Why Are Indians Giving Up Citizenship in Record Numbers? | Vantage with Palki Sharma

Why Are Indians Giving Up Citizenship in Record Numbers? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Indians top the list of people acquiring citizenships in OECD countries.
Question is- why are Indians giving up on the Indian passport in record numbers?
Where are they going?
Palki Sharma brings you the report.
---
India | OECD | Indian Passport | VISA | Citizenship | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#india #oecd #indianpassport #visa #citizenship #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
​
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029...

[@Firstpost]

We’re on the verge of reaching 3 million subscribers on KZbin! Are you part of our community yet? Join us! Subscribe to Firstpost at www.youtube.com/@firstpost

[@meowchat6175]

Because the entire subcontinent of India is doomed to sink into the sea in the near future. The world leaders know this fact and have leaked this information to their acquaintances who have done their best to inform their loved ones. The rest will drown.

[@sonaliv1489]

Because we have been trained to be British clerks thanks to British education system and Congress loot and rule for decades and centuries. That's why they in West build business and we beg for jobs still. Please talk about this aspect

[@codejunkes4607]

​@@sonaliv1489 The critical point is that the horrible governance of the corrupt politicians that ruled India and are still ruling India has made India such a bad place to do research, business, high-tech industry or highly educated work. If you are a good student in science, tech, and business, you will affect your career badly if you stay in India. I chose to research in India and visit Germany as a guest scientist; I see the funding and the easy availability of high-tech instruments and materials. Even a special kind of optical glass USA refused to sell, as some electronics, especially after the Russian war started as India didn't fall into their geostrategic allies. Many more technical equipment, chips and special materials are now classified as strategic items even if they have a remote strategic application. The lab I visit has more than 20 times (2000%) more funding than ours, even though Germany's economy (GDP) is 20-25% more than India's. Because Indian politicians are more focused on building temples and stealing money (corruption) than research, specifically scientific and technical, keeping us backwards. Scientists are working here, even if he/she is super talented, and the probability of getting a Nobel prize is much higher here than in India. Even Canada is economically (GDP) much weaker than India, spends much more money on research and do come up with more research paper published in reputed journals per capita. Even if there is a slim chance, which scientist wants to give up that?

[@violetsapph1]

Palki Palki Palki!!! Can’t wait for 3 million, wishing you many more!

[@TanksBradley-bf8nt]

Life is cheap in India. You earn more as a uber driver than a doctor in Dehli or Punjabi state.

[@jpau2090]

A very important reason for wealthy / well settled Indians to migrate is quality of life. Terrible traffic everywhere, pathetic work life balance, and lack of green open spaces especially for kids. Highly underrated factor which you guys almost totally missed.

[@_SoundByte_]

True! The report did not really cover anything.

[@vickyv4707]

Who said only wealthy are moving???

[@meg9816]

Aur bahar jakar jo kuch b kaam karte hain, blind side b hona west ko lekar, and wahan tax b properly dete hain jo india mein har ek tax bachane ka sochte h. Kuch 25l dekar bunker mein jaate ya uni admission lekar beech mein chhorkar job karne lagna. Mostly are actually bind sided.

[@DocTor-lw9wy]

Reason is religious hatred

[@vickyv4707]

@@DocTor-lw9wy lol hating which religion...

[@devshreebhardwaj3096]

1. Over-population /over-crowded 2. Pollution 3. Lack of meritocracy thanks to reservation and general mediocrity 4. Lack of work-life balance and corporate slave attitude 5. High tax rate and still no good infrastructure, thanks to corruption 6. Weak Indian Passport - that impacts mobility I'm in Germany and NRIs are discussing this topic on daily basis.

[@Anna_Swamy_Nageshwar]

Lack of work-life balance and corporate slave attitude ...this is one of the reason I left India

[@binod7623]

most Upper Caste people are unpatriotic😡

[@crmbackupcrmbackup988]

5 Germany also has high tax rate i think , we have patience here ,t htinga are changing , Infra is coming . 6 they are working to fix it . those NRIS are often similar minded , no variety in their discussions

[@Xiaa_Jyoti_xinpho]

​@@crmbackupcrmbackup988look at the cities they still look like 1960s although bjp is doing better than others most are still stuck in socialism

[@Avenger-bd2fs]

Reservation is main reason. Atleast our kids must live in a place where if they work hard they will be successful. Their birth doesn't define their success .

[@user-kg5lq6nd7q]

I went to india with my mom who by the way has never smoked or experience breathing issues. 2 days in jaipur and she was ILL. She struggled SO much with the pollution that it almost debilitated her. So, that would be a good reason + the cleanliness

[@adrienneanderson-smith2257]

In USA we had protests - back in the 1960’s! DEMANDING factories to filter exhausts. To STOP water pollution! We came up with methods to clean the environment. Businesses were fined if they didn’t comply. It IS achievable. IOW: Clean up your own mess before you come over here!

[@RedRooster52]

The biggest reason is for 200 % tax on imports.

[@sushimmukerji515]

Five of my uncles and aunts- aged 85 to 90- passed away in the last few years in Calcutta, one of the most polluted cities in the world; none of them suffered from lung problems/disease. Another uncle- still living there- is doing well at 95. One grand uncle lived to be 99. And over here in the US kids (and adults) have severe breathing problem at home, at school where everything is kept clean and pollution free. My kids growing up in US never had such breathing issues. Sorry for your mother. But too much coddling is going on. Smell the roses. And enjoy life. By the way, Jaipur in India is far less polluted than Calcutta where I came from.

[@user-kg5lq6nd7q]

@@sushimmukerji515 sometimes that’s just how it is. My moms friend died of lung cancer and never smoked a day in her life. My grandfather was a chain smoker and never got cancer / didn’t die from lung issues. Sometimes it’s just chance 🤷🏻‍♀️. It’s good they don’t struggle, couldn’t imagine having to deal with that

[@sushimmukerji515]

@@user-kg5lq6nd7q Your mom seemed to have allergies that acted up in India (Jaipur); perhaps due to stress of travelling long flights; it happens even in America if you are stressed. And you attributed all her troubles to the pollution and cleanliness of INDIA! And aired your complains against India/ Indians when you noticed a news item on India!! I have been to Jaipur once about 20 yrs ago. It is a historical place with castles and all where so many battles were fought and romance displayed in the past (anytime you visit to any historical place you should read its history before you visit). I don't know if you noticed numerous stalls on the street selling wonderful handicraft. Anyway, I left India immediately after I graduated just to get away from home. With my education I always got a decent job and ended up in USA 55 years ago. USA has been kind to me.

[@noonecares514]

One of the biggest reasons is that people in india are becoming more rude , arrogant and egoistic towards each other day by day. And I'm not talking about one race against another but in general. I walk out in public places and rarely meet someone genuinely nice , the possibility is almost zero atleast in my generation ( youth ). Better living not only is better environment , better infrastructure its also about good people. If you are surrounded by nice people your health , your work will automatically get better. People in india don't even feel like working because there are too many annoying people even in the work place.

[@neil_XXX]

What bullshit lmao.

[@manojsamal3430]

So true. Seems everybody is in a constant war of proving superiority. All people want is as much as flats/properties, Expensive cars and other irrelevant material things with zero respect for environment so that they can show off it to their relatives, friends and neighbours. Here people don't tolerate others success and achievements and search for every opportunity to bring others down. Sad reality but true.

[@shanemad1640]

They are the same here in Australia. Most people see Indians as arrogant. BTW , Mein bhi desi hu . Just saying what most Desi’s won’t admit to .

[@hazelem1266]

I work with a lot of Indian nurses in Australia. I asked the same question, because my friend became a citizen but not her husband. She said India does not allow dual citizenship, so the mother becomes a citizen of their resident countries with their children, and the father keeps his Indian citizenship so that they can keep ownership of property in India.

[@pippo767]

Overseas Indians can inherit property in India. Also any foreigner can buy non farming land in India

[@hazelem1266]

@@pippo767 I’m just repeating what she said. Because non of the Indian adult males had taken citizenship.

[@jeanettenorman7052]

I think it is time to STOP dual citizenship here in Australia. This is a primary reason - abuse our free healthcare education land ownership.

[@joelc9439]

A lot of them eventually sell up their property back home..

[@stillsearching5816]

@@hazelem1266I understand but most Indians that go outside for nursing and caring jobs really don’t know anything about the laws, so I am not surprised.

[@aryavishwanathan4662]

In India, sadly you get nothing in return for the high taxes you pay. That's the single biggest issue.

[@aayushmanmishra8856]

​@@chandan__mAs I citizen I can pay taxes on time but the development works are to be done by government which has so many ministers and workers largest party on earth

[@Indiaengineer1960]

You and your family voted for the past 75 years for the bad messy rules of the past. Remember Congress they have brought this stage, population control was biased only certain communities follow population control rules of the gov others won't follow any law. Vote wise if you need good leadership and safety doesn't matter in the US Canada or even India, presently people can get shot in the street in the US Look at 22 was killed in the street in Maine yesterday, law and order issues are in peak break-ins shooting drug issues are throughout Canada, UK is even worsening. Be thoughtful before the comment.

[@404vlogs]

Absolutely true. On a bad stretch of road, you don't even have the choice to drive on the good part of the road. On that part, you'll find a rickshawwala driving, who probably pays nothing in TAX

[@lovedoggies2819]

Definitely you won't get because since bjp are in power they are cheating and robbing people and they bjp are injoying their life through indian taxpayers and making indian people suffer and making people of India fool by saying jai Shiri ram

[@Iamsahiil]

I live in Canada and I can tell you it's nothing what you think People just accept it as reality and settle but many return bcoz we know India is better than these in many terms

[@HSA-]

I'm a Canadian citizen since this year. For me the biggest reason is to avoid the corruption. I bought a property in Canada without being scammed or having to pay bribes to any government officials.😂 I'm relieved that I don't have to deal with the Indian income tax department from now either 🙏 the other thing is I don't have to worry about my property being seized randomly like it can happen in India

[@adrienneanderson-smith2257]

Canada! LOL! Just wait, it’s coming.

[@13JSL]

Absolutely true and people think Canada is finished but they forgot Canada have 100 years resources hidden in North which will keep country running always …. Long live Canada America ….

[@rajatgupta4840]

True...Biggest reason is corruption and reservation...Even in Modi's era, both evils keep on increasing..deserving People are now sick of all that BS...But NRIs will always love India no matter if they denounce citizenship

[@ankanaghosh5163]

but it will be costly to live there right?

[@rajatgupta4840]

@@ankanaghosh5163 India is more expensive

[@rohitshenoy6102]

Population is one of the biggest factors. Flights, tourist places, 5 star hotels, everything is crowded in india. In USA, countryside is sparsly populated

[@giridharrao8055]

I am Bindu Rao from Bangalore. The main reasons for our Indians to leave India and settle down in a foreign country are… 1). Poor infrastructure in India 2). Common people don’t follow even one small bit of traffic rules or any other basic rule. 3). Cleanliness- far away from our routine Honesty and sincerity-last choice 4). No one is committed to our country 5). Corruption at all levels. 6). Reservation on basis of caste

[@ajdano2525]

India Superpower, INDIA IS GREAT POWER NOW 2023 UNDER MODI

[@ajdano2525]

#5 best economy in the world

[@SudhanshuDhanraj]

+ caste discrimination

[@shayanwarisa]

And so you won't stay, help your country educate in all these issues and rather run away to other countries. Wow. Deshbhakt. 🙏🏽🙏🏽

[@nmew6926]

All these issues cannot be fixed because of the so called democracy

[@AX7razor]

To be honest, this will only continue to increase. As an Indian who is currently abroad, I can understand why people are doing this after they've settled into their new nations after studies/Work/etc. There are so many reasons as to why, these are a few: 1) Good quality of life abroad: These include good work life balance, clean spaces, very manageable traffic, etc. 2) Less Corruption: The Indian bureaucracy is highly corrupt at every level and dealing with administrative tasks can be an absolute pain leading to offering bribes everywhere to get things done. 3) A better sense of respect directed towards other people as well as civil rules put in place which ensure the smooth running of society in general. 4) High Trust: People are generally honest and rely on trust to get work done. This is not something that I've seen in India. We can't trust anyone completely and fear that they may stab us in the back when the time comes. This may often lead to micro-management. 5) Equal opportunity: There is no caste/reservation system. Everyone gets equal opportunity to get what they want (no discrimination against your caste/religion/beliefs/etc). 6) Population: Because there is way less population, everything is more manageable (the lesser people you have it becomes easier to manage a nation - lesser infrastructure required, can focus on quality rather than quantity in general in all aspects) 7) Lack of Open & Clean spaces to spend time with friends/family. Being overcrowded means that there are very few green/open spaces. 8) A better focus given towards pursuing your extra curricular activities. (sports/camping/travelling/etc) In India, for most people our only choice is an engineer, doctor Or a Lawyer (I know its a stereotype but it holds true very well from a global, nation-wide perspective. We also work longer hours and can be expected very frequently to work on the weekends depending the type of job you have). This also a good Segway to say that all types of work are respected. People don't look down on you if you don't have a high flying/high paying job. Here, Work is truly Worship. 9) Healthcare: This is a big one. At least in Europe (where I am) healthcare is FREE! Social security covers everything. I don't need shell out a crap ton of money to get my health problems fixed. I Love my country and personally, I may not change my citizenship but I can understand why people are doing this.

[@odynith9356]

Not change citizenship, so what you’re doing is using and stealing from the new country. Typical Indians

[@josephdsouza1515]

No unity in religions... our PM and his members should promote peace and unity INSIDE OUR COUNTRY, FIRST OF ALL and stop running abroad hundred times

[@RedRooster52]

The biggest reason is for 200 % tax on imports.

[@Bauer787i]

@@RedRooster52 true and you can't get good cars like FORD RANGER RAPTOR where as in austrlia this same car is only 40,000 aud.. thanks to MODI

[@chfhyggtyhh999]

Add racism and stereotypes on Indians

[@ljosephdumas3113]

Regarding the India / Canada row. Never confuse a people with a government. As I was told "People sometimes grow up; nations never do." I live in a very diverse area in the US and we all get along. One of my sons was thrilled when he discovered his grade school class had a student body that spoke 12 different languages - out of 27 students. So no surprise Indians in Canada are being welcomed (of course Canadians are the World's Most Polite People to begin with...)

[@1966johnnywayne]

Is it your opinion that Indians lean more towards the Liberal or Conservative party in federal politics? I have a young Indian family living next door, and they are incredibly polite and friendly people...almost too much so...I'm kinda an introvert when it comes to neighbours, and I have avoided any discussions regarding politics with them as I can be very bull headed when I discuss it, but I'm getting a conservative vibe from them. I ask because the recently arrived Indian population could be quite a voting block come the next federal election.

[@cinpeace353]

​@@1966johnnywayneA lot of them are NDP.

[@Pos546]

Vote bank politics of that Pm

[@Raymanujan]

Canadians' politeness is biting them in the back.

[@ibizawavey8630]

@@Raymanujan Trust me they are awake now, go anywhere online, they are fully awake, no more politeness.

[@punishanpika]

Honestly probably helpful because it: - gets rid of fanatical ideologues - increases remittances - desensitises people to Indians and Indian culture - makes other countries closer in culture to India so more international politics in India's favour - creates an export market for Indian goods - gives easier people for the government and businesses to try and work with for international operations, due to the shared background

[@koolcamel]

I was reading few comments. Grass is always greener on other side. I have lived in the USA for 12 years and currently in the UK for 2 years. I understand the challenges India got, but even outside India there are 100s of challenges which people living outside can relate: 1. There is constant sense of detachment once the initial few years honeymoon time is over. Initially you feel "wow this country is great, but you come back to realisation." 2. Social circle remains limited specially with family. Family events are rare. 3. Less culture and food. You try to be wanna be and get involved more with "white people" but they keep limited relationship with you. 4. You struggle with mental and emotional stress. 5. You keep working all the time non-stop. After work, you struggle with your chores. 6. You always feel of going back to India and you miss all that chaos. As I told grass is always greener on other side. It happens either if you are in India or in some western world. Edit: Few judgementals asked when I plan to come back to India. I infact did it in 2020. Left USA and moved back but got admitted to ICU during delta wave and we had 8 months old kid. Wife saw me dying in the hospital and we decided to move out again considering that wasn't the right time for us. Let's not judge others without knowing someone's condition.

[@palikavraja1740]

The most sensible comment on here.

[@deepakishere-e1d]

​@@palikavraja1740absolutely an Indian living in Germany for 7 years and now wanna go back next year

[@Mandar1209]

Only people living outside India understand the pain points !!...........as said in another reply "most sensible comment here" is true .

[@anupshende1986]

I am living in Canada for last 15 years and I can relate to every bit of word you mentioned. Desis don’t understand the value of being with your loved ones until they come here. They think living among Whites make them White 😂😂. Reality strikes to these brownies within few years of their migration.

[@metfreak100]

My immediate cousins and brothers have settled abroad since a very long time. They never faced these issues. They have cultural programs happening and many indian and white friends joining in. Initially there was little bit of getting adjusting but they are pretty much sorted and happy. I have same feedback by a friend whos settled in germany so i think this is an individual perspective. Had they missed out so much they'd have come back years ago.

[@jayaziz3785]

I have never been to lndia but l have an lndian neighbor who always talk very highly and defensively about lndia and visits lndia regularly. I asked him, if love lndia so much, why don't you return a style there. His reply, never, too much poverty, dirt, pollution, corruption, nepotism, relegious bias, unemployment etc..etc..And l wondered. 🙄

[@vikramsidhartha4730]

Agreed 💯

[@bahaar2825]

What a hypocrite!

[@zianeshkasparen4358]

I do wonder too. Let him/her keep lying to him-/herself.

[@pippo767]

​For Hindu Indians India is a holy motherland. All Hindus love India like the Christians love Bethlehem.

[@KrishnaKamal49]

I love my mother too, that doesn't mean I have to stay with her all my life. We move on for better opportunities

[@stevenmoomey2115]

Three of my Drs. In the USA were Indian, our Children’s Pediatrician Drs. were Indian. Only reason I’m down to one is Children are Grown, One Retired, and the other kept changing Practices. That leaves me with one, all are very excellent Drs. BTW, the one that changed practices, was due to lack of respect by colleagues.

[@khanhhung8959]

Leaving India is every Indian dream

[@DIYBill]

Th biggest accomplishment is to leave India

[@gautaminandi5572]

Looks like you dedicated your life to India my dear patriot.

[@bial3436]

@@DIYBillThis says it all

[@divyanshbhutra5071]

1. Reservation 2. Absurd taxes for wealthy individuals 3. No quality high education (The best IIT barely manges to make it to top 500 universities globally) 4. Lack of security against peaceful crimes 5. Lack of pride in Indian brands

[@_saurav.sharma_]

Pin this

[@cherylsaha9152]

Absolutely right

[@ratan012]

Agree with Reservation but all other reasons are ridiculous. Canadian education system sucks. Sceuctity in USA is a joke. Health care is beyond anyone's affordability. Canada Healthcare system sucks too. It used to be good some decades ago. Most people go to India or consult alternative medicine-systems for health issues. No matter how much one says, you are always and forever remain a second class citizen. Cost of living is exorbitantly high. The main reason is, Indians are ready to clean western toilets, drive trucks and do other jobs. They feel proud to be an informed slave to the white people at any given time. Further more, they have no self-respect. Above all, too much population / poluution which drive many too. No worries, things are reversing & more foreign-loving-Indians will pay heavy price

[@JV-oi6ch]

@@nasimulkhan49 it's actually "pieceful crimes" perpetrated by the Re ligion of Piece (a piece of this and a piece of that).

[@Sunny-sc5vq]

Didn't iisc Bangalore make it in the 200-250 range?

[@rampratap7965]

When I was in 2012 they said 2025 will be the golden year of India Indian will become a developed nation with high standards of living, now the number has shifted to 2031, I don’t think this will happen any time soon in next few decades.

[@KANGZZZ.]

Modi said in 2014 India will be a developed nation by 2020 Again in 2019 he said India will be a developed nation by 2030 Now recently again he said India will be developed nation by 2040 Let me tell u a true fact nothing gonna change.China build their country during their highest youth population.And now India currently possess the highest youth population.If India doesn't achieve its goal by 2050.Than India won't change and will remain underdeveloped country.Sadly nothing is changing. Religion and caste these are the two things that destroyed this country.They act as a tool against real problems.

[@MTSeeker-jc1xm]

India is a superpower. It is a Vishguru. Modi ji has been in power since 10 years and he promised "Achhe din" in 2014. And India has "Acche din" now. Har har Modi, ghar ghar Modi

[@bumblebe3888]

Maybe 2050

[@iamuzumakianduchiha776]

@@MTSeeker-jc1xmThe per capita barely even increased in past 10 years 😂

[@bopian8913]

Maybe in year 5000.

[@user-rl3iv2jk9q]

Thank you for your presentation , I watched all of it . I will try to watch more of your reports .

[@4word1]

Oh wow, that makes sense. I see them everywhere now in Canada.

[@Money88147]

Main factors that you are hesitant to call out. Caste politics, reservation in all aspects of life, poor state of medical ,police and justice system. No govt support for child care and social security and ridiculous education cost even from birth. Pollution and traffic takes the life out of you.

[@sukantkarmakar8474]

Also roits of piece full community.

[@abhishekvembadi1036]

​@@sukantkarmakar8474wrong. We leave to avoid people like you, who incite violence against a faith, have disdain towards specific groups based on identity/faith, and lack tolerance to live in harmony. Most people switch citizenship to countries like, USA or Australia, that are more accepting of people's personal choices.

[@JinSakai_Kuroudo]

This caste politics exists in offices too, while recruiting and while working promotions all these things matter. Minorities and low caste people are often treated very badly in MNCs

[@S7evn201]

Caste politics is because of the mistakes of our parents & grandparents. Congress party has been in power for 65 years. Who voted for them during those 65 years? Who popularized caste politics? Your parents & grandparents popularised it. People vote in the name of caste & religion & then blame the politicians. How is that fair?

[@abhishekvembadi1036]

@@S7evn201 Identity politics has always been a part of our politics, even right now, and it's not limited to just 1 political party. The leaders of the current ruling party have made incendiary comments belittling other faiths to mobilise support from the majority groups. Citizens must eschew such divisive rhetoric and focus on what values they espouse-tolerance for all beliefs, equal opportunities for all, economic development, and seperation of politics from religion/caste.

[@karansingh-ez6jc]

I also left Thanks to reservation Thanks to free subsidies and high taxes Never forget that Reverse discrimination is also a discrimination

[@ankitmohapatra22]

bad policies can change but cowards dont coz they are cowards good choice just leave

[@karankumar-yq6ep]

@@ankitmohapatra22 bhai ,,he made a nice decison ....being a coward rewarded me a handsome package and a ultimate hot german girfriend........ mai toh saato janam hi coward choose kaaruga abh #cowardforlife #cowardsWin

[@sonaliv1489]

We left because of old nasty Congress policies. We didn't know if Modi and opportunities he would bring. Had that happened earlier, we would have stayed in Bharat. India got stagnated due to pathetic Congress policies. This lack of growth infrastructure, development and jobs due to bad Congress policies led to the current situation. It will take a while for India to undo all those policies. Till then Indians will travel.

[@amj.composer]

I left too, never regretted it

[@ankitmohapatra22]

@@karankumar-yq6ep 👍👍 good choice just dont come back

[@hindustan1815]

*अच्छी जिंदगी गुजारने के लिए अमीर लोग, अच्छे मुल्क जाते हैं और हमारे जैसे गरीब लोग ये ही सोच कर खुश हो जाते हैं कि भारत से अच्छा कोई मुल्क नहीं है*

[@avinashsalunke8184]

Aap bhi Amir ban jao aap ko kisne roka hai.Aur bad me dusre desh chale jao.

[@kayeditz3]

All thanks to Indian media. Everyone is scared wether they are Hindu, Muslim, and Sikh.

[@ssark9187]

You left one key thing. The General vs SC vs ST category. The mejority of people who are leaving belongs from the general category. I personally know one person who left simply because he felt Insulted that he couldn't get a govt job while someone with a lower number got it just because of their SC status. Now he lives in USA and straight up says that he will never return. I know you can't mention it, but unfortunately just because you closed your eyes, doesn't mean that the problem is not there. 😔

[@codejunkes4607]

The current government has increased the reservation by more than 50%, which is against the Supreme Court's ruling. Today, India has the highest reserved seats under the current ruling government. The only way to improve this situation is to vote wisely and not choose someone who will continue to do that! The critical point is that the horrible governance of the corrupt politicians that ruled India and are still ruling India has made India such a bad place to do research, business, high-tech industry or highly educated work. If you are a good student in science, tech, and business, you will affect your career badly if you stay in India. I chose to research in India and visit Germany as a guest scientist; I see the funding and the easy availability of high-tech instruments and materials. Even a special kind of optical glass USA refused to sell, as some electronics, especially after the Russian war started as India didn't fall into their geostrategic allies. Many more technical equipment, chips and special materials are now classified as strategic items even if they have a remote strategic application. The lab I visit has more than 20 times (2000%) more funding than ours, even though Germany's economy (GDP) is 20-25% more than India's. Because Indian politicians are more focused on building temples and stealing money (corruption) than research, specifically scientific and technical, keeping us backwards. Scientists are working here, even if he/she is super talented, and the probability of getting a Nobel prize is much higher here than in India. Even Canada is economically (GDP) much weaker than India, spends much more money on research and do come up with more research paper published in reputed journals per capita. Even if there is a slim chance, which scientist wants to give up that?

[@divyanshbhutra5071]

❤

[@ssark9187]

@@codejunkes4607 Does not matter who rules India, nothing will change. No party will risk loosing the Vote Bank.

[@codejunkes4607]

@@ssark9187 vote to Aarakshan Virodhi Party then! I don't think that reservation is the major issue in our field, where employees or researchers already have a degree in Medical, Engineering or Science from top government institutes. Even if there is no reservation, to do anything technical, you need funding. But yes, if a student is leaving for his MBBS, MS, etc. then sure. I just added the reservation point in reply to the original commenting person.

[@pritsingh9766]

I am from general category, i hate democracy and this constitution but no matter what, i will never leave my motherland 😎

[@kiwiwala]

Some year ago a former New Zealand Prime Minister, Robert Muldoon, was asked to comment on the large number of Kiwis leaving for Australia. He replied that it did not bother him as it improved the intelligence level in both countries.

[@savioblanc]

In a fun interesting twist, New Zealanders who were born or even brought up in Australia, who seem to be of Pacific Island/Maori extraction primarily, are now being deported en masse back to NZ for being involved in hardcore crime and gangs. Seems like Australia was getting the worst of NZ

[@ProtomanButCallMeBlues]

based Kiwi's always finding a way to throw fire at Australia

[@carloko08]

well, the truth is that kiwis is quite inteligent than aussies cos new zealand is now plenty of yankee inmigrants, and they are not the best quality persons but just ecological and democrats depraveds and junkies from california, so kiwis prefer to leave new zealand to avoid that kind of toxic people, so the minister is wrong: kiwis are more inteligent than aussies

[@pokhuthird1194]

lol

[@maxhugen]

Funny retort from our poor cousins across the ditch. 😎🇦🇺

[@ori5581]

Don’t escape your proud india. Many locals in other country are tired of too many indians

[@BrownByTasteProudByChoice]

The lady speaks in a self righteous authentic tone as if there is a breaking news. And the news report throws some generally available figures without even talking about the real reasons. Great journalism!!

[@varunsundaresan8271]

True! Hahaha :D

[@larrybaba5635]

1. Reservation 2. Govt focus on lower class and Elites, middle class to pay taxes 3. Weak passport 4. Corruption & lard ass govt officials 5. Pollution & Adulteration 6. Opportunities in limited fields only 7. Ever depreciating Rupee 8. No social security

[@isodimetrix]

well last 3 points i kinda disagree..many jobs r in india that reqd skillls but no one is there... pollution..and adulteration..u woudl find that in foreign even more...and abt deprcitating rupee.. all currencies r actually suffering while rupee is still balanced between 80-83 around...and rest of the things u said i agree

[@srujan797]

What about social security

[@codejunkes4607]

The current government has increased the reservation by more than 50%, which is against the Supreme Court's ruling. Today, India has the highest reserved seats under the current ruling government. The only way to improve this situation is to vote wisely and not choose someone who will continue to do that! The critical point is that the horrible governance of the corrupt politicians that ruled India and are still ruling India has made India such a bad place to do research, business, high-tech industry or highly educated work. If you are a good student in science, tech, and business, you will affect your career badly if you stay in India. I chose to research in India and visit Germany as a guest scientist; I see the funding and the easy availability of high-tech instruments and materials. Even a special kind of optical glass USA refused to sell, as some electronics, especially after the Russian war started as India didn't fall into their geostrategic allies. Many more technical equipment, chips and special materials are now classified as strategic items even if they have a remote strategic application. The lab I visit has more than 20 times (2000%) more funding than ours, even though Germany's economy (GDP) is 20-25% more than India's. Because Indian politicians are more focused on building temples and stealing money (corruption) than research, specifically scientific and technical, keeping us backwards. Scientists are working here, even if he/she is super talented, and the probability of getting a Nobel prize is much higher here than in India. Even Canada is economically (GDP) much weaker than India, spends much more money on research and do come up with more research paper published in reputed journals per capita. Even if there is a slim chance, which scientist wants to give up that?

[@rashid4490]

​@codejunkes4607 for ur information U can't just be American, Australian or Canadian citizen It takes 10 to 20 years So all of ur theory is wrong 1st u need temporary pr Than permanent pr Then citizenship Also its not so easy as that requires lots of checking Main they left country 10 years before Now they got citizenship So report doesn't contain how many students left per 1000 population Also china has double list than us Because this list is not per 1000 people Otherwise countries like Maldives will never top the list

[@codejunkes4607]

​@@rashid4490 Lol, my friend gets Canadian citizenship in 3 years. It all depends on your value. If you work in critical fields and have experience, you are critical to the host country. You will be preferred. I can ask for any country in most of the country with varying complications and time as a Doctorate in Physics and experience in critical technologies. But I wish to live in India and work for India, it has always been important for me and it will make me happy. Yes, I would have achieved more if I had worked abroad, but I am ok with the trade-off.

[@Skandawin78]

Do a caste wise and state wise census/analysis of indians migrating to US, Canada, Australia, Europe. Then the picture will become clear on the discrimination with reservation, minority appeasement etc. No political party is even willing to talk about reforms in reservation and minority appeasement policies and what they envision as reforms for 2030-40 etc., due to fear of losing their vote bank.

[@rohi1255]

Point on discrimination of tax payers is the stupidest move govt can do

[@JinSakai_Kuroudo]

Yes a lot of these migrants are minorities and so called low caste people. India has become terrible to live if you want a good life. Even getting into colleges or decent jobs is almost impossible. There is discrimination everywhere since Modi came to power. Hindus believe their "time" has come and are seeking revenge on everyone who is not high caste like them. It is the worst time for not being a minority/low caste person in india

[@johnadam2885]

India's diabolical caste system itself is a form of reservation where the notorious Brahmins reserved education and wealth for themselves. The high castes were appeased for too long, and the lowers demand the cake to be shared.

[@sahibolrahahaibhai]

✍️👇 Let me help you with why indians are leaving - 1.heat problem in indian regions like Rajasthan,gujrat , Maharashtra and souther states are too much to avoid and survive 2.the type of northern east regions are and its focus by center is not good . 3.heat traps in names of building and high towers are created which restrict the wind and dont allow city to breathe. 4.climatic condition and dust in air and its AQI level is high and not good for health. 5.cities home rates are expensive which cost you your 30 years to just pay the EMI ,why should man live is it to pay to builders and bricks ?? 6.high inflation being considered and no body out their to restrict the prices , quality and supply. 7.political parties with building developers enjoy the pieces of cake or whole cake or all amount of people . 8.transport system is not sorted and caviate or constraints are created so that people move out to tier2 cities . 9.job security is not their govt allowing companies to hire in contractor or contractual position so that companies dont bare the cost of employees on soldiers ,even companies are just on paper and no security creating hard for people to forsee life stability. 10.unstability in life can broke people financially, socially,and leads to health problems 11.financially no support from govt can eradicate or kill low wage or low income earners if they dont earn for a month the whole family is at stake . 12.divorce issues as unequal right more preferable for womens and less to man causes or harms the individual whole life . 13.heath security is nothing and expense if you see no companies support insurance above 5 lakh , today their is no value of 5 lakh ,govt should min ask companies to have 15-20 lakh insurance. 14.tax exemption limit in 80c is still 1.5lakh even after 8-9years ,so is govt willing to take all our money in tax and so should we just keep on paying taxes to buy you out the political leaders ?? Their has to be tax changes or else no people would even love to be in india.

[@LOLLOL-kg4dz]

india has no future,with riots in manipur,separatist in kashmir, naxalite insurgency, khalistani resement,wrestler's protest,massive unemployment,rising farmers suicides,falling groundwater level, communal tensions, religion politics, north-south india sentiments,uttar pradesh crime rate, poverty, bihar overpopulated, income gap, woman safety, global warming,infrastructure problems, train safety Ranks #107 out of 121 Countries in Global Hunger Index Ranks #126 in Happy Index Ranks #139 in GDP per capita Ranks #132 in HDI index 10% earn

[@RITOBANBHAT]

Nobody will renounce India's passport if dual citizenship is in effect. Don't blame/criticize those leaving India in legal route, it's their choice, respect that.

[@ravindranmokkilmaruthur23]

In Pondicherry I asked an Australian who has been living there for many years what he thought about the below par surroundings .His reply was "you are looking at sorroundings I am looking at good people here" There we have it Grass is greener on the other side.

[@hsridhara]

All my 3 children are outside India. I often request them to return as I'm 70+. The main reasons are many like 1) work life balance 2) worst roads 3) no floor paths 4) no parking 5) corruption 6) no traffic sense 6) garbage and filth everywhere 7) pollution 8) caste politics 9) huge noise pollution 10) lack of opportunity to raise in profession. Hope Pakli will also take up these issues brought up by viewers

[@Raez_XL]

She wont. She is now a mouthpiece, just like pseudo-journalists at CNN, BBC, etc.

[@Nishant.N]

The problems you mentioned. Are you not the part of that problem ? Those who say filthy garbages. Who do that ? Indians who follow rules and regulations in other country will do same thing what people here do. So, how can you blame country. You are talking about Caste politics. Its people who will bring caste all the time. Politics is done on the social fabrics. If you are not talking on caste issues. Why the he’ll government or political parties will do. Indians are happily working in shifts and even small works they do. But, here in India they will never do. This is the double standard of those who are complaining about the situations in India but they forget they are the part of this. At least someone is doing good for India. Before Modi, the things were like - jaisa chal raha chalne do. But, things will change. 🇮🇳😎

[@FuzzyFTW]

They bring those problems with them when they migrate too they have made uk a dump

[@chinmaynaik6642]

Number 11) no love for parents.

[@prabhavvenkatesh9247]

It is palki

[@subh_here]

India will miss the golden development train if Indian govt keeps putting pressure on middle working class population with ever increasing taxation and dont provide enough benefits to the people who are actually paying taxes. Looks like only 5% may be of the entire population who are shredding their hard earned money in taxes , carrying the financial burden of the development ambitions of India. Rest are either increasing the population or looking after their own benefits using politics. Taxpayers are paying taxes in two folds while income tax is deducted at source, rest whatever remains gets clawed back by anything you buy/use/avail services. Yet they have to go through poor infrastructure of cities daily for the same work, they have to entertain rubbish religious/communal politics being done by those tax payers money for vote banks instead of addressing real progressive issues constructively. If calculated properly, a working class person basically give their 3 months of salary to the govt as taxes in a financial year. That's how the nation is rolling. If this is the scenario then these migrations are bound to happen. People wants to see their hard earned money being used in good place otherwise it's better to choose an option where they can use their money on themselves. It's as simple as that .

[@GajrelaBurfi]

It comes to 4 months if u include indirect taxes as well

[@avg_user-dd2yb]

India is hell😢😢

[@UjwalRam]

Our people are in other countries, and not everyone is without taxes. Main problem people face all over the world is medical help. All of the Indian diaspora, come to India for medical facilities, unless a person is healthy, can manage things on their own, both husband and wife work, things aren't that easy even outside. The only thing is it all looks posh and since all follow rules, it looks clean.

[@travelinsightwithsweetlysp392]

sweetlyspiced.wordpress.com/2023/10/25/cinco-de-mayo-festival/

[@soumyaprateeksahu514]

Well said. Agree that the middle class citizens are being charged with double taxation.

[@abhishektiwari3235]

Why?? As an indian we should not ask this. If there was any bhart in the world i would have left too. But its becoming the india the gandhi has dreamed. Congratulations 👏👏👏

[@kenaidiun3736]

Yes, this is great you should talk more about India 's issues, instead being expert about other countries .👍

[@patlee131]

For me personally, the reason for leaving is Reservation system in our eductaion system. It is rediculous. I'll never let my kid go through what I went through. I love my India, but if I can't get admission even after having 98% while someone with 60% gets a seat in reservation quota, what is the purpose of living there.

[@delmanpronto9374]

correct. merit makes no difference anymore. even if you manage to get past the hurdle of reservation, there is the immense level of corruption you have to face when dealing with State authorities. Absolutely sickening experience.

[@sb.sb.sb.]

left for the same reason

[@Ashokkumar-ux6zv]

Are you sure that was the main reason? Do you know any country giving citizenship or job to an indian who doesn't have good eduction?

[@sudheerkumar4886]

There are many deemed private universities which doesn’t have reservations

[@Lionking-lb5gw]

@@Ashokkumar-ux6zv he left after studying of cource. He didnt want his children too suffer the same thing he said.

[@mayank8768]

Reservation is also an important issue. In India Talent is subdued by reservation

[@sonaliv1489]

Blame Congress for that

[@rohitingle2920]

Well I guess you should blame your ancestors for that, if they followed varna system instead of caste system then the picture would be Bharat is the strongest nation in the world. But your ancestors doesn’t want that instead they want their generation have top positions in the society despite of their talent.

[@ullah8334]

Maybe running away from BJP?

[@codejunkes4607]

The current government has increased the reservation by more than 50%, which is against the Supreme Court's ruling. Today, India has the highest reserved seats under the current ruling government. The only way to improve this situation is to vote wisely and not choose someone who will continue to do that! The critical point is that the horrible governance of the corrupt politicians that ruled India and are still ruling India has made India such a bad place to do research, business, high-tech industry or highly educated work. If you are a good student in science, tech, and business, you will affect your career badly if you stay in India. I chose to research in India and visit Germany as a guest scientist; I see the funding and the easy availability of high-tech instruments and materials. Even a special kind of optical glass USA refused to sell, as some electronics, especially after the Russian war started as India didn't fall into their geostrategic allies. Many more technical equipment, chips and special materials are now classified as strategic items even if they have a remote strategic application. The lab I visit has more than 20 times (2000%) more funding than ours, even though Germany's economy (GDP) is 20-25% more than India's. Because Indian politicians are more focused on building temples and stealing money (corruption) than research, specifically scientific and technical, keeping us backwards. Scientists are working here, even if he/she is super talented, and the probability of getting a Nobel prize is much higher here than in India. Even Canada is economically (GDP) much weaker than India, spends much more money on research and do come up with more research paper published in reputed journals per capita. Even if there is a slim chance, which scientist wants to give up that?

[@coder_thoughts]

my reason for applying for german citizen once i am elligible. if you want your country to favour people based on caste instead of talent so choose the caste. talent will go where it is valued

[@bigears5809]

Be patriotic. Live in you own country. Fix what is broken and turn it into a better place.

[@ga1226]

Yeah, no thanks....I've got better things to do in my life than waste my energy in that $hithole. Glad I escaped to greener pastures

[@kshitijsharma5974]

hahaha@@ga1226

[@NativeAmerican458]

I found that people from India are courteous, polite and generally of good character

[@sameeraaftab8096]

Haha that's not really my what you see.

[@Elijah-bj8pv]

Agree

[@befeleme]

People voting with their feet is the most reliable indicator of quality of life. They are welcome, as long as they don't bring with them the beliefs and attitudes that made their home countries unlivable in the first place.

[@alecpym1706]

yes this is the number one problem with imigration, "imigrate and integrate" dont attempt to recreate your country and culture in your adopted country.

[@TheGamingMotionTGM]

@@alecpym1706 The workplace seniority problem in south east asian countries is rampant for a long time. Not only moving to a western european country is a better choice, but I would also integrate too. The past must still be remembered, yet I would move from my past to become like my destination, not the other way around.

[@Bell_plejdo568p]

@@alecpym1706that not g there countries are like that tho, y doenst the west return the trillion the stole a

[@Bell_plejdo568p]

What attitudes made there countries unlivable?

[@thecrimsondragon9744]

People do not simply change their beliefs and attitudes overnight. Go to any Indian or South Asian dominated areas in any Western country and you'll begin to see a pattern.

[@revathichandu7676]

I’m a doctor, and I feel that the only thing which I can do to this country is to stay back, withholding the urge to go overseas. Every day in the service or in the hospital, we feel that we aren’t appreciated enough for how much we sacrifice. On the contrary, my friends abroad are well payed, well respected, have descent work-life balance and are safe.

[@robrob6238]

Try in Uk then you understand...you watch too much western media....If you dont have Sewa Bhawana from Hurt, you should not study Medicine.

[@syamkumarkaturi9761]

Because of ambedkar Christian followers .They encroached lands of others people properties....

[@paadipanta2607]

Nice

[@sum7136]

Thankyou ❤

[@seekertruth72]

what are your thoughts about doctors getting thrashed in hospital by relatives inspite of giving best treatment and trying to save patient recently politican asked hospital head in Nanded to clean toilets there was no fault of him in death 0f 36 people in 24 hours most of govt doctors not paid , they stay and work in poor conditions and medical fees is very high in multicrored after paying no guranteee of quality education

[@jimmycologne6032]

SO MUCH FOR ALL THE TALK ABOUT HOW WELL INDIA IS DOING, WHICH IS ALL SMOKE AND MIRRORS. THEY SHOULD STAY IN INDIA AND HELP IT DEVELOP INSTEAD OF HELPING COLONIAL COUNTRIES.

[@RuchiinChina]

After living in China for 6 years, I think what India lacks is pretty much everything when it comes to liveable public spaces

[@gratefulinlove]

Oh ok thanks. I'm sure you did your bit to make things better for the country before leaving. Also fun fact: China was a developed and rich country from the very start. The Chinese did not stay and serve their country and make it what it is today. It was all done by alien supernatural powers overnight. So you and other Indians of your kind go ahead to seek and enjoy readymade comforts and glory. And please don't forget to sit there and regularly complain about what India lacks. It really helps us all out here. Thanks again!

[@YouCantHandleTheTruth.]

@@gratefulinlove Why are you getting all uptight instead of accepting the facts. You seem to accept Palkee's bs lies and call them facts (look at it now) but keep on denying others are better, especially China. Have you been there? This girl is currently living there and she has every right to correct you poor ill-informed and brainwashed minions.

[@Zoramsaltha]

When covid pandemic began, I was like..why was that happening to me in this life. Being Indian in this life is already enough to last several lifetimes😂.

[@FaroukQazi]

Born and raised in kuwait. Came back to india in 2010. Stayed for 10 years. Started having severe depression. Couldn't stand all the noise and traffic on daily basis. My psych told me to go back to gulf. Working in qatar now. Left behind my family and friends. Very lonely life here but my depression is over and im off all medication.

[@Elijah-bj8pv]

Wow

[@whiteclouds618]

Modi ji's Clean India Program 🤩🤩

[@rajendradalei8483]

I got my PhD from IIT Bombay in an STEM subject, then went on job hunting for three years. Private universities offered me salary bare enough for bread and butter, and with heavy burden and politics. After three years, I lived in Dharabi for six months, made enough money, and got a mediocre job offer from a Swiss Company. Living abroad is never easy, but digesting all discriminations and heavy workloads, destiny surrendered before me in four years. Now I have my own company with 50+ overseas employees. I haven't yet revoked my Indian citizenship, but do not want to go back to India. And although India will be a big economy hub by 2030, I don't think it'll care it's high qualified Individuals, like many PhD holders. It's never money, but employment. And one Indian in abroad means more than 20 of his friends and relatives are on the way.

[@aaronderyl]

Good on ya mate

[@HowieHoward-ti3dx]

You should. Hindus belong in India. Go there and build your country.

[@MrSaikathalder]

every one knows the quality of PHD in IIT. the top quality is BTECH guys, the worst are the phd. I know multiple people from IISC PHD. They make top money, earn duplex in bangalore. so you dont work hard enough and not able to get a good job. blaming on government.

[@6732VK]

is it written in the constitution that it will be a big economy by 2030? Even Modiji has forgotten about his promise of a $5tn economy and changes goalposts all the time.But no shortage of less smart people / people with low standards ready to dance to his latest distraction, like calling India Bharat. At least the Rs 2 economy does well.

[@tinujacob2833]

Don't settle abroad in Christian countries....we should live only in India....

[@exploringphotographer]

One key element the analysis misses to point out is that Indians cannot maintain dual citizenship. So, it becomes necessary to surrender Indian passport. Maybe things would be different if India allowed dual citizenship.

[@PKorp-PriyankaKalyan]

nah, that would be painful because then you have to pay taxes for both countries, no one would like to do that, especially for India.

[@dotmarceo]

The question is why? When forced into a choice, why choose citizenship of a foreign country? Why?

[@mythologicalmainstay5029]

@@PKorp-PriyankaKalyanNo, that’s not case at all No country would go for double taxation

[@mushfiqachowdhury]

Then, both countries will be required mandatory tax

[@anonymously_urs]

​@@dotmarceowell said.... And 100% true.

[@tannyschristy8912]

Cool!

[@chrisreynolds3351]

I have enjoyed this debate. It has given me a wider and more balanced insight into Indian immigration to other countries and the valid reasons for doing so. I was aghast to learn that the ´caste system´ still exists and still detrimentally limits a persons life choices.

[@cheerblond]

Social hierarchies aren't just India's issue-they're global. Class, race, or old money-it's the same game of power and exclusion, everywhere unfortunately.

[@chrisreynolds3351]

@@cheerblond Totally true. We just don´t call it a caste system, we are divided in social groups. It´s exactly the same!

[@DHARMAMEHTA]

the biggest reason is competition, for every employee who has done post-graduation in a well-reputed university, there is a cheaper employee available who may have done its postgraduate from distance learning. The worst part is big companies don't mind hiring them for lower salaries.

[@Purplegalaxy00]

Idk if that well reputated uni or grades matter that much anymore, that era of being that as selling point by itself is largely over for employment, which ofcourse means more competition.

[@2sridhark]

Palki, I am one of the few who relocated to India from US in my retirement. AS a physician i had worked there for 20 plus years and i chose India as a place for my retirement because my parents and my wife's parents are living there and it was time to give back to them what they had done for us in our formative years. Of course there is no way we can pay back what our parents have done for us but to be with them in their hour of need was one important factor. For all the talk about how much India has progressed, I see little evidence of it on the streets, in public sphere. Yes, middle class has grown richer and can afford one or more cars, can get a loan to buy a house or a flat etc etc but that to me is not progress. India is a very corrupt nation where no process seems to be in place, be it traffic on the roads or getting a driving licence.Everywhere there is chaos and corruption. I got a glimpse of that corruption when I was applying for a license to a State in US and needed some documents from my Alma Mater in Delhi. The guy dealing with this was a section officer in the college and openly asked for a bribe! Indians are poor at crowd management and lack discipline. I was shocked (during my early months of coming back here)to see a motorist come on to the pedestrian walk to beat the traffic. When I pointed to him what he was doing, he pointed to me the traffic justifying his action! It is not just the political class that is corrupt. Corruption is in the blood of the Indians. Indians also lack knowledge of what ethics, morality is all about. A dermatologist in Bangalore to whom my wife went for a skin ailment gave her a medicine from her shelf and charged for it. Back in US she would lose her license but she obviously had no clue what she was doing was unethical. I can go on but i guess you get the gist. This also explains why so many Indians migrate abroad and opt to stay on. They find a place where they don't have to pay bribes,where they can give their children quality education without having to pay a hefty donation to the school, where paying tax matters because the tax is put to good use (less than 5% Indians in India pay taxes!).

[@seneca983]

"Yes, middle class has grown richer and can afford one or more cars, can get a loan to buy a house or a flat etc etc but that to me is not progress." A lot of people in India have been lifted out from extreme poverty in recent decades. That's real progress, even though a lot of poverty (and corruption) still remain.

[@SakthiG-wo2gj]

Unethical on the doctor part ? Don't base your judgment based on what is happening at the USA ..😂 There are hundreds of doctors who do treatments for the poor for less fees or no fees. USA is a gun prone racist prone country...

[@stanstankov9153]

@@seneca983why Indians can never stop blaming Britain for the colonisation.Almost the entire world has been colonised.Yet India didn’t evolved it remained the third world .

[@zulaab123]

Sridhar, you have summarized it so accurately 😊

[@kevinrtres]

Yup! Contrast that with the Singaporians who decided as a matter of state policy that honesty and honour was to be the rule in the community.

[@vivekkamtikar4268]

Simple reason to go abroad is, Life to live is easy, , Life is tough here, even for simple things, water, electricity, Roads, education, populations, Bureaucracy at every step, lots of simple things like law and order, law abiding citizens finds very difficult to live, etc

[@CanadaMath]

My father left India in 1976. Best decision he ever made.

[@jayashreebandopadhyay9489]

Too many people are fighting for one vacancy( look at our population!! We should be ashamed of !!!) .Hence when one of the aspirants wins the job of a clerk and feels like a superhero ; the salary comes 😢 which is one of the lowest in the world!! The same job in European countries will give him 10 times the salary he gets here!!

[@sonaliv1489]

Because our British education system taught us to be clerks instead of business owners.

[@sonaliv1489]

So we like British clerks run to foreign countries where they start business and we beg them to give us job. Useless British education

[@DwellinginCosmos]

That's why we all should do our one bit. Let's not have kids and contribute to population. I am not going to have any kids in this war-infested, shithole of a world which is filled with miseries and struggle. India will do just fine with 1/10 of the population.

[@dukhi_aatma372]

he will be paid 10x in Europe, but cost of living in Europe is also 10x of India?

[@dtvind]

​@dukhi_aatma372 its not less in india , Europe give education and health insurance. Where we stand ?

[@allancyril4650]

-it is clean - more educated people - people don’t fight for religion - more peace - no caste system - equality for all - very less tax - makes sense of living there

[@gyaneshwarsingh6786]

And no loss of opportunity against the mediocre talents.

[@S7evn201]

Really. Equality for all😂. Then why did black lives matter happen? Why is there Racism even today?😂 The truth is, people with money can lead a comfortable life anywhere in the world.

[@Palenque_pupikaka]

and get shot by a random african for no reason and calling you a "bloody indian"!

[@njshah4845]

​@@gyaneshwarsingh6786good bye 👋

[@gyaneshwarsingh6786]

@@njshah4845 you're leaving mate?

[@drjekelmrhyde]

I have no idea what Palki is talking about, but I just like watching her fine self.

[@drsamuelharrisrajpaul]

Never Mind True Indians stay always with India wherever they are 👌🇮🇳

[@sdutta8]

This subject was researched by an NRI professor at a major U.S. University. His conclusion was that it was the Human Infrastructure. Anything you want to do can be done much more easily in the West because of the way people interact among themselves (excluding those in their own network). This leads to a much more productive, hence satisfying, life.

[@kevinrtres]

Vestiges of the Christian belief system. Hard work, honesty, cleanliness, orderliness and respect for law and order and your fellow citizens. Now of course the west is destroying exactly the same culture that got them their riches in the first place.

[@Matt-zp1jn]

I think a step above Human Infrastructure, is Systemic Infrastructure, and even above that is the Ideological System of norms that comes from different thinking/beliefs in Reasoning in Philosophy religious/spiritual faith and thought. 💭 Different thinking and beliefs lead to different directions in many ways, better or worse.

[@effexon]

excellent way put. I one time wondered how much is to fly in south america or Kongo. It turns it is very expensive compared to similar 5000 to 10000km flight from europe to US. And they have repeatedly explained this as cause why some countries get more prosper and some stay poor. Pouring money wont help at all, as that is not the problem. People attitudes and "they have always done this way". Of course any good country can drop on this like excellent product can become bad over time when this attitude and viewpoint slips.

[@effexon]

@@Matt-zp1jn from other comments I got sense private life is different but people want their business, bureacracy health,kids things to be taken care of efficiently as that is mandatory, not fun part of life. So philosophy is different, though high achieving people wanting to move to new country to find better or get better education for kids is special group of people. Likely they found similar people to attach in new place explaining lot of why enjoy there.

[@akashmohan999]

Believe me, they'll never truly include you as part of their society. You'll be just another "poojeet"

[@VJ592]

It's a win/win for both parties that's the key thing. India is over crowded too

[@nikhilchikkmath]

Agree😊

[@someoneontheinternet-op2ut]

India is crowded with all the leftovers...😂

[@dhirajkumarsahu999]

Yea but what if all the tax payers leave? India will loose a lot of income

[@VJ592]

@@dhirajkumarsahu999 they enough supply of Indians who will make money and pay tax 🤣

[@AG-gv9cb]

forgot dirty, polluted and unsafe for women,, lately too much religious intolerance..

[@buddyatnj]

Point to be noted Indian citizens becoming Canadian citizens presently came here several years back.

[@andrewthacker114]

Interesting clip

[@prasadpatil1160]

I will leave india soon. There are Many reasons. 1. Reservation 2. Corruption 3. Pollution 4. Low income 5. High inflation 6. Scammers 7. High taxes without any benefits to tax payers 8. Weak passport 9. Basic human rights 10. Law System made for only the exploiters. 11. Needless competition for mere low level jobs. 12. Lack of good universities. Etc. And many more whch will take too long to even mention.

[@crmbackupcrmbackup988]

1 . 2 . 5 6/ 7 high taxes in these contries , they had there colonial looting and propserity time , so they dont need to spend on basics , India is catching up . 8. They are mmaking honest efforts on this . 9. BS . Look at woke culture , cancel culture in USA . 10 . true. 11 . it existe there . 12 . particaly true . heavy competion for good unis . You leave but remit back to Indians or invest in Dollar accounts in India . help back the country to grow .

[@girish9841]

Leave early bro good for you 😊 but I will stay in India and it's my karma Bhumi

[@MangiferaIndica918]

@@crmbackupcrmbackup988 he never said which country he'll be in after leaving India.

[@Fan-zx1lz]

@ prasadpatil all you said is correct especially the High taxes without any social security benefits. This comment needs to be pinned.

[@lordhumungus3578]

No toilets!

[@Alin4005]

As an actual patriot of India, but left India because of the pollution and I had aggravated Asthma. The question I ask a ton of Ache Din supporting Indians who migrate is "Why are you here if Ache Din is happening in India?"

[@yao_chin1022]

The pollution is one of the many reasons I never want to visit in India.

[@pessimistic_optimism]

it seems regressed when pollution is stated as a reason during the time when remote work is much more possible. every person who is stuck tier 1 polluted cities can push for spoke offices in tier 2 cities.

[@Alin4005]

@@pessimistic_optimism sorry bro. I am not an IT guy or marketing executive. I work on a construction site so if I call in for remote work then my boss would not remotely call me back

[@KANGZZZ.]

I am from Assam a state full of resource and beautiful nature.But still one of the poorest state in India.Corruption is so huge here.😢

[@pessimistic_optimism]

@@Alin4005 sure remote work might not be applicable for all work lines. But once few companies which are able to work from remote move to tier 2 cities most of the other work lines will also spread.

[@YogalaxmiMuthukrisnan]

Yogalaxmi Muthukrisnan at your service. I am from Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Let's catch Priyanka Chopra ❤

[@user-mt1is1ky2p]

One more possible reason could be the rampant corruption even for basics with no accountability at any level and no tangible grievance redressal. A pathetic judicial process in delivering justice adds to the woes.

[@NewMoonDay]

I moved to US a year ago. Could not work anywhere but Bangalore and I hated the traffic so much. I loathe all the metro cities infact. I now live in a place that's not too densely populated, have lots of greenery around, great parks. Will be a slave to h1b visa for many more years but still every time I go around the parks here I feel joyous every damn day. Why the hell do we don't plan our cities in India.

[@aaronderyl]

Overpopulation and power of real estate / business ensures that green spaces are used for construction before anything else. This is not just the metros. If you see what happened in Shimla - disaster in terms of town planning and after nature’s fury claiming many lives and property they still haven’t given up construction in green spaces. Protecting / preserving nature is not a priority in India.

[@sankhabhattacharya718]

Population is the elephant in the room. Population is a curse in India. India will never become developed due to excessive Population.

[@jimmyhvy2277]

My Indian Friend in Australia , Returned to India Because at the end of the Week he had No Disposable money left Due to the Expensive Cost of Living here in Australia . Back in India he now has some Spending Money for a Better Life Style . The Grass isn't always Greener on the Other Side !

[@starz2020]

what he was doing in australia

[@jimmyhvy2277]

@@starz2020 IT

[@victorferr1]

He probably got fired..

[@chaitanyak.n.4768]

FYI, such people can still return and work in India if you're a US or UK citizen. Some still choose to retire in India. The extra benefit is that you have no visa restrictions to visit western nations.

[@mystica7284]

Few things i can think of: 1. standard of living (lack of infra, open green spaces, cleanliness) 2. weaker passport (honestly it sucks) 3. conservative society (some people are extremist in terms of their beliefs, religion.. if someone is different from their way of viewing the world, it threatens them) 4. lower wages + overworking 5. societal pressure (i think it's big issue in this generation. others are too nosy asking like why you are not working yet? why are you not married yet? etc) 6. lack of recreational activities and opportunities (idk about cities, but it is a thing for people living in rural areas) 7. casteism, colorism

[@RAJBERG]

India is a wonderful country but it has it's own problems. One of the biggest problem among all others is that most of politicians are little educated who are corrupt and don't see a big picture of future problems. People are lead by these in the name of other social problems. And they want people to remain uneducated. illiteracy and poverty is the evil of all other problems. One must have faith in religion as per their beliefs and it's one's choice. It should never be used as a tool. Where ever it happens this gives rise to violence. And this keeps happening all around the world. And the worst part of this is that only innocent people become the victim of it.

[@aaronderyl]

Wish religion never existed. Or wish it was just a personal thing that nobody needs to speak about and the world doesn’t have to battle like how it does, now.

[@shashankb520]

Yeah too many problems so I am moving out Okay who is gonna solve them Reaction is: i don't know😂😂😂

[@RAJBERG]

@@shashankb520 some people don't move out but to rear their family and to fill his own tummy they need to work with the best possible intentions, with a bigger heart and carrying the sin of others.

[@akimbobolaomowumi1899]

This write up seems to be more suited for my country Nigeria

[@manishsharma77729]

I will soon leave india and the main reasons are --- 1 Unemployment 2 Reservation

[@noelinx]

Low income as well ❤️‍🩹

[@iyngaranmankkaleswaran2856]

Hello. Why don't you guys use whatever skills you've acquired and build your own employment? Is that too much of a pain in Bharatam? What is the ground reality in India for Self Employment? Would genuinely like to know thanks. 🙏🏽

[@PradhanmantriBruhh]

​@@iyngaranmankkaleswaran2856Not needed. The more people leave, the better for us.

[@delmanpronto9374]

3. Low Income 4. High taxes

[@xyyzz]

please leave fast my country

[@suniltshegaonkar7809]

As Indian immigrants coming to Canada, it's a long & tough battle ahead and that starts with proficiency in English as not having the same accents as locals. Because communication especially verbal communication is extremely important in any job (except janitorial & labor job), it is extremely hard to progress. The matter is probably simplified for IT specialist because they are not as many in numbers. On the other hand if you look at probability of progress in India, it is not easy and the quality of life _ better not spoken. Yes this news is astonishing to those people who are leaving Canada in the spirit of what they have seen in last few years.

[@Data_on_trail]

Since the USA allows for dual citizenship, Indians immigrating here do not need to renounce their Indian citizenship to become a US Citizen. They do probably need to bring all that high net worth with them though - because this is one expensive place to call home.

[@Alfa.SINGH.]

People need good standard of living... People are fed-up of Corruption in every departments like in Maharashtra... BMC, Housing Registrar's, Judiciary, Police, Politicians all are corrupt... People want to move and have a better Standard of living 🇮🇳😎👍🤘

[@Dattebayo3089]

Bt other states are more corrupted than maharshtra. Whole India is just shit hole. 😊

[@JinSakai_Kuroudo]

And ridiculous taxes !!! Most people escape them, but hard working office going people just pay to let others live for free and make countless babies in India.

[@crmbackupcrmbackup988]

@@JinSakai_Kuroudo Even higher taxes in USA 50 percent , Do research on other countries ,

[@geraltissuperman1749]

Yeah I know how much good was standard of living was when I saw Indians fighting over bag of rice and cops laughing after killing Indian girl in USA

[@Dattebayo3089]

@@JinSakai_Kuroudo in India 13% white collar job employees pay 52% tax of our country 🤣🤣. Means 13% population is paying half tax of our country. Middle class whether it's higher or lower both are doing charity

[@shubhamkhunger7]

I am a doctor with past 3 years of experience after MD. I work in private sector. Though the pay is more in absolute terms in Developed countries but so are the expenses. In India I can enjoy my life better in terms of quality than the foreign nations eg: Maid for household chores, Instant delivery of stuff by companies like blinkit, UPI is amazingly fast, any ordinary person can avail superspeciality healthcare services without being on waitlists, our rich culture and food. Moreover, I have to give back to fellow countrymen as I have studied in Govt medical college in extremely subsidised rates in return for successfully clearing NEET exam.

[@firebrand3515]

Working in private sector. Don't want to move to village. Fleecing people in the name of unnecessary tests. No work satisfaction. Self interests served.

[@sukhino4475]

@@firebrand3515 the tests feed the hospital, in turn the suppliers. So the rich becomes rich. The Hippocratic Oath is in wind. An honest Doctor can heel by reading the pulse,the souls gey connected not the machines

[@shubhamkhunger7]

@@firebrand3515 Superspeciality healthcare service infrastructure is predominantly in bigger cities. Competent healthcare udhar hi milega. Healthcare infrastructure will expand to smaller cities as well. If you feel ki healthcare is expensive then get an insurance. That's the only way forward.

[@harpreetsingh6819]

Well whatever you mention. Maid for household chores. Chauffeur to drive car for us. Don't like waitlist (always in hurry like me first is a comman indian habit). Getting everything through app like blinkit etc sitting on couch. Is not a sign of quality life.. sign that we need someone who can cook, clean and do chores for us, coz we don't want. Some other words we need slave..

[@bigdaddy7729]

You like slaves heh ?

[@sushimmukerji515]

Only in India employers can demand candidates not older than 23 with a PH.D and 7 years experience. And those jobs fly off the shelf. Competition is that tough in India. No wonder Indians move to Canada, Australia and US (immigration to US is harder). If Indians can survive in India they can thrive anywhere. I wish my fellow Indians (Bharatiyas) the best. We don't antagonize anyone, we don't demand special rights. We just do our job, raise our families in peace, and wish the best for everyone.

[@brandinshaeffer8970]

I live in the affluent town of Edmond, Oklahoma and it's been really interesting to see SO MANY Indian immigrants to my area. I have many Indian neighbors in my area that used to be almost exclusively caucasian. They're really good neighbors - they have good kids, they keep their property very manicured, and are friendly. Of all the Asian people's, the immigrants from India are my favorite because it seems like they make an effort to become part of the community. They don't quite feel like "Oklahomans" yet but that's ok. As long as they don't start voting to restrict my 2nd Amendment rights, they're just fine by me :) It is sad that India is losing so many of its good people though. Instead of staying to fix their own country, they're bailing. Honestly, I cannot blame them though. Edmond, Oklahoma is gorgeous & the cost of living is crazy inexpensive. My house has 3 bedrooms, a very impressive theatre room, a large office with built in shelves, a chef's kitchen & the most gorgeous view you can imagine....a pond with geese, 2 huge willow trees & a shallow strip of dense woods.....and it cost under half a million.

[@hardeepmarwah]

half a million USD will buy you 1200 sq feet of a flat in a okay to good part of Mumbai India

[@ibizawavey8630]

@@hardeepmarwah how are indians buying so many pizza shops, burrito places, and every service business in canada? are they that rich?

[@ShikharSrivastava]

Banger of an Ad for Edmond, Oklahoma funnily enough. In any case, appreciate the candor.

[@puneetpuri1984]

These are the ones who moved successfully. But if you ask randomly, I'm sure 5 out of every 10 people in India want to move to another country. Don't get me wrong, India has been on a rise but the there are very deep issues which can never be resolved due to the goverment structure - states and Centre.

[@RandomGuy..192]

The main reason is that people are very uneducated and unskillful here and no one wants to live with bunch of uneducated fools.

[@RandomGuy..192]

@@chandan__m And the person who said this dialogue sells Vimal pan masala.

[@ereh987]

@@chandan__m yall are just 'all bark and no bite'

[@Sagar-wn1po]

People can easily understand rising communalism, pollution, jammed roads, poor drainage during monsoon. So they leave India at first opportunity. I am happy that my brother who also had opportunity to become citizen of Norway returned India to use his skills in tackling climate change induced problems.

[@liezlnaik9184]

You can give up Indian citizenship and acquire OCI but here is no place like home. Culture, food, family.... During retirement days, it is still relaxing to spend years in your own country and state where you feel acceptance without discrimination.

[@jegan4275]

I am from South India and living in Canada. Most of the people from India either from Gujarat or Punjab. Mostly we Indians are hypocrites. We want radical, regressive and useless fanatic system back in India but wants to migrate to liberal, progressive and secular countries.. same applies to people come from radical Islamic countries… Indian population is surplus and no one talk about it. 30 to 40 core population is idle for India.

[@porkistanlostitstinyballin1971]

India, currently the world's fifth-largest economy, is on track to surpass Japan and become the third-largest global economy, with a projected GDP of $7.3 trillion by 2030, as per the latest report from S&P Global Market Intelligence. Those who want to get rid of their passports are free to do so. The ones who stay in India will make India Great.

[@crmbackupcrmbackup988]

yep , there are som many negative of esp USA . lets fix and make our selves first class . rather beign dominated and treated third class in foreign countries

[@girish9841]

You nailed it bro. I had an opportunity to migrate to US recently but I gave up that.

[@girish9841]

​@@crmbackupcrmbackup988yes I have seen some Indians behave awkward when they are in US or UK etc full nautanki

[@guywithpotential6649]

They will come back and retire in India after earning a fortune in western countries with their OCI Card. This will definitely happen

[@HariVishnudeva]

What is the use when you have to divide those $7.3 trillion among 1.5 billion people (projected population for 2030)? The Japanese will still be much better off.

[@arunemails]

Respect for technical,Skilled hard working tax payers and free education for kids😊

[@JinSakai_Kuroudo]

Even farmers and labourers can migrate easily. Truck drivers, painters, carpenter you name it

[@crmbackupcrmbackup988]

Municipal education is only free in USA , private is expensive for even schools

[@marmara9741]

You cannot give free education to 1+ billion population. People have to pay 100% taxes and even that will not be enough to make free education possible. Decrease your Indian population to just a few thousands first.

[@LOLLOL-kg4dz]

india has no future,with riots in manipur,separatist in kashmir, naxalite insurgency, khalistani resement,wrestler's protest,massive unemployment,rising farmers suicides,falling groundwater level, communal tensions, religion politics, north-south india sentiments,uttar pradesh crime rate, poverty, bihar overpopulated, income gap, woman safety, global warming,infrastructure problems, train safety Ranks #107 out of 121 Countries in Global Hunger Index Ranks #126 in Happy Index Ranks #139 in GDP per capita Ranks #132 in HDI index 10% earn

[@naturelover7979]

Out of a population of 1.4 billion, only around three percent of Indians live outside India. This is because it is not easy for everyone to migrate.

[@robbrown4621]

Americans love people from India. You bring awesome food, intelligence in the form of doctors and dentists and more, meditation, Buddhism, Hinduism, you protect the Dalai Lama, and you bring good people with proven emotional balance. Americans trust Indians. The only thing that can still improve would be your nation's disconnection to Putin and Russia. For such a sensible people, it really is disappointing that you do not politically align more closely with the world's first and greatest democracy. But Americans are patient and we know that all good things come in time. Someday there may even be professional baseball and ice hockey played in India and Americans might learn to play cricket...

[@debanikgoswami4834]

I am also planning to go to USA for higher education . Harvard has higher acceptance rate than IITs .

[@saraojala6283]

As a Canadian, I've often thought of giving up citizenship and going someplace like India or a country in Africa.

[@cassiejacobs4197]

I'm so happy I made productive decisions about my finances that changed forever. I'm a single mother living in Vancouver Canada, bought my first house in October and hoping to retire soon if things keep going smoothly for me.

[@ningyen1444]

Everyone needs more than their salary to be financial stable. The best thing to do with your money is to invest it rightly, because money left for saving always end up used with no returns.

[@maxiecharles2842]

Who is your financial coach, do you mind hooking me?

[@cassiejacobs4197]

@alicemark5918 Cryptocurrency investment, but you will need a professional guide on that.

[@cassiejacobs4197]

Facebook 👇

[@cassiejacobs4197]

Evelyn C. Sanders

[@jatsumbal3208]

India ranks 162+in press freedom that’s why

[@abirbiswas3551]

Being one of the Indian who recently became a Canadian. I can say this is the best time to be an Indian outside of India. People take Indians seriously in the western world now. Top positions across the world have brown skin. That gives us a lot of soft power. We are also able to get an extra seat in the name of Diversity and Inclusion, while we enjoy a nation with developed facilities. If you may ask why we dont want to go back, the truth is India is still a 3rd world country where people lack civic sense, high pollution, inefficient government facilities even at the lowest levels and depreciating currency values. So we "NRIs" have found a sweet spot of holding a foreign passport continuing to enjoy visa free travel to 190 countries and also calling ourselves as Indians who can take part in the D&I program. If you think I sound selfish, thats the raw fact and never believe us when we say "I want to move back".

[@democratsrepublicansbothan7973]

It's bigger then that. Your owns in the global brain drain European strategy. There is no win fleeing ones nation. Your just a pawn but Indians are to blind wanting to be whitewashed. Nothing is free. Not even a free user account on KZbin.

[@Sunny-Gupta1]

No, thankyou

[@Babasasa111]

Khalistan Jindabad

[@krashroaddg]

What have you done to change all that in your country where you originally belong to. Sadly the same people flock back to their country of origin when there is a crisis in their migrated country. Then every thing in India becomes so beautiful. If you are in Canada and you like the government there and their attitude towards India then nothing to say. LASTLY We are from a third world country but we are neither a second class citizen nor third class citizen here. We are the proud citizens of this country with no desire to migrate anywhere else sir.

[@paulflores6406]

Nobody respects indians😂

[@happygp698]

Go India!

[@dragondad7733]

Indian people are awesome, I love my Indian neighbors and colleagues. Great folks all

[@Westralia]

I am in Perth,Western Australia and an Australian citizen.Been here 8 years and prior to that 16 years in New Zealand.I am returning to india in january to take care of my elderly parents.For me social structure and infrastructure is important.Hoping for the best.Say Hi if I smilie..used to that here..need to see if people casually acknowledge with a hi or keep a serious,glum face

[@greekgod3974]

Great decision sir India is your country, and if indian want to earn money they have to go to foreign but just for 10 years after that you have to return to your country which is your mother land 🙏😊

[@charleswomack2166]

All of the Indian-American people I know are very well educated people. My Dr is Indian and she is great.

[@crmbackupcrmbackup988]

yes that is true , they are excellent

[@easycooking7140]

Most of us are .. but then there are some doctors who happened to score 50-60% lesser than us

[@nkbrawlstras6609]

​@@easycooking7140so what 🤣

[@easycooking7140]

@@nkbrawlstras6609 hope someone you love needs a doctor and you get a dalit one .. then let's chat

[@nkbrawlstras6609]

Vary funny still stuck in the caste mindset 🤣u know what I'm an tribal India which is worst than dalit because of people like your mindset Indians are leaving India 🤣

[@Plo890]

I welcome all immigrants to the US. Indians are fine people

[@RAGE-_]

White supremacy doesn't agree

[@TheInternetLove]

Ma'am is speaking in English🙏🏾 the last time I went to Montreal I saw an Indian woman speaking French. I was shocked

[@NarayanaPai-]

So much work into this news report 👌🏻

[@premsinha9046]

Indian govt must reward middle class and upper class who pays taxes honesty like free best education, reservation in air or rail ticket free health insurance it will impact good view in taxpayers

[@6732VK]

dear dotard why can't govt give best education to everyone so that we have lots of talented and capable people in the country and we develop fast. Government cant provide everything so get off your high course wanting reservation in air and rail. please kindly enhance your thinking.

[@saraswathykrishnan1718]

Abolish all reservation bcos of it is abused

[@maxttk97]

​@@6732VKhe his not talking about reservation stupid. It's call tax benifits. The tax that you pay from your salary returning to you again by some other means. Health care, child's education, etc.

[@AmitKumar-qz2us]

संविधान संसद लोकतंत्र देश भक्ति यह सब आम आदमी को मूर्ख बनाने के लिए है हम पैसा देते हैं और हमें अच्छी सुविधा चाहिए युवा पीढ़ी इसीलिए भारत सरकार भ्रष्ट सरकार रिश्वतखोर सरकार को पसंद नहीं करती है भारत सरकार को चाहे टैक्स दे या ना दे परंतु रिश्वत अवश्य दें भारत सरकार का यही है नारा भ्रष्टाचार हम सबको प्यारा भारत सरकार को टैक्स के साथ रिश्वत भी अवश्य दे अंग्रेजों की गुलामी के कानून में से चलने वाला देश रिश्वत लेना भ्रष्टाचार करना सरकारी कार्यालय में सामान्य दिनचर्या है ।।🎉🎉🎉🎉।।

[@silviarodrigues3304]

Or simply provide retirement benefits and health insurance in private hospitals for those who Pay taxes. I agree that some incentives should be given to honest tax payers

[@auggieeast]

I'm a mover in Boston and most of my clients are from India. We first move them into an apartment and a couple years later they call back to move them into their new house they bought in a nice suburb with top notch public schools. They have a good life, so they stay. Also they tell me that after living in America their kids are too soft to go back to living in India. They all have American accents in no time. The kids I mean, not the adults. Indian Americans have higher average incomes than even White Americans, because of their education.

[@10an63]

Yes in america, richest community r jews and Hindus Due to there past genocidel experience

[@auggieeast]

@@10an63 Yeah, no. It's because they have the highest levels of education. Indians can't walk across our border. They have to fly here. That's why we get India's best and brightest.

[@10an63]

@@auggieeast yes in India , Hindus was persucuted for 1000 of yr , so they focus on education

[@auggieeast]

@@10an63 India is one of the only places conquered and ruled by Muslims for a very long period which resisted wholesale conversion to Islam, which points to an inner strength in Hinduism.