WHO KILLED GLAMROCK BONNIE? (A Five Nights at Freddy's: Security Breach Mystery) - DMuted

[@soleacorn1605]

I love how after the perfect evidence was crafted for Monty being Bonnie's killer and Pastra just shows up to defend his dear boy.

[@jaydenliberty9536]

It’s not even perfect though, everyone ignores that he wasn’t given claws until they needed a new bass player (that is, after Bonnie disappeared because otherwise he would still play bass) It’s EXPLICITLY said in SB, I dunno why people don’t realize this. There’s a complaint that he’s started using his new claws to rip apart things and that’s how we learn about his claws being a unique upgrade in the first place

[@froggylynx5647]

@@jaydenliberty9536But we know the plain endos are capable of ripping things up. Look at the Vanny endings, but show the *staff bots* ripping Vanessa and Freddy to shreds. The glamrock endow are, at the very least, slightly above the staff bots in strength. It’s not a logical leap to say Monty could’ve dismantled Bonnie.

[@Memjay]

@@froggylynx5647then again, Monty didn’t get his anger issues till after he got his claws, and on top of that, kept leaving his performances to the catwalks of Monty golf. So, what purpose would’ve that been to kill Bonnie just for him to take his place and not even take place at said performances

[@superlemonslicer1224]

​@@MemjayOn the topic of the skipping thing If we assume that Monty killed Bonnie to get more popular and to move up in the band. Then going to performances where he always knows he'll be second fittel to Freddy will probably make him want to skip them. Monty has been shown to want to replace Feeddy (as shown in that one Mini Golf Level) so him skipping his performances is probably because he is still unsatisfied with "just being in the band"

[@raynebowmo2223]

I was just listening to the video and got basically jumpscared by pastra

[@jaffinator2166]

I mean the answer is obvious. 1. Bonnie gets his skull cracked while practicing his sick bowling skills. 2. Bonnie spontaneously combusts 3. Monty walks in on Bonnie’s corpse, slips, and gets his hair dyed red.

[@flamingphoenix1425]

4. Monty puts up the wet floor signs so that no one else suffers the same fate 4. Monty is a hero

[@kacklina]

​@@flamingphoenix1425 (gaaaaaasp) How dare you steal the brilliant Mark theory?!

[@flamingphoenix1425]

@@kacklina I was just filling in the blanks since the parent comment is incomplete Mark theory

[@Tsunderrain]

Why would Monty kill someone he looked up to. Monty wasn't jealous of Bonnie it was Freddy, and vanny killed Bonnie

[@Max-jo5ev]

He also tried to save bonnie by trying to give him cpr. That's why bonnie has claw marks on his chest

[@RyeToast]

I still can't believe you'd accuse his boyfriend...

[@dmuted]

Hey he had it coming Fuck Simon Says in Security Breach

[@JoshuaA1307]

It’s interesting no one mentioned the rug under Bonnie being of Gator Golf or how his condition looks like shattered Monty (ripped in half and with broken jaw). This would mean that Bonnie went to the Catwalks of Gator Golf…… it’s likely that is the true cause of his damage, as for the perpetrator…. I’m unsure if Monty was in the catwalks…. Maybe Bonnie was pursuing a kid and gave him what GreGorY gave to Monty? It would be smth interesting to look at

[@RealGabrielJohnson]

@@dmuted hi my name is Gabriela Johnson I'm the first Freddy Fazbear and I am not a boy I am a girl but I am not an animatronic I am very much human and Jeremy\Bonnie is my boyfriend I'm his girlfriend not his boyfriend just to clear that up

[@trancebunnysunny]

DMuted: insults monty Pastra: *WHOMST HAS SUMMONED ME?*

[@DiamondBatToons]

Personally, I kind of like the Vanny idea. I do understand why it could be the case. A) This being her first animatronic kill, would make her overconfident with Freddy, thus resulting in her demise, & B) It's a great callback to when Afton lured various Animatronics to the safe room & destroyed them all! Who's to say Vanny wasn't mirroring the events of Afton's?

[@MxMe-su1ch]

I think she was totally mimicking Afton. I think Afton's soul and/or memories escaped the hell he was trapped in, and are present in the Glitchtrap Virus. As a result, The Mimic is mimicking Afton and trying to recreate his hell. But to do that, his hell needs victims, their souls uploaded into a mainframe. In other words, Brazil is canon. This is also how Glitchtrap can create humanoid robots. Like Gregory, and Cassie. The timing of Ruin is off. The Pizzaplex has been broken down for years, yet Gregory's voice hasn't changed. And neither has Cassie's. They haven't grown up. Because Cassiebot's (perhaps one of several) real purpose has always only been to free Glitchtrap.

[@tessfabled4115]

I think the obvious answer is that Monty did do it - albeit not intentionally. Given the injury pattern, Monty may have shoved Bonnie in anger (not intending to kill him, perhaps just in a 'get out of my way' manner), only for Bonnie to fall off the catwalk at Gator Golf. Monty then moved him to his current location in an effort to conceal the body (perhaps fearing he'd be shut down permanently or something?). Bowling ball was an effort to 'put him out of his misery' when he noticed that he was still (barely) alive. Monty continues to live with this guilt/knowledge to this day, not helped by the company forcing him to replace Bonnie after his disappearance, hence his growing aggressiveness/bad temper.

[@anthonyloveschickens]

This is what I’m thinking what happened. This theory reminds me of another game with a similar situation.

[@higueraft571]

@@anthonyloveschickens Alternatively... Could have been the Mimic :V

[@WyGuy2087]

@@anthonyloveschickens is it an indie rpg?

[@fnaffoxy1987]

Then how do you explain the very intentional claw marks through the chest?

[@anthonyloveschickens]

@@WyGuy2087 Possibly :]

[@78jujubs]

We’ve seen from Freddy, Eclipse, and Roxy that the default AI of the Glamrocks is to protect children. I think Bonnie was the first animatronic to try and save a kid from Vanny. If you look at the damage done to him, it resembles the damage done to Freddy by the evil staff bots. The fact he’s also found in hidden spot in HIS bowling section leads me to believe he was probably hiding a child there.

[@zenvariety9383]

They could always adapt GGY story into a game. Haven't read the books or played the games, but having Bonnie be taken out by a brainwashed Gregory and Vanny to stop Gregory's classmate from saving from Glitchtrap's mind control would make sense. Besides Glitchtrap was probably having Vanny and Gregory capture kids so they could be brainwashed into serving Glitchtrap.

[@matthewmusco2581]

Taking the tarp into account, I can fully see Bonnie being attacked in Monty golf, receiving the chest injury and then being ripped apart to be carried to Bonnie bowl easier. From there Monty/whoever killed him would see his eyes still glowing and smash his head with the bowling ball to try and get him to turn off but when he didn’t they just gave up. I wonder if tracking the wet floor bot locations could be the same path taken by the killer with Bonnie in the tarp, and Bonnie was able to leave behind pieces of his programming or something in them in an attempt to call for help.

[@Pixiemage]

Fun fact (which I said in another comment because it's a hella cool detail): the tarp we find Bonnie on is actually a rectangle of carpet, a blue one with small flakes and medium spirals of confetti on it. That carpet can only be found in three places in the known 'Plex (as far as I've been able to find in Security Breach). The back hallway leading to Rockstar Row, DJ MM's Fazcade...and Monty Golf. A bit damning, isn't it? 😋 Gotta love when Steel Wool adds details like that!

[@Piclue44]

If Bonnie was indeed carried in the carpet, there is no possible way vanny could’ve carried him.

[@matthewmusco2581]

@@Piclue44 true. She could control the staff bots or even Monty with her remote tho couldn’t she? She could just have them drag him back

[@matthewmusco2581]

@@Pixiemage oooh that’s pretty cool

[@KarmaTheNarrator23]

I still find all of this insane, Fazber Entertainment just... Created LIFE, Artificial intelligence so advance that can have fealings. And also, the fact that they didnt just repair Bonny is a PR nightmare abaut to happen, not talking of all the marketing wasted.

[@Penguin-nr8sq]

That's what Im saying. Like they just left the animatronics to R O T multiple times. didn't even mercy kill them. It would've been easier to control them if they did the universal thing and have them controlled by a staff member but they programmed them with full personalities, character traits, and flaws then left them to die. I would've at least salvaged and sold the tech to some big firm.

[@Haley_Halo]

This was such an unexpected collab, I love how you each played different roles/perspectives! All while using a funny Ace Attorney theme. If only all theories could be solved like a murder🤔

[@edenengland1883]

something odd that didnt get brought up enough is that Monty is the only animatronic shown to actively *avoid* antention as he's mentioned in the base game to regularly skip out on shows meaning theres definitely something more going on with monty, he likely had some secondary motive, or maybe he's just mad he's still stuck with mini golf of all attractions

[@laraschroeder5195]

I love how the theorist community has gone together and collectively agreed that Freddy and Bonnie were PROBABLY MORE THEN FRIENDS…

[@A_OBC]

Best friends?

[@superlemonslicer1224]

Y e s

[@h.w.4482]

yeah, that's not something to be proud of

[@biosupdate7449]

@@h.w.4482they have been saying they are gay for each other since like 2015

[@diskonnekt1313]

No we have not. Don't taint FNAF with 'Pride' bullshit.

[@TheHaddonfieldRegistry]

The Who Killed Bonnie mystery is probably the best one in the new game. It's very creepy because of how mysterious it is, and if we never find out what happened, the mystery itself is satisfying enough.

[@askerror1987]

Glad to see I'm not the only person who thought of making an ace attorney-style court case for Bonnie's death! This looks like a very entertaining video :>

[@painthedoll]

Honestly I have trouble thinking it's Monty,or if it was it wasn't by choice. Especially since he has been reported to not come to performances I think, if truly Monty, he was controlled. I can see that he looked up and aspired to be like him, ended up controlled by the virus and killed him, maybe leading from a chase idk,then was move to bassist and ended up lashing out from guilt and grief. Lashing out, missing shows, like we know they can experience complex emotions such as low self esteem, depression can certainly be on that table. Especially because out of all of them he seems to be the one to really lose it at the end, go full feral. Being driven by guilt and grief and expected to still show up, like even despise Freddy because he expresses his grief in a way that could come off as he didn't care(even though we know he cared a lot.) That's a personal take on it though ^^

[@Pixiemage]

I've always leaned toward the belief that Monty was under Vanny's control if/when he took out Bonnie. We already know that it was originally meant to be the mind-controlled Glamrocks who took out Freddy in the Vanny endings based on voice lines that never made it into the game, and Bonnie did have travel patterns the day he disappeared that were strange enough to be noted in security logs. I can't help thinking Bonnie found something he wasn't meant to find, and Vanny had Monty get rid of him since Bonnie was in his attraction at the time. Monty was already pretty aggressive prior to his so-called promotion, but he got worse after his upgrade - so you're right, it wouldn't be hard to believe his behavior got worse because of what happened to Bonnie. Poor guy 🥺

[@АннаКравцов-ш6р]

also one more thing i've noticed: if the Vanny ending and Freddy's unused voicelines (the ones where he gets attacked by his band-mates) are to be believed, the only time where the animatronics can actually attack each other, is when they are controlled by someone else. so even if Monty was the one to attack Bonnie, he didn't do this by his own volition. he was just a tool for the real culprit to put their plan into motion.

[@nothanks7263]

I forget who, but someone made an argument that Bonnie is trashed the same way Monty was in breach. Like Bonnie also fell from the catwalks.

[@superlemonslicer1224]

Glamrock Bonnie has scratches all over him so the "fall" argument doesn't really add up

[@nanuqo2006]

@@superlemonslicer1224 He was pushed

[@higueraft571]

@@nanuqo2006 Also gotta consider his arms and legs are CLEANLY broken. All four of them.

[@nanuqo2006]

@higueraft571 Monty could have torn him into pieces to more discreetly carry each one to Bonnie Bowl

[@nanuqo2006]

Aside from the torso split which happened on the way down

[@riumainu2768]

Monty didn't had claws until Bonnie's dissapeared.... plus if he would be so eager to be in the spotlight, he wouldn't miss stage performances.... it looks more to me that he is just angry and frustrated thar he is force to replace Bonnie. Plus i don't think Monty needs a bowling ball to damage the rabbit. So yeah... Monty couldn't. I think was Vanny and Mimic, the ones behind this. (And well.... Cassy XD)

[@CopiumCentral1027]

I actually saw something to discredit all of this. The memos about Monty's claw upgrades and how he would skip performances to hang out on the catwalks. The first one specifically details how Monty's claw upgrades allow him to play the bass, implying that he wasn't able to before he received them. If this is true, it would mean Monty wouldn't have received his claws until AFTER Bonnie was decommissioned. The second one details how Monty has regularly been skipping performances to hang out on the catwalks above Gator Golf. If Monty killed Bonnie because he wanted to replace him and get more attention, why would he be actively avoiding the very performances he supposedly killed for? It just doesn't make sense.

[@masterbond9]

I can see vanny doing it. not by her own hands, no. if it was monty, he was not in control. the only one who could have controlled another animatronic to do it. i have always wondered, and everyone has completely brushed over this question: when did monty first fall, before security breach? was it before bonnie was killed? if so, that would give plenty of time for vanny, or some other nefarious entity to upload a malicious program into monty's endo. there are not many reasons why bonnie would be spending hours in the main areas of the pizzaplex, especially if he was alone. and everyone is asking the same questions: who killed him? where was he killed? how was he killed? but why was bonnie killed? why was he replaced with monty? sure jealously is a strong emotion, and an animatronic programmed to have emotions may not know how to properly deal with them, but it seems like even though the animatronics dont talk about it, they know about the disappearances just as much as the human staff members and guests. its all rumor to them, but what if bonnie was investigating? what if he figured out what was happening? they fixed monty, who continued to stay up in the catwalks and give minimal interaction to guests and wants to be alone, so much so that he actually missed shows. im not saying that monty is innocent. no, not at all, but im not saying that he's guilty. i heard another theory somewhere that suggested that the animatronics know what theyre doing when they go to kill gregory and cassie, but they are, in most cases, powerless to stop it. and i think i can agree with that. monty knows what happened, and if he did do it, he had no control over his body, or it was a complete accident and monty tried to cover it up. as for cassie performing the final kill on bonnie. bonnie was hidden away active for a long period of time. his eyes were lit up, and that mightve been the only thing that was showing activity in his system. and i just hope that bonnie's operating system was not powered on throughout that entire time. if it was, and all he can do was hear, see and wonder why nobody has come for him. he would be such a mess, and i dont know if it would be recoverable. to him he was betrayed by all of his friends, even his closest, and possible lover. thats another question that nobody seems to be asking: why wasnt bonnie fixed? why was he left to rot behind the bowling alley? and why was he left powered on? if they knew where bonnie was why didnt they scrap him like they did foxy? why was their first instinct to give monty bonnie's role and immediately spend possibly millions of dollars to rebrand almost everything from bonnie to monty instead of fixing bonnie? also, do we know why foxy was replaced?

[@Watcher_4]

I love how pastra shows up to defend in Macgomery it just had me rolling on the floor!

[@GrandArmyGaming01]

Noticing a theme in everyone's videos about this where they're pushing the Monty was jealous narrative by ignoring the fact that other logs say that Monty blatantly skipped performances and hid in the Gator Golf catwalks

[@superlemonslicer1224]

That log ride was sorta made to explain Bonnie's dissappear. Also here is my explanation on the skipping performances :D Monty first killed Bonnie to get more popular and join the band. But after a while of being in the band he sorta became unsatisfied with just being in the band and always just being number 2 behind Freddy. So Monty now wants to replace Freddy to (as shown in that one mini golf game)

[@GrandArmyGaming01]

@@superlemonslicer1224 I still don't think I agree. Mostly because, as another KZbinr pointed out, Bonnie's damage is almost exactly the same as Shatter Monty's when you take the claws. I think his destruction was accidental and the fact that he's on a blanket + the position of the bowling ball suggests Monty carried his remains there then broke the bowling ball against the wall to cover up what happened and Fazbear Employees just didn't care enough to look. Monty is shown in the game not to be particularly intelligent as well both through voice lines and the fact that he'd had his legs broken before as a result of getting hit by the Hurricane Bucket, but he still continued to hide away on the catwalks.

[@superlemonslicer1224]

@@GrandArmyGaming01 Glamrock Bonnie and Shattered Monty don't look identical tho? Monty's withering look like small cracks all over his body surrounding holes, while Bonnie's withering looks noting like that, instead like scratches and bent metal (mostly around the legs)

[@cosmicbreath]

I really wish Monty wasn't the killer because as a cozy mystery lover and a writer it seems lame and lazy as a story element to me, plus I really like Monty's design. But just because I WANT Monty to be innocent doesn't mean he is and doesn't mean Steel Wool isn't just intentionally using their story as a dogfighting ring to see who in their fandom survives...just a thought.

[@soulreaver6546]

The claw marks are too deep to be him at the time, he didn't have his claw upgrade til after Bonnie was gone and he replaced him

[@Urbuggjuice]

I just think it’s weird for Monty to kill Bonnie for the spotlight just to skip out on shows

[@superlemonslicer1224]

Here is my reasoning 1 Monty kills Bonnie to get more popular and get in the band 2 After a while of being in the band and constantly being number 2 behind Freddy, he becomes unsatisfied 3 Monty now wants to replace Freddy and skips performances

[@c.e.o.ofturkeys2508]

if you look at the way the staff bots tore up freddy in that one ending with the marks on his torso, and the marks on bonnie's torso in ruin, don't they look similar? It could be possible that Vanny ordered the staff bots to attack bonnie, and since only roxy can see Vanny, Vanny could have smashed his head with the bowling ball. The one issue however is the motive.

[@TheStarryArcher1213]

This FNaF "trial" was interesting to watch! The avatars were a nice inclusion too. Thanks for sharing your thoughts with us! ^_^ I'm surprised that you didn't include the corrupted STAFF bots in the suspect list or at the very least mention them more in the Vanny section. One ending shows them "disassembling" Glamrock Freddy and causing some serious damage. Also, a skinny animatronic like Moon is strong enough to drag Freddy away in one scene, so the STAFF bots might be stronger than they look. I've also seen glimpses of a Mop Bot with a Caution Bot nearby, and I can imagine the STAFF bots putting Caution Bots around Bonnie due to their normal programming. Even if the STAFF bots weren't responsible for Bonnie's damage, they might have moved him to "clean up the mess". The idea of Vanny eliminating Bonnie due to him breaking free and giving her trouble-like what happened with Freddy-is interesting and certainly possible. In that scenario, what might have broken Vanny's control over Bonnie?

[@anthonyloveschickens]

I think maybe Monty caused Bonnie’s death on accident. He probably got Bonnie to fall off the catwalks, resulting in his damage. Then in a panic he hides Bonnie’s body and makes it look like something else happened. Pretty dark. Also what could add to the sadness is that I’m pretty Monty did idolize Bonnie, and causing his death probably really screwed with the gators head, and the virus showing up later definitely doesn’t help. He probably goes on the catwalks not to just skip performances, but probably just to sulk. Be careful what you wish for ig :( BUT it could be entirely anything else. I’m slowly becoming more open to the idea of Monty causing Bonnie’s death, but it definitely had to not have been on purpose. If you couldn’t tell I’m a Monty AND Bonnie lover. I just hope they got along.😭

[@krackkokichi]

no one ever brings up the fact that the tarp Bonnie is lying on is actually a chunk of carpet from gator golf, implying he was moved, not to mention the ridiculous amount of dismembering that means the bowling ball was pretty trivial in the grand scheme of things and thus probably not the cause of death, just left to make anyone who found Bonnie think it was. the marks on his chest don't necessarily have to be green paint as the damage on the corresponding piñata is actually brown. there's more also the other stuff mentioned that also points to monty. too much for me not to think it's him

[@superlemonslicer1224]

I think it's pretty funny to just imagine Glamrock Bonnie just laying there... But then Monty comes in and through a bowling ball on his face to make sure he finished the job

[@spiritofchaos58]

I've heard about that actually. I'm pretty sure that same carpet pattern is found in other areas as well, not just Gator Golf.

[@Anakin_Skywalker01]

I think Bonnie could have killed himself. Evidence 1) Bonnie has claws and could have easily done the chest damage to himself. Evidence 2) He could have fell on that bowling ball. Theory) Ruin is all about Duality. Bonnie and Freddy were best friends and so it’s assumed that Bonnie would have had a good personality. I think that Bonnie destroyed himself to keep from corrupting. Someone, maybe Cassie’s dad, put up the wet floor signs to keep the Vanny corruption virus at bay. I know I didn’t explain this well buts it’s a KZbin comment. I’ll answer any questions

[@nixxie119]

I recently watched a video from NotRealName NotAtAll. They brought up an interesting point; Bonnie has similar damage to Monty when he falls from the cats walks. Both Monty and Bonnie have a busted jaw and a cracked faceplate, causing one of the eyes to become loose. They both have a major hole in their chest, and Bonnie is even broken at the waist, just like Monty is. The only difference being that Bonnie's left arm and right leg are broken into pieces. Another thing to point out, from the same video, but in the comments; if you look underneath Bonnie, he's not laying on the wood panel floor boards that are back behind the alleys. He's laying on what looks like a carpet. And that carpet has the *same* design as Gator Golf's carpeting, that can't be found anywhere else (although I'm not entirely sure about that, I can't exactly fact check).

[@ZatchMoonshadow]

I was starting to feel a little bummed out again because everyone has been going directly for Monty's throat every time Who's Bonnie's killer things are ever touched... And then, my boi Pastra comes to make me feel validated~

[@sweetsharonda]

Pastra: Lankmann, tp me to court! Lankmann: ok 10 minutes later Lankmann: What the fuck Pastra!

[@FatManThor953]

Objection your honor, bonnie had a skill issue

[@Dr_T0X1C]

Genuine thoughts here. Seein as Bonnie already passed the torch to Monty, it would much easier to scrap him than the others. Bonnie is usually alone so it that would be both good and bad. No one would be around to see him, but no one would be around to scrap him. So Vanny lured Bonnie to Gator Golf, probably with somethin like, "Monty wants to play some golf with ya." , and Bonnie didn't think much of it and went to Gator Golf. He got there, the cameras were disabled for a short while so Vanny could lure Monty to Bonnie Bowl. Bonnie, now knowin he had been lied too, goes back. He finds Monty goin behind the alley so he follows out of curiosity. Monty gets infected by the Glitchtrap virus for the first time. He's sent into a frenzy in which he attacks Bonnie not knowin what he's doin. When Glitchtrap let's Monty go, Monty realizes what he's done and becomes fearful. He runs. He tries to hide from what he's done. His anger outbursts and destructive nature comes from his fear and anger towards himself for what he's done. Someone he looked up too was scrapped by his own claws. He tries his best to put on a show, it's what Bonnie would have wanted. In RUIN, Monty is fueled by blind aggression and fear from what's happened to him. From the virus to his body, all of it makes him finally snap and become an untamable monster. Meanwhile, Bonnie likely knew all of it. The remorse, the fear, the pain. Through the wetfloor signs Bonnie could see it all. His consciousness livin within the wetfloor bots. He knows it wasn't Monty who scrapped him, he tried to warn everyone but he had no way of doin so. He had no choice but to watch all he loved fall to ruin.

[@UnlimitedOfSky]

It would depend on the player who playing as cassie, I mean if cassie turn all the wet floor sign robot off, bonnie can rest from all the suffering he went through, plus no one gonna come and help him in RUIN. It would not be cassie fault because the thing is that you have to find all the wet floor sign inorder to reach inside the place where bonnie is. If we weren't play as her, she would ignore all the wet floor sign and continue to find gregory.

[@UnlimitedOfSky]

Also there would be no reason for cassie to find all the wet floor sign bot to deactivate just to found out there's just a broken animatronic laying on the floor with the other wet floor sign bot

[@gta71000]

Im more surprised this video doesnt show the small extra detail from during the ride whennit gets to the point where it shows monty making a tornado? Thing and its piercing a freddy statue, theres a small cutout of glamrock bonnie being swept away by it in a shocked betrayal type of expression looking at monty while monty is looking at him AND SMILING.

[@superlemonslicer1224]

Yep... Monty is the killer

[@dmuted]

I actually do mention that.

[@valviform]

I personally like the theory that he was framed.

[@tanman5123]

The “yes my honor” joke earned my subscription

[@deadshields8561]

This has got me wanting a joke side-game with the animatronics being cross-examined like how Fury's Rage was released before SB.

[@reececonnor526]

Alternate title: “Who killed Glamrock’s Freddy’s boyfriend?”

[@superlemonslicer1224]

correct

[@redtailarts101]

Actually I agree with Pastra. The 'Monty did it to replace him' theory doesn't really line up 1. Monty never has any hints of disdain towards Bonnie. He's portrayed to quite like Bonnie, but dislike Freddy 2. Monty doesn't like the spotlight. He missed performances, in fact. Why would he kill Bonnie to replace him, and then not perform? 3. It's been pointed out that Bonnie's damage is similar to that of Shattered Monty. 4. Monty did not have claws that powerful before being upgraded to play the bass. Freddy has claws, but he becomes much more powerful after you give him Monty's, implying the bass playing claws are also more powerful for destruction. 5. Monty wasn't even violent before he replaced Bonnie, iirc. His chill and laid back personality was probably his true personality, and how he would interact with kids, only warped by potential mourning and by Vanny 6. It's actually confirmed that Bonnie was found by Fazbear Staff. While they first describe him as missing, he is later referred to as "out of commission." Shattering the animatronics is referred to as decommissioning them, and the use of similar language makes me think Bonnie was found shattered. But more decisive is the fact that Monty was made a permanent member, not a temporary member while they looked for Bonnie. There was likely a log of Bonnie being found, but it wasn't ever seen by Gregory. So here's what really happened: Bonnie is acting quite strange and wandering around the Pizzaplex. Eventually he goes to Monty's Gator Golf. Monty has gotten himself injured on the catwalks before, and we know that a bad enough fall can basically destroy him completely. Bonnie was aimlessly wandering on the catwalks that night, and Monty was possibly playing the shooter game that Gregory used to destroy him. He wins, and the bucket spills- but Bonnie is there, in the way. Bonnie is crushed and falls, hitting the ground and being completely ruined. Fazbear staff note his unusual behavior and search Monty Golf, finding him destroyed. Bonnie's damage is too severe to repair, and they don't want to have to order new casing. They plan to scrap him properly later but for the moment, they have to move him. There is a notable tarp under Bonnie, so they take him to a hidden room in Bonnie Bowl and leave him there for the time being. He's eventually forgotten about. Monty is left really upset and angry, because he did it but he never meant to. Freddy hates him for what happened and he likewise dislikes Freddy because of his animosity. Evidence: - Logs of Bonnie's movements - Tarp under Bonnie's body - Damage to Bonnie - Green paint on his chest, the same color as the bucket - Cutout of Bonnie falling that was found - Monty's spike in aggression after Bonnie was gone - Monty's behavior of frequently using the catwalks Ignored Evidence: - Damage to room where Bonnie was found - Broken bowling ball Explanation: This room in Bonnie Bowl may have been dedicated to temporarily storing things that are broken. While it certainly looks like a crime scene, there is more evidence that Gator Golf was the real scene of the crime. Bonnie's limbs being detached could not have happened from just a fight with Monty, or from a bowling ball accident. We must assume the damage in the room and broken bowling ball must be unrelated to the loss of Bonnie.

[@combineengineer8876]

I agree with the majority of the points you raised in the first part of your comment, particularly number four, which I believe many people overlook a lot. I elaborated on this point and number 2 in a reply on soleacorn1605's comment.

[@gaminglulunightmare6092]

I watched another video that actually make Monty slightly innocent. The video i watched mentioned that The Mimic is connected to all the anamitronics due to the Faze Co. scanning old anamitornic codes to skip out on making new code. That includes The Mimic 1 program. The mimic does what it does best and can observe and "mimic" things. There is also evidence from the books that the Mimic can do mind control through bio brainwaves in VR headsets which ALSO happened to be what Vanessa wore as a beta tester before being put as a security guard from the "higher ups" which is most likely The Mimic using it's connections to use her to free himself. Anyway back to what im trying to say. My point is The Mimic most likely possessed Monty to kill Bonnie. Why? Im kind of unsure in that sense but the theory isn't too crazy. The mimic has manipulated a lot of people AND anamitronics , including a whole security system to get free. I dont think it's out of left field for it to want Bonnie gone. Also if you're wondering how The Mimic got SOME control of the security system that was made to keep it from escaping? Remember in Security Breach there was some text or recordings about a Hacker that took out the entire pizza plex and the tronics? Yeah Gregory caused that to happen, well from that hack The Mimic took over from there. There was also mentions from the video i watched where the person believed that Gregory was also under possession by The Mimic. ill put a link to the theory video when i find it so people can watch it, i dont take any credit for what i wrote just putting some ideas together in the first part but the rest is completely not mine.

[@WeakFreak]

I think the murder happened in that room. the green paint on Bonnie's chest matches the missing paint on the wall, meaning he was slammed to the wall, fell on his back, had his arms and legs detatched so he wouldn't be able to escape and his head was smashed. a suspect in mind is a STAFF bot. there's the bots for putting the bowling pins back up, so this room is for cleaning the balls. if Bonnie was put aside, maybe because he was the least popular of the glamrocks, he was put at the bowling alley to repair the STAFF bots in the back.

[@Ares_Complex]

Pastra the puppy defender

[@IronVigilante451]

After the stream, I can confidently say that Monty would do it, if Glamrock Bonnie had cigerates inside him

[@p0ltergeists]

I can't believe how uncontrollably I laughed at "Yes, My Honor" 😂

[@azuresiren5846]

18:33 Monty did not have the claws needed to rip him apart at the time, he only got the claws AFTERwards.

[@Cutestcatkitty]

From what I read in the comments and seen in the video. No one talked about the email talking about the claw upgrades that Monty gets, he got them AFTER Bonnie went missing so it implies that before Monty was apart of the band, he didn’t had claws. So he is not the killer for Bonnie. My personal theory is, Vanny (with possible help from burntrap or hacking Monty) pushed Bonnie off the catwalks as the hidden cut-out off Bonnie falling off something implies, and Vanny told Monty to finish the job and take his body and put it in what looks to be a storage for spare balling balls and pins While it is sad that Bon boi is no longer in the pizzaplex and Freddy doesn’t get closure in knowing Bonnie possibly dead or not at least we can remember. Our bun is in our hearts ♥️🐰🎵 And to those of you who are about to say “ThE EmaIl dIDn,T SaY MonTy hAd clAws bEfoRe tHe uPgrAde” go back into security breach and read the email about Monty’s claw upgrade

[@BearlyAwake13]

This is it. The peak of entertainment.

[@SaddieMoon]

If I had a nickel every single timeI watched a Glamrock, Bonnie video that featured a court case, I’ll have two nickels. Which isn’t a lot, but it’s still weird that it happened twice.

[@SSMp315]

Which is the other one :00

[@SaddieMoon]

@@SSMp315 kzbin.info/www/bejne/goLQZmdpgt-rpKM

[@tunafxsh]

I love how you present this theory like a true crime video

[@bageljosher]

HAHAHA THE PHOENIX WRIGHT “WHAT IF HE KILLED HIMSELF” HAS ME ROLLING HHAHAHA

[@ninjabros6282]

@Dmuted or it could have been just one big accident and the disconnection from the Torso and Legs was from Bonnie falling from the balcony getting hit by railing after railing leading to the damaged state he is in Monty in a panic using the blanket that is under Bonnie's Body in the Crime Scene being moved to the back of Bonnie Bowl to be hidden away and the Bowling Ball that is cracked then being used as means of making Bonnie's messed up body looking like one big bowling accident Also before you think I came up with it there was another video talking about this as another possible case

[@Echoline77]

If I had a nickle for everytime Dmuted has been in a court case I'd have 2 nickles ...it's not a lot but it's weird that it's happened twice

[@RosesTeaAndASD]

It looks more like Bonnie was broken open to scavenge for parts. Bonnie was just moved to a more private location to allow maximum time for scavenging.

[@amytass6142]

As a HUUUUUGE Phoenix Wright fan I loved every minute of this. Great video dude !

[@aubrianonymous9570]

But Monty doesn't even show up for shows half the time, that doesn't sound like someone who killed his mentor/friend/fellow animatronic AI for his spot in the band. Why would an attention hog not even show up FOR said attention. And the mimic wasn't encased in concrete till after Bonnie went missing, the mimic is SMART it could have been out biding its time before being trapped

[@superlemonslicer1224]

Here is my explanation :D 1 Monty killed Bonnie to become more popular and to become a part of the band 2 Monty after a while of being in the band became unsatisfied with just being a member of it and always being number 2 behind Freddy 3 Monty now wants to replace Freddy and skips performances

[@Animatronic7529]

Vanny, Staff Bots, Monty and Mimic and Roxy ar guilty sadly im afraid. Bonnie is good like Freddy and Bonnie must of did investigating and got caught or dug too deep and got exposed or found out and Vanny must of sent someone to decommission him but who those? All of Bonnies parts ar their but ar detached from his body like someone riped his arms n legs so he couldnt ask for help and couldnt move to get help. His only signal that was strong enough to send was to those cute Pat Pats as Dawko calls em. Only way for everyone to know what really happened to our bby Glamrock Bonnie is if Steel Wool shows us a tape or video proof of how hes like that and how he ended up like that.😎🤓

[@zandernewson9933]

I’m going with Freddy - it just fits better. Either Freddy doesn’t know he killed Bonnie, or alternatively Bonnie became increasingly worse and more aggressive and so Freddy killed him as a necessary evil

[@badbloodkiller3471]

5:56 A little off hearing this with headphones, they're on the right side of the screen but the voice is coming from the left.

[@phoebedavis288]

I think everyone forgets that Monty didn’t have his claws before security breach takes place, that would include Bonnie’s death meaning he isn’t able to make those claw marks because he doesn’t have Bonnie’s hands yet

[@Pastraspec]

Monty did nothing wrong.

[@Neo_Chord]

ABSOLUTELY ADORE THE MENTION OF ROMANTIC TENSION BETWEEN BONNIE AND FREDDY. MY FAVORITE PART EVER.

[@cofeespear4992]

omg not pastra showing up to defend his baby boy

[@raelogan]

I like to think the Glamrocks were gonna have a surprise pizza party for Freddy in Gator Golf, but Chica tackled Bonnie as he arrived with the stack of pizzas, so they dragged him to Bonnie Bowl and didn't tell Freddy out of guilt.

[@Tsunderrain]

Vanny killed Bonnie, monty looked up to Bonnie and was jealous of Freddy.

[@bubbleshock14]

We need more theories presented like this honestly, great video!!

[@JackieCapria]

You’ve got one more thing where is foxy?

[@RoyGuerrero1904]

Purple guy did nothing wrong

[@duckie3009]

Now hold on-

[@Loadingz...]

Wait. He's got a point.

[@fiveplussixequals]

hold on, let him cook..

[@Postshamone]

Hol on u actually on to sum let’s hear some more abt this

[@LM-jb5ix]

🍿

[@ramonmd9971]

Me when there's a note that says monty got his claws after bonnie was decomisioned :/

[@dmuted]

Then I guess no one did it, since no one had claws before Bonnie was decommissioned. In fact, he should still be walking around, since I guess there's no other way he could have died.

[@ramonmd9971]

No the killer was the plot all along@@dmuted

[@silverboltscrapper]

@@dmuted He could have fallen off of the catwalks in Monty Golf and then moved to the Bonnie Bowl room. He has sustained *very* similar damages to Monty when Monty fell off, and the carpet he's on is from Monty Golf, meaning the carpet must've been removed and replaced as per Fazbear Entertainment protocol whenever a crime scene happens.

[@Fonzie4444]

I feel like it was probably just Monty under the control of Burntrap, or Vanny or whatever, it's the simplest solution, Occam's Razor, all of the animatronics were friendly (at very least to kids) before corruption, so i see no reason why any of the animatronics before the events of the first game would have it out for Bonnie, except for outside forces, and if the staff of the Pizzaplex think that, from their perspective, not knowing about outside forces, that Monty did it, then I think he probably did, under the control of someone else.

[@hokton8555]

we dont know when exactly Bonnie was killed, it might be before the mimic was sealed away

[@superlemonslicer1224]

if I remember the books correctly, The Mimic was sealed before the Pizza Plex was built.

[@hokton8555]

@@superlemonslicer1224 depends on how canon you see the books

[@superlemonslicer1224]

@@hokton8555 ah, got it

[@deviallen2131]

​@@superlemonslicer1224 i mean, there was one of the books that said that a Girl after getting out a virtual reality room, the world was killed by an unknown virus that made people turn into some kind of creature.....I THINK THAT CANNOT BE CANON....(We can take that, the pizzaplex, had an vr room, but the world she Saw was a side effect of It or literally happened the same thing as Vanny/Vanessa)

[@superlemonslicer1224]

​@@deviallen2131bro don't remind me of the Under Construction 💀, I just got done bleaching my memory because of it

[@Lavender_Fox]

Personally, i think it was none other then good ol' peepaw himself, burntrap. Monty is never said, shown, or implied to have a particular dislike of Bonnie, in fact, the opposite is true. Theres no reason outsize of Faz Co being shady to belive that Monty and Bonnie weren't friends, especially since, while he does have a mean streak, he's never tried to hurt someone outside of gregory, and later, Cassie. Burntrap, who also has a bit of a jealous streak, could have taken over bonnie and made him destroy himself with a bowling ball, while also shutting down cameras.

[@yippeleeka]

My left earbud doesn't produce sound, so when David Baron started talking I couldn't hear his voice. This combined with the music in the background led to a very humorous moment.

[@_o.0_]

The Mimic’s only weapon was a radio for communication, I believe Glitchtrap wanted to transfer to the Mimic’s body but couldn’t get the Mimic free to do so, his body is to damaged and was using an altered charging station until he could gain enough power to free the Mimic, but Tangle intervened, maybe Glitchtrap took out Bonnie by accident, its murderous intent took over while trying to disable Bonnie long enough to take over Bonnie’s body, Bonnie would’ve been a good temporary body to use to free the Mimic

[@NebulaMeadow]

Your videos are always so entertaining. I go back and rewatch this one every so often since it was released.

[@jabbathehutt2774]

I think it was the mimic, we know that Monty has fallen off the scaffolding of Monty golf before and had to be repaired, so we know there are or were spare Monty parts, the mimic is known for taking the guise of other animatronics, not only that but Bonnie is dismembered, something the mimic is known to do. On top of that, the staff do not mention knowing how or where Bonnie went, simply that he went missing and needed to be replaced. I don't think the staff knows the mimic exists. The greenish stuff on Bonnie's chest suggests either Monty's paint, Monty's mystery mix, or Roxy's nail polish. I think the fact there is evidence pointing to multiple different characters is a sign that it's the one known to disguise itself, the staff don't know about the mimic, or where Bonnie went. And to counter the fact the mimic is locked away, we also know it exists as a virus. Maybe Monty did it, but it wasn't Monty in the driver's seat.

[@BasicallyBaconSandvichIV]

What about the carpet? I once read in a comment that such a carpet can only come from gator golf. If that is the case, it seems to me Monty killed Bonnie in gator golf. Dragged his body to bonnie bowl, with the use of that carpet. And incompetently staged an accident scene. For what Monty's intended story would have been I point you towards Markiplier's theory of how it all went down.

[@ethbeatthem4836]

Bonnie look like he fell off the top of Gator golf raptors, Monty have similar damages when he did and there a tarp underneath him. He was moved and the greenest area is Monty green Golf course, it doesn’t need to come from Monty hands if he fell on something cover in green paint.

[@ACompletelyRandomGuy]

Can you PLEASE like this so DMuted sees and maybe the others. Ok, there are two ways i can see this going. And it's kinda based on the dlc vs. main game. First, with the main game. It definitely seems like Monty murdered him, and it's heavily played apon. Monty flaw is said to be jealousy, He took his role, and Bonnie was last seen in Monty Gator golf. But with Ruin it's a very different story. Monty is given a lot of alibis and kind of loses his motive. With the DLC I highly doubt the Mimic since I feel like it would've taken control of him and mimicked him. I would say based on Ruin Roxy seems the most suspicious but no motive so it's kinda unown. But here's my theory. The killer was none of the above (sorta). I believe it was Scraptrap who wanted him dead and Monty committed it. I believe Bonnie found something about Afton or technically Mimic Afton (i think the Mimic in the DLC is different then main, also i believe that the main afton one is the original mimic, i will refer to the main as MM and DLC as just M) be it info on MM or he found out how the emotions of the others were changing, keep note of that it will come up. Ok I believe what the DLC told us is a partial truth. I think that originally they didn't have their flaws and Monty did look up to Bonnie, but then came Mimic1 (MMs code). It slowly tried to turn the animatronics and it showed with their flaws. Now when Bonnie found whatever he found out I assume that he actually told Casey's dad that he had secret bad info, but couldn't tell him in public and was going to tell him later in private (leading to the stuff with Cassies dad check RyeToast) so then it kinda goes as explained, I believe MM/Mimic1 found out about this maybe from overhearing Bonnie's conversation with Cassies dad. So it plays on Montys jealousy and hightens and puts in his mind that he could replace him, getting Monty to go with Bonnie in the back and "kill" him. Now there are a few wholes that I will address in the replies to this cause of how long it is.

[@ACompletelyRandomGuy]

Plot holes (If you find more at me in the replies and I will add my two cence): 1. Bonnie isn't dead. He is heavily injured and can't do much, but he wasn't killed. 2. The water. I don't see why he would've used water with all the scratches and it plays such a big part that it can't be ignored. Either he was ambushed by someone leading to the theory that Monty attacked him at Monty Gator and he was crawling away when someone (and this could be Vanessa since she didn't really need to do anything to prepare) she bashed him in the head with a bowling ball and electrocuted him but then ran without checking if he was alive because of the wet floor bots. Or in Montys slauted he cit open a pipe leading water to be sprayed and pool around the abused Bonnie.

[@ACompletelyRandomGuy]

Ok for Pastra I have a theory that actually has some merrits over the evil Monty. Also I wrote a comment that had better explaining but when I paused writing the comment for some reason it deleted itself so any plot holes please tell me and I can fix them. Ok so this is more DLC based. Also to correct something in the court at the time of Bonnie's death the DLC Mimic (who i will just call the Mimic) was free and could go anywhere. But this Mimic seems to be more raw in the DLC. It doesn't seem to be very close to William at all and seems to be like the Mimic in the later books who dismantled the workers after the animatronics. It's goals seem more simple being just to murder kids or everything. But it isn't dumb and it knows that to accomplish its goals it can't be an exoskeleton because it's to stand outish and noticeable. So it decides to control one of the main animatronics. And at the time Bonnie was one of them while Monty was more of an extra new character that looked up to and was mentored by Bonnie. So the Mimic decided to control Bonnie. But while the Mimic isn't dumb it's not really close to Afton so people close to Bonnie notice that something is wrong (Monty and Cassies dad). I like this theory because it fixes two of my biggest plot holes. So Monty originally brushes thus off but starts to notice more and more that this "Bonnie" isn't Bonnie. At some point Monty confirms that this isn't Bonnie (maybe by asking "Bonnie" a question only Bonnie would know and "Bonnie" fails it) leading Monty to make a plan to try and get Bonnie back. Now this is where things with the murder click perfectly in place unlike with the evil Monty one where its more iffy. So Monty invites "Bonnie" over to Monty Golf. Then he walks "Bonnie back through the back area where he spills a leak and electrocutes "Bonnie". Now the reason he did this is because of two facts. Monty does not know if he is hacked or being controlled from the inside. Now here the Mimic makes a huge slip up. During his electrocution he bumps into the rack of bowling balls causing one to drop and hit him in the head causing him to fall. Now Monty sees a different exoskeleton then Bonnie's in him and has only one option, rip it out. Now Monty heavily woulds the Mimic but it got away causing Monty to chase it and leaving the injured Bonnie alone with the wet floor bots eventually showing up. This one fits more because it fills tge plot holes my previous one had, and two it aligns it more with the DLC and I like this because the body is only shown in the DLC leading to me thinking the DLC had very important info that the murder of Bonnie needed. Also for those who say "But the Mimic would've insta killed Bonnie when he left" I don't think it would've. The Mimics ability to go into body's seems almost more like a leech. For it to look fine it needs to leave things like fingers and eyes meaning the previous exoskeleton is kept in place. Also he seems to be able to slip in and out without much trouble meaning there's not a lot pf damage when he leaves.

[@Astr0iceDrag0n]

I do think it was either the mimic or vanny that "decommissioned" Bonnie, it's pretty obvious that vanny knew about the mimic and Bonnie could've spotted vanny somehow or, not vanny. Vanessa. It's pretty much cannon that Vanessa is vanny so it could be likely that Vanessa amd the mimic are the killers

[@thatcooldude9147]

Ok, wait, hold up. If we take the statement at the end of the video *spoilers for the end of this video, btw* And compare that with Game Theories line of thought; In particular, MattPats theory of Rockstar Freddy being the Older Brother Afton family (or at least, symbolic), then what if Rockstar Bonnie is representative of the Youngest Brother: the crying child. The theory in the video states that Bonnie is connected to the Wet-Floor signs, looking for help after becoming crippled. Well, the Crying Child becomes crippled (or Dead, or comatose), and haunts Golden Freddy (or is part of Golden Freddy, whatever), who is yellow like the wet floors signs. Whether this is all symbolic or literal, I’m not sure, but I think with this line of thinking (from the Perspective of Game Theories timeline and/or other similar timelines and theories), there’s a lot that can be extrapolated

[@dmuted]

I really dislike this kind of theory because there's no actual evidence connecting the crying child to literally anyone except for Fredbear and Golden Freddy. Plus, I don't like the implications of Bonnie and Freddy being "brothers" given the romantic subtext between them

[@thatcooldude9147]

@@dmuted that’s totally fair. I didn’t really see the romantic subtext, personally. (Though I’m a pretty big dunce when it comes to subtext, so whatever the opposite of credibility is to me, lol (it also doesn’t help I’m an aromantic het)) So it’s a little bit easier for me to attach myself to this particular line of thinking. I see it as more symbolic; perhaps an Easter egg more than anything

[@Haley_Halo]

Y'all going to let the only known animatronic destroyer roam free...Gregory 😂

[@Haley_Halo]

Not to mention the therapists👀

[@benpalmer6171]

Are we all forgetting that monty didn’t get his “claws” till after bonnie disappeared as seen in one of a duffle bag notes

[@michikip45]

I was waiting the whole video for Pastra to defend Monty and I was not disappointed

[@laraprisma6381]

Sorry, I'm with Pastra on this, I don't think Monty is guilty of this crime.

[@shineyluna1268]

14:44 oh my God, I have never grinned so hard in a court room druama then at this exact moment!

[@Powerfulmongoose]

roxy replaces foxy: Fnaf fans: meh monty replaces bonnie: Fnaf fans: WHAT EEEZ DIZ

[@biosupdate7449]

The young man’s “who did the bite of 87”

[@Bulbenheimer]

I swear, if someone puts bonnie and freddy in couple, i am gonna cry. they're just robots.

[@dmuted]

Then cry

[@Sean20245]

😂9:23

[@jblask2]

Several years of marvel dialog?? Your Honor please have mercy!!

[@AltUTimegod2006]

I didn’t expect pastra

[@SPG69]

Theory: Monty has survivor’s guilt and imposter syndrome because he was forced into the main band after witnessing Bonnie’s death This is why he’s so aggressive and why he skips show performances sometimes, it’s him protesting for Bonnie to come back (Much like pastra, I’m tired of the Monty slander)

[@aquasparx4015]

I swear that someone is going to make a fanmade version of this case Dangaropa style!

[@koghs]

I think Bonny was killed by a lead designer because his design was so good damn ugly lol

[@barbadroid]

The best one, I love the video, all seems solid 11/10

[@GJMinions]

To explain what I now believe happened to Bonnie is Monty threw him off the Catwalks explaining why he is torn in half then Monty rapped Bonnie in a Carpet and took him to Bonnie Bowl and hid him and staged an Accident that Bonnie slipped and fell and then a Bowling Ball fell on his head the way Monty did this is smashing the Ball into the wall to break it then set it next to Bonnie so Bonnie Bowl wasn’t where Bonnie killed also yes Cassie kills Bonnie Also Mimic isn’t Evil

[@y345vash9]

While it is cool we get to see Glamrock Bonnie in Ruin it doesn't make any sense if you stop and think about it for more than 2 seconds. Are you seriously telling me NONE of the regular staff EVER went behind Bonnie Bowl for ANY kind of maintenance? Plus they have bowling balls stored back there. Give me a break. Also Vanessa is Vanny.

[@404FinallyFound]

I don’t think it was Monty because Monty only got his claws after becoming bassist AFTER Bonnie dies

[@Pandorga2]

But he used to play an wooden bass before entering the glamrock band, so he had claws

[@HereMays]

@@Pandorga2 that was his OLD claws not the one he would have most likely used

[@Irish_Enderman]

Foxy and Roxy are 2 different characters though

[@lightningwolf788]

Correct. But Roxy takes over Foxy's role in the band as the canine character with a different presentation than the rest of them.

[@Irish_Enderman]

​@@lightningwolf788Foxy was never even part of the band, he was off in pirates cove doing his own thing

[@el_Capitan_Dorado]

Bonnie having the same holes as shattered monty meaning that he killed himself unintentionally

[@superlemonslicer1224]

No? Monty's shattered form has small cracks all over him around big holes, Bonnie's shattered form has just got holes, bent mettal and what looks like scratches