What motivates people to destroy North American anthropological evidence? | Dr. Elizabeth Weiss

  Рет қаралды 82,845

Aporia Podcast

Aporia Podcast

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 1 400
@cro-magnoncarol4017
@cro-magnoncarol4017 Ай бұрын
Victimhood is weakness, & nobody respects weakness...
@cro-magnoncarol4017
@cro-magnoncarol4017 Ай бұрын
@@rehobothwell Bro, he dodged a bullet on his front... literally. And he's didn't even complain about it. What on Earth are you talking about?
@subsamadhi
@subsamadhi Ай бұрын
Stay in your trailer park you'll be fine
@leroilapue15
@leroilapue15 Ай бұрын
Unfortunately people with zero morals will use victimhood to control the narrative and everyone who bows down to it becomes a demoralized servent to insanity
@Nachos_with_a_slice_of_lime
@Nachos_with_a_slice_of_lime Ай бұрын
Living with yts is not a human right
@horatioguderian4694
@horatioguderian4694 Ай бұрын
Dude, the issue isn't "victimhood", the issue is ANTI-WHITEISM. The issue is FALSELY blaming whites for Siberian-American's problems and using that strawman to justify White GENOCIDE.
@ferociousgustafson4040
@ferociousgustafson4040 Ай бұрын
Trudeau has mandated every university degree include an ‘Indigenous Studies’ component. I had a professor LITERALLY say, “as a historian, it’s not my job to be accurate”.
@JohanDanielsson8802
@JohanDanielsson8802 Ай бұрын
What the... the "not my job to be accurate", is some next level postmodernist stuff.
@billyhughes9776
@billyhughes9776 Ай бұрын
lol - wat?
@FraserMitchell-k4j
@FraserMitchell-k4j Ай бұрын
If you are still in University, drop the course, and look for another course with a prof who approaches their discipline with common sense. Personal experience with similar Woke academics I will tell you save yourself the grief.
@jed-henrywitkowski6470
@jed-henrywitkowski6470 Ай бұрын
The forget indigenous is not a racial or ethnic term. Students ought to be taught about the tall blondes of Slavic and Germanic lands! (Familiar bias, I admit lol).
@deanfirnatine7814
@deanfirnatine7814 Ай бұрын
WOW!
@anthonymorris5084
@anthonymorris5084 Ай бұрын
Victimhood has become a lucrative industry.
@logtolum
@logtolum Ай бұрын
Taken to the level of a fine art up here in Canada with the 'murders' at residential schools controversy.
@anthonymorris5084
@anthonymorris5084 Ай бұрын
@@logtolum There were no "murders" at the residential schools. What on Earth are you talking about? Are you always this misinformed?
@logtolum
@logtolum Ай бұрын
@@anthonymorris5084 Don't you understand the significance of the highlighting of the word 'murders'... Of course, there weren't any... that is the point.
@anthonymorris5084
@anthonymorris5084 Ай бұрын
@@logtolum Thanks for the clarification. I'm not used to such sophisticated literacy from people here on KZbin. LOL cheers.
@carausiuscaesar5672
@carausiuscaesar5672 Ай бұрын
@@logtolumhoax and lies and defames Canada🇨🇦
@DavidMartinez-ce3lp
@DavidMartinez-ce3lp Ай бұрын
I'll never forget Don Cheadle's reaction when he found out his ancestors were owned by Native Americans. They didn't want to free them even after the emancipation proclamation.
@benjaminpratt2016
@benjaminpratt2016 Ай бұрын
Or kunta kintay (jordi la forge)finding out his grandfather was as white as the fresh driven snow. Roots never happened. It's a fiction novel. Cleopatra was Greek. And DUTCH BRAIDS ARE VIKING. stop with the ignorance.
@RambleOn07
@RambleOn07 Ай бұрын
Tbf, the tribes were still technically independent at the time. But yeah, it's really sad how much misinformation is pushed as history for political purposes.
@rustinstardust2094
@rustinstardust2094 Ай бұрын
I don't think *anyone* wanted to free them...I think that was the problem. Native Americans were not unique in that aspect.
@DavidMartinez-ce3lp
@DavidMartinez-ce3lp Ай бұрын
@rustinstardust2094 true, but I've never heard anyone talk about it. When I learned about Don Cheadle's ancestors, that was the first time I learned that Native Americans owned slaves.
@jlacko
@jlacko 29 күн бұрын
@@rustinstardust2094Yeah, nobody wanted them free except for all of those people who fought a war to make it happen.
Ай бұрын
Guilt tripping Europeans, while gifting off them..always is.
@deanfirnatine7814
@deanfirnatine7814 Ай бұрын
It was crappy what happened to them but look at the crap that happened to the Celts and Slavs!
@MP-db9sw
@MP-db9sw Ай бұрын
@@deanfirnatine7814 in other words it was crappy but theres no reason why you should care. Its not like you personally benefitted from it or theres any valid reasons why they might still be suffering from having their homes and rights stripped away, their cultures destroyed, and their personhood denied for...how many generations is it, now?
@peterivers2
@peterivers2 Ай бұрын
So what choice do they have? they are at an enormous disadvantage, you are speaking from the point of view of the conqueror, you are incredibly callous, you aren't taking into account the enormous asymmetry of the situation, and then you probably turn around and say you're a christian.
@showofhands8214
@showofhands8214 Ай бұрын
@@peterivers2 Natives weren't sea bearing and didn't have horses, they enslaved and savaged there own people(eventually bought african slaves), conquered various native tribes only because they didn't have the means to attempt to conquer other lands. They would've, if they had the geography to do it. So pulling the victim card because one side lost here and using fancy words like callous and asymmetry is very Liberal of you.
@peterbills4129
@peterbills4129 Ай бұрын
@@MP-db9sw Who's stopping them from selling their casinos and returning to the wilderness?
@donningarmour2873
@donningarmour2873 Ай бұрын
We need many more academics speaking out about anti-whiteism. TY for the clip. Good stuff.
@Republitarian-g4h
@Republitarian-g4h Ай бұрын
Anti-whyitizm is the most important issue of our times.
@bretave7379
@bretave7379 Ай бұрын
That Won't Happen! The World FEEDS off us, in Every way Possible.
@Tiffany-mu6br
@Tiffany-mu6br Ай бұрын
They are not speaking on the very important issue if AntiWhiteism they are promoting it
@horatioguderian4694
@horatioguderian4694 Ай бұрын
@@Tiffany-mu6br I didn't get that impression, can you explain what you mean?
@MDJ-f7k
@MDJ-f7k Ай бұрын
Respecting people who are white is anti white. Your ancestors like all of mankind came out of Africa. You are an African American. If you were better educated you would know race is a social construct. Race is meaningless. I Have never bought into the conservative culture of victimization. Victimization keeps you trapped on the plantation.
@thermalreboot
@thermalreboot Ай бұрын
I'm a Mayflower descendent and it was eye opening to me to learn how complicated pre-Mayflower New England politics was in 1620. To use progressive terms, the Narraganset Federation had colonized ALL of New England and were putting all the New England tribes under a Feudal system where those tribes had to pay large tribute to the Narragansets under threat of violence. The harmony between the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag was very much true, Massasoit saw the English as an ally he could use to shift the balance of power towards his favor so he welcomed them, what cemented the relationship was when Edward Winslow tended Massasoit when Massasoit was ill with a disease the probably would have killed him had he not received the proper treatment. Massasoit was correct, his English alliance threw off the oppression by the Narraganset and the Wampanoag benefited by their relationship with the English for the rest of Massasoit's life and probably would have continued had Massasoit's son Alexander not died leaving Phillip in charge and torching everything. That however is a different story. What remains is that there is no moral superiority of the Indians over anyone else. My 8th great grandfather was kidnapped by the Abenaki and sold into slavery.
@joanhuffman2166
@joanhuffman2166 Ай бұрын
I was well into adulthood when I found out that the Wampanoag had suffered a 90% mortality from an infectious disease about 10 years before the Mayflower arrived. Before the Wampanoag never permitted Europeans to do more than trade, no trading posts, no buildings. After the great loss, an alliance with the English against their rivals looked much better.
@deanfirnatine7814
@deanfirnatine7814 Ай бұрын
The Sioux and Comanche among others had de facto empires, the Sioux exacted tribute and pretty much forced their "allies" to fight with them to avoid the fate of groups like the Mandan, their "ally" the Northern Arapaho chose to go live on a reservation with their ancient enemy the Shoshone rather than their "ally" the Sioux because they knew they would be treated better. The Comanche did not exact tribute when they conquered others lands the people fled or were slaughtered. My cousins tribes lands where I grew up had actually only been there a few hundred years having driven the original tribe off on to lousier lands on the other side of the mountains. I am not condemning them for all this because this is the story everywhere in the world.
@katl6320
@katl6320 Ай бұрын
nat'l geographic did an excellent portrayal with the film 'saints and strangers'. kzbin.info/www/bejne/ipWzaaxvZpuGftUsi=v4YpzibpRXUuyXgg
@DadHominem
@DadHominem Ай бұрын
Philbrick's "Mayflower: A Story of Courage, Community, and War" is an excellent account of the story of the passengers of the Mayflower.
@SockieTheSockPuppet
@SockieTheSockPuppet Ай бұрын
Plus if it wasn't for Squanto, the Pilgrims would've initially been left to starve in the winter.
@TrebizondMusic-cm6fp
@TrebizondMusic-cm6fp Ай бұрын
It seems that religious fundamentalism and "blood and soil" ideology is OK for the right kind of people...
@ronfox5519
@ronfox5519 Ай бұрын
Wow. Great point
@CodyseusRex
@CodyseusRex Ай бұрын
Its a good thing, you dont have to hate people by wanting to stay with your own tribe👍. Plus God made the nations (ethnikos: root word for ethnicities or races) so they could be used to judge each other when one or more messes up. The devil always tries to connect people against God, globalism was the heart of the tower of babel
@elijahwilson1422
@elijahwilson1422 Ай бұрын
Too bad they ALSO want EVERYONE else's patch of dirt.
@cmcapps1963
@cmcapps1963 Ай бұрын
Namely, the left's kind of people.
@mrq6270
@mrq6270 Ай бұрын
No, it’s not okay for the “right kind of people“.
@cal4625
@cal4625 Ай бұрын
Long standing conflicts and blood feuds between Tribal populations in the Americas were instrumental in European explorers being able to find Native allies.
@rdred8693
@rdred8693 Ай бұрын
Bingo. The Ute's used to enslave the Navajo.
@makeamericanativeamericana7436
@makeamericanativeamericana7436 Ай бұрын
@@rdred8693Nah you settlers just reignited our conflicts that had been settled peacefully for your own awful ends. Divide and conquer. Nothing to be proud of. Yet you people are not very spirit centered .
@deanfirnatine7814
@deanfirnatine7814 Ай бұрын
Exactly, that is how Cortez conquered the Aztec, all the conquered nations joined Cortez in taking down their Aztec oppressors.
@robertthomsonwatson2542
@robertthomsonwatson2542 Ай бұрын
Its called divide and conquer the Romans used it very effectively.
@J-Hue
@J-Hue Ай бұрын
In layman's terms. Feudal infighting and lack of unity amongst the native populations allowed Europeans to effectively divide and conquer the natives and take all of their lands from them.
@NBGTFO
@NBGTFO Ай бұрын
Aside from being legally prosecuted to the full extent of the law, anyone destroying archeological artifacts should have their academic degrees revoked and they should be banned from any archeology-related activities forever more. Ideologs need to be made to understand that their bullshit will not be tolerated, especially when it comes to erasing or misrepresenting history.
@kassandrin
@kassandrin Ай бұрын
The noble savage is a myth, A European myth that native Americans have embraced. They should know better.
@brucepowell7986
@brucepowell7986 Ай бұрын
false
@RawOlympia
@RawOlympia Ай бұрын
noble savage meant people allowed to hunt - only nobles could hunt in England
@Nachos_with_a_slice_of_lime
@Nachos_with_a_slice_of_lime Ай бұрын
False Europeans always recognized most of those tribes as the savages they are
@Nachos_with_a_slice_of_lime
@Nachos_with_a_slice_of_lime Ай бұрын
@@RawOlympianope. Not even close
@cactiguide
@cactiguide Ай бұрын
@@RawOlympiayou may want to believe that, but that doesn’t make it true.
@WelshKnight1066
@WelshKnight1066 Ай бұрын
Making Cheddar Man of England very dark-skinned is an example of this mindset reaching Britain.
@rolthox
@rolthox Ай бұрын
They did so due to genetic evidence
@innocentsmith6091
@innocentsmith6091 Ай бұрын
​@@rolthoxshakey genetic evidence. He could have been a wide variety of skin tones. It was not likely he was as dark as the darkest Africans.
@shaunsteele6926
@shaunsteele6926 Ай бұрын
@@rolthox no, they did not. There was absolutely nothing in Cheddar Man's genome indicating that he had dark skin. It was purely an "artistic" choice.
@geoffdundee
@geoffdundee Ай бұрын
@@shaunsteele6926 ........his skin was dyed with peat
@geoffdundee
@geoffdundee Ай бұрын
@@rolthox .....there was zero evidence.....ABSOLUTELY ZERO
@justoldog
@justoldog Ай бұрын
Maybe classes on the technological inovations of Europeans would be in order. Lets give credit where its due.
@flamesintheattic
@flamesintheattic Ай бұрын
North America was not some utopia. It was more like a post-apocalyptic wasteland with small tribes of people scratching out a survival level living with constant inter-group battles.
@JJ-vp3bd
@JJ-vp3bd Ай бұрын
Bingo
@bballmomma5900
@bballmomma5900 Ай бұрын
I’ve never heard it described like that but sounds accurate. It sounded like such a harsh way to live and wouldn’t be sustainable after using all of the natural resources. Were the natives really concerned with the environment?
@AveragepoliticsEnjoyer
@AveragepoliticsEnjoyer Ай бұрын
Whatever it was it's not Yours Get out
@geraldcalderone5228-x2p
@geraldcalderone5228-x2p Ай бұрын
EXACTLY! Utopia? It was a brutal experience
@geraldcalderone5228-x2p
@geraldcalderone5228-x2p Ай бұрын
@@AveragepoliticsEnjoyerit’s ours now. They lost
@TeamGreenBurrito
@TeamGreenBurrito Ай бұрын
"To conquer a peopel, you must first sever their roots." Solzhenitsyn
@fredgillespie5855
@fredgillespie5855 7 күн бұрын
And they tried to with their residential Indian schools. And they tried the same thing in Scotland and Ireland when they banned the Gaelic language and traditional dress.
@The1Green4Man
@The1Green4Man 27 күн бұрын
Brave ladies, thank you for speaking up
@gwiyomikim5988
@gwiyomikim5988 27 күн бұрын
Yes. “Braves”. You speak-um truth.👍🏼
@VictimPoliticized
@VictimPoliticized Ай бұрын
Revisionist history is easy when stories are passed on orally.
@joeyinwi1514
@joeyinwi1514 Ай бұрын
And digitally
@koltoncrane3099
@koltoncrane3099 Ай бұрын
Idk some Native American tribes only has an oral history. I do believe the Paiutes oral history of them killing redheaded native Americans a thousand years ago because like a century ago people literally found dozens of skeletons in the cave matching the story.
@mattschrader5047
@mattschrader5047 Ай бұрын
@@joeyinwi1514 Underrated comment. More history has changed in the past 15-20 years since "consensus" or peer review tactics have been used on the internet to push historical narratives and literally change and rewrite history. It's done with definitions changing the historical meaning of words as well. The left is responsible for all of it
@fishmonger1908
@fishmonger1908 Ай бұрын
I'm pretty sure I see what you did there. Unfortunately, most won't get it.
@benstandard
@benstandard Ай бұрын
That's why European people are being erased from their own cultural lore.
@westfieldartworks8188
@westfieldartworks8188 Ай бұрын
I like these more historically accurate, fact based, depictions of North American Indian tribes based on real archaeology and historical artifacts. It makes North American Indian tribes more relatable and human, instead of these supposed angelic like figures who roamed North America creating pristine paradises wherever they set foot. That is, til the " evil white man " showed up. Thank you Dr. Weiss for your work.
@fredgillespie5855
@fredgillespie5855 7 күн бұрын
Black Elk (of book fame) said that they sometimes were hungry but that they never knew what starvation was until the white man came. If there was food in the tribe no one starved, they shared what there was.
@jahearme4259
@jahearme4259 Ай бұрын
If the truth is discouraging to you then your on the wrong side of it. Truth is power!
@Ithel-gd7ex
@Ithel-gd7ex Ай бұрын
No, it's just the truth. Narratives woven from truth is how people manipulate and seized power.
@machtnichtsseimann
@machtnichtsseimann Ай бұрын
It's one thing to be a truth-seeker, but if you're in a department at a university where the truth is not prized, then you have no power. Do you want to keep your job? What back-up plans do you have if/when the department doesn't want to support you for tenure and lets you go in favor of, say, a DEI hire who is clearly biased and not a truth-seeker? You might have to move out of state, get lower pay, but at least you have the integrity of serving truth, which is a form of power and freedom.
@jahearme4259
@jahearme4259 Ай бұрын
@Ithel-gd7ex seizing power vs giving power are two different things. RIGHT or WRONG power can be taken !
@grisflyt
@grisflyt Ай бұрын
@@Ithel-gd7ex You are basically arguing Nietzsche. And Nietzsche is virtually always right. The Will to Power is the Will to Truth to History etc. This is why people fight over history. The one that owns the history owns the future. Sort of. It's about the narrative. People don't argue over whether a war happened or not, but the whys. This also means there is no truth. Only interpretations, or whatever. But I would also like to frame it this way. What you don't know hurts you. Thus knowledge is power. The question then is, what is this knowledge? Could it be related to the truth?
@DummyAccount-gx4wc
@DummyAccount-gx4wc Ай бұрын
@@grisflyt🎯
@jmfa57
@jmfa57 Ай бұрын
I make no apologies for colonization of North America. NONE.
@alexmartinez-og8gu
@alexmartinez-og8gu Ай бұрын
whos asking you for one? sounds like your the one looking for something to cry about
@SBrown-ti8xe
@SBrown-ti8xe Ай бұрын
As we shouldn't.
@jamesking1495
@jamesking1495 Ай бұрын
No apologies for genocide? 😳
@MP-db9sw
@MP-db9sw Ай бұрын
Lol Bro "I wont apologize for colonizing the land but I deserve respect for building the civilization"
@deanfirnatine7814
@deanfirnatine7814 Ай бұрын
I am not proud of what "we" did, theft is wrong but its the same story throughout history, numerous European groups hand vast lands stolen by other groups, Indo Europeans used to control Turkey, and the whole Northern Levant.
@alphacause
@alphacause Ай бұрын
Dr. Weiss brings up an important point. A truly unbiased view of history is one that shows that the same crimes that afflicted one culture afflict other cultures. The only difference is the scale of these crimes, and that scale is determined by the technological sophistication of the culture and not the collective character or moral quality of that culture. Murder, slavery , genocide, theft, conquest, etc. etc. are human ills that we all share. The Europeans only get the brunt of criticism and guilt because they had the technological and logistical means to commit these crimes at such a large scale. The progressive culture is so hellbent on hiding the universality of these transgressions so as to preserve the "victim" status of certain indigenous populations. I am so thankful that we have intrepid academics, like Dr. Weiss, who are resisting these attempts at historical revisionism.
@michaellowe9276
@michaellowe9276 Ай бұрын
@alphacause Your post should have 10,000 thumbs up
@alphacause
@alphacause Ай бұрын
@@michaellowe9276 Thank you so much for the kind words. I am genuinely flattered.
@Mooxieclang
@Mooxieclang 28 күн бұрын
I would say it's a matter of both technology and moral character. The Aztecs were technologically inferior but committed wretched crimes on a mass scale.
@fredgillespie5855
@fredgillespie5855 7 күн бұрын
Well said and true.
@Dseanstrickland-tt7bj
@Dseanstrickland-tt7bj 2 күн бұрын
So... we should be able to talk about the exploitation of german people at the behest of elite Js during the 1920's and how they declared economic war against the german people?
@tinfoilhomer909
@tinfoilhomer909 Ай бұрын
Tasmania has a huge problem with this, doing genetic studies on native people is "against the belief system" of the palawa, who promote a conlang invented in 1992 after all the Tasmanian natives assimilated into mainstream culture. The federal government funded the palawa to justify the constant "not your land" shtick that Australia's government uses to keep everyone's rights up in the air, native and european alike. Tasmanian land rights are effectively neutered by the presence of the palawa. All by design. I will repeat, you can test my DNA I am a native of Tasmania, but if you test a palawa you will end up in federal prison.
@JohanDanielsson8802
@JohanDanielsson8802 Ай бұрын
I just looked it up at Wikipedia, and WTF? Australia seem messed up, to say the least.
@carlosacta8726
@carlosacta8726 Ай бұрын
Australia has seriously turned into a shit show!!! Greets from NYC!!!
@markuhler2664
@markuhler2664 Ай бұрын
Huh. Looks like a good set-up for a crime movie. The coppers have their guy, they just need his DNA to tie him to the crime scene. If only they can prove he's not Palawa so they can get it. Where's that rogue detective leaving his gun and badge on Sarge's desk?
@derikuk2967
@derikuk2967 Ай бұрын
The noble savage in the lost paradise. There is (tax) money to be harvested from having a higher position on the totem pole of victimhood.
@thoughtcriminal-k5l
@thoughtcriminal-k5l Ай бұрын
I was born in America, so that makes me native American. I'm not from anywhere else.
@MrKoobuh
@MrKoobuh Ай бұрын
Any other definition is just granting privileges to people who haven't earned them.
@jamesking1495
@jamesking1495 Ай бұрын
We're not native American, that's racist. 🥱
@philosopher1a
@philosopher1a Ай бұрын
haha Great point
@kramrollin69
@kramrollin69 Ай бұрын
No, you are a native Earth Creature.
@Dseanstrickland-tt7bj
@Dseanstrickland-tt7bj 2 күн бұрын
Meanwhile if a Indian from India was born in the US 3 generations down the line they automatically "aren't american" funny how that goy logic works...
@PaxAlotin
@PaxAlotin Ай бұрын
This is the exact same situation in Australia.
@texcatlipocajunior144
@texcatlipocajunior144 Ай бұрын
Funny how the "Noble Savage" is a totally European idea and the indigenous grifters all around the planet latch on to it like it is their own truth. I'm thinking of the Tasaday con pulled on National Geographic in the Phillipines back in the 70s. That Elizidale dude, who was one of Marcos's henchmen, quoted Rousseau directly as if it was his own thoughts.
@elijahwilson1422
@elijahwilson1422 Ай бұрын
It's wild how history books and even AmerIndians can acknowledge their ancestors did AWFUL things and take no heat over it. But all we Whites are ever reminded of us anything our forebears (allegedly)did to everyone else.
@contribution741
@contribution741 Ай бұрын
@@elijahwilson1422 Whytes are singled out for abuse simply because we were BETTER AT war and colonization. And, arguably, everything else.
@gwynnapnudd702
@gwynnapnudd702 Ай бұрын
Some cultures are better than others. The good guys won - that's us. Anthropology was taken over by the "Tribe" under the aegis of Marxism to use as a weapon against us.
@PeterM8987
@PeterM8987 Ай бұрын
Yes. Rousseau.
@texcatlipocajunior144
@texcatlipocajunior144 Ай бұрын
@@8House National Geographic never walked that fiasco back at all either after promoting the story so hard. That is when I lost respect for them and it wasn't long after rhat I canceled my decades long subscription.
@jerrycaughman6324
@jerrycaughman6324 Ай бұрын
I was born in the 70’s and the noble savage bs was what I was fed in school. Fortunately I was taught to think critically and sniffed it out long ago for the bs it is.
@InfoSuperhighway
@InfoSuperhighway Ай бұрын
In the west coast I remember seeing them talk about “traditional native enchiladas”, I knew the entire history of this period was a grift from then on.
@grey.knight
@grey.knight Ай бұрын
In Canada the reserves have "traditional cannabis dispensaries"
@aldoabruzzi6417
@aldoabruzzi6417 Ай бұрын
It shouldn't surprise anyone that as soon as Dr. Weiss began talking this way, she was instantly blacklisted by academia. They agreed that if she retired immediately, they wouldn't fight her over her retirement benefits.
@surfrat8884
@surfrat8884 29 күн бұрын
Because they are so tolerant of other viewpoints
@jmc5910
@jmc5910 28 күн бұрын
then she could easily sue the hell out of them
@aldoabruzzi6417
@aldoabruzzi6417 28 күн бұрын
@@jmc5910 She did. Google "Tenured professor sues San Jose State University officials for stifling free speech and blocking research"
@Meditations2024
@Meditations2024 Ай бұрын
2:17, There's your answer. They were amongst the first colonizers and so aren't indigenous. They also took that land from others before them, so they don't really have a moral leg to stand on in that regard.
@christopherlarsen355
@christopherlarsen355 Ай бұрын
And again at 3:35 - "They need someone to blame for their current state of affairs."
@riumudamc4686
@riumudamc4686 Ай бұрын
Should we not study indigenous tribes who attacked and stole land from other tribes?
@christopherlarsen355
@christopherlarsen355 Ай бұрын
@@riumudamc4686 - Until we can have honest, open discussions about the human condition and experiences, it won't be possible to understand humanity...let alone begin to improve humanity. Osage tribal warriors did not "fall from the heavens to conquer the land" as told in Native American Indian creation stories along the Ozark Plateau. It's a beautiful story with rich meaning. Yet, the Osage people's history is just as fraught with human weakness and wickedness, as well as ingenuity and compassion as any other people across the globe. When we insist this is not true...doesn't that unwittingly describe the Native American Indian as being less human?
@TaraReade64
@TaraReade64 Ай бұрын
I’ve been saying this for decades. Thats why I refuse to call them indigenous, or native.
@ashleytidd-w9i
@ashleytidd-w9i Ай бұрын
Same toss in Australia.
@chuck-jy7mz
@chuck-jy7mz Ай бұрын
Don't forget to add New Zealand, slavers and cannibals and much shrieking. Guess what we're having for dinner? You !
@bigrobnz
@bigrobnz Ай бұрын
.....and New Zealand......life was just lovely and then the White Man came along..........
@brucepowell7986
@brucepowell7986 Ай бұрын
i would bet that christianity as well as jewdism and islam made no sense to the aboriginals now you are morphing into the kawmunist religion went from dumb to dumber thats the case here
@bambam7272
@bambam7272 Ай бұрын
We definitely need more academics speaking out about anti whitetism. Thank you for this video
@Allthingscrafty-u8n
@Allthingscrafty-u8n 4 күн бұрын
Absolutely hit the nail on the head!
@patrickbertlein4626
@patrickbertlein4626 Ай бұрын
There were many atrocities done to the natives for sure, but the fact is half of them have casino money coming in and they could do just fine if they all helped each other out and got there crap together. When many of them are able to go on flights across the world to party at best, or at the least have a monthly check that covers all there bills and food just fine, my sympathy for them as a whole is a bit strained. It really is insane how much money some of them are getting, more than enough to survive!
@jackdeniston6150
@jackdeniston6150 Ай бұрын
The atrocities were more, and worse, between tribes before white Men came. Everywhere White Men went, the world improved. Especially today.
@edekoka6267
@edekoka6267 Ай бұрын
You are stupid.
@BilbdosSaggin-q6l
@BilbdosSaggin-q6l Ай бұрын
They committed atrocities against us and each other, lost to the nicest conquerors in the world, got free stuff handed to them unlike any other conquered people, and cry like a bitch because they’re angry they’re inferior
@ronwatford7331
@ronwatford7331 Ай бұрын
Could also say it was justified.
@omniamericana2172
@omniamericana2172 Ай бұрын
You ppl are cognitively challenged. Goodness the shyt you tell yourselves 😂
@timhallas4275
@timhallas4275 27 күн бұрын
Native Americans leave the air-conditioned bars, haul their horses in trailers, with gas powered pickup trucks to a designated spot in the desert where they ride around on their horses, protesting the pipeline that the white man is building. Not one of them lives in a teepee. 80% of them are recieving U.S. government assistence.
@Dseanstrickland-tt7bj
@Dseanstrickland-tt7bj 2 күн бұрын
Plus maybe if you people spent less time watching ESPN you'd have an actually marriage and family life beyond being on your 3rd wife and paying alimony to see your kid.
@KevinQuinn-f6m
@KevinQuinn-f6m Ай бұрын
It's a grift all a grift
@marcusaurelius5149
@marcusaurelius5149 Ай бұрын
No, it's not. Words have meanings.
@machtnichtsseimann
@machtnichtsseimann Ай бұрын
@@marcusaurelius5149 - OK, it's Woke-ism, Anti-White Race-ism. Which are lucrative industries. Better?
@KevenTomlinson
@KevenTomlinson Ай бұрын
Words without order in wisdom are just Babyl. The tall mood originated in ancient Babylon, what’s left to say about that ?
@IntroducingMrLucci
@IntroducingMrLucci Ай бұрын
It's social engineering to make people of European descent self hating and submissive.
@oldbird-zm8qt
@oldbird-zm8qt Ай бұрын
Jean-Jacques Rousseau, and Margaret Mead have a LOT to answer for.
@jamescuratalo2609
@jamescuratalo2609 Ай бұрын
Original writings of the first Spaniards to explore the southwest, commonly described cannibalism among the inhabitants.
@iamkalixa
@iamkalixa Ай бұрын
And?
@sliglusamelius8578
@sliglusamelius8578 Ай бұрын
@@iamkalixa And they were savage cannibals.
@MatthewVanston
@MatthewVanston Ай бұрын
​@@iamkalixa And? Are you serious? Imagine becoming food for such people.
@yvettewilson7008
@yvettewilson7008 Ай бұрын
We have to start dealing with the truth in all things. Great healing and the ability to move forward positively becomes possible.
@lrayvick
@lrayvick 25 күн бұрын
What amazes me is the anti-white press coverage regarding the illegal immigrants "who only want a better life" while completely ignoring the hostility of the Indians against our ancestors who only wanted a better life in the Americas e.g. Jamestown and Plymouth.
@Max-ht9hf
@Max-ht9hf 26 күн бұрын
Victimhood has currency in society, in politics and on social media !
@chadwik4000
@chadwik4000 Ай бұрын
Dr. Weiss thank you for doing the interview! I would love to see you on Hardballs with Jim Goad!
@bb1111116
@bb1111116 Ай бұрын
Wikipedia has an article about Dr. Weiss. The controversy involves skeletal remains which belonged to the Muwekma Ohlone tribe. Dr. Weiss sued San Diego State University to continue to have access to those skeletal remains. However, the tribe could not be sued and as a result she did not receive access to the skeletal remains she had been studying.
@machtnichtsseimann
@machtnichtsseimann Ай бұрын
Maybe? I don't trust Wikipedia. Too much stealth editing and improper so-called "fact-checking".
@BradKandyCroftFamily
@BradKandyCroftFamily Ай бұрын
Funny thing about Wikipedia is that the CEO said it's not about truth, just wanting a "consensus in belief". IE, it's not trying to publish the truth, just make everyone think the same thing.
@bb1111116
@bb1111116 Ай бұрын
​@@BradKandyCroftFamily ; your comment is useful because it points out that an encyclopedia is not a primary source and should never be trusted on its own. However, a helpful feature of Wikipedia articles is that they link to their sources. For instance the Wikipedia page about Dr. Weiss has links to articles such as from the Mercury News and her own books/articles which describes the situation that I summarized in my earlier comment. As for your comment about the Wikipedia CEO. The person you are referencing is Larry Sanger who is not the CEO. He was the co-founder of Wikipedia however he left Wikipedia in 2001. Sanger’s recent criticisms of Wikipedia are that the site does not reflect current right wing concerns about recent political events. Recent political topics need time to sort out factual information. With regard to Dr. Weiss, a direct internet search led me to a San Jose State University article which has an overall summary of the controversy which I have described. Also the lawsuit by Dr. Weiss is summarized on the Pacific Legal Foundation website.
@bb1111116
@bb1111116 Ай бұрын
​@@BradKandyCroftFamily ; I replied in detail to your comment but as often happens on KZbin, it was deleted by moderation. I will try a summary. As for your comment about the Wikipedia CEO. The person you are referencing is Larry Sanger who is not the CEO. He was the co-founder of Wikipedia however he left Wikipedia in 2001. Sanger’s recent criticisms of Wikipedia are that the site does not reflect current right wing concerns about recent political events. In my opinion an encyclopedia is not the most appropriate method of recording recent controversial political disputes. As for Wikipedia articles, a helpful feature is that they link to their sources. For instance the Wikipedia page about Dr. Weiss has links to articles and her books/articles which I summarized in my original comment.
@noahboughdy2648
@noahboughdy2648 Ай бұрын
Refreshingly honest take. Kudos!
@1776revwar
@1776revwar Ай бұрын
It is becoming increasingly clear due to genetic maping methods, that the origin of what we call Native Americans traces back genetically to eastern Siberia. These peoples migrated to the Americas by way of the land bridge during the end of the last ice age. So you see we all are migrants from somewhere else.
@machtnichtsseimann
@machtnichtsseimann Ай бұрын
"Native" American seems like an overtly political term, not one of accuracy, nod to genetic mapping research. Nor "Indigenous". "First Nations" reeks of bigotry and internalized shame adopted by Americans of European descent. Why not Tribal Americans? Or just the actual name of one's tribe, that is probably the best term, isn't it?
@MrKoobuh
@MrKoobuh Ай бұрын
@@machtnichtsseimann 'Indigenous' as a term for peoples needs to be thrown in the trash. No human is indigenous to any region outside of Africa, all other uses of the term referencing humans are granting undue privileges to people who occupied land that was subsequently occupied by colonial powers. 'Pre-Colonial Inhabitants' is vastly more appropriate, and manages to be even more divisive if that's what they want to go for.
@riceisnice444
@riceisnice444 Ай бұрын
@@machtnichtsseimann Pre Columbian tribes is what I say or just American Indians because even the US government still has the Bureau of Indian Affairs, so it's technically official.
@JoeyGee1000
@JoeyGee1000 Ай бұрын
If their ancestors have been here for 12,000 years or so, I think they can be considered natives. "Native 'Americans' " however, is a little more debatable.
@riceisnice444
@riceisnice444 Ай бұрын
@ they haven’t been here that long no way.
@jaobidan2358
@jaobidan2358 Ай бұрын
Present day natives romanticize their culture, but I prefer the gritty truth about any culture...Good and bad. They were not a peaceful, unified, people that lived in harmony with each other and the land. That's a Disney tale...The natives were at constant war with each other, had no established govt nor borders; A dark age society that was both incapable of unifying in the face of an occupying force and overcoming it to keep what they claim was theirs. There's much to respect about Indigenous people but they, themselves, can't even accept who they really were.
@machtnichtsseimann
@machtnichtsseimann Ай бұрын
Agree. I'd prefer to know the good, bad, AND ugly about the peoples of the earth. Problem is: Everyone has their biases, tribalism, denialism, victimhood, bigotry, pridefulness, envy, to sift through. So, when outsiders speak truths, no matter who they are, pushed back on by the insiders in question, it can be a seemingly endless historical bickering. Frustrating.
@jaobidan2358
@jaobidan2358 Ай бұрын
@@machtnichtsseimann My ancestors were the Romans. There's no denying the good, bad AND ugly when it comes to them. Yet, they're my people and I love the good and condemn the bad. I accept it all.
@makeamericanativeamericana7436
@makeamericanativeamericana7436 Ай бұрын
@@jaobidan2358Keep our NATIVE ancestors out of your mouth settler. You people continue to show the world you have no spirit and a very disconnected from source
@54356776
@54356776 Ай бұрын
​@@jaobidan2358 You owe us reparations buddy. Love from Blighty.
@alexmartinez-og8gu
@alexmartinez-og8gu Ай бұрын
just natives? ever read what the romans had to say about the now modernized fairy tale nordic tribes? id tell you but id get banned for hate speech. everyone likes to lie to themselves. if you think natives lie about history, wait till you find out jewish people and the gentiles who help them like to say lol
@petebyron1957
@petebyron1957 Ай бұрын
If Indians originally came from Asia, How can they be called Indigenous to North, and South America?
@geraldcalderone5228-x2p
@geraldcalderone5228-x2p Ай бұрын
Right on
@Eric.1I37
@Eric.1I37 29 күн бұрын
They have been here in North America for 8,000 years minimum. I think that counts as indigenous. The Salutrans(not sure I spelled right) from what is today France arrived in North America thousands of years before the tribes from Asia arrived. Judging from DNA of indigenous Americans, the Salustrans were breed out through mixing and the few that were not, were killed off. But that was 8,000 years ago when that was finished off, so the indigenous people have been here for thousands of years. Which more then qualifies them as native.
@P-Seeker-y2f
@P-Seeker-y2f 7 күн бұрын
Simple - they aren't.
@DovidM
@DovidM 2 күн бұрын
Their creation myths say that they sprang from the soil, and didn’t come across the Bering Straits. They prefer this version to reality.
@petebyron1957
@petebyron1957 2 күн бұрын
@@DovidM I would rather go with that story, Than with the DNA evidence.
@christianyellic3394
@christianyellic3394 Ай бұрын
Colonialism just took out the top dog wherever it set foot. Good or bad is irrelevant. But that is what happened. When the hardware arrived there was no shortage of “the enemy of my enemy is my friend”. Cortez could not have succeeded in kidnapping Montezuma without auxiliary enemies.
@Me-eb3wv
@Me-eb3wv Ай бұрын
That’s pretty much the forgotten story schools and the media won’t teach and tell you about. They just keep pushing the “natives used to live in harmony with one another and could communicate with momma nature till the evil Europeans came”
@IntroducingMrLucci
@IntroducingMrLucci Ай бұрын
Tlaxacala were tired of being made Aztec slave class and used as a food source
@davidcarrier9877
@davidcarrier9877 Ай бұрын
Stolen native valor? What do we call it.... Like when a certain candidate claiming to be black is rejected because she self-identified as Indian previously. 😮
@m_d1905
@m_d1905 Ай бұрын
A liar got caught out. That's what I call it. The same as Rachel Doizol (not sure of the spelling). A congresswoman, I won't name as well.
@P-Seeker-y2f
@P-Seeker-y2f 7 күн бұрын
Actually, she IS Indian (as in India); she was simply lying when claiming to be black.
@timhallas4275
@timhallas4275 Ай бұрын
So your ancestors came here 12,000 years ago and found most of the land unoccupied and so they stayed, and built teepees and drew fish from the waters and hunted the buffalo. So my ancestors came here 400 years ago and found most of the land unoccupied and so they stayed and grew crops, built towns and roads and eventually founded a great nation. So your ancestors decided there's not enough room for more than a few thousand people in North America so they declared war on the European immigrants. If they had won,and killed all the white people, how would history portray them now? Nobel people? Proud warriors? Founders of a great nation? Or barbarians who murdered anyone who dared set foot on their land? My ancestors won, and they welcomed everyone to share in the prosperity of their success. This land belongs to anyone willing to cultivate and develop it for the good of all. Artifacts belong to whoever finds them. You find the money my grandpa buried before I do, it's yours... because I have not been looking for it and you have.
@machtnichtsseimann
@machtnichtsseimann Ай бұрын
Generally agree, except the "welcomed everyone to share in the prosperity of their success" needs more nuance. Structural racism was a thing. Not everyone was welcomed to share in the "prosperity". Obviously. "America" has been on a growth trajectory in terms of character and justice. I won't be trite in saying "no nation is perfect", the good of the U.S. ought to be celebrated and a part of truth-telling, and the bad must be nuanced in. Attempting fair analysis with due proportionality of, say, costs vs benefits. If we are about truth-seeking. Seems like many don't want to do that. ( Not into endless bashing or endless pride, in other words. )
@geraldcalderone5228-x2p
@geraldcalderone5228-x2p Ай бұрын
Simply outstanding! Thanks
@SURVIVOR-og6dl
@SURVIVOR-og6dl Ай бұрын
Gotta do Us ,Now, keep the ball rolling in the right direction in terms of growth.🇺🇸
@DMM1840
@DMM1840 27 күн бұрын
Much of the land Europeans settled on were once Indian towns, along with many of the roads they used (later paved over). They also learned from the remaining Indians how to grow many of the crops used by them - corn, squash, potatoes, beans, tobacco, etc. By the time Anglo settlers arrived, most of the Indians were already dead. Many of the remaining Indians didn’t have a problem with Europeans settling on Indian ghost towns. Most conflicts still existing today between the two cultures come from dishonored and fraudulent treaties signed by each other.
@timhallas4275
@timhallas4275 27 күн бұрын
@@DMM1840 So you believe the Native Americans had roads and towns prior to 1620? They didn't even have the wheel until it was introduced to them by the Europeans. In the 17th century, Native Americans were stone age peoples. They hadn't even mastered the use of metals.
@timgt5
@timgt5 Ай бұрын
Correct. The people we call Native Americans were in fact the remnants of a civilization that had collapsed long before the first Europeans showed up. Essentially a dark age society. The plains Indians were basically Mad Max on horseback. As for the land stolen, less than 2% of the land in the 13 colonies was physically occupied. The rest was open space and no just walking across some land in itself does not give you exclusive rights. Ownership has 2 paths 1) You have a government of some sort that can grant a deed to an individual as recognition from the community it represents that a piece of defined property as marked and measured belongs to the holder of said deed. 2) Barring a deeding system exists the second path is permeant and continuous occupation either by an individual, a family or a settlement or village collectively claims land it sits on. If neither exists, then the land is available for whoever can settle and hold it.
@goblincookie5233
@goblincookie5233 Ай бұрын
The density at which the dwellers of a land live has no actual bearing on their rights to the land in which they live. As complicated as such matters are when peoples live in proximity, we can safely say that people living on the other side of an ocean have no right to anything.
@christophernuzzi2780
@christophernuzzi2780 Ай бұрын
@@goblincookie5233 Europeans were stronger and had better technology, so we took it from them. We had a war and they lost. That means WE get to dictate the terms. Let them cry and moan and just ignore them. They'll give up and shut up eventually.
@goblincookie5233
@goblincookie5233 Ай бұрын
@@christophernuzzi2780 There is a shorter way of putting that, Might Makes Right. I'm not sure about the shutting up though.
@MrKoobuh
@MrKoobuh Ай бұрын
@@goblincookie5233 Try not paying your property taxes and you'll learn very quickly that ownership of property is a privilege granted to the weak by the strong. That privilege is always subject to re-evaluation or withdrawal.
@timgt5
@timgt5 Ай бұрын
@@goblincookie5233 IF the land is unoccupied how do you claim ownership. colonization of some sort has occurred everywhere in the world at one time or another. People settle on empty land. I am btw not excusing the treatment of Native Americans there were horrible things that they suffered under Europeans but the idea that Europeans of that age were just going to sit at home and never explore the world and seek out resources is silly. Again, this was a dark age civilization that had collapsed with no defined nation states. So there was no mechanism by which they could claim ownership. Ownership requires defined markings and borders.
@JCGCompositions
@JCGCompositions 28 күн бұрын
"They need somebody to blame for their current state of affairs."
@josephang9927
@josephang9927 Ай бұрын
Similar to how France banned genetic tests to protect the adulterous.
@riceisnice444
@riceisnice444 Ай бұрын
not really the same at all. This is a power struggle in America.
@hellequingentlemanbastard9497
@hellequingentlemanbastard9497 Ай бұрын
Same in South Africa.
@user-tm8jt2py3d
@user-tm8jt2py3d Ай бұрын
In Minnesota there are efforts to claim land rights based on that oral origin story, that they came out of the water near Minneapolis. To answer that final question, they will still blame you, and eventually will act upon that.
@JohanDanielsson8802
@JohanDanielsson8802 Ай бұрын
What, came out of the water?
@geraldcalderone5228-x2p
@geraldcalderone5228-x2p Ай бұрын
Oral origin? That will not pass constitutional muster
@jmc5910
@jmc5910 28 күн бұрын
its lucrative thts why, as long as people just go along with it it will never stop
@elliottbaker201
@elliottbaker201 11 күн бұрын
Like the Vikings who forded them waters too
@comment3711
@comment3711 Ай бұрын
Thank you for your honesty here. So impressed with this frankness, I love it!
@marcusweb5999
@marcusweb5999 Ай бұрын
I'm both Native American and British/Irish , and while one half of my family tree colonized the continent, the other half helped commit genocide against another group of natives in the same time period.
@jimmyalfonda3536
@jimmyalfonda3536 Ай бұрын
So what you mean to say is there was genocide on both sides of your family tree.
@Nachos_with_a_slice_of_lime
@Nachos_with_a_slice_of_lime Ай бұрын
No one cares
@Pam_Page
@Pam_Page Ай бұрын
@@Nachos_with_a_slice_of_lime Then why did you reply? 🤦‍♂
@JonFrumTheFirst
@JonFrumTheFirst 4 күн бұрын
Back in the 1980s, I was reading some pop science anthropology books, including those of Marvin Harris. He described cultural anthropology then as divided into Feminist Anthropology, Marxist Anthropology, Ecofeminist Anthropology, and about five more what we would call deconstructivist subgenres. Universsally, it was Marxist/Leftist. Anthropology itself was destroyed half a century ago.
@lumberpilot
@lumberpilot Ай бұрын
What is the point of winning wars when sometime in the future the people you conquered file law suits to get back what you were fighting over? Why are there wars being waged today if this is the case?
@glittermama
@glittermama Ай бұрын
Almost every person from every land today is descended from an invader. That's the nature of humanity.
@DMM1840
@DMM1840 27 күн бұрын
Because treaties were signed, you can read into them, the US government surely doesn’t.
@TheStobyReport
@TheStobyReport 23 күн бұрын
The only reason the Native Americans were “environmentally conscious” was because they didn’t have the technology to do otherwise.
@donsena2013
@donsena2013 Ай бұрын
The indigenous North-American tribes were living in a stone-age culture, in which they didn’t even have the wheel. They sat on a treasure-trove of natural resources totally oblivious to their existence. Europe, by contrast, had its bronze age from 3300 to 1200 BC 3300, followed by its iron age from 1200 to 550 BC. Centuries prior to the arrival of the first Europeans (apart from the Romans, who preceded Columbus), North-American tribesmen hunted down the indigenous American horse for food, eventually driving it into extinction, never thinking to make it into a beast of burden. They had no concept of the continental land mass they inhabited, but instead, constituted an irregular mosaic of very disparate tribes, speaking totally different and unrelated languages with no cultural uniformity. The combination of borders, language and culture pertinent to nationhood was simply absent. They were anything but peaceful with each other. Excavations carried out in New Mexico in the 1970s uncovered the bones of tribes people whose flesh had been hacked off their bones, indicating that they had been cannibalized. The inhabitants had no jurisdictional claims to well-defined parcels of land that would give definition to their status as a nation in some sense. There was otherwise plenty of land here in North America that was not being physically settled that could have accommodated the Europeans who followed Columbus without any need of going to war with the indigenous occupants.
@rickwindham2888
@rickwindham2888 Ай бұрын
So refreshing to hear
@davidgreenwood6029
@davidgreenwood6029 Ай бұрын
Go to mesa verde and ask about cannibalism. If you're already knowledgeable on the subject, the rangers will talk to you, but if you're not and ask if it happened, a lot will just straight up lie, or at least just answer dishonestly, diminishing the truth. Its bizarre. THe justification is they're too scared of people having racist attitudes towards the people who built mesa verde, but its so anti science, and anti truth.
@machtnichtsseimann
@machtnichtsseimann Ай бұрын
Good point! We must strive for truth and good science. ( Bad science, as much as any field can be corrupted by humans lying through their teeth, is quite toxic. )
@riceisnice444
@riceisnice444 Ай бұрын
Well Europeans invented science so, not I'm surprised that other peoples don't respect it properly.
@brileyvandyke5792
@brileyvandyke5792 Ай бұрын
Thank you to the Anthropologist who speaks objectively and resists spinning a fanciful, idealistic image of native peoples.
@gumse666
@gumse666 Ай бұрын
We have the same situation with the Sami in Scandinavia.
@rdred8693
@rdred8693 Ай бұрын
Oh yes, I imagine.
@alexmartinez-og8gu
@alexmartinez-og8gu Ай бұрын
lol yes, people totally dont lie about how nobel or great the nordic tribes were. the romans must have spent 1000 years fighting them because they were so awesome to live next to.
@hyrkanian66
@hyrkanian66 5 күн бұрын
I am 1/4th native American and I approve this message.
@miker72794
@miker72794 16 күн бұрын
I vaguely reminder a video years ago of a person, a scientist I think, that discovered a human skull that I believe he claimed to predate the American Indians. I think it was reasoned scientifically somehow to be that old and was in the shape of that from European descendants. I think the scientist sent it off to others for further study and never heard about it or saw it again.
@ReviloPendleton
@ReviloPendleton 4 күн бұрын
I think that was called Kennewick Man
@robertotto5811
@robertotto5811 3 күн бұрын
Their "current state of affairs" was foisted upon them by government.
@fredpagniello3267
@fredpagniello3267 Ай бұрын
This brings to mind a former friend. He managed in the late 1979s to squander an entire inheritance in the span of two years and later blames others for his difficult life. He used his parents' death as an excuse for not attending college (the average cost for a 4 year degree in 1977 was $8400; his father set aside double that for college, I presume for him and his two brothers). Instead of getting a degree or job training in a skilled profession, he had to eke out a living pushing a nut cart on the streets and later street peddling. Why a former friend? He stuck me with a very large credit card bill and came very close to dragging me down with him.
@tommylatham9868
@tommylatham9868 6 күн бұрын
No one is erasing Comanche for what they did to Navajo.
@RonnieMyers777
@RonnieMyers777 Ай бұрын
Humanity has never been peaceful, not even now
@ozarkrefugee
@ozarkrefugee 13 күн бұрын
probably never will be....
@joemanco-no4jy
@joemanco-no4jy Ай бұрын
Dear Ms. Anthropologist: you are under no obligation to indulge their superstitions or idealized history.
@diffened
@diffened Ай бұрын
Just your superstitions about Jesus and God. You people crack me up.
@amialal4510
@amialal4510 Ай бұрын
@@diffened You crack us up to. These ppl have created ZERO. Unlike Jesus and its impact. It's s complex and compelling creation bot intellectually and morally. IQ is a big factor in everything.
@mrq6270
@mrq6270 Ай бұрын
@@diffenedspot on
@morganreigns1984
@morganreigns1984 Ай бұрын
​@@diffeneddid you say this cus I'm white 🐻‍❄️ lol
@marcusaurelius5149
@marcusaurelius5149 Ай бұрын
@@diffened Just your superstitions about equality when you people never even invented the wheel.
@viper2148
@viper2148 Ай бұрын
Ultimately, Western "colonialism" yielded lower infant mortality, higher life expectancy and a higher general prosperity for all its "victims". That's not to whitewash all of the evils done in the name of post Columbian European Expansionism (and there were many), rather to put it in context now that we are clearly on the other side.
@machtnichtsseimann
@machtnichtsseimann Ай бұрын
But isn't the going narrative that Europeans came here to pursue genocide against tribal Indians of the Americas? "Smallpox"?
@noondayaxeman4668
@noondayaxeman4668 Ай бұрын
Western civilisation needs to be separated into protestant and catholic Europe. The countries settled by protestant nations generally developed well and prospered, with liberty and rights (USA, Australia, Canada). The countries settled by catholic countries (South America, Mexico etc) did not develop the same way, they were more corrupt, had less individual liberty and less opportunities to prosper. These conditions for the protestant settled countries (USA, Australia, Canada) have faded and are almost done, as they have turned away from the values that made them once prosperous.
@viper2148
@viper2148 Ай бұрын
@@noondayaxeman4668 modern Italy is far more civilized and freer than modern Britain. Canada, New Zealand and Australia are socialist shizholes.
@ConsueloWubba
@ConsueloWubba Ай бұрын
hippity hoppity your children are my property - Comanche saying
@vandertuber
@vandertuber Ай бұрын
Diana Fleischmann is a great interviewer. Thanks for revealing the truth.
@roqclimber
@roqclimber Ай бұрын
That's why Anthropology students are taught, "Nothing Before Clovis!" Meaning, when you find Clovis period artifacts, Do Not dig any further down.
@simonjj7397
@simonjj7397 23 күн бұрын
Excellent clip, truth is refreshing.
@Cheche-s7w
@Cheche-s7w Ай бұрын
The lifting up of Stone Age culture is ridiculous: you can be proud of your history but please don’t equate it with modern day culture,
@machtnichtsseimann
@machtnichtsseimann Ай бұрын
Honestly, I don't get how anyone on earth says, "I'm proud of my people", when they don't exactly know all of their family's or people's histories for certain. Especially when it is human nature to obfuscate the sins and evils of their bloodlines. We are all hypocrites, and what's worse, proud before the Creator in doing so. Fortunately, God is merciful, loving, forgiving while extending Grace while we were yet in our sin. Better that everyone, every human being, manage their hypocrisies.
@ralphnewcomejr
@ralphnewcomejr 7 күн бұрын
Nobody wants BONE TOMAHAWK to be known as relatively accurate...
@MarlinWilliams-ts5ul
@MarlinWilliams-ts5ul Ай бұрын
One wonders why the Indian, from Alaska to Patagonia, never figured the concept of the wheel. The first wheel in the Americas appeared in what is now Venezuela, on a cart brought by the Spanish.
@DMM1840
@DMM1840 27 күн бұрын
No, they did create the wheel, but only for toys since they had no use for it. Europeans didn’t figure the concept of the wheel either, it was brought over to them by Mesopotamians.
@Christine-eb1sc
@Christine-eb1sc 26 күн бұрын
There was also no large domesticated animal to use with a wheel. Eskimos used dogs and sleds.less reason to futher advance wheels, yes used in toys.
@sunayakong8537
@sunayakong8537 2 күн бұрын
Wow I had idea there were people willing to speak truth to this subject. Thanks for posting.
@retheisen
@retheisen 17 күн бұрын
Reminds me of the Taliban destroying Buddahs.
@bluartz8158
@bluartz8158 12 күн бұрын
subscribed. Thank you for the content.
@InlikeMikeQuinn
@InlikeMikeQuinn Ай бұрын
Thank you for this awesome video!
@marlow769
@marlow769 11 күн бұрын
“Mindless and Petty”. You’ve just described the entire “Woke Movement”.
@frederickburke9944
@frederickburke9944 Ай бұрын
Oh no! Hierarchical systems!
@donsimons9810
@donsimons9810 Ай бұрын
these types have destroyed academics. It’s dead
@waterst9
@waterst9 2 күн бұрын
I majored in Anthropology in the early 80's and even then I noticed the academic propensity to historical revisionism and leftist narratives and I declined to pursue an advanced degree in the discipline and decided to pursue engineering.
@tomdoyle5720
@tomdoyle5720 Ай бұрын
OUCH! THE TRUTH HURTS SOMETIMES
@clemdane
@clemdane Ай бұрын
Sad and depressing. There are no "indigenous" people. We all came from elsewhere.
@kirkgoshert7876
@kirkgoshert7876 Ай бұрын
I disagree. We are all indigenous - to Earth. May the best men win.
@JohanDanielsson8802
@JohanDanielsson8802 Ай бұрын
@@kirkgoshert7876 I can see that you do not believe in panspermia theory.
@ferociousgustafson4040
@ferociousgustafson4040 Ай бұрын
Isn’t it funny how we were all taught the land bridge theory in elementary school, but everyone just forgot?
@kirkgoshert7876
@kirkgoshert7876 Ай бұрын
@@JohanDanielsson8802 your vision lies to you. because you are unable to see a consistent connection between my belief and panspermia theory you assume knowledge of my beliefs. if you widen your perspective the truth comes into sight.
@crediblehulk420
@crediblehulk420 Ай бұрын
@@kirkgoshert7876 So, what you're telling me is that women are NOT from Venus, and Men are NOT from Mars??
@deanfirnatine7814
@deanfirnatine7814 Ай бұрын
Kennewick man and some other odd remains found in the NW should have never been reburied, who knows what they could have revealed, were their oddities because they were related to the Ainu's ancestors or because they were pure or close to pure North Eurasian ancestry? We will never know for certain now.
@redr1150r
@redr1150r 4 күн бұрын
We have American Indian ancestry on my mothers side from Oklahoma, Texas and the Eastern US from over 150- 200 years ago. They had their wars, assassinations, genocidal wars of revenge, slavery, some cannibalism, some human sacrifice, and a few other thing we would consider unpalatable today. My European ancestors were no better at times throughout their history. The "Battle Mounds" that we find today in the central US are full of the jumbled remains of victims of long forgotten wars of extermination fought entirely by their own hands. Men, women, children, old and young, all showing signs of brutal endings. I'm proud of my ancestry, both sides, both European and ancient American. Because without any one of them, I wouldn't be here. 🙂
@cbryanto
@cbryanto Ай бұрын
It boils down to ppl are ppl. Lets all go on from here.
@goldrivers598
@goldrivers598 4 күн бұрын
Oh wow, I will buy this book. Thank you for saying it like it is.
@brindlebriar
@brindlebriar Ай бұрын
I have to drink the white man's whisky because uncle Redfoot's bones are not buried in the right place.
@andrjsh
@andrjsh 5 күн бұрын
As a bad Catholic and an armchair historian, I come across again and again anecdotes from primary sources about incidents, practices, &c. from Church history that are not particularly edifying or that "go against the narrative". At the same time, there has been a steady stream of grace, virtue, and civilization that continues to this day. This tells me that nothing is perfect, but that at the core there is the good, the authentic, and the true. We must acknowledge the one and cling to the other.
@xoltocrojas2028
@xoltocrojas2028 Ай бұрын
Very true, natives were doing human sacrafices, wichcraft, and kidnapping, rading, and waging war against each other, many ancient tribes were annihilated by others tribes. But they were human and not every tribe was like this.
@russelsellick316
@russelsellick316 Ай бұрын
The africans generally speaking want all remains returned. I do agree with some of it. Taking some chiefs head back to Britain etc was a bit off...
@--Traveler--
@--Traveler-- Ай бұрын
The Africans can have the remains back if all Africans agree to leave the uk and head back home haha
@RobertKempf122
@RobertKempf122 Ай бұрын
This woman is spot on.
@TylerD288
@TylerD288 Ай бұрын
No, she really isn't. She's completely wrong, and probably evil to boot.
@michaelpeters2506
@michaelpeters2506 Ай бұрын
​@TylerD288 maybe try calling her a racist you will get more likes
@--Traveler--
@--Traveler-- Ай бұрын
@tyler where is your mind? It’s completely missing
@RonnieRowe-il7eq
@RonnieRowe-il7eq Ай бұрын
AWESOME SHOW 👌 ❤
@fightingfortruth9806
@fightingfortruth9806 Ай бұрын
They had "hierarchical systems" just like those awful Christians! Whatever will we do if we realize men led their families in the past. Shame! Shame!
@The_Naughty_Kitten
@The_Naughty_Kitten Ай бұрын
I'm a Proud follower of CHRIST - and I am Not awful!
@deankirby7237
@deankirby7237 11 күн бұрын
The nine thousand year old skeleton of an ancient indian known as the kendrick man was given back to the tribe who now inhabited the land he was found on. Even though it was proven they were never related. It was just sticking two fingers up at the white man.
Marshall Sahlins on how anthropology intersects politics
21:26
Academic Influence
Рет қаралды 4,1 М.
How Strong Is Tape?
00:24
Stokes Twins
Рет қаралды 96 МЛН
Каха и дочка
00:28
К-Media
Рет қаралды 3,4 МЛН
THE ONLY KEY--TO UNLOCKING TRUTH ABOUT GOD (ESH-14)
44:07
John Barnett Online Teaching
Рет қаралды 4,2 М.
SOCIOLOGIE : UNE ARME POUR COMPRENDRE LE MONDE (ET NE PAS FINIR DE DROITE)
19:48
BLAST, Le souffle de l'info
Рет қаралды 216 М.
Why the Left's Vision of Equity Is Flawed | Douglas Murray
10:36
National Review
Рет қаралды 1,1 МЛН
"GENS DU VOYAGE" : UN GÉNOCIDE OCCULTÉ, DES PERSÉCUTIONS QUI PERDURENT
16:14
BLAST, Le souffle de l'info
Рет қаралды 44 М.
Trump’s Attack on D.E.I. Will Cost Us All
11:13
New York Times Podcasts
Рет қаралды 7 М.
Learn Russian in 30 Minutes - ALL the Basics You Need
27:50
Learn Russian with RussianPod101.com
Рет қаралды 2,4 МЛН
Does anti-whiteness justify white identity politics? | Steve Sailer
7:03
Two reflections on anglicisms
15:01
Yasmina Pani
Рет қаралды 16 М.