Why is Israel cocky at the UN but coy at the ICJ?: Marwan Bishara

Al Jazeera’s senior political analyst Marwan Bishara highlights the Israeli legal team’s claims at the ICJ regarding humanitarian aid to Gaza. He emphasizes that while Israel portrays itself as aiding Gaza, in reality, no aid originates from within Israel; all assistance comes from external sources. Bishara notes criticism within Israeli media questioning the necessity of aiding Gaza.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#IsraelGaza #HumanitarianAid #ICJ #GazaCrisis #AidObstruction #InternationalLaw #HumanRights

[@Eindhart]

Cocky at UN because of ally's veto At ICJ there is no veto😂

[@Bewareinjustice]

Lol you nail it

[@riotsociety730]

[@msbayramoglu1]

You are %100 correct USA can’t veto ICJ order neither can US Senate do anything so Zionist are exposed to their true colours

[@joshowen9054]

unfortunetely, incorrect. ICJ can give a judgment, but it has not power to enforce it: the US will veto. so it will remain an accusation. only the ICC can put netanyahu in jail, he is afraid of the ICC. that's why both the US and Dracula went crazy about the ICC

[@haiseiiyc5032]

So true 😂

[@ynow9722]

A flood of aid 😂😂😂. More like a flood of lies.

[@jdsull]

It's bursting from the trucks all over the roads,spilling out of the crushed boxes and shattered bottles.

[@davidwilson448]

The world agrees - Pstinians have brought it upon themselves. no ceasefire, no evacuation, more 2000 pounders!

[@cagdas135]

@@davidwilson448 It's funny how your hasbara solely depends on shamelessly lying even when commenting about you shamelessly lying 😂

[@scranshaw5509]

Marwan Bishara, man of great integrity. Respect.

[@DawnAlRayyan-mv9mq]

Agreed! Inshallah ✌️✌️✌️justice yahrub!

[@abdulazizalzut8963]

l would believe everything he says. Does he work for the Gaza ministry of health?

[@budakon]

He is the salt of the earth. This isn't a tragedy, though, since tragedy is unavoidable, while this crime against humanity is purposive and deliberate ... it is a brutality.

[@Sylvia-ps8tg]

@abdulazizalzut8963 he speaks out what the whole world is saying by now. Gncd.

[@martinwhite9691]

The poor civilizations are like walking skeletons, they're like death camp images from WW2 what Japanese and the Germans done to prisoners.The cruelty that Israel has demonstrated over the years is inhuman there is something fundamentally not right with most of them.

[@rosemaryspiota9836]

See the videos of the Israelis stopping and destroying the aid which is held up in thousands of trucks outside Gaza with Israel not allowing it to pass.

[@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings]

Mind Begs the Question: - If a States policies are - Starvation,Death Camps,Gassing/White Phosphorus,Dehumanization,Pogroms,Mass Graves,Ethnic Cleansing,etc - Has the right to exist?

[@carolwhelan5717]

Alll lies. Aljazeera is sh....

[@user-rp1lj9qv6o]

Marwan Bishara, spot on as always

[@BoldAtty]

Shockingly U.S. Congress did not threaten the ICJ judges and their families like they did the ICC judges and their families.

[@fatinhermiz8729]

But they did

[@infinitesolutions2602]

Alhamdulillah. Allahu akbar.

[@Kaaanipaa]

Rishi amd his cabinet, Biden and his cabinet are also complicit

[@infinitesolutions2602]

@@Kaaanipaa Agree

[@Sinvare]

The US ratified treaties for the ICJ but did not sign onto the ICC. So technically the US Senators could be tried for threatening the ICJ as the US has agreed to be a part of the ICJ. The ICC has no jurisdiction because the US didn't agree to it.

[@theancientsancients1769]

Excellent analysis by Marwan Bishara who has been with Al Jazeera English since it's start in 2006.

[@Landis_Grant]

Deliberately lying under oath in court = perjury = prison sentence.

[@douglasthompson2740]

All court actions are theatre in which the more money and the more power you possess the more you get to define the outcome. Don't look for any real punishment of any kind.

[@fatiema276]

It's no surprise

[@theseustoo]

For anyone... EXCEPT Israelis, apparently!

[@allcatall3931]

@@theseustoo other groups could also try the 'chosen' lines, then see if the u.s/west will blindly support them as well, after a while..

[@zozo327]

It's true narcissist gaslighting at its finest, but I got faith in the judges it's so in your face they treating everyone like we are simple, like we not seen truth on internet it's shocking, I pray the icj stop this genocide save humanity ❤️ 🇵🇸 ♥️🇿🇦♥️🌎

[@Kamdaman2024]

Let’s hope. I’m still not convinced of their integrity based on 2 points. 1. They haven’t stopped it yet. How much more evidence can one possibly need? 2. Sebutinde is the Ugandan judge who voted now on all points in the first ruling. She was more hardcore than the adhoc Israeli judge. Shortly after she was elected vice president of ICJ. Sounds like corruption and political interference to me.

[@Kamdaman2024]

Wow, my first response was deleted by KZbin. All I said was “let’s hope”

[@Kamdaman2024]

I think they censor responses based not only on actual responses, but the first comment. Why not delete the first comment instead?

[@Aleaaitacest3736]

@@Kamdaman2024i actually had problems censoring thx for the tips b

[@trygd100]

There is no genocide. Hamas supporter

[@metalmamasue3680]

We all see and know the truth. 💯✊️🇵🇸

[@rn1047]

Love and respect to Mr Bishara the greatest analyst 🙏🇵🇸

[@walterscott2501]

Brother marwan an outstanding brother that stand firm with truth justce and rights fr the oppresed palestnian people/ god blesses him and his family ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@rizwanhussain645]

Cuz there is no American veto at the ICJ!!!!

[@rizwanhussain645]

@davidwilson448 By the World you mean the 🇺🇸 and a few of their international lap dogs...got it David.Regards.

[@MsJacobowski]

@davidwilson448 No, the world does not agree on this. Just the depraved Zionists like you do.

[@user-qc4mi1dw7n]

"A theatre of the absurd..." - such an apt description !!!

[@Citizen052]

Hi Marwan, a friend of all justice loving people

[@paddydalton2373]

You Cannot Claim Self Defence By Trampling Over People's Rights 🇵🇸

[@mehruneusufzai2341]

Thank you so much Mr. Marwan Bishara and Al Jazeera correspond for the great analysis. ❤❤❤❤❤

[@KevinDavis-op3qp]

Won't help these oily arabs are going to never forget October 7

[@active1508]

Ya'll be HONEST you're here because AL J KILLED IT with that headline! LMAO! RESPECT!

[@nishantnijosson]

Marwan Bishara is one of the few analysts who gives me hope in this time of darkness. Like Francesca Albanese, or even Bassem Yousuf, no one, absolutely no one, says it like he does. Maximum respect 🙏🏼

[@salaam2u171]

Israeli settlers attacked and injured the driver of an aid truck headed to Gaza in Beit El near Ramallah . Aid trucks are reduced since day one in October . Settlers are protesting everyday , and destroying aid . Aid is perishing in queue to enter Gaza . Isreal has said to let Palestinians starve . What cruel way to drop aid in the sea , and on top of the demolished buildings . All borders must open now , enough is enough .

[@abdulazizalzut8963]

Egypt is a good friend of the Palestinians and has done much to help get aid into Gaza

[@dsj82]

Liar!!!

[@trygd100]

Nobody wants the violent and depraved Palestinians. Bunch of violent Arabs

[@Kittyparcel]

​@@dsj82you are the liars, you and !df and most israhellis

[@Kittyparcel]

​@@dsj82we have watched footage of settlers looting aid trucks then destroying food and aid daily and the !df just stands by and allow that to go on, stop saying its lies, go and search and watch and see with your own eyes

[@christopherczajasager9030]

The junta in Washington never " pleads" with Bibi...😢

[@MafuzBaja-cq8hz]

marwan ...the best world political analysts.. i love your the way yout describe ..

[@myfatherschild5820]

Thank you so much Marwan and AJ, it's always so good to hear the truth and an in-depth straightforward analysis, this brings hope. We know God is on the side of justice, but it's so encouraging to listen to your analysis. It keeps me sane lol. God is able to bring the arrogant down from their high place, we will wait patiently for that wonderful day.😂 God bless you mightily, much love and respect.❤😄

[@user-qo8yk9ew8r]

💓👌

[@Mera_Bharat_Mahan521]

Thanks for news updates

[@user-em5ns9og8i]

Excellent analysis ,thank you Mr. BISHARA

[@fgv1001]

Marwan Bishara tells the truth.

[@user-xy1oo7bv7d]

Thank you AlJAZERA Great 👍 marwan Basher Very Appreciated your work and support. QUESTION FOR BOTH. Why Don't You guys Bring to Arbs And Middle East Kings to Interview.😮

[@AhJodie]

Marwan Bishara you speak well and are easy to understand, I hear the truth from you! We are in a 'flood' of totally opposite words.... and it is up to each individual to sort things out.... I am glad to hear you talk, because you say better than I can what I see.... and then I can also try to talk as well as you when I talk with others. Thank you!

[@claudiastridacchio]

Free Palestine ❤❤❤🇪🇭

[@KateBates22zabu]

Look forward to your analysis❤from USA thank you

[@lydiad9658]

Excellent, Dr. Marwan Bishara! I actually expected you to react just like this ! Intertesting analysis.

[@AbefeAdewale-bg7up]

Marwan great man

[@salaam2u171]

We haven't seen any Isrealis living in refugee camps . Over one million Palestinians are living in camps , in zero rated humanitarian condition . Damage caused by bombing will take many years to rebuild .

[@KevinDavis-op3qp]

Thanks to hamas

[@trygd100]

Bla bla bla

[@mahamaedmusa]

sudan 9 million refuges

[@oladelekoleola2001]

A great Man 🥰🥰🥰

[@XYZ-ft7vf]

Marwan Bishara thank you for your no nonsense approach to cutting through the lies. It is obvious who the criminals are.

[@stephenkeddy6849]

If the aid is being flooded then why drop it from a plain?

[@sabrinayounisaden7238]

Love you aljazeera english and Arabic🎉🎉❤

[@aquabat104]

i love al jazeera because it is unbiased and gives both sides

[@kenbou8892]

That jew Israel rep at UN with paper shredder is such a clown. How can he still enter the UN building oh my God

[@The-Man-Right-Chea]

😮😮😢😢😢😢Can someone please explain to me again why no European nation including the US wanted these people in their country before during and after WWII????? What did they know that we are now finding out???? 🤔

[@AichaGwinner]

Experience 🤔

[@adamson760]

‘Power corrupts; absolute power corrupts absolutely’

[@Redrider2016]

Cocky at Un because of Usa veto. Icj there is no veto to save them.

[@Tman501]

I thought that shout at the back was saying fire 🙈 but she was saying liar 😂😂

[@user-fo8bk7fv4h]

The floating port is a prelude for the establishment of a permanent porth for to aid in the future extraction of the vast amount of Gazas oil and gas later?

[@newsbuster292]

Or worse, part of a plan to 'ship' the population of Gaza out to make room for jewish settlements, exactly like the zionists had in mind from the start.

[@dominiqueabel8856]

thanks, good analyse.

[@ximivogue1234p]

Justice for 35k people

[@JeromeVanDerMeulen]

35k human shields!!!

[@ximivogue1234p]

​@@JeromeVanDerMeulenwhat you mean 35k people no value

[@ximivogue1234p]

Why no value for 35k people how israili doing genocide still now

[@Fyi90]

@@JeromeVanDerMeulen even if someone is used as a human shield (which they arent) does that give anyone the right to kill KNOWING full well that innocent people will be killed? NO! So this human shields argument makes IDF look worse because they dont care for anyones life.

[@andreaspapapetrou5220]

Three things in life you can ask and never know the truth, (1) Ask a man to tell you how much his wage is ,(2) Ask a woman how old she is ,(3) Ask a jew about treatment of the Palestinian people

[@purplerose5]

Give Marwan more time. Cant get enuf of his analysis

[@DMC1982]

Destruction of CARE and UN aid is criminal act. The destruction of humanitarian aid during a famine constitutes a war crime.

[@mohamedaslam3976]

Some comments still supporting Israel, what a shame after all this genocide.

[@muniebabrown4021]

❤❤Marwaan❤❤a Hero, he speaks facts,never hold back and has no fear❤❤

[@monirasultana1029]

Perfect heading

[@Hlth-cn4fh]

When Israel commands Mo to sit, Mo sits. That's why.

[@Tina-qn8bg]

Blah blah blah blah blah blah

[@muniebabrown4021]

In your Retarded dreams, Marwaan Fears No1.

[@muniebabrown4021]

Your delusional mind is slowly creeping up on you😂😂😂and your idol😂😂soon your comments will be no more and you will have to make a run for it😂 🏃‍♀️ 🏃‍♀️ 🏃‍♀️

[@suzanneharris8339]

It's like the conniving 8 year old who goes to his mother when he wants something because he knows his dad will say no.

[@Marymare-katniss]

☮️☮️☮️☮️😔

[@tomas1110]

Israel has a different way of approaching the truth, if you lie long enough people will tend to eventually see it as truth.

[@SaccoMabowles]

Because that's how they are in every scenario. Tough in groups only when it's easy, but consistently sweet and shy kittens when they're not treated like special snowflakes who depend on money from real countries to sustain their pathetic attempt at a country.

[@EDM_2905]

How can those 2 evils stand there and lie through their teeth?! 😳🤮

[@blingbling2841]

There is no US daddy to hold their pinky finger, or should I say pukey finger.

[@chrismullins3645]

With respect.. As for the UN’s “license,” the argument on its behalf was based on the dramatic vote, still fresh in memory, that had taken place on November 29, 1947 at a meeting of the United Nations in its then-headquarters in Flushing Meadows, New York. Then and there the General Assembly, by a two-thirds majority, recommended a plan for “Independent Arab and Jewish States” and a “Special International Regime for the City of Jerusalem,” to be implemented two months after the British evacuation but no later than October 1, 1948.

[@LittlePenguin1-17]

Acting strong & aggressive in the UN GA Acting innocent & humble in the ICJ Sounds like a criminal trying to escape it's fate.

[@lutfishehadeh5906]

Is there a time is ending very quickly. very soon we will see a new state emerge

[@LGG-hg6nt]

It is now up to ICJ to demonstrate if it matters or not. What we have seen and learned so far is that only lies & money matter. Nothing else.

[@jarosawbielski2301]

The righteousness of the righteous makes his way smooth,

[@korocam9137]

I live in a small town in Aotearoa NZ of around 50.000 people. We have been Protesting every Saturday since this Catastrophe started! Today we had a few heated Confrontations.. it just tells me that more people are waking up to what the Zionists have been doing to the Palestinian people! We will keep fighting for you Palestine ❤✊🏽🇵🇸

[@rubylicious1024]

they probably have some other thoughts, with the port and the type of division of gaza, with the type of road thingy!? firstly, if they didn't want to let aid in, why shut of everything and close down places, so it needs to be? (like the bread bakeries, they later, annoyingly enough, brag they have opened up..) they have some serious control issues, and the problems with their control, is what goes in and out.. and so much so, that the humongous gifted x-rays aren't enough, so they go through everything.. so how are they planning, to go through all of it there?

[@rawlsrules]

Good question. Tragicomedy.

[@user-mb7sc1ob2w]

The pier is going to be permanent security for the canal they are building

[@deboradebora6089]

What Should Israel Do Next in Light of Their Declaration of War? First, we should reflect deeply upon the painful divide that has festered among us, causing the devastating toll of hundreds of lives lost and thousands wounded. We need to yearn for a major change and wholeheartedly unite as one. Only the bonds of unity can shield us from future tragedy and elevate our nation from the abyss of despair. We cannot afford to nurse bitterness or delay action, waiting for the war's end to ponder our fractured state. Now is the time for introspection. We need to pinpoint the reasons behind our present circumstances and act accordingly. Our quest for understanding needs to extend to our lives’ very source: the upper force of love, bestowal and connection that acts on us beyond our current level of awareness, which perceives through an egoistic and divisive lens. It is no matter of religion, but a realization that reality’s governing force is singular, and we accordingly need to stand united before it as one. Precisely in our trying times, we are in need for an expansion of consciousness to let the upper force of love and bestowal into our lives. We need to raise the pain and anguish that erupts in so many people in such times to the upper force, and wish for it to mend our torn relations, and draw us closer together. We must seek to hold each other close to our hearts, not solely in times of war, but as an enduring duty. We are a nation established not on a biological foundation, but on a spiritual-ideological one: "Love your neighbor as yourself." That is, we were people from all around ancient Babylon who felt a problem with living our lives solely according to competitive-materialistic ideals and sought for a higher truth to our existence, which we revealed as a higher force of love, bestowal and connection that united us above our divisive drives. That is why we cannot remain divided without suffering from our separation. Our mission to unite above our divisions is constant, because divisive egoistic desires constantly surface within us, driving us apart. Therefore, much like a diligent student who finds new homework awaiting them each day, we should not accumulate any more overdue assignments that end up exploding in our faces, pressuring us into critical situations such as the one we now find before us. Instead, we should hurry up and correct our hearts to favor unity “as one man with one heart” above our divisions.

[@Sandy-tw8ru]

Why doesn't Al Jazeera question those Arab leaders who are not cutting ties with Israel? They can resume relations after the two-state solution.

[@anitaaziz3255]

Stop wondering… they are not worth the question why. They hearts are filled with sheer arrogance

[@moldymush]

🇬🇧 🇵🇸

[@freejosephmusic]

What do I teach my kids about truth and lies

[@zoo-xibbitjayne2081]

The whys and wherefores of insane consuct are too labyrinthine to follow.

[@philipcarter8511]

Marwan Bishara is really incensed. He feels it to the bone.

[@woodrowbarstad4549]

the floating port& Israels road by setting GAZA if for the Palestinian off shore Gas Fields

[@reggieduquesnoy]

The big lie of the land...the land of the free.ks...

[@ch.k.3377]

"Therefore, power must be constantly questioned" Last election in the Palestinian territories in 2006 🤦‍♂

[@bernadettedunn6129]

Multi-national peace force NOW

[@tanialoftus1063]

KB, I love your picture. It reminds me of, and may I add, are you attempting to rival "Kats over Brats?" If kitties ran the world we wouldn't have these insane unnecessary wars. EGYPT: I implore you to help the animals escape Gaza. You will be rewarded with good karma, I guarantee. The donkeys are so thin and miserable, they don't want those ropes on themselves or to pull those heavy buggies. Ask the Gaza men to be nice to their horses and help the ones you can escape Gaza altogether, Egypt is so much bigger and you can control the horses' breeding. It makes me very sad to think of these poor little creatures opening their eyes for the first time after being born thinking "a fun life awaits me" only to end up a slave. Please help them. Also, is there a way to turn sea water into drinking water?

[@MaxOvergaurd]

Im an American. God has made me feel love for the Palestinian people. I say from the river to the tree. Brother of thee. I am of three. What does this mean? I say we share for the sake of Jesus Christ!

[@gjerrildkro]

Nakba

[@fatinhermiz8729]

By the way the float is to make it possible for Palestinians to flee anywhere , but for Israeli and USA astonishment no Palestinian will ever leave their own land they have tried for 76 years now!!

[@ARAFATHOSSAIN--]

Best version of amber heard.

[@wanazlisuleiman172]

When you know you are wrong and no one is there to help you. At the UN, they have their idiot big bro who would rubber stamp everything they do and veto anything that comes their way.

[@kaioser]

We all know this is all about politics

[@wernercoetzer9005]

What is Sinwar doing to get aid for his people? I mean except hiding between woman and children as his human shield.

[@thundercatt5265]

.....the ICJ can form a New alliance that can break the cycle so justice can wash away the obstructions in our paths from many nations

[@nurlindafsihotang49]

Because this is A COURT OF LAW, and they knew Israel gonna lost.

[@shamhi_thewatcher]

Verses from The Quran (<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="128">2:8</a>3) And We took the covenant of the Children of Israel: “You shall not serve except God, and do good to your parents, and regard the relatives, and the orphans, and the needy, and say kind things to the people, and hold the Connection, and contribute towards purification.” But then you turned away, except for a few of you; you were objecting. (<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="128">2:8</a>4) And We have taken a covenant with you: “You shall not spill the blood of each other, nor drive each other out from your homes.” And you agreed to this while bearing witness. (<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="128">2:8</a>5) But then, here you are slaying yourselves, and driving out a group of you from their homes; you act towards them with sin and animosity. And if they come to you as prisoners, you demand ransom for them, while it was forbidden for you to drive them out! Do you believe in part of the Book and disbelieve in part? The punishment for those among you who do so is humiliation in this worldly life, and on the Day of Resurrection they will be delivered to the most severe retribution. God is not unaware of what you do.

[@AmusedCoralReef-ts9ro]

Its being recorded in real time, hearsay and ideological argument is not evidence

[@damienjacqnes2747]

Greatman Bishara.

[@ruthgallagher9584]

Yes,theater of the absurd...

[@intricatic]

Because Israel is not one person, but many people, most likely.

[@user-dd9re5wm6y]

The "Zionist"

[@seniormukhtar2715]

Is a very shameful to the people of Israel

[@suraiyayaqub9551]

Marwan Bashar is always right. He knows what is Israel doing. World is not buying what Israel is selling

[@all3ykat79]

For the first forty or so minutes he just moaned about South Africa and about the ICJ too, how they had no right to question them

[@AbuHashemPSC]

That ship has sailed 🤣

[@all3ykat79]

@@AbuHashemPSC it should t have even been launched.

[@alhamdulilla_AllahuQairunHafiz]

Say: ‘O Jews, if you think that, leaving all other people, you alone are the friends of Allah (i.e., Awliya’), then long for death (because His Awliya’ will not fear in the grave and the Hereafter) if you are true (in your thinking).’‏ (الْجُمُعَة‏ - Al-Jumu‘ah [62 : 6]) And these people will never long for it due to (the rejection of the Messenger and disbelief) which they have sent forward. And Allah knows the wrongdoers well.‏ (الْجُمُعَة‏ - Al-Jumu‘ah [62 : 7]) Say: ‘The death from which you are fleeing is bound to catch up with you. Then you will be returned to Him (the Lord) Who knows the unseen and the seen. So He will inform you of what you used to do.’‏ (الْجُمُعَة‏ - Al-Jumu‘ah [62 : 8]) The Glorious Quran App Minhaj Publications

[@Tresi-lm7of]

Why Al Jazera never condemned Hamas 7 October? That's why this channel will never reach international level.

[@KB-ny5nl]

Why are they doing nothing about the jew extremists destroying aid and attacking driver's?