Why do Scholars say the opinion of Hanafi or Shafi madhab is wrong, what is authentic

[@mohammadmezan9287]

Simple answer is all 4 schools (Hanafi, Shafe,Maliki and Hambali) opinions correct bcos difference of opinions allowed in fiqh jurisprudence matters but not in Aqeedah. But nowadays majority muslims and these media scholars are ignorant and ummah dividers out of ego and ignorance.

[@ayyylmao101]

In summary: There is only one truth, which is known by Allah, but all of the schools' Imams were sincere and diligent in their efforts to find it. So whichever of their opinions seems the closest to the truth, aided by reference to the Qur'an and the Sunnah, follow that one. However, if you cannot tell, go to a sheikh or another person of knowledge whom you trust, and follow the answer given. That is sufficient for you.

[@prasetyoardi7912]

Pin down this guy comment pls

[@Akmarvel1995]

But u can't follow all the fiqhs all at the same time or can u?

[@marke2233]

Jazakallah khair Shaykh...alhamdulilah in the six years since I accepted islam I have learned so much from you and Dr Muhammad Salah...may Allah reward you and bless you and your family

[@Dr.AmjadAli-393]

Congratulations brother, you have accepted the truth. The religion, deen of the Ibraheem(Abraham) A.S, Mosaa(Moses) A.S, Esa A.S(Jesis). I feel hapy when a non-muslim accept the truth...I wish that the whole world accept ISLAM...

[@burnttomato3577]

آمين

[@humzdon4life]

The humbleness of sheikh assim he calls himself a laymen may everyone be humble like this ameen

[@irfanfarid]

How does layman refer to Quran a sunnah, through a shaik. So we should trust this Shaik judgement over the judgement of school of scholars who live close to the time of the Sahaba رضي الله عنه. 🤔

[@QuranicMoments]

3:16 I agree We must return our conflicts towards Qur'an and sunnah But my question is: 1. Those imaams also extracted their opinion by Qur'an and sunnah. They had better fahm of Qur'an and sunnah than us. In spite of this, we've got different opinions. 2. What about those topics (particularly relating to modern issues) about which the Qur'an and sunnah are silent? Kindly answer my doubts ❤️❤️

[@navinstrument8353]

Agree. And those are special ranks of ulama. Hence we need to get rid of thinking that our "group's" understanding of Islam is the "purest" and the rest are wrong. Syaitan is slick. If we're too convinced we have the purest understanding of Islam, we may end becoming heretics and shunning other who differ w/ us.

[@jafermoulana]

And their thaqwa was way higher than the thaqwa of our ulamas of this era of fitna.

[@sayedur6456]

Answer to Question 1: The answer is that look at what most of The Madhabs/Scholars say and if their answer is backed up with a Hadith or a verse in The Qur'an. If their answer is backed up, then you can trust them InshaAllah. Can you elaborate a little bit more on the Second question?

[@Zulfibf]

Just simply say that all of the four imams are correct

[@fardunali2100]

Quran says, "Wa'tasimu bi hanlillahi jamee'ah, walaa tafarraqu" And hold the rope of Allah firmly, and do not make dispute among yourselves.

[@haroosabdeen8320]

The imams are guided by the Qur'an and the headers I don't think any one of the imams will give a fatwa on their own

[@noorsnotes3467]

To think scholars of a madhhab research and dispute and come to an answer but a layman brings an evidence and assumes ALL those scholars were ignorant and never read that evidence, Wallahi is backbiting. Never say a madhhab is wrong, just say “I follow other than it”.

[@faisalz8849]

Or say I’m more inclined to this opinion

[@waj7hasan]

People are 2 groups either Mujtahid or Muqallid. If you reach the level of Ijtihad then you can follow the Quran and Sunnah but if the person didn’t reach that level then it’s permissible for them to follow the Mujtahideen. But to open the door for the common people to take the rules from Quran and sunnah is very wrong. Jazakullah Khair

[@arabic-englishhadith4828]

Have you ever Wanted to Memorize Hadith? Alhamdulilah, YOU can start Today!

[@o_o-037]

*MUSLIM 1:* Shafi is wrong! *MUSLIM 2:* No, Hanafi is wrong! *ME:* Asr is Asr!

[@usmankhalid1415]

He mentioned the 3 top generations who we take our opinions from and all 4 Imams fall into 1 of those top 3 categories alhamdulillah. So all 4 are correct in their own respective ways. ❤

[@aidasjournal]

Jazakallah kheir Sheikh Assim. May Allah reward you🤲 It is now one year ago since my Shahadah and I really love this sheikh, his knowledge is very beneficial for us❤ He is the first one I learned about Islam after my Shahadah and Alhamdulillah (I thank Allah) for sheikh Assim🤲May Allah give him Jannah🤲

[@yusufuabusufiyan4558]

All madhabs have different opinions in different topics, each of them is right in some topics and other topics no, it's about ijtihaad. The prophet knew this will happen and that's why he said in Hadeeth: Whoever strive to give Judgement (through Qur'an and Sunnah) and is right in his judgement then he will gain double reward ( for using Qur'an and Sunnah and for being right in his decision) and whoever give Judgement through Qur'an and Sunnah and is wrong, he will get one reward ( for using those sources). Therefore, don't exaggerate in following Madhab, follow them, but don't only concentrate on your Madhab, look to other scholars as well to see what evidences they have used to conclude what they say. Even Maalic and Ahmad have made mistakes in some rulings and they were right in some. Look who have used concrete evidence on this issue then you will know. Shafii have two phases of Madhab.

[@abdulalimomar6116]

Allah is most merciful and forgiving. May Allah forgive me, you and whole Muslim ummah.

[@exsalafi393]

The best ulema after the sahabas were the four imaams. Imaam Abu hanifa would have a group of the highest ranked ulema to decide upon such matters, thus the opinion was based on the evidence presented from the Qur'an and sunnah. Follow one school of thought as rightly said by the Shaikh.

[@zaidshaikh4935]

@Salafiyyaaa so you are more clever than imam abu hanifa imam shafai imam ahmed bin hambal imam malik... or you know more hadees than tabai imam abu hanifa rah.... I respect ahle hadees salafi people's but I dont like those who judge others.... There are 90 percent muslims who follow fiqah are they jahunnami or bidaati.... Imam ibn taymiyyah rah was also a follower of imam Ahmed bin hambal rah...Muhammad ibn wahab najd was also a muqallid..... Brother we and our scholars are not blind or deaf... These fiqah are from sahaba tabayin and salafiya jamat is made in 1920 so please dont be judgmental

[@eesakhan7837]

@Salafiyyaaa so if you are not knowledgeable in Quran and ahadith how will you interpret without one particular scholar

[@eesakhan7837]

@Salafiyyaaa if you follow more than one what do you do if one says such is wrong and one says such is not

[@TravisLee-p2d]

"Sue me." 🤣🤣😂 Sheikh's savage, may Allah bless him continuously.

[@mdashrafurrahman55]

I think that the summary would be," Be a good student of knowledge and accept the messages which are closer to the Quran and sunnah. But if you don't, stick with someone(Hanafi or Salafi, etc) with whom you agree more

[@cocobos]

What if, some we agree but some we don't and rather agreeing to other scholar instead? After what we've read and studies.

[@MustafizulIslam-w2y]

Masha Allah Sheikh ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ Alhamdulillah ,i think i found the best answer❤❤❤❤

[@Guyfawx42]

Why do we act like there are only 2 scholars in the world, Bin Baz and ibn Uthaymeen? And why do we elevate these modern scholars over far greater classical scholars?

[@AbdulRehman-ts1xk]

Jazakallah khair ya sheikh. Best explanation 👍

[@ai6749]

The differences between the schools is a mercy.

[@MrKHAN-mb3qh]

Alhamdulillah I respect all 4 imams , all 4 of them are right I take what is supported by Qura'n and sunnah and abstain from the rest .

[@inongbalee3092]

4 of them could be on the right path or at the same time wrong one ...that's the essence.. The truth are only in Allah, this four imam make an ijtihad to getting as closer it get to the thruth ..if the effort/ijtihad are correct he got 2 prize but if they wrong he got 1 prize

[@tasneemfawzi]

Jazak Allah khair We need education from the cradle to the grave, Please continue to keep the process until we die

[@xondeez757]

I'm pretty sure that he follows hanbali methodology, he says maliki, shafii and hanafi scholars are wrong but always seems to agree with hanbali scholars

[@nazribahnan502]

You learned Qur'an n sunnah also from the scholar..imam syafi'e n imam hanifah give their opinion also base on Qur'an n sunnah..the prob scholar today their think their better than tab'i n tab'in

[@jasulimaat3670]

For me the next question is how can we know from our intelligence that we can absolutely know that this is 100% more correct from the other

[@Xenon-bp6hd]

Jazakallah sheikhhhh! ❤ you're good

[@mohammadmezan9287]

Difference of opinions allowed bcos Prophet Muhammad pbuh approved it with companions so becomes Prophet Muhammad pbuh Sunnah and companions sunnah.

[@ztoefy4026]

Is the sheigh saying that a layman needs to determine for himself by looking at the quran or sunnah... Is a layman qualified to go look at the quran and sunnah on their own without a ustaadh?

[@irfanahmed6411]

Dear shikhe Allah bless you you are doing great work on this planet and we love you

[@hannafatehmamode3347]

All 4 scholars are good Each one has its way of doing

[@Uzi3055]

This was an excellent answer MashAllah

[@dayan47]

Here in Egypt the experts tell you the the madhab of Imam Shafei is the imam of the scholars, even though in Egypt they claim to follow Hanafi.

[@syedshafeeque7382]

I'm bit confused as I sense that the shaykh indirectly telling to follow one Imam (which is good) which also shows us that Taqlid of any one Imam is not prohibited. If I felt wrong please correct me. Jazakumullahu khairan.

[@mahmed4581]

Imam Abu Hanifa was the greatest imam❤️

[@wewenang5167]

well that is the perfect answer, most of us are laymen and we follow what one of the tabiin told us, the 4 imams of the madhab depends on where you live, but don't be ta'asub or follow blindly and judging other people who follow other madhab. If you from shafie but you go to a country that follow hanafi, so just follow the local norm, don't make a fuss about it by making another sof in the masjid or make a new masjid for your own madhab lol.

[@mewzi]

Sheikh Karim Abuzaid recommended a book on this topic↑↑↑ رفع الملام عن الأئمة الأعلام، المؤلف: ابن تيمية The removal of blame from the great imams by Ibn Taymiyyah It explains why the imams get things wrong sometimes

[@aquaisnotades]

Barakallah feek

[@oueizaii976]

4:10 🤣 I love this sheikh

[@imahmud]

Jazakallahu khayran ya sheikh.

[@tasneemfawzi]

Jazak Allah khair May Almighty Allah swt reward you for sharing this knowledge and give us all hidaya and protect us from the evil

[@Y8ko53Offical]

MashaAllah brother Aasim. Well said

[@mahmed4581]

It has been unanimously agreed that Imam Abu Hanifa was amongst the Tabieen👌💯

[@ahmadnurzam7402]

Yes. He is actually ever met with at least 4 last sahabah. Including Anas Bin Malik r.a

[@nafizalhoque2065]

جزاك الله خيرا

[@Justalayman]

واياكم خير الجزاء

[@zk3128]

When u have no Imam/teacher ,ur imam is gonna be iblish...u will be more confused then.u can blindly follow any of 4 imam.. Insha Allah u will also go jannah

[@seddiqullahkhaliqi5916]

جزاک الله! یا معلم

[@Gog3453]

You need to understand the ijma accordingly to there schools of Islamic jurisprudence

[@tasneemfawzi]

Jazak Allah khair May Almighty Allah swt reward you for inculcating the correct religious knowledge to the people this process is from the cradle to the grave

[@Justalayman]

Waiyyakum, Ameen, and you all!

[@catealdali1936]

Advice to reverts follow ahl sunnah wal Jamah, simple, straight forth and less confusing also they purely go off authentic hadiths on important matters.

[@leonzaki]

Ask this sort questions to scholar, they will give u concise answer in couple of mins

[@EvolveFiRE]

Assalaamu alaykum! How can the laymen get a comprehensive overview of the Sunnah of our Beloved Nabi, sallallahu alayhe wassalam?

[@monstermalik3159]

5:06 why only baz and uthaymeen?

[@MoeedKhan1979]

Yes these four schools of thought on right path which one you follow you will be succeeded. No other schools maybe parallel to these four❤️🌹❤️🌹

[@towhidahmed2780]

110%👍

[@zubayr7539]

Follow Quran and sunnah with the understanding of first three generations salaf us Saliheen May Allah preserve you Sheikh

[@trustee0129]

The answer is self contradictory. Imams Abu Haneefa, Shafi, Malik, and Ibn Hanbal (May Allah be pleased with them all)all are from the first 3 blessed generations and those who contradict them including your Shaikh Ibn Timiya and present day salafis are Kalafs or late comers. Therefore, you are obliged to follow those salaf scholars. This understanding is as per your own statements, that Quran and sunnah be followed as understood by the first blessed generations.

[@RezbisGrappleStrike]

All three imams were salafs from the first three generations. What do you say to that?

[@jafermoulana]

Imams also belong to the salafus saliheen

[@realusefulchannel]

Very nice Jazak Allah Khiar I only have to say that the Salaf themselves (first and best three gens of the nation) disputed and had multiple opinion among the fiqh branches, aqeeda branches. As normal Muslims we do not have the knowledge to decide which opinion is the correct one so we ask a mufti. Either it was a normal issue (salah, zakat, marriage, divorce, finance, etc.. issues) or it was a new situation (Nazila). The difference between the too is that the second needs a qualified Mufti to -1 understand the situation and -2give his own opinion that suits your situation the best, and mostly he does not stick to one Mazhab. While the first type needs a knowledgeable scholar in fiqh that is able to identify the issue and give you the right answer according to the Madhabs books. So, the fatwa is (Islamic knowledge + full understanding of the reality) while asking about the Sharia ruling is just (Islamic knowledge) Know that: -It is not always the same answer for all people. -Mazhabs are made to make our practice of Islam proper, not confusing, and organized. -Following one of the four Mazhab is enough to lift the obligation on you, because each Muslim who is not able to do Ejtihad is required to do Taqlid (following the scholars). -Without the opinions of some scholars we would have been in a great deal of hardship because a new situation came and new circumstances are now upon the Umma and following some opinion may be very hard and troubling for Muslims. -It is the last thing you want to do is to give (fatwa) from your own head because the mufti is signing on behalf of Allah with the knowledge and piety Allah have granted him, and if you are giving fatwa without those things you are sinning a very dangerous sin even if what you said happened to be correct by chance. And Allah knows best,

[@RoselinaARahim]

Jazakallah khayr.

[@ytg5272]

How dare anyone say Shafi school is wrong, The teachings of Imam As Shaf’i is the best school, If anything imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal and Abu Hanifa ( May Allah have mercy on them ) used to study at Imam Shafi’s madrasa. And today Al Azhar in Egypt inherit the teachings of Imam As Shafi’i directly and he’s also from the descendants of the Prophet s.a.w. So if anyone is to follow a certain madhab, Shafi’i is the one to go for

[@maeezshaikh642]

Masha Allah Jazak Allahu khair ya Shaikh fidduniya wal aakhirah Aameen Ya rabbul aalameen

[@CleopatraPsyco]

They say follow the Qur'ān and sunnah. All four Schools of thought follow the Qur'ān and Sunnah and give their opinions according to that. We as lay people cant go to the Qur'ān and Sunnah ourselves because we do not possess enough knowledge to do so. I respect Sheikh Asim and I watch a lot of his videos, he is asking us to find a sheikh who can guide and teach us, but why can we not follow the Scholars (Imam Shāfi Imam Abu Hanīfa Imam Hanbal and Imam Mālik) from the golden era after the Prophet ﷺ?

[@ObaidahNaseer]

Madhab means way. It is a way to et to the sunnah. So the objective is the sunnah. These schools of thought are a later phenomenon not only from the sahabah but also from the four imams. Regardless one cannot come with their own interpretation and must follow the understanding of the salaf salih.

[@theyellowflash100]

MashaAllah sheikh is so humble and modest

[@nousheenfatima1433]

Is there any source from which we can understand how the imams reached the conclusion

[@TheServantOfAllah99001]

It was narrated from 'Abdullah bin Buraidah that his father said: "The Prophet (ﷺ) heard a man say: 'Allahumma! Inni as'aluka bi-annaka Antallahul-Ahadus-Samad, alladhi lam yalid wa lam yuwlud, wa lam yakun lahu kufuwan ahad (O Allah! I ask You by virtue of Your being Allah, the One, the Self-Sufficient Master, Who begets not nor was begotten, and there is none co-equal or comparable to Him).' The Messenger of Allah(ﷺ) said: 'He has asked Allah by His Greatest Name, which if He is asked thereby He gives, and if He is called upon thereby He answers. The dua in arabic: اللَّهُمَّ إِنِّي أَسْأَلُكَ بِأَنَّكَ أَنْتَ اللَّهُ الأَحَدُ الصَّمَدُ الَّذِي لَمْ يَلِدْ وَلَمْ يُولَدْ وَلَمْ يَكُنْ لَهُ كُفُوًا أَحَدٌ -------------------------------------------------------------------- Sunan Ibn Majah 3857 In-book reference : Book 34, Hadith 31 English translation : Vol. 5, Book 34, Hadith 3857 Grade: Sahih

[@musthas]

Brilliant explanation. Jazak ALLAH Khair.

[@fazalkhan4788]

great answer by sheikh

[@syedamuslimah7155]

I stick to Qur'an and then sunnah. Be a follower of Islam and Muhammad ﷺ. Surely we can take knowledge from the knowledgeable Imams and Scholars.

[@mastery7901]

Akhis. I see a lot of words that are new to me as a new Muslim. Can someone explain what the words fiqh, aqeeda, madhab means? Also Mujtahid, Muqallid, Ijtihad?

[@thefreegamer7928]

Just Google it out !😊

[@Know_Allaah_The_All-Mighty]

Jazak Allaahu Khayran

[@ganjakhor8782]

May Allah always bless you Sheikh

[@muhammedmuneerkp402]

In islam there are four imams who we have to follow one of them in Kerala (Indian state) more Muslims are following shafie

[@danishsameer17]

Of course, we trust in your knowledge Sheikh..!!!

[@farahsiddique6702]

May Allah save us from sins AMEEN and forgive us our sins

[@farahsiddique6702]

SubhanAllah

[@rafeequlislam3624]

If I don't know Arabic and I follow your teachings isn't it taqleed. Because to understand Quran and Sunnah one must have strong grip on Arabic.

[@nasserbadie4897]

Assalam alaikoum ya Shaykh I hope you are fine I'm Nasser from Cameroon. I'm salafi I trust you. I'm just afraid that now you are popular you may change may Allah cover you with his rahma ,add you will good knowledge and maintain you on the straight path

[@ImamOman7]

Well said , mashAllah

[@Maneempire]

Both are strong an authentic, both are salafs, in my humble opinion hanafi is stronger but respect both. Scholars who came at times when there was so much fitnah and helped revive islam.

[@ShowBizJunkie]

He did not answer the question. Does touching a woma invalidates wudu or not?

[@ColombianCaliph]

"Sue me"😂

[@shamimbow]

Where is the answer ⁉️

[@FathimaFathima-sr4qh]

Good Question

[@hamidul9]

How do we know who is correct ? In the present contex of odhu what to follow ?

[@taibjaulim1]

My comment isn’t for this video , it was for another video when explained about hanafi vs other regarding fajr and asr Salat, the comment was turned off, I don’t like that but it’s ok. This is my Question and my opinion. Shaykh says the prophet Muhammad prayed fajr when it was completely dark, hanafi school of thought pray fajr when the sky light getting a bit bright, and the Quran says fajr begins when true dawn appears in the horizon, which mean there’s light in the horizon not pitch black dark nor bright light just in between,what do we do now? The prophet Muhammad is always right no doubt about it, but is the Hadith is really authentic regarding time of fajr? We don’t know for sure I mean I don’t know for sure, not just because the scholars agreed upon it, it make it true or false. but Allah is Authentic and true, I follow what Allah says so I’ll wait a bit at least 45 minutes before the sun rise I’ll be into the time fajr definitely, I believe abu hanifa is correct in my opinion, when fajr is prayed when is completely dark it contradicts the Quran.? After all Quran is the ultimate guidance. Praise be to Allah alone. Peace and blessings be upon prophet Muhammad. May Allah guide us all. Amin.

[@ganjakhor8782]

May Allah bless you Sheikh. Masud from Bangladesh 🇧🇩

[@Jacksparrow-gv8dn]

Im Shafi from India and my father is hanafi

[@ALIALI-dh8jl]

My question is then why don’t people follow Quran procedure for divorce Because in Quran there’s only 1 way for divorce but people these day have different ways

[@cam0987]

Which way ur talking about?

[@aminzakeer7742]

All 4 imams are correct it just depends which 1 that you follow. But you can't pick and choose the things thats suits you from all 4 imams.

[@ElhamAarianfar]

Masha Allah❤

[@rosmiyathishamsudin2449]

i'm in malaysia follow imam shafi'e

[@yusuf605]

But imam shafee said his madhab is sahih hadeeth

[@infjlogic]

I felt like he's directly addressing you 😅

[@abudujana13]

JazakAllah khair

[@generous6200]

1:27 is there a hadith or any source for this? Very interesting

[@-mz5rd]

These questions will come from India Pakistan and Bangladesh only

[@zulfikaregzikutor5561]

Do not blindly follow any school of thought and by the way there were many more school of thought throughout the history of Islam like Zahiri, Jariri etc. Many people unfortunately fanatically follow their school of thought.

[@gazisultan4374]

Asalamualikum As me hanafi if i pray fazar with qunoot with majab imam...will my pray will be accepted or shall i pray again fazar pray as hanafi way.. Zazakumullah bakhair

[@wavy-submitted315]

Assalamualaykum my beloved brother

[@faa8472]

Ve aleykumselam brother

[@Quantum-1157]

Sorry to say and no offence to Indian brothers and sisters, but india is one place full of ‘blind followers’: you have non-Arabic speaking ‘scholars’ who just keep parroting defending villages in India; deoband and Bareilli and just shut their mind to anything else or anyone else and worse assign stereo-typical labels to all opinions that differ from Indian village school interpretations! This ‘legacy’ then has be transplanted into the masses where people just don’t accept anything else except what their ‘maulana’ told them. It’s tragic, india is not even a Muslim country and many Indian Muslims think they know more than scholars of Saudi Arabia, Syria, Egypt, etc ego issues also play a role as does I guess perhaps ‘patriotism’!

[@yasreh5845]

Alhamdulillah☝️. I have listned to asim al hakeem from around 2013/14.i can say i trust him because he says what all scholars should teach us wich is Quran an sunnah.and inshallah alot of disputes would be resolved.

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp4905]

السلام عليكم ورحمه الله وبركاته Akhi. May I ask, What app do you use for editing?