Why Boolean Commands Fail in Rhino 6: Jewelry CAD Design Tutorial

[@nicolasc8782]

Thank for your tutorial, your first solution works perfectly for me.

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Great to hear!

[@SUGARdelite]

Always good advice! Sometimes moving as .001 is all you need!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

That is right!

[@murtazaikram6762]

Thank you, you are very good teacher....

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You are welcome!

[@maluloa6677]

A much needed video! Thanks :)

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Glad it was helpful!

[@Cresaliajj]

Brilliant. Thank you.

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You're very welcome!

[@beatriceleigh28]

Very useful, thanks PJ

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

My pleasure!

[@FSV3D]

Excellent tips as always!!!!!! Thank you PJ !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Super!!

[@mikeyonshay7080]

Thank you PJ.

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Very welcome

[@Heroic_struggle]

Can I apply these and the other videos info about Boolean union fails to meshed stl models?

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

the concept is the same but I don't like to edit mesh in Rhino

[@marounjahchan3698]

Thank you very much for the advise, it was really helpful

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Glad it was helpful!

[@herbhoover]

Rhino is great at accuracy, but not great at fixing how artists build and alter as we go. Rhino likes a straight-forward plan. You often start building something, make a decision, and then re-start from scratch with the math in mind. Watching that process, and how fast you work even when starting from the beginning, is very informative, especially once you're deep into a project and the dang boolean fails. "Just start again..." isn't a disaster to the project with your working method.

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Right on, Herbert

[@voulazarpani7688]

Excellent tutorial!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Glad you liked it!

[@HanaSD]

Do you have any idea about the Booleansplit when it's failed ?

[@cristinafernandez8284]

Thanks, your advice it will make my job easier

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Glad to hear that!

[@sh8d8e]

Thank you

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You're welcome

[@josjaniessen7588]

Thank You PJ!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You are welcome, Josja!

[@niccody93]

Thanks for your help!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You're welcome!

[@vikas90584]

thank you so much

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Welcome 😊

[@ManuelLopez-xe5rf]

gracias, me resolvió muchos problemas al hacer Unión Booleana

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

that is great!

[@rushabhsoni407]

Master, If we want that Pipe as same diameter from everywhere, Should draw two Polylines from TOP view at the irregular overlapping then Trim it and Blend both surface ?? I learnt it from your another videos only 🙏😌 thank you

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You can

[@LIN9273135]

this help me a lot thanks

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Glad it helped!

[@freedomchongjf]

Good video thanks PJ

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@UnlikelyVentures]

Thanks PJ

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

you are welcome, Henry!

[@tarakatanchi8490]

can you please also explain why the split boolean fails?

[@baoyuj5585]

So in your first example, what if I want them exactly aligned. I should have to trim and then manually combine them together, right?

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

that will be a good solution

[@ljsarda95]

This helped me so much!! Thank you

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Glad it helped!

[@louiskutyla6943]

thank you for this so much

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You're so welcome!

[@nikouer]

Is there any better solution than move the object? E.g. change the seam line location?

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

you can move the seam only if it is a single closed surface.

[@nikouer]

@@PJChenJewelryDesign so the first two cases seems actually to be a rhino bug. You provide a solution but you loose accuracy. I have a lot of times problems with rhino booleans. I end up manually explode split delete and join again individual surfaces. But in cases like yours that's extremely complicated.

[@manishdas35]

Mam- I Am Facing A Problem In Two Closed Polysurfaces Even Though They Are Not Having Naked Edges

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

what is the issue? boolean?

[@manishdas35]

@@PJChenJewelryDesign Yes Today I Have Sorted Out The Problem By Following Your Videos

[@saidota89]

Thanks alot for the video :)

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

My pleasure!

[@jemi011]

Thank you !!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You're welcome!

[@laxmanvaswani]

thanks a lot mam

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You are welcome

[@danielcastellano1171]

Good tutorial

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Thanks

[@Neerajsha1]

Hello sir, Is it necessary to do boolean after completing design or before creating stl file?

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

if you can make it one clean shell that will be great. if not, as long as they are closed solid parts, they should be fine.

[@Neerajsha1]

Thank you so much, you are awesome ☺️

[@boristonev6560]

thank u

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You're welcome!

[@beyzagunay8152]

adamsın reyis teşekkürler

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

you are welcome

[@catroche009]

Nice Video

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Thanks

[@juzensari2589]

Kralsın bro king

[@AlexGM3d]

good !!!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Thanks!

[@jarvinnavas9494]

Nice this error is fatal

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

haha

[@jacekchwedenczak5894]

Is it only me who thinks that shifting object 0.001 unit is not a good solution? Maybe I am expecting to much from a CAD software (eg. to be precise)? Can anyone with more experience comment on that?

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

it is one of the solution. you can also avoid the seam to be overlapping by more the seam away if it is on the single surface.

[@boristonev6560]

10x

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

super!

[@shuvodipghosh9230]

Thank You

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You're welcome