Who Created God?

[@mrd.808]

God was not created. God always existed. Our brains cannot comprehend this understanding.

[@mike8984ify]

Or the cosmos was not created, and the cosmos always existed. Because our brains can't comprehend that, they come up with invisible men in the sky to worship

[@paulorobertosilva8794]

⁠@@mike8984ifyI see your claim but I don’t see any evidence of it

[@bradrochow9181]

@@mike8984ifyGod said that he always existed, I wasn’t there to confirm that, but there is evidence that God spoke truth to people who wrote down prophecies and history.

[@unholywarrior9007]

God is just like us he has a mother and father. We're not Pinocchio. Neither is God . Geppetto didn't make us or God a pet or slave. Man being created is symbolism let me prove it . Luke chapter 3 has the genealogy of Jesus let me just post the end of the genealogy Luke 3 38 kjv wich was the son of Enos wich was the son of Seth wich was the son of Adam wich was the son of God. .. ah thete we go God is our grandfather. Need more convincing? Psalms 82 kjv God standeth in the congregation of the mighty he judgeth umong the gods 6 I have said ye are little gods children of the most high. .... Roman's 8 16 kjv the Spirit itself beareth witness with our spirits that we are children of God. ... now I hope you don't try to tell us the Holy Spirit is lying to us about this . .so we have both Jesus and the holy spirt telling us we're children of God . 1st corinthians 15 kjv 37 and that wich though soweth thow soweth not that body wich shall be but bare grain it may be chance of wheat or if some other grain 38 but God giveth it a body as it has pleased him to every Seed his OWN Seed . ... We have God's seed we're not created. And if you didn't get the vs if you plant say wheat do you sometimes get a different grain like rye ? Now you might want to read the chapter slowly you should find God is earthly and has a body . Just incase you miss it ill give you a 2end scripture showing God isn't a spirit Mathew 16 15 he saieth unto them but whom say ye that I am 16 and Simon petter answered and said thou art the Christ the son of the Living God. ... living not a ghost . Now I could post stuff from John 5 but thos should do .

[@bradrochow9181]

@@Bill_Garthright John 1:1-5 Jesus was in the beginning God and with God. All things were created by Jesus, who claimed and proved that he is God.

[@tyamada21]

A segment from 'Saved by the Light of the Buddha Within'... My new understandings of what many call 'God -The Holy Spirit' - resulting from some of the extraordinary ongoing after-effects relating to my NDE... Myoho-Renge-Kyo represents the identity of what some scientists are now referring to as the unified field of consciousnesses. In other words, it’s the essence of all existence and non-existence - the ultimate creative force behind planets, stars, nebulae, people, animals, trees, fish, birds, and all phenomena, manifest or latent. All matter and intelligence are simply waves or ripples manifesting to and from this core source. Consciousness (enlightenment) is itself the actual creator of everything that exists now, ever existed in the past, or will exist in the future - right down to the minutest particles of dust - each being an individual ripple or wave. The big difference between chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo and most other conventional prayers is that instead of depending on a ‘middleman’ to connect us to our state of inner enlightenment, we’re able to do it ourselves. That’s because chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo allows us to tap directly into our enlightened state by way of this self-produced sound vibration. ‘Who or What Is God?’ If we compare the concept of God being a separate entity that is forever watching down on us, to the teachings of Nichiren, it makes more sense to me that the true omnipotence, omniscience and omnipresence of what most people perceive to be God, is the fantastic state of enlightenment that exists within each of us. Some say that God is an entity that’s beyond physical matter - I think that the vast amount of information continuously being conveyed via electromagnetic waves in today’s world gives us proof of how an invisible state of God could indeed exist. For example, it’s now widely known that specific data relayed by way of electromagnetic waves has the potential to help bring about extraordinary and powerful effects - including an instant global awareness of something or a mass emotional reaction. It’s also common knowledge that these invisible waves can easily be used to detonate a bomb or to enable NASA to control the movements of a robot as far away as the Moon or Mars - none of which is possible without a receiver to decode the information that’s being transmitted. Without the receiver, the data would remain impotent. In a very similar way, we need to have our own ‘receiver’ switched on so that we can activate a clear and precise understanding of our own life, all other life and what everything else in existence is. Chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo each day helps us to achieve this because it allows us to reach the core of our enlightenment and keep it switched on. That’s because Myoho-Renge-Kyo represents the identity of what scientists now refer to as the unified field of consciousnesses. To break it down - Myoho represents the Law of manifestation and latency (Nature) and consists of two alternating states. For example, the state of Myo is where everything in life that’s not obvious to us exists - including our stored memories when we’re not thinking about them - our hidden potential and inner emotions whenever they’re dormant - our desires, our fears, our wisdom, happiness, karma - and more importantly, our enlightenment. The other state, ho, is where everything in Life exists whenever it becomes evident to us, such as when a thought pops up from within our memory - whenever we experience or express our emotions - or whenever a good or bad cause manifests as an effect from our karma. When anything becomes apparent, it merely means that it’s come out of the state of Myo (dormancy/latency) and into a state of ho (manifestation). It’s the difference between consciousness and unconsciousness, being awake or asleep, or knowing and not knowing. The second law - Renge - Ren meaning cause and ge meaning effect, governs and controls the functions of Myoho - these two laws of Myoho and Renge, not only function together simultaneously but also underlies all spiritual and physical existence. The final and third part of the tri-combination - Kyo, is the Law that allows Myoho to integrate with Renge - or vice versa. It’s the great, invisible thread of energy that fuses and connects all Life and matter - as well as the past, present and future. It’s also sometimes termed the Universal Law of Communication - perhaps it could even be compared with the string theory that many scientists now suspect exists. Just as the cells in our body, our thoughts, feelings and everything else is continually fluctuating within us - all that exists in the world around us and beyond is also in a constant state of flux - constantly controlled by these three fundamental laws. In fact, more things are going back and forth between the two states of Myo and ho in a single moment than it would ever be possible to calculate or describe. And it doesn’t matter how big or small, famous or trivial anything or anyone may appear to be, everything that’s ever existed in the past, exists now or will exist in the future, exists only because of the workings of the Laws ‘Myoho-Renge-Kyo’ - the basis of the four fundamental forces, and if they didn’t function, neither we nor anything else could go on existing. That’s because all forms of existence, including the seasons, day, night, birth, death and so on, are moving forward in an ongoing flow of continuation - rhythmically reverting back and forth between the two fundamental states of Myo and ho in absolute accordance with Renge - and by way of Kyo. Even stars are dying and being reborn under the workings of what the combination ‘Myoho-Renge-Kyo’ represents. Nam, or Namu - which mean the same thing, are vibrational passwords or keys that allow us to reach deep into our life and fuse with or become one with ‘Myoho-Renge-Kyo’. On a more personal level, nothing ever happens by chance or coincidence, it’s the causes that we’ve made in our past, or are presently making, that determine how these laws function uniquely in each of our lives - as well as the environment from moment to moment. By facing east, in harmony with the direction that the Earth is spinning, and chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo for a minimum of, let’s say, ten minutes daily to start with, any of us can experience actual proof of its positive effects in our lives - even if it only makes us feel good on the inside, there will be a definite positive effect. That’s because we’re able to pierce through the thickest layers of our karma and activate our inherent Buddha Nature (our enlightened state). By so doing, we’re then able to bring forth the wisdom and good fortune that we need to challenge, overcome and change our adverse circumstances - turn them into positive ones - or manifest and gain even greater fulfilment in our daily lives from our accumulated good karma. This also allows us to bring forth the wisdom that can free us from the ignorance and stupidity that’s preventing us from accepting and being proud of the person that we indeed are - regardless of our race, colour, gender or sexuality. We’re also able to see and understand our circumstances and the environment far more clearly, as well as attract and connect with any needed external beneficial forces and situations. As I’ve already mentioned, everything is subject to the law of Cause and Effect - the ‘actual-proof-strength’ resulting from chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo always depends on our determination, sincerity and dedication. For example, the levels of difference could be compared to making a sound on a piano, creating a melody, producing a great song, and so on. Something else that’s very important to always respect and acknowledge is that the Law (or if you prefer God) is in everyone and everything. NB: There are frightening and disturbing sounds, and there are tranquil and relaxing sounds. It’s the emotional result of any noise or sound that can trigger off a mood or even instantly change one. When chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo each day, we are producing a sound vibration that’s the password to our true inner-self - this soon becomes apparent when you start reassessing your views on various things - such as your fears and desires etc. The best way to get the desired result when chanting is not to view things conventionally - rather than reaching out to an external source, we need to reach into our own lives and bring our needs and desires to fruition from within - including the good fortune and strength to achieve any help that we may need. Chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo also reaches out externally and draws us towards, or draws towards us, what we need to make us happy from our environment. For example, it helps us to be in the right place at the right time - to make better choices and decisions and so forth. We need to think of it as a seed within us that we’re watering and bringing sunshine to for it to grow, blossom and bring forth fruit or flowers. It’s also important to understand that everything we need in life, including the answer to every question and the potential to achieve every dream, already exists within us.

[@brandone.5106]

I’ve never understood why anyone thinks this is a good question from anyone but a child. If God is properly explained, the question shouldn’t arise.

[@caitlinjohnny3828]

Facts

[@mike8984ify]

Just like anyone that thinks "the cosmos has always existed" hasn't had the cosmos properly explained to them, which gets rid of any reason to posit an eternal god.

[@spamm0145]

@@mike8984ify The cosmos is not properly understood and has many phenomena that puzzle scientists, it is mostly theory with lots of assumption and science has verified the universe is incredibly fine tuned for life. We have math which is an abstract concept and can only reside in a mind, before life existed the universe had precise mathematical laws, where did these laws that require a complex understanding of math come from without a mind to comprehend them? That's right GOD.

[@bbjornr]

the only reason athiests ever ask the question is in response to christians asserting that everything has to have a creator. So, an athiest will respond "if everything has a creator, who created god"?

[@caitlinjohnny3828]

@bbjornrud ah I get it now

[@darrylmarius2239]

Disembodied, ultradementional, ALL the qualities of perfection & to top it off Love personified perfectly!🤯

[@ddpeter4444]

Love personified??? He says we MUST love him otherwise we burn in fire for eternity. WTF kind of love is that? It's like a jealous boyfriend saying, "I love you but if you leave me for someone else, I will kill you".

[@zerosteel0123]

If something or someone had to create God, then he wouldn't be God.

[@mantralibre1367]

They don't get it, as simple as it is.

[@teks-kj1nj]

Exactly, something even greater than god MUST therefore exist. Nothing eternal (god) can exist without being created by something that exists outside of eternity. Don't worry that your can't comprehend that, it's just a limitation of your mind, you just have to accept that it is true - because 'there is no other explanation' (I'm just applying christian logic)

[@rizdekd3912]

@@mantralibre1367 that’s called special pleading, ie to posit something that explains some quandary by just saying it solves it but without any explanation of the kind you might ask of the naturalist who says that the natural world possesses all the things needed to explain what we are aware of.

[@rizdekd3912]

@@teks-kj1njand indeed any explanation for the basics is going to end up sounding like ‘it just is’

[@Gilvids]

"Who created God?" question is the same as "what happens after forever?" question.

[@Hydroverse]

There are different levels of infinity.

[@mantralibre1367]

@@adelinomorte7421 absolutely. Or it could be the contrary. However the hegemonic one would be a qualitative being, say - spiritual, in which the other is.

[@sophistrydebunker]

​@@mantralibre1367 Who cares? Why does it even matter? Believers think they're right with no proof. Atheist think they're right trying to leverage things like science, which also is not 100% proof(although it's premise is much more believable). There will never be a 100% proven without a doubt answer.

[@Not_InterestedThankYou]

Amazing answers & explanations...LOVED IT !!

[@Thefrogsaint]

The question how do you know the Christian God is the right God? Answer …prophecy God declares the end from the beginning so that when it comes to pass you know He is God. Time space and matter are tied together. God progressively reveals Himself in His word proving He is the first cause and transcends the material world. Observation of the material world will give you general revelation and points to His attributes, but it’s prophecy the gives special Revelation.

[@alanpfeiffer9686]

Isaiah 53 prophecy of Jesus Christ and His death on the cross , it was fulfilled you should open the bible and read Isaiah chapter 53 for your self then read the gospels and see how the events unfold . @@Bill_Garthright

[@ddpeter4444]

Reveals himself? When, where? A bunch of obscure signs that some interpret as miracles. Why would he just not reveal himself so there is no mystery? I know, for true believers there is no mystery but for people with half a brain, belief in something without demonstrable proof is just stupid.

[@cathy7382]

​@@ddpeter4444Au contraire belief or faith in something you can't see doesn't make it untrue Have you ever seen subatomic matter? Just because you can't see God doesn't mean that He isn't real I know He's real changed my life and answers prayers

[@ddpeter4444]

@@cathy7382 Faith in something you cannot see is illogical. I agree, I have not seen subatomic particles, but I trust science. I have never seen a flying spaghetti monster, so does it make sense to believe that one exists. I have no evidence of either. Please tell me what evidence you have that God exists other than your feelings. Real evidence does not exist.

[@cathy7382]

@@ddpeter4444 just look around at the wonderful works that God has created if there's a building someone had to make it a painting is made by an artist All I know is God drastically changed my life, it's not a matter of feelings

[@Justalil27]

I love your channel ❤️

[@johngreenstreet9347]

If only we had the humility to say we don't know.

[@IAMhassentyou-h5w]

1 Peter 5:8 Be alert and of sober mind. Your enemy the devil prowls around like a roaring lion looking for someone to devour.

[@BingGeaux]

@11:29 - the Psalmists do talk about how "the heavens declare the glory of the LORD" and it is mistranslated 'universe' to promote the heliocentric model. The word 'heavens' is not synonymous with the word 'universe'. In prior translations it reads, "the firmament declares God's handiwork" but more of the argument here is that the sun, if a hydrogen ball of gasses burning for millennia, has been burning long before the earth was formed by gravitational forces and elements colliding, but God explains that the sun is a light placed in the firmament long after the earth was established, then how can you reconcile the rest of the Bible as truth if you reject the "beginning".

[@lannybrasher2452]

It can take millions of years for a collection of gasses to fuse and explode into a sun.

[@wausauaaron7737]

Thank you Father in heaven for blessing us with people like Don. His answers to difficult questions are some of the simplest I’ve heard. In a good way. I’ve gone so far as to write these down so if I’ve ever encounter a sceptic I have the confidence and faith to respond…which is not always easy.

[@Dominick13777]

It is said by some, that time is eternal. However, those that say "who created God" are admitting to us that they themselves know that they are created. This means that they understand intuitively, that time is not eternal. (Psalm 102:26; Isaiah 51:6; 2 Peter 3:10; Matthew 5:18; Hebrews 12:27) Time has a beginning and an end. Therefore, since we are a creation, are ability to understand God's eternal nature is inconceivable. Job 11:7 “Can you fathom the mysteries of God? Can you probe the limits of the Almighty?

[@Wmeester1971]

"Time has a beginning and an end" We don't know whether time has an end. There is no evidence it has. I'm not even sure whether it has a beginning.

[@brunobastos5533]

no we just asking who create him

[@priscillajervey8345]

Please tell me the name of the expert "schlor" in this interview. I have searched his video on evolution vs Scriptures???

[@JRTIGER07]

Saw the shorts on this , im glad i came to watch the whole interview 🙏 Praise God for your guy's knowledge and Sharing it 🙏 I'll have to watch again to get all the big words used lol God bless 🕊 Yeshua Messiah is Lord 🕊

[@recoveringknowitall1534]

"I don't know, but i Believe"

[@jameshale6401]

Your not alone no one knows

[@dkhes1]

Pheno! Great job men! You've whet and satisfied my appetite tonight! To God be all the glory thru Christ Jesus Amen.

[@joykeebler1916]

- the Cross of Zero-Point Gravity is explained as the Nothing in Astrophysics and the Cross was personally added to description

[@joshlheureux1194]

The “Who created God” question is dumb . It clearly states in the Bible that God is the beginning and the end which means he was never created and the creator of everything. If God was created he wouldn’t be God.

[@rolandjosef7961]

My toughest question as a Theist is that, why is it that outside time and space and matter, the default is there is an eternal God? Where he came from and how did he come into existence.

[@MatthewPeeters-l7i]

Good question. I would recommend this article: Who created God? - creation.com/who-created-god

[@jstube36]

That "Default" is instilled in most from childhood. It's also instilled to never put that default to any doubt or question. But we humans are a naturally curious species. So when we are told to not even dare ask questions about things once thought to be infallible. We take that as a green light to question. Think of this thought. It may be so that this Universe does have a creator source. The issues is the identity of said creator source. It might not be what most expect.

[@globalcoupledances]

"outside time and space and matter," is nonsensical

[@jendarame]

You’re pointing to observational evidence that there are no other universes and yet you have no observational evidence that “god” exists. I think what needs to be clarified BEFORE you start the conversation is to DEFINE god. But you keep bringing up the Bible and so now I know what I’m dealing with. I’m out ✌🏼

[@spamm0145]

This is what I love about atheists and evolution lovers, they won't accept that life was created but always question who created your god. In this realm God created, everything needs a beginning, this is what we always observe and we are bound by this law that things need to be created. God is outside of this and has always existed. God is powerful beyond our understanding, his perceptions are limitless and because of this time is different for God, in a single second he can have more thoughts than every person who has ever lived or will live. He is beyond human comprehension and no matter how advanced our technologies become we can never know his greatness.

[@seansstepbystep1]

AMEN!!! HALLELUYAH!!

[@mantralibre1367]

Man, the reason is pretty simple. First: you have evidence of the cosmos - and logic says that the cosmos IS everything. It's quantic, as we now know. You don't have evidence of "god ". Second: the act of creating something implies the fact that space and time exist, and that you live in a space and time. Hence, if this universe was created it was not by a god, it would be a sort of simulation.

[@cosmasmbuzi.1467]

The question "who created God?". Now we are told in scripture that "For by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him:" Colossians 1:16. This means God created himself, for "all things were created by him."

[@mantralibre1367]

Occam would say the cosmos was not created, since you have evidence of the latter, and none of former. It's not that we cannot conceive god. We cannot conceive a "beginning". That's why we make up god.

[@IgnatiusVaz]

No! God did not create himself! That's a Paradox you stated. For God to create himself, he would have to pre-exist, be outside of himself - Moreover, created Gods do not exist. Best Answer : Like the bible implies, God existed always and is uncreated. He is eternal, the Beginning and the End - Infinite He is the first cause ! God is a mystery that our finite mind cannot comprehend May be in eternity, (heaven) we could ask God to reveal this mystery

[@jasonlloyd4156]

I'm not religious and i don't go around raping and killing people. Having good morals is not a religious idea, i treat other people how i would like to be treated.

[@timlenord1]

But atheist accuse you of throwing stones from a glass house when you ask them what caused the Universe but can't answer what caused God. 🤔

[@mike8984ify]

"I don't know" is an intellectually honest answer, unlike "because God". The point is that both positions have a brute fact of "it always existed" at their core, which shows that "God" isn't a better answer.

[@brunobastos5533]

Lol, it always been there, is you that can grasp that

[@mantralibre1367]

An atheist usually understands that the concept of creation is contradictory both to a universe AND to a God.

[@grasonicus]

I created a comment giving the full answer. Look higher up.

[@sinclairj7492]

@@mike8984ify” I don’t know” is by definition Not an answer, it means you don’t have an answer.

[@Critter145]

“Who created God” is a contradiction. It assumes God isn’t God because He would have to be made, and if posits a Divine Supreme Being. The question itself makes a claim for an omniscient omnipresent omnipotent God, just not the Christian one…

[@Jigglepoke]

You can't have have an "irreducibly complex" argument evolution and the say the most complex thing known to humans was just always there. Didn't learn anything, he always knew everything. Didn't grow in love, he always was love, didn't create power, he just is power. If he was fully formed in all things, what motivated him to create?

[@fahadraza7916]

I am a Muslim and your arguments are damn solid, Sir! Thank You very much for sharing them!

[@BrandoTheBald]

very under-appreciated channel

[@Sola_Scriptura_1.618]

I can't wait to meet God when my time comes. I hope I am on the elevator going up and not the one going down. I can't wait for all the answers to be revealed to me, one miricle at a time. I pray for the atheists and the wicked so that maybe they, too, will be welcomed into heaven and they can share in the knowledge and eternal life. God bless.

[@rizdekd3912]

@@Sola_Scriptura_1.618 do you also pray for those who despite thinking they are worshipping Jesus will be told he doesn’t recognize them because they didn’t do the will of the father. IOW it’s not the obviously wicked and atheists who are in trouble but anyone who, because they are on the outside, will not understand and will be lost. Wide is the path that leads to destruction and many will follow but narrow is the way to salvation and few will find it. And it’ll be too late to do anything about once you find out.

[@Sola_Scriptura_1.618]

@rizdekd3912 Do you read scripture? Christ is clear as to what is required for eternal life; we just need to accept his grace. John 3:16. God will judge us according to his expectations of us. He knows what opportunities were provided and how we responded to said opportunities. God is great, God is just.

[@Hydroverse]

I don't believe in something out of nothing, so wherever that leads me is what I believe.

[@caitlinjohnny3828]

Well energy can't be "created" and you still utilize it.

[@mike8984ify]

You realize there are practically no atheist that believe something came out of nothing, right? Nothing about that conclusion requires a god.

[@caitlinjohnny3828]

🤔 I'm stuck on how people think we could get our morals from monkeys 🐒

[@spamm0145]

@@mike8984ify An atheist has to believe all matter came from nothing and complexity beyond human capabilities created itself without the need for intelligent design, which has never ever been observed, highly complex mechanisms utilising purposefully sequenced information ALWAYS necessitates and intelligent mind, atheism requires a special pleading for a mechanism never observed. Considering 'observation' is a massive part of science, this is a huge problem for atheism and requires a suspension of reality, that complexity requires higher and higher levels of intelligent input the more sophistication increases.

[@mike8984ify]

​@@spamm0145Nope. I'm an atheist and I don't believe all matter came from nothing. So your reply is obviously false. I don't know what "complexity beyond human capabilities" means. Are you familiar with Cellular Automatons? Very simple rules can produce complexity "beyond human capability". Many natural processes are very complex. This doesn't require any design, even if you assert it. I'd love to see your argument for WHY such complexity requires intelligent design, but I know you'll just spout the same nonsense as other theist. Finally, similar to the point of the video, if you're saying that complexity requires design, then who designed God? If you get to say it's just a brute fact that God is complex, then I get to say it's a brute fact that the universe is complex. No free lunches.

[@davidposey4721]

God always was and always will be and doesn't need a start like mere man.

[@mr.gamerkabir8142]

and what if we define god as existence only who expressed himself by merging with his power and created this universe

[@telwood15]

We need to accept that there are limits to what our minds can comprehend which does not mean we have to understand what a supernatural is and perhaps accept that one can exist.

[@cosmasmbuzi.1467]

@IgnatiusVaz I understand you my brother. But reading Colossians; "For by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him:" Colossians 1:16. One of "thrones" is "throne of God". By Colossians this throne was created "by him". Now that throne is certainly eternal, everlasting.

[@joykeebler1916]

- I AM THAT WHO GOD is what would have so been written in that of Moses' inquiry towards But instead so written I AM THAT I AM If exactly God and so notice a capitalized 'G' and then after small cased 'od' as in that of Elohim

[@kcvasqu]

So by this logic, existence is eternal. This universe as well as all the others are eternal and did not need a creator? Right? Why does the universe need to have a beginning but God does not? Not trying to be a gotcha kind of guy. Curious about this logic… Uses science to prove universe needs a beginning but doesn’t need proof of God?

[@Sola_Scriptura_1.618]

Reading many posts from Athiest that claim "they do not believe the universe came from nothing." But not one of them explained where the universe came from. I am asking because I want to understand what Atheists believe. God bless.

[@luisdasilva3879]

Amazing video , congratulations 👏👏👏

[@joykeebler1916]

- ETERNAL AND PRESENCE OF CONSTANT EVER BEING

[@Yeshuas_emulator]

Vastly terrific video CMI 🤩 God bless you all

[@richardmorley4223]

God did not created man. Man created god

[@mr.gamerkabir8142]

kinda yes but mostly no

[@John75Mulhern]

Christians can't say something created God as the whole thing falls apart if it does. Christians cannot have that

[@francoisona]

The question 'Who created god' is not materialist. It's not an atheist question (whatever that means). It s a response to the theist statement that poses as a so called explanation regarding the creation of the universe. When you say 'god'... . you e x p l a i n N O T H I N G. Anymore than a kid that says 'he did it using magic!'. It looks like an answer but it has not explanatory power so answers NOTHING! You still have to explain 'supernatural' and 'eternal'. It 's a classic god of the gaps. I dont know therefore god. That does not logically follow. The bachelor analogy is idiotic. Since the concept of bachelor and 'marriage' is construct that we understand. A timeless, non physical 'God always existed' So what is the answer? Theists you are not going to like that. It requires a lot of humility and certainly no claim that you have a special relationship with the son of the creator of the universe.. WE DONT KNOW!

[@uvoros1512]

To add, "Who created God" is not even a valid question since there's no proof of his existence to begin with. We can already prove the universe exists, so why exactly are we adding an extra layer that we can't prove the existence of.. oh yeah, to ease people's minds from the nothingness that comes after death, of course. Like trying to understand how the universe was created wasn't challenging enough, let's also say this intangible figure created it and we have no way to prove it.. how convenient.

[@keibro13]

At the same time, if god is eternal so is the universe. One of the theistic principles is that the universe has to have a cause, ergo god. Atheists would add that if anything has to have a beginning so does god.

[@colski3333]

Good talk. Mind will never figure it out. Park in Your heart and power it instead of the mind and experience the whole creation.

[@55Quirll]

If that was the way people kept thinking we would still be living as shepherds instead in this modern age with all these miracles of modern technology. I am not saying a god or gods don't exist, only that due to a lack of evidence I lack a belief. Once evidence is presented I will change my mind and accept that god or gods exist, but I will not follow or worship it since I don't worship anything or anyone.

[@anthonycraig274]

Every thing that has a beginning needs to be created, but what makes you assume god is eternal. If the logic is an everything needs a creator, then the creator needs a creator, then its creators all the way down.

[@joykeebler1916]

- actually, the word of God, describes the Universe itself as ZION and yes it had a beginning

[@Gondortheelf]

The greater revelation is this: We went through two metaphysical changes when God created us. The first was His image. The second was when Adam and Eve ate a fruit that made us gods ourselves, to which end, God had to send us out of the Garden of Eden and prevent us from eating the second fruit. This new nature, that is also the exact nature of Jesus and His miracle abilities, is what we all possess. Coincidentally a man will one day rise fully aware and able to use his god powers, and this man will parade as the Christ himself, but this man will be the Anti-Christ. We are gods. A scary thought.

[@newcreationinchrist1423]

God is the first cause. He exists eternally and is beyond our comprehension. If He was that easy to figure out, He wouldn't be God.

[@deguilhemcorinne418]

I have a good comprehension of what "he" is not : not Anu, not Zeus, not Odin, not Bêl, not Ahura Mazda, not Varuna, not Utikxo, not Rangi, not Mulugu, not Tirawa atius, and definitely not Yahwe. So that's a start, and I am doing well with this.

[@newcreationinchrist1423]

​@@deguilhemcorinne418you were doing well until you hit Yahweh. 🙂🙏

[@funkfamily4165]

" Who created God?"This is a lazy question.

[@terryquarton2523]

Some grifting priest like Donald trump

[@funkfamily4165]

@@terryquarton2523 He's announcing that next week....

[@rizdekd3912]

And gets an equally lazy answer...God is eternal and just IS the way he is.

[@funkfamily4165]

@@rizdekd3912 No, it's the Biblical answer. God's always existed.

[@rizdekd3912]

@@funkfamily4165 So what if it is. That in itself is a lazy answer. It provides nothing that explains how God can be eternal and still do things with no time to do them in. And if God can just ‘be’ the way he is with no explanation and if he can do thing in an eternal state then so too could an eternal natural world be fine tuned just because it is.

[@bobbybailey4623]

Aliens gave the impression they were gods.

[@colski3333]

Most pple created God of their own making. Define God and Its sure not God.

[@realnazarene5379]

Also, if time itself began with the Big Bang, then the concept of "before" and "causality" would've been nonsensical before; if in fact the word "before" is appropriate in this context.

[@petroflorence7962]

And god cretivity of universe is still on going from when he started it

[@ardbegthequestion]

7:17 - ah the tired "something from nothing". God is the one who creates something from nothing. It's your argument, not ours.

[@creationministriesintl]

Christians admit that, based on Genesis 1, God spoke and miraculously created everything over six days. Atheists also have their miracle that the universe came from nothing but don't won't to admit it. kzbin.info/www/bejne/oaOlmap_osuDpLc

[@WhyAreWe_Here]

Even if an atheist you need something thats eternal and science doesnt say thats the universe, so the question "who created God" even from an atheist doesnt make sense.

[@wittwfiii]

My mind understands God's existence. God Is.

[@arnoldripkin1]

God is real or eternal? How do you know this?

[@ardbegthequestion]

4:47 - our universe had a beginning, as in space, time and matter seems to have started at the initial point when "the big bang banged". There may or may not be something in the cosmos that sits outside of our universe that works (naturally) different to how space/time/matter physics work.

[@creationministriesintl]

If it's 'something' and works 'naturally', then, by definition, it is part of the universe. (You've differentiated 'universe' and 'cosmos', but they're the same thing.) However, there is, indeed, more to it that just what is in the physical universe. That is, the realm of the supernatural, which is, by definition, 'other than' the natural realm. God is supernatural. He is a sufficient cause for the entire natural realm.

[@ardbegthequestion]

@@creationministriesintl agree only that using language that speaks of the Space-time universe breaks down at whatever it means before it. But however it works is the bigger container of the cosmos. You can fit your paradoxical god into that as well, you’re just faced with much more work than the smartest minds on the planet. Good luck demonstrating that, especially having to defer to an ancient book instead of the vast array of knowledge that only continues to supplant outdated folklore.

[@kevinrtres]

@@ardbegthequestion The outdated folklore says there are 7 days in the week....which vast array of knowledge decided that?

[@ardbegthequestion]

@@kevinrtres - people who came up with it course; the earliest evidence of an astrological significance of a seven-day period is connected to Gudea, the priest-king of Lagash in Sumer during the Gutian dynasty (about 2100 BCE).

[@kevinrtres]

@@ardbegthequestion ..and so they liaised with all the people around the earth to come to a common understanding, yes, of course.

[@meb280]

Question for all of you deep thinkers out there. Is it even possible for there to be infinite time in a physical universe such as ours? Let me approach it from another angle: If time existed into eternity past, could we ever have reached "now"? I'm not so sure you could. What say you?

[@MartinGentile-fv5sk]

The universe did not have to have a beginning. Einstein proved that energy can not be created or destroyed. 'Nothing' does not exist therefore there is always something.

[@zuby985]

Supernatural being can be eternal? what is the evidence for this assumption? the bible says god is eternal. this is circular logic. its interesting that he quotes science yet im sure he does not agree when science contradicts the bible. I was a christian minister for 20 years. I am an non-theist. there is zero evidence of any god. just subjective experience of faith. thats not enough. sorry.

[@ntkmw8058]

Asking “who created God?” is as stupid as asking a hard atheist “who created the universe?”

[@SSIIMMIXX]

Actually with James Web telescope scientist are begging to doubt the theory of big bang.

[@petroflorence7962]

MR D YOU SMART MAN BRAVO

[@Quranic-Topics]

Who baked the bakerman? = Who Created the Creator?

[@Loading....99.99]

😂

[@BingGeaux]

@17:37 - it is one thing for a person to profess being created in "the image of God" and accept that but reject other revelations of the creator to us about ourselves and from whence we came and the order of those. and another thing for a person to reject everything, but there is still hope for them both. I was once one of them, too. All you need is God. God is love. Therefore the Beatles affirm, all you need is God, because God is love. All you need is love. God is all you need. God is all you need. God is all we need. @18:20 - thoughts....no. God spoke words. God didn't think to himself, God spoke words and revealed himself to us with words. God speaks. Also to say to yourself this it is presumptuous and boastful - you cannot have the thoughts that God has. for the scriptures say, "God said, my ways are not your ways and my thoughts are not your thoughts" - much of what we do know is in the realm of 'forbidden knowledge' because God didn't intend for us to complicate our time with understanding the workings of things, we are just to know they work for our good and God is the One who set them in motion for us. These forbidden truths were passed to us from the ones who left their first domain and began to mingle with mankind. That's another discussion into accepting what God's word says as opposed to what men say the word of God says.

[@The_Big_Unit69]

Josh I hope you find the truth 🙏 this will help you....

[@ElParacletoPodcast]

God is not a spiritual entity, that’s a fallacy and unbiblical. I am The Parakletos

[@jorgevial131]

Evidence points to a finite and temporal universe. A God, by the definition, cannot be finite or temporal. That is why our Universe had to ve created while God didn't.

[@Loading....99.99]

If an eternal creator God doesn't exist that created the universe, then whatever else that exists that created the universe must be an eternal creator God.

[@grasonicus]

Nobody created God. Here's a full explanation: First, let's get our heads around what a chain of causation is. Say Y created Z, then the immediate question is who created Y? Why X of course. And who created X, you ask. That's W. And so on and so on. If we travel back along this chain of causation, we will eventually reach A. In our quest to discover who created the Universe, we can start with anything in the Universe and then travel back along this chain of causation. There are only two possibilities. This chain can be: 1) Circular 2) Non-circular If the chain is circular, we will eventually get to something that was created by something that it had created--the chicken came from the egg that the chicken had laid. That's Wheeler's Participatory Universe. In short, the Universe was created by intelligence the Universe had created. This concept has to do with particles acting like waves if not observed but acting like particles if observed. That means that the act of observing them after their creation made them go back in time and influence their own nature, so they act like particles. That's enough to give anybody a headache and, not surprisingly, this explanation for the Universe's existence hasn't really caught on. If the chain is not circular, there are only two possibilities: 1) Infinite regression--we never get to the ultimate creator, which will mean nothing can exist. We know this is not the state of things. 2) Somewhere, we run smack-bang into an uncaused cause--the higher intelligence. There are only these three possibilities: 1) The Participatory Universe possibility. 2) Nothing exists because there's no ultimate creator--the infinite regression problem. 3) The uncaused cause is behind everything. One cannot ask where the Uncaused Cause came from--that's a stupid question. Just like people were happy to accept that the Universe was eternal, and Stephen Hawking was happy to believe that the Law of Gravity was eternal, and those of the Quantum faith have no concerns with a quantum vacuum being eternal, we have to accept that there may be an infinite higher intellect.

[@ddpeter4444]

You sounded like you know what you were saying until you said, " No, we do not have to accept this. There are some things that science cannot explain right now but given enough time.... If you destroyed all the religious books and all the science books, in 5000 years the science books will be re-written and say the same thing. The religious books would be totally difference other than their need to create a god/gods because of peoples fear of death.

[@grasonicus]

@@ddpeter4444 Whatever or whoever created the Universe is God. There's no exception to, only nothing comes from nothing. To believe that the Universe came from nothing is to belief in a miracle greater than any in the Bible. Also, then the Great Nothing will be your God.

[@dalewyatt230]

I'm oversimplifying this, but that which man creates has no power over man (car, house, nuke, human killing robots), so since God created the act of creation, it has no power over him. God is outside of the act of creation. I can go into greater explanation but that's it in a nutshell.

[@dalewyatt230]

@@Bill_Garthright I'm not claiming you are immune to car crashes or anything else and I was afraid it was too simple of an explanation, so here it is in a bit more detail. God is perfect and flawless and man is not. Man even though he creates something, his creation doesn't have power over him initially, but he can lose power in three ways, giving it away, being taken from, and losing it (where are my car keys?). Let's say a Man creates a human-killing robot, he would have to give the robot the power to kill humans or himself in 1 or all of the above 3 ways. God is perfect so only giving the power away could apply to him. So God created time, space, matter, and the very act of creation, so since he created it, he is not bound by it. Does that give a bit more clarity? Sorry, I should make a video so it's easier to digest. Ha! The cool part about this is you can test this theory and it works 100% of the time for humans. Just look through all of history and time and time again man creates something but loses the power of it through 1 of the 3 above ways. God bless!

[@colski3333]

How are you good. Eating from the tree of good will bring in the bad. There is another way of being which is beyond good. You can heal good and bad by knowing you are both. Actually we are good bad ugly and magnificent. We are all of it. Allow what you feel and you have it made.

[@mrd.808]

Simply put, God does not exist in time. God can go eternally into the past and then eternally into the future.

[@VincentCMercandetti]

Simply put, God not existing in time means God does not exist.

[@mrd.808]

@@VincentCMercandetti 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@mrd.808]

​@user-xp4fm2st8u God exists outside of time. Time does not apply to God. God is eternal and always exists.

[@Hydroverse]

​​@@mrd.808I would be cautious to base your theology on the belief in time since you're applying scientific theory to biblical theology.

[@mrd.808]

@Hydroverse my apologies, I am easily confused, and I do not comprehend what you are explaining to me.

[@mzubuki]

You will eventually have to say there are somethings that always have been, which will always will be, and always is, and that is the substrate everything that emerges from. To say the beginning of a beginning is to begin the fallacy that would look much like looking at a screen of your computer screen you'll peer into a fractal and an infinity. I do believe there is evidence to suggest a higher order mind that runs the show.

[@millennialpoes5674]

What was god doing for all eternity prior to creating our universe?

[@squaretrianglez]

First Time as we know it did not exist. Its difficult for our brain to comprehend beyond one dimension of time. John 17 gives us clues. God the Father, Son and Holy Spirit were loving each other and glorifying each other. Its a full time job to love the Creator.

[@OneEyedJack1970]

Chilling...

[@anthonycraig274]

But you still haven’t asked the question.

[@davidhuffman4036]

We created our gods, we praise in religions. I believe in our creator of everything of everything. Eternal creator is my God. But I'm still curious how our eternal creator was created. I believe but only curious.

[@BingGeaux]

@14:33 - the attributes of the world on which we live is that it is orderly which means that the creator must be orderly. So, let's consider this point of evidence....if the world and everything in it is orderly and that concludes the creator must be orderly then, it must make no sense to follow the heliocentric model since it originates everything out of chaos? Unless you want to commit to forcing God into your man-made construct of space. Is it so difficult to accept that God provided an orderly explanation of the heavens and the earth? Why is it so difficult to turn away from the man-made idol and to turn to the God who is spirit and love? We'll see which way this goes. 14 minutes out of the 27, I'm not leaning toward him confessing the heliocentric model to be false.

[@graemedoig2225]

Just saying God is eternal explains nothing. God's existence is the mystery and the answer should be 'no body knows'. It's too big a question for us to fathom.

[@joykeebler1916]

- Infinite, is the ever movement in so time and finite is that of measure-able time within so space

[@ReasonOrDogma]

From the skeptic's standpoint, what the Bible says is irrelevant. It's just some ancient ramblings. So saying "the Bible says that God is eternal" doesn't address anything. The question of "Who created God?" comes up when religious people try to prove the existence of God without recourse to scripture. Arguments typically run along the lines of "everything has a cause, so there must be a first cause, therefore God." To which the obvious challenge is "What caused God?" If the argument runs along these familiar lines, then denying that God needs a cause amounts to special pleading, since it violates the rule already established. So "Who created God?" is actually not a silly question at all. And pretty much any way you can think of to sneak God into a special category that does not need a cause, such as "oh, well, He's eternal", you can just do with anything else or the universe itself, and just avoid God altogether.

[@douglasmcnay644]

Not consistently, you can't.

[@ounkwon6442]

The answer is in the question. God created by God. What the heck is God to begin with? What God? Which God? Whose God? Mormon God? Catholic God? Protestant God? Muslim God?

[@BingGeaux]

@3:47 - reducing God to your own understanding and then questioning who/what created God. this in and of itself is a way we work. Reducing the world around us to what we know and understand so we can make associations and comparisons. what is done at 4:42 - the statement, "the universe has a beginning" begs the questions that we are within the universe. What is the universe? And I suspect this will be answered by the "big bang" explanation and that this man believes the big bang theory as a fact. The Big Bang Theory is a Jesuit-plot to discredit faith in the Creator as the One who, "In the beginning ...created the heavens and the earth." God doesn't explain a big bang. God explains that everything came into being at His word. "In the beginning was the word, and the word was with God and the word was God, and everything created was not made without him, but was made through him[the word]." "He is the light of life and the light of the world" and the "spirit of God was hovering over the surface of the deep and God said, 'Let there be light.' and there was light" , Then God put two lights in the sky[firmament] to mark seasons, days and years. The greater light (The sun) to rule the day and the lesser light (The moon) to rule the night. "Let their light shine DOWN upon the earth. And so it was/ Genesis 1:1-17 = notice in the sequence of events that the earth was created and the sun and moon and stars were created to light the earth. As long as you force God into a heliocentric big bang model of existence you are not trusting God completely. You are accepting God in one sense while trusting man-made explanations for the rest of creation in the same sense. Do a show on Biblical cosmology with this same guest and with Ken Hamm and with William Craig....these men all believe in God the father, but they all also believe in the theory of evolution and the heliocentric model of the universe and the existence of alien beings off the planet somewhere in the vast universe.

[@petroflorence7962]

God is infinity God did not come from the begging the beging came out of god for he holds everthing together if he was not there would be nothing existing but god is not created he is creator who is the past present future

[@bibleburner8426]

God always existed because that's how you define him...great, we'll take your word for it.

[@zachsplep]

Maybe we should worry more about "When is God going to end?"!

[@freedom.families]

Profound! ❤❤

[@onlymyself7225]

if a small child asks the question , that makes sense to me , if we as an adult ask this , that seems pretty ridiculous to be asking who made God . He is the one and only uncreated being that has created all things , which is why , he is God and we are not . People will find any excuse they can possibly grasp at , even if it has no logic , even if its ridiculous , to avoid searching for the truth , and , giving the path a sincere effort , such as when someone with fruit and apparent answers that seems to fit and at least make sense if you were to believe it , well , giving it a real effort , which would be to open Gods word , follow and OBEY it , and , test the claims , its either the truth or its not . All this other stuff is just a sinner trying to hold onto his pride , his sin , his rebellion , this world they love more than God and his righteousness he requires of his people to be in his holy creation . If you don't want to follow and obey God , you do not have to , just do not be shocked when he removes you from the kingdom he is establishing , to fix all the issues you cry about , asking where is he , why is he not doing it when you are so blind not to see , he is , he has , he will , do it all . People want to have everything good God has to offer AND be in opposition to him living in sin , that is the real fantasy going on here , a delusion that will not work out well for any of us , Jesus Christ is the truth , the way , the life , end of conversation , test the claims or enjoy your sin for a little until the lake of fire welcomes you into that kingdom instead .

[@petroflorence7962]

And u understan this u must understand the spirit relm

[@JuanManuel-ep8do]

It shouldn't be a question what created god because we dont have any evidence for god. I think we should first find evidence for god and then find out how he was created.

[@ddpeter4444]

God was created by humans for one reason, the fear of death. If we did not die, there would not be a need for any gods or any religion.

[@eddsroom69edds]

You are the ones who deflect the question of who created god.

[@dwaynejordan5898]

You cannot supply belief to a man who wants facts and proof and expect him to change his mind or vice versa.

[@ddpeter4444]

Exactly, belief is the absence of facts and proof. So, I cannot prove I have an invisible friend who grants me wishes and you cannot disprove this. So is my friend real? I think he is but you probably do not.

[@kpkpm3604]

We, the humans on planet earth, created not only one god, but thousands of them. There are at least 8,000 known gods.

[@wordbird711]

It's impossible to create what is uncreated. In the Secret Book of John, the Savior gives the best description of God the Father or The One, as distinct from the Demiurge who masquerades as god in the Old Testament, constantly demanding sacrifice.

[@benvanrensburg4261]

I marvel at the word games that believers have to play in order to keep their knowledge of the unknowable standing. Prime example right here. Physical things like matter and energy are natural and CAN NOT be eternal. Spiritual beings like my God are supernatural, and they CAN be eternal. Easy to say!! But saying so does not make it so. Your reasons require a reason! Your unexplained spirits explain nothing. It's simply unknowable, and hence not worth talking or worrying about.

[@ARRAM57]

Who created god? Man created the concept of god. Proving your concept is real or has any effect on reality is the real test.