Which Pickup to Choose?! Lollar Pickup Comparison on Collings 290s

Chris from Maple Street Guitars compares neck pickups on 3 Collings 290s.
From Lollar: P90, Charlie Christian and a Staple P90

[@liv2praz]

love the staple. more clarity on the top and more punch at the same time.

[@noahtrock]

I prefer the Charlie Christian warmth, but I wouldn't pass on any of the options. Option D - all the above!

[@ccfmafia3301]

Staple: had the most low-end thump. Sounded the most acoustic and woody to me (similar vibe to a floating pickup). This really stood out on the second riff you played. CC: had the fewest highs, and to me, sounded the mellowest (maybe more mid content in this one?) Classic p90: nice and lively! The staple was my favorite. What did you think in the room?

[@LawtonChiles]

Both choose both