Who Knows History Better? Debating Archaeologists Vs Self-Taught Historians With Dr. Malavika Binny

[@vidyaashok2510]

All respect to those seeking the truth! I have been studying Kumari kandam.I have explored TamilNadu, Kerala and Karnataka in Bharat and Egypt and now in South America. I agree with Ranveer absolutely to keep questioning. I study about Kumari Kandam and Siddhar parampara..I stumbled upon Kagabujandanar an eminent Siddha in Siddhar tradition(Kaga means Crow).He has seen many civilization and witnessed the cycles in repetition on birth and death.. He mentions of meeting Ved Vyasa and telling him,I have seen many Vyasa before you and will see whoever comes after you.(He was a symbol of immortality) .when the Kumari kandam sank,he had migrated in boats to egypt.There people have worshipped him as Thoth(He who is like the Ibis)..Ibis is bird just like Crow.Look at the similarities of Crow and Ibis both are witness to civilization and still revered as ancestors with ancient knowledge for human survival. Now in Ancient book "Emerald Tablets of Thoth" They describe him as Atlantean(one who escaped dooms day). From that we can infer that Thoth built Pyramids and also there was a huge war with demons.During the war,Some where buzy documenting,some were buzy fighting,,but some escaped to what is Mexico (Meso America Civilazation) There are evidences of boats in their architecture and people have learnt trading in course of time ... Patanjali (Yoga maharishi),Kagabujandar and many more have attained Siddhis (knowledge transfer through consciousness).. Bhogar was a Shaivite Siddhar believed to have ancient Chinese medicinal knowledge.He also taught Toaist founders on Yin and Yang.He returned back to India and installed Palani Muruga(Karthikeya statue) which has medicinal properties. Since the books on Siddhar are written in riddles,It's hard to decode them. I am a humble enthusiasts and keen to know truth just like many here. Because we are living in a world which needs faster transformation and there is divine consciousness that's driving us to walk in the path of light. Vellalar was a 19th century saint revered as gnana siddhar.He spoke that we are all light beings and devoted most of the time in charity.He said the Intelligence we possess is Maya,and it's not the true and final Intelligence. Jai Hind! JAI BHARAT!

[@mithileshjnaik]

Nice.

[@arjunlonewolf]

Search for LMRK. Lion Mayura Royal Kingdom.

[@vanillajoy2106]

Good analysis.

[@vidyaashok2510]

@vanillajoy2106 Thank you for your words.Blessed be your soul

[@vidyaashok2510]

@vanillajoy2106 Thank you,Blessed be your soul

[@mitravasusharma7937]

Person who talks of aryan migration is basically wrong

[@jagatsimulation]

South Indians are Aryans

[@MadhuSudanReddy-m4p]

@@jagatsimulation anybody who is noble in nature is called an Aryan...

[@soumyasub]

@@MadhuSudanReddy-m4p But, here she's not talking about 'Noble People Migrating'.

[@MadhuSudanReddy-m4p]

@@soumyasub u cant make a new meaning of a word out of thin air..

[@amsindia1555]

She's so closed for any other possibility than what she believes. Just another half baked 'historian'. Animals also are evolving and carry inter- generational memory. You can have that little knowledge of you followed any national parks' videos about 3-4 generations of any animal. All of them will give you more insights than you can imagine. all of the animal species have their own languages and emotions. You can easily pick that up if you watch them enough. Just because someone doesn't understand them doesn't mean they are not evolved or evolving.

[@SR-mv2mf]

Beerbiceps team please vet your guests. First you get Madan Gowri and then now this lady. You are doing great disservice to Thamizh and Thamzih Nadu. This lady is not even Tamil. From her accent and name it is clear she is a Malayali and that too one with a clear agenda to distort evidence for the sake of her funders.

[@vivekkatoor]

Absolutely...why on earth was she called even?

[@kdm850]

J Sai Deepak looks different.

[@Trentz2]

Archaeologists can be bought. Also, people have their own angle or hidden agenda.

[@ramdularsingh6531]

Ranveerji, it was about a week ago that I had requested that you invite trained historians and/ or archaeologists to comment on the claims of people like Nilesh Oak and Rupa Bhaty, the latter whom I listen to and found her assertions to be fantastical. It remains me of an occasion, when I attended a pravachan by an ISCON monk, who made declarations of people living for three-four thousand years, and were tall as one-mile long, referencing claims from some of our ancient texts. At question time, I pointed out to him that there were parallel civilizations that existed at the time, but made no such claims in their experience. He quickly pivoted saying, "Oh these incidents occurred in other planets." I am aware that your podcast draws viewership from thousands of people with a predilection to believe in "alternative theories." In the US and around the world many believe in aliens etc. and have been fed by fictional works of Erich Von Daniken. Christianity is going through a serious rethink on the literal beliefs associated with biblical stories, which have no evidential base in history. It is refreshing that you have brought on Dr. Malaika Binny, whose introductory remarks were enough to cast doubts on these claims, although you were attempting some pushback. In the social media world burdened by an overload of information that is not verified or verifiable - the facts do not go through the same comb of scrutiny as reputable news media. Many people tend to accept these claims. No wonder so many people succumb to conspiracy theories, and are subjected to mind-control/ indoctrination. Podcasters have a responsibility to offer balance, even if they wish to whet the appetite of those prone to esoteric and bizarre beliefs. We live in a dangerous world of "fictional truths."

[@amurthavalliselvanathan9818]

Please interview writer Jayamohan sir,he has written Mahabharata in Tamil called Venmurasu, it's neo classical the book is one of the longest in world with 25,000 pages, it's beautiful classic book, one of greatest writer in India, some of his books are translated into English too

[@adhithisuryaconsulting]

You should invite Dushyant Sridhar to your podcast.

[@mithileshjnaik]

One second, she agrees that evidences might be gone, but social memory stays. Aren't the Vedas/the stories/scriptures related to social memory and knowledge transfer??? Being adamant about recorded evidences related to archeology and geology is like putting blinds to horses, to make them follow one direction only. Being stubborn about "only this way is right" is an instant negativity for me. She sounded like the science vs. God argument. If science cannot explain something, it is considered incorrect but it need not be. 200 years ago human flying in air was also illogical. Science is what humans have interpreted and discovered. And it is a constant process, we need to accept that. Somethings which may seem illogical now can really be right few centuries down the line. Denying possibilities based on science and archeology evidences ONLY is nonsense. No doubt free thinkers hate these geeks. ONE thing I have learned over the years is, listen to things with open mind, otherwise you can't progress..

[@ss-ib8gm]

Yes she is contradicting herself

[@ripsanskrit3609]

Science is the kind. Beliefs only lives exists in one's mind

[@Pras123zzx]

She is more logical than kala jaadu theory

[@shivasubbiaah]

Kuku fm is bad but now sounds better than what she explained

[@adityaji2001]

It's funny when people like ranveer are confronted with something called as ' logical reasoning ' .😅😅😅

[@MadhuSudanReddy-m4p]

or pseudo logical reasoning like binny

[@alanalan6884]

இந்தபெண்மணி கேரளாவைசேர்நாத. புலலயர்வகுப்பைசேர்ந்தவர் நல்அறிவுமிக்கவர். தமிழ்தெரிந்துபேசவில்லை. தமிழ்இலக்கியஙாகளை ஆங்கிலத்தில்படித்துதானா. தெரிந்துகொள்கிறார்

[@manlath]

We don't like evidence. We believe in faith.

[@anilk2100]

She doesen't know how evolution works and giving gyan on evolution. 🤣😂🤣😂

[@abhijitn943]

Social evaluation is something different, like we have the custom of nail cutting is part of social evaluation.

[@ajithasajith618]

Sanghis are crying 🤩🤩

[@anilk2100]

@@ajithasajith618 🤣😂🤣😂

[@MAYURESH2731]

First comment ❤❤

[@JJE894]

Seems he will not believe his own DNA report rather he will go with piranha story Karan’s birth 😅😂😂

[@JJE894]

He is confusing with history and belief / imagination

[@ripsanskrit3609]

Short it

[@sunilambat9982]

Again she is brilliant, too good

[@RM-yf2lu]

Was your high jump bar set for limbo dancing?😂

[@manlath]

She's good.

[@mephistopheles2378]

Second comment 😎

[@amsindia1555]

How does she know if what she knows is all the evidence that's out there to know? Can't stand idiots. Sorry can't watch this video more.

[@abhijitn943]

She is speaking Based on the evidence we have , for example u know ur farther is ur father based on what ur mother told and ur birth certificate but what if someone says ur neighbor is ur father will you indulge that ....let people enjoy fanfiction ? Well ?

[@amsindia1555]

@abhijitn943 I won't stoop so low to reason why you are wrong. Using father mother, neighbour as father- you might think you have written something super smartly. It just shows your ignorance.

[@abhijitn943]

​@@amsindia1555 u can't tolerate fanfiction on ur father why should other tolerate fanfiction on our forefathers???? Well ?

[@Colemanchris-o7p]

​@@abhijitn943is spewing bat crap on others comments and feeling like a keyboard warrior is what you do for living? Grow up mate! Well??😅

[@cosmicdrop7001]

juth bol rahi hai !!

[@555nicky]

Why lots of cry ? India is vast dont thing only hindi is Hindian 😂

[@manlath]

Alternate history is fiction