Why Didn't Harry Ever Use The Killing Curse On Voldemort?

[@rnp497]

The trauma of what happened to his parents and also Dumbledore never fought to kill and no matter what Harry looked up to Dumbledore

[@katj3443]

Makes sense to me, I think your right he most definitely suffered PTSD especially after his experience with the dementors. I doubt he’d be able to bring himself to use the curse that killed his parents. I mean he couldn’t bring himself to perform the cruciatus curse properly on Bellatrix sooooooo...../*~~~~~~~#%#%¥

[@berrym7776]

Short answer. He was a decent wizard and he wasnt planning on dropping down to his level anytime soon

[@ultravioletskye]

I actually don't think he had it in him to actually make the unforgivable curse work.

[@Voldemort321]

Heheh

[@denizkenger52]

dropping down. he was just an average wizard, voldemort was one of the best wizards of all time.

[@Voldemort321]

@@denizkenger52 finally someone gets me!

[@fate-vs-destiny8239]

Harry and Voldemort are foils, our hero has a moral code and wouldn’t dare stoop as low as Voldemort.

[@lalalalalalalalalla6673]

Love the fact that Dean is so active and KZbin and uploads atleast once a week.

[@noorelamir9128]

EVERY DAY YOU MEAN

[@liesherarchive]

EVERYDAY

[@KanielOutis147]

Gives me that Harry Potter dose I need

[@samidhasrivastava3811]

Me after seeing the title: Cuz expelling is worse than killing... Hermione Granger taught that to him when they were 11..

[@zoejanssens8662]

😂😂😂

[@samidhasrivastava3811]

@@fellox3339 thanks.. hehe

[@roseminervagranger-weasley9686]

This ain't original

[@samidhasrivastava3811]

@@roseminervagranger-weasley9686 huh??

[@roseminervagranger-weasley9686]

@@samidhasrivastava3811 I saw that in a meme

[@myyklmax]

Harry refused to use the Killing Curse because he remembers it taking his mother's life (Harry's 1st cognitive memory). Instead Harry preferred the disarming charm EMPELLIARMUS. However, Harry's expelliamus combined the disarming charm with a stunning charm and repelling charm

[@alexjomain828]

It's always a good day when Harry Potter Folklore uploads a new video

[@musicianbone]

True that

[@lvmhr]

frfr

[@jesusaldairortizrosas1386]

The last two have been too controversial in my opinion...

[@renealbrechtsen9743]

There's also the simple fact that Harry wasn't a cold blooded murderer.

[@gailmckay5551]

The shock of what he did to Draco with Snape's spell in the bathroom also was probably a reason

[@piotrdworowy183]

But that spell was different spell ,not the killing curse ,but "slashing"

[@devin59320]

@@piotrdworowy183 well, the killing curse is arguably worse than sectumsempra as well, depending on who it is used on, as the killing curse does not allow for the afterlife I also think voldemort would semi-know a way to negate the effects of sectumsempra, given all that he accomplished in his time

[@piotrdworowy183]

@@devin59320 First agree,second:he could not know how to negate that effect,since there are only two people who knew that spell:Snape and Harry.And only them knew the "counter-spell" which Snape used on Draco in that bathroom.

[@devin59320]

@@piotrdworowy183 is there seriously only one way to counter-spell sectumsempra? O.O

[@piotrdworowy183]

@@devin59320 I meant ,if It already hit the target, avcording to books yes,only the other spell designer by Snape(forgot the name),though you counter it by expelriarmus or else I think.

[@masterclass4277]

Harry: AVADA KEDA... Hermione: stop, stop, stop, you're saying it wrong.

[@YellowBear-kx1ff]

Hermione: It’s Avada KedAvra, not KEdavra Harry: You do it then, if you’re so clever. Go on.

[@atlgeek926]

When voldermort attack at the minisetry. V tried to get Harry to use the Cruciatus Curse on Belatrix, Voldermort told him he needed to mean it to make it work,

[@tommoore2012]

I thought he was implying to Harry to use the killing curse?

[@squxde]

@@tommoore2012I am pretty sure it wasn't

[@jorgecarbajal8076]

Expelliarmus was Harry’s signature spell, and it always served him well. He had no reason to change that.

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

I assumed it was the Patronus

[@Zandercraft]

I like how literally a third of the video (34.14%) is the intro and sponsorship before even getting into the content. 😂 Great video though :)

[@shanirgookool7679]

Most videos are like this nowadays unfortunately 😪

[@melaniereynders]

This is the one thing that I dislike about this channel. The outro is almost a minute so I always exit the video early and skip over the sponsorship once I know who the sponsor is. I don’t need all the information for the same sponsors over and over again.

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

@@melaniereynders Same

[@Nontheknee]

Two wizards with similar dark past, didn't get to see their parents, didn't get their love but their life decisions made them so different. *it's our choices that show what we truly are, far more than our abilities* ~Albus Dumbledore

[@lemonking3644]

MAKE A VIDEO ON: what happened to the death eaters, ministry of magic, and main cast after the 2nd Wizarding War

[@rachelleliddell3494]

I second. This would be extremely interesting.

[@SaltySev]

@@rachelleliddell3494 And I Third

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

@@SaltySev I fourth

[@SaltySev]

@@BlackangelKatakuri Fifith

[@RnB_Rhythmical]

I fell off my chair at the Moody impersonation roflmaoooooo!! Honestly between you and Harry Potter Theory doing the Luna Lovegood impersonation I'm just hoping for you two to do a voice over battle LOL edit: BTW you forgot the skillshare link!! :(

[@holly9263]

I love how there is always one video a week ( sometimes more !!! ) I also love how they are so so detailed but don't dwindle on about the boring bits ! An absolutely great video as always !!!

[@oldscoolgaming6700]

4:13 The only "hate" that Harry ever really had towards Voldemort was from killing his parents.

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

I'm sure there was more.

[@bluebellea3]

1) I totally agree with your assessment of Harry's character about him not basically having hatred in his heart. I think the only time he might have let hatred rule him was when Aunt Marge badgered him about how rotten his parents were and being that she had a history of being consistently nasty to him in prior visits to Privet Dr., he unleashed his anger at her, without a wand. Also it's true that in book 3, Harry didn't know the incantation of the killing curse yet. 2) Adding to his pitying Voldemort, the use of Expelliarmos might have parallelled what Lily did, in a way. Lily didn't fight or resist when Voldemort attacked her, in order to protect baby Harry. In turn, Harry, was doing what was necessary to protect and defend; not surge and attack. His wand might have realized what this true hearted intension was and respected Harry all the more, thus exerting even more power to the Expelliarmos spell, helping to overpower the Avada Kedavra.

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

What about when Bellatrix killed Sirius?

[@bluebellea3]

@@BlackangelKatakuri If you go by what's presented in the movie, yes Harry was incensed over Bellatrix murdering Sirius. He cursed her with the Cruciatus curse but he managed not to thoroughly finish her off the way he could have. And this was despite being able to hear the voice of the Dark Lord egging him on before he actually made his appearance in the Ministry of Magic lobby (leading to the duel between him and Dumbledore). If you go by the book, Harry fires the Cruciatus curse at Bellatrix but she was able to laugh it off saying that Harry had to really mean it for the curse to do her any serious damage. In either scenario, Harry definitely felt enraged by Sirius' murder by Bellatrix but he didn't have it in him to exact revenge with the intense rage that he would have been justified to feel for witnessing the cold-blooded killing of his godfather.

[@llamacade3834]

The reason is that Harry wouldn’t be able too as he was too light hearted for it, he couldn’t use crucio for the same reason

[@Missielou66]

Like Bellatrix said you have to really want it

[@Ab_obla]

One objection, he did use crucio on amycus Carrow when he spat on McGonagall

[@ishratsharmin9310]

@@Ab_obla when?I m sorry I don't remember

[@Ab_obla]

@@ishratsharmin9310 deathly hallows ( only book) when McGonagall comes in after Luna stuns Alecto when harry and Luna where in rawnclaw tower to see the diadem's looks

[@ishratsharmin9310]

@@Ab_obla oh I m still reading PoA so I didn't knew.thx

[@eugenelau3927]

Harry was so decent , honest and showed empathy even with his enemy. He wanted Voldemort to repent and feel remorse in order to turn Voldemort to the Ministry. Very honorable!!!

[@blossompanda5265]

I love how he tries to do the accent for the characters.

[@BigRob1994]

I mean, if he’s on his broom (or the sidecar of Hagrid’s bike) let’s say 200 feet in the air, and he shoots a stunning spell at someone and knocks them off their broom, he might as well have used the killing curse.

[@amyconkey9423]

In the books he says that, which is why he disarmed Stan shunpike revealing himself to Voldemort

[@vladaivankiv3111]

so wonderful to be one of the first to see such a great video!

[@Voldemort321]

Hmmmmm

[@grandmyotismon]

He used crucio and imperio which tbh are worse curses in theory for the long-lasting impact they can have.

[@nessgottesmann063]

I'm sure others have wrote this too, "Hermione says, it could kill us or even worse get expelled, so Harry learned that expeliamous is worse than the killing curse" Or something like that, was in a joke j saw a year or two back

[@sweep_swoop]

You might possibly be the only KZbinr I've ever watched without skipping their ads, the way you advertised skillshare was clearly personal and showed you actually wanted to advertise it.

[@HarryPotterFolklore]

Thank you very much, i really do think skillshare is a great platform. I'll only work with companies that i feel are beneficial for my viewers

[@andrewsowl8696]

You ignore that he very willingly used the other two unforgivable curses...

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

And yet despite using one in book 5 was never sent to Azkaban

[@aryamanjoshi9283]

Heyyyy big fan your videos are amazing!!!!

[@Voldemort321]

Hmmmmmm

[@katboo9807]

Excellent video ❤👍🏻

[@dubofriend227]

I love these videos so much

[@OpinionsNoOneCaresAbout]

That was always one of my favorite lines in Goblet of Fire.

[@noahp67890]

I imagine the killing curse and all of the other dark magic in Harry Potter works like the dark side of the force in Star Wars. Like, a Jedi can’t just blast force lightning out of their fingertips whenever they want, it’s not something you can just learn - you literally have to have pure hatred in your heart in order to use it and the stronger your hate, the more powerful the lightning. Same thing for the killing curse and other dark magic in HP, and there’s no way Harry would ever give into hate like that

[@realJoeMavro]

In the Legends universe, Luke Skywalker and Plo Koon can use variations of Force Lightning, but it's (presumably) nowhere near as potent as Sidious' for the exact reasons you stated.

[@DBLCreations]

I didn't really like how Voldemort's death was depicted in the movie. I liked the books version much better. Where everyone was in a circle around both Harry and Voldemort. Everyone could see the dark lord, being defeated! And he was just a human, like all of us. So his body was laid somewhere far away from the others! But you could at least see his death body. Something i'm sure Voldemort would have been very scared off! Anyway, that's just my opinion of course.

[@samosborne6757]

Good video man!

[@SpringStargazer]

Another excellent video. Thank you so much for sharing. Btw, can you share the SkillShare link please? Thank you!

[@PascalLuchs]

My opinion is that Harry Potter didn‘t fight to kill, he fought to survive

[@robinpullman1488]

I always love your videos!! =]

[@caseygobel1227]

I just can't see him ever doing that as he would never want to kill anyone, and I'm sure that knowing/having met/heard of either those who had used it or had it used on him, on top of the fact he's the only one who survived it twice, would make him not want to use it.

[@_Harry_Potter]

Brilliant video ❤

[@YellowBear-kx1ff]

I think the reason you didn’t use the Killing Curse on Voldemort, Harry, is because if you did, you would be no better than him. Sinking to the villains level is not what the hero does.

[@_Harry_Potter]

@@YellowBear-kx1ff yeah you are right that was the only reason 😁

[@ancapistan6378]

If I was in Harry's place, after the 6th movie I would exclusively use Sectumsempra on Voldemort.

[@reiniernn9071]

May I add that Harry used the other forbidden curses more than once. Examples: Imperius during the break in in Gringots. Crucio (with success) against Amycus Darrow in the Ravenclaw family room when Amycus spat at McGonacall. (The crucio agains Bellatrix does not count, he did not mean it enough).

[@v-rex6262]

Hears something. Since Snape was a very intelligent, what if he was sorted into Ravenclaw?

[@YellowBear-kx1ff]

Well, for one thing, he wouldn’t have turned to dark magic or been influenced to believe in blood supremacy

[@miketns2212]

hi, just wanted to ask if you knew that another channel (harry potter theory, if i remember correctly) posted a video with almost the exact same title as this one about 9 months ago? i really like your videos, and understand that the topics to make videos about is limited (at least imo), so this might just be a coincidence. edited because i looked up the channel's name

[@sondrehyland3818]

Thanks for the video! And... where is that skillshare link?

[@geraldd9738]

Love all the uploads. Never ask a question on here so here it goes. Why do Wizards need glasses? Idk if thats a stupid question seeing how Dumbledore seem to have glasses.

[@therangemen8627]

Didn’t Harry use the imperious curse, when he and griphook were under the invisibility clock? In the deathly hallows

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

Yes he did it twice at least

[@paulcowlishaw]

Video idea. Can Lord Voldermort be impersonated by someone using the polyjuice potion

[@and_metatheory]

if you recall from the flashback James Potter disarmed Snape before using levicorpus on him to hang him upside down, and then proceeded to take off his trousers. I imagine that Harry had a similar plan intended for Voldemort, if only he could disarm him first....

[@patrickdrazen3574]

Harry was not arrogant enough to place his own life above anyone else's--not even Tom Riddle. The only person who can kill is one who believes that the opposite person does not deserve to live. Tom had that level of superiority, ironically because he knew which family he had come from, and he despised them. His upbringing had also taught him to despise all others--whether wizard or Muggle.

[@Musical_Sockss]

my notification popped up when the intro ended

[@simonblackwood4672]

One criticism. That ad at the beginning was way too long.

[@cassandrakarpinski9416]

I think he probably also scared himself when he cast sectumsempra at malfoy in 6th year too

[@59rlmccormack]

Harry wasn’t a curse person, he was a charm person.

[@piotrdworowy183]

Btw.not Moody in that moment ,But as you said BCJ.

[@LadysGallery]

Lol 😂 @ the moody accent - great job Dean!

[@nigelblatz1249]

Could you do, "What if Lily was a muggle?"

[@asharshabbir4423]

I just realized this but voldemort favourite spell lost his own body 🤣🤣

[@beauclock1311]

Because I love him is channel not himself

[@ZephyrBW]

I thought the spell for Expelliarmus only disarm someone not reflect the spell back at a person

[@andrewfurlong9073]

hey dean remember he did use the cruciatus curse on bellatrix once

[@kalpar990]

Hello! I've been watching your videos for quite some time. I would like to have a question/video idea if I may. Would we call a witch/wizard pure blood if they have had once, hundered generations ago a muggle in their lineage? And how many times should the offspring of a half-blood marry to mages to be considered pure blood (like Harry's son, is he a half-blood still, and if yes would his children be too if he married to a witch?) This is rather a question of curiosity than something really relevant. Thank You!

[@kieranof]

Intro is sick

[@jonathank4278]

Skip to 2:56.

[@lucybufton7147]

Because to use the killing curse you have to want to kill in your heart or it'll fail. Because he decided he didn't want to use dark magic anymore after how he hurt draco with the cutting curse. Because he and voldermort were foils of eachother, and therefore Harry had to use "good" magic for this to be a typical "good vs evil" fight. There's a multitude if reasons.

[@knitcrochettiger361]

also remember what both Dumbledore and Sirius told Harry....Dumbledore told Harry that is was never about how Harry and Voldy were alike, it was about how they are NOT....Sirius told Harry that we have both dark and light inside us, but it's how we choose to act upon it...Harry took these two things to heart because of all the people in the world that he did know...Dumbledore was his adopted grandfather and Sirius was his adopted Father...Harry adopted them and i believe that both Dumbledore and Sirius telling Harry these things would have influenced him....remember Harry was ready to kill Sirius when he first met him because he thought Sirius betrayed his parents....Harry did have the same hatred for Voldy until Dumbledore and Sirius changed his mind

[@mehekhumairah3436]

Pure man, Harry Potter

[@ivettevera]

To me is a matter of not sinking to the death eaters and voldemort's level, they thought that harry was soft for not wanting to kill his opponent but I think he just had principles

[@Voldemort321]

Thanks Harry

[@scottalderson4708]

I just had a thought. Is there a way around the killing curse? It says you have to draw your hate and want to destroy. What if you hate the action and want to destroy it? Can then you kill the person? Redirecting you hate and to destroy from the person to the actions of the person in question.

[@DryBones271]

The disarming curse was taught to him by both Snape, and halfheartedly Lockhart, Lockhart was an idiot though, SNAPE taught the class really.

[@sifilore9462]

Thou shalt not kill is the 5th commandment, so it go to all 3 sides, the laws of man, God, and Nature which no one thought of it being a part of. Animals killing each other to survive is a different standard by nature's laws, just like being magical "IS" normal but most mortals would say otherwise cause of their own standards. If "hypothetically" Harry did kill under self-defenses means, then surely nothing would happen to his soul. When Harry used the torture curse on Bellatrix after Sirius died, understanding what he was emotionally going through is to b taken into account. If not, then something happened to his soul then but good deeds after have fixed it. Again, if not, then like Snape said before "Life isn't fair".

[@goroufromgenshin57107]

Simple: he’s above such petty things as killing.

[@joedoom9444]

I like this explanation

[@jordanrobinson9064]

Harry has the to DESIRE to win, not the INSTINCT to kill!

[@realJoeMavro]

Confringo is a better offensive spell, anyway. Better to have a rocket launcher than a revolver.

[@MidoriNatsume]

To;Dr: Dumbledore passed the last 6 book teaching Harry the value of life and love.

[@DesolatorMagic]

But why didn't he ever use a high powered sniper rifle against him?

[@Matt_fxx]

Harry used the imperious curse on a goblin

[@zeroexmachina]

Empathy and a healthy dose of *timeout*

[@kdrumm477]

Expelliarmas (hahaha can't spell it) worked because there wands were brothers which is why their spells connected allowing Harry to see the people Voldemort killed last.

[@octolingeight8541]

being expelled is worse then death

[@musicianbone]

😆

[@YellowBear-kx1ff]

We could have all been killed, or worse, expelled.

[@hypertumppa]

Can you do video that what if umbridge use crucio to harry?

[@GamingsMostAmazingSoundtracks]

Your next video should be if Hermione can use the killing curse

[@jtwatts7990]

My answer: Voldemort was immortal and using a killing curse would be little to no effective. Destroying all the horcrux would be more effective

[@Voldemort321]

Hahahaha

[@denizkenger52]

it would still make him lose his body though like he did when the killing curse rebounded in 1981. it would be effective but annoying because they would only be delaying the war but never fully defeating him because he would always be able to possess someone else or restore his body again.

[@jtwatts7990]

@@denizkenger52 Ya. But I kinda felt they were tad unprepared as war can do to people so your conclusion would've helped them out tremendously and maybe even take down Wormtail since he played the biggest role in Voldemort's return

[@CallumBridson]

if used when Voldemort was still using his wand that shared the same core as Harry's (And voldemort hadn't made the Horcruxes) it would still be ineffective is that correct?

[@jtwatts7990]

@@CallumBridson Nah if he didn't have his Horacrux and carried the brother wand of Harry's I'd definitely say there's a chance Harry would've been able to kill him but at the same time as stated Harry didn't have anger towards Voldemort, only pity

[@yanetquintero9334]

Maybe because he didn’t want his soul to have a black mark after killing someone, just like Dumbledore mentioned that draco still had a pure soul and salvation and don’t have to kill him

[@katie500]

And I'd should say Harry didn't want to feel guilty about killing someone even enemy. As well he probably thought if he'd use that unforgivable spell he'd may go to Azkaban. That's my opinion!

[@thenightscythe2030]

He did, after gaining ownership of the Wand... The only Truly disappointing part of the final movie, Voldy got killed by Thanos....lol they don't really show Harry use all three of the "Unforgivable Curses" in the Film, perhaps to maintain the character on screen... We only(sorta) see Harry use one in the Greengott's Vault on the Goblin, but it isn't really made obvious it is the Imperio Curse (i don't think he says it Aloud)

[@thenightscythe2030]

Expelliamus was actually the Important reason that the Elder Wand chooses Harry as its Master... Not just because he is the Master of all 3 Hallows... But because he Disarmed his opponent's in most duels (Draco for example)... Dumbledore was the last Master of the Elder Wand, and he obviously did not Kill Grindlewald... Which made him the new true Owner... Grindlewald also did not Kill its previous Owner... Which is what made him the true Owner previously..... All other's, seemingly got it by other means, which they themselves met grizzly deaths. JK really should have explained this better in the books overall, but the final book got more Rushed than the other's... Hence why we got 2 half-thought-out plots, jumbled with flashbacks from Dumbledore's past... And a rushed Horcrux Hunt. We really deserved a better explaination forthe Wand Lore. We coulda got 5 more books outta Deathly Hallows

[@TheAnswerToIs-uk5fq]

I feel like there is a little irony in the Harry Potter series when it comes to these two spells. Voldemort is the epitome of evil and his killing curse is green which just so happens to be the color of Harry’s eyes. Harry is pure hearted and his disarming charm is the color red which happens to be the color of Voldemort’s eyes. Even more so, if you look at the Star Wars series, Darth Vader was the epitome of evil yet he had a red light saber (the color of Harry’s disarming charm yet the color of Voldemort’s eyes) and Luke Skywalker was pure hearted yet his light saber was green (the color of Voldemort’s killing curse yet the color of Harry’s eyes). Kind of funny how all these opposites come into play

[@nickstoehr911]

It's love. Harry's mother, Lily, died by that curse in the name of motherly love. Greatest love there is. And Harry would NEVER sully her or James sacrifice by using it.

[@leoniemarie-louise]

Question, do you think killing Voldemort and Quirell split harry's soul?

[@musicianbone]

That's a good question

[@YellowBear-kx1ff]

It was manslaughter. He killed Quirrell by accident.

[@Voldemort321]

Heheheh

[@denizkenger52]

harry didnt kill voldemort. We dont know how quirrell died based on books...but both dumbledore and voldemort said quirrell died when voldemort left his body, which implies that he died from Voldemort leaving his body. Btw it is known that possessing is really painful and the animals voldemort possessed had their lifespan reduced as well. It was either Voldemort leaving his body or the love protection of lily on harry that killed him, but we do not know this.

[@lordshadow3822]

I don't want to kill Voldy... Just disarm him unless he's behind my teachers head then muhahaha

[@YellowBear-kx1ff]

Muggle-borns are descended from Squibs who marry Muggles, right? Because I believe that Belle from the Beauty and the Beast remake is Hermione’s Squib ancestor because both are played by Emma Watson, both love to read and both are very intelligent and brave.

[@Voldemort321]

Oooooo

[@YellowBear-kx1ff]

@@Voldemort321 You gonna kill Belle because she’s a Squib Voldy?

[@Voldemort321]

@@YellowBear-kx1ff yes...

[@YellowBear-kx1ff]

@@Voldemort321 You’d have to use a Time-Turner because Beauty and the Beast takes place prior to the French Revolution.

[@Voldemort321]

@@YellowBear-kx1ff FRICK

[@jess84096-m]

Video idea: What would happen if Harry and Hermione ended up together?

[@denizkenger52]

@@Voldemort321 ginny would marry ron.

[@Voldemort321]

@dr103 lol

[@denizkenger52]

@@Voldemort321 it was a joke but incest was common among some pureblood families in the harry potter series.

[@tammymartinez7488]

@@denizkenger52 eeeewe their weaselys not gaunts

[@carmensavu5122]

So when an Auror kills on the job, their soul splits?

[@oldscoolgaming6700]

Harry never used the Killing Curse on Voldemort because, unlike the Dark Lord, he always showed and knew mercy.

[@PrachirSharma]

Small Question - if Harry never had hate for anyone , why did he used Sectumsempra on Draco

[@PrachirSharma]

@dr103 well without knowing any spell and its outcomes , Harry shouldn't have used it.

[@headstrongbachelor3152]

I don't think Voldemort could be effected by the killing curse as it said to only ripe the soul out of the body which can't be the case with Voldemort as the horcruxes kept his soul bound to the mortal world. The reason why his physical body was destroyed was because his unstable soul broke apart.

[@jamesmeagher7424]

Can you do a video on how hogwarts was rebuilt after the final battle?

[@danielgatford7686]

I give it up to harry I dont think that I could show so much restraint when my friends were dying round me I would never use it against anyone who wasnt pure evil though I think a wizard or witch should k ow dark magic but only use it in the gravest circumstances i would always try and disarm but if you killed my friend infront of me I dunno if I could hold back but it would be riotous anger not evil hate so would the curse work properly probs not