Which Edition of Minecraft is Truly Better?

[@battae5984]

The only reason Bedrock doesn't have hardcore is because of a handful of bugs that can kill the player in an instant, such as spawning under the obsidian platform in the end and dying to fall damage when exiting a bubble column. Since we recently got spectator, its safe to assume hardcore isn't far behind. Btw I had to type this comment twice because my computer gave me the blue screen of death when I was typing it the first time. Overall, there is truly no superior edition of Minecraft. Both have their ups and downs and are fun to play for different reasons

[@naitsirhc.]

Love this comment. There are better features in java and better features in bedrock, both are great!

[@battae5984]

@@naitsirhc. That blue screen of death killed my PC entirely. It does not work anymore

[@naitsirhc.]

Oh gosh! What happened? I was going to say hope you pc feels better but...

[@battae5984]

@@naitsirhc. It was just old, this was inevitable

[@Jeremonkey90]

The reason people say Bedrock wither is harder is because on hard mode it gives you almost a minute of wither to which would take down anyone without regen, totems, milk or something else that can save you. It also summons 3 wither skeletons and explodes multiple times

[@Tik-tok7308]

I agree! No matter what version of minecraft you play all that matters is you have fun! also did I hear HARDCORE survival series coming in the near future??? Great video! keep it up!

[@DatWooferson]

When you’ve been waiting for nait to upload:

[@zulfahmi1664]

I started playing last year using my phone so I have a soft spot for Bedrock. Now Java is automatically free if you bought the Bedrock version so I can play both. But I still stick to Bedrock. I still havent defeated the dragon because I have been restarting my worlds many times. Maybe after I finished all achievements in Bedrock, I will try Java.

[@BossGamerDK]

It's only free if it's Bedrock on PC and vise versa

[@SevdenCrown]

Im wondering why you found the Java fight harder than the bedrock fight as looking at all the aspects you can see that bedrock wither is a lot harder, just look at what people say online! Lets take a look at the things that the Bedrock one does that’s different: • ⁠Shoots skulls in burst shots rather than individual skulls • ⁠Guaranteed blue powerful skull at the end of each burst fire, can be deflected back at it because Bedrock has goofy ass mechanics but doesn’t do any damage to the Wither • ⁠Can’t be trapped under normal circumstances • ⁠Unpredictable movement pattern • ⁠Summons a small group of wither skellies once it gets to half health and also explodes before summoning them too, same ranged attack immunity as Java at this point • ⁠Only uses charge attack at half health • ⁠Explodes on death as well, so you can beat him and still get killed • ⁠More health than Java variant

[@naitsirhc.]

From that info the bedrock wither definitely is more difficult... But... When I fought the java wither I died multiple times while against the bedrock wither I didn't die or even really get low. Overall just by playing the game the java fight was wayyyyy harder than the bedrock fight. If you want to see how each fight went the bedrock fight happened in my 100 days bedrock video and the java fight happened on ep 11 of my 1.19 let's play. (Not trying to promote anything. It's just if you wanna see my how each fight went for me.) i do see what you're saying though

[@shitalsawant1973]

4:40 *As a Bedrock Edition Player this is a The Most Important Parity Feature to he added to Bedrock Edition, I've been begging Mojang from 2016 to give Fully Functional Offhand Support to Bedrock Edition 💀🗿*

[@rozhismail9103]

I wish the full functional offhand was in bedrock it doesn't make sense why it's not

[@kettutelvella122]

I like the terrain generation on Java much better than on Bedrock. The biomes are the same now, but Java will spawn ravines much more frequently and it seems like surface lava pools aren't as common in Bedrock.

[@idrinkkoolaid2501]

I feel like java is probably the more technical version, where u can move further away from basic/simple minecraft but bedrock is more simple and customizable

[@DarkSoul.2410]

facts

[@Jongolorian]

Silent Whisperer and wattles have both covered a new feature in the recent bedrock minor update that allows the player to put any item in their off hand through commands. It is definitely not finished but they seem to be close to putting off hand java capabilities into bedrock. This is also easier to use now on pocket edition because they recently introduced the new controls which have new buttons and a cross hair and is much easier to use and more precise than the old controls. Nice videos btw

[@FiremanSamBoy2008]

To be honest, I along with my older sister who's 18 prefer Java more than Bedrock because we've both always been used to it. I feel like Java is much easier to use and much easier to navigate through, I've been playing Java since I was 6 in 2014 and Bedrock too (on my dads old phone and sometimes my mums too) and I fell in love with Java ever since. Now I'm 14 and I'm turning 15 next year on the 5th of July 2023 (I was born in 2008) and I still prefer Bedrock.

[@Dukekabo0m09]

I like bedrock more. Mainly because you have the power to have your entire world in your pocket and by that I mean phone. Great video btw

[@naitsirhc.]

Great way to think about it, being able to play minecraft anywhere is real nice. I used to bring my tablet all around to play mc.

[@Dukekabo0m09]

@@naitsirhc. Same

[@D_egi]

to be honest as a mobile (bedrock) user the reason there is no torch in your left hand is because then we need another button to place the torch soo.

[@naitsirhc.]

Ohhhhh. This actually makes soooo much sense, thanks

[@Game_Crazy-zh3nh]

I enjoyed your world series so much I can't stop watching ur videos now

[@naitsirhc.]

Thankyou! I love to hear this ❤

[@galacticjellyfish9971]

I love your videos they're brilliant I hope you continue and continue to make brilliant content

[@wavesfordayz8074]

I love the video!! And found your channel looking for a mc play through and instantly was hooked to you channed

[@JackedUpJaw67]

Congrats on 11k subscribers

[@naitsirhc.]

Thankyou ❤

[@jus_jada]

I wish that some of the Java features were in bedrock but overall I still like bedrock more because the best part about playing Minecraft for me is playing with my friends. On bedrock it’s much easier to play with friends and doesn’t require a server or anything like that. You can just have someone join your world on any platform

[@ericmathena]

I prefer Bedrock because I started playing on Xbox and I'm used to using a controller. I get frustrated trying to learn how to play using keyboard and mouse. Thanks for a good video on this subject.

[@JustManuelito24]

Thank you for not being toxic about bedrock edition, there are people that just judge bedrock and they didnt even giving motivations

[@chaza360gaming6]

First yay also thank you for bring my 100th subcriber I am working on a 100 subcriber special however it is delayed cuz I'm sick at the moment. I think that java is better for modding and having the servers available and I think that bedrock has some great vanilla details to it so both versions have good things about them.

[@Alanboss777]

Bedrock has mods too and you can make 3d blocks without needing optifine on bedrock edition

[@chaza360gaming6]

@@Alanboss777 wait bedrock has mods? Ig only pc bedrock I'm only on console bedrock

[@Alexminecrafter1]

@@chaza360gaming6 same but legacy console is still better even if villagers are garbage in there the games is better and more fun

[@chaza360gaming6]

@@Alexminecrafter1 yess the xbox 360 version is still my all-time favourite I need to get my old 360 down from the attic

[@Alexminecrafter1]

@@chaza360gaming6 sadly my xbox 360 is loud af but it still works after 15 years without a red ring of death

[@nemulo2997]

hello, could you make a tutorial for building bridges??? we have a similar style and taste for choosing a place for the base. I have a big problem with bridges. please help. :)

[@naitsirhc.]

I don't think I will because I do want to do tutorial content as of now, but possibly in the future I'll do so.

[@nemulo2997]

@@naitsirhc. good to know, i will be waiting for such a guide :)

[@gabthegameplay3349]

Java it's just on pc... Meanwhile Java on mobile game exist..

[@TheRealChad15]

Thanks for marking very good videos for us I see a great future on you and I also love your videos thanks again and I rather Java but I just played Java for 4 or 3 times I don’t have Laptop or pc so I can’t play but if I get I’m gonna start Java 💫

[@FlamyCatYT]

Build a soccer arena in the next survival episode😊

[@SamKing377]

You are one of my favourite Minecraft KZbinrs because you also care about bedrock players

[@Gamerripped]

Well the off hand is going to be no problem for bedrock because they are getting an update on the off hand soon, and hardcore is going to be added to bedrock maybe next year because the both versions already have spectator mode.

[@slushirain3157]

Great video keep it up!

[@LucasEEV5]

I'am a bedrock/pocket guy. I dont have a pc or something like a laptop. I didnt play java ever one time in my life. I play minecraft with my xbox controller every day and its so fun, i respect both versions but yea, im a bedrock guy.

[@real_rsaNoob13]

Main reason the off hand can't hold more than a limited set of items on bedrock is because they can't figure out how to implement it on mobile, with amplified it's coz of performance, only $400-$1000 phones would probably be able to handle it, I'm only mentioning phones cos they're the second weakest link, behind the Nintendo switch of course :)

[@Kent-w8h]

Love your vids

[@Alexminecrafter1]

Legacy console edition but if you say a non-discontinued than java edition cause i can't even have fun in bedrock my motivation just drains out very fast

[@Dogie1234]

Easy answer BEDROCK IS SUPERIOR

[@elite4149]

False, bedrock is very limited

[@Pumpkinpirate1]

Isn’t Java moddable and bedrock isn’t?

[@Acplay83]

@@Pumpkinpirate1you can mod bedrock

[@Acplay83]

@@Pumpkinpirate1just not a lot

[@Pumpkinpirate1]

@@Acplay83 ?

[@Baxter792]

They are both cool.

[@naitsirhc.]

Definitely!

[@evokegaming9029]

Hi bro u r doing good keep it up. 😊

[@naitsirhc.]

I'm doing good, thankyou I will. How are you?

[@waxe1627]

greetings from Romania

[@rindevn2715]

Bedrock is better than Java

[@quackyfru-di1or]

Bro you can off hand the totem and the shield and a map in your off hand

[@naitsirhc.]

Yeah but thats pretty much it... In java you can offhand everything mainly torches and food which is very nice

[@Kevin-ki2rp]

All I want is sweeping edge in bedrock and to be able to put items in your off hand

[@naitsirhc.]

That would be GREAT for bedrock

[@Paulmkr]

Nice!

[@msmmonsterdiscoverers]

I think That It DOESNT MATTER Which version is better but we can agree That Minecraft Is Minecraft no matter which version or how we play Minecraft is Minecraft

[@Michaelsmith-wr4ee]

I have to go with Java simply because auto farms and such work better and are more efficient, the offhand, hardcore, mods, etc

[@Alanboss777]

Mods exist on bedrock edition

[@naitsirhc.]

I think he means a wider variety of mods

[@medalgearsalad1419]

The transition when he says "bedrock" at around 1:18 is a dead give away its an A.I voice reading a script. God I hate finding out my fav channels have A.I voices instead or ones 😔

[@naitsirhc.]

There was no AI used at all in this video or any of my other videos. Absolutely none. *Edit: For that exact moment on the timestamp I accidentally said java when I recorded this the first time and I didn't want to record that section again so I just cut out where I said java and added a clip of me saying "bedrock". No ai *2nd Edit: Also if you listen just 7 seconds more I do the same exact thing where this time I insert a clip of me saying "java". I had them backwards when I recorded my audio and fixed it this way when I was editing.

[@abdallahsaidmohamedalzaraa1206]

I like java but I played it twice only and things like building above the nether roof and more powerful axes is great

[@nathansullivanmusic7574]

I’ve never played Java as I’m a console gamer. I do own a PC obviously and I’ve considered getting Minecraft on it as I love the texture packs and shaders that it offers BUT as someone who has played consoles for most of my life, I can’t get my head around using a keyboard to control my player. My previous experience of using a keyboard for games has been terrible and this puts me off the JAVA edition.

[@hedwigheavenly95]

I agree the same for me😎

[@naitsirhc.]

My whole life I've only used a controller (or touch screen) to play games and just about 4 months ago I started to play keyboard. It definitely was weird at first but after getting used to it, it was enjoyable.

[@Mr_Key.]

For your information the wither have 600 heart on hard difficulty but 300 on any other difficulty

[@naitsirhc.]

Oh ok thanks, I did fight the wither on normal but it was normal on bedrock and java.

[@Mr_Key.]

@@naitsirhc. l don't play on Java so l don't know but l always play on bedrock so if you need any information " about bedrock of course " l am in your service.

[@Mr_Key.]

@@naitsirhc. And if you didn't make the 400 days Minecraft bedrock can you please play with your hands because playing with a keyboard and mouse is kind of cheating and thanks.

[@moy7256]

the best part of bedrock are the servers cause if ur on pc ITS SO FUN because 50%of players are on their phones and u can just destroy them,while on java every one is on pc

[@ksej42]

In the end, the best edition is the one that you prefer. There is no better or worse one overall

[@mohammadsarwari9484]

For me bedrock edition is good because I have so many memories in bedrock edition when I was 6 I play bedrock edition with my friends, cousins let's don't forget bedrock edition

[@alvaroorozco6610]

I say both are equal and each have their pros and cons. 😎

[@naitsirhc.]

Exactly

[@xtroy_ff]

Love ur vids bedrock better

[@johnsencedric1918]

The thing that makes bedrock wither much harder to fight than the java ones is because they can’t kill the bedrock wither by trapping inside a cave. They can easily get the wither star by constantly attack the wither in a small cave in java.

[@Fortnite_dude9654]

I've played only bedrock edition but soon I'm planning to get Java

[@MyNetCut]

So which one should I get guys?

[@Bibou_Guimauve]

When you are waiting for a new video: :l When there is a new video:🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@Cristiano2896-x2w]

I'm playing with mods and creative too but I'm not only playing Minecraft on creative or mods

[@jedrekfiolog5298]

I vote bedrock addition because I have a mobile tablet😁

[@gamingdudeplayz9661]

If u could hold every item in off hand and hc mode would u like it more?

[@naitsirhc.]

That + hardcore and maybe certain bugs fixed. Yes.

[@toantran-ci6bb]

well the reason you feel bedrock is easier than java because bedrock is only really hard when in hard mode, on normal difficulty, java have 300 health and bedrock is 450 health, when on hard difficulty java will not change anything much in addition to dealing higher damage and longer lasting wither effects. bedrock wither is completely different when on hard difficulty, wither's health will increase from 450 to 600 health, not to mention in 200 day bedrock because you play in normal so bedrock wither feel kinda easier but with hard difficulty you need take even more time to kill it, bedrock wither has 2 exclusive move on phase 2 is summon wither skeleton and dash attack, on normal wither rarely use dash since you kill it too fast but with 300 health on phase 2 hard difficulty, it will use it by alot that dealing high damage and delete every block when it dash to you. also note that wither on java is pretty easy if you know how to fight it since it the first time you fight wither in java so you find it very hard but if you know how to fight then it really easy, you can alway tank and outheal java with protect 4 and golden apple, because it alway above your head so you can just rapidly shoot arrow and bring java wither to phase 2 super quickly, after that just go in and swing it to dead, even easier is trap it in the cave tunnel and java wither will become useless lol funfact: bedrock wither used to way harder than normally since before 1.19, wither effect can piercing protection enchant on bedrock so wither effect can delete your health like crazy but after 1.19, protection enchant now actually protect player from effect on bedrock

[@blizard4739]

When will the next let’s play video be

[@naitsirhc.]

Within a week

[@l1amakid]

Hi remember me

[@jurgitajuskyte6918]

In Java, you can put a sharpness enchanted book on axe, but in Bedrock you can't do this.

[@casandramartinson8223]

I love both versions

[@thebadguy1636]

I play bedrock edition but the number 1 thing I hate about bedrock is the ability to emote like is Minecraft turning into Fortnite

[@subhannadeem2486]

Bedrock wither is harder when you fight java wither you only need potion of regeneration and the fight will become easier try that thing

[@philippebelanger9272]

I personally prefer bedrock and when I tell my friends, they literally don't believe me.

[@YOUR_NARRATOR975]

Bedrock runs smoother but Java plays smoother. That's the biggest difference.

[@ZeroFoundContent]

If he went all the way down to bedrock and made a mine like area He would've beaten the wither way easier

[@ilikeplanetbolsalot]

7:36 (vine boom)

[@Nolh26]

You forget to mension the fact that in bedrock you just need a furnace and 65 Iron for an infinite ewtremly fast XP farm

[@naitsirhc.]

Didn't even know about this, thanks

[@Nolh26]

@@naitsirhc. you just Cook 64 Iron and let them in thé furnace then you take one iron ingot in your chest and finally you click a lot of Time on the 64 Iron in the furnace with the one in your hand and it will give you XP it is a lot faster with ancien débris (in15 hours you Can go to the max xp level

[@m_dpb]

Imagine if bedrock had a hardcore and the off hand

[@skrillZUPOLARCOINS4599Parjol]

Dungeons joined the chat 🍸🍸🗿🪨👍

[@KENDERTDS]

Amazing video! Also 100th like!

[@drashyatutorial9379]

Mojang is working on the bedrock edition offhand in the new update it will be released on bedrock edition

[@yanggaming5624]

If you wonder i play java on smp which is both java and bedrock in my phone

[@peppergrinder8947]

#BEDROCK

[@Kiyotaka_ayanokoji9-i3u]

What if mojang make it like the same that will be soo insane bad that never ganna happend but I'm happy to be bedrock player

[@scorvens8299]

Bro the hand is diffrent how the game looks is diffrent the bracking glitch of blocks and lots more

[@dark2627]

58 seconds ago ongg bro

[@H1MLbambo]

I play bedrock and god bridging there is much easier only learn the skill to go fast and place a block one another and boom your god bringing!

[@Aaravlol69]

Me being a mobile player i have to say java is better because in bedrock if u make a world anyone can join but in java no one can 🗿

[@carmen-florentinaignea6262]

i like bedrock more because i play on it

[@BenDavis25]

Java is better but I play bedrock cause it more accessible

[@Gregtalks2]

Bedrock better

[@PROUD_TITOIST]

Offhand is not in bedrock because of m9bile i think because you dont have that much buttons and you have spamclick so it is hard to optimize

[@strayvolcan5294]

2nd person

[@yanggaming5624]

I use sword to defead wither in java I use bow to low his health and sword in bedrlck

[@randomguyonyt7851]

I wish mojang could just merge bedrock and java and keep all the exclusive features.

[@jessicaschantz3554]

I play bedrock

[@johnscienceexperiments2194]

For me java wither is so easy

[@userd-bj4th]

java wither fight is so but you are bedrock player so combat is different

[@shitalsawant1973]

Java Wither just Spams Skulls on you which barely gives you any damage, while even one skull hit of Bedrock Wither can give you 1min of Wither 2, Bedrock Wither's AI is much more Advanced

[@Brokenlegchewbacca]

I PLAY BEDROCK EDITION IVE PLAYED JAVA AND ITS GARBAGE LITTERAL GARBAGE ITS JUS❤T❤ SO ANNOYING IT SUCKS

[@Jnn10-y3k]

Java

[@peterpagac3058]

bedrock is better

[@Yux_An]

LOL we can play Java on mobile

[@BLC717]

Bruh th wither so much harder in bedrock

[@KublentJán]

Bedrock edition is good

[@pranabbarua2044]

Like if you love bedrock

[@hannesjons1]

both is better no shit

[@mobil3toxin569]

Bedrock has antilag so bedrock better