Why we will NEVER return to TULUM Mexico - Violence, Sewage, Income Inequality

[@michaelyoung4056]

I moved to Tulum for a six month stay last year. I lasted two months before returning to San Francisco. This video is spot on. The last thing Tulum needs is another foreigner like me impacting the environment. Thank you for posting this.

[@kylekennedy363]

I have been going to Tulum since 2002 - I would go at various times of the year - No Seaweed!! I remember walking along the beach for hours and occasionally seeing another person/couple - At one point I walked by a giant sea turtle laying eggs on the beach - sooo Magical!!! The “biosphere” national park gave me the impression that the area was protected from over development. Most of the cabanas were “owned” by Europeans - there were a few restaurants on the beach and tons of access - Several years later I began to see trash on the beach, increased development but still pretty suite. I loved going there to get out of the city and decompress, and connect with the locals - there is so much to do and see in the natural world there. Then in around 2012 the seaweed started to appear at certain times of the year - I didn’t go back until last year 2022 - I always stayed at my favorite quirky cabana’s La Luna - I was shocked to see exactly what you are talking about!!! I had to wear ear plugs at night due too (2) clubs next to the cabana’s pumping music until 4am - instagramer’s EVERYWHERE!!! Trash, seaweed - total insanity - I left there more stressed then when I arrived. I literally had a good cry on the beach as I had to let go and say good by to Tulum - It’s so sad to see what we as humans are doing to this planet. How can we not see that we need to live in harmony with the environment, with eachother - with other culture’s. This video is very accurate - so sad!!!!

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

It is very sad. You are fortunate you got to see it when you did.

[@chrisg5894]

The seaweed is normal for the whole yucatan

[@alexfranco3879]

I live in usa and when I go to a park if I find garbage I pick it up

[@annebateman8339]

Welcome to global warming and the affect of humans garbage in the ocean.

[@tenishaj.7074]

@@alexfranco3879 lol… Elmo 🎉🎉

[@lorenalopez9770]

My brother and sister n law just bought a condo in Selva Norte Tulum. November 18 as they were excited to decorate it, there condo exploded due to a gas leak. My brother died a week later and my sister n law died 11 days later 😢 💔 many residents there had complained about gas smells and nothing was done. My whole family is so heartbroken and seeking justice for them 💔

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

So sorry to hear your tragic story. Our prayers go out to you and your family.

[@winniethepooh8945]

Oh wow. Condolences ❤

[@Alicia-vq8jg]

Girl, this gave me chills I was supposed to move there in July because I thought I made friends but I think they were sex traffickers I think everything is just really corrupt there. I am so deeply sorry for your loss. I’m so heartbroken for you and your family that is absolutely devastating. I’m so sorry for your loss😢 I really think that it’s like the wild wild West so it’s a lot of rich Americans that are into scams and stuff and I think it’s pretty obvious because how can you live like royalty in a place and constantly see the wealth division. I’m just so heartbroken for your family. I’m so sorry to hear that that’s absolutely devastating and there’s no words I would not recommend for anyone to move to tulum Ever. Also, in Mexico, the real estate agent Seema little Siri so I would never buy property there now or rent unless it was through my actual close family friends that I’ve known since I was like six years old they have Associates there. I literally thought it was like a dream come true and like the most magical city I’m so glad that a sex trafficker laughed in my face when I told him it was the most magical place. I’m so glad. I wish I could give you a hug, and I hope you’re getting through this insane loss I can’t even begin to fathom.

[@Belovelyava]

Beyond heartbreaking. Condolences ❤️‍🩹

[@lademoiselleketoret6958]

Horrific. I am so so sorry for your loss 😭😭😭

[@debbiestevenson2745]

I live in nearby Akumal. All of our beaches are easily accessible and we still have a quiet and quaint vibe. No overdevelopment has happened yet. I've been here 9 years from the USA and love it. I'd never think of going anywhere else. I get annoyed when people over emphasize the cartel or drug trade. Have you seen the US news lately? I feel much safer here than I ever did in the USA. We don't have to worry about school shootings or Super Bowl Parade shootings. If you stay away from drugs, you will be fine. The cross-fire shootings are few and far between. There is so much beauty in Mexico. Don't judge it more harshly than your own country.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your comment. Much appreciated. We certainly do love visiting Mexico…

[@caseygotaas7035]

Where did you live in the USA? And was it hard at first with finding a place and job? I'm at occidental Xcaret

[@29aaronjones]

That is such great news. I love Mexico and I prefer to think people can live peace there.

[@arnoldodin7443]

Gracias por tu comentario. 🙏🏼

[@insurgentecucaracha]

Akumal is Kind of gated

[@doctorclutterbuster8791]

Glad I saw Tulum 30 years ago when it was still relatively rustic and quiet.

[@ramirez036]

Same here, remember the beach back then? Amazing!

[@FronkCartel]

Appreciate the video. I want to share a few thoughts. 1. You are right, a lot of people see profit over people, and that's why I see it as essential to step in where we can and help out where there is inequality. 2. For the beach access, there are unfortunately only 2 or 3 public beach spots left.. some hotels will let you through without needing to stay at their beach clubs or paying anything. 3. I would at all costs avoid taxis in tulum if you need to take one, ask locals what the ride should cost, insist on the price, and never take a cab that is stationary.. always look for someone who is already on the move as the, are somehow less likely to overcharge. Also, if you want to go to the beach, there is a collectivo (minivan) going every few minutes (they have red letters on the front), and they just cost 20-30 pesos. I don't know what to say about 4. & 5. .... Tulum needs some serious systems for waste! 6. Yep, that's the mafia... 7. Luckily, there are systems now to build houses out of seaweed :) There is a project going on. You can find info on vice 8. At least it's armed guards and not the mafia rolling around 24/7, lol 9. If you know where and how it can be affordable... you honestly need to know which places to avoid :) Overall, Tulum is the most expensive town in Mexico!! 10. I hate them Instagrammers 😂

[@thh_h]

Just returned from Tulum. I chose not to watch your video before I traveled and everything you said is absolutely true. It was such a disappointing trip. It was not a vacation it was absolutely stressful.

[@unknownpleasures100]

Did you visit anywhere else less stressful? I was thinking of Holbox before it turns this way...

[@thh_h]

@@unknownpleasures100 only Tulum. If you visit the pyramids or would like to try the restaurants its really just a one day visit.

[@winniethepooh8945]

Thanks im crossing Tulum off my list

[@j.kristineemmons]

​@@unknownpleasures100 Holbox is on the radar and I imagine will probably be quickly consumed.

[@cupidok2768]

how is this man living here? this is so dangerous. is he surviving? that's what you get for not listening to him before traveling

[@robertneilpalmer]

Thank you for the honest and authentic video about Tulum. Basically its the equivalent of Bali, Indonesia where I lived for 3 years. Almost identical problems and issues, land ownership, overpriced, sewage, etc., etc.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thank you for your comment! Never knew that about Bali….

[@winniethepooh8945]

Bali was on my bucket list now I’m reconsidering

[@AnRvMoto]

10 minutes in Tulum, and I was turned off. The Seaweed was rancid, and the price gouging ridiculous. Asked a taxi for a ride for what amounted to about 3 blocks, and he wanted 500 pesos. No thanks, I'll walk. The same attitude was present multiple times. I have no interest in going back. Loving Bacalar, though.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your comments. There are much better places to visit in Mexico.

[@garzapedroa]

As mexican i am, it's a shame, that this place its so incredibly over rated, and so its so unsafe, check what happened in February 5th in a beach club, an inocent tourist was a victim of the huge violence rate in that piece of sht town

[@sallygasser1898]

Tulum is beautiful. The hotel industries do not care about the Ecosystem or the community. This is why I chose not to return. My goal is to support local economy and the people to help them prosper aswell.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Yes, we believe in supporting the locals as well! Thanks for sharing 👍🏻

[@IamNotanumber-z3j]

It’s ironic because when I went in the late 90s it was a small hippy style retreat with eco thinking before anyone else did

[@DiegoMagengo]

Unfortunately this is the story for lots of coastal tourism cities in Mexico and Latin America, really sad to see the the two extremes of wealth living side by side. Also hard to see this cycle ever ending😢.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for watching! Yes it was very sad to see. Playa del Carmen, just a short distance away, seemed better.

[@tremblence]

@@ShouldWeLiveHere People are 1000x more likely to complain about trash, than to pick it up I am different--- I complain a little bit, but then I pick up trash 1-2 hours per day every time I walk, bike or travel in general Mexican citizens need to take pride in their country and PICK UP TRASH..... but instead they trash their own towns

[@javierflores752]

EstA bien pachec0

[@jc6781]

not all Latin America .... El Salvador is AMAZING .... we ave been all over latin America (Margarita Island, Venezuela .... San Andres, Colombia, both coasts in Mexico, Roatan, Honduras, Costa Rica .... etc etc) NOTHING TOUCHES EL SALVADOR RIGHT NOW ! truly PARADISE !

[@exceptico6156]

The problem is not the wealth the discrepancy of wealth (avoiding envy) but poverty. But what can't you expect when the state expropiates everybody at least half of their Work/wealth while coercively regulates our lives and entrepreneurship initiatives through thousands of laws and regulations

[@alanizaguirre4670]

I have lived in Tulum for months and greatly loved the place. Just be slightly open-minded and considerate and you will fall in love with Tulum. Most of the comments trashing tulum on the web come from Karens, uncultured, Americans. Don't be a Karen, if steppin' out of your comfort zone and into a different lifestyle just stay home. :)

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for watching and sharing your thoughts.

[@Hazel64348]

Not true. If you love garbage, constant construction, dead animals m dirt roads, mud or dust bowls, over priced restaurants truck and car exhaust pollution, over priced restaurants and taxi, police presence in the beach and high amounts of sargassum along the beach. It's more expensive then anywhere I've been in Mexico, 375 peso for a burger, come in. 500 peos each to site in a chair, then Tulum is the place for you

[@jfr27s]

@@ShouldWeLiveHere tu canal es demasiado negativo y solo se dedica a criticar, si quieres ver lugares perfectos deberías ir a Europa o a países desarrollados como USA o Canadá

[@odellowe7340]

You are a Karen, this is all lies, I am from Miami and been living here 2 yearS, violence here is nothing like what I see in USA, canada and Europe, I don't see the trash he is talking about, I know countless people here who work here and I know people who making more than most people from USA, this guy is what they call Karen in USA

[@MrNanah38]

Reminds me of some places in jamaica .

[@maximeduardo333]

This is barely scratching the surface. What I felt when I was in Tulum this last weekend was the palpable grip of extremely powerful, greedy, and dangerous cartels. Short of the evil, most people were just entirely fake. The real Tulum, as I imagine it was was probably far more public or at least not so disjointed between dozens of beach clubs. It's not just that the prices are high, it's that you can't skip from party to party on the beach and just have a good time like you should be able to or like you can in places like Boracay, Thailand, etc. What you end up with is paying over $20 per drink and blind covers of over $50 in an elaborate and classless money washing station. Tulum is invariable proof that billionaire cartel leaders still don't have good taste and don't know how to create a great party. They're more about the flex, but clearly don't understand the first thing about authenticity and human space interaction. This is a particular shame when you consider the immense beauty that could be enjoyed if none of the clubs were there, or at least were far less intrusive. Tulum is a treasure, nightmare, and a tragedy all wrapped into one. Mexico is losing its charm, most prominently in Tulum.

[@j.kristineemmons]

Bravo!

[@wallyklw5]

It looks like an armpit. Thx. Now I can skip this place.

[@moisesortega3684]

I blame the greediness of Spanish conquistadors for your unpleasant trip. Maybe you should visit New Jersey or Atlantic City?

[@r3dp1ll]

I agree. On a side note, Mexico is getting expensive now. Especially accomodation.

[@4Gotto]

Shitskins gonna shitskin

[@Another_taco.Yes_please]

So sad. Almost brought me to tears. Loved Tulum before it was 'discovered' and destroyed.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

So true- It is such a beautiful location. With proper thoughtful planning and development it could have been so much better.

[@Another_taco.Yes_please]

Instead folks wanted to cash in and here we are. End of.

[@duygukayhanisaskank4915]

​@@ShouldWeLiveHere THANK YOU SOOOO MUCH for getting "the word out" about this horrible town. Your well-tempered commentary is 100% accurate. Since 2007, I've lived on The Yucatan Peninsula & I've traveled yearly to what's referred to as The Riveria Maya since 1984. The fact is...Tulum is a VERY DANGEROUS, VERY FILTHY, VERY EXPENSIVE SHITHOLE. It is quite the opposite of the seductive travel brochures, etc. The paradise that was once Tulum is long gone. The ecological disaster is well known. But the tourist-driven economy of this region of Mexico disregards this profoundly sad reality while murdering "The Golden Goose". I believe you'll find this documentary very interesting: kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6uuoKx_m6l8adk The town of Tulum & all its' authorities are corrupt & controlled by a vicious cartel. It controls the area from Playa del Carmen to Tulum. Another cartel controls North of Playa del Carmen to Cancun. They're equally vicious & control government authorities as well. Only the diligence of The National Guard provides a "sense" of safety. Tourists & residents are not safe in Tulum. Every year, assaults & murders of tourists increase. Information related to this criminal activity is aggressively suppressed to preserve tourism; from which the entire economy is derived. The government of Mexico knows too well how the uncontrolled cartels destroyed tourism on The West Coast during the 1970s & '80s. That was the impetus causing The Caribbean Region of Mexico to be developed for tourism. Before the 1980s, The Yucatan Peninsula was regarded as a foreign country by officials in the capital city. Your points & keen observations about the senseless & irrational building projects are accurate & well-spoken. They are the result of money laundering by corrupt officials, the corrupt wealthy and the cartels. To keep my commentary from being agonizingly longer, I won't say anything about the issue of sargassum...except...it's now a year-round problem & will continue to inundate beaches of The Caribbean Region for the foreseeable future. I know my commentary is lengthy...but...your excellent video about Tulum kinda' lit a fire in me. For what it's worth, I have subscribed to your KZbin Channel. 🙂 Best regards from Yucatan, Ben

[@tremblence]

It was destroyed by greedy businesses, mexican citizens themselves (dumping trash) and the cartel who only cares about profit Most of the American and European tourists I saw DID NOT dump trash, and instead were picking up after the Mexicans who dump trash

[@chrisg5894]

Alright old Darren. Move to Detroit with your grandson

[@hdfchggvjh]

the fact is if tourism ended in tulum 99% of the locals would be in far worse shape. i also became friends with a few locals that i speak with pretty regularly who moved from mexico city and they enjoy the slow paced life there. Also, go to Playa Mirador right on beach road and it's pretty much ONLY locals as it's free parking and access. It's clear you only spent a couple days in Tulum and act like you are an expert on local life.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your feedback. I can only report on what I see at the time…

[@stevenleslie8557]

If you look at resort towns in Latin America through the lens of a humanitarian, you are always going to witness many conditions of a third world country. It sounds like you are better suited to be a Peace Corp volunteer than an exploitive American tourist and that's ok.

[@Hazel64348]

Everything said on this video is totally true, just returned Mar 11 2023

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your comments!

[@jh11ful]

Yep, we were there for a week and it's scammers central. They put way more emphasis on using visitors like ATMs than immersing people in a real cultural experience. It's disappointing for a place with so much history. I'm not going to discourage people not to go even tho it was the worst experience we've had, but if you're going to visit, make sure you do a lot of research and DO NOT take taxis - rent a car from a top rated rental company!

[@marcovinicioaguileraneira9159]

Like a mexican I would like to say THANK YOU!!! Please go and NEVER return. The tourist are destroying our most beautiful natural places.

[@tubethis777]

​@@jh11fulthanks for your tip, but should've taken cabs instead of renting a car, the only scam I had.

[@rozhonzagros7014]

Thank you so much for sharing this! You sure saved us a lot of hassle.❤❤❤

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

And thanks for watching plus adding your comment!

[@aleksintravel]

Right now returned from Tulum. And it was my biggest mistake. Thailand 100 times better. Tulum prices are crazy. Taxi drivers take minimum of 500 even it’s 5 minutes walk. Attitude is incredibly horrible. They look at you like on the wallet. Rude. Lot of scams. I went on petrol station and was said to pay 1200 pesos. I’m giving 1500 (500 3 times). The same time another guys comes to me and offers to clean the wind. I say no. Turn back to the guy I’ve just paid too and he shows me 500, 500 and 50 pesos. They do it on petrol stations, hotels. Like the Mexican vibe, music but WILL NEVER GO BACK TO TULUM OR CANCUN. You can have much better vacation for this money

[@MoSamManorManor]

Thanks for sharing the other side. It definitely changed our plan and we are skipping Tulum.

[@Easedan900]

Why just go and find out yourself 😂

[@johnlewis195]

My Deceased Husband and I had a Ball in Tulum...We we're at the Resort but we Rented at the Airport and drove to Tulum.. RIP Benji Miss you BAby

[@aspiring...]

I have a holiday in Mexico booked and coming up. I was considering Tulum. I try not to watch too many of these videos, but this one is very useful.

[@dreamcompletion9671]

Thank you for making your video so informative on a level of importance. And for not stating 'superficial' facts as to why you dont like a place, like so many other travel videos ive seen. These are important facts and they are well received.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thank you for your kind response. I really appreciate it!

[@rafamayzin9093]

This video is 100% accurate. I've been to Tulum 6 years ago and it was nothing like what I've found when I've been there last week. Cartels ruined this place and they totally privatized it. The maintance of public (but no so public) beaches is laughable for a place like this. Roads are 3rd world material, and yes you almost need a 4x4 Jeep/pickup in La Valeta if you get a hotel there like I did. Pollution is just crazy. The massive presence of police and military sometimes feels weird to say the least. But me personally I didn’t had issues with them. The stuff you find on local shops are sooo overpriced and they can be found at the local Chedraui or Walmart in Cancun for more than half the price. Same stuff. You can't even take a walk to enjoy the place because you will be ASSAULTED by hundreds of people wanting to sell you something in a very annoying and disrespectful way. Another thing I totally HATE and everyone should be aware of are those people all around the city (even inside Chedraui and on the road at the entrance of the Ruins right next to the police) rushing you to sell their tours claiming to be Mexican authorities or actual tour guides. THEY ARE NOT! They are just scammers, probably criminals, DO NOT FALL FOR THEIR LIES and do not pay them a single pesos. These people are not just stealing off tourists and not improving the local people's lives at all, they also stress the local fauna so so much. All they care about is their income, doesn’t matter who or what they’re hurting on the process. Even Akumal is quickly following the same path and it's really really sad... This place deserve better.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your comment…appreciated!

[@squirrelattackspidy]

Very helpful information. Thank you for this!

[@walterrojas2761]

As Mexican I must say that is True what you say about ‘profit over people’. Te destruction of Tulum is related with the destruction of the originals community.

[@cdelane3335]

Yes I just saw where a couple where on a special trip came from Texas a wave broke the one guys next and the hospital wouldn't do anything until they paid 20,000 and when they got back to american he was in critical condition. Because the unsanitary conditions at the hospital he got meningitis and they also did the surgery wrong. Doctors in Texas saved his life.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for sharing. I just read an article about what happened. What a terrible tragedy!

[@chadstewart5610]

I went to Tulum during December in 2009, 2011, 2012 and 2017. Each time I stayed in inexpensive hostels and hotels in the town. I had a good time every time I visited. I like the funky, gritty feel of the town. I always biked to the beach, no problem, I like the heat. Scuba diving in all the cenotes is amazing, did that every visit. However, I may never go back as in 2017 I could tell it was getting more expensive and overbuilt, and the last stretch of beach that hadn’t been developed as of 2012 had finally been developed as of 2017, so there was no longer any beach area in Tulum with nothing behind it but trees and other plants. That was hugely disappointing to me, my excitement turned to sadness. I didn’t even hang out there, I biked a couple minutes south to the Papaya Playa hotel where I was able to hang out on their relaxing beach for the cost of a Corona beer purchased at their bar, which was fine. I hope they can get the pollution and trash problems under control. In 2017, I also visited Playa del Carmen for the fourth time, and the amount of beach erosion in the central part of the city, paralleled to Quinta Avenida, as compared to 2012 was shocking. The beach width from hotels to water was half what it was in 2012; the stench of sewage in the seawater was quite noticeable, too, so I didn’t even go in the water. Alas, we are loving the “Riviera Maya” to death.

[@BretBallast]

Check out my latest video. I really enjoyed staying in Puerto Vallarta versus Playa Del Carmen and Tulum. The Mexican culture there was alone worth the trip!

[@rusticwood]

You nailed this one brother

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your comment! Much appreciated 😊⭐️👍🏻

[@chrisg5894]

Yup, he did a great job of putting down a place he couldn’t afford to even rent a place 20 minutes from the beach

[@ksmith2852]

I wish everyone considering Tulum as a destination would watch this video. I have stayed in Tulum for 2 months and experienced everything in your video. You did a good job putting this together. Please keep posting links to your video on the message boards so people have all information to make informed decisions.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for confirming what we saw there. I will definitely post links so more people know what Tulum is like….😎👍🏻

[@Hazel64348]

Me too

[@tremblence]

@@ShouldWeLiveHere Its a cultural issue, where mexican citizens choose to dump trash, rather than pick up trash Most of the European and American tourtists I saw DID NOT DUMP TRASH Infact I didn't drop a single piece of trash in my 3 weeks in Mexico recently, but I picked up 12,500 pieces of trash (from what I counted).......and I am European

[@blacksnowflake8574]

@@tremblence i did the same in Thailand

[@evahori7986]

Thank you for this very honest, detailed & accurate review of Tulum! The whole place has turned into such a money-grabbing tourist trap so between that, the total lack of environmental consideration & planning, and unpredictability of drug violence, it is a no-go for investing for us. Anyone who visits, will see every one of the points you brought up completely confirmed. Ugggh, its very sad & my heart goes out to the locals, who deserve so much better.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

We agree. It could have been so much better!

[@dominiopublicomx6138]

😂🇺🇸 schools more dangerous than 🇲🇽❤️

[@chrisg5894]

This review is of someone who got scammed or overpaid for a rental. It’s a totally inaccurate depiction of the town

[@chrisg5894]

The locals benefit from tourism as it’s the #1 industry there. What else do you think they’d do for money? Sell sand or coconuts?

[@gladlock]

you have to realize that looking to invest is the problem. The more demand we give, the more unscrupulous people will develop. So if we don’t want to contribute, foreigners have to stay away FROM ALL AREAS not just Tulum. I contributed to the problem because I am tired of having these morals and not having anything to my name. So yeah, I had to take my piece of the pie before I don’t have a place to fall dead in

[@dionisiotato4730]

Excellent information. Complete, well organized and respectfully presented. Thank YOu!! We hope the local government addresses these serious challenges so the life quality improves for all residents and tourists. 👌

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

So nice of you to comment! Yes, hopefully things can change in Tulum for the better.🙏🏼

[@GabrielaDey]

Ive been in Tulum for 1 day and I’m already over it. Might end my trip early

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

I hear you on that! Thanks for watching⭐️😊👍🏻

[@followingthecorporations]

How did it turn out for you?

[@GabrielaDey]

@@followingthecorporations hated it. Ended my trip after 3 days and went to Cancun.

[@followingthecorporations]

@@GabrielaDey when I visited my first day there I took a cab there and as I was arriving into my hotel I told the taxi “know what just turn around back to Cancun lol” but that’ was my first feeling, now I did go there because I wanted to see some properties for investment but I just had a feeling of disgust, but had already payed for the hotel, and this that and the third so end up staying for a week,, I was surprised .. maybe I’m used to more of a city but my first impression wasn’t great

[@GabrielaDey]

@@followingthecorporations yeah same here, Im usually one for adventure and trying new things but Tulum really had a “third world country” feel. Except for the hotel zone ofcoarse, but even that, the beach is completely blocked off by beach clubs and the strip isnt even walkable, just a road. The airbnb I stayed at was beautiful but the water in shower tasted like Chlorine. Also sad to see so much trash and plastic bottles on the sides of the streets. People living in handmade shacks right across the street from a luxury building. Cabs super expensive and the locals just try to extort money from you as much as possible. Not as friendly of a vibe as Cancun or Playa del carmen.

[@francesi.pimenteln]

Your video is very real and I appreciate you pointing out the problems that need to be resolved in Tulum. Creating awareness is important. Now I do have to point out a few things, for those looking for first world country feel, in Mexico tourist beach towns, and others such as Dominican Republic you will not find it there. These are THIRD world underdeveloped countries with a multitude of problems to resolve. I was raised in third world, so I know first hand. Please set your expectations to understand this. Secondly, yes, all this is true, but I lived in Tulum 2 years (2020 to 2022 and will be back to live again soon) and I fell in love with its beauty, uniqueness, and energy and there is a TON of initiatives from both locals and expats that also fell in love with Tulum coming together in community to help resolve these issues. The community in Tulum for those that choose to stay is nothing short of amazing. People from all over the world and backgrounds coming together for love of a place. There are beach clean ups and other environmental events initiated by local organizations and local community members regularly. We are working on building a Tulum local currency to help support local producers and businesses. We have an endless list of projects aiming for protecting the environment and pushing sustainable initiatives. Yes, we are up against massive issues, but there are also new government initiatives being launched to help resolve this situation. Just a week ago, a new council was set up by the municipality to oversee Tulum's development, aiming for protecting the environment and pushing for sustainability. Let's pray it is successful and does what it intends. What you see happening here is not uncommon in many other highly sought-after tourist beach destinations in underdeveloped third world countries that are under threat of overdevelopment and mass tourism without proper urban planning. Many forces and interests at play in a constant war against each other. I appreciate your asking to support locals, as that is exactly what is needed, among many other things. I'd also advise in your trips to also seek out the local initiatives that are fighting the battles on the ground to help resolve these issues and find a way to support these. You can do so from a distance. No, Tulum is not for everyone, but is an incredibly special place, unique, sacred and absolutely beautiful. Once you understand what is going on and you accept what is, but also do your best to be a part of the positive change, I promise you will experience magic and incredible life changing experiences. Much love and thanks for creating awareness. Feel free to reach out to me if you want to learn more about what we are doing. Follow @tulumcoindao on IG and get involved or create awareness also about this. Blessings.🙏🏻

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thank you for your comments. We are so happy to hear about the efforts being made. ❤️ We will be sure to follow along on Instagram as we are interested to learn more.

[@francesi.pimenteln]

Thank you! We appreciate all the support we can get.🙏🏻

[@RebelofIreland]

It’s an absolute rip off. I’m devastated to see the destruction . My fourth visit in 15 years. I’ll not come back anymore now. Tired of being scammed. Riviera rip off

[@j.kristineemmons]

I'd love to see things change. I wouldn't be as bothered by the third world things, if they were actually charging Mexican prices, yet, this may be the most expensive place in the world. Da fuq?!?!

[@benjaminz2523]

Nice try, good luck trying to convince yourself. Tulum is garbage.

[@kosmosuniversum4385]

Thank you for this info. You’re totally right!!!

[@Carolinapetroska]

Tulum is polluted and dirty. We spent 500 pesos for 6 km !!!

[@staniberlin1550]

Hello, My wife and I were planning a two-week vacation in March 2025 in Tulum. Thank you for this video. Regards, Stani

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for watching!

[@samandnick]

We agree.... we did not like Tulum as much as the hype is. There were some amazing parts, but its still don't think it's worth a long stay. We just bought a house in Medellin, Colombia, so maybe check Medellin out ;) It's a perfect city!

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for watching. We have added Medellin to our list to check out. 😀

[@Carolinapetroska]

I agree. I am dying to leave after 2 days. Can't wait. It sucks.

[@gretchenryan8344]

You do realize many cities in Mexico are like this? If you don’t stay in a tourist hotel area this is what you experience.

[@alexone8338]

This is rural Mexico. Tulum is a somewhat isolated TOWN. The cities are way more developed, especially the bigger ones.

[@gretchenryan8344]

@@alexone8338 honestly the taxi drivers and police are who you need to avoid in Tulum. The are in cahoots

[@d.e.t4147]

We just got back from Tulum a few days ago. Stayed at Secrets Tulum Resort, which is an all inclusive resort. It was very beautiful and the food was amazing. We did try to venture out to walk into town but we could not find our way and ended up going back to the resort. During our walk I was so shocked and saddened to see trash absolutely everywhere. It’s so beautiful there but I wish they took more pride in their land in keeping it clean. All in all we had a nice and relaxing time.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

I’m happy your stay was amazing at the resort. And yes, hopefully Tulum can turn itself around in the future!

[@jamesjessup1154]

Thank you for publicizing the trend in Mexico to trash the small towns once on the beach not allowing for a laid back "beach vibe" to continue or develop and the fact that none the profits from luxury developments end up in the hands of the local indigenous families, existing small businesses, or the improvement of local infrastructure. It can all be summed up as GREED.

[@cookingwithadamkahnandlixu2718]

We scratched Tulum off our list about a month ago. We'll still be looking for our place too.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for watching! Do you have any favorite places so far? We are planning out where we will go next.

[@cookingwithadamkahnandlixu2718]

@@ShouldWeLiveHere I'm planning on looking at Kuala Lumpur this summer, but haven't been yet. We looked at Spain last year and Portugal. I should have done videos :)

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

@@cookingwithadamkahnandlixu2718 Keep in touch and let us know what you think of Kuala Lumpur! We want to take a big trip to Asia and another to Europe. What did you think of Spain and Portugal? Any favorite cities we should check out?

[@Another_taco.Yes_please]

Try Stewart Island, NZ. Beauty and you can still dive for abolone.

[@sweetieinsf]

I agree with most of your points however you clearly have not spent much time in Mexico. People living in dirt floored shacks with no running water is not uncommon at all. Playa del Carmen suffered most of the same issues 10 years ago but has grown up since. Comparing a new, rapidly growing Caribean tourist town to the metro Mexico City is comparing apples to oranges. Mexico is not the US but it is rapidly being over run by the hords of US citizens escaping from that nightmare and bringing their money and problems here.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Good to know! Thank you for your insight…and for watching. 👍🏻

[@joserobertoramirezarevalo4610]

People live in what?!...sir, you described an average African country, but the american ignorance, don't surprise me.

[@Hazel64348]

Playa del Carmen was never this bad and still isn't. You want people to enjoy Tulum then reduce prices, stop ripping tourists off and the native Tulum residents who where promised by the Mayor to receive a plot of land for voting for her 7 years ago! It's a shame how the average Mexican Tulum residents have to dwell in shanty areas in Tulum surrounded by filth or tourists who stay in condominims surrounded by garbage, potholes, dust boles and loud, very loud construction all day long! You want tourists to come then Tulum clean up your act! I wasted 2 months of hard earned money on a lease, to visit a Tulum I onced enjoyed. Taxis, the Beach Chairs, access to the Beach are completely corrupt. 500 peso taxis to go 20 minutes to the beach, having to pay per person, 500 pesos to sit on a chair on the beach. Acess to the beach is next to impossible unless you slip some guy a hundred pesos to walk through the property and 375 pesos for a Hamburger It's all so outrageous!

[@wetguavass]

Mexico is not as poor or violent as the USA.

[@j.kristineemmons]

​@@joserobertoramirezarevalo4610what he was getting at was the income inequality. The amounts they're charging there and bringing in is absurd. Workers, with that kind of money coming in, should be living like the Vegas residents.

[@lacasarodarte]

Hi! We live here in Tulum since May 2021. We are completely agree with all that you said, but, you forgot about the street animals issue, they are each day more, abandoned or abused, education, information and resources is all what citizens need. Beyond this, we have a lot of reasons because we live here, but, we still wishing this kind of changes in Tulum. We are form Buenos Aires, Argentina bdw. Greetings ❤

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your nice comment. We also hope changes for the better occur in Tulum!

[@lacasarodarte]

@@ShouldWeLiveHere Oh! And I forgot to say, that you're right about the sargassum in February 2023, but fortunely it stops around June, and luckily for local people, we could enjoy turquoise and clean water during the summer. And this year we only had around May/June , and the rest of the year the sea was incredible beautiful. So I think that now, with the climatic change none season is 100% stable.

[@cancanturco]

Por qué viven en México, regresen a Argentina. No necesitamos más Caravanos viviendo en carpas en terrenos baldíos.....gracias por contribuir al desmadre

[@Multigaming927]

got back from Tulum about 3 days ago, definately need to rent an atv or scooter but driving is chaotic to say the least ! restaurants in town are okay but beach side we felt being taken advantage off most of the time wich is unfortunate on vacation. it is very expensive.. ive seen ice cream sell for 14$ in a supermarket and prices were almost the same or higher than Canada. The national guard is hard to get used to as well..and police are corrupted to the bones. Overall weather is great, we found a beach club that we liked so spent most of our time there but definately not going back and wonder if we would have traveled there having seen this video before ! I recommend going elsewhere :) enjoy your trips and thanks for the video it explain well whats going on there behind the instagram photos ;)

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your comments!

[@OSCARHERNANDEZ-un5iy]

got robbed at beachclubbathroom at gunpoint got kicked n hit on head f tulum

[@gaetanrichard8987]

thank you so much for your report and the facts you presented...it helps me in the choice of my future vacation in Mexico

[@tinatingson8564]

Very informative video and it keeps you watching. Very professionally done and fact based. Thanks Bret. Looking forward to watching your thoughts about Bali in Indonesia.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks Tina! 😁👍🏼

[@chrisg5894]

The only reason he’ll be able to go to Bali is because he likes Detroit where crime is the highest in the country and you can get free houses

[@meTWO2323]

😞 Wow. We used to fly into Cancun & immediately take the bus to Tulum. In the mid 90's, paid $4 per night to hang mi hamaca en una palapa right on the beach, almost next to the ruins. ~$10 for food & 1 piña colada per day. It was very safe & beautiful.

[@alereeves]

Tristemente cierto!! Todo lo que mencionas es 100% real. Yo y mi novio habíamos ido 3 veces antes, claro, hace 5 años y era OTRO lugar!! Sin tanta basura, sin mafias de argentinos (en arriendo de moto, bicis, autos, deptos, todo!!!) Es muy triste ver cómo en 5 años cambió tan drásticamente todo 🥺 destruyeron algo que pudo ser un paraíso. También desistimos en invertir y vivir ahí. No tiene absolutamente nada del espíritu mexicano, solo les interesa sacar el máximo de dólares posible a alguien. Una pena y un robo todo. Ni en Ibiza pagué por una cerveza lo que cobraban ahí.

[@hondacbx1975]

Chilena no ? Q rato criticando a los argentinos jajajaja

[@alereeves]

​Tengo muchísimos amigos argentinos, no tengo nada contra la nacionalidad de nadie, sí contra el ABUSO y que destruyan algo que fue hermoso y que NO respeten a los locales. Uno cuando llega a un paìs debe adpatarse y respetar desde la cultura, la naturaleza, el entorno, costumbres y por sobretodo ser amable y educado. Si te sentiste identificado, o eres parte de esos grupos, dale una vuelta entonces constructivamente y ve que si sigues así será pan para hoy y hambre para mañana. Salu2

[@nataliemartin3773]

We just got back from Tulum and I agree with all of your points. It made me sad and confused as to why things are the way they are there. Namely, the hundreds of construction projects, trash, and lack of good touristy things to do like shopping or walking stretches of beach. I enjoyed my time there because I liked our resort and the food, but I won’t go back.

[@RonnieWisdom]

This is very sad. I visited Tulum during the pandemic in 2020, so barely anyone was there. Just a sprinkling of us. At that time it was very magical and peaceful. I remember the beaches and environment smelling very fresh and floral like. I am glad that I went at that moment in time. I had planned to return this summer, but after watching your video I may have to honestly reconsider.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for watching! Your comment is well appreciated.

[@steveb.5617]

The only thing you will be surprised in Tulum is how SUPER expensive everything is. The Hotel Zone has higher prices then the USA does, huge rip off in this area. You will find much better pricing on the city strip of Tulum.

[@CBalderas]

Got back from tulum last weekend. Stayed a week. I've been to tulum 6 times. One visit every 2 years more or less. This time around, I was super disappointed of the experience. I felt tires and robbed al.ost every day. Taxis and food has become super expensive. I remember bekng able to negotiate prices a bit but now it seems like the local have learned to say no and maintain their ridiculous prices. In my 6 visits, I've never ever seen the beach as it was the first time I went there. I remember it was the whitest of the sands and the clearest of the water you can ever get. Now, sand is full of plastic pieces and other residues like dried sea weed or full-on seaweed. Getting around is frustrating. Roads are sub saharan-like. Really bad infrastucture. I dont think I will be going back, sadly.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Yes, hopefully things can still turn around there for the better!

[@markharrison94]

Well just got robbed by cops stopping cars tonight. My daughter and I had just finished an excellent yoga session. One of them had me stand outside the car with my hands on the car. They said they were checking for drugs. Very intimidating. Yes all the other stuff on your video is true.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Oh man! Sorry to hear about your police stop. Frightening.

[@markharrison94]

@@ShouldWeLiveHere will add it to life’s experiences. I lived in South Africa for four years and felt safer.

[@andreas11735]

It's true what he says about income inequality BUT it's not like there are better-paying jobs that the people are CHOOSING not to take in the area. If everyone boycotts Tulum over low wages the companies that pay these wages won't pay more and the people will be left with nothing. Tourists shouldn't have to subsidize corporations that exploit workers but if this really bothers you (and it should) since you're already getting a deal on your vacation, tip generously. I'm all for boycotting to improve things, but in this case, it won't.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your feedback. Much appreciated!👍🏻

[@back2theunderground]

@@ShouldWeLiveHere same copy paste response and no interaction with commenters.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

@@back2theunderground What’s your opinion? I’d rather vacation or live somewhere else in Mexico- there are much better places. For example if you watch our Mexico City video it seems like the residents, in general, have a better quality of life.

[@j.kristineemmons]

I'm under the impression they don't get to keep their tips. Maybe a small percentage. Some try to steal tips from you through incorrect change or overcharging (they then close out the transaction for the correct amount, and keep the rest as a tip). Mexico is a sh*thole for them, yet trying to be world class with what they're doing to Tulum.

[@charlievilla2669]

Yes to all of this! You my friend understand what is really going on here 👌🏼

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your feedback! As always I really hope Tulum can turn itself around and be a better place for the locals.

[@Sabrina-od4mr]

Wow! Extremely informative!

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thank you for your feedback! Well appreciated.😊

[@chars70luke21]

Muy buen video me gustó bastante, qué muestra los alrededores, el ecosistema donde no hay una infraestructura para aguas residuales, donde muestra que está creciendo sin control, y dónde muestra la riqueza del lado de la playa y la pobreza del otro lado, es exactamente documental, Y si yo viviera del lado donde todo es bello , dónde es playa, es mar, etcétera, todo se vería bien. pero tú video muestra todos los aspectos que hay que ver, antes de decidir dónde vivir.

[@Senpaipaya]

Great informative video. Appreciate all the sources included. It’s sad to see a beautiful place and their people ran down by greed.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for watching! Really appreciate the feedback. I always hope though Tulum can turn itself around….

[@mikechapman3557]

“They paved paradise put up a parking lot” Joni Mitchell 😢

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Yep….

[@HomesteadMexicoCaribbean-nx5nh]

Just a heads up to anybody reading this, if you go during the summer there will be sargassum (seaweed) between October and May it’s not really an issue

[@bobbyboombeck]

Tulum is indeed undergoing a massive transformation. It’ll look and feel more like Playa Del Carmen in about 3-5 years. All the building is happening now so it’s chaotic, but it will and is a special place. If you want something polished where the kinks are fleshed out and the gentrification is more organized then Tulum would not be a place for you right now. PDC would be more likely your place.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

You are more optimistic than we are. 😁 Playa Del Carmen has more housing/infrastructure for residents that we didn’t see in Tulum. Aldea Zama, La Valeta and the beach area are set up for tourists/investors. Will be interesting to see what it is like in 5 years….

[@j.kristineemmons]

Totally different vibes in Playa del Carmen though.

[@CC-kl4nh]

Thanks for this video.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

And thanks for watching!

[@Glen-uy4jt]

Well I remember Tulum from 1990. There was only 1 small restaurant and only one palapa on the beach. Maybe, maybe 100 houses. It was an incredible place. Yes Xel-ha was incredible, I swam up one of the canals for hours. I have lived in Mexico now for 20 years. I did have a waterfront coconut farm but tourism and land grabs forced me out. I live in a small town in Chiapas now that does have a good sewage system, a village water supply and is well maintained. Living in Mexico does have it’s challenges and yes it has gotten more expensive, how do the locals survive? With difficulty. I am presently doing my one year obligation to work for the local water board, Agua entubada Ejidal. Your reporting fits in with what I experience in all Mexican towns but it did seem to be far worse because of the tourist explosion. The foto of the construction trash was a classic example of how things are done here. I hate to imagine about the amount of sewage and where it is ending up. Good video.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thank you for watching and your comment. You have certainly have had experience living in Mexico. Do you think it’s possible change will ever happen in places like Tulum?

[@Glen-uy4jt]

@@ShouldWeLiveHere I am sure that I was the first private purchase of waterfront property in Chiapas and possibly most other states. The issues that I ran into were based upon racism ( Mexico is for Mexicans ) and corruption. The corruption at the local level is what affects the locals the most and also causes major problems for tourists and land purchasers. I am a Mexican citizen so I was able to buy a lot inside of the Ejido, which is not legally possible for a non-resident. The garbage is a long standing cultural issue and if you look at it from a rational standpoint, if it is no longer useful, you discard it. We in the ¨West ¨ have a preoccupation with the visual but being a student of Taoism I understand the importance of Feng-Shui in our lives and that of the community. I did not criticize anyone here, I just started cleaning the streets in my neighborhood and the neighbors saw the value of this in their lives. I live next to a tourist attraction and the tourists, mostly National tourism, throw their garbage in the street or hide it in the planters lining the street. You asked about Tulum. I loved that place, I was alone in the ruins for over a week. No fences, no police, no hassle. The huge influx of wealthy foreigners and their huge appetites for everything was probably an overload for the locals and a gold mine for the ¨ officials ¨. I suspect that most land was Ejidal and has subsequently been transferred to ¨ propiedad privada ¨ to facilitate the sale to non-residents. Their must be a lot of shady deals going on with both parties. Local officials, municipal authorities and the state as well. One issue that makes local corruption so bad is that municipalities are autonomous. It is very difficult to iníciate an investigation into them. Apart from this a non-resident does not have access to the legal system unless they are the target. That would be expensive and troublesome. I have been to court many times as making a false accusation is a very common tactic here in Mexico. I have won every case by using my rights and the protection that is afforded Mexican citizen under those rights. A foreigner only has one right, that is the right to be expelled to his or her home country. This is accomplished when the foreigner is deemed to be inconvenient, hahaha. It is not done by a court but rather by SEGOB through an administrative act. If you want to know the ins and outs of property purchase, land issues, documents, procedures, corruption, SEMARNAT and waterfront issues I would be glad to communicate by email. Best wishes, I thought your video was well done, polite considering the subject and also had an objective view of the various situations. Piter Pan

[@ezmealstravels9221]

Thanks for your video. Never been but will definitely reconsider 😮

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

There are many better places in Mexico.

[@JohannaVenturoli]

I have to agree with most of the points you mention, especially the trash issue. Unfortunately, it is like this in most tourist places in Mexico. Being in Holbox especially broke my heart from seeing some many layers of plastic trash in the natural areas. I’ve see the locals just leave their trash everywhere, such ignorance and disregard for their beautiful home. I have decided to stay out from places like that🤕.

[@pjsopinion8028]

Thank you for this video!

[@cancanturco]

I love this videos, please make more...may the CARAVANS will stop 🙏🙏🙏

[@bdawg333]

Wish I’d seen this video before I spent a small fortune seeing it for myself. Absolutely hated this place, and couldn’t get away fast enough. After an amazing week in Mexico City, this seemed like another country altogether… The prices were shocking: one meal cost as much as what we spent to eat amazing food in MXCD for a week! It’s a beautiful area, but the vibe feels dark and the people here seemed almost hostile towards tourists… people were constantly trying to scam us out of money, from paying to park in free areas to overcharging us for a downgraded room… the whole area is just a big money grab! Mostly sad millennials Instagramming their food and beach posing… Won’t be back, won’t recommend.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Yes, it’s too bad Tulum had become like this…hopefully things can turn around there.🙏🏼

[@winniethepooh8945]

I’m reconsidering now. Thanks

[@aletafrances4984]

I travelled the gringo trail way back in the 80's - spent 10 days in Tulum. There was only 2 restaurants... stayed in a cabana aka a thatched roof hut - hooked up my hammock & the floor was sand. The only shower was down the road w/a huge bag of water that spilled over me while I washed up. The whole area was quite primitive which is exactly what I was aiming for. Looks like the world mindset has infiltrated the area... nowhere near what I experienced way back when. I could go to one of the two local restaurants & have a fresh local fish steamed to perfection... with hm salsa, beans & tortillas. Seems like those days are long gone which is very saddening. There was no city way back then - it was a quiet off the grid paradise - no more. Even the beaches have changed & I wonder if the coral reef is still alive? 😥

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for sharing!

[@geofredogirasol4457]

Likewise. Was there in the 80s. After watching this and reading the confirming comments, I have no desire to go back. Paradise lost.

[@sgill4833]

Yeah but the air pollution in Mexico City is not worth it.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks again for your comments. We didn’t notice the air being that bad when we were in Mexico City. We will have to read up more about the levels before we go back. We really loved Mexico City.

[@Black1ion]

Do NOT drive in Tulum, Mexico. When I rented a scooter I thought I’d be able to get around and avoid the INSANE taxi mafia who charge $20+ for 2min drives… HOWEVER be prepared to be stopped by the police and be bribed for money at least once a day… Today was the fourth time they have pulled me (this time because my tail light stopped working, which is the rental company’s fault). Then out of nowhere they insisted that I had been drinking… i was sober… But all of a sudden! They said I could go to the ATM and withdraw 4000 paso’s ($220) and the problem would go away… They watched me from a far go to the atm I got out 2000 paso’s ($110) then followed me down the road and stopped me in a dark alley. I then said it’s all the money I had, they looked disappointed and gave my license and told me to fuck off. Tulum is just a massive SCAM, either pay the taxi mafia $20 to up to $75 for 10min drives from the beach, or rent a scooter and get robbed by the police daily. I’d only recommend coming to Tulum or Cancun if you’re staying in resorts and not leaving. Do NOT drive in Tulum, Mexico.

[@MARIANAMOLINA-q5k]

completely agree with you, I thought I was the only one who could organize the situation.

[@cadrizzay]

Just got back from Tulum 2 days ago. Spent 3 nights there and had a good time. But this video is spot on. 1. I was shocked at how much trash and rubble lined the streets. One of the dirtiest places ive ever been. 2. Costs were insane!!!! Food, i paid damn near double what I’d pay in the US. Uber rides from the city to just about anywhere cost about $50. 3. Speaking of Ubers, if you don’t want to pay that much you can rent a car. But parking is Trash. I rented an ATV, which was fun but also over priced. Not to mention, the roads are so unsafe. Definitely felt like i was living life on the edge. 4. Beach access was trash. I found 1 sneaky, sure fire way to get into the beach without paying. But I just got lucky. 5. I did enjoy the beach (once I was able to sneak on). Gran Cenote was a great experience. Food was really good. Overall i had a good time but probably won’t go back, on my own dime at least.

[@cadrizzay]

Oh yea…and the seaweed was crazy!

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your feedback! Sounds exactly like what we experienced there….

[@marchileno]

That’s why I love Croatia … I travel to Dubrovnik every year. I love Croatia because it is so clean, extremely safe and the people are very friendly and civilised. No crime …. I have never seen anything in 8 years of visiting . I live in Lo don but I feel at home in Dubrovnik . It can be a bit expensive but not extortionate …. There is something for all budgets

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for the information! Hopefully someday we can travel to Croatia….

[@lauriedavis7471]

Wow! Great video. A friend works for one of the All Inclusive hotels in Tulum. His recommendation for us was not to stay at one of the beach hotels, and to stay in town. He said the drug cartels run Tulum and target the beach hotels more so than in the town area. And those policia and National guard vehicles we saw, the cartel control them. And its to keep those midlevel guys safe, not us. I liked Tulum, but not enough to go back. Have you explored Bacalar or Isla Holbox? I decided Chetumal is not the place for me either.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your inside info. We will add Holbox and Bacalar to our list to check out. In November we are going to Puerto Vallarta.

[@nah6730]

:-(…. Omg.

[@TimBenson-r6t]

This is so sad. I went in 2002 for the first time. It was a magical place back then. Getting to the beach from the town was less than $5 and there was hardly anything on it. I camped or stayed in huts on the beach for five bucks a night.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for the memory. Times have certainly changed!

[@hugoestrada3690]

You forgot to metion a few things, but I like your video in general. Thanks!

[@scottlackey3895]

Man, this was depressing. Do you have a video on places you recommend?? (beaches) . Thank you for the info!

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Definitely- most of our videos are places we recommend. We are in Puerto Vallarta right now and we far prefer it over Tulum. In the meantime check out this video on Mexico City! kzbin.info/www/bejne/jGnHgoZ6bcuNo68si=a1CASIBb4vn_8WIO

[@blueybarnes9442]

I was there a few years back and outside batey bar when a shootout broke out !! There was a shootout 2 nights later in the main town between cartels …… I personally find Mexico 🇲🇽 a hellish affair!! There’s a whole world out there which is much safer, cleaner, and cheaper !!

[@johnkla7866]

It's a shame what mass tourism has done to Tulum. It used ot be such a spectacular and laid back place and look at it now. Overrun with hipsters from all over the place paying fortunes for a vegan dish while the locals continue to have no benefits whatsoever from the flood of Dollars. It all goes to the already rich property developers who don't care about the environment and just want to make use of the natural beauty of the place. Really appalling....

[@blacksnowflake8574]

Watched the video as i was planning to go next year; certainly put me off and i am a seasoned world traveller. What could be a better alternative to Tulum? Is the whole Riviera Maya like that? Is Cozumel a better option?

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Check out my video about the best Mexican beach town. We really liked Puerto Vallarta and Plays Del Carmen. I haven’t been to Cozumel yet but I see online there’s pros and cons of going there. Cheers!

[@aninduvialwithagoodheart]

It looks like it can be very beautiful they should employ the locals to clean up the area. Imo when individuals are valued they tend to take better care of their areas. Wow I wanted to visit,I'm glad I saw this video.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thank you for watching! Really appreciate your comment…😊⭐️👍🏻

[@Janeblanc]

People complaining about the cartels and garbage and shacks in Mexico yet Americas top cities the most profitable making trillions don’t care about their homeless problem either. tents everywhere for miles. Cartels in California is a major major issue. And garbage? Well what do you expect from New Yorkers… (I am a New Yorker, and we are selfish entitled people especially people in Manhattan. The next Tulum is puerto Escondido, Oaxaca Clean beaches for miles access on all points, surfing town chill vibes, cheap food. And the greatest food! Oaxaca is known as the best food in Mexico. Check it out 😊

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

We will add it to our list to check out. There are many other places we hope to explore in Mexico. Mexico City is our favorite so far.

[@Cocoloco-qi9gz]

Thanks for sharing this information with us

[@sergioromero6876]

I Think greed has made that place SUCK rn but it will get better with the years as more governance reaches every corner of Mexico. Like you mentioned Mexico City has everything now that Tulum doesn't but it didnt always.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

I can’t imagine the beaches being opened up to the public. The way it is laid out almost ensures it can never become walkable. But one can hope…

[@butchmitch731]

That seemed to me to be a fair and balanced real time description of an area this here gringo knew well 35 years ago. Having lived in both Merida and Chetumal when Playa del Carmen was a still and quiet fishing village with only a couple of spots to really hang out, I lament the passing of that area's quaint & rustic charm. Quintana Roo is a Territory of Mexico, not one of the federated States of Mexico. To understand this fact and it's attached history, is to understand the People and the Place, with Love, unconditionally. There is a Something Present there which, while being far from hidden, is all but Invisible to most. Ojo. ❤ 🌙 🌞 🌧

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for sharing your thoughts! Much appreciated.

[@wildride6349]

This is a sad situation, I was in TULUM 5 times in the 2000s. It was cheap, safe, and fun. I have been eager to go back but no more. Belize, anyone?

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your comment! Don’t know much about Belize but will investigate further…✌🏻

[@VonRix]

Tulum was destroyed by tourists after Playa del Carmen was destroyed by tourists which after Cancun was destroyed by tourists. So are we now discussing what to destroy next?

[@bolly10gama76]

This was a your personal opinion! I have live there and travel many times. We absolutely loved it!!!!❤️❤️

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

So glad!

[@camels9654]

I'm in Tulum right now and people LISTEN to this video, he ain't covered it all. Every major industry in this place is monopolized by the cartel. Cabs are the most noticeable. It's $25 for a 5 minute cab ride here, no joke, and there is only one cab company. Restaurants are all price fixed, dinner for one person is going to be minimum $50, and the food is disappointing. The streets are lined with garbage, the roads off the main strip are fit for offroad vehicles. As a tourist every necessity of life here is double price over US/Canadian prices, and 50% less of it. TONS of mosquitos, I had to make a makeshift mosquito net to sleep at night. And yes it's weird to see luxury condos everywhere, then a literally shack in the jungle with a family chilling in it, with garbage everywhere. I've never seen so much garbage. I'll never return to Tulum. I literally cancelled the last month of my airbnb and rescheduled my flight to get out of here as soon as possible. Words cannot describe how much I hate this place, and I'm escaping -20C Canadian winter right now.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thank you for adding to what I discovered there! I just hope someday things get better in Tulum. Sorry though you had to cut your trip short. Hopefully you still can go elsewhere in Mexico….

[@camels9654]

@@ShouldWeLiveHere I'll look at different places, Tulum would be ok for a week vacation, but living here for the winter no es bueno, not a chance. You can't get soaked and pay tourist prices for 4 months straight. For a week who cares, go wild. Tulum is tourist trap.

[@mirelledominguezsalinas6098]

As a Mexican, I understand there are many inequalities in terms of salaries when you compare what a person from a large city in Mexico earns to what people who are in the provinces and in Towns I can only tell you that there are indeed many problems to correct in Tulum, it is an archaeological zone and beaches with a lot of potential but it is just beginning its modernization process Currently, its new international airport has just been built, which is expected to bring more foreign investment and at the same time better development, foreign investment, also with the arrival of the train Maya to the area, all these areas are going to be modernized, therefore we hope that there will also be more presence of the national guard in terms of security but in general a lot to work on.

[@valentinasantos1474]

You are the first person that mention the poverty of the locals as a problem that must be seen by the Americans that are migrating, and an unfair situation. Every American that comes are always boasting about the advantages of bringing dollars and spending so little.

[@bodyman29]

If you live in the center of Tulum you can walk 30 minutes to Playa Paradiso after the ruins

[@kaimoos9419]

You are right! I am a tourguide from germany and yes, i kwow Tulum from 25 jears ago, where it was just a quiet fishing town without a bank or oxxos! It was a bit like a hippieplace...so sad, how money can destruye a really magical space!

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for watching, and sharing! Hopefully Tulum can still change for the better.

[@Hazel64348]

I'll never return again either, loved it before but this video is totally accurate. Try staying in La Veleta it's a nightmare

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for watching! 🙏🏻

[@91hiace]

Sounds like someone looking to be the worlds best reporter. Lots of misinformation and click bait.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Which specific points do you disagree with?

[@rodraselasturrodriguez4773]

These are good insights about the problems in Tulúm that even people living there have been identifiying throughout this last decade. Just remember, Tulúm is still a small town, and all these problems are common with many towns around the world evolving into small cities and/or tourisric destinations. Remember: "Rome wasn't built it in one day" (Even Rome today, as well as many huge cities around the world, including México City, are also facing similar huge challenges in a different scale.)

[@tk102256]

Visiting now. Totally agree with all in the video. Will never return. Really sad. Puerto Vallarta, where I have been living is a totally better experience.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thank you for watching! Still hope Tulum can turn itself around….

[@x29iy]

What a shame. I went to Tulum in 1988. In those days it truly was a beach paradise. No condos or luxury hotels. I camped right on the beach for $2 a night. The footage from your video is nothing like I remember.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thank you for your comment. Much different back then!

[@Will-Max]

Yeah, I camped on the beach in Mazatlan in the good old days.

[@karenfarris7331]

NOOOO! Was advised to stay in Tulum so we can do some cenotes and Bacalar and we are leaving in two weeks. I feel ripped off already!!! I am in Australia and ten minutes from awesome quiet beaches so we were never attracted to that part of Tulum - it just seemed the best option to use as a base for four days. Any ideas on how to rearrange?

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Sadly I just watched a video that shows the seaweed is quite bad right now in nearby Playa Del Carmen. kzbin.info/www/bejne/a5rdqquIpMeMm7ssi=TOaMjfd_2a5F2b_E

[@andymandy8862]

Although most things said in this video are true, the cenotes are still beautiful and worth the visit. Don't be too discouraged! Playa del Carmen has also always had a problem with seaweed, it's not nearly as bad in Tulum this time of year.

[@chriscahill7463]

How was your trip?

[@IamNotanumber-z3j]

I’ve been 3 times , in the 90s when it was a sleepy hippy seaside resort with cheap low rise cabanas- white beaches and wonderful food- very safe.Second time 2008-I noticed that very few low grade cabanas left , more expensive ones , garbage starting to appear- the last time 2018- very very expensive- very busy - loud - dirty beaches- gang violence ,drug use -big hotels being built - seaweed everywhere- multinationals ownership- high noise levels .its truly sad to see the beautiful place become what it is. The blame - people , greed , tourism.

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Thanks for your comment. Sad to hear about the changes over the years…hopefully things can still get better!

[@Hazel64348]

We have been visiting Mexico for over ten years and never had an issue with a host before. Our host at DK Tulum., Andrea was rude and unhelpful. First, the rules on Sol/Andrea Arbnb where added after us being here for over a month. We were never provided with a list of rules or helpful information. Her mode of operation is to keep the rules secret and then try to catch you in a violation so she can fine you. Our first encounter was a request for the kitchen sink plug to be replaced as it was broken She demanded a picture to prove that it was broken!! Ok, strange but I sent her one. She responded that it was not broken. I pointed out that you can see in the picture that there is a hole through it. She answered," The plug is not part of the operation of the sink and contact me with a real problemlike the WiFi". She never did replace the plug and we had to use the plug from the shower to do dishes. She had someone taking pictures of the guests, apparently to try to catch them doing something wrong.. Are Airbnb hosts allowed to do that? Next we got a message from her saying to not dry towels on the balcony rail, (we only put them there after they where in the dryer for over an hour)as it is too flimsy to hold a towel! How strange! Our next incident was a message from Andrea saying that our rental bikes were parked illegally And she wanted to fine us. At this point we had had the bikes for almost two months without complaint and again had never been given any rules or guidance about bikes. We were doing what others were doing assuming this was ok She said that the staff had repeatedly told us about the bikes. This was not true as no one had said a word to us. We contacted the building administrator and he said we could keep the bikes in our unit so we did. We just wanted out of the three months rental after one month but she would not agree. Finally, her supervisor, Sol, agreed with Airbnb to let us cancel the third month but it cost us a penalty. Andrea sent us rude comments about feeling sorry for our next host and, regarding our having to pay a penalty to get out of the third month, and sent an emoji of crying. Now we were down to a little over a week to go and hopeful of getting out without further problems,but no. We get a message that the water would be off due to work in another apartment. When the water was turned back on, there was no water to our bathroom sink although the kitchen, shower, and toilet were ok. We had. tested the kitchen but not the bathroom. When we reported this to Andrea, her response was,"Now you tell me." She refused to believe that it wasn't working and demanded a picture. When I refused saying that was insulting and to please deal with it, she sent me a picture of a bathroom sink working and said she had had the staff check it. I pointed out that it was not our apartment in the picture. Finally I went to security myself and someone came up and got it working. Regarding DK Tulum, the apartments are quite nice but the surrounding area is terrible. We never expected unpaved streets and huge pot holes filled with muddy water. There was construction everywhere and jack hammers and loaders going all day except for Sunday. There was garbage everywhere. When we arrived in January we were dismayed to find mud and muddy water everywhere. If you went for a walk, you had to work around mud holes and in places the whole street was flooded. In February it stopped raining and the mud holes dried up leaving a thick coat of dust which got on everything. We had to mop the apartment and the balcony twice a day and clean the dog's paws every time we took him for a walk. The brochure showed a little restaurant in the compound where you could get snacks and drinks by the pool. This had been abandoned and the area was strewn with broken tiles and dishes and mildewed furniture. At some point they started to renovate it so the compound was disturbed by sawing and drilling. It was never reopened while we were there. The staff apparently did not consider the deck area around the restaurant to be their responsibility because, as the dust began, this area of the pool deck and the furniture was coated with a thick layer of dust. Anyone considering renting in the La Valeta section of Tulum should be aware of what they are getting in to. The prices seem good, but they don't tell you about the unpaved streets, the mud, the dust, the construction and the garbage everywhere.😮 The mode of operation is to try to fine you on rules that are not even posted, it's like a prison. DK Tulum, La Veleta

[@ShouldWeLiveHere]

Sorry you had such a terrible experience. I really wonder what it will be like in those areas in a few years. We really don’t see it improving.

[@Natalieturtle8]

Omg who would ever write this much on a KZbin video?? So sad..