Could Starship Booster 12 be re-flown? What do you think? EDIT: Yes, it should be a HIGH instead of a LOW water table!
@slice98Күн бұрын
Yes, it can. After refurbishment that it
@stevengavraКүн бұрын
The refurbishment will be long, but I'm sure they'll use it again
@otiebrown9999Күн бұрын
That is the POINT! YOU NOW HAVE 33 WORKING ENGINES.
@Lu.capuchinoКүн бұрын
no it wont be reused, same way B1019 wasn't
@Lu.capuchinoКүн бұрын
its engines have already been sent to McGregor even
@junkbot931Күн бұрын
I still can't believe we are in the Starship age now. 4 years ago we were dreaming about what a full stack could look like and now it's fast becoming a normal process. It's mind blowing!
@chrischeshire6528Күн бұрын
Remember when a flyover shown a big hole in the ground where the OLM is now. A lot of progress!
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
SpaceX, where impossible is turned into late!
@la1m1eКүн бұрын
It wasn't a hole! They just knew design is bad so decided to dig the hole for water deluge! By, well, Using rocket engines@@chrischeshire6528 😁😁😁
@rishabh12singhalКүн бұрын
Elon doesn't tackle problems which sound doable to humans. 😂
@charlieodom9107Күн бұрын
SpaceX, where Science Fiction turns into Impossible Dreams, turns into "See, I fucking told you so!!!" Elon is, and has been, absolutely wiping the floor with the entire globe's space agencies.
@mattthomas4024Күн бұрын
High water table. Low wouldn’t be a problem. 😊
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Congratulations! You found today's mistake! Thank you for bringing it up! I edited the pinned comment to reflect it!
@Zonal-CheeseO2v4521 сағат бұрын
@@Whataboutit is this a Daily game? i mean it is fun
@user-gv4cx7vz8tКүн бұрын
Ignored several fake update videos this week in favor of WAI. Can't waste time on AI-narrated and factually ignorant videos. Keep up the good work and keep the faith in SpaceX! 🎉
@MrHockeymania25000Күн бұрын
100% agree
@tahjaiesaunders889Күн бұрын
WAI is worth the wait all the others are disappointing
@steveplace1232Күн бұрын
How do you know Felix isn't just a clever bot? Space isn't real, otherwise all the air would leak off the earth duh.
@RekuzanКүн бұрын
Felix and Tim Dobbs from E.A. are about the only sources you can trust these days.
@justinvollenweider5414Күн бұрын
@@Rekuzannasa space flight is pretty good too
@thomasjess6131Күн бұрын
Felix, I can't wait to watch Launch 6 with you live! Your response on 5 was awesome!
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Hey Thomas! I can't wait EITHER!!! Looking forward to watching it together with you!
@ThomasDillon-z6uКүн бұрын
I'm a retired industrial electrician. I've seen construction work in areas where the water table is just below the ground and this is going great. Based on what I know about construction it would be a great idea to give the flame diverter a steel lining. Heavy stainless steel to be exact. This would minimize the thermal shock to the underlying concrete as the water is boiled out of the flame trench by the super heavy booster.
@twooftenКүн бұрын
High water table
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Yes, Sir! I edited the pinned comment! Thank you!
@rwmcgwierКүн бұрын
Felix this is a HIGH water table as the water is close to the surface.
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
100%. This was completely my mistake. I even know this. Puzzled why I said low.
@rwmcgwierКүн бұрын
@ great segment as always
@Jimjon2422 сағат бұрын
@@Whataboutit bad Felix.
@CB-rv9kb12 сағат бұрын
... because you're human
@EvanPang-w4iКүн бұрын
8:30 that discoloration is really pretty!
@davidgraham8065Күн бұрын
augers don't install "sheet piling". Sheet piling is driven or vibrated into place. Augers are usually used to put in piers or case-ons.
@amazeddude1780Күн бұрын
caissons not case-ons
@mikepoe529323 сағат бұрын
Augers are used just to make a hole to dump concrete in for a "footer"
@NoeSchmoeКүн бұрын
I like the rainbow discoloration on the stainless steel, just like on motorcycle mufflers. Also, the handprints were from Iron Man helping with the flight, dont ya know?!!😊
@essiac6697Күн бұрын
I mean who was surprised that it was a Boeing satellite
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Things are closing in on the Boeing Corporation fast. It's a shame, considering that Boeing is almost an American heritage!
@YovanNoelКүн бұрын
😂😂😂 If it’s Boeing - I ain’t going
@theOrionsarmsКүн бұрын
It worked for seven years in the harsh condition of space, SpaceX hardware usually break after few months(like their space toilet on dragon capsule), I think they called that fast turnaround 🤣, well who needs to shit in space, Musk would provide future astronauts with anal plugs and make them a free anema when they return to earth.
@GtTrader67Күн бұрын
@@Whataboutitthey let greed overtake skills..
@gdpirahnaКүн бұрын
I have to wonder how many of your viewers understood your reference to Sisyphus, and how many recognized the name at all. This is a weird mashup of ideas, talking about cutting-edge space hardware, and ancient Greek mythology. I love it. You must be a little of a myth geek, like me. Excellent work. Thank you, Felix.
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
You got me there! My Mom made me read the Iliad when I was around 15 or so. Been hooked since then. Thank you for watching!
@sputukgmailКүн бұрын
I caught it and appreciated it :) Greek myths and space flight have a lot of history - Apollo anyone? :)
@dphuntsmanКүн бұрын
@@WhataboutitYou had a great mom!
@gdpirahnaКүн бұрын
@@Whataboutit It didn't take force for me. I've been nuts about Greek and Norse mythology since before kindergarten, even before I saw Alan Shepard's first launch. OBTW - It's obvious you enjoy your job. Congratulations.
@bobthebomb1596Күн бұрын
This heathen first encountered Sisyphus via Ummagumma.
@JonnoPlaysКүн бұрын
If I wanted to drive down for Flight 6, what's the date? 🤔
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Very losely November 11th. But that will likely still shift! Keep watching WAI. We'll give you the latest estimates possible. Catching a rocket launch isn't easy, pun intended.
@40over86Күн бұрын
Thanks Felix. I always enjoy your reports.
@craigmooring209120 сағат бұрын
A little linguistic malaprop at around 3:00 - The problems you describe occur when the water table is TOO HIGH, or close to the surface, not too low. It is too shallow, but not too low. The depth is low, but the table is high.
@Silverado2021Күн бұрын
They should put “12” in a museum
@FrostiesTanks12 сағат бұрын
522k already, WOW! You'll be at a million before you know it. It has been so much fun watching you and your team grow over the years - thanks for the continued awesome videos. Here's to the future of the channel and community 🍻 Keep up the awesome work Felix and team! -Nick
@drshoe874423 сағат бұрын
You know, if only SpaceX installed the Chop Sticks on Tower 2, they could clear out that water filling the flame trench in a few seconds, plus do a Starship Raptor Test at the same time. 😂
@stevenmcneely1466Күн бұрын
Another great video, Felix. Thanks!
@ysfex3sew14 сағат бұрын
they should do the full suite of pre-flight tests, including a static fire and wdr on the caught superheavy. Just to see if it can take it.
@AdamKadmon-cg5qsКүн бұрын
While I greatly appreciate all the work you and your companions put into your reports, I would love to see an episode, after the next Starship launch of course, that goes deep on everyone else EXCEPT SpaceX. Not hating on them! Merely want to get a broad view of the space travel industry at the moment.
@andrewturnbull789Күн бұрын
Great content as ever, love what you do Felix. So impressed with what you do and how the channel has developed over the past few years. Just to note, CFT piles are not sheet piles. The flame trench has sheet piles around their perimeter, they interlock and are driven into the ground to provide a curtain. CFT piles are auguered boreholes filled with concrete with or without steel sleves or rebar.
@davidferdig9456Күн бұрын
Is it a high water table. Meaning the ground water is close to the surface? If it w was a low water table you would need to drill down deep to get to the much lower water table. Otherwise you have a high caliber of a show!!
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Yes, Sir! My mistake! I edited the pinned comment to reflect the mistake.
@lanav967918 сағат бұрын
Channel Metrics are Super Dope Dude ! So Cool !
@johnpaulchimebere3196Күн бұрын
Happy new month everyone 🎉
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Happy new month!!!
@johnpaulchimebere3196Күн бұрын
@@Whataboutit 😮🤯
@zedrocky652910 сағат бұрын
“One second you’re the new marvel of space flight the next second you’re just taking up space” Perfect! 11:11
@MrBiloxifiremanКүн бұрын
When I was a kid (35 years ago) we played a RPG named Rifts. It was Speculated that 1 of the reasons people could no longer go to space was because of all the space debris would shred anything that was in orbit. I truly hope that Fantasy prediction never comes true.
@rongray8934Күн бұрын
@@MrBiloxifiremanif it becomes more of an issue a solution will be implemented. Like we are cleaning the environment here on Earth now. We learn from our mistakes. I played Traveller as a child. Still have most of the materials. Both great games.
@1mariomaniacКүн бұрын
Kessler Syndrome.
@denysvlasenko186521 сағат бұрын
It's a fallacy. Once the density of debris pieces become high enough that collisions happen often ("every hour rather than every 10 years"), the rate of collisions will start to increase even more, on a scale of months, until all debris (and anything else) is pulverized to dust - submicron-sized particles. And here's the difference: these particles are far more susceptible (compared to large pieces) to light pressure, solar wind pressure, Earth magnetic field resistance, etc - so they will be deorbited or blown away to interplanetary space in a few years, tops. Which will clear orbits, thus "people could no longer go to space" can't happen.
@davidlee855118 сағат бұрын
Felix, we do like your presentations. Most people know when someone makes a “job” look easy is because it is someone with talent and a good work ethic to get it done with high standards! We do look forward to your presentations. I am sure your staff is a great help ti y you . Thanks for all you do.
@lanav967918 сағат бұрын
Love the Red Line Heli ! So Super Cool ! FanDamTastic !
@wadewoehrmann2835Күн бұрын
Water table is not "very low" but rather very high - like just 8' below grade...
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Absolutely. 👍
@JurassicJenkins15 сағат бұрын
Hi Felix, awesome vlog as usual! Love your enthusiasm 🎈Do you happen to know what happened to the space cowboy that hitched a ride in the early years?
@andrewcastiglia9548Күн бұрын
Big question, if the central raptors have start up gasses why not just start them first and use their turbine exhaust to spin up with outer 20 boost engines? Eliminates the need for the raptor QD and gives you a passthrough to be able to push a "forced" ignition of the boost engines if they give tou trouble.
@Вова-ц4м1иКүн бұрын
Американцы молодцы ракеты штампуют как горячие пирожки!
@High.Desert20 сағат бұрын
you are welcome to join the party 🥳
@emisasian19 сағат бұрын
I think you mean to say South Africa.
@GeoffHamilton-i5t12 сағат бұрын
Thanks Felix, Love your skits
@bigroundwatermelon6456Күн бұрын
They need to develop satellite harvesting, the amount of material just floating out there must be worth millions upon millions.
@rishabh12singhalКүн бұрын
Yes. This is one of the unsolved problems of space but in my mind that problem is solved once orbital refuelling is solved. Because the theory is to catch it by matching speed. And reusable refuelable rockets can just carry a peice of foam or something and open the doors to catch it and move on to the next peice. Bigger peices, peices that create risks first... then all the rest... few at a time... will take years to complete. But sounds like doable for humans once elon solves the bottlenecks like reusable and refuelling in orbit.
@maxdude4645Күн бұрын
Did it explode or was it destroyed by Russia or China???
@seancollins9745Күн бұрын
@@rishabh12singhal it's pretty much solved and starship being stainless steel is a huge help in resistance to ballistic damage from captures
@lcstarchaserКүн бұрын
Recycling the materials will be a tedious and expensive process once the pieces are back on earth
@mglenadel21 сағат бұрын
Not that much. It's not the materials that make them expensive, it's getting them up there. There's probably more 'valuable' metal in one percent of the world's bicycles than in all the satellites ever launched (pulled straight from my keister, be probably not too far off).
@lcstarchaserКүн бұрын
I want a tshirt with a mechazilla holding a starship and booster in each hand like a kid playing with toy airplanes
@DejaVuDejaVuDejaVuКүн бұрын
So Happy SpaceX Exists :)
@joshma3305Күн бұрын
Smashed the like button, broke my phone screen, thanks Felix.. 😂
@lord1toddКүн бұрын
Love your channel/content !
@michaelreid2329Күн бұрын
My god, the astronauts that accompanied the booster on its test flight and demonstration catch landing left behind hand prints from where they jumped out of the ship! Amazing.
@Andreas-gh6is6 сағат бұрын
I hope they can finally pick up some pace. The slow progress on Starship is already delaying Artemis III.
@guypehaim1080Күн бұрын
For debris retieval, I could see using two StarShips, one on either end of a huge net flying trough the orbits in question and scooping up all the pieces parts.😊
@JonnoPlaysКүн бұрын
Watch all the comments about the low water table mistake make the algorithm blow this video up. Bet bet
@tonywesthill7701Күн бұрын
The term water table is often misunderstood. It is the TOP OF the water, the top of the soaked layers. It is not itself a 3 dimensional layer. People often think it means the zone of saturation, where pore spaces are usually filled with water. If someone said that the layer of water-filled sand, gravel, muck, mire and stuff goes very DEEP, it can be understood why Felix referred to something related to groundwater as being LOW.
@realulliКүн бұрын
The location of that fractured satellite as well as its movement should be fairly well known. With and explosion, all the pieces got a kick in a somewhat random direction, but after that, they were all just coasting. That means, they're all on separate orbits, with one interesting peculiarity: these orbits all intersect, exactly in the location where the satellite used to be, the pieces just take different times to circle Earth, but all the pieces fly through that location. With these two pieces of data, it should be possible to build something t catch all the pieces. It just needs to hover in that location (well, actually, not hover but assume the late satellite's orbit and after a while, all the pieces should show up and be able to get collected (and not even with all that much Delta-V, since all the energy they got that moved them to separate orbits was from the tanks of the satellite. E.g. a large block of very low density foam should do the trick - catching everything by removing all the relative speed these pieces had. Any objections/comments/citicisms of that idea?
@mikepoe529323 сағат бұрын
Magnets work in space they could simply place one in or it and move it to Intercept all the pieces especially if it was a supercharged electro magnet...
@realulli22 сағат бұрын
@@mikepoe5293 Unfortunately, I assume most of the satellite pieces will be non-magnetic. Just about all the ferromagnetic stuff is just too heavy for use on spacecraft. Unless you're named SpaceX, of course. ;-)
@animal9432Күн бұрын
The quick reference to Sisyphus will be lost on many...
@Douglas_H-Can6 сағат бұрын
You mean a high water table, not low. High means it’s close to the surface. Low means it’s way below the surface.
@ROGU3L3PHANT22 сағат бұрын
It will be so cool to see them try and catch a starship.
@brenden-petersКүн бұрын
Excited to see Boeing workers successfully striking! SO many of Boeing’s issues across all their divisions have been flagged by workers who were ignored or told to keep quiet and keep working. When the workers are respected, we all get to see safe spacecraft that actually work, and that’s pretty cool. This space flight enthusiast stands with Boeing labor ✊
@stephenwise363517 сағат бұрын
🤘 respect from Manchester (UK) :)
@lanav967918 сағат бұрын
Super Cool ! Wow !
@tonymack5162Күн бұрын
Felix, love your channel so much but I think you mean a High Water Table and not Low. A high water table is just below the surface. A low water table is much deeper below the surface and usually doesn't cause a problem.
@Nathan-vt1jzКүн бұрын
Boeing isn’t merely on the struggle bus, it’s more like a train where there’s always another car.
@Logan4661Күн бұрын
What if Boeing built the struggle bus? If the struggle bus doesn't work, is that a good thing, or a reeeally bad thing?
@Nathan-vt1jz20 сағат бұрын
@@Logan4661 It would cost billions of dollars, the doors would fall off, and it’d eventually explode into hundreds of pieces. 😅
@smorrowКүн бұрын
Starbase with a tilt-shift lens is something I didn't know I needed
@texan-american200Күн бұрын
It's acquired a very nice patina from its use.
@j.w.salphabet2096Күн бұрын
That is a high water table, not a low water table. A low water table would be that you can dig deep and not hit water. I always love your videos and always get a lot of insight from them, thank you for all the hard work you put in.
@KruellNationGamingКүн бұрын
Actually, the proper term is the water table is extremely high... You want a low water table because it means the water level is lower or farther from the surface.
@mikepoe529323 сағат бұрын
Booster 12 needs to launch again to test "reusability"....or put it in a museum somewhere since it's the first to go to space and return in 1 piece by being "caught"....
@TolisOnLine23 сағат бұрын
All surfaced of OLM subjected to thrust blast could be covered with these hexagon heat tiles as used on the second stage.
@michaelchartier405616 сағат бұрын
Could they add a system on the tower to help boost the booster off the pad and up the tower like a slow compound bow. Might Build speed and momentum quicker and also save on fuel
@CrowtalkingКүн бұрын
Great episode!
@Only1clarkeyКүн бұрын
Hi Felix. Can you explain why the ship disconnect arm needs to be connected at launch? Why not just fill up and disconnect prior to take off?
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
That’s what they do. It is disconnected shortly before lift-off… but it can’t retract far. A good improvement for the future would be to either make the rocket turn quickly after lift-off or to redesign the SQD to be able to retract further or be better protected. A protective hood could do this.
@Only1clarkeyКүн бұрын
Thanks. I thought that it disconnected at launch. Surely they can design an arm which can spin or articulate to the opposite side of the tower? I'm not criticising them though. SpaceX rock. Love the channel btw. I never miss a show. You are my fave youtuber. Keep up the good work 👍@Whataboutit
@EddieVieraКүн бұрын
Love your show Felix you really rock 😊
@kevinvanhorn2193Күн бұрын
No, the problem at Starbase is that the water table is extremely HIGH. A very low water table would be ideal.
@UnmannedairКүн бұрын
I honestly cannot fathom why on Earth they would use a solid material floor under the launch mount. Why not just have the lunch Mount over a pond? Then you only need to drain the pond when you need to do maintenance. That can be done pretty quickly
@Lu.capuchinoКүн бұрын
lmao mr.comment section engineer knows better than SpaceX
@amptunesКүн бұрын
Interesting idea.
@HankScallyКүн бұрын
A pond would direct all of the thrust produced by the engines right back up into the engines, assuming a bowl shaped depression.
@taavetmalkov3295Күн бұрын
great video! do you know is there a planned space tax for all who send stuff up there so thate the resource can be used to clean up the floaters ?
@danielward998322 сағат бұрын
Hey, there should be fire hydrants on the Crain to prevent fires
@robwideman2534Күн бұрын
Great video, but I dont believe continuous flight augers are used for sheet pile installation.
@0range.19 сағат бұрын
Pretty soon we'll be talking about who's going to mars next. 😮 Can't wait.
@holographic_redКүн бұрын
Next week: This Is Unbelievable !!! Just joking, thanks Felix! ♥
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Wouldn’t that be true, though? I still can’t believe it and I analyse this stuff for a living! SpaceX is crushing it! 🤯
@holographic_redКүн бұрын
@@Whataboutit Totally agree!! So many have said they where shaking when they caught that booster and it's true! Every launch i'm just amazed, It's still insane they caught that thing right?!
@fettmaneiii4439Күн бұрын
jesus I got jumpscared by the "chop chop!"
@douglasbuchanan8722Күн бұрын
The “Sisyphus” flash @ 3:12 was very funny.
@kevinim30021 сағат бұрын
4:07 i predict some water deluge to be included with the QD assembly. 😎
@michaelchapman1502Күн бұрын
Uhm, I think the water table is extremely high. Very close to the surface of the land. imho.
@richardzeitz54Күн бұрын
I think you meant the water table is high. It's close to the surface - that's high. Deeper would be low.
@jasonmarkwell8593Күн бұрын
BOEING followed the GREED instead of the American NEED. DUMB 😆
@stevengavraКүн бұрын
You got a point, they should focus on fixing their airplane flaw instead of jumping into the space industry
@jasonmarkwell8593Күн бұрын
@stevengavra or atleast do a better job at bribing politicians. If the public knows, then boeing wasn't paying enough. Lol
@i-love-comountains3850Күн бұрын
@@jasonmarkwell8593 That is absolutely the wrong lesson to take from the incident. Wtf?😂
@jasonmarkwell8593Күн бұрын
@i-love-comountains3850 I know right. But who am I to judge our corrupt political/corporate class. Well other then at the ballot box which for some reason they seem to hate. Can't understand why . . 🤔 😆
@andriandrason1318Күн бұрын
@@stevengavra The Lunar Roving Vehicle (LRV) or Moon buggy, S-IC The first stage of Saturn V was made by Boeing and much more.
@MudGuardian23 сағат бұрын
Broke my screen smashing that like button
@G.R.-lq7mpКүн бұрын
Hey Felix.. Thankyou from a UK, fan.. Been following you for over two years now.. I noticed, that when I "JOINED," Your channel, when I returned, after paying and filling in my details, etc... My "SUBSCRIPTION," to your KZbin channel, had been, mysteriously...!!?? - CANCELLED.. Just my observation... I wonder, if other channel members, have had a similar experience..? - Thankyou WAI...
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Hey! Thank you very much for the active support and all the best greetings to the UK!!! Yes, that's an old and very common problem. Everytime I mention it on an episode, though, people accuse me of lying and trying to make them subscribe with a "cheap reason". Yep, it is real and yep, it does happen all the time. And on top of that, nope, KZbin doesn't fix it.
@JeshuaAdornoКүн бұрын
Production should’ve been designed as an assembly line. Weld from top to bottom “mecazilla chopsticks “ to support movement.
@bogususer2595Күн бұрын
The have an overhead or gantry crane for the lifting of the Starship sections. Plus it is more flexible than the "chopsticks".
@thecaribbean861523 сағат бұрын
Just FYI: Red color is for "Remove before Launch"
@KevinTheCaravanner22 сағат бұрын
What makes a block 2 starship different to block 1 and not just an iteration of block 1?
@simongeard482413 сағат бұрын
It *is* an iteration on block 1... just a big enough one to be worth designating. But it's mostly an accumulation of small changes... e.g. the block 2 ships have the flaps relocated slightly to shield them more effectively during re-entry.
@jorgealbertomartinezortiz374Күн бұрын
I’m amazed with SpaceX pace of development 😮
@juju_buzz2396Күн бұрын
i mean when workers are being exploited, it makes development faster and cheaper
@jorgealbertomartinezortiz374Күн бұрын
@@juju_buzz2396 You know that people can quit anytime, right? It's not the 19th century anymore.
@juju_buzz2396Күн бұрын
@@jorgealbertomartinezortiz374 Quiting after they have been injured or after they died at work is too late i think
@bogususer2595Күн бұрын
They're mostly late on all milestones. After they get a payload up, they need to work on tanker refueling before they try for the moon landing. I'm amazed at how long it's taking.
@JordanKennedy-e5uКүн бұрын
I am seriously scared of space debris. It’s like burying a nuke with a random timer. Unknown, extremely dangerous, and can last for hundreds of years. We might not see the consequences of this, but maybe our children will or their children. It’s very scary.
@jklein17Күн бұрын
That would be a high water table, not a low water table.
@rudivandoornegat2371Күн бұрын
I'm eagerly waiting for the first ship with raptor 3 installed as well as the first sighting of block 2 Boosters (with integrated hotstaging ring).
@Lu.capuchinoКүн бұрын
first R3 vehicle will most likely be S33
@mikesbasement695422 сағат бұрын
Given that the starship is expected to refuel from the bottom, why the heck don't they just run extra pipes up inside the booster to the ship and get rid of the sqd all together.
@Nuke-MarsXКүн бұрын
do we know when spacex will use the raptor V3s?
@shockers1251218 сағат бұрын
Feels like yesterday we had a concrete tornado 😅. The next 5 years will be exciting
@DysfunctionalParrotКүн бұрын
Haven't been this excited about space travel since I was a kid.
@flo7165Күн бұрын
When considering the new tower design, i still feel like that if a starship system explodes pre launch, then all water tanks are going to be destroyed. And the tank far that has been in your rendering
@elysium4775Күн бұрын
This may sound like a dumb question, but how come SpaceX didn’t make the first orbital launch mount like the one being made for the second launch tower?
@simongeard482413 сағат бұрын
The same reason they didn't launch the first Starship test article to orbit - they hadn't yet learned what the final version needed to look like. Because the launch pads are iterative design, no less than Starship itself... they've done enough launches now to know what worked well and didn't work well with the first iteration, and can now design a better one.
@sagecoachКүн бұрын
Geostationary satellites are all going the same speed in the same direction, so they may eventually bump together; Debris from an explosion could go any direction with a very low chance of interception of a geostationary satellite.
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Excellent observation but not entirely true. Debris clouds always have the tendency to form rings. Those rings end up directly inside GEO. They block a considerable area and can absolutely collide with other satellites. Sad but true. I had a long talk with the Director of OPs at ESA’s orbital debris tracking department. That talk was very enlightening! 💀
@hifex_4275Күн бұрын
@@Whataboutit How safe is it that the satellite blew it self up? I wouldnt wonder if it was a collision with a small rock. A fist sized rock should be enough I guess. Unlikely to happen but we have so much up there for so long that it is only a matter of time until it happens.
@sagecoach6 сағат бұрын
@@Whataboutit That had to be an interesting conversation. Gravitational attraction is so limited between objects but planetary rings are real. I consider each related object to be in a near but different orbit with little speed difference, like docking. No question a very few random objects cross GEO at speed in every direction.
@robertmorgan9112Күн бұрын
I’ve been watching you forever , but I can’t subscribe because KZbin says that I can’t “double subscribe with notifications on “! I tried to persuade them with no luck!
@WhataboutitКүн бұрын
Thank you, Robert! Keep asking! 🤪🙏❤️ I really appreciate your long lasting viewership!
@MCOATCRetiredКүн бұрын
Felix. Question for you. The Crew Dragon as well as other human carrying rockets have abort systems to keep crews safe during a launch failure. Maybe I have missed it but I don't think there is one on the Starship. That would seem to be a requirement for any human rated Starship.
@dphuntsmanКүн бұрын
There isn’t a human-rated Starship- for launch from Earth- yet.
@admarsandbeyondКүн бұрын
There are no official requirements from the FAA or any other regulatory agency for human rating. NASA has some requirements for their own astronauts but these are arbitrary, e.g. the Shuttle also had no launch abort system, yet they demand one form Dragon, or the SLS has a LOC of 1 in 70 while they demand from Dragon a LOC of 1 in 270 (for the entire mission, including months docked to the ISS, many thousand to 1 LOC for launch)
@simongeard482412 сағат бұрын
There's no *requirement* for an orbit system - that's merely one way of achieving safety, by accelerating a small crew capsule away from an exploding rocket. But you know, rockets don't actually explode very often - in seventy-odd years of crewed spaceflight, there's only been one case where an abort system has been used to save a crew - which is the same as the number of cases where people have been killed by an abort system triggering unexpectedly.
@scottpostma63927 сағат бұрын
Do you mean "high water table" makes buliding underground difficult? I think you do.
@tonyug113Күн бұрын
Must admit not entirelky convinced by the tiling, i mean Stainless may not melt in the flow But i doubt you want superhot steel heating up the contents of the tanks -- even if they technically not used --- might go bang.
@rooscowКүн бұрын
It's a "high" water table measured as a relationship with the surface of the topography of the surface of the ground. It's a common misinterpretation.
@24escaladeКүн бұрын
I wouldnt be surprised if they build a Mega Mega bay where the high bay is and the medium bay was that was torn down a while ago