Why is there no "historical criticism" of the Qur'an as there is of the Bible?

Also, why do Muslims hesitate to "adapt" the Qur'an to the needs of the modern age?

[@caucasianxy4436]

"He who does not live in the way of his beliefs starts to believe in the way he lives." The third caliph, Omar.

[@intekabalam7340]

Omar r.a. is the 2nd Caliph brother. Osman r.a. is the 3rd one.

[@alvirarahman2690]

2nd not third

[@REAAX]

@@intekabalam7340 Omar (LA)

[@intekabalam7340]

@@REAAX Are u a Majoosi? Because in Islam we were taught not to curse people. Cursing is done to only those people whom Allah and his messenger sallallahu alaihi wa sallam has cursed. May Allah guide you to Islam.

[@REAAX]

@@intekabalam7340 cursing rather than blessing the enemies of ahlul bayt is necessary

[@ShinsekaiAcademy]

You have no idea how heart warming was it for me to see an old scientist sitting in a room full of books, talking about his findings. Blessed you are sir.

[@anasnazim5774]

Let's pray for borther's paul's long life. Amen.

[@sulaxana7847]

Its funny n ironic to think someone read so much book on their lives, but missing the book that God is the author

[@Fahad-gf1wx]

He's not a scientist 🤦‍♂️

[@diiriyetv]

@AnarchoRepublican and you? A troll?

[@ShinsekaiAcademy]

@Rayrad 696 pagan x) like in the movies reference i like it lul, makes it sound convincing and kool !

[@godisgreat1535]

I was lucky the day I subscribed to your channel brother Paul. I'm a Muslim and I learn every time I watch your videos. May Allah almighty always bless you and protect you and your family in this life. May Allah grant you janatal firdousse 🙏🏽🤲🏽 ameen

[@BloggingTheology]

❤️

[@jorgoasparuhov4131]

you will also learn a lot if you watch Cristian Prince an Arabian Speaking person and specialist in Islam.

[@anouaressanoussi]

No you won't, spreading falsehood huh? Interesting.@@jorgoasparuhov4131

[@abdelkaderkhaddaouiabderez9303]

😂😂🤣🤣😂😂🤣LOL@@jorgoasparuhov4131

[@ammarkarsou9687]

I recently found out about your channel, and i'm happy that i still have many of your videos to watch. Valuable material ♥️

[@BloggingTheology]

Welcome aboard!

[@ammarkarsou9687]

I don't "want to", I already have absolute faith in God

[@MohammedAhmed-py4rk]

@ammar kasou Me too

[@MohammedAhmed-py4rk]

@@pankaja7974 The only problem is you don't know Arabic, so, translation is like scratching the surface. I want to give you advice, Learn Arabic.

[@MohammedAhmed-py4rk]

@@pankaja7974 Speak Arabic if you can understand word Makr.

[@aq_ahmed]

This guy does alot of research on different religions. I am not sure which religion he believes in but I pray Allaah to fill his heart the light of the only one true religion and show the truth inshaa Allaah

[@zinsarip6791]

He was Christian and became Muslim but recently left Islam...if I am not mistaken

[@boboiboy9350]

@@zinsarip6791 where did you get that from? I have not heard it at all

[@doityourselffixityourself3110]

@@boboiboy9350 he comes to speakers corner alot, He became a Muslim few years ago. you can search br paul speakers corner.

[@MrTvjungkie]

@@zinsarip6791 i know him from speaker corner videos.. i didn't know he left Islam.. do you know why? Where did you get the information?

[@adityamohan7366]

He is Paul Williams. He's a Muslim.

[@TheSaleem57]

I recommend everyone to read book by Martin Lings, titled "Muhammad"

[@BloggingTheology]

Wonderful book!

[@MnM_CuteCatClips]

Peace and Blessing be Upon Him.

[@muhammadshahidhaque2745]

Martin Lings was his pre Islamic name. He renamed himself as a Muslim to Abu Bakr Siraj Uddin. ❤️

[@fulaanibnfulaan8806]

martin lings book has some criticisms. 'the sealed nectar' is better

[@smkhan6773]

I FOUND SEERAT BY MUHAMMAD HAIKAL MORE READABLE

[@ahmd5]

I am delighted to have found your channel. Thanks for sharing your reading with us.

[@Stillwater860]

Ask not why the Quran cannot be adapted to fit our time? Ask why we can't adapt to the Quran. Brilliant.

[@soheil527]

what about shia rafidhis who hate the quran and talk about 11000 versese missing?

[@mahadali619]

@@soheil527 they are non-believers of course they’ll fabricate whatever they need to to make their point

[@abdhalimabdghani4218]

Qias...technical adaptation ..riding camel donkey evolve to bullock cart path to roaf bicycle car bus lorry....train .....plane

[@leupt3283]

Cannot be adapted In terms of what? Don't just play with words. Get your point clear and straight.

[@JonathanDeLeon-em4px]

The Quran cannot be adapted to fit the needs of mankind for unlike the Bible, it does NOT come from the Creator of mankind.

[@usopp0021]

The best part of Paul video is always the book recommendation.

[@BloggingTheology]

👍

[@abdulkader7104]

@@albertnehmat7093 watch the last video qadhi made responding to your nonsense can u tell me on of the holes he mentions?

[@abdulkader7104]

@@albertnehmat7093 i like the red herrings and ad hominems again did u watch his last video ? and what are the holes he mentions since u are relying on his authority to say there are holes don't play deceptively so waiting

[@ReshadSherzad]

@@albertnehmat7093 Look, brother. The hatred within you has taken over all of you. The notion that God sent a prophet to arabs is very disturbing and offensive for both Jews and western people. It has to do with the culture and skin color. Western culture wants to be their own gods. Nobody can stop you from this. You are human beings and as equal as I am as creation. Nobody can judge you but God. If you want to believe in the bible as the way of salvation, so be it. You have all my respect. I am a medical doctor and so was Keith Moore and also a professor in embryology. He read those verses that you ridicule and if you are a medical doctor you will understand how profound they are. Regarding the rib cage and man emerging from there, it is simply because western people don't know arabic, there it clearly states that man came forward from between the backbone and ribs which is exactly where the uterus (womb) is located and during childbirth man indeed comes forward from there, Moore became a muslim. To just google and find "claimed" contradictions is not enough. Look, I had the same problem as you. I coudn't believe an arab became a prophet. What I did was imagining a man, illiterate, from the 6-7th century in the arabian dessert suddenly preaching these verses. When you read the quran in that sense. There will come alot of things that will shock you that you have to answer in order to dismiss it. Furthermore You really have to deal with the concept of trinity. Something so profound as the core of christian believe shoud be openly stated in the book of God. And also the philosophical concept of trinity is not in line with any monotheistic belief system on earth ever. How come God created everything and then he missguided people or more plainly, he kept the truth a secret and then sent his son who also kept it in the shadow and then when the son was gone suddenly Paul comes and says, Hey guys, Jesus forgot to mention this and that and also don't listen to him because he tells me I have authority now. You know, I wouldn't but my afterlife in the hands of such a man, if you do, with all due respect I wish you the best.

[@aq_ahmed]

@Lilia murah Masha Allah. May Allaah reward you for the time and effort you put in defending the true religion and best of the people, Prophet Mohammad.👍

[@mab9739]

Thanks Paul for sharing The knowledge one gets from your few minutes-long videos makes one dispenses with many hours of reading thick books. It works for me. Many thanks mate.

[@laminsillah5999]

An objective and diligent mind at work. Well done Paul. Allah bless you with Islam.

[@merromerro1618]

Good to see you again, brother Paul....it's been so long since I last heard from you...May Allah bless you

[@MrTvjungkie]

@ParangLima betul..

[@limelyte5390]

@Rayrad 696 Allah is just one of God's many names dear, Rahman, Malik, Aziz, Razaq, Wasi, Basit, Raheem, Qudus, Jabbar, Hayy, Qayyum, Kareem, Qadir, Jallal, Hakeem, and so on and so forth. Google names of God in Islam, there are 99 of them as mentioned in Qur'an, also these are only those mentioned in Qur'an. And it's common for people to ask if Allah is God in Islam, what was God called in Arabic before Muhammad pbuh? Well, god in Arabic is ilah or elah, so as a worshipper of the one true God, you testify that there's no elah except Allah, ie no god but The God. One and only. Also, Islam didn't start with Muhammad pbuh, it was and always has been the religion of the prophets from Adam, Noah, down to Ibrahim, Moses, Jesus and finally Muhammad Allah bless them all.

[@palpatine1809]

@Rayrad 696 easy fix for you go pick up a bible and pick up Arabic translation it will say Allah even Christian Arabs say Allah so you got a problem take it up with them not us

[@palpatine1809]

@Rayrad 696 yet they translate god to Allah I’m sorry he’s not the same he’s not so weak to let his son die for the sins of man he doesn’t even have a son as he is beyond human comprehension a being supreme you dull his name by giving him human characteristics where as we glorify him as the one and only

[@Revert2010]

Dear brother Paul May Allah swt grant you goodness in this life and in the hereafter

[@BloggingTheology]

❤️

[@AbdurahiimRoberts]

Paul, I find your content utterly fascinating. Subjective "feelings driven" arguments so often enter the arena of debate; arguments that start with the search for a particular outcome, instead of the truth, as a goal. Your methodology, one of scholarly representation, objectivism and etiquette, is extraordinarily refreshing. Have you come across the book "The History of the Quranic Text from Revelation to Compilation - A Comparative Study with the Old and New Testament" By M.M.Al-Azami? A tremendous work in my humble opinion.

[@BloggingTheology]

Thank you. Yes I have read that book.

[@barnabychesterman7620]

There is nothing remotely objective about this guy.

[@beth1979]

@@barnabychesterman7620 I find him to be objective. What proof do you base your opinion on?

[@beth1979]

@asma bint marwan your grammar is terrible. I have no idea what point you are attempting to make.

[@barnabychesterman7620]

@@beth1979 Hahaha, surely you're joking, right? The guy's a Muslim convert who reads from two books, one by a Muslim and the other by another Muslim convert! And guess what conclusion they come to...??!!

[@joebaz4844]

Great analytical presentation, Thanks and take care.

[@hadiyatali193]

Assalam u alaik to our beloved brother Paul from me and my entire family.You will not know how greatly you have inspired us to keep learning.

[@sochbachar]

He inspired you because he was talking in favor of Islam despite of his illogical statements?

[@seikhshartaz547]

@@sochbachar who are you..?? if you not follow Islam it's doesn't matter, so oil your own machine

[@efdawahfan]

@@sochbachar the scripture speaks for itself ..if you like it or not like it ..it is what it is.

[@efdawahfan]

@Rayrad 696 lol what a waste of your time completely fake arguments at least our God has a name and he has 99 beuatiful names but you are not blessed because like Jesus pbuh said im not finished i have much to say but you cant bear them now ..this verse is very clear about the religion is not completed in his lifetime...and Allah said i have completed this religion for you islam btw in isaiah 42:8 he says i am LORD thats my name not jehovah you guys keep changing the scripture lol even today you keep corruping the corrupted even more what a joke omg even in exodus he says my name is i am who i am and again not Jehovah ..what kind of name is that ?? My name is I Am Who I am LOL

[@efdawahfan]

@Rayrad 696 40 prophets wrote the bible are you serious ??? So are John, Paul ,Luke and Mathew prophets ?? I dont know your understanding of prophets.All bibles are different and all of them contain different gospels ..the bible is not preserved im sorry its updating every day ..Jesus pbuh will say you get away from me...you evil doers !!

[@kobanichelsea3740]

I love this brother hes doing a grate job in speakers corner as well may Allah grant him and every muslim as well as all good people a place in Jannah.ameen

[@kobanichelsea3740]

@@albertnehmat7093 There might be holes in ur brain the Quran is not sent down for this generation alone its sent down to the final day . Just because for the last few decades the west created fake Democracy and free drinking alcohol and freedom of sexuality as well as drugs dosnt mean this is the way we should live in my friend !! The way this system going only God knows what we will become if we carry on like that so you cant judge the Quran because it dosnt suit the fake freedom they created wake up.

[@olive3186]

Kobani Chelsea ALLAH found in the BIBLE MUST WATCH kzbin.info/www/bejne/qpDOeIV8qLSji8U

[@rizaanjappie]

Paul you a gem in these times, a great example to us all

[@3boys1family]

It's really interesting to hear this info, jazak Allahu khairan!

[@hamidabattla758]

Dear friend. You are doing such an excellent job in clearing many misunderstandings about Islam verses other faiths. God Almighty has chosen you specifically for this job. May He bless you for your hard work, dedication & short effective presentations. Thanks

[@BloggingTheology]

❤️

[@adamlabnaki9216]

Volume quality is amazing, thanks brother Paul, God bless you. Great academic thinker, well needed by the Muslim community

[@BloggingTheology]

So pleased the volume is good now!

[@lpra1685]

@@BloggingTheology May Allah bless you for your honest, unbiased and academic work ❤❤❤

[@edrisasam4403]

Thank you sir, This video is based on facts, and its good to see that you played a good umpire to the opinion of the two writers depicting the real essence of what both wants to potray.

[@satobaide]

Wow! my 1st time here. I used to watch Br Paul in many London's HP SC vid Excellent ! this is the complementary for what other brothers do at the Park different method, different setting Jazaakallah khairan

[@BloggingTheology]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@dbliebermandb3498]

Peace paul been checking you out all the way from Boston in the states. Keep up the good work my dear bro

[@TheMuslimParadigm]

Brother Paul always makes incisive & valuable contributions to the ummahs learning. Alhamdulillah.

[@rafaqathussain2131]

Liked your thoughtful work on the subject 👏

[@moosadiamond3965]

Asalaamu alaykum shukran jazilan gaira jaza for the beautiful explanation and inspiration you are indeed a brilliant scholar

[@goidogoi]

I like how organic messy his bookshelves are.instead the standard studio clean and organized shelves of many academicians. That is how an academic and a scholar bookshelves should look like. Going through books upon books, never really have time to put them back nice and proper. 😂😂😂😂😂

[@rashidhakim7021]

Goi Dogoi; As Salaamu Alaykum, Wa Rahmatulahi, Wa Barakatuhu , - I Completely agree with you! The Oddly Organized, Messiness of the Scientists, Researchers & the busy Students! - Honestly, I think that you have made a very astute observation!. - May The ONE MOST HIGH-(SWT) Forgive, Bless, Protect, & Guide Our Bother Paul, and All of us as well! Ameen.

[@omotosotajudeen9741]

Amiina.

[@goidogoi]

@Rayrad 696 What cave did you just came out from? We are talking about his shelves and you start rambling about four letters because the Jews ARE FORBIDDEN to call upon HIM for their own excessess and doings. We Muslims are opposite. HE likes and encouraged us to call upon HIM and say HIS Name much. LOL.

[@goidogoi]

@Rayrad 696 Go sit with Bart D. Erhman about your Bible and stop wasting my time with your fantasies. If i want to know about your Bible i go take knowledge from a Biblical scholar not someone like you who have can't even compute Jesus spoke in 'Aramic and not Hebrew. 😊😊😊😊😊

[@goidogoi]

@Rayrad 696 Sorry mate. We Muslim don't adhere to such low standards.

[@idiotic1021]

People like you are rare to find these days. You are a gem.

[@Daynite786]

Bro Paul Assalam, what a pleasure to c u again, pls let keep coming.

[@abdulelahkhunji6871]

Great you came in the right time, i was searching for an answer for this question... Thanks

[@BloggingTheology]

Glad it was helpful!

[@hussinm2985]

You speak with knowledge, sincerity and an appeal for rationality in discerning especially a highly sensitive topic such as religion and faith. Continue the sharing.

[@manzerm7805]

Thank You for a very enlightening talk.

[@nabwin3254]

Loved ur vid, I think that everything was precisely accurate to what we are witnessing now days

[@macanmalaya1]

Hope more of this kind of revealing can be shown.its not only to answer all question nor showing the right path for some 1 searching whatever,but more importantly,such infomations,makes me a better muslim/person

[@AhmedAli-sr5jp]

Like always the argument is to the point Paul and the to the discerning the difference is obvious, carry on Paul you are doing a great job.

[@mustaphafikri45]

Always enlightening.

[@dinocomot]

great effort sir. appreciate your analytical insight. wondering and imagining you having intellectual discourse with Dr abdal hakim..take care saty safe

[@Chandransingham]

Good one Paul. Thanks for sharing. Food for thought.

[@yousafzaifrnd]

All your videos are great work and thought provoking. It is like a seed you have sown in the earth. Now it depends on the fertility of the land.

[@livingrateful]

Thank you for this video 🙏 In the Bible the narration of the word of God is always according to somebody. The gospel ‘ According to John. The gospel According to Paul etc. Different versions of events by the many disciplines of Jesus and how they remembered events. (Like the Hadith). The Quran on the other hand is direct and only one voice narrates the entire Quran. Only Allah speaks in the Quran. None of the companions of the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) are quoted directly or indirectly in the Quran. Muhammad (SAW) does not narrate the Quran. We learn about him in the verses. As we learn about Moses, Jesus (AS) etc. Moses (AS) is mentioned more times than Muhammad (SAW). If Muhammad (SAW) is the narrator of the Quran as some Christians believe would he not have mentioned himself more often? Allah refers to Himself as I and We in the Quran. We learn about about events which have come to pass which Prophet Muhammad (SAW) would never have known. Things like the sea/waters that never mix. planets, the sheer size and scale of the stars etc. Taking full credit for the narration. Allah recounts past events, foretells future events, tells us about the 🌍 , the beauty of the Angels “like scattered pearls “, the evil of Satan, the seen, the unseen and warns about sin and the punishment that awaits sinners in the afterlife. HE also tells us about the rewards that HE has prepared for the believers and the do gooders whether Muslim, Christian or Jew. The Quran is not just a book, it’s a comprehensive reference book, a guidance and a way of living for Muslims. A chapter for every life lesson from the foetus in the womb to death and beyond is covered in the Quran. Every time you read the Quran you learn something new. There is no religious book that can ever be compared to the Quran as there is no other book that has been recited by the Almighty Creator, except the Quran. Yes l have read the Bible (both versions).

[@IbrahimKhan-gv6cw]

@@wilfredsaldanha8238, stop being ignorant and disregarding the truth because of arrogance. Muhammad (blessings of Allah be upon him and peace) was the original conveyer of the message of Islam. We are his ambassadors as Muslims and his followers. And Prophethood is decreed through one being appointed by Allah as a prophet but Islamic belief (Ahmadi beliefs and other beliefs aren't Islamic) states that after Prophet Muhammad (blessings of Allah be upon him and peace) there will be no more Prophets!

[@JonathanDeLeon-em4px]

The Quran is the word of Allah according to Muhammed but also according to those who memorized his words. In addition, the Quran is also according to Abu Bakr who compiled its verses into writing. The Quran was later revised by caliph Uthman who burned all other versions of the Quran except his own. The Arabic Quran of today should therefore be called, "The Revised Version of Caliph Uthman." Watch the KZbin video, "The First Burn the Quran Day" for an expose' of how the Quran was created by Arabs.

[@JonathanDeLeon-em4px]

@karl drogo You're welcome. Glad to know there are seekers of the Truth out there.

[@sincerelyhumble643]

My friend the Quran is a direct relationship with God. His msg is spoke directly to the people. Its not narrated or filtered throughout a cult... Peace be with you

[@JonathanDeLeon-em4px]

@@sincerelyhumble643 Muhammed established the cult of Islam. It is he who speaks in the Quran and NOT God.

[@redaspect836]

Love your channel Paul. May God open all hearts to His oneness and the acceptance of all messengers’ and prophets’ exhorting the world to the final return. One other profound scholar to listen to Dr Ali Ataie.

[@JonathanDeLeon-em4px]

Muslims need to accept the apostle, Paul. He was more a messenger of God than Muhammed since he was an educated man who had studied the Jewish scriptures under the great rabbi, Gamaliel. Paul also had spiritual encounters with Jesus who revealed unto him the mysteries of the Gospel.

[@JonathanDeLeon-em4px]

Listen to pastor Al Fadi on KZbin. He is a former Sunni Muslim who now preaches the Gospel to Muslims.

[@tasdad2116]

Superb information explained so well. JazakAllah khair.

[@yussraa9556]

Great videos May Allah guide your heart and mind to His path

[@BloggingTheology]

Thank you! You too!

[@MrTisback]

Amazing brother. Keep up the good work!

[@asifsiddiqui9926]

Thanks for sharing this wisdom

[@BloggingTheology]

You are so welcome

[@Jsralla1800]

Thank you so much for sharing these insights!

[@BloggingTheology]

You are so welcome!

[@finalprophet813]

Great video, keep the good work up

[@Oliver_Tate]

Where have you been brother? Havent seen you for a long long time. Good to see you. May allah reward you for your efforts.

[@Fightrec]

I hope us men and generations pray to yearn knowledge and wisdom like this guy

[@izharehaq]

jazak Allah hu Khair brother in Islam Allah has given you knowledge

[@snekjuce]

Paul the evolution of your channel is stunningly beautiful, as we follow the evolution of your conscious mind; we too are taken on a journey of learning and growth. Thank you. I don't know if you ever thought that such subjects would even garner any attention but I guess it turned out better than we both thought haha. I wish you well, and I do hope to other viewers to view these with a critical mind and not a prejudiced and divisive one. (i am sure it's been said before, but "this channel deserves way more subscribers" is something i'd like to reiterate lol.) from a 27 year old Californian.

[@muslimguardian6514]

Asalamualikum Paul, love to learn from you. keep moving.

[@minhajmirza721]

To ALL who keep repeating the comment of “Why dont you become Muslim “? Muslim means submitting 100% to GOD. Anyone who believes in the ONEness of god, beleive in all the prophets is already a Muslim. There is no need for advertisement of being a Muslim. GOD / ALLAH sees the heart.

[@BloggingTheology]

Well said Minhaj.

[@ibrahim187]

True. You dont need to say any shahada before some cheikh to certify that you submit to God, or give yourself an arabic name. God suffises as a witness to our submission to Him. Making peace with God is not some fancy "welcome to the club" religion like most people makes it to be.

[@gloryanseeh154]

Islam is not only a beliefth but also a system' of life.

[@pristinelawncare6968]

No my brother , one MUST confess with the tongue!!

[@pristinelawncare6968]

@heera rodriguez the Prophet (SAS) said that he was commanded to fight the enemy until they said the shahadatyen. And the Prophet's uncle Abu Talib believed that the religion of the Prophet was the best religion of the people and he died with that belief yet Allah SWT did not allow the prophet to pray for him because he was not a believer. Shiekh Muhammad Salih Al-Munajjid said: If a person accepts Islam out of conviction , and begins to practice it, then he is a muslim, even if he doesn't register his Islam officially, or go to a court or Islamic center to obtain documentation, or announce it to others. If such a person dies, then we hope for Paradise for him and pray for mercy for him. I hope that this is sufficient for you my brother in Islam. Salamu alaikum wa rahmatullah.

[@irfaansulaiman8373]

It's amazing how Truth sounds and is so obvious

[@irfaansulaiman8373]

​@@muslimhussain786 WOW. What an amazing piece of works. TBH, I haven't heard of *_Tawafuq_* before this. Jazakallah for sharing this and all the awesome references, and for the time taken.👏✍ Your commentary is beautifully laid out! Salute! 🙏👍 PS. I've taken a snapshot of this commentary because I most definitely want to take this further in understanding

[@RynneFdin]

@@muslimhussain786 Jazakillah Khairan brother. May Allah bless you

[@azlanameer4912]

Very interesting video. Thanks

[@maydarwiche5816]

It’s very important to note that Islam doesn’t claim that it’s a new religion but rather a continuation of the two previous Abrahamic religions. What it alleges, though, is that it came to correct the misconceptions and hearsay that seeped into those religions. As a word, Islam means peace and submission to God.

[@xaviermathai8466]

How can it be the countnuation of previous religions. The ideologies are totally different.. Islam is not a region it is a political ideology.

[@dwacts17apologetics54]

It is a not a continuation why you trying to make the quran sound relevant? The shit copies everything from the Bible and from old Jewish stories that didn’t qualify to be in the Bible and then Mohamed claims he got revelations. It can’t a be a continuation yet deny almost everything about the books prio to it and make up a completely new ideology whilst borrowing texts from the same books that it claims are not fit. Madness and confusing is what I call Islam.

[@amersekic8535]

@@dwacts17apologetics54 you already know it's absurd to say it copied other books since there was no way of that since no jew who lived in Arabia accused Muhammad of such. He was illiterate he didn't write It by his own hands, he would just recite it and his companions would write that down on the spot. They never knew when will new revelation come. Its so absurd there is no word to explain how idiotic your claims are except i remain silent about that. Its pretty much logical that it came to fix its predecessors since Bible or should i say Injeel was turned into Bible, and Injeel was original Book which was is in arameic, which Romans changed completely into latin which is also one sign of plagiarism. Also Torah isnt just part of Bible as old script but they have their own remainings which jews read on their religious events. Its really wierd to say jews and christians since both books were intented to jews, 'Isaa was jew by his mother and was sent to jews to make some laws easier on them. Qur'an describes their laws in details how Allah ordered them to do. Qur'an came to complete originals not these pale copies that were changed over and over again. So in their root they all share same Source that is God One and Only, and messegners who all had same mission, to call people to worship Allah only. If they all share the same message which was unfortunately changed by their people who were idiots that didnt want to accept Allahs rules how can you say that anything is copied since it comes from the same Source? Nonsense. It just came to correct all changes they have made out of their hipocrisy and to show them that they can't ever overshadow Allahs true rulership.

[@olive3186]

May Darwiche ALLAH found in the BIBLE MUST WATCH kzbin.info/www/bejne/qpDOeIV8qLSji8U

[@dwacts17apologetics54]

@@amersekic8535 first of all I like how you choose an area less contradictory, you are forcing the narrative by skipping areas I want you to talk about. Talk about how fake the dude was, prophecies are not supposed to be personal, but for some reason everything he revealed was designed to cater his needs.... he’s says only 4 wives but he gets 11 😂😂😂😂. He marries his adopted child wife and some how allah shows him a prophecy that make it okay. This dude made allah ( the Muslim good) look very childish and always changing his mind clearly this allah can’t see the future because he tells him this then later on changes and tell him that. So either the allah is fake or Mohamed was making up things he sees fit. He’s the worse curse the earth has ever had. Everything about him is terrible, his life choices, he’s greedy and hate, nothing about this guy makes an average personal better if he chooses to follow him. He calls Christians and Jews and the unbelievers the worse of creatures and that they should be killed unless they accept and surrender to Allah and Mohamed. Why would God force you to love him? Why would God want you to do his work if he’s all powerful and all knowing? Of course the muslim allah is weak that he seeks mere muhamads to do his job. Same Muslims you find them hating the west because of the lifestyle yet fight and risk their lives to get here. If Islam is soo perfect why don’t Muslims stick to their majorities and have peace and harmony there? Truth is their regimes are backwards and have behaviors that don’t support a modern society and Mohamed is to blame for that. If you see all religion from a critical point of view, Islam is the worse because they have no grounds to stand on.

[@adnankhursheed]

Great video sir! May Allah bless you with happy healthy new year.

[@rashidhakim7021]

With, Success & Prosperity, in This brief Existence, As well as In The Eternal Times, which MUST come after This! Ameen

[@jing2581]

Great selection of passages.

[@ranjah007]

You are truly a remarkable individual. I do wish that fate would allow us to share a cup of tea one day In sha Allah.

[@echumico1503]

My Allah bless you, brother paul

[@amjadmalik7285]

Great commentary!

[@BloggingTheology]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@AhmedAli-sr5jp]

Assalamualaykum rahmatAllahi wa barkatahu another good one Paul......l thanks

[@rostembouaziz992]

so Blessed to find ur chanel sir

[@BloggingTheology]

Thanks and welcome

[@amjadmalik7285]

This guy Paul is a true scholar. He is always factual & reports things truthfully.

[@comecarltd550]

Well, what I see is just the reading to us of some pages from two Muslim scholars' books about their qur'an. Is this what is called true scholarship? Do you just pick a book and read to people and claim that is scholarship? Unfortunately, all what he has read has been seriously challenged and even fall apart from the same Islamuc historical sources. A bit more and rather a serious study could be needed apart from reading some pages of two books.

[@BloggingTheology]

@@comecarltd550 fair point

[@moozoshaj4397]

@@comecarltd550 Nothing nice then better to not say anythink

[@derekallen4568]

Ask yourself why one muslim has won a nobel prize for science in the last one hundred years. Population 1.7billion. 43 Jewish scientists out of 15million have won it. That should tell you a story. We saw what happened to egypt when they attacked Israel 1967. They left their tanks and their boots in the desert and ran.

[@piruz3243]

@@derekallen4568 I don't know what your comment has to do with this thread. I suppose you want to say that there is a correlation between winning the Nobel prize and the religion which the winner follows. I won't argue whether that is or is not a discriminatory opinion, but I ask you to consider an alternative correlation. About one fifth of Nobel laureates have been Jewish. Also, well over 90% of all the winners, regardless of religion, have been of European descent. About 95% of Jewish winners have not been Israelis. And only four or five of the Jewish winners have been Mizrahim, about 2% of all Jewish laureates. So maybe the stronger correlation is between being a Westerner and winning the Nobel prize. This makes more sense as at this point in history, the Western world is much more advanced. If being Jewish were the stronger factor, one would have expected to see a lot more Mizrahim winners. Having said all of this, there is no denying that (mainly Western) Jews are vastly overrepresented as laureates, which is probably the result of their overrepresentation in academia.This is probably a very positive cultural trait. Let's hope it remains that way, as humanity is very much indebted to them. Have a great day, my friend 🌹🌹

[@MuslimBro7865]

Ma shaa Allah. New subscriber here

[@BloggingTheology]

Excellent

[@angelicabalisnomo7155]

Assalamaleikum warahmatulahi wabarakatuh hope your channel grows! You deserve it In Shaa Allah 🤗

[@samwon1]

Another super topic, another video.

[@yusufbackshi9459]

very well said sir, thank you....

[@hnsfamily]

Hadith: the prophet sas has said two things a man can’t get enough of in this world of knowledge and money . Allah guides who he wants and misguides who he wants it’s up to him.

[@rafique-fy2iw]

Very2 informative for me.. TQ brother Paul..

[@curiousmind90]

Excellent Job 👍 it would be great if you write it in your blog or Fb group in text format.

[@akinlabiakeemfemi-crown8398]

Good analysis by Bro. Paul. God bless you sir

[@BloggingTheology]

Thank you kindly

[@lbo2726]

Well done brother Paul.

[@lbo2726]

Just to clarify my position on Al Quran, I have no question on authecity, trueness, of Al Quran as Al Quran is the word of Allah Taala, the Al mighty and the creator of the universe.

[@Amg187uk]

Thank you very insightful.

[@BloggingTheology]

Glad it was helpful!

[@shaikhahmed7929]

I believe this needs to be answered or at least responded to in the very basic manner, the question you left in the video description. Within Islamic faith, there are few core beliefs that supersedes everything else. One of them is accepting and knowing by heart that everything is by the will of god. Whether you understand it (meaning, if you know why something happens) or not. If someone dives deep into the interpretation on quran will find that it's verses can be categorised into several classes. Some are about fundamental islamic beliefs like the Sura Ekhlas (3rd chapter from the last), some verses contain rulings and guidelines about daily lives, economics, state running, rules of war, raising family etc, some verses are about historical events, some are spiritual guidelines, warnings etc. And there is also a category of verses which don't seem to belong to the above classes. They seem to provide a glimps to some higher form of knowledge but then stays very short and concise. As if allah wants the reader to ponder upon these verses and try to interpret them in the right context, like why allah has said this, what allah actually hinting us these with, or what exactly it indicates to. This is where modern science opens the door to many answers. As we understand, in science there is nothing as a definitive last word, because everything is subject to change based on new knowledge. The more science advances, the more knowledge it creates and we have newer perspective to look at things. So science actually works as a tool to interpret quran. Then again, if something can't be alligned with todays scientific discoveries, then Muslim go back to the original belief, "everything is by god's will. If we can't explain it, then perhaps our study of nature isn't close enough". So in that sense, there's nothing like a modern adaptation of quran. Instead, we are in a constant journey to a complete understanding of the quran. This angle actually welcomes more effort into study and research of the things that are still unanswered.

[@oyunoyun4711]

Best wishes from Turkey to Mr. Paul and my religious müslim brothers. i hope you are all in good health and happiness.... i am extremely sad that why Christian know about jesus in wrong way . jesus is never died on cross because if you read prophet's history you will know All of them overcome their enemies. Because God(Allah) always help to prophets ....

[@MrStegha]

Cette chaîne est magnifique..on devrait pouvoir traduire son contenu en Français et en espagnol..sous titrage ..au mieux une traduction vocale..

[@sweetcoffee2458]

I speak French and Arabic. I'd love to help translate his videos!

[@MrStegha]

Merci pour l'attention que vous accordez au contenu de ce site ..je vais informer le webmaster de votre disponibilité.... pour la traduction..peut être trouveriez vous un terrain d'entente avec lui Merci

[@abdulqadirgooni607]

Masha Allah very fascinating books read by great learned Muslim. Jazakallahu khayr❤. I wonder if you could help me find the full titles of the two books 📚 🤔

[@imranb4985]

Keep up the good work sir.

[@salmanakbar2380]

An honest representation of the how Quran is different from Bible.

[@mahmoodrdalla]

@@wilfredsaldanha8238 look between the lines and you will find only the important details about the hestorical events in the "stories" of the quran. The big difference is that the quran is written in the shortist length possible for a text with that much info. So every letter is idealy placed and contributes to the meaning and the indications of the text. Thats why in order to be critic you have to study arabic and then spend many years studying the book.

[@Tumbleweedpassingby]

@@wilfredsaldanha8238 Ah yeah I do wonder how satan starts the chapter with, "I seek refuge in God from the satan the outcasted one" quite ironic.

[@Tumbleweedpassingby]

@@wilfredsaldanha8238 Satanic verses, how your recommending it to the newborn babies makes quite a sense from your point of view because you have this perverted idea that babies are born with SIN.

[@Tumbleweedpassingby]

@@wilfredsaldanha8238 Next time you read about a criminal, why dont you take The blame loving christian/fanatic. We are not born with sin im not responsible for The sin of Adam and eve. When we reach maturity then we start to sin,when we know The diffrence between right and wrong and we choose to do one of them. A baby doesnt know whats right and whats wrong usually there a term for such person,spoiler alert (INNOCENT). For us to be born with sin we have to inherintly know The diffrence between right and wrong rooted in The heart ❤️ looking forward to the day we can convict babies. Your ideology is full bullshit and could actually create a club for all The tyrants throughout history pharoah is included or King your god doesnt know The diffrence.

[@Tumbleweedpassingby]

@@wilfredsaldanha8238 Wavering mind? Your God is The one Who keeps changing his mind.For God so love The world........ He didnt send himself 😂😂😂😂🤦‍♀️. You guys where never forgiven you just paid a debt, thats not forgiveness.

[@toolsnthings5539]

very good insight

[@elm34536]

Jazak allah khair br

[@MoroccanARROWS]

Why do Muslims hesitate to "adapt" the Quran to the needs of the modern age ? This is a bad/wrong question (one who knew the core of Islam, they wouldn't formulate such a question). *Quran is a divine guideline from the Creator fitting every time and every place. It is up to the Creatures to get on line with Quran not the opposite.*

[@richdelarby9387]

@heera rodriguez Adnan Ibrahim is a MD.....he shouldnt issue Fiqh statement

[@richdelarby9387]

@heera rodriguez i m a structural steel engineer .....i dont let my welders/ technicians / labour people BShitting me. So if you wanna issue high level analyzis on a subject you need to do a minimum of schooling.

[@richdelarby9387]

@Rayrad 696 yahweh is the arabic meaning of "God of Love" ....Judaism is just an ancient arab cult and jews are just an ancient arab tribe

[@richdelarby9387]

@Rayrad 696 true christians ? The Messiah didnt come up with no new religion.

[@richdelarby9387]

@Rayrad 696 peace be upon Him and his holy mother the virgin Mary. Read the Bible in its original language.

[@shirufaanrushdhee5241]

OMG.. all those books must be heaven.. i'm so jealous..!

[@omotosotajudeen9741]

Me too, it's appreciated.

[@anonamos3287]

Wonderful insight into diferent scriptures. Just one point, what people understand about things can change and over time, what was seen as an important tradition to be guarded, in modern times can see seen for what it really re-presents, take for instance the tradition of not putting ones mouth on a bottle of water when drinking it, no one back at the time knew how bacteria spread and grow on surfaces, but now we know what is actually happening when we leave saliva on the utensils we use. So we can know more deeply things that were just seen as a tradition to follow and protect, so we do not need to walk around in ignorant blind faith if knowledge gives us a clearer under-standing why to act correctly. Many Islamic traditions are now just followed blinding while ignoring the greater truths they hold, so have become empty hollow actions, that hold no intrinsic value to life, devoid of their proper purposes.

[@tapsumbong5691]

I hope your channel grows larger in'sha'allah

[@BloggingTheology]

Big thanks

[@arsenalfanpage3767]

We need like u to tell the truth eventhough the quran always defend by itself alhamdulilaaah i hope u also become muslim insha allaaaah❤❤❤❤

[@quranforhumanity9024]

Humans need to adapt to the Quran and not the other way round. If Quran adapts to needs of human, the utility and purpose of the Quran will be lost. It's not appropriate to interpret Quran in context of a small era of time or limited geographical location.

[@wahidulislam3143]

Very true

[@omarn7650]

@@albertnehmat7093 Today, we will be talking about a scientific fact, mentioned in the Quran, regarding the male reproductive system. It is important to point out that while the Quran is not a science textbook, many of the latest scientific discoveries that were revealed in Quranic passages 1400 years ago. This is in stark contrast with the Bible, which contains numerous scientific errors (due to corruption by the scribes: (Jer 8:8, Mat 5:20, 23:13). For example, regarding genetics, in Genesis 30:37-42, Jacob changes the characteristics of animal offspring by having their parents look at white stripes while mating. FIRST We will examine the Quranic verse that describes the location of seminal fluid prior to being discharged. Literal translation of Quran 86:6-7: { (Man is) created from gushing water (which) comes out from between the backbone * and the ribs *. } * from Al Qamoos, Lisan Al Arab, etc In other words, just prior to gushing or coming out of the body, seminal fluid is located between the backbone and the ribs. At first glance, a layman might think that SEMEN comes out from the testicles. While the SPERM is produced in the testicles, NEITHER is the sperm NOR is the seminal fluid (essential for natural fertilization) anywhere near them prior to ejaculation. The verse specifically mentions the entire fluid, and not just the sperm “component”. So let’s examine the process of emission, where all the components of semen are joined. Sperm is stored in the epididymis, which is not in the testicles, but above them. The Sperm which comprises 2 to 5% of the seminal fluid, , travels from the epididymis up through the Vas Deferens duct and around the bladder. Together, the seminal vesicle and the prostate gland produce 90% of the fluid in semen. This mixture travels through the prostate and is joined by mucus from the bulbourethral glands, just below the prostate. www.webmd.com/sex-relationships/guide/male-reproductive-system?page=2 en.allexperts.com/e/s/se/semen.htm  en.allexperts.com/e/e/ej/ejaculation.htm It is at this point that semen is fully formed, comprising both the sperm and the seminal fluids. As we can see, just prior to coming out of the body, all components of semen are mixed near the prostate, which is centered in the body, between the backbone and the ribs, or between the spine and the chest, which is between the back and front of the abdomen or torso, and most certainly not in the testicles or in the lower body at all. Someone might object by saying: the ribs are too high to say “the prostate is between the backbone & the ribs.” To this objection, we answer that: the head is still between the shoulders even though it is too high, & the genitals are still between the legs, even though they are too high. Now let’s check the verse again. { (Man is) created from gushing water (which) comes out from between the backbone * and the ribs *. } This precise scientific description could not have been known 1400 years ago, and even today most people don’t know it, as we will see next. SECOND We will examine some false claims regarding the scientific accuracy of this verse. In reference to this verse, answering-islam.org quotes mistake by Dr. William Campbell: “…we are left with the very real problem that the SEMEN IS COMING FROM the back or kidney area and not THE TESTICLES.” answering-islam.org/Quran/Science/semenproduction.htm www.answering-islam.org/Campbell/s4c2b.html In fact, SEMEN does NOT come from the testicles. (only the SPERM is produced there, which comprises 2-5% of semen). And as we saw earlier, SEMEN IS ACTUALLY FORMED NEAR THE PROSTATE. Next, let’s also listen to the false claims of the person discussislam: “This description reflects the view of Hippocrates, common in the 5th century…that SEMEN comes from all the fluid of the body & passes through the kidneys on the way to the penis. We now know that it comes from the testicles.” First of all, DISCUSSISLAM also falsely claims semen comes from the testicles “We now know that it comes from the testicles”. It’s astonishing how those attacking Islam make the same layman errors, without checking their facts. In any case, The Quran does not contain the scientific errors of Hippocrates view 1) That Semen comes from all the fluid in the body. 2) That Semen passes through the kidneys. As such, contrary to DISCUSSISLAM’s misrepresentation, there is no similarity whatsoever, between this Quranic passage, and the view of Hippocrates. Furthermore, let’s examine some more of Hippocrates related scientific errors, that are again NOT in the Quran: 1) sperm originate in the brain 2) men & women produce sperm 3) “healthy” sperm is produced by healthy parts of the body 4) stronger sperm results in males, weaker sperm results in females IN CONCLUSION The Quran clearly mentions the scientific fact, before it was known, about where semen becomes fully formed before “gushing” out. Semen includes the sperm AND seminal fluids, which are BOTH absolutely required for natural fertilization. The Quran accurately states that this fluid (gushing water) is between the backbone and the ribs prior to coming out of the body, as seen from the profile view of the male anatomy. Those attempting to discredit this Quranic verse, simply demonstrate their own lack of scientific knowledge regarding the male reproductive system. In addition, trying to ascribe the numerous scientific accuracies from the Quran, to philosophers like Hippocrates, who could rarely AVOID scientific errors on any matter, is obviously quite ridiculous. As we have demonstrated, misrepresenting both the scientific facts, and the views of ancient societies, is not only the strategy but a fundamental requirement for people attempting to refute the Quran’s overwhelming signs.

[@omarn7650]

@@albertnehmat7093 Semen is formed in an area known as the Seminal vesicle.

[@johnbravo1317]

​@@albertnehmat7093 my guess is you got this from CP and if you did I just want to tell you that he is a liar, he says stupid shit and curses other religions , I saw his videos and they are embarrassing and funny for someone who understands Islam his followers are Cristian and they believe his nonsense that explains why he doesn't show his face and why no Muslim scholars take him seriously , he is a joke and an embarrassment to Christians.

[@dsr4902]

@@albertnehmat7093 bring your proof please stupid paganism underwear zombie naked worshiper

[@mohabatkhanmalak1161]

Good point at 5.56, and I quote you "The passage of centuries cannot erode the words of God, that after all is the point of a divine intervention in the affairs of this world. The Revelation is located in time, but it is itself timeless". On the passage of time, people have really not changed with the passing of time. Two, three, five thousand years ago people faced the same toils and challenges that we have today. We may work in a factory, office or farm carrying a mobile phone but we face the same life challenges as people of the ancient world, only they had different tools. They got married, had families, got sick, travelled to markets etc and we do the same. The fundamental principle of "Mankind on this earth and his relationship with his Lord" remains the same.

[@robd3470]

Morality is in the heart of the enacter.. Once there is awareness of suffering, there comes morality . This is a truth since the of dawn of mankind. Once enlightenment enters your heart, the need for reformation is of the utmost duty.

[@hamzahrahmat4883]

Simple and clear

[@akassimkassim3252]

لَّا يَأْتِيهِ الْبَاطِلُ مِن بَيْنِ يَدَيْهِ وَلَا مِنْ خَلْفِهِ ۖ تَنزِيلٌ مِّنْ حَكِيمٍ حَمِيدٍ

[@hkicgh7277]

صدق الله العظيم

[@hondashiine8973]

وصدق رسوله الكريم

[@Thewatchman303]

Great succint narrative! Super useful

[@BloggingTheology]

👍👍

[@khaledali-jr7nb]

Very sweet, thank you.

[@balqeessuleiman5504]

Thank you.

[@BloggingTheology]

you are most welcome

[@balqeessuleiman5504]

@@BloggingTheology most is nice😆

[@deliciousrhd3237]

Paul is so amazing..stay blessed

[@BloggingTheology]

fake news

[@peaceinjesus5221]

There is indeed a further question that must be asked about Akhtar's statement and it concerns this line: "addressed to a man, fully known to his contemporaries and to subsequent history *a man living in only two geographical locations in the same country."* We may fairly ask that if these "two geographical locations" that are the "only" places he "lived in", being "Mecca" and "Medina", where is an original ancient map of this period, around the 7th century, with these cities labelled on it, to prove that these locations actually existed? There exist some later and modern maps which have placed these two locations on what is supposed to be a rendition of a 7th century map, but can anyone actually prove it from an original map, or was Mecca either a non existent or irrelevant location if it is not marked on any authentic 7th century map? The point is, that if Mecca cannot be identified on an authentic map of the early centuries, then this calls into serious question, the Islamic historical narrative that claims that Mecca in Saudi Arabia is the birthplace of these things! Can anyone find such a valid map (not a later rendition with Mecca marked on it, but the map from the actual time period)? If no such map exists, then the story of Islam and Mecca cannot in fact be true as we have received it!

[@solako3896]

Islam brings special happiness to the heart ❤

[@ateeqn1985]

SubhanAllah

[@rashidhakim7021]

Indeed, Subhan-ALLAH!!