Why is India such a Dirty Country? Organized Chaos

[@georgecyriac2907]

The whole of India gets fewer foreign tourists than tiny Singapore. Think hard about that. It’s not organised chaos… just chaos…

[@farookjahoor4977]

And a large percent of those Indian tourists are NRIs and people of Indian origin and their desendants fulfilling a wish to visit the home of their ancestors.

[@varadarajanseshamani4698]

Why do we need more tourists.

[@nishashah6230]

The teenagers and young people of the world don’t ever want to go to India for holidays. They say it’s horrible everything there. It’s disgusting

[@MirrorVisionYT]

India is known for medical tourism and spiritual tourism. It's not a place for teenagers anyway. So it really does not matter.

[@antares_m20]

@@MirrorVisionYT bvangladesh was the country which bstowed the title of "medical tourism" now even they've stopped going over there lmao

[@MirrorVisionYT]

@@antares_m20 There is nothing to be bestowed upon India, Ayurved is as old as India's history. India used to give Bangladeshi FREE medical visas, which it has stopped. You are free to speculate who is at a loss.

[@krishiv1292]

​@@MirrorVisionYTthat's a terrible thing to say for a whole country.

[@cynthiahernandez4882]

Those photos of China were taken at least 20 years ago. Something is very strange. You don't look for the reasons for your shortcomings and try to change them, however you use photos of other countries 20 years ago to convince yourself is not that bad. How can you make India better with this kind of thinking ?

[@dylanosment004]

Well said.

[@MirrorVisionYT]

Nope, very recent. All you need to do is search garbage in China. It's that simple.

[@t_w_7821]

@@MirrorVisionYT very recent? lol.....ok~ you just need to convince others to believe you. the dirt in India is notorious.

[@unknownpressure87]

@@MirrorVisionYT you said hyprocrisy of western / major media, and your source if China info is comming from "google search" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@RoyFJ65]

@@MirrorVisionYT I saw more garbage in US and Europe and during events, people piss on streets be it Zurich street festival or Denmark music events. China is far cleaner and I along with many western travelers have seen it with our own eyes. Most vehicles in Chinese major cities are electric so noise level far less than other cities.

[@primechenterprises8120]

China, England and for that matter most countries have areas which are as dirty as India's Difference is that while dirty places constitute less than 10% the rest 90% are clean & neat. In india the dirty places constitute 90% while clean places are less than 10%.. So there is no comparision. Your contention that Swacch Bharat is a success is totally off. My perception as a citizen living in India is that this place is more dirt than it was 10 years back.

[@user-it6rh2tn2e]

Those places in uk were dirt is there is the same place where people of indian origin stays

[@dratul15]

Rightly said, you cannot walk along side a road for more than 10 minutes in india, your eyes will feel gritty due to dust, you throat will feel like its has swallowed dust, there is smell everywhere. If we dont know how much deeper a whole we are in in how can we think of getting out of it

[@quincypnw]

In other coutries you can find garbage in cities; in India you cities in garbage.

[@bharath9in]

You nailed it. This is what I say to lot of people, the garbage will consume the cities in no time. and people take it very lightly.

[@asifkhan-yu1rn]

❤😂superrrr

[@ssangyongA230]

It's just dirty, and chaos... hey don't make it sound nice, it's totally unorganized. 😢

[@krsajith22]

Issue is that people in India mostly consider cleaning as inferior work or work that is least appreciated. Homes are mostly cleaned by elder women in home or servent. Even at home it is ok to make the place dirty for some else to clean. At home someone does it as there is no other option. Outside no one does it and Government does not have the resources or will to clean as it is not rewarding and people have to take effort to not make the place dirty. I am struggling to educate my kids to do it, but is loosing. I am unable to impose penalties at home, but expect Gov to impose penalty. Maybe rewarding would work.

[@sutanugupta2836]

Ignorance is our biggest problem. Most of us don't the truth about our own country or know any other way of doing things than how they are doing. Also, we are extremely gullible and so, very easily misled. The comments here will prove that. The other major problem is the ritualistic mindset, some call it tradition, which blocks all new ideas.

[@farookjahoor4977]

Earlier this year I was staying in a condo not far from the beach in Goa. One morning on our way to the beach the path and surrounding area was littered with empty liquor and beer bottles and plastic cups from an overnight drinking session. These young adults obviously had no pride in the cleanliness of the environment in which they lived. To solve this problem education about the health benefits of personal and environmental cleanliness and hygiene has to be taught in Schools starting in first Grade all the way to University.

[@rishithakur7186]

As an Indian citizen that constructive criticism is much needed. Urban planning will improve our cities such as people-friendly roads, sidewalks, less car centric areas and more public transit facilities. And also all is not in the hands of govt. as people need to take initiatives, cooperate and support the govt. as residents of Indore did to keep things clean, not spit pan masala as that is ill-mannered, and overall police others who tarnish our country’s cities like that... Both Mentality of people and funds by Govt. will improve the quality of life in our cities #SwachhBharatAbhiyan #PublicHealth

[@rishithakur7186]

@@TigerWang1101 Your constructive criticism is valid, valuable and will be considered when planning for Cities of the future in India… We will purchase and adopt the best, most sustainable urban planning practices and or waste disposal recycling technology from the world no matter how expensive whether Japan or Europe but when developing our existing and future newer cities and projects we will have to adopt to the best, carbon zero, and 3R practices. Which is what we need to implement and improve on and eventually it will have to happen there is no point delaying that because we have seen the results of bad urban planning, mismanagement of finances for good urbanism and just a lot less awareness amongst people as well… However, the power of internet will take all the best and most sustainable practices of urban planning to create a more conducive, fostering and accessible environment for all its citizens. Sustainability and good critical thinking, logical, evidence based understanding and other methodological decision making are the key which simply cannot ever be compromised on. Will continue our future of cities to be more human scaled and human friendly than vanity, luxury, bankrupting, increasing public debt type of projects.

[@rishithakur7186]

@@TigerWang1101 Just like Europe or Japan we will not have unrealistic blind consumerism or capitalism… But a more sustainable, Earth friendly capitalism and consumerism economy…

[@badshahshah4611]

Well presented with good intention. Eliminating the term “organised chaos” has little to do with lack education in civic sense & civic responsibilities as citizens. Call it what yu will, We Indians need less democracy & more affirmative action without considerations of caste, religion & politics. Doing the “right” thing, not necessarily “popular” is an essential ingredient for success, respect & self-worth. ⚓️⚔️🇮🇳

[@venkatakrishna1811]

Discipline should start from home then school, the present education system is main cause of all these situation.

[@ViceCoin]

Failing state. Cant even win olympic medals.

[@aaradhyarawat7589]

That should be the least of concern. Just saying for the sake of saying!

[@twilight6460]

Yep. Largest population on Earth no medal. 😂😂

[@shellieperreault6262]

It seems to me the problem is with character/integrity, self respect, and common courtesy. You cannot tell me the "broken window" theory drives men to pee all over walls in public spaces. The whole rest of the world did away with diapers by the time they were two, and are capable of holding it until they are at a designated place.

[@d.s.5157]

The creator of this video is more worried about phrases and is in denial. I've been to India in 2007 and 2023 the bus stations don't seem to have been cleaned properly nor refurbished since they were built (perhaps late 1970's). Same for shop fronts that look like the were built in the 1930's and never be refurbished or cleaned (inside many are ok). No pavements, open sewers and ditches were common on side roads as were piles of rubbish (they don't have house to house waste collection). The Ganges is referred to as the 'Holy River' in which people bathe and wash their clothes but it's full of sewage, chemicals, human and animal remains !! They still can't clean it despite many attempts - it shows some of the Indian mindset and is embarrassing.

[@yaphonghor4409]

You showed the whole Chinese streets having mountain of trash? Are you sure??????? You think the local council sleeping?

[@ruturajshiralkar5566]

India's biggest Problems:- 1) Lack of Civil Discipline 2) Poor Waste Management 3) "Chalta Hai" Attitude 4) "Kaun Dekhta Hai" Attitude 5) "Kya Farak Padta hai" Attitude 6) Poor Urban Infrastructure 7) Massive Internal Migration 8) Poor Internal Security 9) Poor Aesthetics

[@electrowizard2658]

being indian i would like to contribute to solve this probelms like using tech asking people to donate for social works

[@mahendrarathod1656]

How long, ? 10 year's?, more?

[@onlyPROFIT_BITCOIN]

you explained this concept very well , where there is garbage , people unconsiously through more garbage , spitting dosent occur inside a mall bcz there will be a fine and arrest for that , the fear is also neccesary

[@srn2295]

Stating organized chaos isn't the solution to the problem. At least sympathy works for the people and government of India that tourists haven't published dirtiness that goes around every parts of India on social media. Let's not compare the dirtiness of other countries, rather try to resolve the dirt of own country. This perception might be helpful to drive forward attitude of every nationals to make the country clean. Keep the motive clear and teach others and influence other by act how to clean the environment rather than comparing the dirt of other countries. The dirt of other countries don't last for long and are very minimal in degree to the dirt the India has. 70% of the surface water is polluted in India. There is a higher degree of dirtiness in restaurants, shops, rivers, and railways in India.

[@skariapothen3066]

Habits of people is a result of their culture.

[@EA_customersupport]

India can build good cities that are organized such as:- Chandigarh Gurgaon Noida Bangalore City of Delhi is very old to begin with. It was like that even before british. It was depopulated several times by huns, ghurids, timur and nader shah throughout the centuries. Take out the slums in mumbai, it will become another new york. There are billionaire realtors waiting for those slums to vanish to build skyscrapers in it's place Goa can be developed into something like las vegas or sao paulo, given the beaches and landscape it offers New city named amaravati is getting constructed now. India is embroiled with corruption, and s&itty politicians who would create hindrances in every path of its development. Indian parliament is as equivalent as an african parliament, where politicians don't convene for the betterment of its people but to use that venue for verbal arguments to gain silly political mileage causing upheaval in the legislative processes.

[@7_years_and_]

There is no such thing as "we build an un-organized city . " We make any heaven an hell by over loading it with people . Any organized city will become unorganized hell if it receives uncontrolled number of people. for example, delhi - mumbai Main culprit here is over population and their migration in to cities for better life

[@JohnWick-ez6vs]

1. Social and Environmental conditions 2. Poor quality materials used in construction 3. Political Corruption and benefits.

[@antares_m20]

@@JohnWick-ez6vs keeep making these lists like ur forced to memorized for govt jobs lmao.

[@rex_schd]

You ad 1000000 people in cities built for 1000 . What will happen? Same way don't expect any changes in India atleast for next 300 years .

[@jaybhailikar6231]

Heavy fines do fuckall. I'm sad to admit that we never really understood our system of government and needed to be kept on a tight leash with brutalist laws holding borderline inhumane punishments for a while after independence to really appreciate what we have. Indians respond to the laws of brutality; caning, heavy fines, public shaming, human rights abuses. We are not a people who can be dealt with gently.

[@86kickass]

Yeah corporal punishment isn’t always a bad thing if it’s not abused by those in power

[@swainp2012]

Showing anecdotal evidence of filth in the first two foreign countries is dishonest. Focus on aggregate or sum of all these.

[@moongrass217]

A storm on the teacup. Our per capita GDP is 2800 USD per annum. We should not even compare ourselves with west.

[@staceywalker8699]

The photo from England is VERY rare I think people can ignore bins. But it's looked down upon. I've lived all over UK all my life never seen anything close to that bad. I did spot an Indian family few years ago fly tipping all their garbage even th council provide big bins. No disrespect to that family maybe they needed to be shown. We have problem with our own fly tippers too and they have no excuse. Our rivers don't look like that we don't have massive disease problems for a reason. Pooping in the street doesnt help the health of your kids. Also basic hygiene with street food.

[@HO-mg2yl]

Population is the problem ..

[@Santhoshkumar-ku1jg]

we call this arsho barat culture of India..spit is treated as a good anti germ liquid..

[@ViceCoin]

Ukraine was the worst country in Europe, with a population of only 40 million.

[@rampallion8694]

No manners is the problem

[@sureshnaidu201]

Not really. Kerala is most densely populated state in india...with far less problem

[@twilight6460]

Quantity NO quality

[@mrvn000]

Make India Clean Again!

[@SeizeTheDayMukhtar]

This video isn't visible without bypass tech

[@gussysingh3643]

No discipline , No Fines, No Pride of The Mother Earth sand soil

[@rakmawa]

Dear sir! You did intellectualize a problem which is pretty much our second nature😂 India is chaos period! And that admission should be the start point of fixing it. Swatch bharat was "half baked" as it did not solve the issues end to end.. it provided excellent optics for the government, yet made little long standing changes on the ground. The problem is this: utter lack of necessary infrastructure for waste collection, disposal and/or recycling. The second part is the citizen responsibility of segregation, cooperating with standardized collection etc. The government used entire media machinary to fix the citizens end of responsibilities without doing anything about the civic / local bodies end. The result is that we are as trashy as we were in 2014, probably worse.

[@shamchodankar3235]

Our politician suporting to have more children atleast 03 or more. Please reply me if anyone know which country is having highest population in the world.

[@ravigujju1780]

Who invented plastic,,,who make dirty in india all over world, today human civilization facing big problem with plastic covers

[@1213stmarie]

Perhaps the leaders of India, and their families, at all levels, should be seen to clean up outdoors. Set an example for the people. Set aside one day a week for cleaning up outdoors, no matter what caste one is. Make cleanliness a point of pride. Also, teach people it is expected that they will clean up after themselves.

[@psoon04286]

It’s too bad that India is allowed to degrade to such a level. Individual pride as citizens will be a start, but the government has to have the resolve to lead the way by ensuring all levels of governing bodies are accountable. Corruption has to be tackled seriously so that the average citizen don’t perceive that some privileged people can easily get away with wrong doing. Cleaning up is the responsibility of everyone not just because the old caste system delegated it to the ‘untouchables’. Wishing India to its deserved greatness in the future.

[@bimalroy4626]

Nice presentation but you forgot about the dishonesty and corruption aspects at the gubernatorial level, God Bless

[@rahuljain5980]

We have seen change happen during common wealth games. Also the maintenance of NDMC areas. Delhi metro is another example so change is possible. But go down NH8 from Gurugram to Jaipur,you will find a lot of policemen stopping cars with RJ or UP plates and checking papers while not stopping people on wrong side .

[@ViceCoin]

World events only cover up problems temporarily.

[@anilbdas562]

I think as an Indian telling others are dirty doesn't make India cleaner. On the other hand teaching Children in primary classes cleanliness who in turn can also teach their parents cleanliness would definitely help. That is the only way the country will become clean. We on the other hand teach them STEM subjects and problem solving. But does not provide them infrastructure to put their learning in practice. So they leave and India remains what it already is a failure.

[@azmanhamid4569]

U'll be shock da moment u step on it till da moment u left 😋

[@VictorThang-b5p]

Cockroaches human cells

[@theonesithtorulethemall]

Literly google dirtiest country in the world and India is rank 1 with 75 compared to 2 with 55

[@eggchipsnbeans]

I thought this very interesting. I have no first hand knowledge of India but the picture of chaos and, well, squalor in some places is quite a familiar one. Your words tell ne that the problem is very real and that serious government programs are needed to solve this. While the picture of (I think) London with piles of rubbish in the street is not unknown here, it is unusual. London is generally pretty clean. That's not to say there are no other signs of deprivation here. We do have homelessness, addiction problems and many areas struggling economically and are pretty grim. Good luck with your project but next time we play you in cricket, England will be avenged!

[@MirrorVisionYT]

We shall see you on the pitch. 😊

[@soothingmeditationmusic6581]

Good report. The absurd Mindset is the real issue. Most of the problems r related to huge population in a small area leading to insecurity indiscipline n chaos.

[@radhakrishna1845]

There's what is called Mahtma Gandhi Rural Employment Scheme.. India can be cleaner with millions of people Working to keep villages clean..

[@prasenjeetrathore]

Nice video essay. I agree with the analysis that "organised chaos" is just indiscipline. People should be made more aware along with government investment in waste management and urban planning. But in my opinion another huge problem in India is that "Government is too big" so its hard to keep them also accountable for issues. Government is involved in everything in India from running businesses (PSU's), buying agricultural produce, affirmative action/reservation , etc. A small government is more efficient government, also less possibility of corruption is number of ministries are less, and less ministries mean public officials can also be paid good so that they don't have to rely on corruption to make a living. Government should be limited to only these ministries mainly: - Ministry of Finance - Ministry of Defence - Ministry of Home Affairs - Ministry of Education - Ministry of Health - Ministry of Trade and Industry - Ministry of Transport - Ministry of National Development - Ministry of Manpower - Ministry of Foreign Affairs - Ministry of Communications and Information - Ministry of the Environment and Water Resources - Ministry of Social and Family Development - Ministry of Law - Ministry of Culture, Community and Youth - Ministry of Forest

[@datolee7069]

Thank you for your health info. Modi needs to educate the people first. How about putting a few Giant video bill boards on trucks showing China and Singapore in their slumps yesterday and clean as a whistle today. Drive a few of this Trucks promoting Health cleanliness all over India particular in rural India to create Health awareness. I bet the Indians in shame will get Modi to do something the better for India. Can you blame some Indians staying permanently in clean Singapore ?

[@dratul15]

you cannot walk along side a road for more than 10 minutes in india, your eyes will feel gritty due to dust, you throat will feel like its has swallowed dust, there is smell everywhere, not to mention the noise pollution of constant honking. If we dont know how much deeper a hole we are in in how can we think of getting out of it !! Saying vishavguru bharat and all this shit is not gonna change anything Google HDI, quality of life index, life expectancy, indian passport strength, we are all way behind except in corruption index

[@MonicaLopez-ze3dd]

Good perspective 👏

[@MirrorVisionYT]

Thank you

[@UngSenang-bs5qg]

Better travelling to Japan, Korea, Taiwan, China, very clean Countries, no air polution , no water polution, Very Safe...in the city no cows, no dogs walking around, the street is very clean,.

[@AndrewJEagle]

You say Jai Hind but actually your whole video is Jai Switzerland. Organised chaos at least admits that there are different 'norms' in different societies. Your video measures India against western 'normal' as though there is only one normal. Maybe try accepting that India can be India?

[@anshumansarkar3206]

Westerners like Poverty pornooo what too do???

[@vpn740]

@@MirrorVisionYT funny that "citizens" have been demanding action on it. who is littering the streets and public places?

[@kiranpandiyan159]

cleanliness is not a western value, it is a global value. Also these issues have a far reaching impact which people don't realise. Noise pollution is causing a lot of heart attacks and hypertension. lack of cleanliness is causing spread of lot of communicable diseases.

[@anandsuralkar2947]

litering is not the issue but general indiscipline and dirtyness is​@@MirrorVisionYT

[@tonyatgoogle6076]

Having a clean environment and low noise, low polution are Western norms? And the creator agrees with you 😂😂😂😂😂. Thats right its not an Indian thing to be clean. Lol

[@sriramv3786]

Bull!! The entire world was built on Indian looted wealth and ideas. I have traveled to most parts of the World.The most convenient and safe place to stay is in India.

[@makoa143ify]

Stressful

[@MichToJoshya]

good video... in my view it should be added in schools, and with a significant percentage score should be attached to it.

[@kishormotghare1237]

Decentre....Destate ....(self district government... private.self department ...municipal self .. municipality and self village )

[@x8z195]

Because it was colonized for 1300 years

[@JayaseelanPatchy]

Its the rural people cominy to big cities for jobs . Too many rickshaws ,buses and motorcycle causing more pollution . One rickshaw and motorcycle carrying only one person does not make sense

[@dineshmalla3651]

poverty and mindset and habits and awareness

[@supersayaaain]

Nope ,caste system is biggest problem of India.

[@Android-kk2yf]

​@@supersayaaain government is the biggest problem of India

[@yvonwheel4943]

First image: Philippines

[@vinaykumar-ld3yi]

Overpopulation reason for this

[@ZgO_o]

Its clear Chinese picture is quite old tbh and england has turned that way in recent years... its like comparing oranges and apples man,

[@alvinaliathos6137]

Indonesia has far worse organized chaos

[@sureshnaidu201]

In almost every aspect, Indonesia is better then India

[@famahyus]

Your government is trying its best. The problem is with your people, or communities of peoples

[@azharidris7092]

you are talking bullcrap about china.. that picture was an aftermath of an accident.. get a live..

[@VinayDutta-kw5yj]

The cleanliness drive has taken off in india. Millions of toilets have been made. An awareness has started coming in all of us. It'll take some more time to reach Singapore Standards.

[@BoLa-uv5oy]

Even in a 1,000 years still will not reach Singapore standard From : Singapore 🇸🇬

[@VinayDutta-kw5yj]

@@BoLa-uv5oy You're wrong. Did you ever imagine that India will be Fifth largest economy of world?? Same way things will happen.

[@BoLa-uv5oy]

@@VinayDutta-kw5yj In terms of absolute numbers and GDP per capita of $2,300 still far far behind. 😂 Singapore GDP per capita is $93,450 Try to match that in a 1,000 years. Can't even build toilets yet blah blah blah. From : Singapore 🇸🇬😂

[@VinayDutta-kw5yj]

@@BoLa-uv5oy Let's meet after 50 years , be my guest. Then we will discuss 😊

[@BoLa-uv5oy]

@@VinayDutta-kw5yj 50 years ?? Give you 500 years. India is forever a country of the future where the future never arrives. From : Singapore 🇸🇬😂😂

[@sandyj342]

Ok let's not improve our country and migrate and solve other people's problems

[@9356079]

More stricter enforcement of rules is required

[@MrPathorock]

just chaos, no organized

[@sabujoseph5035]

First let them stop that red spitting on the road, and there are these billiener heroes giving encouragement by advertising

[@angelomariano9494]

LEARN FROM JAPAN!

[@observer-2LC]

India cannot learn from Japan, too big of a difference, need to start somewhere small. Japan is way too far ahead - Indian mentality is backwards. The cows still roaming free, which create chaos, you think if the cows are considered sacred, they would keep them in a safer place, instead of roaming free in the cities, risking getting killed! Just doesn't make any sense!

[@rampallion8694]

Maybe it has something to do with the caste system.

[@ingeborgpadgett7079]

Too many people

[@ryezengd8617]

God Bless You All. Jesus Christ loves you.

[@matjebonklumen147]

Image issues!

[@shubhahalder4226]

Go and find out in China, America other countries where population is low ....

[@tarunpratap8618]

Aapka video accha laga. aap ek informed person hain. aapke subscribers aur hone chahiye.

[@MirrorVisionYT]

Ji dhanyawaad, jaan ke accha laga ki aapko video accha laga. Umeed karta hu aapne Subscribe kiya.

[@judeking-h8w]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@rollinglama]

Indian cities are dirty and chaotic. Almost 700000 villeges are clean and tranquil. Usually foreighners visit delhi jaipur agra which are unorganized and dirty. Delhi is a mess. But in villages and smaller towns things are totally different. Indian cities at the moment are just like western cities in the 19th century.

[@antares_m20]

lmao what are u smoking mate

[@desiputtar89]

India is not a dirty country. India is beautiful in terms of flora and fauna but it has waste management issues. That's because cleaning 🧹 🧼 a city requires a lot of time and resources. Politicians don't have time for that because elections here take place in every 5 years. Cleaning a city is a long-term process. It can take more than a decade to clean an entire city inside out. But since the elections in India take place in every 5 years, the politicians have to focus on short-term goals in order to win elections. That's one of the problem.

[@desiputtar89]

@cocomojo1858 It's not a dirty country. There are governance issues. These problems are manmade and can be fixed.

[@jamesbond4810]

India needs administrative and bureaucratic reset and discipline. The whole bureaucratic system is still resembles the British colonial rules.

[@supersayaaain]

​@@desiputtar89not governance but societal issue

[@nishanthmusica]

Hey! I didn't expect that!! Indepth analysis 👋🙏🫡