Which Goalies Belong In the Hall of Fame Who Aren't Currently In It?

[@SolidPain6624]

Mike Vernon belongs in the hall. He’s helped Detroit and Calgary win a cup those years!

[@johnburns9634]

And beat "some guy" in the finals in 1989.

[@kentboersema9995]

Yes to Mike Vernon! He also beat Roy in a fight!

[@kdutch98]

@Christian Stokes Vernon absolutely beat Roy in the 1997 fight. Bloodied him and everything. And Vernon beat Roy twice in a playoff series....as well as won a Conn Smythe Trophy. He belongs in the Hall.

[@kdutch98]

@Christian Stokes watch the fight again. Roy was bloodied, and went down. Vernon wom the fight without a doubt. And, Detroit in 1997 was hardly a "stacked team" Colorado that year was more talented.

[@sergeiyzerman7240]

Lol. The guy with the bloodied face who ends up on his back on the ice won the fight. Ok.

[@BoyNamedSue4]

The lack of goaltenders is why, as much as I love JS Giguere. I can’t see him ever getting in.

[@11DNA11]

Jiggy played his ass off against the Devils... They would've been absolutely smoked without his play.

[@jordanmazzitelli8841]

Jean-Sebastien Giguere will be inducted into the hall of fame before half of the goalies on this list.

[@Junketsuadidas]

Knowing CuJo still ain’t in, I fear Giguere will never

[@sunsandkings]

We need to ask your friend Michael Buble, who shall remain nameless.

[@christopheraffrunti9939]

and we must consider the goaltenders that played a crucial part in the outcome in the war of 1812 and how they fit in hall of fame discussion

[@mamaji277]

Awards we need: Rod Langway Trophy - Best Defensive Defenseman Paul Coffey Trophy - Defenseman with the most Points Wayne Gretzky / an Elite playmaker (maybe Ron Francis) Trophy - Player with the most Assists Bob Probert Trophy - Best Heavyweight, or player with most penalty minutes

[@maxrates]

The Art Ross is pretty much the Gretzky, but nice suggestions

[@spastikxd4022]

I would also say the Larry Robinson trophy for most plus minus instead of just being called the “plus minus award”

[@pierrepellerin249]

You mention Jose Theodore Hart trophy but not Carey Price Hart trophy? just an oversight i guess.

[@hockeykid9878]

Something you left out, Price won the Hart trophy when he won his Vezina. He also won the Ted Lindsey. Based on that he will likely get to the hall. Along with his international achievements. I think international play is weighted much higher for goalies in determining if they should be in the hall or not. Lundqvist's international play makes him a hall of famer without other awards.

[@dababy8007]

I bet Price will be in this argument after he retires

[@dababy8007]

Erik Arktander I think he just needs one more playoff run and this year is the perfect time

[@Blatty26]

Chris Osgood, easily. 400 wins, 3 Stanley Cups

[@kylestoddart]

thats hard to argue

[@NiceBoyAdam]

Any goalie would of won 400 games with those Detroit teams Infront of them

[@CodyHeimbach]

@@NiceBoyAdam CuJo struggled with that same Detroit team. If Grant Fuhr made it, Osgood should too.

[@TheBunnyBunz]

@@NiceBoyAdam With that logic Marty Brodeur doesn't deserve it either behind those New Jersey teams...

[@wingsandtigers]

He would have won the Conn Smythe in 2009 had the Wings won the Cup. You could argue he deserved it in 2008 too.

[@AngryFrog97]

Chris Osgood. He always turned it up in the playoffs. 401 wins, Three Stanley Cups and a William M. Jenning Trophy.

[@kdutch98]

Absolutely he deserves it. 401 wins is 13th all time. More wins than Hall of Famers Rogie Vachon, and Dominik Hasek.....And only 2 wins behind Grant Fuhr.

[@Zamppa86]

Osgood is pretty much the most overrated goalie of the modern era. Sure he has wins and cups but he also played for Detroit before the salary cap which reduces the value of those stats some. Osgood was good but no way HOF level.

[@AngryFrog97]

Zamppa86 agree to disagree, you’re not thinking about the caliber of competition he played against as well. And Detroit isn’t the only team he played for.

[@sdeepj]

Had Detroit won in 2009, the label of Osgood being a good goalie with a great team in front of him would’ve been lifted. He would have been the Conn Smythe winner and backstopped the Wings to 3 Cups. That would merit him being in the HoF debate.

[@jayTeal]

Carey price won the hart too

[@jayTeal]

Daniel Treadwell yeah great numbers hart trophy all behind a garbage team. Coming from a mtl fan.

[@11DNA11]

@Daniel Treadwell Nah. That would be Brodeur. Marty never had to drag a bad team into the finals.

[@hockeykid9878]

@@11DNA11 2012 says hello

[@anonimuso]

@Daniel Treadwell I genuinely don't understand the hype Price gets. He had one really great season, and since then...pretty much an above average goalie.

[@MikeSmith-du9gh]

He had 2 great years when his team was good and then average years when his team sucked.. Montreal has no good prospects so won’t be good for a while. Sadly..

[@noctaroh5121]

I think goalies in general get criticized and judged to a harsher degree than other positions. A lot of the goalies on your second board were either crucial to Stanley Cup runs, great assets on teams that just never quite got to the top, or carried mediocre/bad teams on their back. In any scenario, the team they were on would have been nothing without them and it proves how elite they were. On a semi-related note, I think hardware plays too large a role in deciding whether or not a player is HOF worthy.

[@OttawaNow]

When you count Emile Francis and Jim Rutherford (Builders Category Inductees) there are 41 goaltenders in the Hockey Hall of Fame.

[@shrihithtalapaneni9227]

I have to say Thank you for the consistent uploading. Seriously, I can't say enough about all the videos. It is much needed, especially now.

[@och70]

Tony Esposito did win a Stanley Cup with Montreal in 1968-69. He was the third goalie on the team at that time, behind Rogie Vachon and Gump Worsley.

[@cloudsopowera6248]

och70 his name is even on Stanley Cup

[@hockey582004]

A really great breakdown video, keep up the great work!

[@dougsalmon6137]

Another gem. really interesting numbers, Thanks again Shannon

[@AlphaKooze]

Tim Thomas probably should get in. A cup, Jennings, 2 Vezina's, and a Conn Smythe.

[@allsystemsgo8678]

Career/peak was way to short.

[@patrickrusso9919]

@@allsystemsgo8678 but again, it goes by what your criteria is. If its hardware, then Thomas needs serious consideration. He wasn't great for long, but he was one of THE best goalies out there when he was

[@victorvegas777]

@@patrickrusso9919 needs to be a combination of hardware and longevity. Thomas is missing the latter

[@1.21JJWatts]

Thomas made history with his Bernie Parent hat trick, but I just don't think he was good enough for long enough. I will love him forever for 2011 though.

[@robins5798]

@@victorvegas777 Tim Thomas' NHL career was just as long as Ken Dryden's.

[@caniackyle88]

Would be really interested to hear you do this with forwards, especially your opinion about whether or not Rod Brind'Amor deserves a HOF spot as a player (coaching aside I think he does). Wondering what you think.

[@ianschwartz2496]

The Ace up Carey Price's sleeve is the year of Vezina, Hart, Ted Lindsay (MVP voted by players). I know that the Lindsay doesn't have the same acclaim as the Hart, but he is the only Goaltender to have won it, and very unlikely that another G will before he is HoF eligible. Great video!

[@mayureshanmuhunthan3876]

Johnathan Quick is probably my favourite goalie to watch. His flexibility is insane.

[@Sempermortis84]

Osgood and Vernon for sure

[@DucksUpDogsDownCatsSlide]

Ron Hextall should get in as a builder.

[@allsystemsgo8678]

LMAO!! 😂

[@NiceBoyAdam]

Kiprusoff should be #1 had a great career. Realistically he won a cup and had the best season a goalie has ever had. Has vezina and got snubbed twice. + Jennings

[@NiceBoyAdam]

@Daniel Treadwell not a prayer you get let out the mental hospital.

[@SMG2fanatic]

You don’t “realistically” win a cup. The puck may have crossed the line in game 6, but it wasn’t called a goal. No goal, no cup

[@NiceBoyAdam]

@@SMG2fanatic stick to the family guy videos. He won the cup. We all know the flames won that game fair and square.

[@MisterMike95]

A K If the Flames won the Cup in ‘04, they should’ve won Game 7. Kippo wasn’t really overworked in the Final too much though.

[@justinmiller5660]

@@NiceBoyAdam nope. Puck never crossed the line. It's called parallax. The angel of the camera made it look like the puck was in because it was off the ice. Maybe read a science book and win a game 7?

[@joshblack5874]

Price also has a Hart trophy.. over guys like Crosby, Ovechkin, Kane etc.

[@JM-yn8mb]

You also need to focus on IIHF, International, Olympics success too! That certainly factors into the decision!

[@bdonaghu]

That would help Miller with his case considering his silver medal and Olympic MVP from 2010.

[@fishbomb6378]

Brett Donaghue it also helps lundqvist since he won gold in 06

[@boland73]

It is DEFINITELY harder for goalies to make the HOF because their standards are higher

[@fjthatguy9496]

Can you do a video on goalies who were excellent, but played for really bad teams? Like Ron Tugnut for Quebec.

[@samifyrqvist258]

I think one name, who is not in this list, because he had only 319 wins, is Miikka Kiprusoff. He led the God awful Flames team for many, many seasons. He was the reason they made it to cup finals in the 03-04 season, and in general was by far the best player of Calgary Flames par from Jarome Iginla. Kiprusoff won the Vezina rightfully in 05-06 season. He also played on many seasons more than 70 games (from 05-06 season until 11-12 season). His save% is 91,2 and GA is 2,49. Great goalie, deserves more recognition.

[@NIVO1972]

Chris Osgood. 95-96 played 50 games and won 39. 3 cups(2 as a starter) and solid numbers to back it all up. Over 400 wins.

[@spectacularmoments]

Glad to see Tommy Barrasso baby!!!!

[@jasonfire3434]

I'd love to see Quick get in, 2 Cups and a Smythe and God-mode in the playoffs (2018 against Vegas, anyone?). But I doubt he gets in 😞

[@adameaster8976]

Tuukka Rask should be on the board, he has a Vezina, and he’s the Bruins winningest goalie, probably the best goalie in Bruins history

[@jakeelliott3562]

But he isn't retired

[@adameaster8976]

B1gg3st Blu3s Fan neither is Carey price, or fleury, or Lundqvist, they were on the board

[@markhodge7]

Well thought out. Good vid Shannon

[@griffx]

Tom Barrasso, Calder and Vezina in his rookie year, two Stanley Cups with the Penguins

[@danb.9891]

I appreciate the amount of work you put into this Shannon. I wish you could have included Gaa. & Sv.% for each as well. #OsgoodHOF

[@MisfitPhobia]

Tom Barrasso should be in the HOF.

[@islezynkeez72]

Tom Barrasso deserves to be in 100%

[@jordanmazzitelli8841]

Nabokov won a Calder memorial for ROTY. That should be noted considering he won the award ahead of other rookie goaltenders; Roberto Luongo, Marty Turco, and Brent Johnson.

[@jordancivic96]

Grant Fuhr has 5 Cups, not 4. He was still on the team in '89-'90, he was just injured for part of the year and the playoffs, but still qualified. And Tony Esposito does have a Cup. He was the backup/3rd stringer in '68-'69 with Montreal. Due to injuries to Vachon and Worsley, he played 13 regular season games, and dressed as backup for all games in the finals, so he qualified for a Cup ring. He also has the unique distinction of winning the Cup the year before winning the Calder.(Dryden did it as well)

[@dababy8007]

Fleury and Luongo needs to be in the hall

[@elwizschold]

As does Lundqvist

[@jackkelly252]

@@elwizschold no question Lundqvist gets it.

[@sensfan7550]

@@jackkelly252 Price and Osgood will get in too

[@11DNA11]

@@jackkelly252 Has to get in. He has the most wins of any Ranger goalie in history. That's 100 years worth of goalies almost :)

[@TheBlazersfan22]

What about vernon or belfour ?

[@MrJulianhood]

Really liked this. Thanks!

[@jackrabbit08]

One of my criteria for the HOF in any league is whether they have success changing the way the game is played. I'm a casual LA homer that doesn't watch as much hockey as I'd like to, but Quick is (was?) one of the most flexible, dynamic, and aggressive goalies I've ever seen. He plays the game more akin to a soccer sweeper keeper than a shot stopper. Not sure if that is enough to get him in, but I feel it should at least merit contention.

[@johnburns9634]

Miikka Kiprusoff's an interesting one, 319 career wins, A trade to the Calgary Flames in 2003-04 brought Kiprusoff into a starting role, and he set a modern NHL record for lowest goals against average (GAA) at 1.69 as he helped the Flames reach the 2004 Stanley Cup Final. He won the Vezina Trophy as the best goaltender in the NHL in 2006 along with the William M. Jennings Trophy for giving up the fewest goals in the League. He played in his first NHL All-Star Game in 2007 and is the Flames' franchise record holder in both wins and shutouts. His career .921 playoff save percentage was .09 higher than his .912 regular season average. Many skaters are mentioned in the playoffs as either disappearing or taking it up a notch, Miikka certainly took it up a notch in the playoffs. More/Less or As important to the Flames success as Iginla? Maybe one day the Flames will retire his number.

[@NiceBoyAdam]

KipperGoat

[@Nickleblanc41]

489 Wins is pretty impressive when you look at what Luongo had in front of him for his entire career.

[@justinmiller5660]

@@kenklak people also forget Luongo had shutouts in 2 of the 3 win for Van in the finals that year.

[@Petskuta]

If Rask keeps his play up for a couple years, I think he should be in the conversation. He's at 291 wins and by far leads all active goalies in SV% and GAA. One Vezina, but likely to have 2 at the end of this season. Also one cup, although not in a starting role. Anyway one of the most consistent performers for a decade now and the numbers point to it.

[@bigoldbillybob]

Hard to believe Ward won that many games. He was on some awful teams and wasn't good in shootouts or he could have had 400.

[@fjthatguy9496]

People shit on Ward for being bad when he played, but Carolina would've been A LOT worse without him during the years of being bad or mediocre.

[@bigoldbillybob]

@@fjthatguy9496 oh yeah I'm not shitting on the guy he was given close to zero support for most of his career and is a huge factor in the cup the canes won.

[@fjthatguy9496]

bigoldbillybob Exactly. You don't get 300+ wins as a goalie by being bad. The fact that he got the majority of those wins on a bad/mediocre Carolina team should give him some HOF consideration, imo.

[@jacobfleenor3497]

He was pretty badly hurt from never having a good backup in Carolina too. He had back and knee problems. He was incredible during his first few seasons until his body caught up with him. He had a .908 career save percentage and every season between 08-12 was above a .915.

[@jacobfleenor3497]

He also played 74 games in the 10-11 season

[@boland73]

The Jennings is now what the Vezina used to be. Just given to the goalie with the best goals against average... which gives older goalies an advantage because it made the Vezina easier to win & that trophy means more than a Jennings does today

[@mumineaux]

Mike Richter won the cup in 1994, not in the hall. 3x all-star along with his jersey retired in the garden. think he should at least be on a shortlist for the hall...

[@wilnerolivier7971]

Don't forget his performance at the inaugural World Cup of Hockey where he almost singlehandedly beat a loaded Canadian squad that featured Gretzky, Lindros, Messier, Yzerman & Stevens. He also was great at the 2002 Winter games in Salt Lake City where he helped the U.S. earn Silver.

[@Daslatcher]

The bar is higher, something that has to do with it is there's only 1(well, 2, but you get what I mean) per an active roster, while there's 6 defensemen, and 12 forwards. Makes you wonder though about the stats, how many forwards per goalies, or even dmen are there in the Hall?

[@keving4408]

If there's debate about Grant Fuhr, there should be debate about Ken Dryden. As you noted, Fuhr played for a team that was allergic to defence. Dryden played for possibly the most complete team in NHL history. With Robinson, Lapointe, Savard et al protecting him (all HOFers) , Dryden likely faced very few high quality chances per game. By contrast, most of the shots Fuhr faced were high quality chances.

[@jaredcampbell]

IMO Barrasso should 100% be in already, he deserves it the most of the players not in that are currently eligible. I also feel Vernon, Moog, Osgood and Joseph should all already be in.

[@amyfielder8727]

Pekka Rinne has been a foundational player for Nashville and is on this list. Regardless of Cup, which I hope is coming soon for him, he deserves to be in the HoF. Vezina, best Finish Goaltender ever, continues to set records and a lot of years as Nashville was establishing this team, he was the team. My opinion, yes, standards are too hard considering the hardware available to this position and impact on team.

[@37willdog]

Career save percentage should be the most important factor, but the era they played in should also be taken into account as well (a good save percentage in the 80s isn’t comparable to a good save percentage during dead puck or post-lockout)

[@JM-yn8mb]

Luongo, Lundqvist, Fleury, Price... Price will get one... Luongo and Lundqvist both lost in the finals... Their wins make up for it... Not to mention they all have gold medals too!

[@heyitsbranigan]

Price will win a cup?? In Montreal? How lmao

[@JM-yn8mb]

​@@heyitsbranigan, Montreal has a good young core at the moment. If they had added Tavares in free agency, they would've been right at the top... Drouin, Domi, Weber, Gallagher, they'll get Kovalchuk back... They need to add a first-line center and maybe a D-man and they'll be a contender...

[@murray1978]

Quick is a shoo in.

[@SolidPain6624]

Quick belongs in the hall. 2 cup wins, Conn Smythe, best American goalie of all time.

[@SolidPain6624]

Otto Zizak clueless

[@jfriesen39]

As a viewer from Thailand, I'd like to see a video about where your viewers come from and how many you have in each country.

[@OttawaNow]

Only 5 times in Hockey Hall of Fame history have they inducted more than one goaltender in the same year. The last time was in 1980. 3 were inducted in 1958 and 3 were inducted in 1961. 1945: Charlie Gardiner 1945: Georges Vezina 1958: Alec Connell 1958: Hugh Lehman 1958: Paddy Moran 1961: George Hainsworth 1961: Percy LeSueur 1961: Oliver Seibert 1963: Riley Hern 1963: John Bower Hutton 1980: Harry Lumley 1980: Gump Worsley

[@father042]

Tony Esposito was a member of 1969 Canadiens stnaley cup team but he only played 13 games for them

[@DjDannyBeee]

I didn't scroll down but you've got Tony Esposito having no cups. He was on the 68-69 Canadiens that won a cup. He should've won at least one in Chicago however.

[@dalepopula2473]

He only played 4 regular season game as was backup for the Cup.

[@nathanlarson310]

He should be in for the 15 shutouts, that will probably never be surpassed

[@aaronjohnson3463]

Leave Esposito on that Canadiens team and his shutout totals you can add at least 30 more

[@aaronjohnson3463]

He's got Harry Lumley retiring in 1940 🤡🤡🤡

[@snakeknife7518]

@@dalepopula2473 He actually played 13 games in reg. season none in playoff.

[@romangagne5842]

I'd argue Arturs Irbe deserves a nomination to the HOF. Latvian pioneer, Led both the Sharks and Canes to the Playoffs and almost won a Cup with the Canes. Sure he didn't win any Cups or Vezina's but he played for a long period of time

[@romangagne5842]

@Daniel Treadwell Fair enough

[@OttawaNow]

You said 1980 was the only year where they inducted more than one goalie. You were wrong. 01. 1945: Charlie Gardiner * Georges Vezina 02. 1958: Alec Connell * Hugh Lehman * Paddy Moran 03. 1961: George Hainsworth * Percy LeSueur * Oliver Seibert 04. 1963: Riley Hern * John Bower Hutton 05. 1980: Harry Lumley * Gump Worsley

[@midimusicforever]

King Henrik!

[@Leafsdude]

I go: Fleury, Lundqvist, Joseph, Price, Quick in Luongo, Miller, Giguere as unsure (maybe in a down year where there's not many names to consider). The rest as close but no.

[@edwardofgreene]

Vladislav Tretiak was inducted in 1989. I know it wasn't in the NHL, but I feel he should not be left off any lists. The best goalie of his time. On a very short list of best all time.

[@DickieDarkside]

Miikka Kiprusoff started late, but was dominant for long enough that I believe he deserves to be in.

[@thefiddleronthegreen]

Here's an interesting question, now that we know the playoff format for this year (and that Montreal is still in it, fingers crossed): say by some miracle Montreal wins the cup this year, getting Price that 1 cup. Does that cup maybe have an asterisk on it for HoF voting?

[@jacquesuntel5401]

Carey Price for sure. You didn't mention the other trophies he won... four in one season as I recall... and when he's on his game he's still the most feared goalie -- toughest to play against, according to other players -- in the NHL.

[@damonwebb813]

Food for thought Between 1988-89 through to 2007-2008 19 years Roy, Hasek,Brodeur had 13 of those Vezinas, not room for anyone else to win. Belfour had 2 and you could say he deserves a couple of more Olzag had one, deserved at least 2 more .kipper deserved another one or two, but that's what happens when you have 3 HOF goalies in a short span, they were that good, and consistent

[@Nickleblanc41]

That 2nd Cup for Hasek was as a back up

[@TheBunnyBunz]

After Hasek faltered, Chris Osgood carried us to Lord Stanley in 2008.. Ozzie was 1 win away from a repeat in 2009.. He deserves the hall.

[@kentboersema9995]

you forget how he was screwed out of a cup in 1999. foot in the crease. also if you look at the roster Buffalo had around Hasek for most of his career was not up to par to some of the other teams during the pre salary cap era.

[@milanfrk7710]

Being 43 years old (a year ago having SV% .923 and GAA 1,79 in 18 play-off games).

[@philippemarois5828]

It’s definitely more difficult for goalies to be HOF. I truly believe that Vernon, Moog and Barrasso are all deserving to be enshrine in the HHOF! I think that Fleury and Lundqvist are going to be voted in when they come available once they retire.

[@CarharttCowboy]

Barasso is a no doubter in my books. One of the best seasons for a rookie netminder ever

[@davyt0247]

Hey Shannon, was there an issue with the audio? You sounded different than usual, I think there’s an echo

[@jacquesuntel5401]

audio gain cranked up too high led to some distortion

[@davyt0247]

Jacques Untel thanks I knew it sounded different than normal

[@Kn0wka]

I may be wrong, but doesn't the HHOF consider international play when it comes to inducting players? If so, players like Luongo, Price, and Miller who placed at the Olympics should get a boost

[@elwizschold]

Ozzy and Cujo needs to be inducted, ASAP.

[@mamaji277]

6:26 Man I was thinking to myself, "is that all hes gonna talk about? Goalies in the hall?" All of a sudden I see that next board and I knew shit was real

[@matthewpaluch777]

😎👍🇺🇸🇨🇦🏒🥅🏆 Thanks for the props Shannon! As a card carrying member of the Goaltenders union all I can say is... " GOALIES RULE! "

[@sdgakatbk]

AHEM!! Billy Smith is on the list of big game goaltenders!! In fact, I put him on my very short list of goalies I want in there for a tight game 7 or an elimination game!!

[@tsgpk9184]

chris Osgood. His career stats in Detroit are amazing, even his empty net goal & what he did in the 08 season was also amazing

[@wilnerolivier7971]

What hurts Osgood's case for the HOF is that he was too inconsistent at the beginning of his career!! Had his play in the 2nd act of his career been somewhat reflected when he was starting out he would have a much better chance of getting in.

[@BrettHornby]

Goalies do seem to be held to a higher standard for induction. Top three listed in Roberto Luongo, Marc-Andre Fleury and Henrik Lundqvist I'd confidently put in when eligible. Say Mike Vernon part biast and numbers with hardware. Curtis Joseph did prop up some teams due to his play is a maybe. Chris Osgood gets knock against that he's success was only with Detroit but was a part of Stanley Cup wins. Same with Tom Barrasso but those goalies could come in on leaner classes or many years later.

[@ghostspectre1861]

I'm biased, but Curtis Joseph was on another plain of existence at times. I'd love to see him in the Hall of Fame.

[@OttawaNow]

2020 UPDATE 43 GOALTENDERS IN THE HOCKEY HALL OF FAME 01. 1945: Charlie Gardiner 02. 1945: Georges Vezina 03. 1947: Lester Patrick 04. 1958: Alec Connell 05. 1958: Hugh Lehman 06. 1958: Paddy Moran 07. 1959: Tiny Thompson 08. 1961: George Hainsworth 09. 1961: Percy LeSueur 10. 1961: Oliver Seibert 11. 1962: Harry Westwick 12. 1963: Riley Hern 13. 1963: John Bower Hutton 14. 1964: Bill Durnan 15. 1965: Clint Benedict 16. 1966: Frank Brimsek 17. 1967: Turk Broda 18. 1969: Roy Worters 19. 1971: Terry Sawchuk 20. 1972: Hap Holmes 21. 1973: Chuck Rayner 22. 1975: Glenn Hall 23. 1976: Johnny Bower 24. 1978: Jacques Plante 25. 1980: Harry Lumley 26. 1980: Gump Worsley 27. 1982: Emile Francis (Builder Category) 28. 1983: Ken Dryden 29. 1984: Bernie Parent 30. 1985: Gerry Cheevers 31. 1987: Ed Giacomin 32. 1988: Tony Esposito 33. 1989: Vladislav Tretiak 34. 1993: Billy Smith 35. 2003: Grant Fuhr 36. 2006: Patrick Roy 37. 2011: Ed Belfour 38. 2014: Dominik Hasek 39. 2016: Rogie Vachon 40. 2018: Martin Brodeur 41. 2019: Jim Rutherford (Builder Category) 42. 2020: Ken Holland (Builder Category) 43. 2020: Kim St-Pierre

[@andyvu1325]

just a quick thought.. since it’s the Hockey Hall of Fame, shouldn’t international competitons such as Olympic medals and World Cup (only as of now..) also have some weight? I’m not talking deal breakers but some consideration?

[@poonking3628]

The fact that Barasso & Vernon aren't in the HOF but guys like Giacomin, Esposito, and Cheevers are in is OUTRAGEOU!

[@OttawaNow]

Yes, they should call it the Rod Langway Trophy for Best Defensive Defencemen.

[@sunsandkings]

Curious if you were to expand your thoughts on the Ryan Miller trade to St Louis. I remember being so sure the Blues were going all the way when they got Miller even though their goaltending was solid before the trade, and then... well.

[@danjacques77]

Out of those that are retired ... Luongo is the only one that should get in .. Maybe Cujo, having played for Toronto will eventually help his case.

[@cassetteclassics86]

Goalies have it way harder. Forwards have some established bars to achieve to be a hOfer. Even defenseman can use that standard to some extent. But goalies have no standards since the stat keeping has changed drastically for their position

[@ukyboy4073]

Talk about goalies more. Really enjoy the videos

[@boland73]

Fleury should be going to the HOF, absolutely no doubt about it that he’s better than some that are already in there. It doesn’t matter that he doesn’t have a Vezina, he proved that when the Pens were done with him & thought he was washed up... he came out and had the best season of his career and carried Vegas to the Stanley Cup Final in their very first year as a team! He should arguably have a Conn Smythe too but they just handed it to Crosby by default

[@bikingD]

Most underrated goalie who needs to be in all day long with the amount of awards. Stanley cup final. Not even on your list Olaf Kolzig.

[@jessiegandhi4340]

It’s a crime that Chris Osgood isn’t the HHOF, and for skaters(Mogilny)

[@allsystemsgo8678]

I agree about Mogilny. Osgood no

[@Zamppa86]

Osgood is pretty much the most overrated goalie of the modern era. Sure he has wins and cups but he also played for Detroit before the salary cap which reduces the value of those stats some. Osgood was good but no way HOF level.

[@bradhoff]

Osgood is 4th in playoff shutouts. 50 regular season shut outs. He was second in Conn's Smythe voting in 08 and 09. 401 wins and still put up numbers with horrible nyi and STL teams. 17 straight years in the playoffs Osgood belongs more than fuhr.

[@OttawaNow]

41 Goaltenders in the Hockey Hall of Fame 01. 1945: Charlie Gardiner 02. 1945: Georges Vezina 03. 1947: Lester Patrick 04. 1958: Alec Connell 05. 1958: Hugh Lehman 06. 1958: Paddy Moran 07. 1959: Tiny Thompson 08. 1961: George Hainsworth 09. 1961: Percy LeSueur 10. 1961: Oliver Seibert 11. 1962: Harry Westwick 12. 1963: Riley Hern 13. 1963: John Bower Hutton 14. 1964: Bill Durnan 15. 1965: Clint Benedict 16. 1966: Frank Brimsek 17. 1967: Turk Broda 18. 1969: Roy Worters 19. 1971: Terry Sawchuk 20. 1972: Hap Holmes 21. 1973: Chuck Rayner 22. 1975: Glenn Hall 23. 1976: Johnny Bower 24. 1978: Jacques Plante 25. 1980: Harry Lumley 26. 1980: Gump Worsley 27. 1982: Emile Francis (Builders Category) 28. 1983: Ken Dryden 29. 1984: Bernie Parent 30. 1985: Gerry Cheevers 31. 1987: Ed Giacomin 32. 1988: Tony Esposito 33. 1989: Vladislav Tretiak 34. 1993: Billy Smith 35. 2003: Grant Fuhr 36. 2006: Patrick Roy 37. 2011: Ed Belfour 38. 2014: Dominik Hasek 39. 2016: Rogie Vachon 40. 2018: Martin Brodeur 41. 2019: Jim Rutherford (Builders Category)

[@TheHockeyGuy]

www.hhof.com/LegendsOfHockey/jsp/LegendsPlayersByPosition.jsp?pos=G

[@OttawaNow]

@@TheHockeyGuy Oliver Seibert - 1961

[@OttawaNow]

@@TheHockeyGuy They are counting Lester Patrick because he once played emergency goaltender when Lorne Chabot was injured, and the Rangers won the Cup with Lester in net. But they are not showing his stats as a goaltender.

[@OttawaNow]

@@TheHockeyGuy Harry Westwick - 1962

[@OttawaNow]

@@TheHockeyGuy Emile Francis and Jim Rutherford not included on the list because they were inducted in the builders category. That brings the total to 41.

[@maverik094]

If Quick can get to 400 wins he might be in the Hall. Fleury is a HOF i think.

[@Vladiator01]

Kipper should be in the hall of fame

[@coachrobwille4176]

What is a Rover ?

[@DARK24-7]

Good point it does seem the goalies fall out of favor very rapidly.

[@angusofmangus621]

Miikka Kiprusoff: 319 career wins, 1 vezina on a team that struggled to make the playoffs.

[@jerryjhudson]

Corey Crawford, deserves to go in. 260 career wins so far and 2 Stanley Cups.

[@USAF-mt1tu]

I believe Tim Thomas belongs in the hall. He set NHL records, won 2 vezina trophy, Conn Symth and a Stanley Cup. I also believe that you can make an argument that the NHL should make a journeyman wing for people like Tim Thomas.

[@OttawaNow]

I think Fuhr petitioned and got his name on the 5th Edmonton Cup too! Fuhr played 21 games for Edmonton in the 1989-1990 season. It's 5 for Fuhr, not 4.

[@TheHockeyGuy]

He officially has 4 Cups.

[@OttawaNow]

​@@TheHockeyGuy Fuhr was on the ice and celebrated with the rest of the team for the 5th Cup. Yes I know he did not play. I will have to read the names on the Cup again when I go to Toronto.