Why Israel’s War Cabinet is About to Collapse

TLDR News: ‪@TLDRnews‬
TLDR News EU: ‪@TLDRnewsEU‬
TLDR News Global: ‪@TLDRnewsGLOBAL‬
TLDR Business: ‪@TLDRbusiness‬
TLDR Daily: ‪@TLDRdaily‬
Despite the ICC submitting an arrest request for Netanyahu, the Israeli wartime government continues to be frustrated with the pace of the war in Gaza, leading many to suspect that Israel's war cabinet is about to collapse.
🎞 TikTok: / tldrnews
💡 Got a Topic Suggestion? - forms.gle/mahEFmsW1yGTNEYXA
Support TLDR on Patreon: / tldrnews
Donate by PayPal: tldrnews.co.uk/funding
Our mission is to explain news and politics in an impartial, efficient, and accessible way, balancing import and interest while fostering independent thought.
TLDR is a completely independent & privately owned media company that's not afraid to tackle the issues we think are most important. The channel is run by a small group of young people, with us hoping to pass on our enthusiasm for politics to other young people. We are primarily fan sourced with most of our funding coming from donations and ad revenue. No shady corporations, no one telling us what to say. We can't wait to grow further and help more people get informed. Help support us by subscribing, engaging and sharing. Thanks!
//////////////////////
1 - / 1790438175003033902
2 - • Israel war cabinet mem...
3 - www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c...
4 - www.ft.com/content/27041f14-3...
5 - / 1792113019805118926
6 - www.politico.com/news/magazin...
7 - www.timesofisrael.com/ben-gvi...
8 - / the-chances-of-a-israe...
9 - • Israel war cabinet mem...
10 - / 1790438175003033902
11 - / the-chances-of-a-israe...
00:00 - Introduction
01:04 - Context
03:12 - Why the War Cabinet is Collapsing
05:40 - What Happens Next?
06:49 - Sponsored Content

[@TLDRnewsGLOBAL]

CORRECTION: At 3:05 we show the party symbol for Smotrich's Religious Zionism party when we're actually talking about Gantz's National Unity party. Apologies for this sloppy error; we hope you nonetheless enjoy the video!

[@safiya1629]

6:32 did you guys just quote a "Andalusian Horseman" as a source

[@Rigoosh]

I was just about to say something regarding this mistake and I like the fact you beat me to it :) BUT this is not the first mistake I find on your videos regarding Israel (a false map of Israel and the Palestinian territory), that video was hosted by the same person and I am starting to think that the team up between your editor and this presenter should be re-evaluated.

[@caynebyron]

Seems like you guys make a lot of sloppy errors nearly every video.

[@ryoukaip]

​@@caynebyronso true, like there's no QA or something

[@habeebmakhoul7173]

did you just call Israeli settlers going into Gaza - "Jewish immigrants"??? they are not immigrants they are criminals under international law!!!

[@Ar1AnX1x]

Netanyahu not even mentioning any plans as to what happens to Gazans after the war is definitely not suspicious at all

[@garethrasmussen6186]

what would you do?

[@shafsteryellow]

​@@garethrasmussen6186pls say you're being sarcastic

[@kfiraltberger552]

He said in a cnn interview that he does not plan to settle Gaza. But if that's his only option, he'll do it to survive in office

[@zrusit9640]

There is plausible accusation of genocide pending at the ICJ and probably even arest warrants. Everyone with half a brain can infer what is Netanyahu planning for Gaza.

[@fabiofernandes9122]

probably bcs he doesnt want what happened to the USA in afghanistan to happen to him. its no their responsibility to raise gaza when the gazan are the primary responsibles for the destruction of their home.

[@dannydenison6253]

"be replaced" is putting it very nicely.

[@PacmanBrunner]

Kind of how like the true Israelities were replaced. The original Hebrew people were Black.

[@tinypie9659]

​@@PacmanBrunner Wake up

[@PacmanBrunner]

@@tinypie9659 Already woke up. Now its ur turn.

[@quacksayssquawk2899]

@@PacmanBrunner Mate they were not black, they were a Semitic people. They probably looked something like modern day Iraqi Jews or Palestinian Arabs

[@gabor6259]

The Israelis will live in the ruins with no running water or electricity, sure.

[@ORO323]

Hasn’t his popularity plummeted after the Hamas attack? To the point where they expect him to resign after the war is over? It wouldn’t surprise me if he prolonged the war for the sole reason of maintaining his grip on power.

[@zurielsss]

Don’t underestimate the snake

[@rasmussundin637]

My headcannon as well

[@pollbun7490]

That is his exact strategy

[@Peter-hs7zn]

They should have sacked the war criminal on Oct 8th This was all his plan to stay in power anyway. No security and knew of attack .

[@greenredblue]

You're a few weeks late to the party on that conclusion. Thomas Friedman (Pulitzer prize winning NYT columnist and widely respected authority on the Israel/Palestine conflict) has been pointing out for quite a while that Bibi has perverse incentives here, because when active fighting ends he's likely going straight to jail.

[@Legion617]

Netenyahu is literally surviving only because of the war's existence. The moment the war ends, his career, and probably his life, will come crashing down instantly regardless of how the war ends.

[@merrybr6937]

The newly arised mindset is that war is a #waste.

There's always something saving him

[@bboykabir2]

the Sponsored Content part on every video is always +10% volume😂

[@Ipsissimus]

Use sponsorblock extension.

[@JustAnotherAccount8]

It's a psychological trick. Cable TV has been doing it for decades with the ads being louder than the show

[@amh9494]

​@@JustAnotherAccount8pishes me off every time and makes me not but the products.

[@moonshot9056]

@@amh9494 I refuse to buy things, even if i want them if i see them on an ad, hate all this forced consumerism sh**, i understand why they take sponsors and i have no issue with it, but i refuse to support ads.

[@amh9494]

@@moonshot9056 agreed for the most part, there are incredibly rare ads that are truly interesting/entertaining/educational that I make exception for.

[@Voyage.001]

Saudis: We will normalize with you if the two state solution happens. Israelis: No for two state solution, but we want normalization with you. Saudis: ….???

[@shootershooter9079]

2 state solution seems great on paper but it has very big risk of both these to states again going to war in future and now its kind of become a frequent war between Israel and Palestine (or hamas) which restart every few years and create a humanitarian crisis for normal people who just want to live

[@luciferkotsutempchannel]

@@shootershooter9079An independent Palestine can form a defense pact with the rest of the Arab world, and an Israel that doesn’t have territorial disputes can seek an exemption to the “European” requirement for joining NATO. Though NATO might pull the Greece/Turkey approach in that situation and demand Israel and Palestine be admitted simultaneously. Assuming Palestine can form a proper democracy. There’s a lot of potential pathways to peace in a 2 state solution.

[@shootershooter9079]

@@luciferkotsutempchannel Lets consider ur scenario first all the major Arab countries r dependent on us security guarantees (and spend heavily on us military hardware) none of them have a actual strong armed forces second till now even non north atlantic territories of nato nations is not included in that pact so its very unlikely they will allow israel to join and let suppose even if they allow Israel to join then now technically us is guaranting security to both parties does us want to do this no us president will push us deep into conflicts with very less gains when they have looming risk of china and loosing their global power and even if some us president want to do so us people will not allow it (large part of us population don't even like giving aid to Ukraine so giving security guarantee to palestine and Israel they rnt going to support it) Then there is hamas(self proclaimed representative of Palestine) and Iran proxy and will iran stop funding and arming them and let its years of work in making hamas go into vain when it can use it to stop a alliance between Israel and Arab states like Saudi etc no they will keep aiding them and arming them so terrorism will be there as it is now. And hamas elite will not like to loose their grip on gaza so they will attack Israel again and again to stay relevant and keep supporting goals of iran. Now democracy can't be applied when there r people who want to consolidate power if u blindly put democracy into place authoritarian regimes will find their way like happened in russia So again ur solution looks good in theory but can't be applied practically

[@eranhaim9913]

The Saudis couldn’t care less about the palestinians. This is an American demand and Israel have historically did everything to have two states and to move on. But turns out once the pals control a territory they turn it into a terror base so we have to stay in there. Also the west bank has notable Jewish old cities like Hebron, Bethlehem, Jericho, Scheme, etc that some people view as too valuable for us to give up on.

[@luciferkotsutempchannel]

@@eranhaim9913 “Israel has historically did everything to have two states” Why ya fuckin’ lying? Settling into palestines land is not “doing everything to have two states”.

[@StarterOffical-Jousha-lf6ig]

This is what happens when you have Benjamin Franklin at home

[@sebresludolf9611]

Bruhhhhh

[@shafsteryellow]

This is Adolf

[@Theaudacity787]

lol

[@shy404usernotfound]

Ben Franklin lived in England for 16 years and his parents were immigrants.... from Britain.

[@StarterOffical-Jousha-lf6ig]

@@shy404usernotfound you forgot the "Jamin" in Ben

[@azizithelethargic9229]

" *American-European* -Arab-Palestinian Security Administration to "manage" Gaza" Seriously. How does anyone in the right mind and knowledge in history would think this is a good idea?

[@Stixxs254]

Soon Netanyahu will have an international arrest warrant. But the US would invade Den Haag :DD

[@nxtlvlnlkr5312]

Even if the warrant is approved, no one will arrest Netanyahu, he can just stay in Israel or move to the US.

[@kims4149]

Article 5 in action! NATO turning against the Americans 😂

[@jared4walsh]

if he leaves Isreal.

[@snow-n-gel]

sure. hamas wars advancing. they are rats playing with everyone in UN, ICC...

[@zurielsss]

NATO invades NATO 😂

[@_utahraptor]

I was about to start studying why did you guys have to upload now

[@StarterOffical-Jousha-lf6ig]

Bruh💀

[@hoteny]

Bro will be like “8 minutes of good watch. Then I wait till next hour :00”

[@user-op8fg3ny3j]

Watch on x3 speed

[@SJokes]

Nah same

[@davidescristofaros2241]

​@@hoteny literally me

[@de132]

These are very troubling times indeed.

[@PacmanBrunner]

Troubling for ppl who live lies. Israelite people were originally Black.

[@cavalex]

​@@PacmanBrunner what?

[@PacmanBrunner]

@@cavalex Ther will be universal peace in the world only when we accept that all ancient people especially the Israelites are and were Black, the same Black folk in the USA today

[@warweasel2832]

Housing crises all over, massive unemployment and underemployment even in the countries where jobs are traditionally outsourced to, Strong-man politicians threatening war and escalation. It seems like we're entering the later part of the 1930s. 2025 will probably be our '39

[@gilkujawski7023]

No Israeli outlet suggested a civil war scenario. The article you showed is merely a medium post by undisclosed "Andalusian Horsman"- which I never heard about. The chairman of the Histadrut (Israel’s biggest trade union) already indicated that if elections won’t be announced in the short term he’ll set a public strike- which is something no prime minister can fight against. So- election will be held, with Netanyahu trying to push the date to after Nov. 5- the US elections, with the narcissistic idea that a Trump win will lead Israelis to support Netanyahu (the so-called "friend of Trump", which is BS ).

[@ZuLKiNG]

Even worse, Andalus is the Arabic name for Spain when they held it.

[@LordDoof]

"Andalusian Horseman" kek, that's a pretty obvious pseud in terms of what they stand for. However he may be half right, Israel was on the brink of ripping itself to shreds with IDF strikes looming before Oct. 7th. It's not implausible to see Israel having some sort of coup or uprising if the crazy fundamentalists keep trying to push the envelope.

[@julianchristensen7350]

​@@ZuLKiNGyes, but there is also a Spanish region called Andalusia and the people who live there are called Andalusians.

[@ZuLKiNG]

@@julianchristensen7350 great, neither is going to be a legitimate Israeli outlet then. Andalusian Spaniards are not Israeli either. Therefore there is no "Israeli outlet talking about civil war".

[@jamessloven2204]

Wait, why would there be a civil war? If there are calls for civil war, you should talk about it, and not just put it in for bait.

[@shadowtimez2452]

And Norway, Spain and Ireland will soon recognize Palestine

[@SkepticalGuy23]

They will recognise the Palestine created in 1948, alongside Israel. That is not want Hamas or the PLO want, they want from the river to the sea ie no Israel. Spain, Norway and Ireland are all on Israel’s side against Hamas and the PLO.

[@geofftottenperthcoys9944]

@@snow-n-gel Piss off!

[@hahdhsh401]

@@snow-n-gel Norway Muslim country?😅 they got like 4% Muslim and Ireland is like 5

[@imammurrahsstudent8905]

143 countries who recognise Palestine are also Islamic ??​@@snow-n-gel

[@user-df1ns1ob8y]

@@snow-n-gelThey are far from having the largest muslim population in Europe and Ireland has always been pro-Palestine.

[@roscaris6541]

Would the ICC prosecution decision harm Netanyahu domestically, or have no effect, or maybe even help him?

[@user-pc7ym1we5q]

It may hurt him a bit but his base of voters wil vote for him no matter what and he is already not popular among other Israelis.

[@user-pc7ym1we5q]

On the other hand the ICC prosecution may seem to Israelis as an external attempt to influence the war and Nethanyahoo could try and use it as the reason for the failure to remove Hamas in the war.

[@mkvenner2]

Netanyahu is politically screwed no matter what if Israeli history is anything to go by.

[@yotadisigma]

Domestically, it has already helped to re-unite the war cabinet temporarily, but Netanyahu is so disliked by the Israeli public, I don't think it will have an impact on him at all long term.

[@user-xw3vi4nk2y]

It will help him. It creates a seige mentality in population.

[@none7574]

Did you know Netanyahus real name is milkovski hes a European jew. Another startling fact is every Israeli pm has changed thier names to sound more middle Eastern. Now it may be trivial but why change your name? What's more damaging is the UK backs milkovskis genocide.

[@JerzyFeliksKlein]

Actually it was his father who changed his so Bibi was born Nethanyahu. And it was Mileikovsky.

[@GreatgoatonFire]

Who are the people talking about civil war?

[@CommissarMoody1]

Most likely Alarmist and people looking for click bait titles.

[@caseclosed9342]

Alex Garland

[@eranhaim9913]

As Israeli, any talk of a civil war breaking is completely detached from reality. That’s a complete hallucination. All Israelis support whatever will remove the threat, let us live quietly, and we just disagree on the way to do it. The left thinks that by catering to the enemies they will be satisfied and stop attacking us. This was done in the Oslo process and the withdraw from Gaza. They think that if we give up on idf security of the west bank, leave Jewish cities with significant cultural and religious sites like Hebron, Scheme, Bethlehem, Jericho etc, they will stop attacking us and we’d be able to move on finally. The right does trust the enemies and wants full security control, strategic depth, and Jewish presence in our old cities. But there is 0% chance of a civil war.

[@Charles-wp9dd]

Biggest lesson i learnt in 2023 in the stock market is that nobody knows what is going to happen next, so practice some humility and low a strategy with a long term edge.

[@MileyHumphrey-ql4jp]

Nobody knows anything; You need to create your own process, manage risk, and stick to the plan, through thick or thin, While also continuously learning from mistakes and improving.

[@Joseph-zw3sb]

Uncertainty... it took me 5 years to stop trying to predict what bout to happen in market based on charts studying, cause you never know. not having a mentor cost me 5 years of pain I learn to go we’re the market is wanting to go and keep it simple with discipline.

[@Sarah-ui3vd]

Could you kindly elaborate on the advisor's background and qualifications?

[@Joseph-zw3sb]

Just research the name Angela Lynn Shilling. You’d find necessary details to work with a correspondence to set up an appointment.

[@Sarah-ui3vd]

I searched for her full name online, found her page, and sent an email to schedule a meeting. Hopefully, she responds soon. Thank you

[@itairoz1434]

civil war what kind of twisted dream someone have there

[@Charlesmagne800]

Thank you for your explanation!

[@hgfku-tn6hb]

It's unfortunate that Netanyahu do what pleases himself. He's not on behalf of Israeli people. Anyway, he's your choice

[@TristanBanks]

The israeli people arent exactly innocent allowing this to continue for 75 years and encouraging the settlments and millitary brutality.

[@juanthegreat3954]

The same could be argued towards Hamas and the ordinary Palestinian people. Since the Palestinian voted for Hamas and celebrated when they paraded dead Israeli civilians, is it okay for me to claim that Palestinian civilians are equally as guilty as well?

[@hakuofthesand]

Yes they are all not innocents and they want to take the whole land and kick the Palestinians. but the current gov is working against that goal by using brutal force which may lead to less western support and also may damage the integration of israel in the region. Most of them are evil but some smart and many stupid and few trapped in critical situations like Netanyahu!!

[@adamsaciid4919]

@@juanthegreat3954 donkey

[@hossana1287]

@@juanthegreat3954 Palestinians voted for Hamas after a 38 year-long Israeli occupation of the Strip, in which Israel constructed ilegal settlements in the Strip and after which Israel imposed a total blockade of Gaza, which became indefinite after Hamas took over. Palestinians have lived a constant state of threat in their own land, even before Hamas had power.

[@kfiraltberger552]

3:05 that's the wrong party symbol. His party is national unity, not religious zionism

[@pevzner100]

++

[@A.Severan]

No one cares about Israeli party symbols, let alone their accuracy.

[@mozi3051]

I was loke wtf. Zionism has no specific religion

[@noahjohnson935]

Practically should be considering how he sees Palestinians.

[@Averyhappypotato335]

@@noahjohnson935huh? He’s against settlement and supports calmer situation in the West Bank and less incursions

[@HaranYakir]

3:08 you have the wrong graphic there. That's smotrich's party's logo

[@tchotayadallee721]

I'm favourably impressed ! Tnx.

[@bothi00]

Just to clarify: Netanyahu's gov. already has a majority in the knesset without gantz. Gantz was just to provide extra stability and votes in the knesset because of wartime. Netanyahu does not need gantz to keep his majority stable in the knesset. Gallant is the issue given he is also of Likud. A new war cabinet will at least include smotrich given that the finance minister also oversees a ministerial position in the defence ministry. Its a matter of whether a faction around gallant or within likud can garner enough votes (ie, just 4) to vote against the new war cabinet. There's also the issue of the ultra-orthodox parties in government likely not willing to vote for war cabinet that will end exemption for hareedi jews from the idf

[@TequilaToothpick]

Fantastic video. Ben-Gvir and Smotrich need to be next in line for the arrest warrants.

[@eranhaim9913]

Lemme break it down since she did a bad job explaining the positions. All Israelis support whatever will remove the threat, let us live quietly, and we just disagree on the way to do it. The left thinks that by catering to the enemies they will be satisfied and stop attacking us. This was done in the Oslo process and the withdraw from Gaza. They think that if we give up on idf security of the west bank, leave Jewish cities with significant cultural and religious sites like Hebron, Scheme, Bethlehem, Jericho etc, they will stop attacking us and we’d be able to move on finally. The right does trust the enemies and wants full security control, strategic depth, and Jewish presence in our old cities. But there is 0% chance of a civil war.

[@MagicNash89]

Netanyahu needs to be out, even his own Defense minister disagrees with him on the future of Gaza, let Gantz and parts of Likud like Gallant sort this out.

[@PacmanBrunner]

How come there are no Black skin ppl in his cabinet

[@winterinvicta]

@@PacmanBrunner This is such a good question because Israel is an African nation and they have a large enough African population to the point where the odds of Africans being in positions of power is high.

[@laithmughrabi8990]

he is no difference, but he pretends to be.

[@original_O]

Suggesting that an israeli civil war is imminent is showing your lack of knowledge on israeli society

[@angelcabeza6464]

when you force ultra orthodox jews in the military they dont want to join means an increased chance if an uprising in isreal society dum dum

[@notaspeck6104]

Well she doesn’t live there no does she? It’s an honest mistake, it’s still better journalism than any mainstream media.

[@Emiltecknar]

@@notaspeck6104were do you think they gets ther info from. Do you thing they have There own team flying around the world reporting stuff lol?

[@rupertthomson767]

Great analysis, thanks 🙏

[@user-gr9fq9gt9w]

3:05 That is not the logo of the party lol

[@Miamcoline]

Very well explained.

[@wildfire9280]

Excellent call.

[@khanch.6807]

A Politician will do anything to stay in power....even start and continue a war. History of human behaviour is self repeating.

[@sebjornsprauten1406]

Hard to start a war that already started

[@BOZ_11]

in becoming a Zionist, it often helps to be joo ish

[@ThatGuy-bz2in]

@@sebjornsprauten1406 There were and are options other than a full on war. Netanyahu jumped at the chance of war because he needs to cling to power to avoid prison.

[@sebjornsprauten1406]

@@ThatGuy-bz2in what other option is there than war exactly?

[@MagicNash89]

This is disproven by countless politicians who didn't start a war. Its not nearly as simple.

[@skranz2732]

Why is every person around the table being given Coke Zero?

[@Peter-hs7zn]

They all have shares in the brand.

[@seanstansbury5585]

You didn't know that this war is sponsored by Coke?

[@scolardc]

Interesting that this is out on YT before it's out on Nebula

[@ramkovitz]

I disagree with the civil war outcome of this inner conflict, but the rest is spot on. Around 65% of Israelis want Natanyahu's government to fall. This last couple of years have been disastrous for the sane majority of Israelis in so many different ways. With that being said, the Israelis still have existential threats like Hezbollah, Hamas, and Iran so after oct. 7th a Jewish civil war is not very likely.

[@drmajalis1583]

Both the ruling party and Netanyahu's most prominent rival both basically agree there should never be a Palestinian state that that Palestinians should be ethnically cleansed from Gaza- and people still claim the problem is "just" Netanyahu

[@yehoshuamoleman]

Most people in Israel in principle are open to a two state solution with a Palestinian state. However as there is no assurance that it won’t become like Gaza and become a terror base to attack Israel. They won’t openly support a Palestinian state given what happened with the 2005 Gaza withdrawal where the Gaza Palestinians could have built a secure economy and life in peace with Israel but instead hamas took over and made it what it is today. So in practice they will not agree to a Palestinian state if it is governed like Gaza, which is what according to polls most Palestinians want.

[@arnoldmbuthia2687]

War cabinet. Like the Fire Nation. 💀💀

[@PacmanBrunner]

Original Israel people were Black-skinned.

[@PacmanBrunner]

@@grapesurgeon Wypipo come up with anything to take attentiin off of Black Lives Matter movement. U know how it is

[@user-gr9fq9gt9w]

​@@PacmanBrunner Most Israeli Jews are Mizrahi and Sephardic Jews, rac ist consp irator.

[@PacmanBrunner]

@@grapesurgeon Psh wit brothers like u its no wonder we in this mess

[@winterinvicta]

@@grapesurgeon I mean, you could be black.

[@bettyswallocks6411]

The UK, also, is one of those rare nations without a written constitution.

[@carlospesqueraalonso4988]

Sorry, but... why is it not in Nebula?

[@jewishboi3384]

Wtf we are not on the verge of civil war lol

[@RealThorwegian]

It's usually not apparent.

[@saaammmmyyyyyyy]

The ideological differences between the liberals in Tel Aviv and the million religious settlers in the occupied West Bank is not something that can be ignored

[@jobloluther]

@@saaammmmyyyyyyy No, we are not that differents

[@ronben-ezer8373]

​@@jobloluther the liberals and leftists in Tel Aviv and the settlers in the West Bank aren't that different??? what?

[@jobloluther]

@@ronben-ezer8373 You Westerners have a caricatured view of the political divide in Israel and are projecting your own problems onto us. The people of Tel Aviv aren't that left-wing at all, we're generally the most economically liberal in the country, and we want to destroy Hamas, and we want the army to enter Rafah, and we don't want a so-called Palestinian state. The entire population of the country agrees with this, except for an extreme minority of left-wing lunatics. Our opposition to the right is mainly cultural and religious, we don't want Israel to become a halakhic state, we want the Haredim to contribute to the country's defense and economy as much as we do. There are a million Israelis who are officially settlers, we're a small country that sticks together, these people are the same as us for the most part.

[@caseclosed9342]

Some politicians here in the US seem to support Gantz replacing Bibi as PM. In fact, Chuck Schumer has openly called for it…

[@sinocte]

Ideologically, Gantz doesn't seem that far away from Netanyahu's positions... but with that said, he also seems to understand that Israel can't afford to piss off the entire world without consequences. Something Netanyahu keeps doing fairly routinely.

[@ronben-ezer8373]

​@@sinocte a Gantz led coalition absolutely WOULD be ideologically different tho, as it would include more left leaning or Palestinian parties like Labor, Meretz, Ra'am, unlikely but possibly even Hadash

[@ABG1788]

NO BS news. I really like this channel :)

[@roystonboodoo7525]

U.S, MSM presenters, could learn alot from this eloquent lucid presentation. Perfect pace, enunciation, vocal tone, .... .... ....

[@Greentrees60]

I agree- I haven't seen this presenter before but I think she did a great job

[@abdmo7575]

he wants to repopulate Gaza with Israelis? tired of those saying this is not a genocide.. even if israel left now the situation is already shitty enough for gazans

[@crappymeal]

It was always an enevitablity, did they just think the people there would be cool with someone walking in and starting a country, it's nuts

[@Adam-326]

Who cares? There is absolutely no way that that kind of operation would be successful, let alone practical. That’s just a talking point.

[@crappymeal]

@@Adam-326 yet a region known as Israel actually exists on land that was inhabitanted by other people, it does happen

[@Adam-326]

@@crappymeal I mean that, for the foreseeable future, that sort of action is impractical and I’m sure that even the likes of Ben-Gvir know that. There will be no genuine attempt to have that happen, if for no other reason than that it is not the right time and could only cause more harm than good.

[@dilucragnvindr130]

If you watch the video, Netanyahu doesn't want that but that's what the far right members of his cabinet want to do. Netanyahu just wanted the war to continue for more months but in order to do it, he must appease his far right members.

[@Thewinner312]

The UK doesn't have a formal constitution either.

[@yehoshuamoleman]

The Uk has a long tradition of convention and moderate political culture which means that this unwritten constitution is not really tested. Israel has an increasingly radical government that wants to reduce judicial oversight and democratic protections that only exist through convention. Due to this different political culture a written constitution is more necisarry than the Uk.

[@BIGJXXX]

@@yehoshuamoleman facts

[@mtnhar]

Feels like we already have a TLDR News Israel

[@vorsichtig1235]

I think at this point, people would realize this is not only the problem of Netanyahu. Majority of Israel want to ethnically cleanse Palestine. They simply elected Netanyahu to do their job.

[@shinydewott]

I think the most scary part of the post-war situation in Palestine is that people more extremist than Netanyahu’s base (Netanyahu himself is an opportunistic snake. It’s his voter base that are driving his speeches and policies) will be in power in Israel

[@DrVictorVasconcelos]

You know what they say. If there's a table with 10 people, 1 war criminal arrives and no one stops them from sitting, now there's a table with 11 war criminals. Wait.

[@Adam-326]

Naive.

[@SirSX3]

Only a Sith deals in absolute.

[@MimOzanTamamogullar]

This kind of logic makes every country in the world war criminals

[@abelosei420]

Between a rock and a rock

[@shai.ben.yossef]

hey. just a small mistake at 3:08 . you put the religious zionism inignia on benny gantz instead of the national unity insignia

[@DingleberryWhite]

You say 'civil war' but that's at the very least misleading. Please don't misinform your audience, or at least explain what you mean by that. Maybe you have a different idea of what that means in your head...

[@adamelghalmi9771]

what she means by civil war, is civil war. the country will split into different factions, netanyahu shows all the telltale signs of a dictator, so...

[@busoko_Ismail2468]

When a corrupt and lying dictator like Netanyahu rules, his government will bring destruction, the civil wars and devastation to maintain his rule as much as possible , and the whole world knows that the Israelis want to displace the Palestinians from their land, and this will not happen, even over the body of the last Israeli

[@bignigel2360]

Saying that Israel is on the brink of war is so Fucking stupid

[@table_salt]

Stop pretending you don't understand what they mean

[@iDraaagy]

What’s the name of ur outro track?😅

[@rahulchaturvedi8623]

Just a nit: it seems that this video was available on KZbin before Nebula. I prefer watching these videos on Nebula given the lack of sponsor bits - but in this case I was forced to KZbin due to it not being there on Nebula.

[@leonidassophie2666]

It’ s humanity Hope !

[@PhilipLaSnail]

As an Israeli, I can confirm that is the best Pronunciation of Hebrew I have ever heard. Respect.

[@PacmanBrunner]

I am Black skin and I wonder how come I can be real Israeli but theres no Black skin ppl on his cabinet. Stragent times

[@PhilipLaSnail]

@@PacmanBrunner The "Black skined" Which are usually from the horn of Africa are something like 1.8% of the population... Which is only a bit more than the percentage of mormons in the USA (1.7%) And there are 3 people in the Cabinet (Bibi, Gants and Gallant.) and three observers (Dermer, Eizenkot and De'ri) which makes sense that they are all white compare to the tiny amount of Afro-Israelis in Israel But out of the 120 Knesset members there are 3 "black skinned" (Moshe Salmon, Tsaga Tsnagash Malko and Pnina Tamano) 1.8% Israeli Americans in Israel 2.5% from the Knesset Sounds fair to me This is not America, we don't choose people to govern us just because they are black (Ahem Ahem Claudine Gay) we choose them if they are good at their job. Israel is majority white, if you'd choose 6 random Israelis, you'd most likely get 6 white people.

[@user-gr9fq9gt9w]

​@@PacmanBrunner Lolll Ben Gvir himself is an Iraqi Jew, ignorant.

[@busoko_Ismail2468]

This tyrannical dictator brought him down, man

[@user-gr9fq9gt9w]

@@busoko_Ismail2468 You clearly don't know what a dictatorship is.

[@soupwithfriends]

new anchor seems good

[@lazyautomation3481]

Civil War? That's a bit much

[@Xlebaking]

This title was extremely misleading and bad click bait

[@Achmedsander]

How come? It seemed to fit the content. Due to disagreement within the cabinet people are about to resign and this could lead to collapse.

[@Xlebaking]

@@Achmedsander No, they said the war cabinet would just continue without Gantz. That is not collapsing by any definition…

[@BreakThroughhh]

This was a good video, but at the beginning she said Israel may be on the brink of civil war… and that’s not happening

[@jensboettiger5286]

bummer

[@laithmughrabi8990]

they don't show you much videos. - heated fight between the Ortho and the secular on joining the army. - heated fight between family of hostages (demanding a deal with hamas) and extremists (who wants the war to continue) 49% of israel opposes rafah invasion (Haaretz) the closer to 50% the more devided.

[@user-ry9vw8hm9m]

you've confused with the icon of the party of Gantz (3:06)

[@waspwrap1235]

They corrected it in the pin comment

[@hassanhussein4269]

Where you from

[@JustMe-em7hl]

So Gantz is essentially Netanyahu light?

[@yehoshuamoleman]

Yes in terms of his personal policy opinions he is similar but more secular. But in power he will be propped up by left and arab parties that will pull him more to the left in practice, just as Netanyahu is propped up by far right parties that pull him more to the right.

[@innosam123]

Recent polling is showing Netanyahu’s coalition rising to within 5% of Gantz’. This isn’t the disaster you’re making it out to be. Israelis are consolidating behind Netanyahu due to the international attacks on Israel.

[@KingXArthur]

0:50 I had to do a double take with that last line.

[@ejiroabraham]

It about to escalate. Netanyahu might not back down

[@Keln02]

Hey TLDR, can you stop using the words civil war ao wildly?

[@archockencanto1645]

you mean ' casually '.

[@busoko_Ismail2468]

When a corrupt and lying dictator like Netanyahu rules, his government will bring destruction, the civil wars and devastation to maintain his rule as much as possible , and the whole world knows that the Israelis want to displace the Palestinians from their land, and this will not happen, even over the body of the last Israeli

[@nathanbanks2354]

It's curious that Gantz says Israel should have gone into Rafah months ago...wasn't he leading a less extreme party?

[@zurielsss]

It’s political suicide to say otherwise probably

[@admar1208]

it sucks that the previous prime minister of israel got unalived by a right wing israeli he was about to reach a permanent peace deal with the palestenian authority that would've gave the palestenians a state and this conflict would've ended.

[@queerchs]

@@admar1208 Rabin's deal was offered in complete by Sharon and Olmert. It was rejected.

[@valentinmitterbauer4196]

@@admar1208 Without trying to equate the situations, this reminded me how Archduke Franz-Ferdinand was appearently planning to rebalance ethnic relations in Autria-Hungary by giving each people more self-governing authority (once he would have assumed leadership). Princip killed him (among other reasons) because such a federalist reform of the empire would have severly weakened any support for separatist movements like the one he belonged to.

[@anderskorsback4104]

@@admar1208 I doubt it. His public statements on what he thought the peace process should lead to do say the Palestinians should get "less than a state", way below what subsequent Israeli peace negotiators have offered the Palestinians. Granted, he was trying to shore up support in the Israeli parliament for ratifying the Oslo Accords, but there's no telling whether he was going to change his stance afterward. Without his assassination, he probably would not have had his current reputation as a visionary peacemaker.

[@idoyossef9039]

The written party (when you explained who is ganz) isn’t his party

[@vectorfox4782]

*we do not learn from the past*

[@kacperzimowski4626]

You are doing God's work with your journalism. Thank you!

[@cvby100]

0:50 "Israel might be on the brink of a civil war"? seems like you're lacking knowledge on Israeli inner affairs.

[@laithmughrabi8990]

anyone *critisizes Netanyahu Netanyahu: "you are khamas"

[@ronben-ezer8373]

the whole Khamas joke feels kinda antisemitic to me ngl. Like, it's laughing at how Hebrew names sound, it's in the same vein as how Ching Chong jokes are (rightfully) considered Sinophobic. I'm not trying to claim that all anti Zionism is anti-Semitism or anything like that, just this particular joke

[@freejosephmusic]

There is no division they get the same goal

[@tomlangford1999]

6:00 that's a lovely way of saying "ethnic cleansing"

[@Adam-326]

Not the same thing, but whatever.

[@Peter-hs7zn]

Sure is

[@farhanrafi8481]

@@Adam-326that is exactly what ethnic cleansing is. Ethnic Palestinians in Gaza would be removed and replaced by Israeli citizens.

[@Adam-326]

@@farhanrafi8481 Debatable. In any case, that’s not going to happen any time soon. Even people like Itamar know that.

[@gkbhai8962]

As someone who understands what's going on in israel quite deeply i can say that this video is more accurate than 90% of the videos out there in english about israeli politics.

[@wildman958]

Since you know so much, can you explain what part in these video is more accurate? And what you predict?

[@gkbhai8962]

​​​@@wildman958most of what was said is true except that a civil war is not something that's even close to happening. My prediction is that the fighting in Gaza will continue for the coming 2-3 years as the IDF erodes the capabilities of Hamas. That is unless an agreement is reached whereby Hamas disarms or its leaders leave gaza and give Gaza to the PA. Unlikely. Most likely Gantz will be the next prime minister of Israel but it may be only in the next elections in a few years as netanyahu cherishes his prime ministership more than anything and will not resign even though majority of israelis demand it. Even if he is driven to the extreme by ben gvir he will be willing to swerve to the fascist right as he completely lacks a moral compass or a willingness to do what is good for the country when it doesn't serve his political interest. His cynicism knows no bounds. The only chance for any sort of peace is a very strong dictatorial Palestinian leadership that is able to violently suppress Hamas and the Islamic jihad. This is not likely at the moment to happen but if it doesn't Hamas and pij will successfully sabotage any attempt at an agreement. It's also fairly likely that a war will insue in the northern border with hizbulla in the coming 12 months that will see great devastation in Israel and far far more devastation in Lebanon.

[@TimeKing2]

I hope Netanyahu will leave office and will be replaced by his brother Netangogle

[@EnSnusTack]

Why is the two razor-heads on the computer lid?

[@danceteras2884]

That's the logo for their printed newspaper.

[@EnSnusTack]

@@danceteras2884 Ohh, now i look dumb. But ty for clerification.

[@moanzx2]

3 issues with the videos: 1. About civil war, there absolutely no way there will be one, people can get angry in israel but a civil war is not even close especially after October 7th. 2. Likud with Netanyahu for a long time was more than willing to sit with the extreme religious Zionist party which you said they didn't, about Jewish Power party you are right they didn't want to sit with them in the past. 3. Minister of defense Yoav gallant, is actually reassuring the Public that he will not withdraw, you can say that maybe in the future he will but it's not really accurate to put him in the same place about withdrawing with Benny Gantz that is from an opposition party, even though they both see a lot of things eye to eye.

[@caseypenk]

I totally didn’t realize Bibi is keeping the war going for his own political survival. I have autism and am a very literal thinker so it’s hard for me to read between the lines. Thank you TLDR!

[@aaronweiss3294]

Wow, as bad Bibi is the 6 points are terrible. 1, 2 and 5 would be great and everyone would like them to happen, but it's not just a decision. Tbh 3 and 4 are similarly problematic 6 is ridiculous

[@yehoshuamoleman]

Why do you say 6 is ridiculous? Most Israelis want equality of national service so ultra orthodox and Arab Israelis pull their weight, whether through military service or other national service (it already exists as an alternative to military service to have an option to work in hospitals, schools etc.)

[@erickmarin6147]

To resettle and to replace; the language tiptoes around the topic of genocide, with is shamefully apologetic

[@temptemp4174]

Normalisation with Saudi Arabia is the holy grail for Israel. With that one move, countries such as Pakistan are much more likely to recognise Israel too, this is significant because they're the only Muslim country with actual nuclear weapons and the largest military.

[@adamelghalmi9771]

and? they have their neighbor to worry about, unless they manage to fully cripple india, a country 6x their size, they aren't going to do much against israel. but normalisation with saudi arabia is not happening

[@palmoart]

@@adamelghalmi9771 India has China to worry about who is Pakistan biggest ally.

[@RDSyafriyar]

"Not every "return to Zion" is a religiously significant achievement: one sort of return which may be described in the words of the prophet: "When you returned you defiled my land and made my heritage an abomination" (Jeremiah 2:7)." - Yeshayahu Leibowitz 🇮🇱

[@parsifal40]

says the indonesian

[@hakuofthesand]

That’s also described in the Quran, the jews will gain power on the whole world again but they are already a screwed up society!

[@Ken-cg2wr]

Qur'an 17:8 to the Children of Yacob (Israel): "Your Lord may yet show mercy to you. But if you return with your evil, We shall return with Our punishment."

[@yaseensharawi8034]

Khazaers lol

[@460mas]

If anyone wants a deeper discussion on this listen to the call me back podcast ep 226.

[@mikesercanto9149]

Thanks!

[@agrajag24]

"The Palestinians to be replace by Jewish immigrants" means ethnic cleansing by the way. Let's try to name things by their names.

[@igbl108]

At this point a 2 state solution almost guarentees perpetual war. Just now with even more legitimacy as the PA will most likely join the Arab League, and will strain relations throughout the Middle East. A Palestinian state will most likely be even more of an escalation towards regional war, as other Arab states will be binded by treaties to go to war at the side of Palestine. Believe it or not, the current situation is one which is more likely to produce peace than a 2 state solution which randomly pops up. There needs to be SHARP deradicalization throughout the Palestinian territories, a strong leader with a likening to peace, and IMMEDIATE treaties between a Palestinian state and Israel. A 2 state solution is not the simplist solution.

[@flamboyentpromotions3471]

How would it collapse if he still has a majority? Some questionable points made

[@dewaard3301]

The idea of civil war in Israel is absolute nonsense. A people so bound together by historical and imminent threats is least likely to turn on each other when a much more real enemy is knocking on their door.

[@Danhalperin2]

That's not true. Although it has not escalated to it just yet. While our enemies are bashing against every gate, we have a government that doesn't function in a way that will finish that horrible war. Netanyahu is as dangerous to Israel as the terrorists we have as neighbors.

[@zehavi111]

​@@Danhalperin2 טוב לדעת שיש אשכרה אנשים כמוך שעושים הכל בשביל להרוס את שמה של ישראל בעולם. גם אני רוצה שנתניהו יעוף אתמול, אבל השנאה שלכם כלפי מישהו אחד מעבירה את דעתכם עד כדי חוסר הסכמה למישהו שאומר שתרחיש מלחמת אזרחים לא ריאלי בישראל. הזיה

[@kevinbourke1847]

A coup

[@konstantynopolyt6770]

Politicians answering questions? Israeli government is wild

[@hlc95]

All should stand tight and strong together. United we stand , break we fall !

[@vincentrockel1149]

No country that lacks a constitution can truly be considered democratic and law based.

[@slamwall9057]

So the UK isn’t a democracy either? Also, Israel kind of DOES have a constitution, though an imcomplete one. It’s called the Basic Laws

[@user-ll1bn8cq7d]

6:00 "resettled"...so, genocide?

[@SirSX3]

Someone doesn't have a dictionary

[@adamelghalmi9771]

@@SirSX3 alright, so resettling the strip... doesn't take land from palestinians? it wouldn't force them to leave their homes?

[@the_world_of_math_and_science]

​@@adamelghalmi9771That's not a genocide.

[@idoshulman6379]

​@@adamelghalmi9771it might be bad, but it isn't genocide. Genocide is murder not resettlement

[@JoinThe_BingvinArmy]

oh no! anyway

[@gpac8147]

No it isn't

[@LahtariFIN]

I wonder what the US is going to say if an Israeli civil war brakes out? 🤔 "Both Israels have a right to defend themselves?" 😃 Would be a firearms salesman's wet dream for sure. Seeing how military service is mandatory for both men and women in Israel, the profits that could be made from a civil war in Israel are enormous.

[@steinarnielsen8954]

The Israelis who didn't start the war have a right do defend themselves. That's how it works.