Why did the Yankees replaced Joe Girardi? - The Michael Kay Show TMKS May 20 2024

[@Platerpus7]

I never thought the Yankees should have gotten rid of Girardi.

[@michelangelocaruncho8571]

Especially for Aaron Boone who’s never had any managerial experience before then it really is a head scratcher

[@Ali-oc8og]

Should have never gotten rid of Girardi. At least Joe won a WS

[@Lord_Bibulous]

Especially the way that team played for him in 2017.

[@michelangelocaruncho8571]

@@Lord_Bibulous good point because we know now that the astros cheated we probably most likely would have made to the world series and won I know it’s a what if but that was their hight of the cheating scandal

[@ChocolateMilk1978]

Never should’ve fired Torre. That man should have had a lifetime gig.

[@LAWMethod]

“Load management is crap” 😂

[@drumitar]

Aaron Boone is angry but only at the umpires.

[@samuelsandate9804]

Absolutely. He never holds back on the umpires.

[@mikejay8232]

Girardi is like the discipline parent who teaches his kids Toughness!! & accountability!! Boone is the parent who's friends with their kids! The one's who needs to be coddle 24/7

[@armani-ru3qx]

So basically, Kay is saying players are pussified just like the entire world today

[@00177454419]

Isn't it possible that Girardi , and possibly other managers are let go for reasons that have nothing to do with baseball ? When he was here he handled the bullpen better than anyone in baseball, certainly Boone. That wildcard game against Minnesota where Severino shit the bed probably would have been lost with any other manager. Girardi thought Sanchez wasn't an MLB catcher. He was right. He didn't like Refsnyder. Right again. I don't think his baseball decisions go him canned. So why was he let go ? First of all, he was at the end of his contract so its not as if he was fired. I think his health was declining. He looked and sounded like a nervous wreck. He himself didn't seem enthusiastic about continuing. Perhaps Cashman thought Girardi was out of gas and didn't want to make another multi year commitment to him.

[@jpetersgoyanks]

The numbers don’t agree with you, Boone’s bullpen has a lower ERA

[@00177454419]

@@jpetersgoyanks What are you talking about ? Girard's career versus Boone's career ?

[@natch27]

Girardi in ‘08 took over a veteran team who didn’t necessarily need a taskmaster at the helm. But one by one those guys retired, left or were traded and a younger crop of players arrived, led by Judge, Austin, Bird and Severino. Maybe the younger guys needed a manager who was more encouraging. Also, ten years with one championship in the Bronx wasn’t enough to keep his job. Boone will know this if he doesn’t win this year.

[@santorico123]

Mgrs aren't hired to be friends w players. Just saying

[@zcorpalpha2462]

“ How about them New York Mets ⁉️🥃🔥🤪🤷🏻‍♂️⚾️ “

[@zcorpalpha2462]

Sacramento A’s should hire Pete Rose 🌹 ‼️🤣🥃🔥🎲🎰

[@stephennixon9609]

I don't understand what Don is talking about because Girardi won but I will always maintain the Yankees won in spite of him not because of him. Boone hasn't won but players love playing for him because he's softer than Girardi? Practically all of the players on this team have only known Boone as Manager. I also feel if the Yankees win it will be in spite of Boone not because of him. There are very few coaches or managers you can say that team won because the Manager or Head coach made great moves that helped them win. Thibs hasn't won but he's shown this season he can be a coach that his team wins because of him not in spite of him. If the Knicks stay healthy next year they can keep the same players and go to the NBA Finals.

[@BadDriversOfNorthCarolina]

Giradi was too mean and wouldn’t go along with the front office. The team needs it though.

[@joqqeman]

Players are adults, adults want to be treated as adults. Some of these classic authoritarian coaches act like theres only one way to so anything and its their way.

[@Justin-tu4fk]

Ten years is a long time. Things wear on ya. What constutes a longer tenure? Nothing lasts forever. I get it, nobody wants to step, on toes! Over this issue.

[@zcorpalpha2462]

New York Yankees will get to Game 7 of the 2024 World 🌎 Series, 15th Inning, Bases Loaded, 2 Out, Full Count of 3 Balls / 2 Strikes & Lose 😂

[@Frankieefootballmundial]

That’s a bad take they probably won’t make the World Series they probably lose game 7 bottom of the 9th in the alcs and lose to the Astros

[@thomasgotting6105]

If this happens, I'll come to your place, go on my knees and accept you as the new Jesus.

[@lisazamrok8057]

Replace*

[@jonathanb4689]

Sanchez!!!!

[@user-vx5qg7hj5t]

Girardi didn’t get along with a lot players

[@johnpestano22]

well this is a new generation because Girardi's style doesn't fit with the young kids these days. same thing in Philly there's young talent out there but if you don't have that relationship it's hard to relate and win.

[@zcorpalpha2462]

Mike Francesa says “ Hi 👋 😊”

[@dbreiden83080]

Reality is Joe Girardi has a very bad history of being incredibly difficult to get along with. He had difficulties in every other job with ownership.

[@Lord_Bibulous]

But he won. And the players played for him. With Aaron Boone there's communication issues, questioning as to whether he's really managing the team. Hopefully that changes this year.

[@dbreiden83080]

@@Lord_Bibulous He got a ring in 2009 with a stacked squad. He also missed the playoffs numerous times and did a mediocre job elsewhere feuding with owners and getting canned..

[@Lord_Bibulous]

@@dbreiden83080 So when he won it's because the squad was stacked. But when he lost it's his fault? I wasn't the biggest Girardi fan either, he went to that binder too much sometimes. But the bottom line is under Girardi you never questioned the effort of the team. Under Boone it's happened too many times and sometimes it's as if Boone isn't the one managing.

[@dbreiden83080]

@@Lord_Bibulous Winning with a stacked squad doesn't make you better than Boone or a host load of others especially when said MGR had other chances and NOT only was mediocre he got canned for personality issues.. You also have to understand the Yankees are very analyticalally driven..

[@Lord_Bibulous]

@@dbreiden83080 Or maybe because he wasn't the "YES" man Boone is.

[@BrutusJrThe3rd]

I have no idea. Boone is a clown

[@eternalturtle]

Great analysis

[@brianfleury7964]

Joe won a world series!

[@michaelgallone7409]

Didn't he have braces 😂

[@StrawhatDawn]

I like Boone lol idgaf what any of ya say.

[@eternalturtle]

Deadass

[@RoughRaiders13]

Never did I imagine that as progress and technology soared....... Basic English and grammar would plummet. Replace.......not replaced.......replace. 🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

[@TheBatugan77]

That don't matter.

[@mylesdambly5154]

Y ankees will never win with Boone

[@johnpestano22]

I'm not a fan of Boone either because since he's been manager we've come up short and people feels he's too soft

[@juanpena7436]

Nobody likes joe look at Philadelphia

[@ChocolateMilk1978]

But Philly wasn’t winning. They started winning after he was fired.