What’s Buried Underneath the Treasury of Petra?

#petra #treasury #megalithic #buriedtreasure
Please subscribe and turn on notifications [🔔] so you don't miss any videos.
In this video I continue to discuss the ancient city of Petra and what I uncovered on the subterranean level under the Treasury. The Treasury is the most iconic rock hewn structure in Petra. It is located at the final twist of the winding narrow gorge of the Siq. The paths walked by tourists today are called wadis, which are dried up floodways and river beds. It’s obvious that the Siq, the plaza in front of the Treasury and the outer Siq are covered with flood runoffs. This sediment layer must be substantial because it partially as well as completely covers up the doorways of some caves at the outer Siq. The original ground and path could be several meters lower. What might be buried underneath remains a mystery.
When you see the Treasury, it appears on ground level. You can walk right up to it. But this is not always the case; since the Treasury and its plaza looked very different over 2,000 years ago. Originally the Treasury was much higher up and looked even more formidable. There actually is an entire hidden level submerged below centuries of sediments. What could be hiding there for all these years? Let’s take a look.
Patreon: / curiousbeing
Instagram: curiousbeingtina
Twitter: CuriousBeing15
This is my KZbin Channel “Curious Being.” I have many diverse and interesting topics to share, such as Lost Ancient Human Civilizations, Megalithic Sites, and other related fascinating studies. History vs. Mystery revealed! Thank you for watching.

[@Za7a7aZ]

This is the first time I learned about the subterranian level under the treasury...thank you Tina for bringing this to light

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

You are so welcome! Thank you for the continuous support :-)

[@docker4671]

this is beyond interesting in ways that history channels or documentaries never are. it's thorough and entirely on-point the entire time and you should be given grants to have an official platform to discuss these things professionally in a public spotlight. thank god for youtube, though, and thank YOU for your contribution to mankind!! in this short blip of consciousness, that may end for us at any moment for all we know, it is you who are one of the very few people who shed light and rational thought on these things that people, ignorantly, never think about or care about, or choose to believe the scholarly and far less interesting version of history, than actually look into the TRUTH of it all. thank you, tina, for trying to get to the TRUTH!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Wow, thank you! I truly appreciate your kind words and support. This means a lot to me ♥ Thank you!

[@23a09a]

well said... totally agree

[@megetmorsomt]

Yes, thank you Tina: you're doing marvellous work; many of us suspect that there must be more to all these things somewhere beneath the surface, and you seem to have a nag for digging - please, never stop!

[@sharonjb.y111]

Thank you for posting this! I have never heard about the graves under the main building. Always something new to learn!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for watching my videos :-)

[@sbkarajan]

Never thought there was underground structures. I'd love to see more interior look at these chambers currently below ground. Thanks and great job!!!!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you very much for the support! I, too, want to see more interior photos but there are not many online. Hopefully this new excavation can provide more interior shots!

[@PatrickAsti]

There are many interesting things about Petra. First it was certainly the original Mecca! The location where Nefertiti came to become Queen after the escape of Akhenaten. Petra is on the old equator as is Giza. The flooding goes back to the flood of Ziusudra. The same tsunami wave that damaged the pyramids damaged Petra. The sediment layer was created suddenly.

[@polygonalmasonary]

Academia, 'If its below current ground level it must be a tomb' 😅😂🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@allenwilbur2369]

Exactly. It's either a tomb, temple or a sarcophagus. 😆

[@evalesko4613]

Cool comment 👍👍👍

[@zodammit]

A tomb used for "ritualistic purposes".

[@paulbussolotta20]

Fascinating! I can't wait to see what's down there. Thanks Tina

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Hope you like it!

[@ralewijnse]

Great analysis, you have put a lot of time in this. I was at Petra 3 yes ago and now want to go back to see it with different eyes.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it, Roderik! It must be am amazing experience visiting Petra. I hope I can go sometime soon.

[@khamen723]

Desert wanderers certainly didn’t carve the wonders that are Petra. You didn’t really even get into the theater. Simply amazing megalithic construction

[@InimitableMrG]

Thank you for sharing your work. Like you, I firmly believe we are living in just the latest cycle of human existence. With our 'origin' being pushed back hundreds of thousands of years, a salient question is - if we can achieve this level of civilization in only 12,000 years (assuming the lower dryad event was the beginning of this cycle of human existence) then what were we doing for the previous 290,000 years or so (at least, mainstream archaeology puts us at 300,000 years ... I think we might be much older)??

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Well said. I agree with you. I can't imagine what the ancient people could have accomplished for hundreds of thousands years.

[@PatriceBoivin]

Think about it... 300,000 years and they appear to have been wiped out anyway. Unless they're the UAP people... ;-P

[@boomtao]

And that is assuming that humans have always been the apex. Earth is 4.6 BIL years old, simple life forms began 3.7 BIL years ago. There could have been another advanced species (not necessarily humanoid-like) millions (or even billions) of years ago. This is called the Silurian Hypothesis. It is very interesting and imho very plausible.

[@InimitableMrG]

@@boomtao There is even some circumstantial evidence that previous civilizations existed - human or non-human - based on some irregular peaks in Earth's surface temperature which only lasted a few thousand years; this would be similar to how it is claimed we're affecting the climate.

[@Johnrack]

A very detailed and descriptive presentation Tina. Well done. I also liked the 3D CAD model you made of the lower Treasury caves, which was very interesting. I’ve learned many interesting things about Petra from your videos. It’s obvious that flooding was a major problem for the original builders of the site, and they came up with an engineering solution that worked. But as you mentioned without maintenance the water system would fill up with sediment, and it did. Similarly the ancient Egyptian archaeological sites suffer from being buried by sand blown by desert winds and the odd earthquake. The excavation of sites like Petra and many other megalithic sites around the world is a huge task. One other point. When tourists visit ancient sites in Egypt, what they don’t realize is that most of the sites have been reconstructed in the modern era, like Stonehenge was. Check out the old pictures of the site being rebuilt online. Archaeologists are really just making their best guesses as how to reconstruct them. For example I saw a picture taken in the late 1800’s of the Temple of Horus on the Nile, south of Luxor, prior to its reconstruction. The site was a wreck, with its columns toppled over and the enclosure filled full of sand. Yet as I stood in it one would think that the temple was always in that functional condition, when for nearly two thousand years the site was a shambles and put back together less than a century ago. My point is that just because modern archaeologists fix up an ancient site for tourists, who knows what the structure really looked like in ancient times.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Great insights and information - thank you for sharing with me, John. It's an interesting point you have brought up. What did the structures looked like in ancient times? How much is still buried and how much has been changed...?

[@Johnrack]

@@CuriousBeingbyTina Just like the Sphinx was restored both in ancient and modern times, many other ancient sites around the world have been through similar cycles or restoration.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

@@Johnrack Yes that's very true.

[@jameswalker7899]

An impressively reasoned and persuasive argument, with appropriate use of supporting evidence. Warmest compliments. :)

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you kindly! Hope you will enjoy my other videos too :-)

[@jhnndrs8832]

Your presentations are one of a kind! Love your work! Keep up the good work!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you like them! Thank you for your support :-)

[@michaelabraham9177]

As usual your logic is flawless. in my humble opinion. Your train of thought sticks to its rails and arrives at its destination with one thought following another in beautiful fashion. Someone somewhere is gonna have to make "I watch Tina" t-shirts. I've learned a lot from your videos. Thank You

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

So glad that you find my videos helpful! It means a lot to me. Thank you Michael. Have a great weekend :-)

[@michaelabraham9177]

@@CuriousBeingbyTina You also

[@benbiagioni9906]

Tina gets the award for best investigative historian/archaeologist. Brains, hard work and common sense in spades.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Oh thank you! I appreciate your compliment :-)

[@boomtao]

Apart from the idea that there may be more levels underneath the sediment and the fact that the entrances would have been above flood levels, we should also take into consideration that the construction of the water systems may have been extremely well put together and could function for possibly centuries without maintenance before clogging up and malfunctioning. There may also have been long lasting dry spells. So, the structures may be even much older.

[@ThunderboltWisdom]

Great video on a fascinating historical site. You always come up with interesting insights and connections too. Always loved Petra, and now I love it a little bit more. 🤓👍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it :-) Thank you for the support.

[@51panhead91]

Great video, very informative. It is interesting that so many ancient civilizations were wiped out so long ago.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you. Yes there have been many ancient civilizations in the past. Btw I made a series of videos on lost civilizations and megalithic sites. Hope you will enjoy them as well 🙂

[@The_Dudester]

When I saw the drawing of the treasury, with the four lower entrances and on the "second floor" basically a large gallery with the wide and tall open entrance, it made the wheels turn in my mind. Allow me to explain: In the book, The Guns of Navarone, the Germans carved out some giant rocks in the Aegean Sea and had gigantic cannons inside to basically make the area invasion proof. The guns couldn't be bombed from above and to try and get a shot at those cannons from the sea is placing your ship at great risk. With that said, the ancients built into solid rock to hide something, or hide from something. The gallery on the second floor likely contained one or more F-35 or Harrier type VTOL type craft. Considering the megalithic structures around the planet, we can only imagine the length and breadth of the civilization of the ancients.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Interesting thought and information! Thank you for sharing with me. I haven't thought about that. Now I have something else to ponder. Thank you my friend :-)

[@humbuccaneer84]

City of petra was an important place in the old silk road trading era. Most of these might have been faults to keep merchandise save. After death it could become the tomb.

[@choosecarefully408]

Well, at least that theory is *different.* Still, without evidence of anything that could be used offensively _or_ defensively here, I'm going to do that thing that is rare for humans, reserve judgment until we know more. There are _WAY_ too may unknowns here. Why are _all_ the carvings a depth of little practical use for living in? One doesn't even make one's homes for a large populace that opulent. My theory is that this was a huge market meeting place for the area, but as yet I have nothing but what _isn't_ there to support it: you couldn't _live_ here, even with water running through it. Unless there are hidden refrigerators, food storage is utterly lacking. However, like the Indus Valley & ancient Mesopotamia, this area likely had hanging gardens once upon a time as well. I still think though that this was an enormous market, not military, for defense or even living quarters.

[@randellhillspeaks753]

I do not know why you don't have many more subscribers. You're very lovely woman and quite informative. I hope your channel grows exponentially.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you Randell :-) I hope so too!

[@SeventhSamurai72]

Thank you Tina for the thought-provoking information. 👍

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

You are so welcome! Thank you for watching :-)

[@MizJanice]

I'm fascinated by these ancient sites. I hadn't heard much about Petra , so thank you! We need to investigate all of these sites so we can understand the big picture more fully.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

You are so welcome :-) made a series of videos on megalithic sites; hope you will enjoy them as well.

[@McClarinJ]

I continue to be impressed with your thoroughness and wide-reaching search for answers, Tina. I don't count myself as a believer but a strong "suspecter" that unknown ancients built much of the fine stonework we see today and the evidence that you have brought forth is the strongest in support of that possibility I have seen.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad to hear that, Jim. Thank you for being open-minded and supportive. I really appreciate both :-)

[@sgvincent100]

This is the most unique presentation about an aspect of Petra that I’ve seen for a long time! Thank you for adding to our knowledge of this astounding site! (I just subscribed.) ✌🏼

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it! Hope you will like my other videos which came from my own independent research :-)

[@robiduff]

Your research is top quality as usual. Keep up the good work :)

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you, will do :-)

[@mikeC8756]

Another fascinating analysis Tina. I wonder exactly how old Petra is? And who constructed it? And how? Hopefully time will tell! I look forward to your updates down the track.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you Michael! These are the questions I have been thinking too. Hopefully the new excavation can shine some light. 🙂

[@maryblushes7189]

Nabateans. Here is a short video on it. kzbin.info/www/bejne/mKjcmXdpgayBY5Y

[@keithnolan2386]

Petra is a petrified city hence the name, it wasnt originally built like that

[@mikeC8756]

@@keithnolan2386 thanks Kieth. I think the name probably came from the Ancient Greek meaning Rock. Petrification is the transformation of organic matter into rock from the presence of water and minerals over time. My definition probably isn’t very good but it’s something like that.

[@keithnolan2386]

@@mikeC8756 I seen it in a good vid awhile back I'll try find the link

[@ocker2000]

Thanks Tina, you blew my mind again! Good to see your channel is getting tracktion with a growing audience!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad that you enjoyed it :-) Thank you very much for the support!

[@Henrikbuitenhuis]

Amazing video and info. Thanks so much. I wish you All the best.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you very much for the support! I really appreciate it :-)

[@Henrikbuitenhuis]

@@CuriousBeingbyTina you are so so welcome.

[@danielcruz8347]

Well done presentation, as usual I've learned more about fascinating subjects such as this presentation about Petra in more intricate detail than other lesser channels!! Ms.Tina thank you very much.!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you Daniel :-) I appreciate your support!

[@yvettekosta7994]

Fascinating as always! I've seen documentaries of GPR and laidar studies that attempted to map out the water channels and cisterns of the area, the Roman ruins and pools, the more ancient works like what were considered tombs with the treasury among them, but this is the first time I've heard mention of structures beneath what was apparently visible. The documentaries study how the structures were apparently built and don't bother to look deeper into the structural past. So much knowledge is prevented by governments wanting to preserve what they have and know and for the sake of tourism, but really fearing the truth and a more exciting evidence of our past. I've always wondered about the discoveries of so many older layers under cities like London or Paris, and those are only a few hundred years old. It's never really explained how that happens that street levels keep rising while dwellings remain at their lower levels. Hope I live to see the results of new studies, it's always such a tease with no real conclusion cause it all takes decades.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Well said, Yvette. Thank you for sharing your insight. There must be much older layers under cities like London, Rome or Paris. Many renowned cities are built upon ancient sites and such sites could be established on even earlier towns. I read a paper stated that in some areas core drills need to be at least 10 m deep to potentially reach to sediment layers from 10,000 years ago. Sediments have buried a lot of evidence...

[@aloneandscared1]

this channel is pure gold

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you! ☺ I appreciate it!

[@evalesko4613]

Thank you so much Tina 🙏😍great as always ❗i haven't known about these facts yet👍👍👍👍happy weekend sweetheart ❤

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you Eva! Have a great weekend! ❤

[@freddiemontes244]

I gave u 2 thumbs up and subscribed You have covered more than anyone has ever covered on the lost city of Petra!!! That includes tv docs, books, and any youtube video I have ever seen! Thank you for bringing this wonderful piece of art to us! Much Love and I hope 2 see more of ur videos!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you Freddie! Welcome aboard :-) Hope you will check out my other videos too!

[@darrenwoolley8736]

Always awesome, nothing left out, I really enjoy your videos Tina.. thanks as always. 🙏😃🙏

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

You are so welcome. Thank you for the continuous support, Darren! :-)

[@Morpholaf]

Great video =) One thing that puzzles me though is the entrance path through the narrow gorge. To day the ground of the gorge is at same level as the area in front of the Treasury. If the front of the Treasury is burried under at least 8 meter of sediment, then the entrance path would have the same build up of sediment. The waterduct carved in to the side of the entrance path would then originally be 8 meter higher up on the cliff wall from the ground. Food for thought =)

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you! Yes I agree that the Siq has thick sediments too. The water channels within reach now could be much higher originally, similar to the high-up cliffside channels which are seen in different areas of Petra.

[@gbtriumph3216]

WONDERFUL, well thought out information and theories. VERY nice, as usual Tina! Thank you!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you for watching :-)

[@terrybrown7601]

All your videos are great and present different ideas then most. Very intuitive.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you like them! Thank you for the support :-)

[@AnOldSod]

Very good, strong, creative and logical thinking. Keep it up I have subscribed and look forward very much to your subsequent videos.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Welcome aboard! Thank you for your support :-) Hope you will enjoy my other videos too!

[@jeffjeff4477]

Good morning!! Another wonderful segment. Lost ancient technologies are certain to me, the evidence is right in front of us. You do a great job of making light of this. I think you are awesome and Thanks for your channel Tina Happy Summer!! From Sunny FL. 🙂

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you very much Jeff! I appreciate your support. Happy Summer!

[@cathyd74]

Good information in this video, especially about the excavation of lower levels.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it :-)

[@whyiscumred7701]

incredible. thank you and looking forward to your next update with this wonderful site.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad that you enjoyed it. I plan to make a new video when the 2020 excavation report can be found online :-)

[@kgbval6785]

Great job! Nicely refreshing the Petra subject.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you liked it! Thank you for watching :-)

[@rbu13]

Tino, your comments are the most concise I've heard on this platform so far. There are many authors. who point to mysterious constructions but your way of erudite explanation of the issue (always in context, clearly and concisely) is unique, including answers to selected comments. I have a similar view on many things, but I do not have time to go into a detailed search for follow-up studies in waste paper. I am of the opinion that people's thinking has not changed over the millennia, and if we are descendants of previous civilizations, we have a chance to rise to the top of civilization again. I wish you a clear mind in solving other mysteries.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you very much for the support and the kind words! I really appreciate that. Glad to have you on this truth searching journey :-)

[@johnclarke6334]

Tina, I like your channel and your research. In my opinion your one of the best researchers in ancient history. Petra is one of my favorite sites on the Planet. This site screams Romans and the Gods. All roads lead to Rome. The lay lines, location, columns, pyramid symbolism, the stonework, the name Petra is connected to Rome, Pope Peter, Pietrus Romanus Prince of Persia, Atlantis, and the Titans.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you, John. I really appreciate your support and the information you shared with me.

[@Johan-ez5wo]

it has nothing todo with rome

[@shanianacnac3764]

Great show Tina....loved it❤😊❤

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thanks so much! I appreciate your support ❤

[@mr.k5865]

Tina, why are you so awesome? After chocolate lava cake and baby pandas, your KZbin channel just might be #3 on my list of BEST THINGS EVER. You're the kind of person who is so calm and luminous, that if you were a scented candle you'd be called "Morning Summer Rainbow" and it would smell like an angel's hug. Your immensely comforting presence is basically like sweatpants for my soul. And just when I thought I was the only person who appreciated giant decorative pencils (regularly seen in your earlier videos), BOOM, you gave me hope that I wasn't alone ;) I hope you don't feel I'm exaggerating anything here. I truly admire how methodically analytical you are, and above all how you have the courage to reach your own logic-based conclusions no matter how far it departs from the status quo. By the way, I feel very qualified to speak here since I'm experienced in a variety of historical field studies. And by that I mean I'm really good at collecting seashells on a beach. Keep up the amazing work. Sending lots of love and gratitude! PS, I recently watched your Chinese Pyramids video but what do you make of the Shaohao granite pyramid in China? It seems quite different from the others, especially since all-granite structures are practically unheard of in China's distant past.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Wow, thank you for your wonderful and funny comment! I'm flattered 😀I really appreciate your kind words and encouragement! It means a lot to me ❤ As for the Shaohao pyramids, its construction started in the Northern Song dynasty (960-1125 AD) and has been renovated multiple times later on. The pyramid is 28.5 m/ 93.5' wide and 8.37 m/ 27.5' tall, made of stone blocks and mortar. There is no source on the stone type. Ａ Chinese said in his blog that this pyramid was built with granite but the web page no longer exists. I think he was making an assumption which can't be used as a credible source. I haven't seen good close-up photos of the stone so I can't tell what kind of stone it might be. You are right, the shape of this pyramid is different from the earlier and bigger mounds from the Han dynasty. There are quite some granite caves in China which I think could be the work from a lost civilizations), such as the Guishan tomb (kzbin.info/www/bejne/i6bXiaxmfZqNj7s) and Guyaju cave cluster (kzbin.info/www/bejne/p6jdmJR4pb2UaJo). Again, thank you for the cool comment. Enjoy your Sunday!

[@mr.k5865]

@@CuriousBeingbyTina Thank you for your prompt and detailed response! Your video on Guishan absolutely blew my mind. You are just the coolest (insert thunderous high-fives). I also rewatched your video on Beidongshan, another absolutely astonishing site that I found through you. Incidentally, Beidongshan contains several additional similarities to Egypt that can be added to the discussion such as the distinct pair of large drill holes for the door hinges and the very, very subtle relief carving of squares (which I've also found in Peru, Turkey and in remote Aswan hillside quarries). Also, the roof pitch (via my photo analysis) in the Osirion chamber is 31° degrees while the roof pitch in Beidongshan is 31° to 31.5° depending on the photo/angle it was taken. Obviously proper in-person measurements need to be taken but this is quite the coincidence. Interestingly, the approximately 31-degree roof pitch is one of the more common types of residential roof pitch used today for precipitation management- it's called a 7/12 or 7:12 roof and has an angle of usually 30.26° degrees. It's clearly not a new idea! It possibly is also another clue that the Egyptians dealt with rain in remote antiquity.

[@seanneal552]

Great production. Love your presentation.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you! Hope you can share my channel with people who might be interested :-)

[@MrMichaelAndrews]

You have an amazing channel here. I love it.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you! I appreciate your support :-)

[@nicoleorton5299]

What?! Wow, this was never brought to my attention before. Thank you! I want to know!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Hope you will enjoy it! Welcome :-)

[@icescrew1]

As always thank you. I've learned more about Petra from you than I have in the many years previously. Everything else was the same things over and over. Hopefully, someday, someone will apply you archeological detective style to our Southwest region here in the US. There is so much here that is unspoken and locked away.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Wow, thank you! I really appreciate your support. I read a little bit on the circular stone structures in the Southwest region. They are very interesting. I might do some digging when I complete on-going projects :-)

[@icescrew1]

@@CuriousBeingbyTina I live right in the middle of the best archeological area of the SW. I've had several Archeologists friends that have clued me into information that the public doesn't see. Would be happy to assist. Respect. MW.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

@@icescrew1 Thank you! That sounds intriguing. If I plan to visit the Southwest, I might contact you 🙂

[@davidperkins2103]

I always look forward for your videos to come out. They are always so interesting. Thank you.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Happy to hear that! Thank you David :-)

[@centuriontwofivezeroone2794]

Very interesting and we'll put. An excellent argument for revision of Petra's history.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad that you enjoyed it. Hope you will like my other videos too :-)

[@n-bynorthwest1347]

I enjoyed this video very much! The information was presented so well!!!!!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it! Hope you can check out my other videos too :-)

[@kananaskiscountry8191]

thank u Tina for the time u spent explaining more of Petra

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad it was helpful! Thank you for watching :-)

[@titanium4k]

You get a big "That A Girl"!!! Great work !! And your beautiful ✨

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you! 😊

[@alanheadrick7997]

I just can not believe that there are likely lower levels and no one has bothered to uncover them. Like you say ground penetrating radar, how easy is that to peek at whats below. If the original builders kept the site clean and some of the previous tenants then it may be way older than the sediments indicate. There should be something at the bottom to carbon date. Its really hard to wait two weeks for a new video!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you Alan! I appreciate your support! I do hope the new excavation can discover more clues, though I haven't seen any update on it...

[@mannumex]

As always, excellent, well researched and original videos, food for thought. Thanks for all your work! 🙌

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

My pleasure! Thank you for watching my videos :-)

[@erikistrup3477]

Thank you for this anticipated video, Tina. You bring news and good arguments!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thanks for watching! I appreciate your support, Erik :-)

[@kawasakikev8905]

WOW Tina , you've done it again . another fascinating video with previously unknown content , why has no one else talked about these underground caves , why has no one used the same logic that you have to suggest there may be much more below ground level than is currently suggested ,it's not beyond imagination to presume there could be more than one level of caves ,i want to go there with an excavator and dig the floor up ,just to prove your theory correct . i hope the future planned digs turn up some interesting finds and many more caves . i look forward to more updates . keep them coming.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

So glad that you enjoy my videos :-) Thank you very much for the support and encouragement. I appreciate you ♥

[@juaerez69]

Great presentation Curious. Thank you.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it. Hope you like other videos too :-)

[@gregoryhousch3321]

Another great video on a fascinating location. Thank you Tina

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it. Thank you for watching, Gregory.

[@j-beatsimaginationstudio1987]

You are brilliant! Love your content. Be safe :)

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thanks so much! I appreciate your support :-)

[@martinsonne7001]

This is great content Tina. Thank you!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you Martin :-)

[@theRhinsRanger]

Hi Tina, when you go up the valley you see lots of carved out caves which look like they were living spaces and that a huge flood rip through the valley tearing the walls off of those living spaces. I've thought about this but i never knew about the Dam

[@Slavigrad]

Because of your videos I am going on vacation to Petra and Egypt in November. I hope I will visit it before the world ends 🙂

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Have a great trip! It'll be wonderful to visit these amazing sites.

[@Slavigrad]

@@CuriousBeingbyTina Thank you, yes, I am looking forward to see it, like your videos which are very inspiring and educative!

[@fantastickpuff5368]

Very interesting presentation. Well researched and displayed with good graphics. I have subscribed for more information and to promote your ideas. Thank you.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Awesome, thank you! I really appreciate it :-)

[@tashuntka]

Tina......always has amazing insights 👍💛👍

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you very much for the support!

[@williamthomas5889]

Great channel. Always good material.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Much appreciated!

[@jasonh.3006]

I truly enjoy your videos. Inspiring ideas is a blessing, especially when the ideas are backed in solid facts. Thank you for your hard work.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

So glad you like my videos :-) Thank you very much for the support.

[@richardliles4415]

Great video! Thank you Tina.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad it was helpful! Thank you Richard :-)

[@lotwizzard1748]

i💖your voice Miss Tina. this has long been one of my interests of ancient sites. get down to the foundation.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad to hear that. Thank you for listening :-)

[@lotwizzard1748]

@@CuriousBeingbyTina it would be nice to hear your thoughts on Ellora cave in India. also praveen has an interesting new video of a precarious cliff carving

[@nicolaeionescu-kosa132]

An other nice and informative video from you as usual. Thank you for your great work.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you Nicolae :-) Glad you enjoyed the video.

[@therogueresearcherschannel9887]

Hello Tina, I like your work very much because it is very thorough and well presented.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you so much! :-)

[@kromulviking8568]

as always you got smart and interesting theories.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you for the kind words :-)

[@yetiskies9240]

Fascinating. I had no idea about the lower layer. So much hidden history. Thanks for your efforts.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it :-) Thank you for watching!

[@iang1]

Fascinating

[@tomsamsungandroid5402]

Very, very nice observations and again something new to me 🙂

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you Tom. Have a nice weekend!

[@tomsamsungandroid5402]

Have a nice weekend Tina :)

[@yuppy1967]

This is brilliant, great work! This is probably the most compelling argument ever devised regarding the creation of Petra.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you very much! Hope you can check out my other videos too :-)

[@lip3gate]

great analysis!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you! Hope you will enjoy my other videos too :-)

[@markkerlin2585]

Excellent report, thank you

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it. Thank you for watching :-)

[@tattoo62]

You did a very nice job on the video !! Ty!!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thanks for watching! :-) Hope you like my other videos too!

[@alex-650]

Thanks for the thought provoking video! Time to start organizing some tour groups to these amazing places, so you can share your insights in person!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thanks Alex! I hope I can do that someday :-)

[@raichuraichu7632]

Awesome video! Great information 👍

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad that you enjoyed it! Hope you will check out my other videos too :-)

[@djknight1725]

Very cool!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you!

[@neilharrison9144]

It really is an interesting place ,great presentation.too.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you for watching! I appreciate the support :-)

[@briangenn6479]

Very thorough! You are an inspiration.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you Brian! I appreciate that :-)

[@AncientHistoryCriticisms]

Great topic! Thank you.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you for the support! :-)

[@yiwenedwinang5696]

Thank you Tina for this video. Your video presented many information not found in other documentaries on Petra. It has been a while since i last watched your video and i’m glad i watched this video today! I recently changed job and it has been hectic. Hope things are well with you. Also, nice painting on your wall

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Good to hear from you Edwin! Thank you for watching my video. It takes time to adjust to a new job. Hope you will get pass this hectic feeling very soon. Be well!

[@yiwenedwinang5696]

@@CuriousBeingbyTina yeah, it takes time to get pass the beginning stage.. hope you are doing well. Seem like China is reducing quarantine duration. Not sure if you would be visiting home or your family with you at the States?

[@kenichinishikawa7007]

It is very interesting video. This is the first time to see the below the treasury in Petra. This video makes me to visit Petra more than before. Thanks.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it. Hope you like my other videos too :-)

[@jwrappuhn71]

Excellent vid Tina.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you :-)

[@SG-js2qn]

Have they done ground penetrating radar in the subterranean Treasury chambers? That could help establish whether there is an additional layer of structure beneath, and guide excavation. It also seems like they should attempt a series of core samples or radar to determine how deep the accumulated sediment in the wadi goes.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

I don't think they have done that in the lower caves under the Treasury. I agree it'll be really helpful if core samples can be extracted before the new excavation (might help preventing sample contamination). The sediment could be really deep.

[@williamryder5021]

Is there going to be any new or ongoing excavation? Or wilk they continue to just tour it as is forever, not knowing whats beneath the sedement. Id install clear thick plexiglass floring over aluminum and steel frame ontop of large sections of ground level and then cunduct a live excavation beneath the sections, so that the tourists walking above and watch history being revielved below.

[@TheSupershoz]

Awesome video Tina

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it - thank you!

[@stevewhitson2006]

Thank you for this video. You are brilliant.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

You're very welcome! Hope you will enjoy my other videos too :-)

[@johnbowman476]

very interesting video! Thanks for all the effort you put into these, getting educated

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you for the support :-)

[@68Mie]

Hello Tina 👋. You are fantastic ! 🤠👍

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you so much, Mie Mie :-)

[@MarvinMonroe]

Wow 60k views! This is great news! I'll be able to say I was an early fan when your videos are getting a million views

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you for the continuous support :-)

[@johanwise9713]

Great work! Thanks for realising my wishes of information 🥂👍

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

My pleasure! Thank you for the support :-)

[@johanwise9713]

@@CuriousBeingbyTina You are always welcome! 🌻

[@nicoleorton5299]

You’ve done remarkable work on this.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you very much, Nicole! Hope you will enjoy my other videos too :-)

[@johnweaver4564]

Thanks Tina! Well done!

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Glad you enjoyed it :-)

[@johnweaver4564]

@@CuriousBeingbyTina What’s your site for donations? I’d like to contribute 😊

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

@@johnweaver4564 Thank you John ☺My Patreon account is curiousbeing. It's a site for monthly donations. I'm grateful for your support!

[@johnmqueripel2367]

Very well done.

[@CuriousBeingbyTina]

Thank you John! :-)