WHAT’S THE POINT IN VAR?! Referee shocker - but certain players must do better! Surely Guehi now?

Рет қаралды 36,076

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 245

@markwilson9100 Ай бұрын

I'm not a Newcastle fan but Diaz played the ref and var, once again despite all the BS from the suits - var and all the officials haven't improved..... same old sh*t I'm afraid.

@tomwebster5348 Ай бұрын

Diaz went through schar when the game was stopped and got rewarded for it 🤦‍♂️ it’s so refreshing to have you, Keith, say it exactly how it was - officiating was probably the worst I’ve ever seen, somehow they get worse and worse 🤷‍♂️

@waynemarch-hq2qi Ай бұрын

One goes both should go simple

@lyndawren4724 Ай бұрын

I cant belive schar was sent off for head butting its just not like schar they guy put hes face in schars face then went down like hed been shot hes a cheat in my.opionion the red card should be overturned 100%

@lyndawren4724 Ай бұрын

@@Cristobal_2012 well they were var should have picked up schar didnt head butt him var are useless make far to many mistakes

@Disillusioned-k9j Ай бұрын

Pawson Southampton's no 12 brereton cheat git

@geordiedog1749 Ай бұрын

I’m a supporter of VAR but when this happens I feel like shouting “guys! I’m trying to help you here and you pull this shit!”

@anthwebber79 Ай бұрын

Lewis hall is getting criticised today , the lad done fantastic to clear that off the line.

@JulieDorsetBelle Ай бұрын

Exactly - Livramento was outstanding as was Joelinton - bloody fans that just hop on one mistake - bruno has done the same mistakes too ...

@anthwebber79 Ай бұрын

Exactly, 👍

@stevenphillips4494 Ай бұрын

Lewis had a poor game, he also did fantastic to clear the ball off the line .. both things can be true at the same time.

@adamcrawford1346 Ай бұрын

Didn’t think he was poor mate. Not sharp and it’s a little disappointing that they seemed to set the mood early, maybe just my imagination. We never seem to be able to convert crosses. Always seems to fly past all the team. But … we won. So woohoo. Happy Sunday to all.

@revenger32 Ай бұрын

Lewis did well defending, but some of his transition passes was horrible and gave southampton many decent chances.

@stephennutkin2477 Ай бұрын

Please note that the var operator Kavanagh has been banned at leased twice for poor var decisions so what went wrong with var and the ref. That said Schar is experienced enough not to be goaded in fact he should have fallen when pushed…but surely that’s not the name of the game. As an after thought. If the sending off decision is looked at and it is found that Diaz had fooled the ref then it is he should be missing for at least two games . Var was supposed to see through cheating .

@thesabreferret Ай бұрын

He's fucked Newcastle over on multiple occasions as ref and as VAR lackey. Total piece of shit.

@davidbarker9068 Ай бұрын

Surly has to be overturned

@A544N85 Ай бұрын

It’s mad that he’s still in the room doing var duties he clearly is incompetent of

@poolie-mag8282 Ай бұрын

Joelinton is an absolute animal hope his form continues

@andrewrostron2495 Ай бұрын

Schar was foolish but if that isn’t rescinded under appeal then it gives the green light to the rest of the league to play-act to get other players sent off. Diaz went down like there was a sniper in the stands! What a fraud!

@ozzy6162 Ай бұрын

Pawson is not a Premier League referee - he was terrible for both sides throughout. If Schar had to be sent off then why not Brearton as well for his "tackle" on Schar & simulation?

@jonnyfungus Ай бұрын

And they say that the standard of refs has never been better 😂😂

@Britisheats Ай бұрын

Minteh with an assist on his debut. Still cannot get my head right with the injustices of this league. There's nothing Premier about it but he would have been good for us at RW this season.

@Raggattoni Ай бұрын

The free kick was for the foul on Bruno. Diaz then took Schar out after the whistle. That is a straight red card! The reaction from Schar was not a red card. Shows the PGMOL fraudulence. Time for the Fans of all clubs to bring legal action against the PGMOL as it appears the clubs are unable to litigate against the crooks who run the game! Shocking, shocking, shocking state of affairs!

@phil5357 Ай бұрын

I miss the days when the football was about the football

@Toenala Ай бұрын

I was there today and I loved it Keith. Great fun. Pantomime baddies, awful refereeing, Newcastle win. What's not to love? This is what it is like supporting the toon.

@jtaylor8606 Ай бұрын

I wasn't there, but I thought it was great too!

@aking-plums6985 Ай бұрын

What's not to love, well a possible 3 match suspension for Schär, Crystal Palace increasing the price of Guéhi because of NUFC immediate need for a right sided centre back .

@SirMonkeySuit Ай бұрын

He isn't a Newcastle supporter. He is there as a neutral, It was beautiful and justice was served for the Geordies but of course the Neutral would find that awful. Referee ruined it.

@eddouglas Ай бұрын

Standard prawn sandwich boomer toon fan that sees a nice game of football with a nice day out... Missing schar for 3 games, price hike for Guehi, more BS. Shocking dive caught on 4k. Barely watching football, we're watching rich people hypno fuck about with football.

@flazzy6931 Ай бұрын

Gordons unfit because southgate had him rotting on the bench, hopefully the fitness comes!

@Steph-wq9it Ай бұрын

For the conspiracy theorists, it’s all part of a corrupt premiership to stop Newcastle at all costs achieving anything that involves upsetting the so called top six clubs. Gordon is knackered after a very long season.

@AlanBrownPhotography Ай бұрын

Game was finished as soon as Dawson pulled the red card. I can't believe how in any world the instigator of both violent conduct AND simulation can be rewarded in such a manner. What message is this sending to others?????

@markillingworth1972 Ай бұрын

Well it wasn’t finished cos we scored afterwards and won 😂😂

@TheDefJamm Ай бұрын

Classic case of the ref loosing his head and completely loosing control of the game. He was out his depth.

@briancarrigan1982 Ай бұрын

Ref is a joke, var waste of time and diaz is a total shit house

@allyloogs Ай бұрын

Can’t believe our guys were shaking hands with him after the game. I would have been in his face giving him shit. What a nob he is.

@desfarrer6045 Ай бұрын

The premium league is curupt after 15 minutes Mr CRAIG PAWSON was out of his comfort zone league 1 standards Chris cavaanagh in VAR it was never gonna be over turned the lads done BRILLIANT ❤

@stevevenus1 Ай бұрын

If Schar had to go then surely Diaz did as well. Yellow for the foul and yellow for the simulation.

@David-vx4mx Ай бұрын

Always makes my blood boil when I see certain players deliberately exaggerating things like this.

@goatfather5711 Ай бұрын

It was a head kiss from both players. Never a red card.

@golfinggeordie7203 Ай бұрын

If the ref gives red cards for this fakery then they are condoning all diving in our game.Ref,s and VAR need to stamp all fakery out.Its spoiling it for all fans....

@golfinggeordie7203 Ай бұрын

@@Cristobal_2012 Totally agree..Its the reaction to ensure someone is either red carded or yellow carded..spoils it for all fans...Refs need to card the divers and the over reactions.Its getting worse....

@TheJDUBMedia Ай бұрын

Pawson was an absolute joke

@steveeccleston3084 Ай бұрын

Hope he appeals and it gets overturned but, he shouldn't have got himself in that situation.

@igg3937 Ай бұрын

Do you honestly think that the types of characters who go into refereeing care about common sense though? It's all about petty power games.

@phil5357 Ай бұрын

We got away with it today, but a valuable lesson (that we should already have known) that majority of players nowadays are looking for any excuse to fall squealing to the floor.

@martyjago8636 Ай бұрын

We had 10 men for an hour ffs 😂

@tgdkls5891 Ай бұрын

Cheers Keith. Thanks for telling it how it is, as always. Grim, but what a win! Joelinton = God.

@NUFC2412 Ай бұрын

Game has gone soft. But Schar has to be more disaplined than that. Soon as you lean yr head in. Yr in bother

@markspark7634 Ай бұрын

Immense performance from bruno, Joe and Sean in midfield, and greatmfrom the rest of the team, unbelievable amount of grit and fitness on the first game of the season, the players have obviously smashed pre season and have come back fitter than ever

@roncalvelt5943 Ай бұрын

The ref was conned

@sid-d4w Ай бұрын

And somehow var were too?

@NUFC2412 Ай бұрын

Well he wasnt

@Geordie7878 Ай бұрын

@@sid-d4wprobably wasn’t even looked at

@sid-d4w Ай бұрын

@@Geordie7878 Hopefully their will be a successful appeal

@beepmac275 Ай бұрын

Great analysis Kieth, totally agree , where is the common sense! Thanks.

@SpeedZonez Ай бұрын

Is this refereeing situation ever going to improve? I had high hopes of better officiating going into the new season and we have been let down already, both on and off field refs very poor, Pawson is dreadful.

@DUDLEYBADBOY123 Ай бұрын

Can’t even add anything to That Keith you’ve summed the whole game up tremendously . The red card should get overturned if football wants to have some common sense. That red card just spoiled the whole spectacle and clear cheating for me Diaz. One thing you don’t do is come to Newcastle and upset the crowd 🕺🏻🏳️🏴

@2006stephendavid Ай бұрын

Great, honest report Keith. Totally agree with everything you said 😁👍 ⚫️⚪️

@JulieDorsetBelle Ай бұрын

👍Well said keith - justice prevails. Every time I've watched Pawson he does the same thing. Nothing given in the first half to frustrate Newcastle and then gives a few in the second half to even up his stats. Blatant professional fouls by Soton - Harwood-Bellis on Gordon early doors not given - Bruno up-ended every time - stifling our creative players - must be so disheartening for our players to put up with this. Fair play to Soton - came with a game plan and ref was sucked in - which is unforgivable in this day and age. As for Brereton-Diaz - HAH! Outstanding effort from the whole team in the end.

@thedarktowercometh9989 Ай бұрын

Commonsense has been lacking in football for a long time.

@0GHacksNET Ай бұрын

All the schar decision really proved. Is that youre allowed to antagonise, playact and still get the best decision. Nevermind the fact it also proved that diaz is genuinelly useless as a footballer and missed more than one chance to actually make a POSITIVE difference for his team. Fortunately for newcastle and football in general, diaz's behaviour not only contributed to a poor decision overall, (schar deserved it by the book, but touroises have moved their hesds faster) his actions actually HELPED newcastle win by his inability to score easy goals. And by his actions causing fair hostility from the crowd which ended up helping Newcastles players have true fight and win the match. I think Diaz's actions are a fair outcome of HOW NOT to behave on a football pitch and help your team win.(Or lose...in this case)

@DarrenBrians Ай бұрын

VAR... Crag we've got 7/1 Newcastle to get beat £1000 on it mate. Half time. Crage we've covered the bet. 10/1 Newcastle to win😅. Hey the beer in hear is better this season 🍻

@kendo5862 Ай бұрын

If var isn’t preserving the integrity of the game in terms of sportsmanship and helping the ref who’s been hoodwinked… then the ofiicials behind the scene are failing the principles of the game …

@markwilliams6 Ай бұрын

Great coverage and oversight Keith. Positives to take from today and lessons to learn also. Evolution is the key and we need to remember that this is a case of building for the future. Without input from yourself and the rest of the Sky Sports team, us fans won't know the intricate details. Thanks for the graft, and one day, it'll be worth it.

@ztyneisnigh Ай бұрын

The refs and var were shocking. I have never been so enraged. He deserved all the booing he got. We were not great in the first half hour. Everyone was so nervous and the players were losing possession cheaply. Once the sending off happened it was a different game. Thanks to big Joe once we went ahead we never looked losing. Southampton are a poor team and with a faker on their squad deserve every defeat that is coming their way. I hope every team smashes them.

@Plymonk666 Ай бұрын

Jacob Murphy yet again the man

@BigDom61 Ай бұрын

If that was a sending off my god VAR-has got a lot to answer for saying that the ref should have had a word with Diaz for going down like he’s been shot

@philireland749 Ай бұрын

We've gone too deep on trying to get Guehi, if we walk away now were going to get mugged for any other player we go for, so just pay the ransom that Palace want and move on

@markillingworth1972 Ай бұрын

Appeal the red card

@Dave-ug9bh Ай бұрын

We should be 100% walking away from the Guehi deal

@YankeeGeordie Ай бұрын

VAR Kavanagh has much to answer for but that's a separate issue. The referee is in charge of the match, and I place *all* the blame for this on Pawson. He created the situation. Bruno was fouled and Pawson's initial reaction was to hesitate. There was no advantage to consider. After the foul, Pawson is ahead of play and *visually* signals (no whistle yet), then jogs nearly 10 yards into the center circle before raising his whistle to his lips. This is an eternity to players, and most of them weren't aware of his visual signal. You can see player confusion and frustration all over the pitch during these few seconds. AFTER THE LATE WHISTLE, three seconds pass while Diaz runs over ten yards, lowers his left shoulder, pushes off his right foot and barges Schar in the centre of his back. *That* is the only thing here that begins to approach violent conduct. Pawson is busy dealing with Bruno's reaction while this is happening. Pawson CREATED THIS MESS. While he isn't responsible for the two players' actions, he is responsible for creating the confusion and tension that gave rise to them. Referees are trained and expected to anticipate and to diffuse, to make clear signals, both visual and with the whistle or voice (advantage). Pawson did none of this. He wouldn't have passed a local assessment in a Sunday league match with this display. His last error was a failure to self-assess how he had created a problem and to stack another error (red card) on top of this tragic comedy instead of fixing the damn situation.

@richardblackshaw6567 Ай бұрын

Excellent summing up of what happened. Pawson inept

@petersmith9470 Ай бұрын

Don't know what was funniest, Pawson being called a referee or McLaren beating Bruce to the Jamaica job. Another shocking VAR decision but not as bad as the one for West Ham's penalty

@sensel4298 Ай бұрын

After watching the Euros it’s clear the standard of referee-ing is the worst in the top 6 leagues here

@ChrisTelfer-j1s Ай бұрын

You're the only pundit that has commented on referees' performance. Even without the red card, his overall performance was a disgrace. Well done for highlighting it, Keith 👏

@rooneyroo5338 Ай бұрын

Gordon wants a move to Liverpool Isac the Gunners... its so obvious..... Loads going on internally..

@silver-bullittadventure3634 Ай бұрын

The refereeing for the start of this season has been appalling. The referee give Andreas for Fulham vs Man U a yellow card yesterday for taking a quick free kick when two Man U players were not retreating from the ball I actually couldn't believe it never seen that before in my life WTF.

@NUFC82 Ай бұрын

It's no surprise that var didn't step in, the whole of the UK is doubling down on THICK!

@MrNelliboy Ай бұрын

'Officials' again...

@geordiedog1749 Ай бұрын

I’ll take that result all season though!

@55north17 Ай бұрын

Keith, Yet another great video, thanks. Sorry, the rule does't need changing, it works the way it is. Sadly it's the officials that are inadequate. Don't know how you rectify that when it only seems to be Dumb Dumbs who put up for the job. It's a great shame that we've totally lost the concept and ethic of sportsmanship. All that seems to matter now is winning at whatever cost and money. I'm 82 now but in late 50's thro 60's and early seventies I played in the Northern Amateur league and guess that we could have easily got through 90 minutes without official and just simply played to the rules, we did that on our training kick-abouts.

@what_im_eatin_uk Ай бұрын

This is not the first time we have had dubious decisions from this referee. Blowing the whistle over and over not playing advantage how many times does Bruno have to be fowled before a card comes out absolutely awful refereeing

@grahamritchie7755 Ай бұрын

Great review Keith just spot on

@sveinroarhansen9893 Ай бұрын

If anything Bereton Diaz should be banned for three matches.

@dennisnielsen4289 Ай бұрын

I would say 10, bringing the game in to disrepute. It would be a hard lesson yes, but one that would teach him.

@ozzy6162 Ай бұрын

Don't worry Keith we've got loads of centre backs man! £75M bid for Guehi on the way to Palace at half-time. 👍

@ericengleby265 Ай бұрын

Was at the match today looked soft at the time and our players reactions said it all towards Diaz. Thought Walker-Peters was very good for Southampton. If Tripps goes i think he would be a good signing for ourselves ge can play Left back or Right back Joelinton was absolutely superb. In all fairness gutsy 3 points today. We were well off it b4 the sending off. Far to slow moving the ball. Also us going long ball the whole game rather than Pope rolling it out to either full back was crazy. Think wee need a Centre Back in more than ever now.

@jackmcmahon7216 Ай бұрын

I thought Joelinton and Bruno were everywhere today like

@tugwilson786 Ай бұрын

the ref needs to have a word with himself!! Before the sending off we seem to have reaped the rewards of a poor transfer window - having said that we would have lost this game last year

@levstone415 Ай бұрын

First duty of the ref is to protect the players. If Diaz had knocked over Murphy or Pope (people with dislocated shoulders) then would the ref have done anything?

@rayfegan8701 Ай бұрын

Not the greatest performance today by the toon but thanks to our defending somehow we managed to get the three points. So that will do for us Newcastles fans today.

@sp.8632 Ай бұрын

Mostly brilliant comments, except at the end. I disagree about gaehi and our position at CB. We should still walk away from Palace negotiations. Schar missing doesnt mean we have to be financial mugs. Krafth has shown himself to be a capable cover option at CB. Trust him and give him his chance

@Neale-c4l Ай бұрын

Var is a disgrace

@grahamstitt6297 Ай бұрын

The problem was apparent for me. We didn't keep the ball well enough in tight areas. The lack of pace at centre back weighs on everyone's mind. It will definitely cost us this season if we don't sign that quality centre back. We need pace in there. Tonali will add that class. And as much as I love Murphy, we need that extra quality wide right. Hard work is great but it not going to win you the tighter games.

@Oscarancasey Ай бұрын

Ot on with your comments, especially re the referee. Newcastle were poor throughout even before the sending off. I fear for Southampton if they couldn't take advantage of an off form Newcastle, playing against 10 men and a friendly referee. That tackle on Gordon that received a yellow could easily have been a red. There were so many poor decisions.

@RobGThai Ай бұрын

Very poor ref and VAR(as usual). Over exaggerating should be yellow card imo. If Southampton plays their football as good as they are playing the ref then they would have won. We fought well regardless.

@Pubtomfoolery Ай бұрын

Great post. I'm overseas and the time difference can make it difficult to watch live so appreciate a round up of the game! Seems like some things don't change - incompetent VAR, Refs etc. We're always in an uphill battle, what's new? I definitely think the powers at be don't want to Newcastle settling into the top 6 and 'silly' decisions by the VAR or the referee will be a big part in stopping that, if you can chip 20 points away from us, over a season. Hopefully it's just a one off but I've seen it far too often over the last few years.

@paulcarruthers1314 Ай бұрын

Both Hall and Livremento looked shaky

@trevorarkle124 Ай бұрын

As always Keith 💯 Eddie's got work to do with the squad Paul has work to do with the board ASAP Keep the powder dry Trevor Thailand

@RichardAnderson-f3p Ай бұрын

Great synopsis Keith. So much better than the glass half empty, negative, snarky diatribe from Craig Hope.

@ianrichardmorrissey6082 Ай бұрын

Is this going to be yet another season of Bulshit, NUFC get your shit together and show up for every game 100% ready to play ya heart out. No more lame excuses regardless of how bad VAR and referee incompetence is. Hopefully the red card is appealed and negated.

@senshibat8920 Ай бұрын

the FA EPL should summarize the VAR tapes on these sorts of decisions hurt the integrity of sport?

@peterarmstrong3298 Ай бұрын

Well said Keith.

@gaho6256 Ай бұрын

It was awful to watch , it was morning and our style of football is poor!! As much I like Bruno but he was poor and slow today and he shouldn’t be captain. Can’t really blame Isak , we just don’t have any creative players or football to feed him. Seriously the game was boring

@thumpertoon76 Ай бұрын

Newcastle's new problem I'm seeing is when we face a different formation Keith, we seen Luton and Forest come up to St. James' last season and play 442 and walk away with point(s) as with Soton today playing 352 and we struggle to match the tactics on the pitch when we face teams who play a different formation to the new regular 433 that most top teams play now and with Luton last season they started the season trying to play the same 433 and it wasn't working for them, they changed back to what they were playing in the Championship 442 and started getting results and points on the board, could be an idea for Eddie and the team to learn how to combat a 352 or a 442 by then matching the tactical formation, 352 is a solid formation for attack and defence if you have quick physical wing backs....

@SuperEthel Ай бұрын

spot on yeah schar did not expect to be playing against a disgraceful faker like DIAZ but took the bait and done it with pride in showing how unprofessional and embarrassing DIAZ is as a player for southampton...pawson covered his incompetent ass and VAR well its showed the FA are full of crap when saying its improved and better ....was the VAR part of the WWE refereeing team....but pointless crying as nothing will be done and hope and pray this happens to man untd and see what happens

@ianclayton2651 Ай бұрын

the point of VAR is legalised corruption and it has been from day 1,the game stinks to the high heavens,blokes sitting in a room 200 miles away waiting for a nod from their paymasters ,it just quite simply stinks

@D23348 Ай бұрын

All clubs votied to keep VAR at the expectation of changes this season with better training or whatever they promised.from the 1st game they have proved their complete incompetence. The club need to appeal to get that card over turned. Whats the point of putting another bid in for Gehi they will just bump up the price another 15 mil. Go and buy Tbiaw who done just as good in the Euros and half the price

@mercurial382 Ай бұрын

It is utterly ridiculous that VAR is not used in this context, or why have it at all? That Southampton player should be given a several match ban retrospectively. It's not rocket science.

@peterfinkill8098 Ай бұрын

The rule that sent Schar off apparently says "A player who when not challenging for the ball deliberatly strikes an opponent or any other person on the head or face with the hand or arm is guilty of voilent conduct unless the force used was negligible." It was certainly negligible so the Ref shouldn't have sent him off. NUFC should use this to appeal against the sending off and the 3 match ban.

@mypointoftoon Ай бұрын

Sorry Keith. Although I agree with your pov on why VAR was needed over referee making his own mind, I firmly disagree with your reasoning for it i.e. ruining a game as a spectacle - This is going down the rabbit hole of where sports more an entertainmebt

@petarpan8176 Ай бұрын

Looks like this coming season main topic will be ref's AGAIN!!

@stevenphillips4494 Ай бұрын

All the idiotic pundits like Chris Sutton who are immediately falling over themselves to back the referee should be put on the dole … I honestly don’t know when common sense went out of football. I thought Isak was outstanding after the sending off positionally and defending from the front , worked his heart out.

@kicka11 Ай бұрын

VAR is meant to uphold the on field decision unless obvious evidence. Pawson has always been a complete joke, the blame is with him.

@jtilb1508 Ай бұрын

Bit pointless picking out players when we had 10 men for 70 odd minutes, yeah we didn’t look great with 11 men but no doubt we would of got to grips with them, they played through the press a few times but didn’t trouble pope before we went down to 10

@House0fHoot Ай бұрын

Big Joey The Warrior 🖤🤍💪🏾 That diving divvy diva, Diaz, is disgraceful!

@JRHunter1993 Ай бұрын

No point in appealing as the bottom line is that the PL will want to teach other olayers and youngters watching to not react at all. Doesnt matter if you make contact or not, just dont react physically. But obviously a shocking decision and shows how useless VAR is hat they cant intervene through common sense. If the ref has to watch it again on the monitor he surely cant give a red for it.

@Dodgyguitarist Ай бұрын

Soon as i heard it was pawson i just knew it would be one of those games and sure enough. How many times does he blow early when he should be playing advantage for a few seconds at least. Then the red card incident. its either yellow yellow or red red. hes a joke and needs demoting.

@PerKorsen Ай бұрын

When Schar take that little move, he gave the ref the oppertunety to show the red card. And it is'nt a clear and obvious foul by the ref, but soft, yes.. What he did not do right was that Diaz should have two yellow cards. First for the push that started it and then one for the confrontation that led to the red..

@senshibat8920 Ай бұрын

Right you are sir.. Their play leans in first schar on the angle is straight up. then wamo schar leans then the man flopped like a jurgen Klinsmann

@B-jz6fk Ай бұрын

Schar is old enough to know better than to touch heads. Also Joe Linton lost the plot later on. Players losing their heads can cost us games because like it or not certain teams will pick them out and try to wind them up and get them sent off.

@Thegeordiemusician Ай бұрын

Dont waste money on a player that a clubs trying to pull every penny from us for walks way and buy a different player and Get a winger in asap

@jamesfretwell1511 Ай бұрын

No way we should pay that much for guehi. Hes clearly not worth 50 million nevermind whatever palace are trying to get for him. Krafts a decent backup for the time being.