What Will Rumi Do Now That She Knows The Truth About Hamza? | Ishqiya | Pyar Ke Sadqay | Jalan

[@SomethingHaute]

Thank you sooooo much for all the birthday wishes. I feel so so so special! Thank you thank you thank you for all the love. Love you all! ❤️❤️❤️😘😘😘 -- Hassan

[@nidafareed370]

Hassan many happy returns of the day... i want to tell you something that you resemble my cousin alot... he is 7 years older than me... i always thought your style way of talking everything resembles him alot... and today i was surprised that you also share the same birthday with him

[@sadDe16]

Happy birthday hassan..

[@rubinahussain5377]

You're very welcome and yes you are very SPECIAL!!!! HAVE FUN 🤗🤗🎂🎂🎁🎊💐💐💐

[@syedazainabzaidi1681]

A very Happy Birthday Hassan.

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

Many happy returns of the day, Hassan. You're a gem.

[@saminakhan1456]

Amna's point on Jalan and Ishqia is valid ...we can't compare these two situations...they have different backgrounds/motives

[@vimalasunder7]

An IMPORTANT POINT YOU MISSED TO DISCUSS IN PKS: Washma makes a dangerous statement when she reproaches Sarwar........she says she knew how to protect herself from hisr lecherous ways and she will protect Mahjabeen now from becoming his victim. SO.....didi Sarwar hit on Washma too?? Is that the reason she moved out of the house and preferred to stay with her phuppi?? Does Mansoora have any clue about this?? So, is Mansoora now realising the imminent danger to her marriage and how shallow it is anyway?? Does she regret not protecting her daughter, herself???

[@samarrafaqatali6714]

Bhool gy lagta

[@inabiyahrehman7266]

I think washma meant Abdullah couldn't save him from sarwar and she saved herself by leaving the home

[@khaulahzia3722]

Even though they mentioned it in the intro of the video... They forgot to review at the end.. Was looking forward to it :(

[@aliyabawany2444]

They just skimmed over PKS and called it a drag this time when the episode was marvelous.

[@rubew978]

The writer seems to have left this point open. She could just be talking about how Sarwar was always greedy and had that look. I feel like if he had harassed her maybe she would mention it to Pho, but they’ve left it vague.

[@shaziakhan6473]

Ishqiya is all about revenge, whereas Jalan is about seduction and lust. There is a difference between two plots. We can't compare both.

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

Mansoora is telling Abdullah not to divorce Mahjabeen because of her own selfish reason. She knows Sarwar will leave her for Mahjabeen if Abdullah divorces her. Thousand kisses for a girl like Washma.😘😘😘. Compassionate, intelligent, independent and strong, totally opposite of her mom, who is insecure, selfish and dumb.

[@anumshaukat5095]

I agreee i wish i had read this before i wrote mine😂😂😂😂😂

[@zarataha6083]

@@anumshaukat5095 yes soo true. she is a very insecure needy woman.

[@saherbabar4175]

Yes totally agree with you

[@earthyworthy3444]

How could Hasan and Aamna miss discussing this key point about Mansoora's narcissism and sefishness?

[@burstingburiotos4225]

I don’t think she’s being selfish I think she’s testing out sarwar slowly but steadily she’s gaining confidence to test out her theories one last time. I think this is the reason because she went to pho and she there as well strengthened herself.

[@saraali673]

There is no similarity between Jalan and Ishqiya Agree with Amna's stance

[@humazarar2093]

totally agree

[@forreal2009]

Amna’s review on jalan was soo sensible. Also I understand Minal Khan did a fine job but Itna bhi nahi tha that we need to watch jalan just because she’s doing well. She was just fine.

[@shahshah4681]

Jalan: thank you Amna for those comments. People please boycott stories like these. This is being shown far too much and is so disgusting ! Please dont review this third class story !

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

True. I decided not to watch it knowing about the content. It's sick, shows unnatural relationship. Can't understand how such blatant obscenity was allowed to be aired on television which is watched by families in every household. We already lack morality. No respect left for any relation.

[@umbreenmansoor8398]

Totally agree!! The whole concept is horrible and it’s like planting ideas ...

[@zaaimk]

Defenetly yeh kehna ke acting buhat achi hey doesnt justify the content. Plz boycott jalan and drams like that..

[@shahshah4681]

Mahnoor Qureshi exectly. A nikah is not halal between a behnoi and saali so its kind of mehram relationship in my eyes and for me hitting on you brother in law is as gross as hitting on your brother (God forbid).

[@umaramesh5310]

Mansoora's daughter also warns her that Abdullah divorce will not be good for her marriage. That's why she says to Abdullah that he doesn't have to divorce Mahjabeen.

[@umbreenmansoor8398]

Mansoora only wants him not to divorce because she realizes that her husband is after mahjabeen .. she knows it and she is a loser character!

[@hafsa7284]

Happy Birthday Hassan! This time I agree 100% with Aamna on all points. Nisha can't be compared to Hamza. Hamza has made mistakes, but as a viewer I understand where he's coming from without agreeing with his antics. I also like that his character is consistent. The way he's gone and spoken to Azeem and Hamna - he's not apologetic. Full tashan mei gaya hai. Because Hamna ne dhoka toh diya hai. While talking to his friend he does say that he hopes Hamna and Azeem will find it in themselves to forgive him. But he doesn't actually care about them and their feelings - he just wants to make sure Rumi doesn't find out the truth. But given time I feel he will genuinely come to regret every thing he did because as a character Hamza does seem capable of repentance. All the wrong things he did were out of rage and heartbreak from being cheated on. Coming to Nisha - there's no other way to put it, she's disgusting. She has no history with her BIL. She's after him just because she's jealous of her sister. If a girl does realize she's developing feelings for the significant other of a sister/friend/cousin the only decent thing to do is to avoid the man/put herself away from that situation which is really not that hard in our culture. Nisha's sister is shown to be absolutely lovely to her. I am absolutely repulsed by that show and this sister rivalry trope is one of the worst. Will the world please stop pitting women against each other - especially sisters!!! My bond with my sister and my best friend are the two strongest bonds in my life. It's so sad that TV and movies rarely show such bonds - where are the Desi versions of Leslie Knope and Ann Perkins?

[@indianambrosia4498]

I agree with everything you've said about the difference between Nisha and Hamza. Their situations are not comparable. And I get so uncomfortable watching Jalan, I'm going to stop watching it. Nisha is a disgusting, shameless, greedy and selfish character with no redeeming qualities. Why should we waste our time on such negativity? Honestly, such black characters are extremely off-putting, especially when all the focus is on them. And besides it's frustrating to watch poor Meenu being the target of her own sister's plotting. And now even her husband who had seemed to dislike Nisha from the start is going to fall for her? Unbelievable!

[@DisconnectedandFree]

I think Shafaq should book an appointment with Dr Haris... They both are made for eachother 😅😅

[@wrezzii]

That would be the weirdest crossover .

[@DisconnectedandFree]

@@wrezzii He likes rich, disturbed young businesswomen while she likes men who don't respect professional boundaries. But their kids would be really messed up 😂

[@saniaahmed5881]

That's not even funny shafaq has no comparison with Dr. Haris disgusting

[@deeptimohla8672]

LOL..This is really funny

[@aliyabawany2444]

@@DisconnectedandFree Lol at the kids comment.

[@aliyabawany2444]

Pyar Ke Sadqe 1. Abdullah hasn't divorced Mahjabeen yet. If he had, he wouldn't waste time in sending the papers because the papers were called/prepared before Mahjabeen's father passed away. Watch the next episode's promo, Abdullah is still scratching his head. Sarwar had handed Abdullah a pen but Abdullah never signed it. Then Munshi Ji died, and Abdullah never did the deed. He had pulled out the envelope enclosing the documents at the start of the last episode but then he reminisced about Mahjabeen and Munshi Ji, and buried his face in his palms. Immediately after, Shanzeh called him and asked him to end his existing marriage otherwise she won't sign her contract. 2. Mansoora has the realization about what's going on without a doubt, but her interests are selfish. It's not like she doesn't know Munshi Ji was wrongfully detained. She wasn't going to Munshi Ji to say sorry to him. Please replay that scene when she talked to Lalarukh while traveling to the police station, in the second to last episode so far, to gain clarity. 3. Mansoora had slapped Washma earlier because the latter had talked down on Sarwar, and that tear trickling down Mansoora's nose while recounting the incident in the last episode, wasn't because Mansoora thought she had "overreacted" to Washma. 4. The reason why Mansoora said, "Allah na karay" when Abdullah asked, "What if Mahjabeen is speaking the truth?" was not out of protectiveness for Mahjabeen. If it was, why would Mansoora have led to Mahjabeen's agony by encouraging Abdullah to divorce her, if Mansoora had the guts to oppose Sarwar in the initial episodes? Mansoora sent Mahjabeen away because she didn't want Mahjabeen around Sarwar. 4. When Sarwar said he had better things to do than attend Munshi Ji's funeral, Mansoora said, "Forget about Munshi Ji. That's not what I'm interested in. Why don't you love me the same way you used to?" 5. When Abdullah reiterated that he could not find it in him to divorce Mahjabeen, Mansoora told him to listen to his heart, under the guise of guiding her son to do what's humane. But Mansoora was concerned about Washma's warning in the very same episode (last episode), "Mahjabeen's divorce is going to allow Sarwar to pursue Mahjabeen." If Mansoora's advice was just about sparing a distraught Mahjabeen's feelings by not sending out dissolution papers, we would give Mansoora some credit. Legally of course that would still mean that Mahjabeen was free to remarry anyone. But would a sort of role model, as you guys are giving Mansoora the credit for, tell her son to keep the truth about his divorce status from his new wife to be, knowing it is a deal breaker for her?

[@smilychugh2937]

wow.. You got it so right !! Mansoora is a very insecure, love deprived and codependent character who needs constant validation and due to this toxic codependency she has been letting Sarwar ruin her children's lives. I wish makers of PKS emphasize on this deep rooted psychological issue of Mansoora in coming episodes (so that everyone gets the point the way you explained) that how one's own insecurities can affect/destroy so many lives, like amna said in some previous episode of something haute "kamzori gunaah hai"

[@Mary._.am028]

Hassan mansoora said to abdullah to not to divorce mahjeebenn bcz at the the start of the drama there is a scene between washma nad mansoora where vashma said to mansoora agar Abdulllah ne mahjeeben ko divorce de do to sarwar ka rasta saaf ho gae ga and Amna abdullah said k Mai talaq nhi dena chahta Btw love u so much guys seriously i am not kidding i love u guys so much ❤

[@ambermalik3146]

True and when Abdullah asked her, what if Mahjabeen is right? Now she is thinking about everything. And Munshi death was a big shock also

[@maryamnoor3303]

Yes absolutely! I was thinking the same...

[@gurkiratsandhu5006]

Hassan ji, please don’t compare ZGH to any other drama. To me, it’s the best ever drama to come from Pakistan. Perfect casting, perfect direction, attention to detail, each character individual, and psychologically correct, and.....in short, all is perfect. I’m watching it for the 4th time. It’s true to life even in the small details. I forgive you , though, because you are watching it..😊👍

[@shahneelmehmood951]

With amna I agree, Hamza and nisha both are wrong but Hamza have reason but nisha is only out of jealousy doing this...

[@AA-ne8ov]

I'm extremely fed up of fans continuously only showing Hamna as the culprit in Ishqiya. I remember how in Khaani, Mir Hadi was given so many sympathies despite the person he was. And just because Feroze Khan is a great actor (I'm a huge huge fan btw) doesn't mean his toxic characters need to be justified. According to him(Hamza), he was cheated on, okay fine. That is acceptable. It was his right to react the way he did when he found out. But, everything after that was completely wrong. Marrying Rumi was wrong. Constantly harassing Hamna was wrong. For a moment please forget how great Feroze and Hania's chemistry is on screen because other than that their character's relationship is just toxic and unacceptable. I really think it's time we stop romanticizing such relationships shown in dramas. This whole drama is messed up. I really don't know why fans get so possessive over it. Hamna's not the only bad guy here. Everyone is just so unbearable. This drama is nothing but crap. This whole bad guy being bad 27 episodes and falling far the good jolly girl at the end and changing himself storyline really needs to be put to a stop. I remember being 14 and reading and watching English movies and series based on this but even they've come a long way and now people are sick of this overused storyline.

[@misbahshahid4369]

completely agreed

[@zuniqureshi2241]

Agreeeed

[@amensaeed6738]

Totally agreed

[@sidrakafeel9160]

So true ishqia is very confusing story and its like writer is simply fooling us all by showing hamza all the love ,big claims and craziness from 1st till 19 episode for hamna but he didn't respect her nor understand her situation, as if he was jealous of azeem and might want her back,but suddenly fall in love for rumi just to prove a point that true love is between husband and wife ,hamza should b only guilty and apologetic to all as now writer made hamza total confused character

[@Nimra.Zainab]

Finally someone talked sense👏👏It's high time that our dramas stop romanticizing toxic obsession🙄

[@shanaa1910]

Happy birthday Hassan. In most of the plays male leads are flawed. But Dr Asfandyar and Banister Danyal in yakeen ka safar is good characters. Dr Zubiya also evolve as strong character. So waiting for your review on yakeen ka safar, specifically from 2nd half onwards

[@satisfy123.]

I agree with Amna's point ishqiya is different and jalan is different

[@saranaveed02]

I don't feel Shafaq is bechari. She's independent & strong. Her past has nothing to justify with her immoral actions.

[@azkashams]

Why don't we show characters like Talia murad (a theif and scammer who wants to quit scamming ) Haya Suleman (a girl who is so loyal to her husband even though she has never met him ) Hunain Yousaf( حنین) (A teenage girl who is also a computer hacker )edit or Haneen as i am always confused about the pronunciation These are all female characters from urdu literature Our books have such strong stories why don't drama writers adopt them or at least try to write like that We have talent

[@ambermalik3146]

One is jannat ky patty please tell the other books names

[@azkashams]

Talia from haalim And hunain from namal

[@rafiqueahmad634]

I agree 👍

[@crystalight]

I don't intend to disrespect but just wanna tell you in namal the name of hacker girl was haneen, the spellings are even mentioned in one of the episode.

[@kainatkainat9830]

I wish Nemrah Ahmed writes someday for pakistani television because her FL are always so strong, confident and independent. Her scripts would definitely bring something fresh to the terrible content that is being created in this industry over the past few years (there are obviously some exceptions)

[@fehmidaafaq6153]

First I was hating Alishba in ishqiya but now i start liking her because she make the story move forward. Before ishqiya fight was like school days but now it had become like the war on border between pakistan and india😀. Washma rocked everytime and way she was talking to sarwar😚

[@samaz8384]

I so agree with Amna about Jalan. Itna ghatya script isn't even worth watching. Makes me sick thinking about it.

[@Apassionist]

I have to say Jalan has a certain dark air about it, something like that of '50 shades of grey'... My heart sinks because it is something I cannot come to terms with or understand the need for.

[@kanwalashfaque9571]

Yumna Zaidi and Srha Asghar are the stars of PKS. 😍😍 First time ever, HERO KI BHEN is the real Hero of the drama. 😑

[@288amna]

Hasan, Humza is trying to just ruin Humna as a way of getting back at her but nisha is trying to ruin her own sister’s life for no reason at all!

[@emaanzafar9538]

Mansoora said not to give divorce to mahajabeen because washma indicated that if abdullah divorces mahajabeen so sarwar ka rasta saaf hojaye ga thats why she said that atleast i think,secondly we cant say that mahajabeen’s pregnancy will lead abdullah to reunite with her we all know abdullah didn’t signed the papers and he also confronted his mom saying he wont divorce her!! mahajabeen and abdullah being parents is another element which will lead abdullah to take stand against sarwar to protect his child and obviously mahajabeen overall great reviewww -love 💜 emaan

[@saniak5466]

Correct

[@fatimakhawer1082]

Why did Washma say that she saved herself from savar’s gandi nazar? Did he also creep her out?

[@fj5072]

Fatima Khawer yes thats something I noted too.

[@sabihazain976]

May b

[@mrsusman7982]

She said that because she moved to po’s house, and didnt turn out to be like Abdullah, she saved her sences!

[@saranaveed02]

Amna is absolutely right about Kashaf & Mushk. Kashaf was progressive because her mother gave her the full freedom to speak & express. Her mother was full of support & love. In the opposite case, Mushk is so suppressed, she has now got an open gate to explore the world.

[@aliyabawany2444]

Remember that one time Zaroon gaslit Kashaf because she was too reserved to take a ride from him and sit on the front seat, when most girls in Karachi are good sports, and don't create a fuss about their precious moral values? When Kashaf finally gave in, and she returned home, her mother said something about "muaashra", "ijaazat" and "ehtiyaat" which reeked of "log kya kahein ge".

[@aliyabawany2444]

Kashaf was a different brand of a human. There's absolutely no need to compare the two characters.

[@saranaveed02]

@@aliyabawany2444 absolutely yesssss! ❤️

[@erummunir3494]

Amma is right about ishqiya and also jalan is more problematic as there was no back story.

[@tahirachaudhry3272]

Hassan there is no similarity between Feroze and Emad. Come on Hassan. Stop defending Jalan.

[@mahnoorabubakar1601]

Right

[@meralkhan4638]

I completely agree with you Amna, What they've done with Jalan, they have further perverted the pure relationship between sisters and SILs with BILs. I genuinely love how at least in Ishqiya, Azeem portrays a good brother in law as he genuinely cares for Rumi as a sister. Purely.

[@StarrGazer_]

I loved Mahjabeen's scenes with her mother. Salma and Yumna gel beautifully together onscreen. I have been following Yumna Zaidi as a performer since her early days and I'm so happy to see her evolve over time. Such a fine actress that is finally getting her dues and it was LONG overdue! The other scenes I enjoyed was when Vashma confronted Sarwar. That was outstanding. The dialogues were solid and I really felt the tension. Also, Lala Rukh and Vashma scene was an underrated gem. The USP of the show other than Yumna and Bilal chemistry is the simplicity within the storytelling. And happy birthday, Hassan. Best wishes :)

[@ishiramunshi2663]

Well said 👏

[@muskagul7959]

Hassan's justification of jalan is so annoying 😒

[@AliAnsari71799]

KASHF IS OUTSTANDING......Danish nawaz deserves award for Kashf🙌🙌💓

[@shumailakz4115]

Danish nawaz yasir's brother?

[@fj5072]

shumaila Kz yes he directed it

[@bl3601]

He definitely definitely does!! Hira and junaid as well!!

[@bakhtawarzehra6395]

I rather believe that the scene which hints at Abdullah's and mahjabeen's beginning of intimate relation was beautifully portrayed. We see this kind of direction very rarely where strong messages are given subtly. It is not always important to show flowers, candles and what not to imply that the couple got intimate. We have already seen a lot of their romance in different scenes so it doesnt matter if they did not pin point the exact day when they had physical relationship.

[@mubashirah3575]

I absolutely agree with hassan that azeem is being overly protective for rumi. He doesn't even care about his own marriage let alone his wife. Whereas i also really found the scene between rumi and hamza very cringy. Like who the hell just wakes up and starts blowing whistles😂.I don't even know if it is morning or evening when i wake up.😂

[@hinakhan217]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@ShManzar]

After the day of Shanzay's marriage, which Abdullah and Mahjabeen missed, the dynamics of their relationship did change in a very subtle way. She became more confident about him, and let herself fall in love. He, in private, let his guard down. But soon after he got thrown into the deep end when Shanzay walked out of her marriage and immediately started ensnaring him.

[@kanwalashfaque9571]

At that point I can agreed that Mahjabeen's pregnancy is totally justified bcz they didn't go to shanzay's marriage, and all those things but still I would say that the scenario they have made is not good, Abdullah should know the worth of mahabeen in his life and he should accept her with open heart that he loves her, then her pregnancy and their reunion will be completely joyful and overwhelming for us as well, but "pregnancy ki wajah se qabool karna mahjabeen ko" will be very wrong.

[@aliyabawany2444]

Pregnancy ki wajah se qubool karna isn't the catch here. This isn't the kind of tale where the guy automatically falls in love with his wife for giving him an heir, because that feeling doesn't last. That's why babies don't always fix broken marriages. Abdullah's legal disability to divorce his wife until the next nine months, and his obligations towards Mahjabeen and her offspring following that, is actually what everyone is enthralled about. He couldn't make his mind, right? But now it's simple. If they're doing everything right, Shanzeh wouldn't marry him.

[@ShManzar]

4 reasons nullify divorce: 1. If husband is forced to give 2. If he is intoxicated 3. If he goes mad 4. I've forgotten the 4th, but there's a fourth reason.

[@tayyabanajib1604]

There are girls like MUSHK. I remember in my college and university time when girls that came from very suppressed environments wanted same adventures as other girls. They also went on dates with such losers that you can’t imagine but they felt pressurized by other haves that have nots was just following them without calculating risks and consequences. I belong to middle class and even I felt pressurized by the elite and made mistakes so I wouldn’t judge characters like Mushk. I judge the parents who are not understanding their child and the changes because she is studying with privileged people. They have communication gap and her father is so strict that she can’t even be herself in front of him. And that’s why she isn’t understanding their restrictions and point of view. Parents and children need to communicate well in our society.

[@haniyanasir6887]

exactly

[@faizarajpoot]

About Jalan: I have a younger sister. She always wants same thing that I have, even she uses the things which are are given to me from my in-laws.... I love my sister, and my fiance adore her as little sister.... I can't even think this kind of shit, I don't want to watch this drama for even a minute.... This type of shows are horrible, what kind of thought they are putting in viewer's mind, it's disgusting 🤮

[@ayeshasaulat6451]

You are 100% right ... younger sisters liking or wanting elder sisters things is so normal as the elder ones inspires the younger ones ... they show it so negatively in dramas ..... pure feelings are portrayed so contaminated that one can’t stop but doubt all relations ..... they should not promote such ideas

[@mirzakhalid1338]

In the end,it will be bad for Nisha.so the conclusion of such things is horrible se they are putting in viewers' mind that if someone does like Nisha then it will not be good. But our stupid people don't understand that the conclusion won't be negative

[@faizarajpoot]

@@mirzakhalid1338 but still can't digest.....😐

[@tabinda460]

Kashaf mother was strong and she saw her mother gracefully struggling Mushk mother is struggling but emotionally abused. That's the difference between strong mother and weak mother and how it impacts children

[@sophiaadil4487]

Mansoora said don’t divorce her because mom doesn’t want her to be available for sarwer. Mansoora knows sarwer is after mahajbeen. Why you guys did not get underline mansoora concern?

[@mirhakhan634]

👌👌👌

[@shahmanz]

Iddat of a woman divorced when she is pregnant is till the end of the pregnancy. Its in the Quran.

[@shahmanz]

@@daniakhan9436 No that is not completely correct my friend. Divorce applies, but iddat is until the child is born. Divorce remains valid.

[@daniakhan9436]

Shah Manz oh! I apologize I wasn’t aware of that, just read up about it. Thanks so much!

[@shahmanz]

@@daniakhan9436 May Allah Increase you in knowledge of Deen, and in Amal and Taqwa. Ameen.

[@daniakhan9436]

Shah Manz Ameen

[@fouziaandleeb9986]

Can I ask is there no morality in Pakistan? Can’t they show single drama with moral values so that our society learn something. I don’t understand is it just one topic girlfriend boyfriend breakups and affairs. I am genuinely interested in knowing in Pakistan there’s no more values left in our society. It’s really creativity to cheapness honestly. Used to be Ankage, dhoop kinare, alpha brave and so many with bit of romance without cheapness. If you’re voice is heard then it’s your responsibility to keep demand good dramas for the betterment of our society.

[@ammarasultan2699]

It's me or anyone else thought that Soniya Hussain is doing overacting.

[@izmazahid4334]

Absolutelyyy..

[@saraali673]

Totally..i dont know why people are praising her

[@samarrafaqatali6714]

تھوڑی نہیں بہت زیادہ

[@inabiyahrehman7266]

Yes ,she's doing overacting

[@saqh.4439]

Yes over acting ,too much

[@ShManzar]

The most important statement made by Mahjabeen to Abdullah in this episode is that she is not his beloved/ mehbooba. Food for thought for Abdullah.

[@vishnukumar6706]

Hamza and Rumi are toxic. Sleeping around with a girl and harassing her sister at the same time has no justification despite the back story. Also i really wish makers could show normal relationship dynamics of a couple.

[@amnaamjad6078]

I agree! Hamza is toxic but how does that make Rumi toxic???

[@82mkhan]

Amna's annoyance for Jalan and Hassan's annoyance for Ishqiya... Both are completely on point

[@soofiaqureshi1021]

Hasan bhai, mansoora wants to keep sarwer to herself. Washma has indicated that releasing mahjabeen from Abdullah's nikkah will only allow sarwer to approach mahjabeen freely with no strings attached. Mansoora didnt ask Abdullah to not divorce mahjabeen because she feels guilty its because she is living in constant fear of losing sarwer

[@SomethingHaute]

Good point! -- Hassan

[@hassanfarnaz1169]

PKS: It was not Mansoora's goodness of heart that she told Abdullah not to send the divorce papers. It was what Washma made her realise that once Majhabeen is divorced, Sarwar will be free to do as he likes, that is marry her or whatever. Mansoora is protecting her own marriage here. Also, i dont think div papers have been signed.

[@SABZ512]

Regarding jalan ...... Hassan u r not getting amna's point.... She is trying to say k aisay characters hotay hain but very rare in are society,not in general.... So there is no need to glorify such characters and making dramas on it

[@shaguftanaheed1224]

Amna is right Jalan and Ishqia are differant

[@maryamnoor3303]

Exactly!! Stop making dramas like jalan

[@SomethingHaute]

So it's ok to show a brother in law harass a sister in law on tv? -- Hassan

[@SABZ512]

Not at all hassan.... M not admiring it either

[@mamtajuljannat9892]

@@SomethingHaute dear hassan, no it's not ok, but they were lovers of 4 years before they became bro and sis in law. so naturally some residual emotions are there, but in jalan, nisha fall for the man after he became her bro in law, knowing that he is her bro in law. this difference you can not ignore.

[@aliciawayne]

Amna is absolutely on point about the difference in characters of Hamza and Nisha. A completely different situation-no comparison between the two. Hasan is also right about Abdullah who definitely hasn't signed the divorce papers. Mansoora only encouraged him to not divorce Mahjabeen due to selfish reasons (Washma told her that the divorce would only pave way for Sarwar). Hence Abdullah's surprise as to why his mother had suddenly switched gears. P.S Happy Birthday Hassan! 😃 Looking forward to you entertaining us for many years ahead. And please stop twisting Amna's words 🤪

[@sabikanaqvi981]

31:58 Hassan it's because hamna was Hamza's Past they were in a relationship but on the other hand nisha and his brother in law were not in any relationship 🙂

[@alizzahs1]

Mansoora didnt realize her mistake, she got concerned when Washma warned her at mahjabeen's house that what Sarwar will do if Abdullah divorces her.

[@ainayaseen6429]

One bilal and yumna interview after or before last ep of pks....

[@emaanzafar9538]

yes plis 🥺🥺🥺 SH

[@shabbirahmad7186]

No

[@emaanzafar9538]

Shabbir Ahmad ok🥺

[@gurrmalai]

Kashaf and mushk's parenting is different. Kashaf's mom is strong independent sort of woman where as mushk's mom is very much under her husband's authority.

[@saranaveed02]

Mansoora, as a character, always had the gut instinct that her husband is wrong & unfaithful. She is in denial. But now slowly, she is getting fed up of this fake game. That's why she's now (hopefully) going to take step against Sarwar.

[@Sherookiamma]

Mansoora realizes after her conversation with washma that she is only clearing sarwar’s way by getting mahjabeen divorced. The only reason she is giving abdullah some time to rethink

[@sunalirose6913]

Zindagi gulzar ha is a classical drama. And your comparsion of ZGH with RAaze ulfat is not ok. In that ZGH kashaf shown struggling for her survival in which she have to pay rent, marry younger sisters, afford her own studies. She took freedom with fight and utilize it to solve her life issues. While in RZU mushk has no such worries... her main problem was freedom. She got it and now she is misusing it.

[@nazneenkhan6717]

In Humsafar, Asher didn’t trust his wife despite of knowing her nature and spending so much time with her and then when he got the proof then he trusted her and said such game changer dialogues. And in the same way, in Pyaar Ke Sadqey, Abdullah is waiting for the truth to come up despite of Washma telling him again and again. He spent quite a lot of time with Mahjabeen and he doesn’t know her at all. And will accept Mahjabeen when he gets the proof. We idolise such spineless heroes!😑😑

[@muneezahuda8396]

I know it’s a drama but I don’t agree with Jalan we should promote good characters and writers should take this into account .

[@hafsa7284]

BTW Hassan since you're watching old dramas and are enjoying comparing them to the new ones (I'm enjoying the comparisons too! Totally agreed about Kashaf vs Mushk) Please watch Bin Roye. It makes a delicious comparison against Jalan. Saba and Nisha. Uff. I hope you see this comment and watch the drama!

[@aliyabawany2444]

I completely sympathize with Saba. By a hundred percent. The way she was raised and spoiled, and the attachment she had with her cousin who was like a parent, brother, best friend, grandparent, all in one, when Saba had actual people in her life to play those parts. Nobody taught Saba to navigate her emotions or discriminate between her feelings because pep talks weren't a thing in that household, nobody took her seriously, and Saba was too happy-go-lucky, and entitled to pay any attention to lessons. Even Saba's brother thought Saba had a healthy platonic relationship with her cousin, knowing how immature she is. At the same time I agree that Saba's sister and cousin had a right to make their choices. Irtiza was one problematic character in my eyes, he was too casual with Saba and there were moments I thought Saba was being led on for good reason. He just wouldn't give her space, with all that "childhood friends" drama even after his marriage.

[@hafsa7284]

@@aliyabawany2444 I do too. I didn't care much for Mahira before Bin Roye but Saba - you could feel her heartbreak. I don't want to get into the details here on the off chance that Hassan somehow does end up reading this :p he hates spoilers. I just want to say that despite how much she loved him, what she did once her sister was married to him, her behavior with Irtiza - that is the only right thing to do for anyone in that situation.

[@aliyabawany2444]

@@hafsa7284 Apart from all the times she acted up when a proposal actually worthy of her, came at her doorstep, or someone of her calibre, showed an interest in pursuing her.

[@hafsa7284]

@@aliyabawany2444 I only meant her behavior with Irtiza. As for the rest, like she said - 21 din ki nai, 21 saal ki mohabbat thi. Sabr aane mei waqt toh lag hi jaata. The important part is that as devastated as she was, she never tried to introduce any kind of trouble once her sister and Irtiza were married.

[@aliyabawany2444]

@@hafsa7284 Yes, but she had ample time for sabr to start kicking in. She wasn't going to get seven years when she would be old and grey. For quite some time after her sister's marriage, Saba's grandmother kept putting off her marriage because Saba was young. She could have talked with her grandmother without holding back and cleared her head. When the family thought it was time for Saba and Saba didn't disagree, they helped her look for someone. Irtiza's friend's brother-in-law was willing to keep her so happy, he was broad-minded, cool-tempered, was head over heels in love with Saba, and the two could find some common ground having done the same Masters'. The proposal was blessed by Irtiza and the family. Later Saba had to settle for that other cousin who wasn't properly checked and she was scammed. The only reason Saba was grim during Saman's life and didn't match anyone's energy was that she was pining over Irtiza. Since she kept up that behavior, without giving a reason for it every time the subject came up, her sister connected the dots. Saba couldn't stay that way and expect Saman and Irtiza not to be troubled or affected by it. If Saba had actually embraced the truth, she would have moved on and opened her heart to love again.

[@abdurrahmankhan6660]

PKS : abdullah nai sign nhe kie , Hassan is right Abdullah said mjhe talaq nhe deni , then mansoora said dnt send papers

[@aqsanoran1443]

Hassan watch “Maat” best sister rivalry drama of all times!

[@nabinabinabi]

In Ishqiya's recent promo for next episode they showed that Rumi confronted Hamna and Hamna confessed about Hamza's wrongdoings. And we'll probably get to watch Rumi taking Hamna's side and asking Hamza about the blackmails and stuff.

[@ShManzar]

Divorce is not effected if given under duress or the man is pressured to divorce. Such a divorce is null and void.

[@asmashoainaofan7422]

I want to share an interesting story with something haute i recommended my cousin sadqay tmhry drama that is the real story of famous khalilurrehman she misunderstood with pyar k sadqay after watching half the drama she asked me when will abduallah( who is playing the role of khalilurrehman according to her) become writer......??😂😂 i said you lost the taste of two beautiful dramas😂😂

[@umm8318]

😂😂😂

[@wanderingexpatinturkey7414]

Hhahah

[@meralkhan4638]

Dear Hassan, I just watched the segment on Ishqiya and this is a response to it. I agree with Amna as: In Ishqiya, Hamza married Rumi out of revenge for what Hamna did to him. This relationship was never pure to begin with as it started from a chapter of vengeance. Hamza was explained as a tragic hero and veered into a dark character but I think the plot is trying to reaffirm that he is in fact a tragic hero who has now truly fallen in love with his wife. However, as the beginning of this relationship wasn’t pure, this is why there will be massive conflict. Hamna was aware of why Hamza was marrying Rumi and she CHOSE to stay silent nor further explain her hesitation. Rumi would and will always think that when Hamza was with her, he was thinking of her sister. Rumi loved him and he used her. Similarly with Hamna and Azeem. Azeem and Rumi's realtionship was pure as there was no baggage or terrible intention going in. In Jalan, Meenu and Nisha were sisters and shared everything but Nisha almost always wanted what Meenu wanted. Her ego was satisfied when she being the younger sister was given a proposal from a cousin who is on the path of achieving great things as Ahmer was meant to settle in the UK. Along came Asfi and married Meenu. Nisha started lusting after Asfi AFTER he and Meenu were wed. She is out to destroy this household and created an insane drama to postpone their honeymoon. She is clearly trying to sabotage their bond now that she is in their home. These shows are not the same. In Kashf, Zoya too is a problematic sister as she clearly resents her upbringing but more so her sister as she and Wajdan like each other. Wejdan is a symbol of a good approachable male in her family and being the youngest she probably feels like she deserves a break from her terrible family and live with a more stable family that is helpful and loving. But Amna is right, these shows are terrible as they keep encouraging terrible conflict in the purest of relationships. Hope I made sense up there and Happy Birthday!

[@izmazahid4334]

I just hate every single character of Jalan..Misha kyun is qadar bewaqoof bani wi hai achi trah janti hai apni behn ki badniyati ko phir bhi koi check nhi apne ghr m lakar chor dia..poore 30 episodes viewers ka khoon jalaen ge or last ep me nisha ko kisi mazaar ya dargah me bitha den ge....Totally waste of time....:!!

[@aliyabawany2444]

So true. Going to the Mazaar is payback and cleansing of sins, all in one, for our writers.

[@turtles3258]

Istg azeem is getting more and more annoying, his reaction was over exaggerated and why is he not even a bit concerned about his own relationship with hamna? And just because she was in a relationship makes her character "daghdar"???

[@abdurrahmankhan6660]

MTA: i agree with amna 100% Shafaq is a negative bad character , it annoys alot

[@BilalKhan0710]

I completely agree with Aamna on Jalan. Jalan is a drama with an extremely toxic story line, I absolutely despise it! Ishqiya cannot be compared - Aamna made right points. A request - Plz interview Feroze Khan, about Ishqiya, his thoughts on it and the development but also on his future projects! Feroze Khan is my favourite actor and he is smashing it in Ishqiya 👌

[@shaziakhan6473]

💯% agree with Amina on Jalan. I have same sentiments about this drama. It looks disgusting. We should discourage at all levels. ,

[@ayeshashahzad2449]

When Mansoorah said to Abdullah to not to divorce Mahjabeen that’s because Washma tells her mother that if you’ll force Abdullah to leave Mahjabeen it will clear the paths for Sarwar to get Mahjabeen. So for now we know that Mansoorah is in complete denial of the fact that she knows what Sarwar is intending to do but she’s just reluctant to admit the facts.

[@ambermalik3146]

Amna loved your comment on the pink shade/blush on eyes. Its ture from Hamna to mahjabeen in payar ky sadqy. Now a days these actress think that they look innocent but yes its annoying.

[@rubew978]

Happy Birthday, Hassan! Today I had to sit down and take notes on your video because I wanted to address so many points 😆 Aamna’s roast around 3:32 was so cute 😅 and Aamna is right at this point because we are showing the lives of two different characters. Not all characters are going to be positive and progressive. The point Aamna made at 11:50 is so good, and I hadn’t even though of it. I feel the writers are not trying to justify Shafaq’s actions because they’ve clearly shown through Ulfat’s initial reaction and the Khala’s comments that these actions are not right. What they are trying to do is show Shafaq’s thought process and make her actions understandable. For Jalan, the reason why everyone is against the drama is because as Aamna has said we have seen this trope too many times where a sister is trying to destroy her sister. It’s been shown way TOO much. But you’re forgiven, Hassan, 😆 because you have not seen that many of these dramas and you thought that it would be more about mental issues. I think we cannot say that Minal Khan has not done good acting since it’s because of her acting many are watching this drama and she has not overacted. The difference between Ishqiya and Jalan is not because of gender. There may be a slight bias of viewers towards Feroze Khan, but the stories are definitely different. For Pyar Kay Sadqay I agree with Hassan that they have given enough signs that they are intimate. But Aamna is right that if Abdullah goes back to Mahjabeen without there being a child then it would have shown that Abdulah is only going back for mahjabeen and it would have been better. Now it’s slightly because of the child as well which is not as strong. Hassan is right about the dialogue in the scene between Abdullah and mansoora. They have left it vague whether he has signed. Honestly, Pyar Kay Sadqay does not feel stretched to me cuz of the acting. Aamna did great analysis of mansoora at 42:44 👍 The same as Shafaq I believe that they are trying to show the reason behind Sarwar’s actions but not justify them. This new part is nice at the end. It’s always fun to hear Aamna’s opinion on fashion. ⭐️

[@snehapoddar7876]

Abdullah and mahjabeen consummating their marriage is quite ajeeb in my opinion. The way mahjabeen's character was shown, the type of questions she ofter used to ask, with all of that it seems pretty silly.

[@Alicasweetie]

In our dramas, Both male and female are let's in search of love of their life and marriage is shown as sole purpose of their existence, it must evolve now. We have to find some real talented writers to get good scripts and stories.

[@nmeditz9654]

Next episode promo was disappointing Hamna will play the victim card with Rumi and will get away with it Rumi will insult Hamza infront of his whole family because of Hamna which is very wrong..... If Rumi was gonna fight for herself I would have supported her because uske sth glt hua hai but she will insult Hamza for Hamna which is wrong Hamna is as much wrong as Hamza and she does not get to be victim here rumi fighting for Hamna is wrong because Hamna bhi utni hi glt hai I hope yeh ab saari glti hamza par na lagade and Hamna ko Victim na banade I get it Rumi is an amazing sister unlike Hamna who has only cared about herself since the very beginning but Rumi needs to understand that it was her sister's selfishness and lies that started everything and ruined everyone's life that her sister is not the victim here

[@IDontCare39]

But she was being blackmailed by her ex and harassed. Does that not make her the victim. She's selfish when it comes to her sister yes and maybe also hamza but that was past. Harassing a married woman and blackmailing her like that... Idk but I somewhat sympathize with her.

[@nmeditz9654]

@@IDontCare39 he was just blackmailing her to open the truth if hamna wouldn't have told so many lies and destroyed everyone's life Hamza would have nothing to blackmail her about Hamna has been selfish since the very beginning she has only told lies and only lies then acts innocent so that people could sympathize with her Hamza actions were led by the betrayal he got from the woman he loved which made him blind for revenge hamza was never a bad person the betrayal he got by the woman he love blinded him with revenge making him do whatever he did the only person he wronged here was rumi if she would have fought hamza for herself I would have supported her but hamna is not the victim here everyone around hamna is victim of her continuous lies one of them was hamza he was getting his revenge other victim is Rumi who should not forgive Hamna easily if rumi and azeem are gonna give second chance to Hamna then Hamza deserve his second chance too he was not worse than hamna....Hamna never trusted Hamza even when she claimed to love him she could have told him her problem hamza phir uske ghar rishta lejata but she choose to lie then she lied to her family and Azeem Hamna cheated on Hamza with Azeem she married azeem while she was still in a relationship with Hamza she should have warned rumi but she didn't because she was only worried about herself even Kiran Hamna's friend was more worried about rumi then Rumi's sister Kiran ne hamna ko bola ke rumi ko warn karna chahiye uski zindagi barbaad hojayegi but Hamna answered her saying " Rumi ki zindagi barbaad nahi horhi mero horhi hai” something like that.....Hamna has always been so selfish instead of helping her sister she let her sister's life get destroyed Hamna never became a good daughter, a good sister, a good girlfriend and a good wife she has lied to everyone even before Hamza blackmailed her that he will reveal the truth she lied to everyone where as Hamza was cheated on by the person he loved the most in the world because of her he almost lost his life and was traumatized for weeks before giving his life new meaning to take revenge but he gave up on his revenge when his hatred got replaced by Rumi's love he was quick to put an end to this and tell rumi the truth....even a gentleman like Azeem kept taunting Hamna when she was going through the pain of her Father's death but Hamza's revenge was long forgotten because of their father's death he not even once bothered hamna because he was not a heartless person and he always respected his in laws Hamza is a nice person but a huge incident in his life led him to do some bad things for which he owes many apologies to Rumi but everyone deserves a second chance in their life which Hamna will get and I hope writers don't do dirty to hamza making him the only wrong here And if Hamna was a nice sister even a bit she wouldn't have turned rumi against hamza more and played the victim card when Rumi is pregnant with Hamza's child she would have tried to make things better for rumza but instead like the selfish person she is she tried to defend herself in front of rumi instead

[@nmeditz9654]

@@IDontCare39 oh God I talk alot and write alot don't mind me I am not trying to be rude or anything it's just that I am a writer myself and I study every character of the drama I am watching and well after studying characters of Ishqiya I can understand the reason behind Hamza's actions but Behind Hamna's actions was only her selfishness all I want to say is that they should not potray Hamza as the only wrong person here and Hamna as the victim rumi should fight for herself not for Hamna since Hamna only got what she called for because of her lies I want happy ending for both Couples everyone deserves a second chance Hamza too deserves a second chance like Hamna because in ost we can see Hamna got her happy ending

[@inabiyahrehman7266]

Totally agree

[@sidradawood4380]

Amna: credit lena immodest lagta hai Hassan: tou lage... Me: esa confidence chahiye 🤣

[@vanditavineet1680]

Justification of jalan and it's comparison with ishqiya doesn't make sense ishqiya is bad story I agree but jalan is worse morally and it's not tolerable ab Hassan ko kaun samjayee!!!!!

[@hassanfarnaz1169]

Happy Birthday Hassan. All the best and thank you for providing us great entertainment in these challenging times.

[@user-fk8md4jn3i]

Literally in every drama there is atleast one marriage sequence🙄🤦‍♀️

[@shrishtimishra2724]

Yes Aamna is right there is no comparison between hamza n nisha......hamza was hurt but yes he was not loyal to his wife but at the same time he was not bad to her plus sex without love is so common in pakistani shows this is the only thing I don't like about pakistani shows its like sex is a responsibility or mandatory once you get married

[@tariqaziz8846]

I think yay jo payaar kay sadqay may pregnancy Wala part add kiya this was too much odd

[@sumairamithani1032]

I think miscarriage hoga next esp ma

[@maryamnoor3303]

Yes and rumi's pregnancy too

[@fatemahatim6277]

With regards to Ishqiya, Hamza was just making Hamna jealous and always had affection towards Rumi. And them having a kid is not a surprise. And this vs Jalan is no comparison. Hamna and Hamza have a backstory as against Nisha and Asfi. And with regards to PKS, thank you Hasan for that perspective. Abdullah has anyway decided not to divorce Mahjabeen so it's not going to be about the kid saving the marriage. Loving PKS. ♥️

[@user-mq3gy5nd5t]

Pks is being dragged but Bilal Abbas really honestly said this in his interview that this will happen unlike many of the actors who tried to cover all the errors of their dramas...plus jalan and ishqia both r really stupid n nonsense scripts but still they're getting this much views shows that majority of our audience still likes such disgusting topics

[@subhadramenon2720]

Wishing you a very happy birthday, Hassan. On Kashf, I must say I feel a sense of foreboding every week. Powerful plot, but like staring down a dark abyss

[@rafiaazmat8665]

Please do interview of kashf director

[@sabdullah1979]

Mansoora has now realised that Sarwar is after Mah jabeen, after her daughter confronted her about it. Hence now she does not want Abdullah to divorce Mah Jabeen so that Sarwar would not leave her.

[@imanakhtar5289]

Hassan's analysis of Azeem's reaction to Rumi's pregnancy made me LOL at 6 in the morning lol

[@ammaraumair5912]

Happy birthday Hassan stay blessed and have a great life ahead 🌹💃😎😄such a great show with a great content 👍💕😘

[@vanditavineet1680]

Just saw hello !pakistan best actress lockdown award they have given it to madiha imam over Yumna zaidi as mahjabeen and sajal Aly as aina is completely biased and on what basis I don't understand. Madiha is a fine actress but have to go a long way . According to me star of 2020 is Yumna zaidi now if they don't appreciate and acknowledge her it's lame let me say 😓

[@salehaarif1071]

Loved today’s review !! Because I was missing the rift between u two and I m a satisfied viewer now. On jalan I indoors Amna and yes ishqiya was as ridicules as jalan for me. I totally agree with Amna on her that point that our dramas has spoiled the beauty of relations. Even in PKS. Which is disappointing & it should be stopped.

[@theaddozais3123]

You both should watch Baraat series.. Azar Ki ayegi Baraat Dolly ki ayegi Baraat Dolly Ki aa gae Baraat Takay ki ayegi Baraat Annie ki ayegi Baraat Trust me... It's worth watching...

[@uzmazia6017]

Mansoora might be realizing, but the main reason behind why she said To Abdullah not to divorce Mahjabeen is that she felt insecured after Washma said "Ap sarwar ka raasta saaf karrahin hain" now she's insecure that Sarwar could marry Mahjabeen after her divorce from Abdullah, as she can clearly see his interest in Mahjabeen

[@salwahabib573]

My point of view for Shafaq is simple: HOME WRECKER 🙂

[@countdracula9881]

I don't know why the news of pregnancy comes as a surprise to the characters in almost every pakistani drama. Don't they remember what had happened between them? It's understandable in case of western dramas as they are mostly drunk while doing the 'thing' but I don't get it in case of pakistani dramas.

[@becki7968]

Yup

[@saranaveed02]

In my opinion, Shafaq is a weak character. Shafaq in her past has been in a dark relationship which eventually collapsed her faith in men. Now, when she saw Shahan, madly in love with his wife, she is unable to differentiate between right and wrong. She actually knows that she's doing wrong but she's fallen for this ideal man.

[@sabrinaislam]

Seriously, I am beginning to enjoy these reviews by you guys much more than the serials! :D