Why This MG Is Better Than An Audi Q5

[@ScotsGal]

I have the outgoing 2024 HS Trophy manual model and I love it....The MG HS was never a car I'd considered before but I think that was just down to badge snobbery ....we needed more room in our family car and I happened to find myself in a MG showroom ...I couldn't beleive the quality of the interior of the hs ..soft touch material all over the cabin, electric heated front seats, dual air con , ambient lighting , reclining rear seats ,electric folding door mirrors and a whole host of other on board tech ..I have no idea weather the Audi is better than the MG or vice versa I just know my car does what I need it to do and thats get to work get the kids to school and get the shopping ...not everyone can afford to go out and buy an Audi ,BMW or Mercedes most people just get what they can get and in my humble opinion you get plenty of bang for your buck with the MG..I think this new model is stunning and will sell brilliantly here in the uk ...Great review

[@birdmanmarbella]

Don't understand why people hate it. Yes, it's no Audi, Mercedes ,BMW etc but it's not targeted at buyers of those brands. It starts at £25.000 and offers everything most people with no interest in cars want.

[@AutoPosts]

Right!!! And i’ll go further, i’ve seen many car people seeking out for those new chinese automakers…. The big 3 germans are becoming more and more of the same, it’s like paying a premium that doesn’t really exist anymore

[@cinch]

Exactly! It's usually the underdogs that present the best value for money too

[@r20bym]

Smug MG fanboy driver here - we're on our fourth brand new one, both of our current cars are brand new, fully electric and top of the range (there isnt a lot of choice when it comes to spec) 72.6kw ZS and 77kw 77kw MG4. The MG4 does 0-60 in just over 6 seconds and is real wheel drive. Both cars compently achieve over 260 miles on a charge on real world conditions. Both cars cost under 3p per mile to run. Capital cost of both after discounts was a shade over £60k. Should have been more like £74k - but big discounts to be had through the MG Affinity programme and general laclustre performance makes it a buyers market for electric if you shop around. I do feel very smug seeing what weve got when compared to my neighbours Merc EQC400 worth circa £80k. It has roughly a 250 mile real world range from a 100ish KW battery due to it weighing more than a tank. Its a lovely car - and i know when car thieves come down our street theyre going to take his rather than either of mine. And im completely at peace with that. 80k warranty over 7 years. And i can outdo most things at the lights (well in one of the cars at least) I can live without the badge - keep your 3 spokes or 4 rings - ill have the cash.

[@davidllewellyn5168]

Sensible presenter, some of the comments comparing to Audi says everything. Lrts face it, Great Value and the design is spot on. 8:47

[@kevyo43]

I have a mk2 MG HS its 2022 this is the mk4 thats two more in 2 years are there planning on a new model every year.

[@vp272]

Why do reviewers always praise lower driving positions in SUV’s? Surely most real world drivers appreciate the highest setting for a more commanding view out hence a mention of seat adjustability might be more useful for future reviews.

[@cinch]

Good question. It's worth mentioning for those who don't want to be in a "commanding" position but need the practicality of an SUV. A lot of SUVs are already high enough for most and with seats that don't allow much room to be lowered - it becomes uncomfortable if not restrictive for taller folks /Jamil

[@CB-RADIO-UK]

Nice to see a manual car tested.

[@cinch]

We agree! Save the manuals 🙌

[@AR-zr1om]

We have the previous generation of these as our work cars. They really surprised me when I first drove them but when the battery is flat they really drink fuel (the previous generation only managed 25 ish miles of electric driving) and the transition from petrol to electric was really sloppy. The suspension was also pretty poor but it was still a great value car

[@matthewwebb8206]

Are you sure there's no adaptive cruise control and or lane keep assist on that spec. The old HS did all within MG pilot

[@oliverstemp9132]

It has MG Pilot

[@ciybersal3499]

Looks great, its a winner

[@cinch]

We think so. If the previous MG HS was any indication, this will be a hot seller. /Jamil

[@ep1929]

This new HS looks the part I must say. Can't believe the low price either, how do MG do it?

[@cinch]

It boggles us... ...but we can make an educated guess. Economies of scale? Vertical integration? If anyone knows how, please let us know. /Jamil

[@maximuswong3092]

China.

[@AldoScotia]

Chinese labour costs

[@andrewcarroll2162]

The spec is lower than the 202l model and it's £ 3000 dearer. M G are now taking the piss 😢

[@jonestoke1180]

This isn’t even almost a audi Q2 😂😂😂😂

[@SuperLloyd84]

A lower seating position fixes a huge problem the previous HS had. I tried one and never got as far as actually turning on the ignition as even in its lowest setting, the seat was far too high up. I'm only 5'11" and I felt like my head was brushing the roof which was just silly.

[@cinch]

That's why we felt the need to mention it. It's about the small improvements /Jamil

[@robincurston7086]

I am 6 foot 1 inch never a problem for me.

[@kevyo43]

Yeah I have a MK2 HS 2022 feels like I have to tilt my head to see. And that stupid ear view mirror

[@n8n8n8n]

Waiting for 7-seater with PHEV and 4x4 from MG :)

[@cinch]

If they made one of those in similar style of the HS (great value for money) it stand a chance of being popular for that segment /Jamil

[@wayneheyes4934]

This will sell really well! Shame the MPG isn’t higher in the petrol but that’s the compromise

[@vwgolffancarreviews7111]

It will not sell because no one will like it

[@AldoScotia]

Current model is one of top sellers? MG owner make many components for your beloved VW, including Audi.​@@vwgolffancarreviews7111

[@davidhart559]

Dont be silly ​@@vwgolffancarreviews7111

[@cinch]

No doubt! It's got a lot going for it. Curious to see how Audi and other premium crossover makers respond to this /Jamil

[@cinch]

Time will tell, I guess /Jamil

[@martinm8471]

Do both versions of trophy model (auto and manual) have powered tailgate ? As was told in one of dealers last week that manual version doesn't have it.

[@cinch]

Hey! Our test car was a manual with a powered tailgate, so we presume that’s the case for customer cars too. Would be strange if it wasn’t the case 🤔

[@Car-guy307]

The old HS looked better

[@lucassitanggang5154]

MG HS better than Audi Q5? No! Audi Is better

[@paulhayes2189]

Say how....

[@ubfoodstory7329]

MG 👍

[@bugsymalone5744]

I hope it is for double the price, but I bet you it's not twice as good.

[@vwgolffancarreviews7111]

I hate mg

[@MadR6]

Those tiny tucked in wheels make it look cheap. The Q5 has good filled arches that look fancy and expensive. Cheap small wheels are a big mistake. Fill those arches and look posh.

[@cinch]

I would agree with you but in testing we found that the taller suspension travel (causing the arches to look unfilled) is a contributor to the great ride comfort. This has the effect of making the wheels look small but if they were any bigger and heavier, they would transfer more forces to the cabin. Bonus fact: smaller wheels = cheaper tyres. Which lines up nicely with the value proposition of the car. /Jamil

[@oliverstemp9132]

Feels entirely average. I can see why someone would go for it.

[@cinch]

Electric only range is well above average and its price is well under average. Even then, there's nothing wrong with average. Something has to be. /Jamil

[@oliverstemp9132]

@@cinch that is true, it’s very good value

[@th-l8936]

How can something be longer, wider and shorter?

[@oliverstemp9132]

Lower

[@r20bym]

Height

[@Tibchy91]

2:58, that plastic fit is terrible...

[@bugsymalone5744]

No it's not

[@ruialves4965]

😂😂😂😂

[@cinch]

I love that we were able to make you giggle with this one /Jamil

[@raipratik]

Chinese branding is terrible 🤮 I would never lay my hand on them. wtf is MG and BYD?

[@cinch]

This is giving "what is a floppy disk" vibes 😭 I thin it's time we made a film on the great history of MG /Jamil

[@AldoScotia]

What is VW?

[@robincurston7086]

Drives around in 10 year Astra

[@bugsymalone5744]

🤡

[@kevyo43]

Chinese branding lol GM engine, most of the running gear is audi

[@vwgolffancarreviews7111]

I hate it is hideous I will stick with the Aud thumbs down to mg it not better than the Audi if just another Chinese car which I hate mg don't sell no more mg in the UK only sell them in China MG that are very dangerous does you stop making any car

[@AldoScotia]

You're rambling and incoherent

[@davidhart559]

You said alot..without saying anything

[@bugsymalone5744]

Frustrated much?

[@vwgolffancarreviews7111]

I am not have you seen on Google MG are dangerous

[@AldoScotia]

​@@vwgolffancarreviews7111why then did you say mg don't sell cars in UK?- MG sell plenty - in fact the MG hs was the biggest seller in January last year. Incidentally many components of your VW are made by MGs owner Saico in china

[@oilbeefhooked351]

He has been paid to promote the MG. People will be influenced. I have the outgoing MG hs and it's cheap but value for money but with one big flaw at why it's cheap. The engine is terrible. Uneconomical and under powerd when the vehicle carries 5 passengers. You get what you pay for

[@cinch]

Hey, Sam hasn't been paid by MG to promote this car, this is a purely editorial video review. Don't forget, the HS in our video is completely different to your last-generation one; the engine is totally new too. So it's not the same at all as your car. Hope this clears things up 😀