Who's the Author of the Quran? Questions about the Quran, part 3 | Dr. Shabir Ally

[@SiegeDamage]

Very great series and show. Please never stop sharing Allah's message and wisdom. JAK

[@Hamza000h]

I really liked this video. Jazakallah.

[@Aim4sixmeals]

Dr Shabir is so clear its unbelievable

[@السيدالمسيحعبداللهورسوله]

لا اله الا الله وحده لا شريك له له الملك وله الحمد وهو على كل شيء قدير

[@fidelcatsro6948]

Takbeer!!!

[@Downlead]

الله أكبر

[@fatimaxo4885]

I hope you see this message, can you please do a detailed video on your views if shaping brows, hair dyes (black is said to be haram), acrylic nails or polish does it prevent wudhu? Sorry very vain issues but I’m sure sisters would want to know too...

[@rezatofangsazan8607]

Where the donations are to be made and how?

[@Ndms467]

Love ❤️ you brother Shabir 🇵🇰

[@avidverse2122]

Allah hu akbar ☝🏻

[@cartoonnootrac]

Most of the info is borrowed and doctored a little. Even sura is a city of Syria

[@scoops2382]

Just the ridiculousness of a god or creator of the amazingly huge universe, wanting to send us little humans, who haven't been in this universe for a billionth of blink, a book is ludicrous.

[@Natalie-fj7fs]

God didn’t send a book, humans wrote down revelation so that people would not forget the guidance.

[@scoops2382]

You know what i meant

[@cotesia7931]

If God want to help us, so be it.

[@hazratmuhazmat8831]

Why does the Quran think that bones are formed first and flesh put on afterwards? Why is this error there if it is from allah?

[@FarhanAli-qo9we]

from an embryological perspective. this is indeed true. the muscle fibres form after the framework for the skeleton forms

[@hazratmuhazmat8831]

@@FarhanAli-qo9we Hahahaha. Where did you learn that, Zakir Naik? Bones and flesh form simultaneously. But when the bones first form, there is no hardness to them so it actually appears more like flesh. So if you really wanted to get technical, it is the flesh that forms first.

[@Downlead]

@@hazratmuhazmat8831 Dr. Zakir Naik is a medical doctor. He knows very well about embryonic development. Who are you? The distracter of Islam with weak contention.. Did the chicken prince know how to make a chicken?

[@cartoonnootrac]

What do you think. You didn't give your version. Tell us how Adam came to earth, was he dropped from heaven or shipped to earth.

[@cartoonnootrac]

But information was available in previous books, cultures and civilizations and even known to contemporary people of other religions and countries like, Yemen, Egypt, Syria Persia and Europe and even india

[@foursquareenterprise4158]

How old are you

[@preapple]

Multiple persons wrote the Quran over two generations.

[@robd8457]

we know that Allah wrote the Quran because that’s what the Quran says and we know the Quran is truthful because Allah wrote it.

[@pinkpetal489]

Being from the Muslim religion, I would opine that this is not purposeful logic ☘️

[@robd8457]

@@pinkpetal489 love the word 'opine' never heard it before, yes its circular and that was my point but you'll be surprised how often I've seen it as basically validation for the quran

[@agusiman2340]

The biggest problem for every human being is not being able to see God directly so that they are often wrong in looking for the form of God (the real one) & wrong in positioning the existence of God, therefore humans often make wrong decisions in choosing God. But because God is omniscient, most loving and most merciful, then God gives a true guidebook (whose authenticity is preserved until the end of time, namely the Quran) to every human being in the form of revelation (God's words) through a messenger. Therefore God sent down a chosen human being, qualified, holiest and noblest on earth and in heaven because he was given the glory to receive the revelation and convey it to all mankind as a prophet, the messenger of God, namely the prophet Muhammad SAW. God, Allah swt also gave wisdom (the ability to understand and carry out the instructions of the Qur'an correctly) to the prophet Muhammad SAW which was compiled in a trusted hadith book that was sourced from the teachings of the prophet Muhammad himself, so that what was taught / conveyed by the prophet Muhammad SAW must be followed and obeyed . However, all humans will always be tempted, persuaded, misled by the devil & demons so that they are trapped in sinful acts until that person falls into torment & is burned by hellfire. The problem that humans make themselves is that they do not obey the instructions given by Allah swt. They refuse to believe in the Qur'an and hadith, eventually they stray from the path of truth (Allah swt) because in fact they only follow their lusts and worldly desires without caring about the consequences in the hereafter when they are directly faced with God's judgment (Allah swt).

[@joshuaganzon4609]

Very well said. I agree with your point and your explanation is very clear. I think this explanation can be similarly found at the back of the quran that has the English translation that discusses why Allah sent prophets to mankind.

[@joshuaganzon4609]

I would like to add as well that people were created with freewill so people tend to go astray from the just and righteous teachings of God the almighty. The prophets and the teachings (such as the torah, psalms, gospel, and quran) are the guidance of the humankind towards to the orderliness of the world and towards an individual's salvation once he dies (to go to heaven)

[@whatislifebuttheenjoymento3405]

I heard a sheikh say, the Quran was translated to prophet muhammad(scw) in Arabic by jibril(as)

[@bngr_bngr]

It was.

[@ML-jw8kf]

Translated is wrong word. Revealed is correct.

[@Downlead]

@@bngr_bngr the sheikh just want to test if @bngr bngr is happy to hear it.

[@bactrian1442]

Quran 19:64 And we descend not except by the Command of your Lord. To Him belongs what is before us and what is behind us, and what is between those two, and your Lord is never forgetful, In this verse, it is clear that the speaker is Jibril (Gabriel) and not the imaginary Allah.

[@mistermurtad2831]

You mean the author is anonymous? There is no signatory page?

[@TheEchoeman]

Yes. Everything about the Quran is based on CLAIMS. In fact, the very basic claim is that the Quran was revealed to Muhammad by the Angel Gabriel, not Allah. It was this "Angel" who made a CLAIM that the revelation was from Allah. And many Islamic antagonists even say that this "Angel" was in fact the Angel Lucifer who deceived Muhammad inside the cave. There were no witnesses to this cave encounters. It's a STORY that Muhammad told his wife.

[@bngr_bngr]

Muhammad created the Quran.

[@voiceofpeace7658]

*I invite everyone for quran recitation thank you* ❤❤💔

[@thetruthwillsetyoufreejohn3767]

It’s v.sad.. Christian prince is making thousands of Muslims leave Islam.. Why is no one defending Allah from Christian prince.. is there no one brave to debate him.. please do something..😔😢

[@amy84667]

U go say to cprincess do not became keyboard Warrior. Came to open debate. Many muslim want to debate cprincess.

[@cartoonnootrac]

Allah sent messages in the mind of the Prophet Muhammad which he recited to the companions who wrote it. Simply right Or a brain child of prophet,, but to know all that written in Quran maybe is the recollection of the Prophet ,stories he heard from people

[@rafiqul991]

You are always going round and round without sticking to the question. Tell us the evidences we have that the Quran was compiled as God intended. Specially as Othman ended up burning lots of different versions. Was there unanimity for the version we have?

[@bngr_bngr]

Muhammad created the Quran.

[@gyro4726]

@@bngr_bngr prove it. Baseless claim no evidence LMAO.

[@charlesmuhmanson3928]

@@gyro4726 Where is the wall of Dhul Qarnayn? Without the wall, quran falls.

[@sHuRuLuNi]

@@charlesmuhmanson3928 Well, Qur'an hasn't fallen yet, or have you SEARCHED the whole planet and determined there is no such wall?

[@nondual4601]

All the prophets are to be in past or far away future if someone claims to be prophet now they will be put in madhouses or will be killed by fanatic believers. If "God"exists .. is omnipotent and omniscient god doesn't need a middle man. It's just a the dirty trick of human mind which needs external agency to believe in and cling to it . All the religious scriptures are just dead words. You can consider them just as a piece of literature not a holy book. GOD is a hypothesis..

[@bryanbradley6871]

Allah

[@thetruthwillsetyoufreejohn3767]

Dr shabir I think you are the only one who can debate n defeat Christian prince. he is stealing so many of our brothers n sisters 😔

[@thetruthwillsetyoufreejohn3767]

Please debate Christian prince. thousands of Muslims are leaving Islam bcs of this Christian prince .. we need to take this seriously ..he is our nightmare!!!!!😢😭

[@peterhwang1860]

If the Quran was dictated by Muhammad, the scribe could not properly record it, because the entire alphabet for the new Arabic written language, derived from Nabatean Aramaic, had not yet been fully developed. This was introduced later in the form of diacritical marks. Thus, there are ambiguities that can never be resolved, and there are now at least 10 different qiraats, different Arabic versions of the Quran. Interesting choice of language for God's ultimate revelation to mankind, no?

[@sHuRuLuNi]

Really? Like for example right at the beginning in the very first chapter, where you have the word MLK, and in one dialect you read it as "Maalik" and in another you read as "Malik" ... Oh noezzz the Qur'an has been destroyed!!!111 These are CLEARLY TWO DIFFERENT WORDS! Well, what does that verse where this word is in actually say? It says "The MLK of the Day of Judgement". So, if you read it in one dialect it then means "The KING of the Day of Judgement", and if you read it in the other dialect it then means "The RULER of the Day of Judgement". So, isn't a King also a Ruler? Not only does the overall meaning of the verse not change -- but it is in fact ENRICHED by the existence of the two readings: Because someone, at some point in time might not know what a King is, but he would know what a Ruler is - or vice versa. The verse makes sure by the existing reading to fully convey the MESSAGE it presents --- that All-llah is the KING/RULER/THE BOSS / THE ONE IN CHARGE / THE JUDGE / on the Day of Judgment - so as to hammer it down properly that no one could claim "Oh, I didn't know actually that Allah would be the Boss here ..."

[@peterhwang1860]

@@sHuRuLuNi Thank you for your thoughtful reply. However, that is not how language works. Words themselves carry different ambiguities, which is why you have to think carefully to choose the right word, and on top of that, you write many words to explain what you really mean. This is what you have just done, demonstrating that you are a better writer than the author of the Quran. And the differences between qiraats are not dialect differences. The different word substitutions change pronouns and all kinds of words to produce contradictions.

[@moshimodich3645]

John 1:1-4,10,13-14,34 In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. [2] The same was in the beginning with God. [3] All things were made by him; and without him was not any thing made that was made. [4] In him was life; and the life was the light of men. [10] He was in the world, and the world was made by him, and the world knew him not. [13] Which were born, not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God. [14] And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us, (and we beheld his glory, the glory as of the only begotten of the Father,) full of grace and truth. [34] And I saw, and bare record that this is the Son of God.

[@watch13famouspeoplewhoacce45]

💯 Real Proof Jesus Is Not God ❌ The bible makes it clear no one can see God ( 1 John 4 : 20 John 5 : 37 ) ( This proves Jesus can't be God because Jesus has been seen ) ❌ Jesus made it clear he is human by saying to the people our God is one ( Mark 12 : 29 - 31 ) ( This proves Jesus was human, not God ) ❌ Jesus said, why do you call me good ?”No one is good except God alone ( Luke 18 :19 ) ( This proves Jesus can't be God ) ❌ The bible makes it clear God is not a man ( Numbers 23 : 19 ) ( But the christians claim Jesus is human & God 🤦‍♂️) ❌ The Christians claim Jesus is God & he knows the future, but the bible makes it clear Jesus does not know the future ( Mark 13 : 32 ) ( This proves Jesus can't be God )

[@Downlead]

You are right brother. But no Christian dare to reply, except by weak contention.

[@watch13famouspeoplewhoacce45]

@@Downlead totally agree with you brother

[@TheEchoeman]

Jesus NEVER wrote the Gospels. Why are you quoting from it? It's the same as Muslims quoting the Hadith, and yet Allah NEVER wrote the Hadith. Muhammad himself NEVER wrote a single piece of Hadith. So why do Muslims quote and obey the Hadith?

[@Downlead]

@@TheEchoeman As I said, weak contention. Do you know the difference between the author and the copier?

[@TheEchoeman]

@@Downlead I never used the word "author" or "copier". These are your own words. What issue are you bringing up with me? This is what i said, and i will say it again for you: Jesus The Christ DID NOT write the Gospels. Jesus NEVER wrote anything in his lifetime! Why quote the Gospels? Allah NEVER wrote the Quran. Allah NEVER wrote the Hadith. Muhammad NEVER wrote the Hadith. But Muslims quote and obey these writings that NEITHER Allah nor Muhammad wrote. In fact, the STORY says the revelations dictated by Muhammad came from Angel Gabriel, not Allah. Do you know what a STORY is? Did your mother tell you a STORY when you were younger to put you to sleep?

[@thetruthwillsetyoufreejohn3767]

u know there was a sheikh called Muhammad.. he phoned Christian prince n said I'm the best sheik debate me.. n yesterday sheikh Muhammad left Islam after talking to Christian prince.. it was shocking..😒

[@pedroamaralcouto]

Sorry, but you're spamming while trying to convince Shabir to debate with someone who is not a scholar and seems to be a KZbin professional polemicist. Some Muslims are discussing with Christian Prince, for the sake of winning debates, and also making childish videos trying to humiliate him. I'm pretty sure Shabir is not interested in participating in something like that. Some of those Muslims personally attacked Shabir for having a Western scholarship and different opinions. They didn't take constructive criticism. It seems they merely tried to discredit him for no good reason. On the other hand, William Lane Craig praised Shabir. David Wood and the Apostate Prophet, who dislike Islam and mock many Muslims, as far as I know, never denigrated Shabir. I believe it's because Shabir behaves respectfully and doesn't join those fruitless discussions.

[@Downlead]

If he calls himself the best sheikh, so he isn't. His attitude is far from Islamic teaching to avoid arrogance. I believe chicken prince can't take Hidayah from anyone, as he can't give it to anyone. Nevertheless, there are so many fake ex-muslim have been exposed embarrassingly.

[@thetruthwillsetyoufreejohn3767]

@@pedroamaralcouto bt Christian prince is making thousands of people leave Islam. We must take him seriously..

[@Downlead]

@@thetruthwillsetyoufreejohn3767 How do you know so much about Chicken prince? Your KZbin account was registered on September 20th, 2021 ??

[@thetruthwillsetyoufreejohn3767]

@@Downlead magic..? 💙

[@peterhwang1860]

Surah 80 is so vague that it is impossible to tell what the the author was talking about. You could make up any story to try to explain it, such as Muhammad and the blind man, concocted centuries later.

[@TheEchoeman]

There were no witnesses to Muhammad receiving revelations from the Angel Gabriel. Zero witnesses. The Quran is based on dictations made by Muhammad to his Companions. And they didn't even have paper to write on during those days. There are so many opportunities to insert stuff and polish the Quran for many years. And this claim that they double-checked with Muhammad if they got it right, is very rudimentary. Just because a scribe said "I checked this with the Prophet", it doesn't mean he actually did.

[@peterhwang1860]

@@TheEchoeman The situation may be even worse than you think. There is growing evidence that the Quran was composed before Muhammad supposedly lived. All those stories about Muhammad and his companions do not appear till centuries later in the Abbasid caliphate.

[@TheEchoeman]

@@peterhwang1860 There's even a story about the Angel Gabriel slicing open the boy Muhammad's chest when he was 5 years old, cleaned it with water, and sewed it back into his chest. And the Islamic authorities classified it as Authentic Hadith because they said so.

[@shazanomar4033]

@@TheEchoeman Iove your writing. You have got a good sense of humour.

[@TheEchoeman]

@@shazanomar4033 No, it's not my writing. It's Islamic literature. They teach it to Muslims. Haven't you read this before about Gabriel slicing the chest of the boy Muhammad to take out his heart?

[@moshimodich3645]

Allah is not God of Israel. YHWH Elohim the true God of Israel savior He was revealed in the flesh through His Word His Son Jesus christ savior THE WORD OF GOD WAS JESUS. Isaiah 44:6 Thus saith the Lord the King of Israel, and his redeemer the Lord of hosts; I am the first, and I am the last; and beside me there is no God. Luke 2:11,25-26,30-32 For unto you is born this day in the city of David a Saviour, which is Christ the Lord. [25] And, behold, there was a man in Jerusalem, whose name was Simeon; and the same man was just and devout, waiting for the consolation of Israel: and the Holy Ghost was upon him. [26] And it was revealed unto him by the Holy Ghost, that he should not see death, before he had seen the Lord's Christ. [30] For mine eyes have seen thy salvation, [31] Which thou hast prepared before the face of all people; [32] A light to lighten the Gentiles, and the glory of thy people Israel.

[@TheEchoeman]

But God "finger-writing" on the stone tablets of Moses, was based on a STORY. It's a form of STORY-TELLING. God Almighty NEVER wrote the Torah. So who wrote this STORY? Why is proof and evidence simply based on some STORY? Ahmed Deedat himself said in his videos that Moses NEVER wrote the Torah either. And where are these stone tablets anyway?

[@thetruthwillsetyoufreejohn3767]

Dr shabir I think u are the only who can debate n defeat Christian prince.. he is stealing so many of our brothers n sisters😔