What Was Before the Big Bang?

Ever wondered what existed before the Big Bang? In "What Was Before the Big Bang?", we dive deep into the abyss of the universe's origins, exploring the edge of what science, philosophy, and cosmology can tell us about the very beginning. It's a question that has puzzled thinkers and scientists alike for centuries: if the Big Bang marks the explosive creation of everything we know, what, if anything, was there before?
This video isn't just a science lesson; it's an adventure that stretches the limits of our imagination. We'll explore various theories that attempt to answer this mind-bending question. From the possibility of a cyclic universe, endlessly expanding and contracting, to Stephen Hawking's revolutionary No-Boundary Proposal, suggesting a universe without a beginning as we understand it. We'll also delve into the fascinating concept of a multiverse, a cosmos filled with countless universes, each unique in its own right.
Featuring insights from leading physicists like Brian Greene and Paul Steinhardt, we peel back the layers of the cosmos to reveal a universe far more complex and interconnected than we ever imagined. Whether it's the intriguing idea of universes giving birth to each other or the enigmatic forces driving the universe's acceleration, we're covering it all.
So, grab your cosmic passport and join us on a journey to the very edge of knowledge and beyond. "What Was Before the Big Bang?" isn't just a question; it's a gateway to understanding our universe's past, present, and future. Let's explore the ultimate mystery together, and who knows? Maybe we'll find some answers-or even more questions-along the way.
Subscribe to Science Time: / sciencetime24
#universe #briangreene #bigbang

[@ancipital]

One of the curent emerging theories is that that our univsere was in fact created from a singularity from another universe so the big bang was in fact a huge mass collapsing into a black hole. The reason we would never be able to cross into that universe is that you cannot cross the event horizon of a black hole in the other direction being that is the boundary to our universe. This would mean black holes forming in our universe would in fact be the creation of other universes. An interesting theory to say the least!

[@off__world8668]

🤔🤔🤔

[@mikekolokowsky]

The other collapsing Universe was antimatter. +1 Universe and -1 Universe came out of 0. Antimatter went the opposite direction in the dimension of time, positive matter went our way. And here we are.

[@ianbattles7290]

But then where is the entry point to our universe from the outer universe?

[@DJWESG1]

Not a collapse. Old and cold.. re-seeded through a conflict of pressures.

[@1000joshfootball]

Literally not new nor emerging

[@drinny26]

When I think about the universe and how big it is my mind almost explodes.

[@Folker46590]

What Was Before the Big Bang? Another Universe, and another before that. Extending infinitely into the past and the future.

[@stephenjohnson9560]

The truth in the room is they don't know, like a lot of things.

[@silversnow3186]

No human does. We’re all the same.

[@TheCureThatKillz]

Exactly! I agree! I love and believe in science but there are just some things we’ll never be able to figure out. I heard recently that scientists recently discovered how many ants are in the world. I mean, come’on!!!

[@petemitchell9996]

They didn't say they do know. Those are all theories.

[@blacklyfe6881]

It's not that we don't know we know, and the answer is nothing happened before the big bang because time didn't exist before the bug bang only at the moment of or after the big bang. It's like me asking you Where's the edge of the universe, or what's darker than the color color black or what is stronger than gravity? The universe doesn't have an edge. There's nothing darker than black, and nothing in the universe is stronger than gravity, so your question makes no sense.

[@blacklyfe6881]

​@TheCureThatKillz science will be able to figure out everything that's why it's called discovery. If they did so for tens of thousands of years what makes you think they won't in the next few billion years? You just womt be alive to know it.

[@Malyfcntoo]

Did space was just pitch black in quiet emptiness?? If so, what is this Pitch black emptiness ? Where did it come from? My mind keep asking to go back and back its so hard to think of anything

[@610610billy610610]

This is exactly how I think. How can something come from nothing. A black empty space is still a space, so where did that come from. If there was no space, then how did anything form.

[@joeyfung-i]

I think the same way as well. Since I was a kid it terrified me and captivated me at the same time. Or the thought that space can not have an “end”…. 🤯

[@Ramirez83786]

@@610610billy610610 There must be a creator. That's my conclusion. The universe or even that empty space can't magically appear out of nothing. It must have had a starting point. And that creator/entity can't have a creator because that would lead to infinite regress.

[@Folker46590]

People are trapped by the idea that everything has to have a beginning and an end, the idea that the universe has always existed scares them, for some reason.

[@Ramirez83786]

@@Folker46590 That’s impossible, the universe is finite, stars depends on fuel and other things.

[@tonytucker1]

My question is always how did the materials appear to create the Big Bang. How did something just appear out of nowhere?

[@petemitchell9996]

It didn't appear out of nowhere. According to Einstein and Hawking, the universe existed in a singularity. All matter squished in a bubble smaller than a dot. This almost infinitely small thing then collapsed and exploded.

[@tonytucker1]

@@petemitchell9996 yeah but it always begs the question where did that singularity come from? It’s so hard for me to comprehend something just showing up with no known start. It’ll almost drive you crazy lol

[@stehdguyh2829]

There was a 0.0000001% (or even infinite less, but non-zero) chance of universe becoming reality. If there is a chance for an event to happen, and the chance is not a complete zero, it will certainly happen, given enough time.

[@zohaibaijaz1856]

What's the first thing ever existed and why?

[@ashish5675]

​@@zohaibaijaz1856and where 😂

[@rogergaylord3036]

The truth is they only have guesses which only create more questions. That's science.

[@PaddleDogC5]

If I was a scientist this would drive me MAD.😮

[@watgaz518]

So when we put two magnets together and they repel, is this how our universe operates, where we exist in the area between the two magnets?

[@TheWhateverMan420]

Its incredible to think that everything we can touch, see and feel all came from this "unknown nothing" of a bang.

[@caryd67]

So if gravity can also be repulsive, perhaps that indicates a necessary relationship between gravity and heavy objects. It sounds like gravity actually seeks out heavy objects to “link” to, but when no objects are close enough to each other to actually interact, it “zooms out” creating this universal expansion. There could also be an unknown connection between gravity and temperature. What happens to water when it freezes? It expands. As the universe continues to expand it also continues to cool. Just a thought. And yes, I don’t know 💩 about gravity, but it’s fun to think about

[@godmeloanthony7895]

Heres how I see it , Nothing cant make something , thats where u have to consider a higher being , just think about all the conditions that make it perfect for us to live on this planet

[@EmeraldEyesEsoteric]

The future must create the past. Simply remove all the empty space between atoms, to make a new big bang and time will flow in reverse.

[@GodlovingAndrei]

​@EmeraldEyesEsoteric How the hell are you so sure of that?

[@EmeraldEyesEsoteric]

@@GodlovingAndrei Actually, if you remove all the empty space you also remove time so you just make the original big bang, not a 2nd one. Like a balloon popping. If the future creates the past...

[@hollyfut]

Yeah how did the higher beeing came into existence

[@tomsmith4542]

'god of the gaps', has been debunked numerous times

[@error7329]

How different types of elements were formed ?

[@Quranic-Topics]

Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and then We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe? -Surah Al-Anbiyāʾ, Ayah 30

[@Infinityisone]

10:05 thank you.

[@arthurjunroiurwatts]

past partical could it be put in the futchers past that never exsited in the first bigbang

[@timhallas4275]

I imagined once that this universe is like a bubble, one of many, fully attached to each other,some expanding as other's contract, sharing both energy and matter.

[@smileyp4535]

Yeah that's the last hypothesis they mentioned, it's a cool idea

[@iamBlackGambit]

So what's the universes origin then?? 🤔

[@timhallas4275]

@@iamBlackGambitWhy does there have to be an "origin" ?

[@iamBlackGambit]

@@timhallas4275 because it exists

[@GodlovingAndrei]

Much like soap bubbles in a bath tub. Christ i never thought i would say this

[@Dr.Akakia]

To me BigBang is like a heart beating, means there were more BigBang before ours and there will be more

[@iamBlackGambit]

What banged though?

[@standbyDtH]

"asking what happened before the big bang is meaningless, because time as we understand did not exist before the expansion" That does not make the question meaningless

[@thompson3rd]

Maybe its a bad question, but not meaningless

[@bobbyt223]

If the universe does collapse in on itself, it seems there must be something outside the universe that creates a small amount of pressure so instead of the universe blowing apart, the momentum eventually stalls and it collapses in like a bubble bursting

[@peternesbitt]

It's funny how scientists are fascinated with our past but we really should be focusing on the future. Our planet is on fire, the oceans are over heated, natural disasters are ever increasing, the planet is over populated and nuclear war is on the horizon. Other than that we're fine.

[@rohullahkarimi744]

Simple answer: Nobody Knows and never will and maybe the question is wrong.

[@petrowi]

"when" is a point on the axis of "time". Time has a direction because everything in the near-by universe moves at the speed of light in that (or close) direction. Time, as we perceive it, requires such a direction and that didn't exist until after the big bang. Maybe a simple analogy (and not very correct one) can help visualize the concept: A star shedding solar wind; the solar wind moves away from the star and a very small observer carried by a shockwave in that wind may see their 2D universe (the shockwave front) expand and cool off. They could measure "time" with that expansion - the distance from the surface of the star to a 3D observer. They'd infer there was a "time" when their universe was very small, hot and dense - at the center of the star. That would be a singularity from their point of view, it would make no sense - similar to how we observe our Universe. The main deficiencies of this analogy is the speed at which we are moving away from the BigBang being the speed limit of causality - the speed of light, and that we experience our Universe as 4D; one of the dimensions being one-directional because we can't turn back time, because everything around us travels as fast as possible in roughly the same direction at the speed limit

[@off__world8668]

i bet we'll discover in time that our universe is far older than we think it is .

[@TheLastStarfighter77]

Webb has already proved this 👍

[@ElKabong3345]

It could be that our observable universe came from _one_ Big Bang. However, The Big Bang Theory doesn't really explain where Spacetime comes from, it's an assumption. It could be that Spacetime has always existed, and its Dark Energy is prone to creating Big Bangs of Matter after extremely long periods of time. Example: 10 Trillion Light Years from us could be a way older Big Bang, already going through its heat-death, meanwhile, in another direction 10 Trillion Light Years from us? Another Big Bang could be occurring right now. And we'll never know due to the distances.

[@Folker46590]

It's always existed, scientist have a hard time accepting that you can't have something coming from nothing. They want to believe the Universe has a start, so it can have an end, they enjoy thinking about death. An infinite universe scares them.

[@RadagastBrown420]

Brian Greene !

[@joshuakunda6708]

People are so quick to defend the random creation of something from nothing. But God is where people draw the line😂. I don’t understand why God and science can’t coexist. God said let there be light and the Big Bang happened.

[@theinvestingpalace4710]

Because falling on god as the explanation is unreasonable and “god of the gaps.” Science seeks to find answers, not just say everything was created by god

[@joshuakunda6708]

@@theinvestingpalace4710 so energy can neither be created nor destroyed yet the universe just randomly decides to spontaneously combust into existence? Completely violating the first law of thermodynamics?

[@BL-vd8mb]

Science is the systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation, experimentation, and the testing of theories against the evidence obtained. Without any evidence we can't suggest God as a scientific theory. Now personally I like to believe that there has to be some kind of creator of reality, but the bigger question is, are any of the religions actually true, or is God someone who hasn't revealed himself. I can't say what the afterlife is like or if it even exist, but the idea that "reality just suddenly popped into existence" makes less sense than saying that "God created us into existence". Have faith my friend, i believe that it's completely illogical to believe life came from nothing.

[@paulbunyan9436]

There were many "Big Bangs," but they too distant for our current technology to detect...

[@saurabhmittal8507]

The ancient sanatana dharma saints had already given a precise timeline for these cycles. Its written in the Vedas. The scientists are just beginning to understand this.

[@thekingofmojacar5333]

Very nice video and topic, thanks "Science Time"! What happened before the fairy tale Big Bang? I will tell you the true story now... At the very beginning there was a kind of UNIVERSE BUBBLE EXPLOSION (you can easily imagine this using a soap bubble diagram). In these many different protective plasmas or bubbles, new (baby) universes emerged due to the INFLATION PERIOD (chemical reactions that we already know). This process also perfectly explains the different expansion speeds in different zones of our cosmos. Back in the very beginning, there were smaller bubbles of different sizes that merged into bigger universe bubbles or pocket universes (larger pieces absorbed smaller ones). By the way, it's the same process with galaxies and star clusters... So today, when we look into this gigantic space we call "our universe", we are actually looking into a huge MULTIVERSE or MEGAVERSE that has grown together over time. That's a really nice and realistic idea of the beginning of space and time, isn't it?

[@philipeskelund4433]

Yeah but what was before That?

[@ShobhitMishra157]

Why we always go back to the question of "what was before that"? Maybe there's a type of power which we won't be able to understand bcz it's something we are not aware of at present.

[@WowTowersYi]

now make a video that what was before space

[@RSLT]

Very Interesting!

[@VaRockerDude]

In the beginning God created the Heavens and the Earth

[@petemitchell9996]

Yup. The easiest way for human brain to understand it. Well suited for the average IQ of the human population, and for controlling the masses with religious groups.

[@-.TS.-]

Lol

[@user-em1dg3he1h]

Many of us don't have a problem with that , but curiosity is natural. "The beginning" is not a very specific date , I would like to know when that was. And winding back the "clock" so to speak only gives a starting point for what was created at that event , That also isn't really a beginning. So the question remains , when was the beginning really ?

[@PatientPerspective]

I knew someone was going to bring up god

[@davidbrown8517]

There is no god, never has been, never will be.

[@TheTruth1sPower]

Magnetism=electricty=light/sound at a frequency in that order exactly. What came before that is the right question to ask. And the answer is consciousness, as thats the only possible way for those forces to come about. Don't forget geometry aswel. Geometry is an idea. As that can't happen randomly either. You'd be a fool to think it's random.

[@davidcawthorne7115]

We do not know. 😊❤

[@marvinmartinez5552]

The word was first!

[@EmeraldEyesEsoteric]

In order to remove all the empty space between atoms and create a second big bang where time flows in reverse, I simply have to use the 7 Thunders code words of God, to reverse the Axis of the Golden Ratio and Humanity, which are Thunders 2 and 6. Thunder 2 becomes 8, thereby reversing the Axis.

[@jordannichols8338]

Amen 🙏

[@p3ggy80]

Library. Try one.

[@grasshopperatlaw]

The universe must have repulsive gravity pushing everything outward...but also gravity at the edge of the universe pulling everything towards the expensing edge of the universe.

[@Infinityisone]

exactly!~

[@philipeskelund4433]

The thing about something before the bigbang is a paradox, because what was before bigbang Also had to be created which is infinite. And something Scientific cant be infinite because it wouldnt make sense. Therefore i believe That some godly entity created bigbang. Then you might ask what created god and the answers is nothing, because god is timeless. The problem is we dont know anything about time and timeless or infinite but i Think its the most rational idea

[@theinvestingpalace4710]

I can easily say, “the universe is eternal”

[@anthonydavis2325]

GOD

[@setiandromeda6091]

Where was space or spacetime?

[@timedmonds3]

*If this has happened before* this big bang...and gravity did its job gathering all together again. Scary thought & a infinite amount of times for this to occur.

[@Bassotronics]

I always think of the Big Bang as a sudden burst of charge. Let’s say you have a whole bunch of batteries in the bag. The bag is the dark energy and the batteries is the dark matter. If you keep shaking the batteries over and over and over and over again there will be a point in time that all the batteries will connect with each other and create a voltage and then bam!!… that’s the Big Bang!

[@frederickwoof5785]

The theory of a multiverse would need new 'verses' being created. As each one ends, eventually there would be none left. I prefer the 'bounce' theory. As everything ends and cools to near absolute zero, the universe contracts. Including all the energy radiations. Only a hunch.

[@its_me_roney143]

I actually know that how universe form and how it end

[@tex148th]

What was before the "Big Bang" ? G O D !!! .

[@zozzamozzi]

Why waste time thinking about this. The universe has already shown us its stranger than we have ever imagined, and probably its stranger than our ape brains ever can imagine (even the best of them)

[@therick363]

I can’t tell how serious you’re being or if it’s more a of the cuff type thing.

[@jozsiolah1435]

Galaxies were orbiting the planet located at the centre of the Universe. Its outer ring had such a gravity, galaxies smashed into the ring. The ring was so big, that it nearly fully covered its sun. An alien missile hit the hostile galaxy, it was glowing with light due to its high speed. Parts of the ring went outside of the Universe, and it will reach another universe, destroying their galaxies again.

[@KimDelong-f7y]

I'm pretty sure that the Universe is far older than what they say!

[@GR65330]

I always imagined that there was nothing before the big bang. There was no before: no space no time no dimensions.

[@iamBlackGambit]

If there was nothing before the big bang, What exactly banged if nothing existed?🤔

[@philipeskelund4433]

Okay but what is nothing? And was That nothing eternal? If it was How did the Big Bang happen? That would make it so it wasnt eternal and therefore something had to be there before the Big Bang again a paradox

[@iamBlackGambit]

@@philipeskelund4433 God is the eternal something! Even if the universe came from the big bang it still can't explain life. Life comes ONLY from life.. hence a living creator......God.

[@GR65330]

@@philipeskelund4433Nothing is nothing; no dimensions. Literally nothing. It's beyond description. If you are asking what I think was there before the big bang, I would say God. But this would lead us into metaphysics, which is a discussion that I don't want to get into.

[@petemitchell9996]

@@GR65330That is not science then. That is religion.

[@joeyventimiglia3378]

I dont see how the big crunch could possibly re compact all of the enormous objects that now make up our universe into a singularity smaller than an atom unless a Godly force was at work and as far as what was anything before the big bang is a fun question because we do have endless amounts of proof that we started from a singular point and apparantly expanded outward but what ignighted that infinitely dense singularity is mind boggling and leaves me to almost believe in a creater of all things or some higher power but this is the by far most interesting thing to think of in my opinion

[@KimDelong-f7y]

That's why humans were created. To ponder the unponderable! It's like asking which came first, the chicken or the egg?

[@endtimeslastdays7777]

There was no big bang God alone created the universe and everything else that has ever existed

[@EL_FIN_ESTÁ_CERCA]

The true in: *Genesis 1:1*

[@anunnakimenagerie]

Quarks are made of Universes

[@michaelkewl7056]

Rather than thinking something got created from nothing, why cant we resort to things that always existed & things that came into being 🤔

[@iamBlackGambit]

Huh? Things that just came into being is the same as saying created from nothing lol I don't get your point

[@michaelkewl7056]

​@@iamBlackGambitits basically moving away from traditional view that things should be created to a theory that things always existed which are immutable, which do not follow the create, transform, destroy cycle

[@larryjones2320]

An ENDLESS cycle of BIG-BANGS, and BIG CRUNCHES

[@paulevans8295]

Nothing really is just the absence of something. So it is right to say this cannot be understood as the question about before big bang really is asking what occurs when there is neither nothing or something

[@alex79suited]

Whiskeys yail Mary Jane Rock and Roll. Peace 😎 ✌️

[@darshanpanchal3046]

It just does not matter

[@UncleWally3]

Like me ol’grandma use to say, it’s all fun and games until someone loses their I . . . well, that’s what I heard her say.

[@bobbyt223]

As much as I agree with this theory, for us to think we can understand the entire universe from this Little Rock is like putting an ant on a rock and shooting it with a grenade launcher and expecting it to figure out what’s happening before it lands

[@jordannichols8338]

God 🙏

[@p3ggy80]

Please read a second book.

[@tcuisix]

No need for a god

[@NCfrost82]

Narrator's work made me stay....from the moment u hear it u know the video is worth watching.

[@suecondon1685]

Me too, lovely English accent.

[@corn1134]

Big Bang theory has to be flawed, considering the amount of mass of the entire universe condensed down into one particle. No way possible or for instance the amount of mass needed in to one big ball, still not possible.

[@tomholroyd7519]

7:20 but this isn't the only bubble

[@nvsv_wintersport]

This universe might collapse in the end and then it all starts over again with the next big bang. Who knows?

[@tomholroyd7519]

which leads to the question, what would the earlier cycles of the universe have been like? ALL PROTONS and it collapsed? and time is infinite so yeah what

[@larryleelethbridge8027]

QuantumSingleLarryT came from quantum entanglement,from the from being one with the universe,that creates a wormhole and the days of futures past time paridox,but also because of how time space and reality are one,but not without the whole truth.,and why the stars just dont shine without the one.

[@TheCureThatKillz]

Nobody has an idea what was around before the “big bang”. Come’on!

[@monsterslayer4317]

Always perplexes me to hear gravity described in Newtonian terms in a narrative about Einsteinian relativistic gravity.

[@seanwebb605]

Dinner and a movie?

[@johnpeters5675]

Wow

[@tybeedave]

gravity never pulls, it always pushes, in other words, gravity blows but it doesn't suck. a black hole eventually gets large enough to decay, or, go bang. welcome to the motherverse.

[@PSteve1947]

One potato, two potato, three potato, Earth!

[@michaeltrower741]

Propulsive gravity sounds like an oxymoron

[@theElectricalchannel]

I believe there was a parallel universe, still there, sort a separate reality, can we travel there, no, someday in the far far future, yes.

[@MrJwyne]

Ahhh the universe is a condom 6:31 🤯

[@hollyfut]

Which has torn and run out

[@Yola-zl2tv]

The big bang theory... Wait let me get this straight there was nothing then a loud bang and then there was everything. Cracks me up.

[@justicegluck1301]

That’s why it’s called a “theory” buddy

[@comradechill]

i was there and you'll never guess what i saw

[@Ljordan43]

God.

[@someFLman]

The singularity at the bottom of a black hole could be a "big bang" in the making. The singularity is like an egg and the matter from the universe which fell into the black hole is the...well you get the idea. Black hole is the mommy, universe is the daddy, big bang is the birth and the new universe is the baby, singularity is the egg, matter is the nut.

[@QuranDaily558]

Before Universe There was no Time. Time begins from Big Bang. What spark or initiate big bang? So the answer is God. Quran say : Time it self is a servant of Lord. The sentence explains allot. Quran have allot of information. Quran say : We Created this whole Universe in 6 Days . 7 Skies with no Plillers. There are Angles So Big that you can not imagine.

[@Clearlight201]

Actually for about a million years before the Big Bang there was a big TICK TICK TICK TICK TICK TICK TICK TICK TICK …

[@Bogey1022]

What was before the Big Bang? Well, the bang might have been a really long boom, not a fast bang. And there might be other, parallel universes too. Oh and the universe might be expanding and contracting for like, ever too, with no beginning like ever. Huh? What was the question?

[@colkellahan6676]

Sorry I didn't read ancipitals comment but saying the same thing really. Way to go ancipital.

[@prestonbacchus4204]

What was before the big bang? Other living universes from which our's was born.^

[@stellarwind1946]

What was before the ones that birthed ours?

[@alespidych5311]

​@@stellarwind1946it goes on and on and on.

[@stellarwind1946]

@@alespidych5311so there’s no first one? What started the process?

[@VikingTeddy]

​@@stellarwind1946it's a loop. No starting point.

[@rezadaneshi]

A layman visualization of our universe with a possible parent universe. Imagine a water drain as a simplistic visualization of a black hole. Run the visualization backwards for a simplistic visualization of a white hole in a cosmic entanglement. Every thing has travelled through the drain(center) leading to landing on expanding spacetime. Time is the constant that without it, we can locate the center where Big Bang happened on the space, because we’d still be there. But, time is like the strings of balloons coming together in a knot (Big Bang), leading to space where the strings of time have brought the space expanding forward in all directions. Everything was at one place in one time therefore everywhere was the center of the Big Bang universe at one time. In search for beginning, you tell me where the beginning of a circle is, and I tell you where you think the circle ends. But if you think of the circle or sphere as an expanding circle or sphere, the focal point is the beginning of the circle or sphere and the center at one time. So were every point in the circumference of the circle or the sphere. The center of the universe is a location hidden by time and out of our reach by 13.73+ billion expanding years and out of our visual range by minimum of additional 33 billion light years of expansion, all in a mesmerizing 93 billion light year cosmic visual horizon, which in that picture only, we’re the focal point (center).

[@larryleelethbridge8027]

It was an inflation universe,then the big bang was the transferncence to an exspansion universe,then the final transference into a mutiple big bangs eternaly creating universe,one universe with multiple amunts of life that works in infinate diversity,in infinate combinations.

[@SeaScienceFilmLabs]

Stephen Hawking, a World Famous Atheist; And, One of the Men that hypothesized the theoretical Gravitational Singularity described in the Big Bang Theory: Believed that “Nothing existed before the Big, Big Bang…” Do you believe: “Every Effect has a Cause;” Reader? I do…

[@therick363]

One man’s opinion downs then equal fact of reality correct? Do I think every effect has a cause? I do think so yes. I am open to both sides of the question because that’s how good scientists and philosophers should be.

[@thekingofmojacar5333]

I don´t think that S. Hawking was an atheist, he was always very respectful about different opinions and points of view...

[@SeaScienceFilmLabs]

Thanks for the replies.

[@SeaScienceFilmLabs]

Do You think that an “Atheistic” or “Agnostic” philosophy that includes the “Big Bang” Cosmological Model allows for belief in “Eternal Things?” 🍎

[@SeaScienceFilmLabs]

@@therick363 TheRick! 👋 👍

[@Pogikun99831]

But how is something created out of nothing?

[@Suntzu_saidthat]

It could possibly be quantum fluctuations or from a singularity But it's speculations not facts, well not yet.

[@ENTERESANBIRSORU]

Allah

[@Seven_s7_j]

If we take the theory of bing bang as the origin of universe. The singularity were does this singularity exist? Was it just an empty space. Nothingness. How was the singularity formed? This is so complicated. Logically if something exist it means it should have a origin.but the origin of our universe is unknown. illogically thinking we can just say it just existed. I think the best theory is thinking about before bing bang is meaningless since time we know of doesn't exist that time. everything just started out of nowhere its just infinity or maybe a loop a cycle that just keep repeating itself.

[@silurian9420]

When were apple pies formed ?

[@bipolarbear9917]

It’s a Möbius loop; Möbiverse.

[@profroe]

No

[@therick363]

@@profroewhy not?

[@profroe]

every thing talked about in this video is speculative And a Mobius model is one of them But nothing of the observable universe supports it at all@@therick363

[@therick363]

@@profroedoes anything go against it?

[@profroe]

as a fun idea it's great But in the observable universe much goes against it @@therick363

[@danielchinta4685]

Not big bang god creating gods hands 🙌 Avery things holy bible Isiah 44 : 24 Jeremiah 5 : 22 Jeremiah 10 : 12 13

[@MENSA.lady2]

There are only 2 possivle answers. Nothing or everything. Assuming that the idea of something being created from nothing is rediculios then only one answer left. The big crunch. This only requires that all the mass in the entire universe be sufficient to cause the universe to collapse under its own gravity to create a singularity resulting in the big bang. This cyclic universe is the only one that makes reasonable sense.

[@Naidu-k8m]

Theory begets more theories. Life of man and science expounds daily. With population ever increasing its to be so.

[@davidfalconer8913]

It's life ( Jim ) but NOT as we know it ..... ( possibly true ? ) ............... DAVE™🛑

[@Marc816]

Nobody really knows. And if they say they know, they actually don't know their @$$ from a hole in the ground

[@JayKerchelich]

Sorry I never could see any credibility in the Big Bang Theory. I still don't.

[@El-Ge]

What Was Before the Big Bang? Answer: the Previous Universe.

[@joeyfung-i]

There is no theory that will ever become law on the creation of our universe. It can never end but it has to have a start. Start of what and from where?

[@randylplampin1326]

Before the big bang? The big crunch. Next question.

[@johnb8854]

*No such thing as the big bang.... What has been from the beginning is "The Processing System of LIFE"...* *1st there was Nothing which is Something or we would NOT be able to refer to it, Awoke or became Aware of it self...* *It is "AWARENESS" that was responsible for establishing "The Processing System of LIFE", based on Concepts...*