Why Ponies Never Truly Lost Magic (MLP Theory)

Did the Ponies in Equestria really loose all of their magic? (MLP G5 Theory)
Special thanks to Sawtooth Waves! I hope to one day inspire others the same way you inspired me. Here's their link: / @sawtoothwaves
Special thanks to doc anubis for helping me clean this theory up by challenging it. Here's his link: / @doc_anubis
Special thanks to Skarmex for helping me with this theory by challenging it. Here's a link to his channel: / @skarmex3439
And a special thanks to The Nameless One for helping me when I first got started. Check out their MLP D&D sessions. / thenamelessone
And thank you Ice Crystal for being a Patron and a good friend. Your support means a lot to me.
Come follow me on my Tweeting Twitter: / wind_strikerfim
A beautiful link to license Info: creativecommons.org/licenses/...
Thank you all for watching this my little pony theory! ^^
^^ Don't forget to subscribe! ^^
Roll the credits:
Thank you PONE177 for letting me use your music for the Amazing Outro. You're really talented! ^^ Here's the link to the talented musician. • Pony Girl (DNB Remix)
Thank you Argodaemon, for letting me use your animations as an outro. ^^ Check out their amazing videos! / argodaemon
The amazing music was made by Kevin MacLeod:
incompetech.filmmusic.io/arti...
Music used: Killers
Here's the link to the amazing images I used:
www.deviantart.com/goldenfox2...
www.deviantart.com/blackgryph...
www.deviantart.com/n0kkun/art...
www.deviantart.com/emeraldbla...
www.deviantart.com/emeraldbla...
www.deviantart.com/caliunical...
www.deviantart.com/remul-leml...
www.deviantart.com/crystalmag...
www.deviantart.com/remul-leml...
www.deviantart.com/gihhbloond...
www.deviantart.com/nocturnal-...
www.deviantart.com/silvertie/...
www.deviantart.com/silvertie/...
www.deviantart.com/alunaazzz/...
www.deviantart.com/emeraldbla...
www.deviantart.com/mlp-vector...
www.deviantart.com/boneswolba...
NOTE TO YOU: I will continue getting better and better thanks to all of you. Your support gives me the strength to continue. Consider subscribing and following me on Twitter for further support and updates. / wind_strikerfim
Is there anything I missed? Let me know in the comments. I'll see you in ten days from now, thanks for watching. Hoof to heart. ^^
#mlp #mlpfriendshipismagic #mlpg5 #mlptheory

[@WindStriker]

I hope you all enjoyed the video. I absolutely love this theory and I really can't wait to get started on my next one. I'll see you in ten days. And be sure to take a look at some of the theories like, Skarmex's theory, in the comments. And remember, Hoof to heart, We'll all play our part!

[@emmaltb4050]

Ooh I can’t wait!

[@Purple_Skid]

Cool, and yes, I did look at his theory.

[@jinxx4655]

There is a couple flaws in your logic, Twilight gave up her alicorn hood and because of equestria girl Twilight for breaking the statue in there world, they would 1 point be at 50 50 in magic so she had to make a choice fast! Because the equestria girls have gotten used to the magic Twilight sparkle in the world of ponies thought it would be a good idea to store all of the equestrian magic in the 3 pony crystals! Three of the leader tribes where then handed there crystals and you know what happens next.

[@WindStriker]

@@jinxx4655 I actually don't believe in that theory by Sawtooth. Think about this, if Alicorns could turn back to their original pony race by giving up magic, why didn't Twilight turn back to normal after Tirek absorbed all of her magic in the season 4 finally? The same goes for the other Alicorns in those two episodes. That means that, at least as far as I can tell but I could be wrong, that Twilight couldn't have given up her Alicornhood in the first place. But don't get me wrong, I love Sawtooth's theories. Just remember that these are all just theories. They are neither right nor wrong until proven otherwise.

[@dhruvsingh5092]

but broeach tribe still thought that the other tribes had magic so keeping that in mind the seperation of race must have happened befour the disappearance of Magic

[@skarmex3439]

Here's a little interesting theory, the cute ceañera. What if it actually had an important job aside from just celebrating the cutie marks? It may seem a little far fetched but hear me out, what if cute ceañeras are a necessity for young ponies to do because it helps "settle" their magic. Remember the cutie pox? That strange condition that swept ponies that appeared out of nowhere? That same condition that also mysteriously disappeared. Well my theory is that way back then, ponies didn't know they had to celebrate their cutie marks coming in, so that lead to uncontrollable cutie marks until each pony found their own way to celebrate their unique talent, some pony in the past may have suggested a big party to celebrate their friends cutie marks and found that only those who attended the celebration was "cured" either that or the entire town attended the party and all of them was cured therefore having the "mysterious" cure of the condition that was mentioned in the book that Twilight was reading. And now, you may be thinking "Well what about Twilight? She didn't like parties!" And yes, she didn't, but perhaps the most important thing about the cute ceañera is to celebrate who you are, and as long as Twilight did that in her own way then she would have been fine. What do you think?

[@WindStriker]

I really like this theory and it's possible. Good job ^^

[@skarmex3439]

@@WindStriker Aww thank you! I think it has some potential!

[@cameoshadowness7757]

I also want to add that even though Twilight doesn't like parties much; we have seen her very willingly celebrate parties on multiple occasions. Even as a foal she was no stranger to celebrations, she pushed herself to see the Summer Sun celebration after all so she mostlikely had one planned.

[@skarmex3439]

@@cameoshadowness7757 Very true :)

[@mochastar3362]

This needs to be fanfiction

[@user-dh4sx9rx1r]

I kept thinking the same thing when I saw the movie, it made me confused how they lost magic but they still got their cutie marks when it’s kinda formed by magic.

[@pihuasija2976]

what if Twilight helped discord to create the crystals and she divided her alicorn magic and when she gave away her alicorn magic she was again a mortal normal unicorn and afterwards she died like everyone else and slowly everyone forgot about her (inspired by sawtooth's theory)

[@windygleam9821]

It may have been more than a thousand years passed since g4. I can only persume that Twilight and all other ponies died in this extremely long period of time.

[@WindStriker]

That's what I was thinking too.

[@magmaticwarrior]

@WindyGleam alicorns are said to be immortal

[@ronaldpagar6513]

@@magmaticwarrior but we're still not sure if they are alive and if still somewhere else

[@magmaticwarrior]

@@ronaldpagar6513 yeah, it is possible that we just don't know where they are

[@ronaldpagar6513]

@@magmaticwarrior just like mandoria in star wars or the upcoming special in may

[@Tairafan]

The conflict probably came first, for some reason, twilight couldn't end the conflict the way she usually could, the windagos were closing in. Someone had to bind the magic that made the 3 of them different to the Cristals. If they unight, they get the magic back; if they conflict, they get it taken away again.

[@CartoonNikola]

Not a bad theory, I can agree, but it is still questionable whether the G5 and G4 are connected. Although I hope they are.

[@WindStriker]

Thank you so much! They do mention twilight and show the mane six in the g5 movie. So they are connected but there's a huge gap now.

[@MissMyah37]

Ik this was 2 yrs ago but spike was shown and they are connected :)

[@CartoonNikola]

@@MissMyah37 Yeah ,although now unlike then I wish they weren't connected... (Also Spike is the best)

[@MissMyah37]

@@CartoonNikola he is

[@Justanotherhandle44]

I was saying this exact same thing today, and then I stumble upon this video. Coincidence. I. THINK. NOT.

[@WindStriker]

It was destiny ^^

[@someobody8800]

IT'S BECAUSE OF THE TOYS! The toys also have it on one side😂 🤣😂 🤣😂 🤣

[@WindStriker]

Buy our toys! ^^

[@bobnob6825]

Sawtooth waves made an interesting theory on twilights fate and it works with your theory

[@ojieeeee]

Same, I've always wondered what happened to Twilight Sparkle, if G5 was meant to be a continuation rather a sequel to G4 considering that it is still the same Equestria, what events might've happened before that lead to the division if the three pony tribes? I mean G5 is a reboot because instead we having a Mane 6, we get the Mane 5. By the way, awesome theory I really enjoyed watching! Can't wait for more!

[@ronaldpagar6513]

What about every creatures in Equestria that are united each other and what happened to them as well?

[@moonlight_875]

Maybe they live far away from Equestria for some reason

[@ronaldpagar6513]

@@moonlight_875 why can't luster dawn and her friends stop her aren't they the new mane 6 and the chosen ones of Equestria?

[@PeppermintSwirl]

Interesting explanation! Enjoyed your analysis

[@WindStriker]

Thank you so much! That means a lot to me. And thank you for the sub ^^

[@emilyeggemeyer8483]

even though in the beginning all pony races hated each other they still had friendship in each race

[@jefferyhiggins6236]

Another great theory! Although I believe there were ponies throughout G4 that also only had one mark. Like a single mirror on that pony in your video describing the rift between the races at <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="146">2:26</a>.

[@WindStriker]

Thank you. ^^ And it's possible but we don't ever really see her turn around.

[@jefferyhiggins6236]

@@WindStriker Yeah that's true. I guess we'll have to see.

[@wanderingmagic3527]

All these theories really make me think... nice job on this one!

[@WindStriker]

Thank you! I'll keep making them and with the ten days I have to come up with them now, I'll be able to have even better ones. ^^

[@wanderingmagic3527]

@@WindStriker I look forward to them! :)

[@pihuasija2976]

I was wondering, from season 4 Twilight kingdom we know that tirek can take flight of Pegasus and strength of earth ponies but in season 9 the ending of the end when tirek took the magic of Celestia and Luna he was only able to take unicorn magic so did he on purpose left some magic or what?

[@WindStriker]

That's a good question. I'll look into that

[@pihuasija2976]

@@WindStriker Thanks, btw I love your theories! :D

[@amberhynes1131]

I actually learned gen 5 fixes an error that gen 4 had, which was the cutie marks. Prior to gen 4 and on almost every toy and figurine only has them on one side of the flank. I never realized because I wasn't born until around gen 3 but never started watching till gen 4

[@lornadallery2659]

I've just seen your video and it's exactly what I've been thinking. And to highlight this theory, we can also see when Tirek steals the ponies' magic, they loose their cuty marks and are left lying on the ground. But an other thing is that in reality, even then, they didn't loose entirely there magic because with the magic of friendship and being able to support themselves all together, they've been able to create their own magic in a way. I think that this new generation has just been used to create a part of their own magic, even though it's not like Twilight's generation, and in a way, they got stronger.

[@Peppermint88]

Most definitely get good rest it's great to put alot of hard work into these videos and the quality shows but most definitely it's also good to have time to take care of other commitments 😉 I know for videos I write a list of the topics and each one but I don't upload yet until the list is done that way I can pick and choose when to release it x3

[@Peppermint88]

X3 yees

[@Alchemierecords]

Another great Video! Take the time you need with your videos and dont think you NEED to Upload NOW no matter what haha. No seriously every 10 days is perfect! :D

[@WindStriker]

Thank you so much! It'll give me much more time for a more indepth theory.

[@someobody8800]

Amazing vid as always.

[@WindStriker]

Thank you so much! That made my day ^^

[@KamilZmarzly-im6jc]

I bet Twilight is in library, and reads some books.

[@QueenKittenGirl]

What if Twilight Sparkle is hiding in some kind of Secret hide out trying to plan how to stop Opaline. Since she maybe doesn't know enough to stop Opaline she is secretly planing things without all of Equestria knowing so Opaline can't find out anything

[@PrinceShadowmoon]

There's something that doesn't sit right with this theory, if you've seen sawtooth Waves video on the fate of twilight sparkle, you'll know that sawtooth believes that the reason no one mentions her is not because she's a traitor but because she sacrificed herself to save Equestria by sacrificing her alicornhood to prevent the loss of magic due to some magical calamity, she did this by creating the three crystal artifacts seen in the new generation, overtime after she disappeared presumably dead due to old age as we know becoming an alicorn makes you practically immortal due to starswirls spell, having lost that she would have died to old age and subsequently her memory fades to sands of time with the only mention of her is on a stained glass window and a singular mention by Izzy(sic) I don't really believe twilight was a traitor, I mean they could have falsely believed twilight to be a traitor I'll admit that, but I don't think twilight would actually betray Equestria like that, I don't think princess Celestia would have been too happy with that, not angry, more like disappointed.

[@keomygomez545]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="325">5:25</a> Hey guys Thanks you all much love ❤️

[@WindStriker]

?

[@felix5118]

I just saw your channel and I want so say I really liked your videos :D

[@WindStriker]

Thank you for that! It's still kind of new. I hope you'll stay for the next video. ^^

[@MoonKitty338]

Magic is very important

[@unripetheberrby6283]

Wow you've only had your channel active for a few weeks??? Crazy 😲

[@RazorUnibop64]

Your welcome and heck my channel has grown a bit but still your welcome wind Striker. Keep being awesome!

[@WindStriker]

Thank you so much! And I'm sure your channel will pick up soon. ^^

[@Guardian-tuffguy]

Maybe she retired like Celestia and Luna.

[@btsrosaline3559]

I think they’re just trying to make it match the products they make considering the products it in the pony figures only have it on one side even with generation four so that’s probably why

[@springbreezeFIM]

Interesting theory

[@GoogleAccount-jg5vd]

I think if they really lost all their magic, they would just be... Regular horses. Nor wings or horns or connection to the earth (or other celestial bodies), no bright colors, no powers or cutie marks, or even the ability to speak or higher sentience. Just regular, grass grazing ponies. We don't have a specific timeline to go off of, but I would think after enough generations of ponies, their colors would start to fade and they would just become regular animals again without any magic influencing their genetics

[@shenron101]

I'm still trying to figure out why the pegasi need magic to fly?

[@andreeelizabeth-og6he]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@Keisky6824]

but according to twilight sparkle reign when opaline attack ponyville and spread chaos and disharmony three pony races hate each other but twilight had no choice to seal all the magic into the three crystals because she can't help everypony and couldn't help them to listen maybe twilight had no idea to seal all the magic in all equestria so who pony or creature who spread friendship the magic last long that's why twilight can't handle those ponies and create a crystals to handle to the next generation who spread the magic?

[@ashie_edits]

400 sub!

[@WindStriker]

The channel is growing so fast!

[@MissMyah37]

8.23k sub :D

[@cool_turtle6698]

Unfortunately, there is a Canon g5 comic that answers what happened to discord and no he did not case the collapse of Equestria, it was Opalean who did.

[@michasinpan8224]

I have this weird theory of what he Christal's might actually be made out of. What if the Christal's were made with the ,magic of the windigos or at least they are trap inside them somehow. I find it hard to believe that for hunders of years of ponies hating each other they didn't appear ones but as soon as the christals got put together and the ponies started to argue near it a storm at of all things came out of it. It would also explain what the hole thong might be, maybe is sucking them into the same prison the windigos are.

[@imp-tweekakarainbow_washov8991]

POV : all the ponies revolted ageinst twighlight and killed her off in a huge war

[@kellingc]

nice use of 'Fame and Misfortune" clips.

[@AstralArbourSys]

Unfortunately, the only one cutie mark thing is just because it looks better in 3d. But other than that the theory makes some sense.

[@WindStriker]

Yeah. But as a theorist, I always look for in universe explanations.

[@AstralArbourSys]

@@WindStriker That's fair. I just like to make sure people know the real life reason too.

[@MoonKitty338]

Awww

[@Purple_Skid]

I like this theory! Also, saw tooth made a video similar to this one, you should check it out, it has a pretty good story about it.

[@WindStriker]

Thank you so much! I did look at the video, The Fate Of Twilight, and I loved it! It's well done. But I have to disagree with it.

[@Purple_Skid]

@@WindStriker oh ok, that’s fine.

[@unripetheberrby6283]

Hope it's true. More interested

[@Walterskidsaccount]

I have my own idea Twlight had to end herself to save magic form a evil force and stored the magic in the Crystal's it sounds crazy but watch some other vidoes we could make a full story

[@farahfirdousazeemi1291]

I don't know?

[@immortalirx]

I’m gonna be as chaotic as discord one day

[@louisventer5666]

Wat about twilight 😢 wat happened

[@Dazzlingnova96]

And the comics explain the same thing

[@h3lldiv3r]

Twilight passed.

[@ronaldpagar6513]

Excuse me, what about luster dawn isn't she the new leader of Equestria?

[@WindStriker]

Well, as far as we know, she was only Twilights student. She never became the ruler of Equestria.

[@ronaldpagar6513]

@@WindStriker I assume she betrayed her mentor because she's fit for the leader because, she ask zecora in the future what's it looks like but it turns out the horrible truth

[@sofsof4853]

Twilight died😩😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😞:-(

[@MissMyah37]

:(

[@user-pg3fn1us2d]

I fink I just don’t no yet

[@ruthalber4658]

I think Twilight might have gotten married and had a family but that's just my thought on the subject for just poured my to put her in a different dimension Siri I have

[@StarEmily_0ffical-_Edits-]

My cutie mark is a teddy

[@kvrkuu]

Idk why I commented this but Remember me when your famous lol

[@WindStriker]

Well, I don't think I'll become famous.

[@kvrkuu]

Well I think one day you will!

[@WindStriker]

@@kvrkuu Maybe. But I don't really think about fame though. I'd rather do it because I love making theories and I really want to unite everyone. ^^

[@kvrkuu]

@@WindStriker awh that's sweet (•ө•)★

[@tyquancleckley7787]

Striker If you want to know what happened to twilight Check out sawtooth wave’s video here a link kzbin.info/www/bejne/oqDZm6ypntWgpqc Hope you come up with great Theories!

[@WindStriker]

Thank you. I did see that video but there's one thing I can't understand with it. Why would every pony forget who Twilight was if she sacrificed her alicorn hood to save magic? At the same time, Alicorns don't unbecome Alicorns when they loose all of their magic. Evident by Cozy Glow still being able to fly after she unbecome an Alicorn. While Twilight gave Tirek all of her magic in the season 4 finally. Evident by her loss of a cutie mark and her eye color. Yet she was still an Alicorn.

[@tyquancleckley7787]

Good point but if you’re Theory about Discord erasing all pony magic And making the crystals is true I think I know someone who knows what happened to twilight Dr. Wolf He is sawtooth friend And he has a discord Theory too Here is the link to his video kzbin.info/www/bejne/e4LOnaqKnq1pgdU I hope this gives you some ideas!

[@WindStriker]

@@tyquancleckley7787 Thank you, I'll check it out.

[@WindStriker]

@@tyquancleckley7787 I remember watching that video. And I have to say, it's entirely possible.

[@tyquancleckley7787]

@@WindStriker Thank you I hope you get to see sawtooth And You to can do A Collab!

[@issy1307]

First

[@BottlenoseTheSeaWing]

My theory is that ponies never truly lost their magic because they never truly lost friendship. The friendship between the tribes is what activated the crystals, but there was still friendship within the tribes, like how Sunny was friends with Hitch at the very beginning, which is what gave ponies their cutie marks. My question is, how would a pony even get a cutie mark or know that they’ve gotten one or what they are if there was no magic?

[@V_REINE]

DRAGONS LIVE FOR 1000 ALICORNS LIVE FOR 100

[@Geofactfile]

According to google opaleine killed Twilight