Why Brooke Houts SHOULD KEEP her Dog

If you love what we do here, help support the pack and join our Patreon!
/ thedawghouse
Dont forget to SUBSCRIBE and follow the whole pack on Instagram
/ the_dawghouse_
Check out Officer Paw Patrol here
/ channel
Check out my favorite channels for FREE dog training tips
Solid K9 Training
/ solidk9training
Leerburg Dog Training
/ leerburg
Stonnie Dennis Dog Training
/ stonniedennis
Valor Dog Training Academy
/ @valork9academy
My take on the Brooke Houts incident involving her mistakenly uploaded video where she hits her Doberman Pinscher, Sphinx. I realize that this is going to be an unpopular opinion but I truly believe in it. We need to rehabilitate owners as much as dogs, giving up at the first hurdle sets a terrible precedent. Sorry for the break in my usual content, but I couldn't keep my mouth shut on this one.

[@KaptainGranite]

Brooke needs to learn patience and maybe go to anger management. She is completely not worthy to own a dog.

[@thedawghouse4674]

I don’t disagree. However she does have the dog. Can’t change that, and in my opinion it’s super important for human beings, probably more than ever, learn how to redeem theirselves and use these crazy platforms that we’ve been given to reach people all around the world

[@KaptainGranite]

@@thedawghouse4674 I 100% agree with you. I feel she has a chance now to take this and better herself and her pupper. Both need help I just hope she gets it.

[@ollie2111]

@@thedawghouse4674 while I believe people can change, her "apology" was just excusing her behavior and it doesn't at all sound like she is considering doing better.

[@kimschuler3989]

I agree with you she is a very bad person

[@tedpoland7650]

I agree that the girl don't have the right to own a dog

[@nifflofair6685]

She should have dog removed! Absolutely is abuse! Not the degree you may think but abuse all the same! More common doesn't make it right! No violence is excusable!!!

[@shadow_is_weird8991]

Well she's worked in shelters She was a vet tech for 14 years. She knows alot of things about dogs And of course arguing with you wastes my time so...

[@shadow_is_weird8991]

@aieden I'm not a monster, marganalizer

[@shadow_is_weird8991]

@aieden it is tho

[@shadow_is_weird8991]

@aieden you can't force me to look up crap

[@P3bbl3]

Her dog was removed from the home and now he gives a nice non abusive family now

[@davidleeroth1968]

how can you say in one breath she’s not abusing her dog then in the next say she’s using violence against her dog...you should look up what using violence against an animal or person is called here’s a hint(ABUSE)

[@luvmikasa5479]

David LeeRoth true

[@krexoriginal]

I just love it when random YT commenters think they can "school" a trained professional.

[@shadow_is_weird8991]

Grow up it's something called an opinion

[@shadow_is_weird8991]

@aieden No not really

[@shadow_is_weird8991]

@aieden now grow up Everyone has there own opinion You don't need to agree You don't need to argue Lol like everyone on KZbin argues

[@gsdmomb530]

She should NOT have this dog period. Do you think this is the first time she did it? Absolutely not.

[@22bashful]

I'm so so confused! You said Michael Vick should be in jail because he abused his dogs, but she hit and spit, and slapped her dog and you're saying that's not abuse. I've never been a dog owner, but I'm trying to become one and I know I have a heck of a lot to learn. But if Michael Vick needs to be in jail I think she should as well. Abuse is abuse in any form. Love your videos just confused about this one.

[@shadetreesurgeon]

Terri Chambers Michael Vick ran an organized criminal operation that regularly tortured and executed dogs... Brooke Houts is an idiot and made mistakes, but these two things are wildly different. Saying their the same makes real abusers not look as bad in my opinion 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@thedawghouse4674]

I would really learn of what all Michael Vick did... and then remember he IS NOT in jail, and has been given a second chance.... however in my opinion, comparing Michael Vick and Brooke Houts to be the same would be like saying that parents who spank their kids are the same as John Wayne Gacy.

[@22bashful]

@@shadetreesurgeon That's why I said I was confused. I knew he had abused his dogs, I just didn't know everything. Thanks for explaining that to me.

[@22bashful]

@@thedawghouse4674 You're right, there's no comparing the two of them. I understand now. Thanks.

[@davidleeroth1968]

The Dawghouse so if someone just slapped and spit on you that’s ok because it’s not abuse but if they put you in the hospital or worse then that’s not ok because that’s abuse...makes perfect sense 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@kimschuler3989]

WHAT SHE ACTUALLY HITS HER DOG AND PUSH THE DOG AND SHE IS HITTING HER DOG HARD SHE DOESN'T DESERVE TO HAVE A DOG

[@thedawghouse4674]

Lol ok

[@P3bbl3]

@@thedawghouse4674 listen I don't care that you've been working with dogs in the shelter for like 14 years or whatever that is abuse she raised her hand to the dog not hitting him and he jerked back and fear that is abuse and you can't tell me otherwise

[@PhatboyHD88]

Ok Jess would you not agree that if a man slaps a woman that it is assault. Now if someone repeatedly punches a woman in the face it is also assault.. so now the degree of animal abuse she committed is definitely on the lower scale of things , However it is still abuse .. maybe more on the mental side to the dog but abuse none the less...that is my view or opinion anyway I have had dogs all my life I am currently 53 and never hit one of my dogs

[@thedawghouse4674]

You are absolutely entitled to your opinion 😊... However to touch on the first part of your comment. I do not compare animals to humans.

[@y5243]

The Dawghouse ... and you to yours. 😎 Miss “points” much?!!!

[@thedawghouse4674]

Lol well yeah I’m fully aware I’m entitled to my opinion seeing as how I made this video 🤷🏻‍♀️ there was no point missing, there’s just a difference in opinion here. Being in the dog/animal “community” for as long as I have, humanizing animals has proven to be very dangerous in so many ways

[@Americanbeauty25]

PhatboyHD88 agreed. Abuse is abuse regardless of the level. People need to learn the difference between abuse and discipline.

[@knoxia]

@@thedawghouse4674 You're right. It isn't good to humanize animals. As her video shows; Humans are horrendous creatures.

[@diskskratch]

I was guilty of almost the exact same scenario, Doberman and all about 8 years ago. Only did it once and felt instantly guilty, and the way I treated him then sticks with me to this day.

[@caitlynnrhodes844]

v4Honda but you learned not to do it.😊 I hardly doubt this lady feels any kind of guilt or she wouldn’t of posted it.😕

[@nicksmith3746]

No, she's just using the dog as a prop. She doesn't treat the dog well at all outside her videos. She is extremely and unfairly short-tempered with her puppy.

[@kimschuler3989]

You are so right

[@bickle8931]

How do you know how she actually treats her dog off camera

[@yorob1246]

No, she shouldn't keep the dog. She pops off too easy.

[@jasonb3465]

If someone hit you like that I’m confident you’d think it was abuse.

[@thedawghouse4674]

Yes but comparing humans to dogs is actually really unproductive

[@nowirehangers2815]

@@thedawghouse4674 basic standards of decency are not counterproductive. The more you speak on it the more i am positive you use forcr against your dogs .

[@gamerkey8278]

@@thedawghouse4674 I'm not trying to come off as rude, but I'm really curious as to your reasons for thinking so.

[@silverc.8105]

While I don't completely agree with you I appreciate you speaking up that she's not a monster just a brat that needs anger management. the comments on her videos are really horrid, full of people saying they want to dox and kill her. animal abuse is horrible but so is murder, people are so vile they just want an excuse to tear someone apart. But here's what I think Brooke should do though: 1. Take up Ethan from H3H3's offer to buy/take the dog away from her and admit she isn't ready to be a dog owner. 2. Turn a bad situation into a positive by being public about her journey on therapy and thus getting her the views and attention that she got the dog for in the first place. (Like half joking)

[@silverc.8105]

Oops my comment was meant to be it's own and not a reply, not sure how I did that.

[@alisonmary1443]

Brooke simply doesn't love that dog 😢unless she feels correction for her actions in her own heart, for the dog and not herself, then it will not work as she may totally withdraw from this animal in absolute resentment for her loss. I can only hope that things are being monitored closely, I am sure you would have witnessed the long term effects on an animal living that situation. Yes there are horrific abuse cases that out weigh this but this is where it starts, with mistreating. I am not hating on you for your opinion I love how you and human Dad love those babies and the recent cat/dog introduction is fantastic 💖 A change in Brooke to be able to love something other than herself would be worth celebrating (new subbie) 👋

[@kimschuler3989]

Ya

[@louisbabycos106]

It's a testament to that Dobermans good nature that he showed her love even after she mistreated him . He is a wonderful dog . If I had a yard I would take him in a heartbeat.

[@charlotteemma2148]

Grimm and zuko in the background 😍😍

[@AnnaElizaR]

"Brooke Houts is a brat" = LMAO

[@Unknown-qz5to]

The way she looked at her dog you see disgust on her face and every time she raised her hand the dog flinched, even the spitting, you spit on someone who you hate. The definition says it "treat (a person or an animal) with cruelty or violence, especially regularly or repeatedly." ABUSE IS STILL ABUSE and should not be overlooked because it's not as bad as other abuse, that doesn't make sense. That is an innocent dog who just wants to play and love his owner and wants the same in return but instead gets hit and spit on, it's absolutely disgusting and trying to make any excuse for her is a shame. She SHOULD get that dog taken away and not allowed to have another one. She has a history of mental issues and being mean to animals. Us humans really don't deserve dogs, they are the ones who love you till the end and treating them in such a horrible way is disrespectful.

[@MsPhillyG]

You really think this girl should keep that dog? We only seen part of the abuse what about when she's not filming and the stuff she cuts out? Abuse is abuse. I'm sure all the 100"s of people asking to take that dog would be 100% better that girl. That dog wouldn't end up in a shelter as someone below eluded too. I read few comments you have below and yeah some people agreed with your view but I notice few do not...and I'm one of them. Dogs are not human we got it that but they don't deserve to be treated like crap.

[@thedawghouse4674]

You’re entitled to your opinion 😊 but I have a hard time believing you watched the whole video. Regardless this isn’t about that dog going to a shelter or not. There’s a bigger point, a bigger picture. And saying abuse is abuse is a sticky view.

[@y5243]

MsPhillyG ...exactly. GOD only knows how she treats that poor dog behind closed doors. Great point and excellent post!

[@MsPhillyG]

@@thedawghouse4674 I said people below in your comments were saying that. And no I stopped your video just to see which way you were going. I went to the comments to see how you would respond to some of the commenters and I was done. I notice some KZbinrs do that clickbait crap and see where the conversation goes. So no I didn't watch your video and it seems as though you haven't been reading all your comments.

[@kimschuler3989]

Your right

[@Teamshortbus]

Ah okay, so it's okay to hit and spit your dog because it's not "real abuse" cool thanks. Can these techniques be used on kids since people do way worse which would minimalize "real abuse"? People should try this excuse out when CPS comes and tell them that people do wayyyy worse so it's not exactly abuse. Giving her the benefit of the doubt that she didn't know this was incorrect behavior is a joke. Just seems like an "unpopular opinion" video for clicks.

[@buckethat789]

i grew up next door to a family from el salvador and saw the process of cutting off the tail with a machete when the dog is a pup and the dog was beat if it left the yard, so while brooke shouldnt do that to her dog, i can see how people would think its not that bad.

[@austinking3962]

@@buckethat789 that is so damn irrelevent. some other dog having its tail cut off has zero impact on this situation. Either the dog is being abused which needs to stop or not. In Asia Dogs are skinned alive before being eaten so i guess having a tail cut off isnt that bad...

[@buckethat789]

@@austinking3962 your comment is rude and will get you nowhere in life if you always disagree with people with such a display of ignorance and arrogance

[@austinking3962]

@@buckethat789 more irrelevance. this is a bit of a habit for you isnt it.

[@buckethat789]

@@austinking3962 you were the one who got rude, how will you learn about the world if you get rude with everybody?

[@tomloasby4929]

If you beat a dog you beat a devil into a dog. There is no need to ever raise your hand. Its exactly the same with kids

[@thedawghouse4674]

This is extremely misinformed of you, but that’s your opinion 😊 You missed the point of my video 🤷🏻‍♀️ but that’s ok, I was fully prepared for a lot of emotional responses

[@tomloasby4929]

@@thedawghouse4674 A person is seen on a video being physically abusive to an animal. I disagree with this wholeheartedly. In what way is this misinformed?

[@nowirehangers2815]

@@thedawghouse4674 you obviously have no credentials,no qualifications and have done zero independent research on canine behavior. You *really* are making yourself look stupid.

[@tomloasby4929]

@@thedawghouse4674 I've rewatched your video. I'm a fan of both yours and your partners but I will admit that this is the first video of yours I've seen. I understand your point, educate the owner. I never disagreed with that. What I have a problem with is the idea that i am misinformed. If you beat a dog you teach that dog that violence is acceptable. You dont need to hit a dog to punish it. Tone of voice, removal from the room or house temporarily are far more effective.

[@issimma]

If it’s such ok behaviour for her to push, hit, stomp, drag, spit and literally demean her dog. If this is all ‘ok’ and ‘normal’ then why does she need to edit it all out ? Obviously she has been treating her dog like this the whole time, yet until the accidental exposure of her uploading this video by mistake she had persistently edited all this abusive footage out. So I ask again, if it’s all so ok and all so above aboard then why edit it out at all. Should be ok to show the world no? So why did she not always include this kind of footage in all of her videos since the beginning then. Your argument here is highly flawed, you spew nothing more but hypocritical and contradictory dog chews... Nice try but no cigar in this occasion I’m afraid.

[@FarmerFpv]

Bingo, you hit the nail right on the head! Thank you for pointing all that out!

[@dixiebisquits]

Nice to see a calm and rational video on a difficult subject. The reactions to that unpleasant video are very understandable, but one thing that people seem to forget is that some times a compromise, like fixing the current situation, can be the best option for the animal. Dogs (that usually get along) can get into scuffles and miraculously bounce back to bff mode after everything calms down. Her dog still comes to her for affection and play after the mistreatment, so their situation should still be fixable. If the violent and aggressive behavior stops, and trust is rebuilt, the dog gets a chance for a balanced life with a human he has already bonded with. Rehoming can be stressful, scary and confusing, so if the goal is to improve the dog’s situation as soon as possible, correcting the owner’s behavior should be one of the simplest options - all hysteria put aside.

[@SuperRobbah]

This is legit. We live in such a polarized world, it's nice to see people capable of perspective. 🖤

[@jillstever3528]

Doberman’s are a hard dogs to train. They are extremely smart. They aren’t for new dog owners. I used sign language with mine.

[@theresasagner7215]

I trained three dobermans.They are very smart.

[@loriloo1039]

I’m sorry, but I have to disagree with you. Just because the abuse isn’t “as bad” as what you’ve seen in the shelters doesn’t mean it’s not abuse. That dog flinched when she raised her hand which means this has been a pattern.

[@JustMe-vj9ox]

Never heard of her til now and seeing a glimpse of the vid she must be physically and verbally abusing that dog everyday. Feel sorry for him if he stays in that home, one day he'll either defend himself and bite back or she'll probably kill him cause she lost her temper again. Hope she is charged with animal abuse and hope the dog gets rehomed.

[@GreatDogs]

Thanks for a great video!

[@ThatCzechKid]

I must disagree, though I will concede it isn't the worst case of animal abuse there is. That being said, it's still abuse. It's like you're saying, "well it's bad, but it could always be worse" and completely invalidating the fact that it's still abuse. I'm not sure what world you live in where smacking, pushing to the ground and spiting on a pet isn't considered abuse? I'm not sure what your self-proclaimed credentials are to be giving this advice, it seems anyone from the pet community likes to think they're educated because they simply have pets. Your disposition sucks and the next time you try to go against the grain on a popular topic because you're just so edgy, please come correct.

[@thedawghouse4674]

My message went right over your head and that’s ok 😊... You disagree and that’s also ok. This was not me giving advice, but me giving my opinion 🙃

[@ThatCzechKid]

@@thedawghouse4674 Did I? Then please clarify at 2:07 when you literally said "not dog abuse."? Since you're just far too intelligent, and your opinion far too grandiose for me to comprehend. Your message didn't go over my head, it just sucked.

[@caitlynnrhodes844]

SlavicDevil I agree.

[@thedawghouse4674]

Yes, in my opinion this is not dog abuse. So I don’t know why you’re quoting me. You are entitled to your opinion, as I am mine 😊

[@CollieflowerKitchen]

I appreciate you sharing your views and opinions on the situation is a respectable manner. Whether we agree or disagree, reacting in pure emotion or emotional agression to something doesn't do anything to make positive change. So thank you for being an example of maturity in your response. As for me, I do agree with most of what you said. Ultimately, I want to see what's best for the dog happen and I'd love for her to seek professional help with dog handling/training skills as well as help in better handling her anger and frustration.

[@thedawghouse4674]

Thank you! Appreciate you’re comment so much lol... and yeah exactly, they both need help... and if she isn’t ok, and knows she’s not capable of continuing to owner this dog, then for sure rehome him. But in a way, that almost lets her walk away from her mistakes

[@marialealealeale]

Thank you for linking those videos! I would like some advice. I have a Boston Terrier puppy girl, who has very high energy, I've been trying only positive behavior training and I've been getting mixed results. She's doing her potty in the right place but other than that she's not learning many commands, not even coming when I call her name unless is in a very playful tone and she has trouble concentrating for training session (even tho I keep them short) and play before. If you (or anyone else) have more videos or recommendations I would highly appreciate them because I've only had her for about a month and I want her to be happy and well trained. Disclaimer: I want to train her properly while she's still a puppy, I would never hit her. I just randomly watched this video and I was able to get something of value for my (very different) situation with my puppy. Don't worry!

[@marialealealeale]

The main reason that I really need her to listen to me and behave is because she absolutely HATES being in a restricted space (even if I'm there with her) and if she's around the house, she eats everything she can find, her bed, her blanket, the legs of my wooden bed, her potty training pads, basically anything she can find and I'm worry she would get sick. I try to restrain her from being in contact with things she can eat but is hard because is basically everything 😅 Some help please! 😊

[@majcherj1]

Zuko can sing, too? Along with all that cuteness and charm? I don’t think I can stand much more!!! He is a verrry special little man indeed!

[@todaXPTO]

I think she should have her dog rehomed. Admit (to herself, most importantly) she didn't know what she was getting herself into and ended up getting a dog she couldn't handle

[@xoxopuppies12xoxo]

Nope. Once an abuser always an abuser.

[@thedawghouse4674]

You’re entitled to your opinion. However in my opinion this is not abuse, this is a young girl reacting emotionally and physically to her frustrations and failing to communicate properly to her dog.

[@austinking3962]

@@thedawghouse4674 You pretty much just defined Abuse to a T lol

[@thedawghouse4674]

Lol no you just have a different idea of what abuse is vs what it actually is

[@austinking3962]

@@thedawghouse4674 its a pretty clear cut definition. physically assaulting someone is abuse. No person or dog likes to be hit in the face. You can't reason out of it.

[@austinking3962]

@@thedawghouse4674 Its not abuse its just a young girl reacting violently instead of communicating.... bahaha how do u not feel stupid saying this xD. As if the fact that shes a woman it somehow absolves her of responsibility. Pathetic.

[@4848patty]

You point out some great facts without being biased, I admire you for that. Thanks You!

[@parkerwinchell2233]

Thx for the heart ❤️

[@christopherbako]

Isn't sending her dogs mixed signals? He needs to "perform " only when she seems fit. I had a Husky, And he needed special training....

[@thedawghouse4674]

Yes she is sending him mixed signals... due to not knowing how to communicate properly with him

[@undeadgaming5245]

You're using peanut butter on your old fellah again aren't you. D:

[@bickle8931]

She is sending the dog mixed signals. She wants the dog to interact in an excited state but also to be calm which is not a realistic expectation of an untrained working breed

[@Danielle-tz9go]

Well done for giving a well balanced realistic opinion on this subject and not just jumping on the hate band wagon. Just hating on someone's bad behaviour to bring them down or punish them helps no one I like that your video was critical but in a constructive way. I didn't know of this girls channel or the drama about the particular video but she seems to me like many dog owners who pick a puppy because it's cute without having practical knowledge or having researched the breed, they soon get overwhelmed and frustrated with the dog when really it's their responsibility to learn and in turn teach, just giving the animal away or having it taken away (unless abuse is definitely present) can't always be the answer, these owners need education and need to be willing to put the work in if after that they still can't manage at least they have tried.

[@daisy1439]

3:49 when the puppy when to sleep with the German Shepard is soooo cute

[@randomlime3477]

you edited out the worse parts in her vid, spitting on him, chasing him off cam and hearing him get kicked in the ribs off cam in the reflection etc,. he flinches at her just pointing at him, and more....

[@bubblepop652]

I'm extremely disappointed with this after watching some of her videos. Anyone notice how she raves about humans and dogs being uncomparable in abuse, yet begs for people to sympathize with a psychopath? With how defensive she is in the comments I wouldn't be surprised if she could relate to her, considering abuse as the "first hurdle" for dog owners. I really can't wrap my head around how someone could equate a mentally unjust person and an untrusting dog with the need for rehabilitation. Brooke Houts is a well enough functioning adult, not an animal needing help. She knew what she did was wrong, and I hope the girl that made this video ends up to, too.

[@trashyysushi]

No she should not keep that dog, take a look at her other videos with her dog, look at her jumpcuts why do you think that when her dog starts jumping on her she jumpcuts it? The video she "accidentally" uploaded clearly shows the type of behaviour she has towards her dog when her dog doesn't act the way she wants. This is definitely not a one time offense and she's only "apologizing" because she finally got caught. Take the dog away from her.

[@HARMARSCH2]

Jessica, I saw only a bit of her video and what I saw was reposted. Here’s my observation She has a Power Breed Dog and is in way over her head. Like you said she gave Sphinx missed signals. I don’t know how old Sphinx is but he seems like a young dog. I agree they both need obedience classes. I’ve seen a dog trainer here on KZbin spit in a dog’s mouth. I agree with you, she should keep her dog. If Sphinx is put in a shelter most likely he won’t come out. Good video.

[@thedawghouse4674]

Thank you! The spitting is pretty damn weird 🤦🏻‍♀️ lol... and yeah he’s young maybe a little over a year I think, maybe not even.. but definitely a breed of dog that needs physical and FAIR mental stimulation.

[@tomedwards159]

if that dog is put in a shelter it will be adopted in a week.

[@thedawghouse4674]

Right........ but like I mentioned in my video, if we took every single pet away from people who have a distasteful way of handling them, the majority of those will not be so lucky

[@HARMARSCH2]

The Dawghouse, yes you did mention that.

[@vonanaya03]

Well said. 😊🙌🏼

[@lenorenevermore6941]

I want to applaud you for having the courage to point out the short-sighted, inflexible, witch-hunt, mentality that the majority of the public has in situations like these. Don’t misunderstand me, I was DISGUSTED and I cried watching Brooke assailing Sphinx. BUT, it’s totally unrealistic to call for dogs to be removed from every owner like Brooke. There isn’t the funding, fosters/potential adoptive fams, shelter space, or resources. Removing most dogs from someone like Brooke isn’t rescuing them from abuse, it’s sentencing them to death row (euthanasia.) Brooke and owners like her can be educated. And that education can save pets lives whilst humbling the owner simultaneously. I once got wise advice from a mentor: “We almost never get the dog we want, we get the dog we NEED. And you need to train that dog. Not the dog you wish you had. It will give you the lesson and wisdom YOU needed along the way, everytime.” I have found it to be true. Brooke needs to learn education, empathy, and patience just as badly as Sphinx. They will teach eachother if properly equipped with the knowledge to do so. *SORRY SO LONG*

[@JessNVee]

THANK YOU. These people are all so out of touch. The word "abuse" is used so loosely these days that it literally has no power anymore. I also think it's disgusting that people are advocating for the dog to be apprehended. You would know first hand what these poor animals face in shelters. Also, that dog loves Brooke, whether people want to admit it or not. Brooke is a part of the pack. Rehoming dogs should only be done if it is absolutely necessary, and I don't think this case warrants apprehension. To say that Brooke is irredeemable is absolutely absurd. She acted ignorantly and out of frustration, but her intentions weren't to physically harm the dog. She is not the malicious "dog beater/abuser" these cancel culture junkies are characterizing her as.

[@oso_Peligroso]

"Sure there's a lot of bad dog training advice on KZbin". Yup.. starting with The Dawghouse channel.

[@thedawghouse4674]

🤣🤣💁🏻‍♀️

[@daisy1439]

Poor baby I feel really bad for him/her. And the puppy in your lap is so cute

[@emmaluoellloveday2889]

Hi Jessica My only concern is that if the dog does not get proper training and she continues to lose control its going to bite her and then the dog will be the one in trouble and suffer greatly in the long term since then it will be most unlikely to be Rehomed please could you give an update xox

[@AlexSmith-ix4oe]

Wow your babies are impeccable! At first I thought they were stuffed. You clearly have invested a ton of time and love into them. Thank you for the educational video

[@thedoty5729]

Well said... Unpopular speech seems to just be the truth anymore.

[@gregstone4835]

Thank you for offering a sensible commentary based on knowledgeable and experience. Well done. I wish more issues were handled as well.

[@darrenvarley105]

That dog deserves better. Saying she should keep the dog because there would be overpopulation if everyone that harmed there dogs had them taken away is skewed reasoning. Many people have little control over their tempers, its not only a matter of educating their owners. Overpopulation of dog shelters is a beast in itself. There's actually a waiting list in Toronto right now for getting dogs since covid started. Ive fostered many dogs and am still on the list is how I know.

[@tomedwards159]

I agree there are a lot of dogs in shelters and most of them don't make it out. It is a terrible situation in shelters a lot of people don't care. they want a pet, it seems they always go to BREEDERS not shelters. you want a dog do your research first, and then go visit your shelter.

[@ohmylagosh9967]

It's not just the things she does though... the first clip you see she gets him all excited and then IMMEDIATELY slams him to the ground and gets in his face and holds him there by the neck. She literally punished the dog for doing what she wanted like she just wanted to punish him. She seems like someone who is trying to have power over their dog for the sake of it and might even enjoy him being afraid of her. That didn't look like just frustration to me since the dog wasn't misbehaving and there was no time where she was trying to communicate. Frustration is something that builds- its not split second like that. I've never seen anyone do that and I've never done it in all my years of dog owning. That's not common. And I would argue that it isn't better for a dog to suffer and be abused just to avoid being in a shelter. I can honestly say I'd rather be euthanized than live a life of fear and abuse.

[@midtennmoto7541]

Always nice to see someone with common sense and a lack of sensationalism getting it right. Well done again. 👍🏼

[@sabrinaveras8570]

Fully agree! Thanks for making this video, it’s refreshing to see a different opinion shared on this.

[@cliffordcanaday7010]

I mostly agree, I don't feel she should lose her dog for smacking him, but I do feel if it dosent improve or it escalates then the dog should be taken and given to a better home. Personally Iv popped my dogs on the snout or butt for poor behavior and doing something wrong, but it's not something that you should do because you get angry at the pup for being excitable. I think it's possible for her to learn to control her emotions better and train her dog in obedience better so that this issues don't arise...also the dog isn't starved or timid and afraid, he clearly still loves her very much, so I don't believe they should be separated just yet. I do feel the girl needs to grow up though.

[@BSD604]

Between you and @Shadetree_surgeon, some of the most rational and level headed commentary on any subject. I don't know much about the situation, but i agree that strictly positive reinforcement is not very effective, and sometimes negative reinforcement is required, within limits. A smack to my kids ass is not abuse, it is to correct a behavior, again within reason. It is an excellent opportunity for her to learn to deal with her dog, change her training methods to do it properly, and rehabilitate the relationship between her and her dog.

[@caitlynnrhodes844]

I watched your video and I have to say i agree she’s a brat but I also think she should get her dog taken away and have to pay a fine. I don’t think she should go to jail because as much as I hate and I mean hateeee her for putting her hands on her poor dog, we need the room in prisons for people like Michael Vick. The laws on animal abuse are just not strict enough. I believe all animals are just as important as humans. We are not above them. My 3 dogs 2 of which are high energy (boxer and pit bull/cattle dog) are definitely my fur babies and I would never treat them less than I’d treat anything else. People need to realize humans are animals too and this kind of behavior is not okay.

[@jackthebass2]

Super cool video. I like the talking head format lil

[@windreaper]

Great video. Sincerely.

[@crystalfagerness839]

Great video!

[@Crazycro905]

I understand your point and it makes sense. World sucks, her case is not the worst but she is still a terrible person. A lot of people don't do research when they adopt an animal. Like you cant expect a 10 month puppy to stop play time suddenly when you are done filming them. If Dogs like Dobies are not properly socialized and trained they can be a bit snappy when they get older also. I am wondering why the dog cant attend group classes, is he already aggressive towards other dogs? I hope she gets herself under control and she gets a crash course on Dog training before that beautiful Dobie becomes aggressive instead of playful.

[@mbarr1029]

Love it, going out on a limb. I see you have a great point and I believe you are correct.

[@MotorcyclesforTallRidersNow]

I don't know miss Jess. I agree... and disagree. In my opinion (and you know what they say about opinions) this is absolutely abuse. Not the horrible abuse and neglect that I'm sure you saw working at the animal shelter, but abuse just the same. Saying it isn't is kinda like me saying a terrier isn't a real dog because I grew up around Bull mastiffs and great Danes. It's still a dog. It's just smaller. And while I agree education is always a good thing, not everyone is willing and or able to learn. I think this Brooke bitch has problems beyond education...I mean who the hell spits on a dog? Who spits on anyone? Dont we stop that after adolescence? Great topic lady. I enjoy your videos.

[@44werewolfnomore]

I love shadetree's and I see your talking head video! You should do more! :) very intelligent and fair!

[@lamofonguera7807]

I respectfully disagree with your opinion but I love the manner in which you stated your perspective and even offering solutions to the problems presented in the BH vid. You are a REAL KZbinr. Keep up your classy vid content!

[@taradactule6052]

On one hand he gets hit and spit on when he is showing her love and hyper (after she hyped him up to perform to her liking) when she thinks no one will see then on the other he gets love and kisses when people are watching..poor dog..probably don't know what to think...even before all this she lied a lot and contradicted herself in her videos often..so I don't think she is a credible source on how she treats her dog lol

[@thedawghouse4674]

Yeah I’m not saying the way she handles her dog is not wrong. My opinion is based on a bigger picture is all. We all know shes messed up big time. Imagine being in her shoes. Anyone that says they’ve never got frustrated in life and reacted and acted out emotionally and lost their temper is lying

[@taradactule6052]

@@thedawghouse4674 oh for sure...I just didnt like her personality before the dog stuff lol she still shouldn't be bullied though.

[@chienneee]

When she slapped him in his face the first time if you can find a video that shows the full part he yelps. But I do agree with you. She should have another chance and fix her behavior, before he’s taken away.

[@syunderkennedy8505]

Umm no

[@nediojon749]

Yup you'll get hate because people are serious about dogs but many of them don't actually learn about dogs and training till they get one. Should she keep her dog i don't know that's up to the authorities to decide not me for it's one video and who knows how she treats the dog when not doing videos it could be worse then we have seen but I will not say she should or shouldn't since it's not my place to say.

[@tedpoland7650]

Hell u kicked your own cat when you was giving one of your dog a birthday cake

[@primrosedolphin6536]

Abuse is abuse no matter how severe or minor it is

[@undeadgaming5245]

I eagerly await The Dawghouse uploading the raw by mistake of her abusing her animals.

[@carlykirk6630]

Whats your take on augusto the dog trainer

[@jimmyboyd817]

I knew people would try and get views by saying Brook deserves to keep the dog. Either that or Brooks PR team are trying to buy a way out! Hahaha not a smart move from the dawghouse here....

[@taylorlampen]

If I’m going to be honest I cried i seriously can’t handle people (Brooke) when she hit her dog and put her dog to the ground she definitely should treat her dog better. I wish the world for dogs where amazing I wish people didn’t abuse there dog I wish there where no homeless dogs I makes me cry and I would never hate on you (sorry if this made no sense lol I’m only 11 but I’m some what smart)

[@thedawghouse4674]

Lol no you’re good, and yep im definitely not saying she didn’t do anything wrong. But just like the things you wish were realistic just aren’t

[@taylorlampen]

The Dawghouse awww I didn’t see the end but it was so cuteeeee

[@shadow_is_weird8991]

Oh your shirt says "Dog people are dope." I thought it said "All people are dogs."

[@bellesmom2012]

I couldn't agree MORE!!! So many people have turned YT into this hate/judge platform simply because they realize that no one can see how they live their own lives. Calling that abuse would get you laughed out of any court because that is where abusers belong, facing a jury and pleading with him to not go to jail. I call this extremely poor handling and I agree that this probably takes place in many homes. That is unfortunate but shoving, slapping or spitting (wtf?) Is not punchng, stabbing of I honestly don't even want to type in things I know about so I'm just leaving it open for whatever. All of these KZbinrs that are offering to take her dog should put their..... & March down to the local shelter & find out who is next to be euthanized & give him/her a name & adopt him/her. BRAVO for a sane person with an unpopular pov!

[@ronfuller9503]

Gutsy video Shows your sincere love for animals and a platform for tolerance

[@simplysophie8161]

hi! i love ur dogs!

[@saraithaguyx928]

I agree

[@sharikelly5949]

A dog is like kid they are all different therefore they all have different needs I think retraining most honors is the way to go because it's about to take away there's no guarantee that we'll have a good life

[@parkerwinchell2233]

Tell all the dogs I said hi 👋 and pet them for me plz

[@tezocsdad]

Very well said.

[@ashlindunbar3341]

That dog needs to be taken away

[@tanbow10]

This video should have more views then this!

[@pitbullultrazord2928]

You must be high I mean seriously why should brook houts keep her dog she spat on her dog and you say its not abuse

[@lauryn4648]

100% Agreed! Very wellmade video. I would write out a longer response about why I agree, but you've pretty much said it all yourself. :)

[@JockStrop]

disagree, we only saw one moment of her abuse, likely she does worse or it will like many abusers escalate into worse violence

[@amandatindall8209]

I agree I was very upset to watch the video of her behavior but didn't feel that she should lose him for good if she could agree to do better.

[@jagertroop]

Great video Jess. I am so torn on this subject, and on this particular situation. I do believe that some discipline is necessary, and while it looks bad, that dog is not physically hurt from a push or a smack. However, where does it end for her? What is her recourse when discipline doesn’t work anymore, does it escalate to actual abuse? Some people just don’t understand dogs. I think most dog owners need training themselves before they take on the responsibility of having a dog in their life. How can you teach a dog if you don’t know how to communicate with them? If you don’t want to learn, just get a cat. They’re easy.

[@thedawghouse4674]

Exactly, all good points and questions.. but remember this is most likely the result of Brooke NOT actually disciplining the dog. He is confused by her and she’s has never been taught the proper way to communicate what she wants and what she doesn’t want and when...

[@veilbreak5867]

I would argue that almost all of us who have children, or animals have behaved in a way we'd be deeply ashamed of if it were immortalized on film, and we've probably forgotten, which is just as well. I do think this case is different in ways yes. She seems to lack any real affection for the dog. He's an asset (though it back fired). But I for one have had to apologize more than once to my children when they were small, for losing my temper too fast, or for shouting at them unfairly, not because it was the right thing to do, but it made me feel better for a moment... Look, I felt just as uncomfortable watching that clip as everyone else, but this demon-ization is getting just as ugly. I grew up during a time when there was no internet and social media, thankfully. But I know people who have done idiotic things that if they did it now...could ruin their lives. Why are people watching someone just because they have a dog anyway? Why are we watching anyones life? We know they're scripted, not real. Are we just waiting for people to mess up so we can get all self righteous? This dog is also a victim of our perverse voyeuristic, unnatural compulsions. Stop going to watch performing animals at the circus, if you dont want them being mistreated. Its supply on demand.

[@angiekneale5831]

Kudos! Actual abuse is horrific. So many videos on KZbin show us that monsters are real. I agree, Brook is not a monster, just a little bitch.

[@kellyflynn467]

No hate here! I think you are totally right. If she screws up her second chance at the honor of keeping or owning her dog that’s another story. Love your channel and your pack.

[@re7075]

Thank You. Someone Finally Agrees With Me !!!

[@randomlime3477]

this evil brooke person pay you?!???

[@JohnHH59]

Agree 100%. She needs help training her dog. A lot of people cross that line and still end up being decent. loving owners. The idiots on the news often go overboard. And yes, if we were all held to that ridiculous standard, most dogs in homes wouldn't have a home.

[@davidvermillion2442]

Smart thinking, I can appreciate your breakdown. Learning behavior modification will take Brook and her dog to learn together/jointly. This will take them coming together not taking away the dog and pushing her into the bad owner corner without learning from this example.

[@machedari]

After seeing her hit her dog ... NAH If shes capable of doing that, shes capable of doing more. Youre wrong on this one.

[@cgx9286]

Unsubscribed

[@foxloaf8843]

we stan the like/dislike ratio