"When She Was Bad" Reaction | Buffy The Vampire Slayer SEASON 2x1 | First Time Watching (Commentary)

A new season and a new...Buffy? My review for the opener of season 2.
Join this channel to get access to perks ►
/ @tyleralexander
Join my Patreon ► / tyleralexander
Follow me on instagram ► / thetyleralex
LINK TO MY BOOKS ► www.amazon.co....
Follow me on Twitter ► / thetyleralex
Follow me on Tiktok ► www.tiktok.com...
Follow me on Twitch ► / tyalexxx

[@TylerAlexander]

KZbin memberships are now live on my channel for anyone interested. Same tiers as Patreon except there are special badges and emojis you get over here for joining. Early access at tier 2, and a brand new tier I've introduced as of this change called 'Slice of Life' (tier 3). This'll be more personal, less polished content like games, Q&As, out of theatre reactions etc. If you're looking for any more info feel free to reply to this comment, and to look at the badges etc click on join and they'll come up. All that said, hope you enjoy our return to Buffy! ❤

[@gehrehmee]

The real "monster of the week" was the PTSD we made on the way.

[@chelsjones]

‼️ VAGUE SPOILER ‼️ literally season 6 lmao

[@bethanyd6701]

​@@chelsjonesI'm late but this is genuinely so fucking funny to me lmao S6 hits different when you're an adult fr

[@Scarygothgirl]

What makes Buffy so great is the way it combines it's fun demon of the week stories with consistent character focused arcs and growth.

[@jennarobinson4136]

Buffy's definitely up there as one of the most rewarding shows I've watched for the same reason you were mentioning here: there are actual consequences, both practically and emotionally, for the actions and choices characters make. Nothing is skipped over or ignored, and characters are allowed to react to the things that impact them in a way that makes sense. So many shows skip over or just fully ignore things that in the real world would really impact these protagonists, just so they can conveniently move things along. But I think most great moments in shows are moments that feel messy and real, and Buffy's great at that, especially from this point onwards. Looking forward to what you think of the rest of the season!

[@Ri-Lizzie]

Yes! And I would add that Buffy is not perfect. Her flaws are on display and depending on the episode/season become larger issues for her to work through. She is an icon for character.

[@bashby97]

You probably realised this but the "I may be dead, but I'm still pretty" line is in the recap to remind us all she died! Also fun fact (that you also probably know by now) but Buffy was created as a kind of mid-season fill in show which is why season 1 is shorter and less serialised

[@Gaydunaway]

For this era of television, even this cursory discussion of trauma was pretty groundbreaking. Even though it mostly resolved, it was more than we got back then. I especially liked how they played with the supernatural explanations for her behaviours, as the supernatural in this show is often a metaphor for real life problems, but to have it be explained by trauma is a wonderful choice. Probably my favourite opener.

[@sherrysink3177]

Willow: Why else would Buffy be acting like such a B-I-T-C-H? Giles: I think we're a little too old to be spelling things out anymore. Xander: A 'bitca'? Still one of my favorite Xander jokes, no matter how silly. 😆🤣 I still use the word "bitca" to this day. The bummer is, most of my friends and family haven't seen Buffy so they don't understand the joke. *sigh

[@psychomagicshop]

The trauma isn’t instantly healed but she needed to release tension into something that felt like a source. Ultimately it’s her role that traumatizes her and that is something she never quite shakes.

[@Cyrinil142]

Oh thank god! i was starting to dread that this series had been cancelled. Season two has so many episodes that Tyler can really sink his teeth into

[@killianlpc]

A great opener from S2 Buffy obviously suffering from PTSD, and taking it all out on her friends. Interesting after Buffy sexually teases Xander on the dancefloor, and then Cordelia even tries to intervene referencing Buffy to Joan Collins as a type of 'Uber Bitch' because she knows that behaviour herself. All's well at the end and a bit of comic relief with The Anointed One ' I hate that girl' Another well written episode exploring psychological illness and how it can affect others. On re-watch you can notice so much more in each episode that was missed first time round. Good reaction again.

[@Teeklin]

To your point about Prophecy Girl and her support system...that's what the series is actually. There have been endless generations of slayers going back thousands of years, why do we see the story of Buffy? She's the first one who didn't follow tradition, to be alone. In the first episode Giles talks about keeping her identity secret, not telling family or friends. That's every Slayer until Buffy and that's where we come in, to see what happens when the superpowers in a fight between good and evil go to a girl who doesn't just do what she's told. It's a larger allegory for feminism and breaking out of traditional gender roles, and over all seven seasons you'll see how they handle that theme and the challenges that arise. But at it's heart, Buffy is the story of a girl discovering the power she has inside herself and using it to stand up to forces from all sides trying to tell her what to do. And you see the consequences of doing that many times, good and bad. Love the content man, really one of my favorite reactors so fast after finding your channel with your sense of humor and insights. Keep up the great work!

[@AnatoleVGC]

Im so glad you are back with Buffy. Your takes on the show are so unique that I cant wait to see what you think of this show overall

[@lepidoptera7856]

You impressed me with your insight re Buffy overcompensating for her dread about coming back to slaying. I never saw it that way-I always read it as her craving violence/action after a long stifled summer of not processing her feelings, and she finally has something to take them out on-but your read makes way more sense to me. Of course she wouldn’t be ready yet to jump back into the thing that killed her, sacred calling or not. She is, as was made clear last time, only sixteen years old. Bonus points for rolling your eyes again at that inane “I’m still pretty” line 😂

[@Nexusofgeek]

I don't see it as that inane, I think it was a way for her to put down the Master in her own unique way. She was effectively saying, yea you drowned me in that muck, but I am still wearing my special dress and I am still pretty

[@tornadochaser2457]

@@Nexusofgeek If she felt that way, she would've said it. My opinion - She was thinking about cupcakes - They're tasty, and this doesn't require exposition.

[@lepidoptera7856]

It’s hard for me to separate certain lines of dialogue from the adult man who wrote them for a teenage girl to say. And while this line obviously resonates as powerful to some, to me it just undermines an already powerful moment. This girl is back from the dead. She was treated like trash to throw away by a master vampire, and here she is, still standing and not even scared. (Or at least hiding it really well.) I feel the rest of the scene (“You have fruit punch mouth”) communicates that beautifully without shrinking her badassitude down to the way she looks. Doing so just feels very “written by a man.” But I’m not trying to argue or change your mind, just explaining why I feel the way I do about that line. 😅

[@Nexusofgeek]

@@lepidoptera7856 fair enough, was still a good fimale though

[@lepidoptera7856]

@Nexusofgeek 100% agree!

[@HuntingViolets]

The band in this episode is Cibo Matto (Italian for "Crazy Food"). At one point, Sean Lennon was one of the members.

[@myeckwaters]

Yep, he was onstage in this episode, playing bass. For some reason he seemed to be brightly lit in blue.

[@HuntingViolets]

@@myeckwaters Thanks!

[@spamfilter32]

@@myeckwaters because blue is the color of depression, and depression is what Buffy is dealing with.

[@Buffy8Fan]

A character who has issues that make her act horrible. It was a rare sight to see at the time on TV and even in the movies.

[@salyx]

Yay, so glad you enjoyed it! What you said about it being a brave episode to make prompted me to think about that - they started season 2 (with a larger audience who may not have seen season 1) with a main character who isn’t likable most of the way through. Totally worth the gamble!

[@eeejjj6378]

That band, Cibo Matto, is so unique and fun. That song Sugar Water is great. I also highly recommend Sci-Fi Wasabi.

[@stevieatthemovies8186]

I can't wait for this man to meet Spike! He's going to have so much to say.

[@TylerAlexander]

Already recorded. And I DOOOOO.

[@migmit]

And that's how the most popular insult in Buffy fandom was born.

[@mathias6185]

Finally back! Can't wait for the good episodes of Season 2... 😀

[@x_rhi_x2772]

Yay Buffy (and tyler reactions) are back! I like this episode and its portrayal of PTSD. as you say, its not just glossed over and our heroine is acting...not super heroic. Its great to see that shes human. She has flaws and she deals with crap like all of us (of course not the same kind of crap, but still). Makes her much more well rounded character.

[@grife3000]

Thank god you're back. Even if you slicked back that glorious head of hair. I was worried Buffy had been abandoned for shinier trinkets. Conner's as good a name as Collin for the kid.

[@michaelolivero1626]

Now that we've gotten past the intro season, prepare for a rollercoaster of monster-of-the-week and character growth all wrapped up together. This is where they start becoming characters you become Invested in. And good job recognizing the PTSD trauma so early on.

[@littlecitygirl]

A new Buffy reaction from Tyler makes a great start to the day. This is a really strong start to S2 addressing Buffy's trauma from Prophecy Girl and I've always liked that they didn't gloss over it. I'm glad you enjoyed Xander in this episode. As a 17 year old, he's on that cusp of being a bit more mature but still with all the stuff that being a teenager brings and I've always loved when we get to see a bit more of him asserting himself.

[@kaywatsup]

Like you said, this episode was very "grounded", which is a wonderful way to describe the writing of this show. I loved your reaction and insight as always

[@tornadochaser2457]

Be careful. If you keep loving it, eventually, you'll fall in love with it, and then want to marry it. That would be pure madness, wouldn't it?

[@warrengday]

So loving your reactions. Buffy really takes off early in s2. And can't wait til you get into Buffy when it is in full flight. Enjoy, enjoy, enjoy, cherish, and appreciate this most special of journeys.

[@pantlesshobo2841]

the show delves into musical level logic sometimes, but it is pretty consistently smart about the writing and the depth of all the subjects they try to cover. some of the best show writing out there that does not rely huge overarching stories we see explore in a few episodes. I love the Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul universe, but sometimes it feels like a super long movie that is cut up into episodes. Buffy allows for small changes in character over time with many episodes in a monster of the week format. Makes for a show that can be judges on an episode by episode basis, but also a strong message that is unique to every episode. My favorite show for a good reason!

[@jamesswan4356]

glad your here with Season 2. You are the best reactor/analyzer out there. Im already looking forward to the next.

[@janeldavis905]

I love how you really think deeply about character motivations. Great reaction! Thanks for sharing with us.

[@kellygilbert736]

We appreciate the suave Tyler we got today 👌

[@sarahmichellegellarseviltwin]

love the scene at the Bronze when Cibo Matto was playing

[@spamfilter32]

One thing I see missed a lot on the Buffy Sexy Dance with Xander, is that dance wasn't only about hurting Xander, because Buffy knew Xander had a crush on her and that line "Did I ever thank you for saving my life ... don't you wish I would?" was definitely designed to hurt Xander. That Sexy Dance was also about hurting Willow. Buffy *knows* Willow has a crush on Xander. And she was right there doing the Sexy Dance in front of Willow; forcing Willow to watch. That was also about hurting Willow.

[@fanmagicks]

Love that the horrible 8 legged creeps mess with him like they do me "Every time!" Yep! EVERY TIME 😳

[@sebastienriviere7371]

Oh new haircut. It suits you. I'm looking forward to experience this season through your eyes.

[@karensamuel5616]

Buffy's one of my favorite tv series and I'm enjoying rewatching them through your first time view. I keep wanting you to watch them faster. 😊

[@corgiluver9718]

Just want to say thanks for another great reaction. Really like this season opener. Take care.

[@Lucy-uv4hv]

Welcome to Season 2! It's great to see you rocking out to the theme song again!

[@davewolf6256]

Damn dude! the algorithm is treating you bad, I didn't even get notified that this video got dropped at all. I just happened to say to myself, "Hm. I wonder what Tyler's been up to..."

[@the_real_tlc]

Finally!!! I’ve been checking every day for this vid 😂

[@JeccaJ]

Welcome back Buffy and Colin! Great comments from others that I echo. Can we all just take a moment to appreciate your fine threads for this season 2 premier? 😘 Very excited to hear your analogies for this season!

[@caseyhart4999]

Good to be back at this. You are in for a wild ride with this season Tyler.

[@J_Mar19]

One of my favorite episodes and it dealt with very mature themes that other teen shows weren’t discussing in this way. Great reaction! I can’t wait until you reach a few more of the episodes this season, especially the finale.

[@morghann21313]

Omg I've been patiently waiting!! So excited for you to start season 2 :)

[@suzetterossini4563]

I'm so glad you're back to Buffy!

[@RedundantHuman-CandyBites]

YOU’RE BACK!! I can’t wait to see you react to more.🫣

[@LadyGreensleeves33]

You are perfect for reacting to this series, because you are excellent at taking note of both the in-character psychology and motivations, as well as the decisions made from a writing and development stand point. And you keep in some truly underappreciated jokes 😂 Almost everyone cuts the 'bitca' line.

[@amandapanda6963]

You're back to Buffy? 🎉 I love your Buffy reactions! Yay!

[@ChildishDeVito]

So glad you're back. So looking forward to this season ❤

[@migmit]

Nah, Cordy has no filter. What she says is exactly what she means.

[@wolandbegemotazazello]

Oh come on, a nose would never detach itself from face and go slumming around Peter. That Gogol will be a flash in the pan. He is too creative, imaginative, and unrealistic for our happy happy joy joy mundane age.

[@kirrisolly-slade1313]

Soooo excited to have you back and embark into S2 with uou

[@moppet1214]

Lol... no spoilers, but in future episodes (if you keep going with this show) I'm going to remind you that you asked for MORE trauma 😅

[@lynnevetter]

This episode had me fall in love with Cibo Matto. They are so kooky. You should react to the video for Sugar Water just for funzies.

[@carrieels]

So excited to get your commentary for season 2 and beyond!

[@JhadeSagrav]

YEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! "I'm going to kill them all..." _tips hat to Xena_ great review as always.

[@MacLeeland]

You're drinking Kopparberg!?!

[@TylerAlexander]

Yuuuuup!

[@eugeniedesalpages]

Don't worry, trauma keeps coming! 😅

[@ninipookie]

You will have a field day with Supernatural with your kind of analysis.Phew. but so happy that you're back with Buffy. Cant wait for Episodes 3 , 14,17,21 and 22 especially 😁

[@jeanetteking434]

In this episode she talks the way she does in cruel intentions….

[@sherrysink3177]

Lookin' extra sharp today, Tyler! 😎Did you have plans outside of reacting to Buffy?

[@andrewdunn8778]

Love Xander's serious, stoneface as she's dancing on him. He knows some shit's not right and he doesn't like it and he's not about to take advantage of it.

[@chelsjones]

big difference from s1 xander

[@ragabashmoon1551]

IF you think those lyrics are amazing, that's Cibo Matto Check out their song "Birthday Cake" haha

[@lynnevetter]

PS.. I still to this day use Bitca. 🤣🤣🤣

[@kilian-one-l]

That Xander Buffy dance always makes me incredibly uncomfortable every time I watch it tbh

[@janeldavis905]

SPOILERS BELOW! 'I'd really like it if they didn't resolve the trauma right away'... Someone's gonna love season 6 😂

[@chelsjones]

i cant wait because season 6 is my favourite cause i’m a character development / relationships over plot girlie and most reactors are the opposite so they don’t love s6 but i genuinely think he’s gonna DIE for it

[@jeffmartin5504]

Season 2 is leagues ahead of Season 1. Once you get about half a dozen episodes in to Season 2, you'll notice a shift and a greater focus on more cohesive storytelling. The show starts to become what it's knonw for. Not to say there aren't anymore mediocre episodes, they just become fewer and farther between.

[@spamfilter32]

I do not place as much blame on Buffy's dad for the summer as you do. When he said Buffy was distant, that was Buffy's depression shining through. And when you suffer from depression and you are in that funk, other people can't break you out of it, no matter how much interest they show in you. It's not her dad's fault she was suffering, and there really was nothing he could do about it. I could talk more about Buffy's depression, but I won't at this time.

[@warrengday]

Others may have also said this---please please watch the original 4x3 version, not the vsry very badly remastered widescreen version.

[@RLucas3000]

Dude, you are such a good reactor, we need two episodes a week, please!

[@ribbontank9704]

Personally, I dont love Xander's moment with Buffy here. I think he borders on vindictive, and it's a huge overstep to say that if Willow gets hurt, he will kill Buffy.

[@TiaNEVERTamera]

need more buffy

[@lyssalovesit]

Yaayyy 💜

[@EM-gz6cq]

🤗🤗🤗

[@migmit]

Unsubscribing.

[@diviya971]

why?