Why I hate Alicorn OCs

[@sockietockie]

Anyone noticed that the Mary sue has her wings on her butt?

[@everquartz]

yeah i did XDD

[@tjordan4576]

Same XD

[@cherrydelicious493]

Awsome!!!!!

[@kreonomy]

Her mind is also on her butt

[@Laythegiggler]

Yes

[@piglungz3166]

when I make ocs, I usually design them first and then create a backstory around the design

[@queerheere9285]

Lizz T. I usually just draw them and design their backstory around their personality and cutie mark.

[@simo-tn9mj]

Lizz T. same

[@milo-kr4pz]

Lizz T. same

[@randomlily9193]

Lizz T. Hah same

[@iworkout7961]

Lizz T. Me too and I made an alicorn oc I am a bad person

[@YukamiEsrovane]

Btw, and antagonist is not always a villian. It's a person who challenges the protagonist.

[@tjordan4576]

YukamiEsrovane true.... Very true

[@nikkinoivern4392]

YukamiEsrovane like a rival

[@Fzy-j]

YukamiEsrovane prime example: Invader Zim Or any story that focuses the narrative of a villian or an anti-hero

[@Louise1025_LimbusCompany]

Me:same goes to you my friend.......no offense 😇 Lunar messorem:😒

[@sporkcutletbowl1565]

Same!! say that to everyone!

[@crayzkit1290]

She...she... SHE INSULTED THE HAT!!!!!

[@catty6151]

Kill it

[@cassiephillips9487]

Blasphemy!! How dare she?!

[@the_plushie_doctor]

I like the hat

[@deltastar4147]

I enjoy your rants because it makes me improve my own oc and it also makes me improve my own write

[@mingjia]

Dude, dats just sad

[@deltastar4147]

Ming Jia I know

[@will_bruh]

how is it sad? i watch rant videos for the same reason? its getting all the help and ideas that you can

[@ShelynXJ]

Yea but u should feel good about urself and ur oc without having to watch rants

[@malia6957]

Blue Crystal well but your OC might suck. I've had an absolutely awful generic alicorn OC. But now I have a much better OC!

[@meganinten0078]

Ah memories... The birth of Maddie's "friend", Mary Sue.

[@ultraviol7nce]

My name is Maddie 😢

[@christinecho2626]

Mary sue is more of a antagonist.

[@arthas640]

she did a really good valley girl accent

[@cennix]

MegaNinten 007 what does Mary sue mean?

[@WinglessCanary]

@@cennix mary sue is a character who is seemingly flawless. They have no flaws and are overpowered, and no one likes em cause others think they are overpowered and unlikely

[@Telepolee]

that "mary sue" character is exactly what ppl r like at my school...

[@sunnyy-arts]

SAME

[@deathvonk4413]

Fire Fox Blitz Ikr

[@peridot_2286]

Fire Fox Blitz YES

[@JupiterJinx]

Fire Fox Blitz same

[@perfectharmony4676]

Fire Fox Blitz yup same here

[@zimonzieclown1633]

Let me just step in and clarify something for you all: antagonist =/= villain. An antagonist is someone to oppose the protagonist or main character in a story. A villain is, to put it simply, a bad guy. Sometimes the antagonist is a villain but not always.

[@urdadsleftasshole69]

*I'M THE BAD GUY* - Dom

[@zimonzieclown1633]

'kay.

[@GLORIOUSCHONK]

amen brah. So nice to know someone know the difference.

[@lbolen4304]

sometimes the protagonist is a villain also.

[@KhanhNguyen-mh5ec]

Scratch that, most of the time.

[@jqdeiii]

Honestly I don't mind Alicorn OCs but they have to have an in-depth explaination on how their OC became an Alicorn.

[@ponyspeedgamer4357]

Spidey-Spoo mine isn't an Alicorn it's a Changeling that turns herself into an Alicorn so she can experience what she never had in the Changeling kingdom and also because she was sick of being a Pegasus and dropping everything cause of her clumsiness so she just went with that form

[@tjordan4576]

Spidey-Spoo my oc was born as an alicorn so.....?

[@PurpleSparklesHeart]

Hisui Kairee mine is basically just a unicorn who got the ability to fly from a Pegasus. It doesn’t make her any more powerful, but I feel it doesn’t work with how magic works in canon

[@Snowyoaks2]

Adults in the mlp community when a child has fun making characters:😤😡😡🤬🤬

[@Snowyoaks2]

@@RandomServitor shut up omg

[@lifeof.jariya3307]

"She saved the princesses from evil" Twilight: Excuse me!? "She's totally discord's girlfriend." Fluttershy: What!? "She's totally bestfriends with all the mane 6" Pinkie and RD: We don't know you....

[@goldenhorse4823]

Hahaha

[@thatfreackluna5013]

Hats rrihg but i have a alicorn oc and i dont act like a brat

[@somebodyidk3336]

Lilit UwU 666 same mines name is Bittersweet Melody. She loves music and the bittersweet part of her name means her life can be sweet but also bitter.

[@insertaname2485]

How can you be friends with the main six if they don't even know you

[@poweroffriendship2.0]

*Magic of Friendship:* _I don't even know who you are..._

[@potatoman-oe5jy]

I hate your alicorn oc voice. It's irritating and makes me wish I was listening to chalk on a chalkboard. It's perfect.

[@parasitophobia]

It's very perfect.

[@jhonwintan6472]

Potatoman .....

[@anniethehetalian6229]

Yes I agree.

[@frostfirephoenix1923]

Potatoman actually chalk on a chalkboard sounds like nothing it sounds like your family rubbing chalk on the sidewalk

[@Grit-n-Grace]

chalk on a chalk board bootiful

[@bethmacdd]

Kim Kardashian if she was a pony

[@Cherry-yg3gk]

Omg lol

[@ramina182]

Lol

[@marisahamel1638]

Beth Zia yeah but she's funny at least

[@cerealproductions8765]

*WHEEZE*

[@iona5917]

True!

[@bonnietelocole6777]

Listen to both their voices closely... *whispers* _u cant hide ur accent x3_

[@chischu3988]

"They are like half dairy products " XD WTF 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@luna_like_variety381]

Choco_ Chara XD

[@desireloverlee3780]

I don't know why I thought that was a funny comment sometimes I get stupid Sorry

[@desireloverlee3780]

try

[@desireloverlee3780]

I subscribe to you though

[@desireloverlee3780]

+Alany Luna sorry I just subscribe to you but never told you but now I'm telling you

[@GodGutzz]

even tho mlp is not my favorite show, i'm on your side munchkin

[@sweett7098]

Violet Grapes yea me too

[@maddypruett5631]

Violet Grapes ii

[@daybreakersadventures7808]

Green In My Tea me too

[@thelastsubwaysandwich2850]

Same

[@brisatorres3882]

Green In My Tea yeah me too

[@avatale8612]

Mary sue alicorn: im discords gurlfriend! Fluttershy: cries in a corner

[@goldenhorse4823]

Me:Cries in a corner

[@insertaname2485]

Discord: Who is this Mary sue? Me: Are you sure about that?

[@PROBLEMATIC_OPINIONS]

Ava tale me:*Viben*

[@goldenhorse4823]

@@Deathanilerhellsking I am all down for it

[@jtbros5804]

Guys I know the ship is loved but let's be honest it's just a pony

[@ediegray8798]

This video should be named, "why I hate Mary Sue characters" rather than why I hate alicorns. I have seen well thought out alicorn ocs, who don't have a drawing attached, and I have seen unicorns that are super op, and were based entirely on the design. Saying that, I agree with your argument, it just spreads to more than just alicorns. (Btw my oc is an earth pony so I'm not defending my own)

[@mothman7126]

I have an alicorn oc and she is not even close to perfect. Her biggest flaw is self acceptance and she has been trapped in situations where she has to think about and accept who she is. She can in fact be defeated, yes, she is powerful, but come on. Not op powerful.

[@endieisded]

someone I chat with sometimes, has an Oc who is a non magical pony, as in they aren't even an earth pony. they have 0 powers, but then... you find out. they invented Wings, a death ray, the tardris, rocket boots, he is immune to magic, and punches and kicks, yet he has weak bones. He is a Royal Inventer, A royal guard, a scientist, and a teacher. And that's before he downgraded the Garysue-ness! He just ignores any and all constructive criticism I give him. (-_-" )

[@thatguythatstoleyourlunch3189]

+gameplaywithgreywolf my oc is a alicorn and he is powerful but his biggest flaw is not having any confidence at all

[@Lovetigersnake11]

When people try to justify their alicorn character by making simple flaws that they could have put into a normal pony.

[@hopelessly.lavenderly]

+Lovetigersnake11 True.

[@blukat232]

I still don't like the idea of alicorn OCs but back in the 6th grade I despised them. I use to have a friend where her OC was an alicorn so I said "how did she become an alicorn?" She said that Celestia used her magic to give her infinite wings. Needless to say we were arguing with the logic.

[@tjordan4576]

Why didn't she just make her oc born as an alicorn? Would've made more sense.

[@SteampunkHorse]

BluKat WHAT. **pause** WHAT THE FU - No offence but WHAT THE FU

[@cardboardshelf7800]

I'm not even part of this fandom I'm just here to see people talk about cringy subjects like OC's but even to me that sounds like a really dumb and boring reason

[@emmaloctober6001]

Wow, even my sixth grade alicorn OC has a better explanation: Nationwide conflicts occurred in Equestria against villains while she was just a filly, and she worked under the radar to cause a series of events that would topple the enemy. Her plans go perfectly, but she utterly fails in the end, but the events opened up multiple opportunities for Equestria’s forces and she was rescued in the nick of time to see that her actions saved at least 100 civilians in both Ponyville and Canterlot. She and her friends who had helped her were respected for their contributions and were allowed to participate in major acts against the enemy She didn’t become an alicorn after that, but as she grew up she rose through the ranks of authority, and became an alicorn princess after leading an extreme victory against an opposing army, while exhibiting pretty honorable acts. It’s not that much on its own but she’d taken part in countless important events so that victory was the act to make the princess thing happen. She gladly accepted, since she dreamed of being a princess since she was a filly

[@destiny_rosscutie918]

.

[@TheTiredCreator]

My sister said her oc is a Alicorn because she is the princess of "Heartbreaking" :^

[@sausagelessgumbog2b447]

And she'll kill you with the power of the friendzone

[@neonnyx]

@@sausagelessgumbog2b447 OH NO NOT THE POWER OF FRIENDZONE! AHHHHHHHHHHHHH

[@Lana-ne8bd]

@@sausagelessgumbog2b447 even worse... the *_sibling zone_*

[@sausagelessgumbog2b447]

@@Lana-ne8bd nonono...wait...daughter zone. Bonus points if it has an allicorn mother

[@YurieSnowie]

That sounds, really edgy, jeez

[@trixastudios1640]

IM IRISH AND PEOPLE ALWAYS ASK IF IM SCOTTISH!!! 😵😵😂

[@tickingtoon9555]

Trixa Studios SAME OMG

[@sannamartin6439]

Trixa Studios SAMEEEE

[@gourmetcheesepizza9006]

Want am I.

[@r3n_hana]

Trixa Studios I’m German and everyone asks me if I’m a na- you know what nvm i forgot kids

[@thenewhwanttohackhack6896]

Same!

[@aku_abel]

Me: MARY SUE MARY SUE MARY SUE My friends: That’s not a Mary Sue she’s just better than any other oc and she can do anything Me: *thats a Mary Sue*

[@jaune6342]

Twemmie The tem Though Mary Sues are not that bad though.. -3-

[@zapcraftihoof8318]

*Mad Munchkin: if everyone is super, no 1 will be* YOU STOLE THAT FEOM INCREDIBLES AND I LOVE THAT REFERENCE

[@potnoodlez4029]

In a way I can relate to this, But if it is like a kid creating a My Little Pony oc, then I would just let them be kids. As a child you just want to make your own character, it's nothing serious to them, but usually they get called on for having a 'bad' oc. I'm not saying that you do call on people with 'bad' alicorn oc's but I just wanted people to know that their is a difference between having a cringey mary sue oc and an oc that a child has made just to express their imagination. No hate! Good reasons, but I just wanted to address it.

[@tjordan4576]

Pot Noodlez I'm a kid and I came up with my own alicorn oc that was born as an alicorn, is really edgy, is kinda invincible but if her horn gets wet she can't use her magic. And I didn't just 'recolor' her, I actually drew her and took my precious time to come up with a back story for her. She is very shy and doesn't show a lot emotion, she cuts herself when she gets really stressed. (She can heal herself tho) She also has the ability to bring people back to life. But as a Christian, I don't even understand how that would work. :/ (BTW I ship her with sans; very important information) And recently I came up with a name for her, (not sure if it's a good one for her but I tried.) April.... Her name is April.

[@星昼-s3c]

I mean everything about them is fine as long as they don’t act edgy and “kill” people or just basically draws 18+ stuff--Just the family friendly ones that’s obviously made by actual kids don’t bother me unless they are just somehow annoying,like maybe you’re just trying to help them writing their oc and all of a sudden they go “MY OC IS WAY BETTER THAN YOURS!!” Like what you haven’t even seen mine yet and even if you did OF COURSE YOURS IS BETTER IT’S FLIPPING OVERPOWERED AND MINE IS JUST A FLIPPING HUMAN-- Basically something like that,because it doesn’t matter if you’re kids if you act like that maaaayyyyyyybe you’re a little tinitiny bit spoooooiiiiiiiillllllllled.....(Or maybe you didn’t get the chocolate you wanted and you’re just mad)

[@PurpleSparklesHeart]

Pot Noodlez When I was 14, I came up with an OC named Harmony. As bad is it is, she’s based on me, but I came up with a different backstory for her. She was a unicorn who later became an Alicorn because she had a friend who was a Pegasus and they fused their abilities. There was also a thing where the affects of poison joke gave her wings due to Harmony already having the magic to become an Alicorn. I based Harmony off of myself so she is really shy and constantly stressed, but she is a huge nerd. She lives with a few other ponies in Ponytown (no canon characters, just OCs) and although I haven’t done her full backstory, I’ve done some small bits and pieces (such as how she met her friends and the Pegasus friend she became an Alicorn because of, the way she got her cutie mark, etc)

[@samsonsongcat]

0:45 Mary sue alicorn oc: and im Discord's Girlfriend, Me: NO. YOUR NOT.

[@alexs.2731]

Even the show says otherwise

[@MadMunchkin]

Hi everyone. This video is over 8years old now, and I did not expect this of all videos to be my most popular video. I do want to point out that a lot can change in 8 years and the audience this video was aimed for were adults who were fans of MLP and how so many fans made alicorn OCs without putting any thought into them. It is NOT aimed at children.

[@nickiverkade8083]

Mad Munchkin I will try to remember the rules😜

[@unknownlizy7491]

Mad Munchkin I hate alicrons

[@kemmaxd]

Mad Munchkin Not every alicorn OC is bad. Some people can make a good alicorn OC.

[@thatoneannoyingdude3825]

I think I need to improve my oc. She's not that interesting but here we go... She's an evil minion (from Despicable Me 2) earth pony. She was (or probably still is) a villain. She hated the mane six because they are loved by almost everyone so one day she decides to defeat them or something. How much improving does she needs? Sorry I'm replying to a month old comment lol.

[@thatoneannoyingdude3825]

And I just want to describe how she looks, she has a dark purple curly/messy mane and tail. She has a light purple coat/skin. She has dark purple eyes and minion goggles. She also has a banana for a cutie mark.

[@rswsaw1]

IM IRISH

[@sugarbuniii]

Stephanie Williams I'm full irish

[@cold_fl0wers]

I'm Irish too!!!

[@hannaha810]

*me too*

[@kaylynntoya900]

Stephanie Williams me too only part though

[@bluetheperson]

Stephanie Williams SAME!!!! XD

[@pidondeyle3630]

THE MARY SUE'S HAIR LOOKS LIKE TOOTHPASTE

[@adeadaccount546]

Probably is.

[@TheTopJimmie]

+Kaden Stowers I love your Undertale icon :D

[@marionick7244]

._.

[@pidondeyle3630]

;3

[@TheTopJimmie]

:3

[@FloofBoop]

She lost me at being Discord’s girlfriend. FANGIRL

[@atomicrose239]

Who What When Where Why How That's how I learned it. :P

[@lianabustard3001]

WWWWWH

[@slebster69]

Same

[@carson4053]

Atomic Rose UnSATiSfYinG

[@happykitty1238]

I learned it like this 🎶 Who, what, when, where and why? 🎶 There was no how in the version I learned.

[@TarigonTetradactyl]

Atomic Rose hahahahhahahahahahhahahahahahahha

[@cerutheghost2619]

Hate is a strong word but... The right word

[@cardboardshelf7800]

Using this

[@stevetate9351]

Ok

[@BlorbHunter]

I made an alicorn OC... Just as an experiment really. It was supposed to be an earth pony that lived by the sea and basically helped organise the sea ponies (I designed my own versions of them... ponies that are literally made of water) and in doing so became an alicorn that ruled the oceans of equestria. I dunno, I planned a comic but I never finished it.

[@BlorbHunter]

I am aware, I just don't like those design so I tried something else.

[@whosacatimacat1670]

kyuubifox1994 Cool I also made an alicorn princess from another kingdom in the ocean

[@highfivepaw]

I love looking back at these videos because it shows how much internet culture has changed, we used to hate these kinds of ocs and now we embrace them with a passion

[@headphonecadaver5321]

I sort of draw my characters before giving them a backstory or name unless I have an idea...

Same, for some reason I can't do it at the inverse way. Maybe I'm too superficial xD

[@headphonecadaver5321]

Or when you get an idea and try to draw it but it doesn't come out like how you planned it so it becomes something else

[@buzzminter6096]

headphonecadaver same I normally just make a random oc then start the back story and name

[@headphonecadaver5321]

I don't really like making ocs because I don't like putting a character into a series that I didn't work on. Buts it's cool that you make then.

[@shadowstarmlp-daghterofkin135]

same cuz looks is what gives u the idea of what the backstory is or their name or cutie mark!!!

[@dontmesswithmeimabigboinow6321]

"o wow, Scotland apart of England, right" me: **facepalms**

[@deltathecomic4765]

The furious bagpipe music is one of the reasons I subscribed to this channel. XD I love you Mad Munchkin. EDIT: "Scotland's a part of England, right?" Me: **Inhale** .......no. No it is not.

[@astrovalleyzone7140]

Looking back on these types of videos, I realize that these ocs belong to mostly children who wanted to have a lot of fun with their characters. Remember, as long as you don’t harass anyone or hurt anyone else for their art or ocs keep doing what you’re doing. Cringe is dead. Life’s too short to care if your video game/ tv show oc is bad. :)

[@SakuWasHereFirst]

Hey how can mary sue be celestia and lunas niece if they only have 2 sisters Edit: OOF I just noticed how many likes I've got here and I was noticed wth?! Thank you!!

[@MadMunchkin]

Ask Prince Blue Blood, maybe he knows.

[@shaelynbarnezangel8956]

+Mad Munchkin why u say that I made an allicorn oc :(

[@rainbowgem2911]

im a pegasus but i can have the power of an alicorn when im angry i was also raised by luna

[@kackaberkova3829]

mary sue alert ! Being related to royality in show and hav alicorn powers is just lazy ..

[@tibblesyorkie789]

Well blue blood is apparently celestias nephew so idk

[@aladdinscarpetcarper5215]

You've helped so much!!

[@blackkittyfreak]

You totally should have used a Pony Generator model for Mary Sue. That would have definitely hammered the point home. I think the fact that the alicorn OC was drawn by you might give it more legitimacy than it necessarily has. Plus it would have been hilarious!

[@internet7605]

Hah yeah!

[@MadMunchkin]

+blackkittyfreak ...I did. That was the irony. Haha.

[@blackkittyfreak]

+Mad Munchkin Yeah, I saw that it was based on Pony Creator, but it was still your art. I'm saying I think it would have been better with an image straight from the Creator, because of the stark contrast in art styles.

[@samreengharu480]

+Mad Munchkin I like your oc. my own oc is not as good

[@collinbarnhill4823]

+Samreen Gharu do you even have a oc?

[@thehipstertwins]

"An obsession with discord" ........ Literally me 😁😁😁

[@finnd9580]

the hipster twins and kp and lightning bliss

[@Sammy_The_Umbreon]

The app discord? Because then it's relatable

[@loonaLoonie]

the hipster twins Legit me aswell 😂

[@jimmythecat763]

I use discord to cha-oh we're talking about mlp

[@Jinx_you_lose]

@@aiglentinaa KP will disagree with you but like what you like.

[@aquagalaxy1948]

The annoying pink alicorn pony backstory should be she begs celestia so much she made her into an alicorn Princess. She goes around showing off so much that people throw her off a cliff.

[@mr.outlaw231]

No...not how that ends....First stabbed, burned, slapped, frozen, then defrosted to be burned again, whipped, questioned on how can she be that stupid, break her wings, and THEN throw her off a cliff. Gosh, I wouldn't say that if her voice wasn't so annoying, she wasn't so mean to her, and she had a story that may or may not have been developed with the help of several people....like if you introduce your OC through an rp, techincally, if not overpowered, you could use that as an origin story.

[@MadMunchkin]

Yes, throw the WINGED creature off a cliff, that won't fail miserably at all. lol x

[@aquagalaxy1948]

Yeah cut her wings off first.

[@shyanblood2012]

Eliza Nelson lol

[@shyanblood2012]

Eliza Nelson lol

[@E-Washer]

My OC is an alicorn, but she is mostly imperfections, does that make my OC a Mary Sue or not a Mary Sue?

[@E-Washer]

Don't listen to past me, I have recently scrapped my entire OC and am starting from scratch 🤗

[@helixtherobotdinosanswifea1295]

If it's full of impurities, it's called an Anti-sue

[@nonbineyspoonie]

Depends. If the Imperfections make your whole character, then she is a MAry Sue. If they shape but do not define her and lead to her development, then she is not. Helpful tip: Mary Sue's tend to be stagnant. If your character has a *ahem* well-developed development arc, then they are probably not a MAry SUe

[@KitKat-sv9qp]

Baby Bunnyquake A mary sue is when the plot gravitates toward the character to the point that everything is *only* around them. If it has good story and competent secondary characters, then the main character is poorly written, *not* a mary sue.

[@alnoa2499]

Baby Bunnyquake ya well past u is still right. Doesn't matter if ur character is a mary sue. Dont change her for the likes of others. They think mary sues r like the end of the world but really almost everything a watch (anime,cartoons,tv shows) has a mary sue so why r ppl attacking other not famous ppl for making a mary sue??

[@AR8c]

mmm, does this mean one of my ocs are bad? because I didn't make up the ocs name quite yet, but I got the backstory and look down, she looks like an alicorn, but there's many unique features, like her wings are butterfly's wings. and a broken horn, plus her backstory might be pretty interesting. idk maybe not. here it is: she was actually born an earth pony, but she studied spells she can do without a horn, and she did a spell where she can get a horn, she did it and it succeeded, she didn't know that her horn was more fragile then a normal horn since it was created with a spell, basically adding a body part, not fully possible without something bad in return, then, she did the same spell twilight sparkles did to rarity, but the spell was to powerful for her, so her horn broke, and her butterfly wings became perminate, and the only way to turn her back to her previous state is for someone else to use a spell to turn her back into an earth pony, the problem is, she doesn't trust anyone, because shes worried they would make her even worse then she already is. I'm mostly worried that her design might make people say she's an alicorn.

[@iclynnx]

Your OC is quite good actually! I like it

[@cheydraws6411]

That is actually pretty good

[@felixwinter6176]

Your oc is a perfect example of having a character that looks different for a reason, if people call your character a mary-sue they are probably over reacting or didn't listen to her backstory, I think your character sounds interesting and she has a few flaws even pointed out by her backstory, of course there are things that could change and a character is never perfect, but I think she sounds dimensional and like an actual person, not a perfect godlike being.

[@yulyalonso7895]

Try the spell was to powerful for her horn. Instead of for her. That makes it a little more less to confuse. I kindo got confused because if she can make a fake horn with a broke horn then she's more powerful than Twilight. So I thought that you were saying she was weak but before she was powerful? But I get it now. Just some advice.

[@aspen8609]

I like the idea of a horn made by magic being fragile and the idea of a idea of a Earth pony having magic. As a pullback to a Earth pony with magic you could put that her magic is weaker and that could be a struggle for her character. But the butterfly wings could be scraped : )

[@Thebeetlemangr]

Fun fact: my character was a mistake, I just made a pigeon that used to come to my balcony as a human and I just LOVED the way she looked...

[@taterhoot5627]

Mine is technically an alicorn.... but her horn’s broken....so...is she still an alicorn?

[@kizannaisalwaysmisundersto397]

TaterhooT yeah

[@juanokug4]

Kinda? I'm not sure, I don't watch mlp

[@miranduhrudeguez6085]

Yeah. But that is a cool concept.

[@Lady-parfait]

TaterhooT I had always wanted to do A Alicorn that has broken wings

[@colaandchill9047]

Nope she's a brokecorn

[@hailliesanimations7688]

Merry sue: Scotland is a part of England right? Me:oh no what have you done... *war crys in the background*

[@cherrydelicious493]

butt wings? AWSOME!!!

[@haisesasagay375]

cherry delicious XD

[@nikkinoivern4392]

Alicorn OC's are just, kinda stupid, because Alicorns have a very special role, and most people make their OC and Alicorn because it looks good and powerful, and more better than any other.

[@iclynnx]

I only made two alicorn OCs because back in the days I thought alicorns could be born normally, and I was a Luna x Sombra fan so I made my OCs their daughters... But not because they are powerful. I just like the way alicorns look. And I love both flying and magic 0_0

[@iclynnx]

But those OCs were quite bad lol. It's just Celestia and Luna all over again. But this time "Luna" doesn't get banished. I think I'll create a new OC xD

[@cardboardshelf7800]

So basically when dbz fans make there oc turn ssj3 at the age of 13 or undertale OC's having every single type of soul to ever fucking exist like derp cringe and swag

[@fin7161]

That doesn’t mean that they can’t make good ay for the character or good characters in general

[@poppysworldofillusion49]

here's where you're wrong. my OC is an Alicorn because as a pony I would want wings, but I would want to use magic too! so I made it an Alicorn!

[@DakotaandKota]

This is perfect. But what would have made it better, is if the character was black and red and had a name that contained 'blood' 'death' or 'devil'. (Bonus points if the character has a dead family and has killed others)

[@CuteieMonster]

Uhh....?

[@DakotaandKota]

+Lolitaholic topkek

[@ellynoir9378]

+DakotaandKota She already made a video c:

[@parachutes_party]

+Lolitaholic I'm going to assume you're joking for the sake of laughing.

[@ellynoir9378]

I AM BLACK DEATH WING AND IM AN ALICORN MY PARENTS DID WHEN I WAS 1 AND I HAD TO FEND FOR MYSELF

[@thesmolswefur1357]

But my oc is a pegasi...

[@ickyzikki266]

SmolDutchieArtZ that's fine! And alicorn OCS are fine too! As long as they have a good reason or tie to being whatever are!

[@maomunii]

SmolDutchieArtZ That’s completely different from an alicorn and that’s ok! An alicorn has both wings and a horn and are extremely powerful. While a pegasi just has wings,no horn. And a unicorn (well,that’s obvious.)

[@moved3887]

SmolDutchieArtZ Mine is a ground pony cause yes

[@suisidemission4883]

Actually it’s a Pegasus unless she’s multiple pony’s.

[@Rhianalanthula]

Mine too

[@pastelcoke]

I'm not a MLP fan, or in the fandom, but your videos make some pretty good points that I agree with.

[@fizzipawp_z]

Cringe culture is dead so I made an earth pony princess named Heartshot. She *does* happen to be a princess but not by traditional means. She was adopted by the 2 kings of a far-off land who saw her potential as a filly. Yes, I said 2 kings, because we need more gays in MLP. Anyways, she has anxiety and her Cutie Mark is a heart with a teal arrow shot through it. She doesn't get much screen time, as the kingdom only shows up in a few episodes, but I thought it would be a fun concept.

[@owowhatsbliss]

I agree totally, coming back to this video years later when I've adopted a "cringe culture is dead and do whatever you want as long as it's not harmful" mindset is really weird. I love your OC :) do whatever you want forever

[@gobsmr]

Heartshot sounds so cute omg! I love the ideas of non alicorn princesses

[@VictoriaC04]

My oc is an Pegasus,I'm ok with alicorn ocs if they aren't Mary Sues No one is perfect,

[@aislynlastname6975]

Karen Chow Yup same :3

[@miranda4392]

same.

[@shadowstarmlp-daghterofkin135]

I agree plus my oc is an alicorn

[@nojaybay]

Karen Chow My alicorn OC isn't a Mary Sue, she isn't perfect at all. And there's a pretty good back story. All things unlike the normal alicorn OC. I mean, the design even isn't fancy, it looks normal, no dresses, no fancy curls, no fancy shoes, she's just normal. With a normal horn and normal alicorn wings. I don't know where I was going with this.

[@spicymcnuggets851]

I used to have alicorn OC but I changed it to a pegasus

[@jigzigsaw]

i used to watch this 24/7 as a chronically online 9 year old like i’m actually so happy i found this again

[@mortis5651]

I’m making an alicorn out of spite

[@rb.v]

You got this Mortis

[@gobsmr]

update?

[@Furiitha096]

Yes go!!

[@Laurax16]

As you should!

[@MadameSpoopy]

Coming back as an adult to thank you for all the comedy and entertainment you brought to my life when I was going through hard times. So happy I found your channel again.❤

[@MadMunchkin]

Glad to have you back. :) Thanks for the support.

[@lyladuncan8014]

Alcorn: Irish You: SCOTTISH!!!!! Alicorn: What ever I can't spell ;-; Edit: 8 likes thx :3 xd and I have 1 allicorn OC but don't worry it's not a marry sue, I made sure not to make it one.

[@tooneychaos4526]

When I was a kid I drew myself as an alicorn not because I wanted to be a self-insert all-powerful princess but solely because I thought having both a horn and wings was the coolest thing ever. Now I just draw mlp fanart; no OCs/self-inserts lol

[@mazeytrinca9675]

I make a back story and then design her......I have an Alicorn oc but I made her back story first before I drew her.....but I totally agree with u!!!!

[@marspikachu5554]

It’s just that alicorns are too basic and OCs are usually like “PRINCESS” or “BETTER THAN YOU AND CANT BE BEATEN” like hey said a Mary Sue. Maybe you have a back story but just because you have one doesn’t mean it won’t be ruined by all of the “too powerful for you” typical alicorn :/

[@drvgsndior]

Mazey Trinca same and agreed

[@cathygao1216]

It’s okay if your alicorn is not over-powered, or is seen better than everybody else. It’s just overused with the same boring personality, snobby, way too nice for someone to be human/a pony, or just some sort of princess.

[@mel8577]

Mars Pikachu there can be well tought out alicorn ocs look at lighting bliss she,s an alicorn AMD NOT A MARY SUE!

[@mel8577]

Haji Para the same things with you they can have FAULTS NOT PERFECT

[@sludgemuffin2447]

To be honest I think you can make the aesthetic first and then have that inspire the backstory. That might not be the way professionals in the design industry go, but it’s another technique, and a lot of people making OCs do it just for fun anyway. In which case the backstory doesn’t have to matter.

[@ItsMinnowSeason]

yea, i make random designs and legit just instantly tie it all to a specific backstory on the spot- either its simple or complex, depends on the feel of the character it just depends on how someone goes abt it ig

[@therobotfromirobot]

you have the most adorable accent! ^-^

[@therobotfromirobot]

and thank god I have a pegasus oc

[@chatnoir313]

Paigee World Trashbag YESSSS

[@fluffymint2941]

yes ♥♥♥

[@theblueone6848]

Why can't I have been born a few hundred miles up the country to have that cute accent :(

[@leoanddallydidntdieforthis3114]

Ok I honestly love your voice it's honestly amazing to listen to

[@emilydoj7079]

Your profile pic is so awesome

[@swerveattack8987]

I have an Alicorn OC but it's not Mary Sue i remove some traits from it to make it not Mary Sue I'm just worried people will judge My OC

[@user-mz2pm3ym7z]

Or you can give it some flaws.

[@ten-fandoms-in-a-trenchcoat]

I hear you sister. If you want it to represent you, just make it act and think just like you. Even if everyone thinks its May Sue-ish.

[@alnoa2499]

swerve attack don't worry about others. If it's supposed to be a mary sue then go ahead but if not then u should still make ur oc the way u want it to be. Unless ur oc represents u then u do self research. Ppl r assholes. Dont look too deep into them

[@everquartz]

dont worry i have alicorn ocs and there arent mary sues

[@korvo3427]

Kate The Werewolf Or remove it's wings or horn or both.

[@artisannoteworthy]

I do have one question. How the hell is Mary's wing attached to her body under/THROUGH her cape?!

[@樱符さくらか]

my first oc poneh was a alicorn , but that was 4 years ago *-;

[@cupoftea3499]

Sakura Kittylite 41 my first oc was a unicorn, the reason why is because I do not like heights (pegasus) or getting my hands dirty (earth pony). I just found being a unicorn was the best one, especially for holding things.

[@PrincessDarknight]

Although I have an Alicorn OC, I do not brag about her. I treat her like she's another pony, and I really dislike those who overpower their OC. That is all

[@shadow_ninja-jq7ht]

Same here I do the same thing :3

[@starvoltnexus3139]

PrincessDarknight I don't see the problem as long as they're not....00:33-00:55 (BARFS) I mean make it believable and not over powered

[@icywolf1761]

PrincessDarknight You are everywhere On Sky's video and every body elses videos I watch man we gotta stop bumping into each other

[@goldenarrow3498]

I agree.One of my OCs (yes I have two,don't judge)is a alicorn, but she has more flaws then good things! She hates spotlight spakle (that's what me and my friends call purple book pony lol) she's very bossy,klutzy,and swears a lot

[@goldenarrow3498]

My other OC is a dark Pegasus named nights wind.She is my profile picture.

[@inacatt]

I love how half the comments start with "My OC's an Alicorn, let me tell you what makes him/her different from others and why it's okay for my OC to be an Alicorn!"

[@inacatt]

***** I mean, yeah, I have created OCs that are alicorns, but that is only because I have created a separate universe therefore an entirely different cannon from that of the true MLP cannon.

[@inacatt]

***** No prob. You know, too many people I think ship just for the sake of it sometimes...

[@pinkmpheles108]

lol, same 😂

[@spikemarns]

+Salenia Cook (Moon Wolf) EVERY single comment XD My OC is a pegasus. What happened to ordinary pony OCs o3o

[@inacatt]

Fluttershy Gaming​ I think if I had an OC it would be a unicorn or a talking winged wolf (like my profile pic).

[@kittyyoutuber9]

my pony oc midlight colors: body: midnight blue. mane and tail: cyan fade color: white others: has wings backstory midlight gone to a unicorn school ponies made fun of her for not having a horn one day she went to the place and asked the princesses for a horn but they said she doesn't need one to be special so she is very proud to be a flying pony. sometimes she helps out the cmc. she also lives in cloud city

[@Caz_Hamilton]

That's a little bit of a Mary sue as the only flaw of the character is that she does not have a horn. Maybe make her a little less I NEED I HORN TO BE SPECIAL!!! or if you really want the she needs a horn bit to fit, maybe set it in Alicornia (the land off of Equestria where all alicorn live) (not canon) because in my story in Alicornia all ponies start out as unicorns and turn into alicorns when they get a tital. Like my OC Rainbowmoon, she had the job to raise the rainbow moon at the monthly rainbow moon festival

[@ugbuktheslayer5091]

@@Caz_Hamilton can you help me out on how to create Emperor Palpatine as a pony?

[@kaitlyncominsky4887]

Kind of predicted the new my little pony movie 😂

[@kaitlyncominsky4887]

Also I'm saying that because everyone treated each other differently over wings and horns

[@prim_pyrenees5128]

I have a unicorn oc who survived a war but lost her magic to live. She the made mechanical wings when everyone made fun of her. Her wings soon stoped working and she was unable to rebuild them. One day her magic sparked back and she fixed her wings. Then her horn fell off. Does that count as a Mary Sue or an alicorn oc? What could I name her?

[@daltonbooth5911]

lucky rocky_ivy You could call her something mechanical? Gizmo? Gadget? Widget? Gidget?

[@prim_pyrenees5128]

Cassidilillah Oaks thanks =3

[@humgoose5680]

Adrazelle?

[@gfrazier3601]

Lucky_Rocky Ivy honestly I live the idea

[@xisunxisun4176]

Lucky_Rocky Ivy her horn fell off?

[@kasugaryuichi9767]

My alicorn OC's reason for existing: I like flying and I like magic.

[@hummingbrdjuice]

2:05 I'm laughing so hard I think I'm going to cry XD

[@texantourguide]

no hate to anyone who agrees with the general argument of the joke being made in the video but most people who are or were in this fandom are/ joined as kids and make/stick to alicorn OCs because it's hard to choose a favorite type of pony and there's a ton of creative freedom and interesting possible backstories that can be made with them. I've seen some alicorns that were dogsh* in power levels and come from alicorn civilizations far from equestria or before the current time thousands of moons ago and would HC that's where celestia and luna are from. It's just not cool to come into a kid's community and start bashing kids for being kids.

[@lunamoon8711]

Honestly these videos are the reason why I’m so proud of my OC now. I’ve fleshed her out her colors represent me and her you just helped me so much. XD

[@PrincessPie]

i have an alicorn OC but i didnt really care how she looked and mine isnt perfect......and i did call her Princess Pie and I got inspired by Pinkie Pie......CRAP IM I A MARY SUE?

[@PrincessPie]

well atleast i didnt call her Princess Pinkie pie..........

[@blue_moon9312]

how I make OC'S 1.I draw the character 2.I pick the name 3.I create the backstory

[@blue_moon9312]

+arcticwolf515 yea like I get inspired by what kind of situation I am in as well. is it is kinda hard but also kind of easy

[@karlthekid4831]

You should retitle it: How EVERYONE makes OCs.

[@kirstyyyyy]

Same here actually!

[@Starcantdraw]

Pretty much same for me I went a while without an OC because the one I had before was crap Until one day I decided to make an OC I started by drawing a pony then searched a lot of OCs for hair style ideas and then colored and stuff then gave her a name. Then I have changed her design as I went on, slightly changing her colors and eventually changing part of her name Aaaand she's my main OC I still needa work on her backstory doe

[@mythiethereviewer2608]

I started with a snow queen similar to elsa, and ended up with a pony colored like dawn who helps bullied ponies. Celestia works in mysterious ways.

[@localinconvenience]

"Oh Scotland is a part of England right?" *TriGGerED*

[@aceeaster7732]

My oc name is Moonstar Sky, she is in fact a alicorn, but I made her as Luna's reincarnation. Her back story is that she was actually a Pegasus, and she became an alicorn when she flew so high, she was in space, she loved it, but she couldn't breath, so she got a sphere-like object, placed it on her head and went back to space. While she was flying around she saw a bright sphere, and wanted to share it with the world, so she gathered all her strength and flew as hard as she could, lifting it. As she did so, the moon rose, and the space and appeared over the pony's. Moonstar loved how everyone looked so peaceful while sleeping, and decided, she will bring this beautiful "night" evey night, and therefore got her cutie mark and stayed with her sister in their home raising the moon and the sun as alicorns. Her sister is also an Alicorn, but thats a diffrent story. Anyway, She is 27 has a dark purple and blue mane, and does not think highly of herself as allpowerful and what not. She is a protagonist. And like I said, when she was younger,about sixteen, she was a Pegasus. Do you still think this is a bad oc? Im not saying that in a sassy tone, BTW, I am a patato. I'm just asking if I should change it.

[@FiveFoxesInATrenchcoat]

Ms. Drawings There's not really any flaws to the character. Maybe she's so humble to the point of devaluing herself and puts everyone before her regardless of the situation.

[@LYNN3Y_]

No

[@tjordan4576]

Great oc! My oc is nothing speacil but she can turn into this huge fire pony thing I don't know how you picture it in your head but it's kinda like how Naruto and the nine tail beast thing (I don't know much about Naruto) but she actually turns into it... Or you know how that blue smoke thingy that Luna made to give her bad dreams when it looked like a huge pony. Just think of that but fire. XD

[@SteampunkHorse]

Ms. Drawings While your OC certainly sounds interesting, you may get called out on it..

[@星昼-s3c]

I think it’s totally fine--She have a reason she’s powerful,she have a full backstory that makes sense,and she’s not like “THE MOST POWERFUL PONY EVER IN THE WHOLE UNIVERSE”,she’s just powerful and that’s all.

[@garbagegremlins4707]

I still come back to watch this 8 years later

[@weeper-san4363]

my pony doesn't even know the main six.

[@weeper-san4363]

or discord.

[@finnamoroll]

“i hate fun i hate fun”

[@jojo-xk8ri]

"Okay... stop scrolling down to the comme-" HOW DID YOU KNOW?!

[@vasilisasolovyeva8454]

oh my god finally! thank you for making this video because every oc i now come by is exactly like that alacorn! ( btw i have been changing the appearance of my character for 1 year now so she could match her personality with i actually thought about and planed also for a year) so i completely agree with your opinion. =D

[@wesleyaustin2670]

Alicorns are the reason why I tell people Earth Pony, Unicorn, or Pegasus when people ask for an oc.

[@MadMunchkin]

what about donkeys, dragons, griffins, ect?

[@wesleyaustin2670]

I do draw gryphons, donkeys, and others but most ask for ponies for the cutie mark, love you art style.

[@wesleyaustin2670]

Did you not read "and others". Zebras are includes in it.

[@bemotu8783]

Ya know what i hate more than alicorns ?

[@BronyTimeProductions]

Same, or gryphon, or just make your own race.

[@SEE.YA.]

Look. I know this is from 8 years ago, but let kids be kids.

[@MadMunchkin]

who said this was meant for kids?

[@ArFrOfficial]

@@MadMunchkin cap 🧢

[@ArFrOfficial]

@@MadMunchkin cap 🧢

[@darkdevil9832]

I somehow have an idea for an alicorn oc who is not able to use her magic and wings and that makes her a victim for bullies. It's not known why she was born like that so not even Celestia can solve her problem. Does that make sense?

[@Rae0814]

I’m perfectly fine with creating Ocs with strong Abilities, but please give them weaknesses. I’m fine with Alicorn Ocs, but give them explanations as to how they became one. Twilight is a decent example, being strong, but with flaws. She practiced Magic ever since she was young and became as strong as we know her as. She helped create a new type of Magic through her deep understanding of friendship, thus earning her status.

[@veestigz]

I love you're accent

[@SharmaineKatie]

SeeU!

[@veestigz]

ReALlY!!!?

[@milkymoomoo5672]

+PopsyCandy your.

[@sara09_kawaiiplayznorskgam69]

+PopsyCandy when i saw this comment i was confused cus we have the same profile pic XD

[@Otakuweaboo3]

HAIL GRAMMAR!

[@mtbmulti]

This video is around 7 years old. And I just NOW noticed how close the Mary Sue looks like she came leaping out of Pony Creator

[@cleanmemes8042]

I love your oc so much! And you taught me a lot in this video, like my oc isn't a alicorn or anything but it taught me more about the oc's structure. I totallly agreee with you in this video. You earned a new subscriber!

[@furrynation2117]

My OC's a blind Griffon named Inkquill who can sing opera. Just throwing that out there.

[@RasetsuBrony]

that is so ... original ... i have no more words for it

[@bjfamproductions]

......that's...I...just...THAT'S AWESOME!!!!

[@furrynation2117]

Wow... thanks. Do you really think so?

[@RasetsuBrony]

FurryNation You can make so much with Inkquill in a fanfic ... nice idea, but how about his character? personality?

[@furrynation2117]

What would you like to know?

[@cordncourtney9650]

Mehh, when talking about Mary Sue, its always reminds me of my friend's OC "AeroShenlan" he literally claim his OC as a Garry Stu (male Mary Sue)

[@MonsterUnderYourBed.]

"Discord's girlfriend" How the HECK can you be atrracted to a goat thing that is older than your granfather...?! Just...HOW

[@cassiephillips9487]

Discord: Make sense? Oh, what fun is there in making sense?

[@the_plushie_doctor]

You can date someone without being physicly attracted to them, ask asexuals that are in relationships

[@MonsterUnderYourBed.]

@@the_plushie_doctor But why would someone actually want to date Discord I just...don't understand...

[@the_plushie_doctor]

@@MonsterUnderYourBed. Maybe they think he is nice and they get along... I mean based on how him and fluttershy get along people have started to think that they are dating...

[@gregstreeter8894]

I am fascinated by sunburst. He is a handsome stallion with realistic coloration and features, like a blaze down his face, and white sock on his legs. A rather unique style of appearance, different from the usual pony marking style. I hope he becomes an awesome mage like Starswirl.

[@RemKoshmar]

OuO *takes the floofy mare pony* ... *hugs the fluffy mare pony* ♥ I like what you had to say on this topic :3c

[@philipmoran2322]

Maddy you should kick her out of your videos

[@artwithjam3304]

When I was 9 I didn't understand that the reason why there were only two alicorns. I thought it was because they were going extinct, so I "solved" the problem by making about 300 alicorn OCs. I took up a good 7ish pages with incredible tiny writing about each one individualy. I think my favorite s were tictok who had the ability to travel across time, and little leaf who liked plants... Ya that's pretty much all I can say about him.

[@Tabby_CatMeow]

The fact that Mary sue’s “backstory” is basically the original Mary sue’s description rewritten to fit MLP is pure gold to me😅

[@Snowyoaks2]

Adults in the mlp community when a child has fun making characters:😤😡😡🤬🤬

[@MadMunchkin]

Who said this video was aimed at children?

[@Snowyoaks2]

@@MadMunchkin the show is aimed at children and marrysues(created mostly by children) dumbass 💀

[@LottiMuller8472]

@@MadMunchkin who do you think makes these characters lol

[@fredericksaxton9782]

@@MadMunchkin I used to like you but that was a ridiculous take..who tf do you think is the demographic? You say it's not aimed at children, but the ones mostly being criticized for these OCS are CHILDREN, because that's who makes them. Wether or not you "aimed" purposely is irrelevant, it's aimed at children REGARDLESS because children are the MAJORITY.

[@MadMunchkin]

@@fredericksaxton9782 Dude this video is 8 years old, chill out.

[@misscoffeecat2635]

My OC Name- Crystal Waters Breed- Alicorn Occupation- Goddess of Water Cutie Mark- A wave of water that looks as if it were a crystal Coat Color- Blue-Green Mane/tail Color- Dark blue at the top, but goes to lighter blues until her tips Eye Color- extremely light blue Backstory Crystal Waters was born into a life of luxury. She was the daughter of Mystic Wave, her mother. She never met her father, as he left her mother before she was born. Crystal was born a Pegasus. Her mother was the Godess of the Sea before Crystal Waters took over her spot. Mystic Wave was an alicorn because she was godess. The only reason she decided to have Crystal was to pass on her duty as godess. Mystic wave was getting weaker and weaker, so she could not keep her duty much longer. When Crystal was finally old enough, Mystic Wave gave her powers to Crystal. Crystal was transformed into an alicorn, and her mother became a regular unicorn. (That is what I have a far. It still needs some work)

[@zain6930]

I don't think only one paragraph is gonna satisfy you not being a Mary Sue :/

[@misscoffeecat2635]

I said I'm still working on it. I still need to go more in depth and fix it up a little bit. I still need to explain -talent -where she lives -likes and dislikes -ect And I can agree now, it's a little bit Mary Sue, but I'll fix it. Also if you think this is Mary Sue, you should see my friends alicorn OC. Just ask if you want to hear my friends' OC's backstory.

[@zain6930]

It's a really good back storie doe ^-^ keep going :D

[@misscoffeecat2635]

Thanks ^_^

[@zain6930]

The video clearly says that pony generator alicorns are Mary sues pegasisterlucy

[@Chloe_thefoxstudios]

I mean Mary Sue does have a point she does kind of go around telling how bad oc are

[@caseymeighan2053]

Rachel gaming I guess

[@table2.0]

Tbh sometimes I make designs first and go from there, assigning traits to them retroactively, especially since all of my ocs are personal and for fun.