Where does Aaron Judge rank all-time? | Baseball Today

[@djardine2520]

Pujols ended up with 703 homers.

[@jeremybingham3708]

Might have been only counting regular season

[@redmage08]

​@@jeremybingham3708nah, he hit 686 doubles. Trev was looking at Pujols' doubles when he said he hit 686 HR

[@BlacknWhiteBadger88]

703 IS his regular season total. I don’t know how they forgot already, it was literally EVERYWHERE…being covered by everyone. He actually had a crazy surge at the end just to get there.

[@taiocruz2499]

Forreal that was like the biggest story out in September of 2022 ​@BlacknWhiteBadger88

[@bentaylor4705]

Glad you pointed that out

[@mattmuelot8457]

Pujols is in the 700 club

[@SPmbp111]

when you use batting average, keep in mind the league wide batting average. Its more useful to compare players against the benchmark set by their contemporaries against similar competition.

[@rvaneand326]

Was pounding the table and saying this when that point was made. .300 feels more like .330 these days

[@SPmbp111]

@@rvaneand326 in 2024 MLB league wide average is .244. 2019 - .252 / 2009 - .262 / 1999 - .271

[@SPmbp111]

Compared to his era, Judge is the having the best 3 year stretch from a right handed hitter since Rogers Hornsby 1923-1925 by OPS+

[@reichelt666]

Was that Sox Yankees last night, I can hear myself screaming “throw it!” on the two base sack fly when I went back and checked the broadcast 😂

[@Gaven-S]

If the Braves do make the playoffs they'd be very scary. Their top 3 pitchers are very good, their bullpen is strong and their hitters are starting to figure it out. Riley had like a .650 OPS in June or something crazy and it's around .800 now. Olson's was in the .600s earlier and now it's around .750. Soler has reached base every game for the Braves, Ozuna, and Harris is back, I think they could be very scary in the playoffs if their bats continue to do what we know they can do. It's been a very weird season as a Braves fan.

[@roarkec9010]

Soler has reached base in all 12 games he’s played for the Braves btw

[@sh19413]

Yeah they really don’t know what they are talking about. Didn’t bring up Schwellenbach either

[@gentlemanjake8005]

@@sh19413It was really just Rose, tbf.

[@michaelbaucom4019]

Per Wikipedia, the names etched unto the Stanley Cup stay on the cup for about 65 years, or until a band is filled. Every 13 years, the top band is removed, and then displayed at the Hockey Hall of Fame

[@jonathanbarb5516]

I don't mind C-Rose saying the Braves suck considering how his earlier "jinx" on the Mets went

[@gentlemanjake8005]

Rose with an absolutely dreadful take on Soler’s production with the Braves lol

[@bentaylor4705]

It's unreal what Bonds could do with an inside pitch. Great show boys!!

[@levicoker8937]

How did y’all forget pujols hit 700 Home Runs, that was such a memorable run in his last season.

[@haydenharris5366]

i’m not surprised that Rosey has a pessimistic take on the Braves

[@sethraver3236]

The closest the Brewers have ever been to a championship, good for them!

[@user-ox4ys]

Where do you find the maddux / bonds thing?

[@asdfaeou]

Agreed with the Manager on the field the play is dead....but it kinda also opens the door for Managers to run out on the field to prevent the other team getting them.

[@davidjachimiak]

People are forgetting about trout. They're both the same age and trouts better in most stats.

[@Brahmabullz]

You're right but Trout has the makings of a guy that will be out soon unless he gets a trade.

[@godsunknicks2832]

Unfortunately Trout has made it easy to forget him. Stay healthy and win in the playoffs.

[@gentlemanjake8005]

@@BrahmabullzTrout just needs to DH.

[@clerns]

Judge has a higher career OPS and SLG than Trout, comparable BA and OBP. And Trout also hasn't been a yearly threat to hit 50-60 home runs when healthy. They're neck and neck right now but it really depends on how each finishes their careers.

[@davidjachimiak]

@@clerns Yes, but trout is a better defender, better baserunner, better ops+, and has done it for 600 more games. It's not really even that close.

[@BiologicalRiley]

50 years for names on the Stanley cup

[@reed5369]

That is Jolly Olive as a major league player 😆😆

[@nathanhartline9159]

How did you guys already forget that Pujols hit 700? It happened at Dodger Stadium

[@epic5073]

STILL no mention of Charlie Morton reaching the 2k Strikeout Club?! I get the take on the Braves because it's fair for how the team has played this year, but you gotta give Uncle Charlie some love for this accomplishment!

[@AnnoyedHikingTrail-es6yl]

I mean Braves did have 8 All Stars just 12 months ago so……. not sure I agree with putting the Dodgers that far ahead based on that.

[@LouieT3107]

The fact that hes being compared to the goats tells you all you need to know lol hes the man

[@TheTEN24]

Trev roasting jolly at the end there 🤣

[@theMLBfan]

30:11 of course we can still say baseball is a "clock-less" game. There's still no clock on the actual game time like there is in soccer, football, basketball, etc.

[@Roysorb]

Rose, you cant claim your Braves prediction anymore after that take!

[@russellchung3119]

Suuuuuuuuuuure. Pujols was "21"when he came up 🤣🤣🤣

[@drluigy809]

How u got the pujols stats wrong he is #4 on the all time list

[@mattculb6990]

y'all know Trev doesn't put that Mountain Dew shit in his temple of a body....

[@Brobee911]

LOL everybody’s gotta try Baja blast tho!

[@user-ox4ys]

Just think how much sooner Judge would've gotten no. 300 without the injuries.

[@Mikehawksworld]

I’d be shocked if judge even gets close to 600 HR

[@garywordman]

MLB jacking Sequence from Coach Trev!

[@joshuameyer1382]

Commissioner's trophy has changed since 1967. Tiffany's contract is up in the next couple years, so it could change.

[@i-chunhuang8413]

For the first 9 seasons, Pujols is way better than Judge, but the fact that 32-year-old Judge shows no decline at all looks really really promising

[@ThatRedHusky]

Judge is hitting homers left and right, thing is this is his 9th year. The only thing that's keeping him away from history is health and longevity. Griffey was in his 14th season at 32 (given he was hurt a lot) and he hit 630. Not to mention Griffey was INSANELY CONSISTENT with homeruns. 40+ HR season after season after season after season. Judge hits a lot of homeruns, but not nearly as much as Griffey. I'm actually betting Judge hits under 600.

[@stormchaserjoe2842]

rose ask a question about braves then talks about other teams lol, should people fear the athletics since they have one of the best records in baseball since allstar break, should team fear the phillies since they cant win anymore?

[@sunsunavery4237]

jolly olive stray lmao

[@hectorcastle1187]

Not exactly sure why Trevor is going to bat for the Braves so much. But his reasoning that they’re a fearful team because of the playoffs has the opposite effect. The only team that has struggled more in the playoffs than the Dodgers the last two years, are the Braves. As a Dodger fan, I would rather play the Braves over the Phillies, Padres, or Diamondbacks

[@gentlemanjake8005]

The playoffs are super random, and any team is just as dangerous as any other. Past years don’t really matter.

[@thegalli]

Rosey: Ri Rove Ru Rountain Rew

[@russellchung3119]

😂

[@nacoran]

Aaron Judge is great, but I think youngest to numbers are more impressive than fewest games/at bats. The Yanks gave him a lot of time to develop. He's going to struggle with the counting stats unless he has a Ryan like career where he plays amazing into his 40s. At his age, even one or two seasons where he misses a lot of counting stats because of an injury and he'll fall way short on counting stats. I think Judge has a shot at 600, but he has to stay healthy. As for the game, walking Judge wouldn't have worked, since Judge and Wells went back to back. Edit- as for appealing the play at 2nd, I'd argue the difference between this and another appeal is the runner is only out if you touch second with the ball. Yes, you could do that before you give the ball back to the pitcher, but I think doing a formal appeal is useful for the crowd. For most appeals the crowd is focused on the part of the play that is being appealed, but with a missed base the action has already passed that part of the play. By making it formal it shows the crowd what is going on. If you just touched the base the crowd would miss the actual put ou.

[@MattMiddlebrook]

703 homers for pujols

[@mrturtletail3945]

You guys didn't mention that Kershaw was the one to notice the runner not retagging 2nd base

[@yungshatter6671]

You can tell rose doesn’t care about the sponsorship for Mountain Dew very much

[@bwestby1]

Albert finished over 700.

[@cashnelson6400]

How dare you guys disrespect Albert Pujols. 703 home runs

[@chrisc8002]

Juiced balls

[@traviskallan9318]

The braves hate from Rose is strong in this episode

[@squashandfries]

Trevor - You should't be afraid of facing Max Fried this season. And Reylo might not be at his peak anymore, either. The only REAL ace we have right now is Chris Sale. That's it. The rest I don't fully trust anymore. This is how bad this has gotten. We are not REMOTELY the biggest threat in the offseason if we get there. Our bullpen is not the same as the '21 bullpen. Our guys are not hot except Ozuna.

[@jsXanatos]

Dead last

[@tesstesseract]

lmao at pujols 696

[@log1162]

Thumbnail question might as well be is the pope catholic?

[@Zo3yX]

That was a bad water toss in NY. They need to learn from the dad's and Machado

[@traviskrzemienski5745]

Rosey is way off on Judge. Every number favors him besides batting average

[@Aaron-rv8qj]

Braves fans have been complaining the last two years about being hampered by the bye, now they get to try to win via the wild card.

[@Champ-iv9dd]

Rose doesn’t have any damn clue what he’s talking about when it comes to baseball or football lol. Probably why he didn’t get renewed with mlb network.

[@LouieT3107]

If your a person watching baseball today and you dont consider batting average a top stat of a player, then you should stop talking and watching mlb. Seriously. And dont tell anyone that ba doesnt matter cause youll embarrass yourself to real mlb people

[@louiscicale6800]

Best right handed hitter ever. Best non-steroid hitter ever. 22-24 is a higher 3 year peak than Pujols or Cabrera

[@FigFrenzy]

Fr

[@stux101ksb4]

Pujols hit the 700 mark. Judge doesn’t topple Pujols until he does that

[@SPmbp111]

@@stux101ksb4 Career vs peak is a separate framework

[@hustlecrowe9440]

LOL. Maybe best hitter in the "juiced ball era", which is whats going on now.

[@KryMoore]

Hall of fame voters look at a 7 year peak average. You might want to go back and compare those numbers.

[@Raine574]

Is judge a hall of famer yet?

[@nunzi83]

Speaking from a baseball fan. Judge is another player that falls into “what could the career numbers be if he wasn’t hurt so much”. Griffey. McGwire etc. just imagine if baseball didn’t block Barry bonds from continuing to play. We’d have a 800 homerun king in the MLB. His last years numbers were better then most players in the game today. He could of played for another 2-3 years.

[@Realdrlipschitz]

He still has 7 years left on his contract lol let’s hold off on saying Judge is another “what if”. He’s had majority injuries from on the field anomalies (broken wrist from hbp, running through a wall, etc.), so he isn’t “injury prone” per sey. The only “what if” with Judge will be: what if he didn’t start so late

[@nunzi83]

@@Realdrlipschitz not saying he’s a what if. But he’s 32 and has been hurt a lot. Look at history. Going 7 more years at an average of 50 homeruns a year doesn’t break 700 homeruns. That’s my point.

[@Realdrlipschitz]

@@nunzi83 oh, well I don’t think he’ll hit 700 either, but I don’t think he’ll go down as someone who dealt with injuries like Griffey or Trout.

[@MichaelHawkins-yd6ge]

If I were Duran I'd refuse to apologize

[@jadap1789]

Judge is the goat

[@AnthonyMartinezmartinez2]

Until the postseason starts

[@KryMoore]

Goats have rings.