGBT+ person was very kind and provided a good vision of christian in the world. He said that the church should'nt judge and reject people.

[@thebluepikmim]

Why is nobody talking about the fact that the priest didn’t care about the fact that the girl was a child but only cares that they weren’t married.

[@willem8820]

So many sooking people in the comments

[@natesmith6413]

Every bit of this made me uncomfortable.

[@paulsmakingmovies1451]

I'm shocked.

[@johndodger]

The bigger picture in all this is that Priests don't snitch. My G's 😂

[@allstars2825]

I am fine with the secrecy of this, but not forgiveness by god. Like, wtf.

[@AlphaLama.]

Mate, forgiveness is literally the whole point of Christianity

[@reddalert4925]

You don't understand christianity

[@angelicamariapuga9418]

I'm so nervous for him❤😅

[@innocentbystander8394]

What if great faith without great doubt is just ego?

[@googleaccount4471]

On the day of judgement you will have to explain this

[@dodgemF1]

There's no day...... stop being gullible.

[@hmul3399]

@@dodgemF1 Wait and see.

[@dragonetafireball]

My (ex-) priest told me they’re supposed to encourage you confess to serious crimes but he did run off with one of the parishioners wives after he got her pregnant so…

[@harryhairo7272]

Spotlight

[@yessir5695]

It is really shocking to see how the church still works this way

[@caitlinbrennan9039]

The Catholic Church will always have confession

[@DetectiveSmilez]

@@caitlinbrennan9039bro is fiercely trying to defend the church😂😂😂 the meatriding is crazy

[@mayadeppweber7790]

Disrespectful of u to even film that. U knew the outcome beforehand this was not necessary.

[@anonymoose7018]

yes it was.

[@mayadeppweber7790]

@@anonymoose7018 nope.

[@fenlandwildlifeclips]

Btw the high cofe church also have confessions, or so I have been told. I hope you passed this on to the police. You should repeat this in the UK & see how that goes...

[@gr3mlin404]

2:02 "Having confessed to something minor. Not in that way, that comes later." 💀💀💀💀💀

[@themegamerx]

underrated stuff

[@bigstubby1969]

This is a shocking expose.

[@Dr.du-du]

For your crime of murder, you’ll be sentenced to one month of hard reading of psalm 50

[@josephdanieljirehdimacali4418]

Watching the prank make me remember an old show tht was popular in my country in my high school days on early 2000's titled "May Bukas pa" (there is still tommorow). Wherein the main story is kid whose MC of the show named Santino was abandoned in a church as a baby. Adopted by local parishioners & befriends an old abandoned statue of Jesus as imaginary friend whom he named "Bro." Who comes to life when Lord Christ himself inhabited the statue. & gave him power to heal the sick. Anyway one arc that change status qou of the show was when his adopted father whose a priest heard a confession of a guilt riddened kidnapper hired to kidnapped Santino. Of course cause it's his adopted son who will be kidnapped. So he told the cops about it have all assailants arrested & prevented the crime from happening. So the priest was removed from office by church head for snitching as it's against church rules as priest. Show & my catholic friends, family who also tuned in the show justified the act. But was messed up how unjust it is. So you're not allowed to save a life just to keep religious tradition? SMH.

[@OliviaWestmorland]

YES YES THIS IS HILARIOUS

[@LouieAblett]

surely this time you guys have actually peaked at last omds.... fking quality

[@brendanleary802]

This is utterly disgraceful everyone is allowed to have their own beliefs and to make a mockery because of someone because of their beliefs is horrible all your doing is making yourself look bad

[@mickeyfilmer5551]

🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂I'm f*ckin crying laughing...

[@haz576]

Here before this video gets deleted

[@cosmicjenny4508]

@@Ami_BK What agenda? That institutional pedophilia is bad?

[@lookhowshegobbledthat]

​@@Ami_BK Found the pdf file

[@dodgemF1]

​@@Ami_BKso you're the gullible one, still looking up in the sky to your pretend father.

[@NicNakBraun]

Totally reported

[@morgancarolan8680]

@@NicNakBraun clown🤡

[@chrisdoherty2199]

This is brilliant

[@Dornana]

Disrespect is being brilliant?

[@TheConMan1]

@@Dornana well, when the Catholic Church is advocating for homophobia, then yes, it is.

[@dodgemF1]

​@aurelian1715 The crimes that institution has committed against children, is abhorrent. There's nothing left of the church to respect.

[@Dornana]

@@dodgemF1 Is that so? How about the Dalai Lama kissing a children, I suppose you dont have buddism as much as catholicism am I right? The catholic church is an institution that goes back 2 milleniums ago. It is responsable for many hospitals, orphanages and instutions for the poor. And the church always did it for free, and as always theres a few bad apples in the basket. As there is pedophiles in goverment, gay pedophiles, homophobic pedophiles and so on.

[@dodgemF1]

​@@Dornanasins only exist if you're gullible, and you qualify.

[@ewsafa]

I thought Sandi toksvig made a cameo at 7:03

[@virtualfroggy]

i never saw this video was released, i missed u guys so much. love u

[@StarWarsGirl98]

I think the gay part of this video is insensitive. I struggle to balance my queerness and my Catholicism, and I have been in the confessional doing this for real. It did not go like this. There are actual queer human beings like myself who try to love both the church and themselves. It’s more complicated than you’ve made it out to be by confessing a sexual act you didn’t do, in a sacrament you don’t believe in.

[@Maukinmassif]

❤

[@kanyewest9002]

God bless you in the struggle to remain faithful for Christ. Those who resist temptation will be crowned with glory in heaven. Some people like Josh and Archie wish to mock institutions without making any attempt to understand them. May God bless you, and keep the faith.

[@HectorCamacho67]

Only fair you go and embarrass other religions now or we just hating on catholics? Be very interested to hear what other religious scholars say

[@M_RM.]

Channel fell off when it changed from Josh Pieters to Josh & Archie