Do we have to follow a Madhab

[@CrustyRizzy]

This is a wonderful video and addresses very serious concerns of Muslims today

[@Noone-pc2eh]

Alhamdulillah Im learning a lot of things from you.

[@FrmleastdevelopedregionofAssam]

The best way i would say is follow a local scholar(whom u find knowledge, trustworthy,of good akidah) not online ones,bcz u just watch viral clips of them,u cannot have a good opinion on them..as we know online are mostly edited,show,people show what they want to...AND than most importantly make dua to Allah SWT sincerely,after evry five mandatory prayers or any nafals u read to guide u to right path..as without Allah SWT help u cannot move an inch..u ask sincerely.. u have a mentality to be better with deen..u r good to go👍

[@AquaOver]

Mashllah Jazakallah kharian For such a great knowledgeable video ❤❤

[@thaknobodi]

the original imams of madhabs said if evidence is found after them that is more true and saheeh go with that

[@taimurahmad]

They said it to their students, not beginners of ilm. Beginning students if knowledge must follow a madhab and that is what imam fawzan has said(vids to watch on zaynalabideen)

[@savlatjonkhuseynov4051]

I never worried about this until I prayed in Bangladeshi or Pakistani masjid where one brother stopped me after jumuah and said I shouldn't pray the way I prayed. I said to him what's your problem with my prayer. He said I am not prayerying like their imam. I told him I don't know how his imam prayers and I have been praying like this for 25 years and he said to me I must follow his imam and I said to him did prophet said that? He said no but it is in his country taught like that.

[@FarhanAkhtar-ek7wu]

They must be followed imam abu hanifa ra they think they are right even if you proof them wrong by hadith and quran they will start calling you wahabi 😂

[@Noone-pc2eh]

Asthagfirullah. Even Hanafi has a Disclaimer saying if there is an authentic Hadith throw away my opinion about that matter.

[@UB40X1]

Seeking knowledge is fardh. Don't just follow a sheikh blindly

[@afnankhan5989]

One does not need to stick with just one sheikh; they can seek guidance from multiple scholars. However, they must choose to follow the opinion they believe is closest to the Sunnah, not based on personal desires. They should remember that they will stand before Allah to answer for their choices, and Allah knows best what was in their heart-whether they followed an opinion out of genuine belief that it was closest to the Sunnah or simply due to personal preference. The evidence for asking questions to more than one scholar can be found in ibn majah 2721 where you ca see that abu musa Ashari radi Allahu Anh saying a questioner to ask Ibn Masud. If by asking multiple scholars, one would be misguided, then Sahaba would have warned against it. Contrary to that, Sahaba have encouraged people to ask questions to more knowledgeable people and try to find the answer which is most closest to sunnah according to one's capability.

[@Justalayman]

It is not permissible to cherry pick like this unless one is a highly decorated student of knowledge

[@naathnaath6377]

This is for the layman, and how will a layman know what is sunnah, when he is a LAYMAN?

[@afnankhan5989]

@@naathnaath6377 There’s a difference between a layman and someone who lacks common sense. A layman is someone who has the sense to understand the evidence provided by his Sheikh. Stop portraying the laymen of this Ummah as if they are senseless. By your logic, even the laymen of the Qadiyanis would be forgiven if the truth reaches them, simply because they’re following their Sheikh. We will all be questioned according to our sense and intellect, based on our individual capacities. However, if we reject the truth after it reaches us due to arrogance or blind loyalty to our Sheikh, we will be held accountable. You are fighting for a wrong cause and will be held accountable for those who believed by your messages that following sheikh is sufficient and ends up doing wrong stuff even when truth reaches them. Scholars deserve to be asked questions but the Ultimate following and itteba is haq of Allah and his messenger.

[@afnankhan5989]

@@Justalayman why do you think this is cherry-picking? If a scholar provides evidence from the Quran and Sunnah for his fatwa, offering translations and explanations, and another scholar responds based on his own reasoning without clear evidence (perhaps due to lack of awareness) or uses evidence that isn't convincing (by making analogies from other hadiths), then an individual who accepts the fatwa of the first scholar because it seems closer to the Sunnah is not cherry-picking.In fact, the concept of cherry-picking could be more applicable to your stance, where an individual might selectively choose scholars, which can be even more problematic. According to your logic, a layman could choose a more lenient scholar like Yasir Qadhi and follow him. Then, if confronted about any mistakes, they could simply say, "No, no, don't show me hadith or Quran; I’m just a layman following a scholar."

[@user-ze9tj9yj4t]

@@JustalaymanWhat you’re saying makes sense logically, but realistically we have to realise that following one shaykh in everything has the following obvious problems: (1) it can lead to fanaticism over this shaykh and believing he is true in everything and (2) that shaykh doesn’t have fatawah in everything nor does he have the time to answer every single one of your many questions, so it’s impossible to actually apply this to our every day lives. One must be sincere and take the safe view when possible, and try to be consistent to the best of their ability, but to only follow one shaykh in everything is not possible in reality and it leads to clear issues and contradictions.

[@hamad7185]

when I was a child, I used to think there are no divisions in Islam and every Muslim are same but i got to know about this at the age of 17 and from that day I have a lot of doubts I need someone to explain everything from the beginning

[@ImranHussain-h5d3t]

When growing up there was no Salafis in the masjid. There were only Ahle sunnat wal jammat. They then started to send and Imams from Najd and fund masjids . Started having Islamic circles to target youngsters and misleading them. That's why so many sects appear. If our beloved prophet did not pray for Najd why should we follow them. They can't even get the moon sighting correct. The four Imams had respect for each other. Stay away from Najd and follow the correct Aqeedah. Look at our history Allah subhana walla thallah gave victory too lthe pious such as Salahuddin Ayyubi. Look in to their Aqeedah and madhab. Then look at the Najadis who broke up the Uthman khilafah by joining with the Khufar against the Muslims.

[@shamimabbaslaskar3186]

0:02 sheikh when someone is an expert in economics and geopolitics international relations but is a layman in islam but a scholar whose an expert of religion which in itself has its sharia based econmony and politics and international relations but in todays time the scholar will be consider a layman in economics politics and international relations so who has more merit to talk about geopolitics and international relation and the nuances of political decisions of a kingdom if one can be both knowledge of islam as well as geopolitics international relation global politics he is better suited i guess

[@jamieammar6131]

I have a suggestion, please, use punctuation.

[@Abd_Allah_1445]

You believe in geo politics?

[@rayyanmohammed]

@@jamieammar6131 😭😭

[@thahiraiqbal7021]

No imam or Sheikh is going to protect you on the day of judgement. Only you will be judged according to your deeds. Islam is a simple religion that ordains us to Worship none other but Allah, and Do Good deeds. Be firm in your belief, and ask only HIS Help and Guidance. Put your full trust in HIM: Surah Fatiha. IT IS THE GOOD DEEDS THAT IS TO BE VERIFIED ACCORDING TO THE QURAN. The four imams have said,'Follow me , but if you have any doubt, turn to the Quran for reference. There were no madhabs during the Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam. They just understood the Quran: the Command of Allah. And the way of life of the Prophet saw Hence, it is the duty of every Muslim to understand the Quran and know at least the basics of Authentic Hadith.

[@IA67676]

The guy he tslks sbout in the end who didjt know about islam reminds me of apus

[@nomadicman6781]

All The Scholars Are Authentic let's NOT Divide us and that's what our enemies create fitna between us May Allah Guide and Protect us All

[@Ruthlessor]

I kindly disagree with you because scholars are human beings, and human beings make mistakes. They are not prophets in where they commit no mistakes. I am not saying don't love the scholars. However, if a scholar follows a weak hadith (thinking that it was authentic), then we leave it out and take the authentic hadith. جزاك الله خيرًا

[@razamughal4582]

​@@Ruthlessorjahil. when the four imams made a mistake, the generation IMMEDIATELY AFTER THEM corrected them. finished. finito. done.

[@Ruthlessor]

​@@razamughal4582 May Allah forgive you brother for you calling me a ((Jahil)). Correct me if I am wrong but: If what you are saying is true, then you are saying that all madhahib (plural of madhab) rely on Saheeh Ahaadeeth, which is not true. One of the madhahib says that doing Raful Yadain is only once in Salah; even though they present their evidence, it is weak, and goes against Mutawatir (sure knowledge) Ahaadeeth. I totally agree that Madhahib relie on proof, but if you don't want to follow the Prophet (صلى الله عليه و سلم) through acceptable Ahaadeeth (Hasan or Saheeh), and want to follow someone or other people than him, then may Allah guide him to the straight path.

[@razamughal4582]

@@Ruthlessor you are incredibly jahil. fix the hindu environment you have in your home. Breaking news: the generations DIRECTLY after the four imams corrected any mistakes.

[@razamughal4582]

@@Ruthlessor you are incredibly jahil.fix the hindu environment you have in your home

[@YaseenPatel-o1d]

To, Fitna e Affidavit wale, If anyone who is struggling to speak ,(E;g Taaaaaa,Taaaaaa,Taaaaaa)there is an Ayat in Quran (Read A life of Sayyadina Hazrat Musa (A.S) As he(A.S) Had that (See E:g) 100 Times a day (Ask Ulema Al Deoband Al Hindi)

[@ergun-re4dr]

I think these four humans who are divided from one, are like lukas marcus john and a fourth. Eesa did not divided after him there was division. These four are already accepted in the brains and generations, so aslong allah forgive and guides its no problem to be born in these 4 accepeted truths.

[@lilratul]

00:00 Intro 00: Ques 00: Answer 1: Counseling Ad

[@Athif_Kamarudeen]

4:38 😂😂

[@kaskovic1993]

Dont follow a sheikh blindly do your own research! We all go into our own grave and we will be asked by Allah SWT about things we followed and believed in, no sheikh will intervene for you unless Allah gives protectors the go ahead! Without Allah allowing them they can’t protect you, so do your own research!

[@ukachajuma]

There was an X on top of a fruit. Kindly what's the meaning? Shukran

[@waseemraza784]

Cross mark, it means,don't pick cherries

[@afnankhan5989]

The reason I am challenging this misguided approach of cherry-picking scholars is that it is hindering effective Dawah. Dawah has become limited to non-Muslims, while within the Muslim community, some scholars are backing practices like interest-based mortgages, corrupt beliefs, Islamic movie nights in the houses of Allah, acting in movies, and women appearing in front of men. When people are confronted about these practices, they often hide behind the flawed logic of blindly following scholars without using their own intellect. This mindset is also diminishing the love of seeking knowledge. People are being told that if they become students of knowledge, they are no longer considered laymen and won't be forgiven for blindly following. What they don’t realize is that even as laymen, they won’t be forgiven for blindly following a scholar without question. They must understand that there is a real possibility of ending up in Hell along with the scholar they followed.Such awareness should actually inspire a desire to seek knowledge, as it becomes clear that merely following a scholar is not enough to secure a place in Jannah. It’s not as if Allah has made us animals without the ability to think and discern. Consider the example of a mechanic. Even if I don't have a lot of knowledge about fixing cars, I still try my best to understand the problem and seek out mechanics who give sincere advice and don’t cheat me. Now, imagine telling someone to stick with one mechanic forever, no matter what. It’s illogical and unacceptable when it comes to worldly matters, so how can we apply this thinking to matters of Deen, where fallible men are involved?

[@Justalayman]

assimalhakeem.freshdesk.com/support/solutions/articles/31000146907-two-trustworthy-scholars-give-opposite-fatwas-whom-should-we-follow-fatwa-shopping-cherry-pickin

[@rathernot6660]

You're waffling. All over the place

[@Inzy-k]

Lay off the drugs akh

[@afnankhan5989]

When ignorants cannot continue discussion with knowledge, 👆 this how there attitude becomes. SALAM!! وَإِذَا خَاطَبَهُمُ ٱلْجَـٰهِلُونَ قَالُوا۟ سَلَـٰمًا

[@rathernot6660]

@@afnankhan5989lay off the qiyaas Akhi.

[@misbahuddinsyed9118]

But isn't it fard on every muslim to gain ilm if Islam at least enough to live his daily life and have right aqeedah ?

[@mewopoly1414]

question So do i have to follow only one sheikh or can follow more than one?

[@PEACEWITHIN114]

He covered this at 6:30

[@reedox5311]

You can follow more than one and follow the evidences

[@naathnaath6377]

Just watch it again?

[@Inzy-k]

So which imam do the salafis follow?

[@omairbinenam6337]

which of the 1 sect is that which enters paradise? don't want to believe it is named after someone or some place.

[@POPALZAiii]

The ones who follow the Prophet رَسُولُ الله صَلَّىٰ ٱللَّٰهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِهِ وَسَلَّمَ and his companions. Simple. As stated in the hadith.

[@omairbinenam6337]

@@POPALZAiii and which are the sects that will not be rewarded with the "Kausar" in paradise?

[@POPALZAiii]

@@omairbinenam6337 The ones who strayed from the sunnah of رَسُولُ الله صَلَّىٰ ٱللَّٰهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِهِ وَسَلَّمَ and his companions.

[@omairbinenam6337]

@@POPALZAiii you have answered in truth, and Allah is the Most Merciful.

[@suitntie8710]

on the day of judgement, will only certain madhabs go to heaven and the rest will go to hell? if only one will go to heaven how should I know which one is correct?

[@AdamFirdaus-wm2xm]

No one with any credibility has ever said that

[@rachmatt5082]

The hadits is: Awf ibn Malik reported that the Prophet ﷺ said, 'The Jews split into 71 sects: one will enter Paradise and 70 will enter Hell. The Christians split into 72 sects: 71 will enter Hell and one will enter Paradise. By Him in Whose Hand is my soul, my Ummah will split into 73 sects: one will enter Paradise and 72 will enter Hell’ (Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi).

[@naathnaath6377]

Madhabs are NOT sects. That's the end of your inquiry.

[@suitntie8710]

@@AdamFirdaus-wm2xm so does that mean all madhabs are able to enter heaven?

[@suitntie8710]

@@rachmatt5082 does that mean i have to identify with a certain sect to enter Jannah? or just identify as a muslim

[@hooman467]

❤

[@lilratul]

0:20

[@noucamper]

How is it that the students of knowledge as he said can pick & choose based on evidence they 'think' is more strong ergo subjective, thus they can follow different madhabs but a laymen doing the same is cherry picking? I assume all madhabs are still under fold of islam and choosing one ruling over the other is NOT going to make you a non-muslim, hence student was able to pick different rulings from the different madhabs.

[@fulan03]

the student of knowledge actually understands where the ruling comes from, a layman does not

[@naathnaath6377]

Would you go to a Doctor or a student who is becoming a Doctor?

[@noucamper]

@@fulan03 So understanding is what differentiates, and that is subjective from what i understand as all 4 madhabs are Ahle Sunnah wa Jama and therefore correct in their opinions? Ruling itself is not correct or incorrect of itself.

[@fulan03]

@@noucamper how would a layman know which opinion from each madhab is correct?

[@fulan03]

@EFe-j9u not every issue is that simple

[@rathernot6660]

Inam Abu hanifa rhm was a very knowledgeable scholar, however the contemporary followers of this madhab are from the deobandi, Taliban, barelwi sufi scholars all misguided who use weak and fabricated hadith and a lot of it is qiyaas based. So to follow imam Abu hanifa rhm it directly implies one will most likely HAVE to follow these misguided sects as a default reference to imam Abu hanifa. Thats the issue on hand. The works of Imam Abu hanifa rhm aren't rejected, but the contemporary scholars of his are off the manhaj of Qur'an and Sunnah. The trustworthiness factor is more defining than blindly following a Madhab

[@KS-eu7jp]

Must follow Quraan not haddiss

[@Steve3333maush]

@@KS-eu7jp Quran orders to follow the hadees, can't follow Islam without hadees

[@KS-eu7jp]

@@Steve3333maush Quraan ki kounsi aayet kehti hai hadiss follow karo???

[@Steve3333maush]

@@KS-eu7jp Quran 4:59: "O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you." Quran 59:7: "Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it; and whatever he forbids you, refrain from it."

[@Steve3333maush]

@@KS-eu7jp Hadees Nabi Paak ﷺ K orders hain , hadees K bagheir kasay follow krr skty hain order? Quran kahta ha namaz parho, namaz ka tarika Quran main Nahi ha wo hadees main ha, Quran kahta ha Hajj kro, Hajj ka tarika Quran main Nahi ha, hadees main ha, Quran kahta ha Zakat dow , Zakat ke amount Quran main Nahi ha hadees main ha, hadees K bagheir Islam ko follow krna impossible ha, ya sab ko patta ha basic se baat ha

[@KS-eu7jp]

@@Steve3333maush Nabi ne kiss ki ittat ki??? Nabi ne Quraan ke illawaa kuch nahi diyaa. Nabi ke naamse mansoob ker bukhari ne joo hadisse di woo Nabi ke 250 saal baad Nabi ke naam se di hai Kyaa Quraan incomplete book hai???

[@aron2015]

I don't follow any school. Never once have I been told I must follow. Anything I'm unsure about I simply research online, KZbin videos etc so I am not cherry picking, I'm simply looking for rules according to Islam. who is liable then if it's wrong me or the video I gained information from? Because they could come from a school of thought? This shieke even chooses opinions and includes strongest one in some of his videos. He doesn't say this is from school x, y, z. Why can't we just choose strongest opinion? And if we follow a school which clearly teaches something that is not the sunnah, are we to follow it? If not that contradicts that we have to follow school of thought and should rather follow strongest opinion?

[@adelow]

Something you need to understand is that. When a Mujtahid says that "This is the correct opinion" then it is only according to him after looking at the evidences! The "Correct opinion" is only the Preferred view of a Mujtahid. If you take Ibn baz or Al-Albani, they both have books on "The authentic prayer of the Prophet" yet they still differ in how this prayer is. Now when the Hanafi or Hanbali school has an official position, they are also saying "This is the correct opinion". But it is according to them. The Ulama in the introductions to fiqh, they mention that when it comes to the Ultimate truth in a mas'alah which is ijtihadiyah, nobody knows the correct opinion except Allah. Hence for the laymen, they blindfollow whoever they trust the most. And the reason the 4 schools are the most trustable, the most Refined by the Scholars of islam, etc, is becausw they have done ijtihaad for more than 800 years. Yet a contemporary scholar today is nowhere near the calibre of a Ijtihaad of a madhab.

[@Muhammad_Abdullah_Lazim]

I hate that madhab dividis the muslim ummah thinking they are better then the others madhab

[@naathnaath6377]

True followers don't think like that. It's the others who think that they are better than the main 4.

[@coffeeboyclips1973]

Nope, they do not divide the ummah, we believe all are correct

[@Muhammad_Abdullah_Lazim]

@@coffeeboyclips1973 they all say that yet....... they do

[@coffeeboyclips1973]

@@Muhammad_Abdullah_Lazim can you explain how they do

[@Muhammad_Abdullah_Lazim]

@@coffeeboyclips1973 what country u live in brother?

[@suitntie8710]

i dont understand, why cant i just be a good muslim on my own. i do what the Qur'an says, follow the sunnah and stay away from sin. if i do this would i be thrown into hellfire? what if i follow a sheikh but he is wrong then will i be put in hell?

[@AdamFirdaus-wm2xm]

Because how are you going to understand what the quran and sunnah tell you to do? You likely dont even know arabic so what are u gonna do? Read a translation? Would u trust the translation more or scholars who have chains of narrations to the prophet? Yes they sometimes make mistakes but thats why there are other scholars to correct each other

[@AdamFirdaus-wm2xm]

To put it very easily

[@AdamFirdaus-wm2xm]

If you follow a sheikh you trust not because you follow ur desires and you follow his mistake you are not blamed

[@adiletaitzhan]

​@@AdamFirdaus-wm2xmwhat if the sheikh or madhab opinion clearly contradicts the sunnah? You are going to follow then too?

[@Ahmad-no1wy]

@@adiletaitzhanno obviously you are not meant to follow contradictions to the sunnah brother, that may be the case with many of the people but we can’t throw away the madhabs just because of ignorant followers of them

[@anbarnasimbihon1126]

Why dont he answear straight forward?

[@Justalayman]

How much more comprehensive can he get? He explains to the last detail Allah’humma barik lahu

[@aron2015]

Because you will ask more questions.

[@anbarnasimbihon1126]

@@Justalayman No. He mostly speaks unnessary and out of topic.

[@maazmustafa2322]

you can search up his other vids where he's answered the same qs many times. Hence why he said in the beginning it's a frequently asked qs. Those other ans are more straightforward. This was more detailed

[@razamughal4582]

he has poor speaking skills