Why did Hunza's Mr. Mumbai return to Pakistan? - BBC URDU

مسٹر ممبئی کہلانے والے ہنزہ کے مومن خان 40 برس تک ممبئی میں رہے اور وہیں شادی بھی کر لی۔ پھر ایک روز وہ پاکستان آئے اور کبھی واپس نہیں جا سکے۔
بی بی سی کی ٹیم نے ان کا رابطہ انڈیا میں ان کی بیٹی سے کروایا۔۔۔
ویڈیو: ندیم عالم الکریمی
CLICK HERE to subscribe to BBC Urdu :
bbc.in/1GsJCMR

[@bladycivilian]

BBC is clever. Post pro Pak stuff on bbc urdu and pro India stuff on BBC hindi for the same stories

[@Love-yl4cx]

Yes! His story on BBC Hindi is longer where he told the difficulties he faced in Pakistan

[@Shahzilrind]

BBC hamesha PAKISTAN ke khilaaf ha

[@sauravdsk5901]

Exactly man hamare bbc hindi me everything is pro india. Mai yaha aaya dekhne ke liye kaya bbc urdu me bhi ye yahi karte hai. This is shameful . They very well know what they are doing bevkoof to ham sab hai.

[@Shahzilrind]

@@sauravdsk5901 ye goree ha inka work yahe hai . ye buhut shatir nation ha.

[@Love-yl4cx]

@@Shahzilrind plz don't mind but ye gore aaj bhi shatir h aur hum aaj bhi bevakuf

[@Salamatgb]

He is my neighbor .

[@alysalmaan]

Mr Bombay has just passed away yesterday afternoon, may God grant him eternal peace and blessings.. He was 104 yrs old.

[@MAZ501]

انا للّٰہ وانا الیہ راجعون

[@phalxmusic5836]

Did he meet his family?

[@shakirnain9349]

His Ton is pure Mumbaikar...Kya bolte bhai 👍👍👍

[@baazigarbaazigar7507]

😂😅

[@najaftassu676]

Chokra krna mangta hai😂

[@arjumandvillagecooking]

he speaks urdu and local Brushski language bro

[@shakirnain9349]

@@arjumandvillagecooking only Mumbaikar Can understand...Bcoz Im Mumbaikar

[@shakirnain9349]

@@arjumandvillagecooking Kv Mumbai aao tb samajh me aayega uncle ki language

[@PiercedCrypto]

May Allah fulfill all his wishes. Ameen Huge respect to this man. We have to respect our parents

[@adnanbinnizam1133]

Gilgit ki govt ko chahiye k inko achi facilities dain or help krain inki. Saal me 3,4 bar apny bachon k pas aany jany ka koi schedule b bnayen...

[@AdnanKhan-wo9kl]

hhhhhhh

[@mariumbatool8434]

Tum le jao na isko iske bachon ke paas itna hi shoq hora hai tou

[@aseesali6225]

Iss k apnay bachay q nai kertay intizaam

[@kidstoyscolorswitheducatio8262]

@@mariumbatool8434 tmko itna gussa kayko he bhai

[@mariumbatool8434]

@@kidstoyscolorswitheducatio8262 meri marzi. Tumhe koi takleef??? Jao apna kaam karo jake.

[@dean7644]

Ab zahir si baat hai apko pakistan kese acha lagega jab apki family hi india mein rehti hai apkey paas proper kaghazat hi nai hain apki family hi apki dushman hai ismein pakistan ka kya kasoor hai? Apke bhai ke bete ne apko jasoos banaya ...ap islamabad jayein aur pakistan embassy se baat kerein apko wapisi ka intezaam hojayega lekin ismein pakistan ko kasoor waar mat banao .ap old age hain isliye hasin nai arahi ager koi larka hota to ye bohat hi bewakoofi wali harkat thi jsipe hasi aani chahiye thi.

[@mariumbatool8434]

That's what exactly I want to say.

[@lajoyafootball478]

even my granddad work there in mumbai in the late 50s or 60s he was a watchman there in a school he also learnt writing reading etc he said the principal helped him a lot and he was praising mumbai then he died he is from swat valley pakistan

[@imanehsan5381]

If he stayed there then he was an indian

[@rizwanabbas813]

No he was from hunza valley. Swat is a different valley.

[@shazainbaloch2538]

Baba g ko wapis India bhej do 🙏🏻zindagi k akhri Din h wohe guzar le bacho k sath

[@aamirhussain4363]

Kiun bhej dain yahan akela hai khush hai

[@shazainbaloch2538]

@@aamirhussain4363 یاد بہت آرہی ہے اسے ہندوستان کی 😂اسلئے مودی کے ہندوستان میں جانے گا تو تبھی سمجھ آۓ گی 😂کہ پہلے کہا تھا اور اب کہاں ہوں

[@saimmalik361]

Plz return him back to India if he wants to go then let him go.

[@Peaceful_World130]

He is not allowed in India

[@fashioninn6107]

@@Peaceful_World130 why so?

[@Peaceful_World130]

@@fashioninn6107 because he is pakistani

[@fashioninn6107]

@@Peaceful_World130 onki family india me h agr wo jana chate hn apne bcho k pas to tm logo ko onhe welcome krna chaye.... mgr tm logo k dil bht chote hn.... shallow people🙁😕😕

[@chaudryukwal8530]

old man cractor like adnan sami tariq fateh maira khan ali zafar fawad khan blasted blaa ................

[@mohdayoub3804]

BBC yaar Kargil skardu road kholne kelia bolna plzzz so that we can meet our relatives in baltistan pakistan

[@MuhammadAsif-bi1xi]

Hahaha ab tur sirf tab he ye Mumkin hai jab IOK Azad hoga....Pakistan tu baat maan jaayegi lekin endian govt kbhi nahi....unhey koi perwa nahi muslmano ki

[@OnlyBaluch]

BBC yaar hahahaha

[@G36051]

Kashmir ki azdi tak ye mumken ni tum indian muslim Kashmir k kiye awz nj utha es ki saza tum ko hindu dyty rhty hn or pakistan kbi pechy ni ho ga jab tak kshmir azd ni hota

[@challenginglife6362]

Bahut jald baltistan bhi India me hoga phir jitna milna hoga mil Lena

[@irpmedia6600]

@@challenginglife6362 😂 😂 yeh baaten ham 75 saalon se sunte aarahe hain

[@jubnaa]

Watched 3 min video. Still dont understand why he came to Pakistan.

[@RetroRampageArcade]

uski irani biwi lae thi simple

[@gujjar78602]

Hunza uska assal ghar hai

[@mariumbatool8434]

Nalaik

[@shazainbaloch2538]

@@RetroRampageArcade مگر جانا تو پھر اسے ایران چاہیے تھا

[@RetroRampageArcade]

@@shazainbaloch2538 uski biwi idhar la aae. biwi ka agay kiski chalti ha

[@rizwanalighuman925]

میں نے بھی ہردیپ سنگھ رندھاوا کے نام سے ایک اردو ناول لکھا ہے۔ یہ تقسیم ہند کے پس منظر میں لکھی گئی داستان ہے۔ ہردیپ سنگھ رندھاوا ان بوڑھے مہاجروں کی داستان ہے جو دوبارہ کبھی لوٹ کر اپنے گھر اپنے وطن نہ جا سکے۔

[@tauqeerjabar1528]

Don't understand why people will love to live in polluted place like mumbai rather than a beautiful place like Hunza. This old man's roots are in Hunza and I don't see any of his emotional attachment to this place. Weird humans still exist on this planet.

[@umairshah968]

wahan is babay ki jawani main mauj hui ho gi. wahan gori chamri ki bhot ehmiyat hai upar se baba to hai bhi gilgiti. waisay bhi dehat k log ko shehron se lagao hota.

[@virusingh6504]

Shayad Mumbai mein rahe nahin hun isiliye ye kah rahe ho ki Mumbai bahut polluted hai. Kuch din gujaro Mumbai mein samajh jaaoge ke log kyon bhagate Hain Mumbai ki or.

[@plebeian6533]

It seems poor pakistani gov is unable to provide even basic facilities to this old man..

[@umairshah968]

@@plebeian6533 o bhai itna dimag na laga

[@shanmumtaz5884]

Zabrdast, it is truly incredible to watch this informative and emotional stuff. He still speaks in Mumbai language.

[@osamasiddiqui8997]

what is mumbai language?

[@shanmumtaz5884]

@@osamasiddiqui8997 I mean the Mumbai dialect which is a bit similar with Karachi's dialect as well.

[@taimoorbaig1724]

Yes tipori language

[@premprasun1516]

@@shanmumtaz5884 the casual hindi right

[@humblebee8334]

Osama Siddiqui Bombay dialect

[@mohammadjawad1822]

No offense, but I can't understand a single word he is saying, may God help him and bless him

[@utkarshyadav6703]

Ya because he speaks in a typical mumbaikar tone.

[@mohammadjawad1822]

@@utkarshyadav6703 What is mumbaikar????

[@natashaday2535]

Dono mulkon k batware ny boht kum logon ko sukh diya or boht zyada ko dukh. Yai sarhadein logon k liye bediyan bnn gai hain jo aik dosry se boht mohabat krty hain magar majboor hain.

[@wondarboy]

Before Partition our Pathan elders used to go to Bombay , Calcutta ect to make earnings and that's why many of my elders and others remember those days. After partition pathans started going to Karachi and gulf countries.

[@nadiasif78]

He should be thankful he is in pakistan muslims in India living terrible life

[@AnsariAli-ux1fu]

اللہ اکبر ۔۔ دہشت گرد کفاروں نے مذہب کی آڑ میں زمینوں پر لکیریں کھینچ کر سرحد بنا دیا ۔۔ اور لوگ اپنوں کو ملنے کے لئے ترس گئے ۔۔ کتنے تو آس و امید لیکر اس دنیا سے چلے گئے ۔۔ انسانیت کے دشمنوں و قاتلوں کو اللہ کبھی معاف نہیں کرئے گا ۔۔ ان دادا جی کا دیکھ کر بہت دکھ ہوا ۔۔ 😭😭😭😭

[@mashooque11]

That's so beautiful!!

[@risingkashmir7305]

BBC love you Very emotional story

[@himanshutiwari3509]

Respected Dadaji 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@farifloris5517]

BBC urdu on some mission

[@shazainbaloch2538]

🤔

[@taharajput9583]

thanks bbc ❤🌹

[@MuhammadAsif-bi1xi]

Baba G Endia ki Population Barha ker aa gye Pakistan 😁🤪 BBC walo tumhey Pakistai Hindu nazr nahi aatay jo Endia ma maraey gye??

[@shamifchhadventures]

😂

[@lovehumanity1815]

Woh w nazar ain ge.... Inko to anti Pakistan stuff chahiye... Baba ji ko kisi ne invite kia tha Pakistan.. Jo inko bhi hmare khate me dal dia.. Ab burhape me mojain nai hoti baba jee... Bbc drame na kro.. Le jao baba ji ko india....

[@shuvamchatterjee8611]

Converted mullos tere mulk ki population explosion check kar pehle.

[@homosapien3849]

Loved it ! ❤

[@bushraali2330]

Kash Pakistan India dost hoty allah karey GA ye din zaroor Aaye ga

[@MuhammadAsif-bi1xi]

Dost ho saktey hain ek kabhi nahi.....KASHMIR jab PAKISTAN ban jaayega

[@shuvamchatterjee8611]

@@MuhammadAsif-bi1xi Kashmir chor Pakistan ke tukrey karke hi chodenge.

[@tariqfate9350]

very intersting video informatic good video

[@ZH-Rocks]

He left his wife and children in india and came here in pakistan with an iranian woman and married her..i dont know what to say now that he is old.but i feel he should be sent back to india to live with his family.😁

[@TechnicalRoshan2.0]

Me Got Emotional When He Talked His Family after 3 Decades Life is Very Painful No One Can Feel This Pain

[@imanehsan5381]

Me a little irritated the the damily didn't call him back

[@amz1284]

In sha ALLAH

[@imtiazdar7787]

*یہ وہ لوگ ھیں جن سے انکا آبائی وطن چھیننے والوں میں ایک کافر ھے اور دوسرا منافق ھے!* 😔

[@aftabahmad1263]

بھاڑے کے کشمیری(پہاڑیئے) جس کو منافق کہ رہا ہے اسی کے ل پر چڑھ کے ناچ رہا ہے

[@aftabahmad1263]

زلیل ہو کر مرو گے تم جیسے

[@imtiazdar7787]

@@aftabahmad1263 *قصور آپکا نہیں بلکہ آپکے والدین کی تربیت کا ھے!* 😔

[@shazainbaloch2538]

🤣 😂 🤣 😂 منافق بھی اب منافقت کا طعنہ دیں گے

[@imtiazdar7787]

@@shazainbaloch2538 *بلوچ تو ایسے نہیں ھوتے؟* 😔

[@farifloris5517]

Aik Banda Aik European airport pe 22 years phansa Raha q k us k pasport gum ho gya tha. Us ko dono European countries ne accept nhi kia tha jahan se aya aur Jahan land huuwa

[@korikrali]

Thats BS

[@samarah2023]

Irani bv kaha gae... or aye q Pakistan ager nahi ana tha

[@fkarim88888]

If you see age of this old man, you only guess that his wife may die. This is not one case in Hunza. There are many people who are living there before partition and never return.

[@muhammadshazaib4631]

His one daughter is in Pakistan and has married my grandfather's cousin

[@ZahidKhan-gw7sc]

My grandpa spent few months in calcutta and Mumbai. What a good days those were when both countries people movement was free.

[@sidhuseynova2883]

The most livable and safe cities in the world: 1)Vienna 2)Paris 3)Canberra 4)Prague 5)Auckland 6)Dublin 7)Vancouver 8)London 9)Nizhny Novgorod 10)Rome

[@MAZ501]

paris???? 😲🤣🤣

[@tanjeevkhan8831]

Very emotional story

[@peaceandlove4646]

I love my country Pakistan zindabad

[@lifeinkarachi123]

Is channel ka maqsad sirf aur sirf Pakistan ko badnam karna ha..i m 1000% sure this is indian funded channel

[@xtylishb4377]

Yup

[@Peaceful_World130]

Ye to India wale bhi Bolte hai

[@mariumbatool8434]

Sooooo true

[@Sahil-ie3ie]

Nahi bro ye bhi yahudio ki saazish hai😂😂...

[@ayazmaqbool2828]

Pakistani kuch hindo gay thy india jin mai sy kuch ko wahan mar diya gaya kuch ny waps aa kr Pakistan mai btaya wahan un k sath Kya kuch howa BBC ko un pr b documentary bnani chaye

[@cricketopinion6756]

Appreciate bbc for there struggle brings near the people of Pakistan and India

[@MainBhiKhanHoon]

Good video and good effort to reunite

[@muhammadakbar3041]

Commendable job BBC

[@villegekihandivlog5365]

Nice

[@rashidpardesi1750]

اسلام وعلیکم و رحمۃ اللہ و برکاتہ بی بی سی سائٹ لندن نیوز ماشاءاللہ بہت خوب انتخاب ہے شکریہ

[@aamirtaqi72]

W

[@aamirtaqi72]

O

[@thinkingandbrainstorming4687]

He should go to india for his family ....BBC please take him to india help him..in same way he want to go

[@johnyastori2273]

Omg ... these borders ... YA ALLAH YE KASI DUNIA HA BAAP IK MULK AND BETTI IK MULK MA

[@Charvak-Atheist]

Mujhe Ghanta kuch samajh nahi aaya, ki ye bol kya raha hai. Subtitles bhi Urdu script me hai, jo ki mujhe nahi aata.

[@MrOvaishkuk]

It is very sad that thousands of families are suffering due to this unnecessary hate and animosity

[@shrek9812]

Always hear that BBC urdu finance by India today I belive that just imagine India ever show in his TV any programme against India om puri is an example we should stop watching BBC urdu now

[@abhimanyukumar1573]

😀😀same bbc hindi ko bhi india ke rightist people hate karte hai .. Rightist means bjp supporter

[@fahadzafar565]

بھارت چلے جاؤ اگر یہ اتنا پسند ہے.

[@AbdulRauf-xq9hj]

Bhai bazorgon ka thora khial krtay hain...

[@gadhvidharamdandanbhoordan5807]

India is great wonderful contrey in the world jo aaya vo Hindustani ho giya

[@mariumbatool8434]

@@AbdulRauf-xq9hj hum nai karte is tarhan ke tharki buzurgon ka khayal. Tum bhi is buddhe ke sath dafa ho jao Endya 👋

[@AbdulRauf-xq9hj]

@@mariumbatool8434 hahahaha O mere behen thora socha kro bolnay say pellay !!!

[@truthprevail8608]

@@gadhvidharamdandanbhoordan5807 mera bharat mahan... muhammed from mumbai

[@attamalicka.t6366]

Great story 👍

[@AMAANASRECIPES]

Aap toh bilkul Hamari Tarha bat karrahe ho..

[@imhussainkshmri4420]

Reunification and complete independence of forcibly divided and occupied paradise JammuKashmir by greedy neighbors is the only way forward

[@abhimanyukumar1573]

Tu kashmir kashmir chillata rh bss ek din yesa aayega ki kashmir ka gdp pure pakistan ke gdp se aage chala jayega ... 👍

[@makbarhussain3677]

Love Gilgit Baltistan

[@yasirlatif6253]

Only tears

[@sardaryousafzai2014]

ایسے شہر میں بسیرا ہے جہان لوگ سجدوں میں بھی لوگوں کا برا ہی سوچھتا ہے واہ رے بھتیجے

[@aslammirza500]

Very imotional 😭

[@iamindianweareonenation37]

Falls

[@eagleeye3500]

Its pro Indian stuff posted ingrab of pro Pakistani.well done BBC

[@kfie3731]

Please someone take him to India. Its his family there. I hope someone helps him. He is alone here.

[@nabeelkhan8574]

Jo ek bar apni ye dhrati chor dy os ko phir ye dharti ras nahi ati..

[@zafaralisarki8540]

Very tragic history of subcontinent.

[@muhammadshazaib4631]

RIP

[@upsigned]

Send him back.

[@AAjpj]

BBC never show good stuff about Asia

[@salman13007]

Hay duki kar diya

[@aamirarman2624]

Mumbai wala dialect baba ji ka 🙂

[@ProPakistani007]

Over 60 both governments should allow without visa movement at least they can meet them

[@jalalkhanofficail380]

iski beti ka koi irada nahi inko milne ane ka ya isko koi mali madad krne ka

[@yasirlatif6253]

Help him to go india

[@faizangondal511]

پلیز انکو انکے اپنوں سے ملاقات کروائیں انڈیا انکو جانے دیں اور انکو ایک اچھا گھر دیا جائے میری حکومت سے اپیل ہے 😥😥😥

[@farifloris5517]

It's look like Part of Endian Chronical

[@tanveerahmad-lo7zm]

Pakistan Kay logon ko is baba Ji ki help Karni chahye chahay is nai India ko pasand b Kia bohat jald India Hamara ho ga jaisy pahlay tha

[@shuvamchatterjee8611]

India kabhi bhi tera nahi tha converted mullo Pakistan hamesha India ka tha

[@masoodahmed9782]

his nephew complained for purpose of grabbing his property maybe

[@ragibcomputer3193]

Border ne hame bichad diya kya kare ab hamare rishtedar hain pakistan me

[@Peaceful_World130]

Accha to tum chale jao

[@MohsinExperiments]

To milne ajao kisi ne roka nahi hai legal tareeqy se safar karo milo julo

[@zainabbanoo3183]

As if Mr mumbai is from kargil o f Ladakh ! Many grandfathers of kargil are also living in karachi or islamabad due to 1947 😄😁

[@MuhammadAsif-bi1xi]

What r U Trynna sy??

[@mzyad9541]

If Pakistan had not separated from India, believe me all the Bollywood actors today would have been from Pakistan...

[@Sahil-ie3ie]

why??

[@surendramandal483]

If pakistan had not separated, all the actors would have been from India and this old man wouldn't have been separated from family

[@mzyad9541]

@@Sahil-ie3ie Who would cast the native Indians if the Pathans, Kashmiris, Punjabis of Pakistan were easily available for films.? Even today all the Khans and Kapoors of Bollywood come from Pakistan not India.

[@Sahil-ie3ie]

@@mzyad9541 LOL all are easily available to bollywood even without Pakistan...

[@mzyad9541]

@@Sahil-ie3ie not available.. That's why they called fawad mahira imran abbas and so many... You have 150 crore population in India but still looking for Pakistani actors just bcos of looks...

[@binyameenVlogs1992]

دوستو اسلامک واقعات پر مشتمل ویڈیو بناتا ہوں اچھا لگے تو ضرور وزٹ کریں شکریہ

[@sahibzadasafi1701]

Buchana maaangta :) haha typicl mumbai style

[@kidstoyscolorswitheducatio8262]

Kese kese log hen k c k c kahania hain yar... herat hoti h... 40 saal India me reh k phr yaha Ana ... har shakhs aik kahani he...

[@kiranfaisal4270]

Baba g ko India bhej dain apni family ke saath apni zindagi ke din guzarlain to acha hai inki help karain bbc urdu ke logo please

[@annu1553]

Baba ji aap kha fss gye Pakistan mein yha rhte to axhi life style hoti apki but sbse important apne baccho k sath hote aap 😥😥😥😥 aap abhi bhi Bambaiya zuban ko nhi bhule hain ❤️❤️❤️

[@MuhammadAsif-bi1xi]

Endia ki Population Barha ker aa gya Wapis Hmara Baba😂😁😀

[@HopeScreen]

aahh sad.

[@chaudryukwal8530]

aap yahan q aae ager indian ho thats not true aap indian biwi irani

[@IrshadAli-kw5hh]

Abai aqal k ando pehlai smjo story kia hai... Ye banda hunzai hai jo mumbai gaya tha, phr wahan shadi ki, partition k bhd yahan apne watan aya tha per wo yahan fas gaya or biwi bachai wahan...

[@premprasun1516]

He sounds like a Mumbiker

[@sharifahmed9383]

Kashmir k loogoon ka hi kiyal krro, wo mangtay key hn,.?srif Azadi say jinay ka haq.... Indian kissan Bhaeyoon ki sono, on pr zulam mat krro keya mangty hn? Sirf Azadi say apni fassal Sell krny ka haq, India mn koe Minority mahfuz nahi. Pakistan say India Aanay jany ka hq nahi, Cricket nahi khaelni, Bus Hindu Raaj bnana h, india mn Poor Aadmi ki koe ezzat nahi, Curse Mudi or Mudi sarkar pr. 🖖😭

[@NM-wh8ms]

Trapped in Pakistan poor soul. Government of Pakistan should help him get back to India

[@qaiserjadoon4129]

😭😭😭

[@basicinfo6816]

Baba g "majy" lanyindia gy thy 😎

[@mikhailkashykk]

1st Comment

[@roshanminai]

That dude in the video call was hawt.

[@muhammadasim3047]

To kis NY kha Pakistan a jao India chla ja trki baba

[@MDYaSiN-rh8vt]

بچے کو بولنے دو ابھی انڈیا کے غلام رہو

[@abdullahahad4901]

😑

[@laughexchange8351]

Chacha Ko Nepal bechdo.. Na idher kay Hain na Udhar kay..

[@IrshadAli-kw5hh]

Chacha hunzai hai.... Ap ko sharam ani chahye respect dai do.. partition se pehlai india gaya tha, phr bht me yahan fas gaya or biwi bachai wahan... Hunza wo state hai jis ne sab se pehlai Pakistan k sath elhaq kia tha....

[@fidahussain9123]

جدائی

[@ayazmaqbool2828]

India ki Army fani army hai Jo Apni tarring bollywood movies dekh kr krti hai toilet hin nahi wahan jis ki waja sy india reap mai number 1 country hai aj kal ho raha hai india mai wo b sb k samne hai

[@istyler]

Koi pakistan gusnay dy ga tu aao gay 😂 😂 😂

[@saadskd3639]

apan to miya bhai