Why Multicultural Pluralism Fails & What to Build Instead with Dr. Stephen Wolfe

[@Brian_Sauve]

Thanks for sharing your labors with us, Dr. Wolfe. An honor to have you in Ogden.

[@katherinewilliams4500]

This blew my mind. I have never thought about multiculturalism like this. Thank you for breaking the spell!

[@jordanfox8027]

Unbelievably encouraging that there is a space for talks like this among Christians. God bless Ogden!

[@NewChristendomPress]

Thank you, Jordan! Glad to facilitate these kinds of conversations.

[@Goliad_Respector]

This is so incredible. THIS is the battlefield. Plain and simple. They want our children gone. Literally. We are a huge problem for our current rulers, though the panel discussion will deny this, it is overwhelmingly true, and sadly this ruling class has wanted us gone for thousands of years. Ask Barbara Spectre. Think about what she’s saying.

[@heatherryan8301]

This puts words to a deep sadness I have about my country.

[@jankragt7789]

We are our own IN group's OUT group.

[@dentonbc]

Excellent talk. Paul Gottfried's "Multiculturalism and the Politics of Guilt" was a real eye opener. He does a great job showing how the protestant church was co-opted in order to bring about the "managerial therapeutic state" that Wolfe has described succinctly. It's good to hear Dr. Gottfried being cited more and more.

[@basedincali8707]

Who did the co-opting?

[@dentonbc]

​@@basedincali8707abolitionists, then the progressives, then new dealers.

[@basedincali8707]

@@dentonbc so the Jews, got it.

[@Razaiel]

​@@dentonbcI wonder what the common denominator is between these ideological groups.

[@eg4848]

@@Razaiel Durr its definitely jooz and not the fact that liberal protestants exist. Definitely dont read books like Protestants Abroad by David Holinger. Also pathetic how you're taking inspiration from Gottfried which (((ethnic group))) does he belong to? fool

[@drumrnva]

Wow.... Some white folks are getting rather nervous about the show being on the other foot, as it were....😅

[@ianlamb5883]

9 hours in and Dr. Wolf is double the views of the rest of the talks 😂 all the hate watchers are talking notes

[@SlamDunkerDonkey]

Lol 3.5k vs 1k and a few comments on twitter. This isn’t making nearly the buzz and controversy everyone wishes it is.

[@raker1980]

@@SlamDunkerDonkeywhy are you gay?

[@theocratickingdom30]

99% of people, for the most part, have no idea who or what this is about. This is only a tiny group doing their theological version of rapture escapism.

[@raker1980]

@@theocratickingdom30 It’s hard to describe how dumb your comment is.

[@gch8810]

@@theocratickingdom30 You have absolutely no clue what you are talking about if you think this has anything to do with "rapture escapism." Who care's if this group is not in the majority? Societal and cultural change never happens based on the will of the masses. True change happens because a small group of highly motivated and capable men make it happen.

[@achase-1097]

This is why New Christendom Press is so badly needed, and your work is appreciated-an organization standing for Christ, Masculinity, and the true American nation. Thank you, and God bless you.

[@brucewykes3730]

I believe the Melting Pot term for mass immigration to the United States was coined by a British Jew, named Israel Zangwill, whose parents were Russian Jewish immigrants to Britain. He wrote a play by that name in 1908, which impacted Teddy Roosevelt in 1909 such that he wrote to Zangwill stating that he considered it one of the "very strong and real influences upon my thought and my life." He was not, so far as I know, a resident of NY. There were earlier, close approximations of the term, but this is, I believe, the source of the phrase as is used today.

[@expansiveman3649]

Thank you for speaking the truth.

[@felixguerrero6062]

Substantive critique of multiculturalism Thank you Dr. Wolfe

[@44golfreak]

He was so real for this

[@JLock1987]

Thank you, Dr. Wolfe.

[@h.f.8432]

Ulster Scot here (JD Vance is my people), just to point out that while there’s things I love about my people, we’re just a huge mess, and I’m pretty sure we bring about as much baggage to the American cultural landscape as any non-European group ever has 😂

[@h.f.8432]

We were (kind of still are) wild, semi-tribal white English people, not fully Christianized, who have assimilated quite a bit with the English and the Germans, which has somewhat mitigated our cray-cray 😂. People groups change and meld throughout history. Yes, it’s fraught, and we’ve got to be aware of that and be cautious, but it would not be a bad thing (in the abstract) if future Americans are all light brown (or whatever hue), as long as we are good, God-fearing people (we agree on that).

[@h.f.8432]

Just to clarify, I basically agree with you- I think you basically agree with me. But I do this there is an over-focus on this issue in this particular group (obviously not in the mainstream, where problems like this are never acknowledged). Truth is very precise though, even in its priorities

[@eg4848]

Vance converted to Catholicism and married a hindu indian

[@jasonwebb2006]

It’s amazing to see how far you’ve come. I remember hanging out with you in youth group and at church back in the day. I love your thorough and engaging presentation!

[@merlewenger4471]

Fantastic speech

[@deryeoman5013]

I've been aware of these facts for 20 years but I've never seen a more deft explanation of the core issues. The 'ingroup as outgroup' description is both new to me and an impressive shorthand for a key concept. Truly excellent work, it's a great joy to see these things being spoken of with increasing frequency. If had one criticism it's that the end part of the speech where Clarence Thomas is referenced needs to be more explicit.

[@virtualpilgrim8645]

I would buy Stephen Wolfe's book, but it is not available as a ebook on Barnes and Noble.

[@eazynelly9785]

Still thinking about this a week later. Especially that ending.

[@Skippy_DCM]

Based.

[@PHDWhom]

based on what? Use real language please.

[@Skippy_DCM]

@@PHDWhom cringe

[@PHDWhom]

@@Skippy_DCM Weird.

[@virtualpilgrim8645]

Sounds like Stephen Wolfe has been reading American Renaissance.

[@christopherlees1134]

American Renaissance is excellent, but it lacks even a hint of Christianity, unfortunately.

[@virtualpilgrim8645]

@@christopherlees1134 It is true that American Renaissance emphasizes race over Christianity, but occasionally they promote Christianity as part of the West. My view is that race and Christianity are both important. Here is an example why... 69% of Black evangelical Christians voted for Biden. 73% of white evangelical Christians voted for Trump. 19% of Black evangelical Christians voted for Trump. 18% of white evangelical Christians voted for Biden. Their voting patterns were 180 degrees opposite. The difference was race, not Christianity.

[@balaams__donkey]

1:04:25 what a powerful ending

[@crossaddicted-60]

Shots fired baby- into the frea boys into the frea 💪

[@debcatman9464]

Very good points!

[@chazsmith2014]

is there any place on this planet where you can have a majority white nation?

[@gch8810]

We used to have them for the majority of human history. Of course we should still be able to have them.

[@legomon]

Poland is still majority white I think

[@elizabethcarpenter8711]

Great talk! I am a European married to an American living in the US. My people are God’s people but culture and upbringing matters. God brought us together, yet there are challenges that couples from similar background don’t face even though we have A LOT in common, starting with Christ, theology, politics and worldview. No one can tell me that throwing a bunch of people from all over with nothing essential in common in a shared space can lead to functioning, harmonious and thriving society. Also, I am very grateful that the tendencies of Roman Catholics to welfare state were mentioned. It’s the Protestant foundation that’s essential to America. We pray for Mr. Wolfe and his family regularly.

[@PHDWhom]

Glad you think so, but it doesn't work, at least not for those of us who aren't white, or white enough. Ask my Shawnee relatives how that "protestant work ethic" worked for us? No, don't answer it. This isn't yours, never was, and never will be. And real talk, but I would rather die than submit to your foreign god.

[@ayanna6]

Maybe you guys should have stayed in Europe, then you wouldn’t have to worry about multiculturalism. 🤣🤣

[@marymack1]

Not Billy Graham.

[@threeformsofunity]

Concerning. Troubling.

[@44golfreak]

Based

[@noahalvarenga1]

We are so back

[@rakovsky3901]

Christianity does not teach "WASP Culture". Despite the benefits of Greek and Roman civilization. It's important to note that Jesus and his disciples were Mideast Judeans whose nation historically underwent persecution by Greek and Roman (European) civilizations. Jesus was nailed to a Roman cross by a Roman procurator. The disciples and apostles preached to ALL NATIONS in the Great Commission. Paul proclaims, there is neither Greek nor Jew, but all are one in Jesus Christ. You can make an argument against Islamic society or against criminal ELEMENTS of some societies, INCLUDING WASP society. But you can't rightly use Christianity to argue for WASP culture against Christian Arabs, Christian Mexicans per se. Peace.

[@goldberg7019]

What his saying is that Christian Arabs should and Christian Mexicans have their own nations to live in

[@rakovsky3901]

This video is teaching a nation of "WASP culture." WASP = "White Anglo Saxon Protestant." So if you are do not have "White Anglo Saxon Protestant" culture, America is not for you. Sorry, but Jesus taught "Christianity," not "Political Protestantism". The American founders taught democracy. They did not teach a "WASP America." This is not Christianity or Democracy. Maryland was a Catholic colony. Louisiana was predominantly French and Catholic. NY was Dutch.

[@rakovsky3901]

@@goldberg7019 Are you "WASP White AngloSaxon Protestant?" Historically American Catholics, Jews, Irish, Italians, Germans wanted America to be a tolerant society instead of dedicated to 1 race 1ethnicity 1 religion.

[@rakovsky3901]

@@goldberg7019 I grew up as a WASP and do not want to live in a "WASP NATION STATE" America.

[@gch8810]

​@@rakovsky3901 You're either incredibly ignorant or downright dishonest.

[@nathanielhunter1280]

That kid in the background of all of these videos was not a happy camper! Quite distracting for this adhd kid. Lol

[@simplyserge144]

“When you’re accustomed to privilege, equality feels like oppression.” ― Franklin Leonard This sermon has little to nothing to do with Christ.

[@mtn9294]

Perhaps because it’s not a sermon

[@simplyserge144]

@@mtn9294 sermon, or speech, this rhetoric, isnt biblical nor compelling

[@raker1980]

@@simplyserge144You’re blind

[@MitchytooSlick]

@@simplyserge144if you’re oppose to white America having an identity in the country their ancestors created just say so…

[@gch8810]

@@simplyserge144 It is Biblical in the sense that nothing it says is in opposition to Holy Scripture. That doesn't mean that all of its content is specifically derived explicitly from Scripture.

[@hondotheology]

epic epic and i'm not even a thomist

[@sandler800]

This is garbage.

[@Zaloomination]

That Dr. Wolfe, such a scary guy! Lol

[@PaDutchRunner]

This is cool. You guys should be free to meet up, have conferences and write books. But please - don’t call it Christianity.

[@PaDutchRunner]

Funny thing: the very next video I watched following this one was a Shane Claiborne talk given about 12 years ago at Biola. The irony here is that you guys are in the same religion as Shane - you just have an opposite take. Neither of you is promoting biblical Christianity, but you are both attempting to exploit a semblance of Christianity to convince your listeners of your respective positions.

[@simplyserge144]

amen

[@gch8810]

@@simplyserge144 Silence anti-White filth.

[@gch8810]

This is perfectly Christian and in line with Christianity. What he is espousing is what the majority of European Christians have believed for all of history. Do you have the humility to consider that maybe you are wrong and not Christians throughout 1,900 years of history?

[@PaDutchRunner]

@@gch8810 Haha ok. Keep telling yourself this.

[@Reformed1]

@CaldwellApologetics

[@gch8810]

Who's this you are referencing?