Why your CORRECTIONS don’t work on your Dog!

[@logun24x7]

This might be the single most critical bit of dog training information on the internet .. and here it is for free. Well done Haz!!!!!

[@angelusapeertje]

Totally agree. Finally a explanation that will help my husband to understand this part. :)

[@TH3FORTE]

absolutely thankyou

[@edriccarrington9427]

THIS. 100%.

[@TDCIYB77]

The whiteboard is BACK! YES! Back to OG content!

[@kab1341]

The moment I saw the blue hair I realized this might be the best video you've ever made Haz 😂😂😂 I don't see any lies

[@thegarbagefly]

Remember when colored hair was a sign of rebellion 😢. What's happened in this world?

[@heavystacks80]

Zach George is having a panic attack and is in his safe space after watching this video 😂

[@logun24x7]

Old Zak is already ramping up to put an end to the Fear, Pain, and Violence, White Supremacies, Colonizers still training dogs with out dated methods ... LOL ... and the rest of the internet is hoping 2025 is the year Zak trains a dog.

[@joebloggs4191]

I wonder if his face underwent a force free procedure! 🤣

[@juliesdroidsync]

One of the best explanations I've ever heard on this topic!

[@zareth-shahar]

Man if I knew this 7 years ago when I had my fearful Corso ... I've learned so much from you Haz!! So great to see your building success over the years!

[@brandoncloudd]

Yes! You have me understanding how to properly understand my Dobie! He gets highly aroused and wants to play when seeing other dogs (doesn't bark) and any prong collar tug is ignored. He bounces too much. Now, I know what I'm doing wrong. I thought negative reinforcement would alleviate the problem. NOPE! You want to use NR to reinforce a desired behavior. So, If I want to train leave it or sit I add NR to get that behavior if the dog does not properly comply. Punishment will suppress and with the proper repetition remove the unwanted behavior(s). Thank you!

[@NickyHughes-rb6px]

Thanks

[@Spyder55262]

When I listen to these Haz talks I take notes. To change the dog I must change the handlers behavior. Clever talk Haz!!

[@steveb7795]

My Daughter and I also take notes too!!!!

[@TonganTomahawk]

Thank you for your content! It’s very important that a professional like yourself explains these concepts to ignorant people who continually humanize their dogs

[@StarkK9Academy]

Great explanation Haz, sharing with both my intern & clients.

[@airidasrudmimas8976]

Great advice and well put together video. I was struggling with a few things with my dobe, started applying your advice and am amazed at the results. Simple stuff really when you laid it out so well, now he is getting less and less reactive to other dogs on a walk! Thank you Haz! Wish you a merry Christmas!

[@deborahyzenbrandt4363]

The wig was chefs kiss 🤌

[@LaurentBertin]

Great explanations. 1000 videos on that on the postive still won't get it. I learned that from you and that changed fundamentally how I train my dogs and how I watch out for that unwanted R- and use R- as a good training tool This changed my dogs and my life with them. Forever greatfull, your courses are the best, and I've taken a lot online. Loved the wig :D

[@acela-and-Onyx]

Amazing as always!

[@heatherws8144]

Great video. Its crazy how many people who claim to be trainers don't know this.

[@thejindoman7471]

OMG!! I read the comments about the wig, and then the video began to play 🤣👌

[@stephanielopez8273]

HIGHLY enjoyed this... Very good explanation for dog Owners! I really hope more dog owners will find this helpful 🙏🏼. As a Dog Trainer I can appreciate this Video. And will be Recommendations for my clients ✨️ TY Hans

[@viridianaxvi8880]

R+ people always say 'you're not changing the behavior, just suppressing it when you use corrections!'. well that's fine with me lol, i want that behavior suppressed!

[@logun24x7]

The R+ people also say balanced trainers don't work on the emotion of the dog like extinguishing the behavior and working on the emotions of the dog are mutually exclusive but you see Haz do this as part of the training all the time .. kzbin.info/www/bejne/mJe2oXV7hd2coqs , once you have the behavior in check you can start rewarding for the dog making the correct choice and decesitising to source of the reaction .

[@DisforDogs1]

Its unreliable then. There can be a time that the dog bursts through this supression. And at the same time your dog isnt happy in life, because they get supressed in outing fear or discomfort. Also if you're not there to supress, there is a risk of a break as well. So changing the emotion is very important in training. Simple example : Dog doesnt like bikes and lunges. You supress it. But when one comes racing around the corner it could break the supression. Also your dog is always still scared of bikes, he just has to take it and hold it in, the fear is still there. If you were to change the emotion to the bike where he is no longer afraid and accepting of it, bam its gone. No fear, no response, totally reliable.

[@logun24x7]

@@DisforDogs1 LOL .. “And at the same time your dog isn’t happy in life” actually teaching a dog the correct way to express it’s emotions opens the world up to them, rather then getting hidden away, unwalked, and being moved from one form of confinement to another. I guess you didn’t read my post above, like I said the key to curing reactivity is both extinguishing the behavior and giving the dog positive experience to work the emotion. Shield K9 has done it this way for over a decade, there is a library of videos sowing the process and the results. The FF bunch will always point fingers at balanced trainers and say they don’t work the dogs emotion like if by doing one excludes doing the other. 1) Teach the dog to respect the Lease kzbin.info/www/bejne/iZmqYWtqrNijndk 2) Work the dog in Real-Life Settings. kzbin.info/www/bejne/bKPYfZKBhbV9qJY 3)Explain to the dog the (XYZ) behavior is not correct and then give the dog lots of positive experiences with (XYZ) triggers. kzbin.info/www/bejne/gGHYXotjmJyii6c 4) How many examples do you want kzbin.info/www/bejne/iIWxYnewad-MZrs kzbin.info/www/bejne/oJSqhmiZhrqpaa8 kzbin.info/www/bejne/a3vTgXdoeaqVrq8 kzbin.info/www/bejne/pYKvZp6gqJqSaZY kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZoSsooaVbpV5hcU

[@positivehotdogs]

@@DisforDogs1 LOL

[@DisforDogs1]

@@positivehotdogs Mature response.. Should as well said nothing because you already said as well as nothing. Bye.

[@MrInfamous1977]

I love videos like this. Great information like always. Thank you for sharing your expertise

[@sawyer4981]

My pup (11wk Golden Retriever) started biting when he doesn't get his way. Used to be just normal puppy nipping, but escalated to sink teeth in and pull type of biting. According to most trainers on YT, redirecting to a toy is the fix. Three weeks of doing that made it worse. Consistently grabbing his collar and giving a light shake and stern "no" has almost completely resolved the biting. And the second I let him go, he's happy go lucky again loving all over me. I'm all for positive reinforcement training, but "punishment" is required in certain situations.

[@pennyontrack]

This is mind boggling but so obvious thank you

[@sithappensdogtraining]

Nicely put bro. Couldn't agree more with how much B.S is out there. Drives me insane.

[@girlthatloves2sk8]

I needed this, i just rescued a cat in my yard 2 months ago, now basement cat. While my german shepherd is upstairs. His prey drive for this cat is wild! Taking all the advise i can get for them to possibly live on the same floor…

[@jirikolar8601]

this is me and what I needed to know.. been negatively reinforcing dog for a year, really hard to fix all that mess now

[@KelJoe_999]

AL FIN, un video en Español. GRACIAS Haz!!!!!

[@Escandella118]

I wish the people I want to show your video understood English better. Very very educational, explained super good!! I was able to get a lot of improvement through positive reinforcement in certain situations with my reactive gsd working line but not a reliability in every situation. I wish I would have known what I know now 5 ys back I would have started with all the quadrants not only half of it.

[@karaleeallen8523]

Thank you. This was good 👍🏻

[@jmo123DT]

I would also add negative punishment and positive reinforcement, which are crucial parts in the quadrant, and there's also the scale of most effective to least effective for each of the 4 types of conditioning.

[@asmrmetalman1061]

I used to believe punishment was only attainable through 'making an event out of it' but now I realize that was objectively incorrect after your video and through your courses.

[@joaquinmartinez8707]

Best 5 seconds intro.

[@edriccarrington9427]

For me Haz bridges the gap between Koehler, the present training climate, common sense, real world practical experience .. all this apllied to me pursuing mondioring as supplemental training and fullfilnent for my own dogs and myself as a handler. Perhaps i should take the online course to further any progress made thus far🤔

[@ItsLukeDude]

Thanks for the video!

[@Spyder.55]

I wish we could have had a video on NR. It is a much more complex theory than the other 3 quadrants

[@CawckyTalksDogs]

Really good video as always, though I think a more in-depth follow up would be good to the difference in the Behavior Reduced vs Alternate Behavior part of your explanation, particularly with dogs offering up alternate behaviors on their own during the Behavior Interrupted part of training (with doing things like sitting or lying down automatically when the behavior is interrupted). I personally found there was some clarification missing on how to actually handle that if/when it happens, when to let an "alternate behavior" slide and when to take further action so that you're reducing the behavior instead of reinforcing it or falling into mindless punishment. Everything else was excellent though!

[@CalebFowlerOfficial]

4:00 Jonathan Katz said the same thing good shit brotha🤟

[@Watchandcutgearchannel]

Opening statements !!! 💯!!!! I fought very hard to keep my little doggies nuts. Every one is on this neuter train .. a bunch of idiots..

[@arye.dogman]

Shalom from Israel. Perfectly presented! Helps a lot in teaching others. Thanks

[@LimitlessJayson]

Saw this earlier on Patreon.. Now we just need more visuals examples LOL

[@Sunshines83]

Thank you for your videos! Wig was 😂!

[@Jesvalles]

Top notch content, thank you! This actually helped me so much. Also... We need to name the blue hair character and make they/them a regular thing 🤣

[@SgtEvangelist]

Hagz!!

[@casscanine]

I wish we didn't have to equate balanced training and comfort with using punishment, with transphobia. Doesn't help our case really, just alienates more people

[@luckluckey2427]

Great information on negative reinforcement but how do you actually achieve punishment to extinguish a behavior?

[@CL-cn1ng]

I wish I could like more than once!

[@malinoisdogtraining3441]

Great explanation Haz. You are a brilliant trainer.

[@swiralgod]

They call it getting the dog "fixed" but I see it more like they're getting the dog broken.

[@jameskissling5136]

Love the wig

[@martinabrahamgomezgarcia2780]

Agradecemos mucho que se pueda configurar el audio en español 🫶🏽❤

[@vincentkingsdale8334]

I love your no nonsense, conservative, common sense views.

[@MichelleDanajka]

😂 (to the wig)

[@chrismarshall7124]

You talked and gave a lot of examples of how people use something as punishment, but it’s actually negative reinforcement well then what is an actual punishment that will get what we are trying to achieve?

[@TristanGibsonDogTraining]

I had the understanding that negative reinforcement was taking something away from the equation to make something more likely to happen. I.E leash pressure to hold accountable a dog to sit, and taking away the pressure once the dog sits. What am I missing here?

[@JamieMcgahey]

Boom og !!!

[@KariEngblom-Youkey]

Demand barking🙄 I have a great dog... Who demand barks. I hate to admit it ( i have a behavior analysis degree and i am rich in theory and "certificates" and teaching behaviors... But, this sums up my experience) Somehow I have reinforced her demand barking. Going back to the drawing board! I got alternative behavior... But, this girl likes to express her disatisfaction with my lack of behavior when she demands attention. I haven't found a punishment ( according to me) that works. Thanks for this video. I am down with covid and my dog is not happy with me...soo...this is a timely video and the perfect time to re-evaluate this behavior on both our parts. 😊❤

[@ripreinhold6572]

In short, an insufficient correction can become a negative reinforcement?

[@thegarbagefly]

Poor timing as well

[@stephaniechapman2010]

Knowing how to use training tools correctly is a big problem I have seen with some people.

[@SatiricalLizard]

Came to learn, stayed for blue hair Haz lol

[@criktun3346]

Watch 2 dogs play together, and tell me a leash pop hurts them lol. It is COMMUNICATION.

[@1packatak]

Well in cases where you want to punish, it actually should. A lot of people just don’t put enough umph in it to create the punishment. Which leads to turning it into negative reinforcement.

[@jadetries]

Hmm… I understand the concept, but I have no idea how to apply it in real life?? My dog is extremely anxious, she’s often very close to her threshold for stimulation. She has pain medication and noise sensitivity medication that -have- reduced her baseline, but she is still a very nervous dog. I can see now that any punishment I’ve attempted has become negative reinforcement instead, but how on earth do I ensure the link between a behaviour and punishment is understood or takes priority over instinct when my dog is almost always overstimulated when she indulges in a behaviour that feels rewards to her? I’m stumped. And especially how can I punish bad behaviour without interrupting it? How can you punish reactivity without interruption? I really don’t understand the application part of this. 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@mds536]

Extinction does never mean, the neurons that mediate that behavior go extinct. They continue to exist. That is science. The only thing you can do is to establish stronger alternative pathways with new neurons that will be faster and stronger than the first existing neurons...

[@joakim4243]

Wouldnt a leash check that makes the dog lounge or increase its intensity just be an example adding a stressor that takes the dog over threshold which is what makes the dog react? Or maybe an example of classical conditioning where the dog connects the uncomfortable stimuli from the leash check to the sight of the other dog, which will make him more likely to react the next time by the sight of another dog by means of adding another stressor to the "sight of another dog-situation" that increases the likelihood of taking him over threshold in that situation? And further, wouldnt an increase in reactivity as a result of leash checks only be an example of negative reinforcement if SEVERAL continual leash checks was administered by the sight of the other dog (simulating continual uncomfortable stimuli) until the dog lounges/reacts whereafter the leash checks stops? Or if continual e-collar stim was administered by the sight of the other dog until the dog lounges/reacts whereafter the e collar stim stops (continual uncomfortable stimuli -> behavior from dog -> uncomfortable stimuli stops -> behavior increases)? Just trying to get a grasp of the technicalities.

[@xanderxander08]

Bro this is gold info for free.

[@radekmamcarz]

13:35 😅

[@Dhejdjskd]

His hairline is receding fast.

This ended up confusing me a bit: does R- interrupt the behaviour because it doesn't last long enough, it isn't strong enough to be percieved as a punishment or for another reason? Leash correction don't faze my dog in the slightest, does it mean they don't work on him or they don't work given from me? If he decides whether I'm punishing or reinforcing him, it sounds like the only path is unending trial and error until I find what he sees as punishment unless I'm missing something.

[@s.b.5259]

My question is how to punish a dog who has been completely desensitized to a prong, slip, choke chain, and e-collar? Any application of these short of actually harming the dog will only either get a redirection with a bite, is ignored, or is just in the -r range... Kind of lost on this one. and no, im not the one who made it worse using -r. Im the one trying to fix it.

[@shawnn188]

just have a few questions what are your thoughts on american akita as a family pet and have you ever trained them how hard is it to train for obedience ?

[@alphakennels]

Akitas are quite headstrong

[@erica_lancaster]

Bahahaha 💀

[@indribennu]

22 secs... Y como decimos en españa: ya estás mezclando churras con merinas... Where do you leave ethical practices in this whole equation, knowing that there are more effective and moral methods when training dogs? I dont understand.. Least Intrusive Minimally Aversive protocol, have you heard about it?

[@shieldk9]

Yes it’s nonsense.

[@joebloggs4191]

Were you raised force free?

[@Shraddha-n7t]

**"Punishing a dog, like using a shock collar, doesn’t solve the problem-it makes it worse. Dogs bark or act out because they’re frustrated, anxious, or lacking exercise and socialization. Punishment only suppresses the behavior while creating fear, frustration, and even aggression. Over time, this can break a dog emotionally, making them scared of walks, the world, and even their owner. Instead of punishment, focus on the root cause. Exercise, socialization, and positive reinforcement are the real solutions. Punishment doesn’t fix behavior-it destroys trust and harms your dog

[@shieldk9]

Nope..😂

[@DisforDogs1]

Mostly agree. Example : Dog is scared of bikes and therefore lunges. Supress and supress doesnt fix the emotion. And if one suddenly races around the corner, he could break out of the supression because the scare was sudden and intense. Teach a dog that a bike is not something to be afraid of and tadaa he wont lunge, even when suprised. Done this time and time again with clients. The ones that supress usually come to ask me after something happend. And I explain it just like that. Never failed again.

[@DisforDogs1]

​@@shieldk9A serious trainer or behaviourist shouldnt respond to a respectfull comment with emojis. Its childish and disrespectfull when the other is just leaving a respectfull comment. "😂" just dont, wont get your point across and I cant take someone serious who does these "😂"

[@brucemckay7828]

I agree. I'll skip the emojis

[@logun24x7]

@@DisforDogs1 I could take you to more than a few R+, Force Free, Fear Free, LIMA, LIFE ... whatever the hell your calling it today community sites that could take that advice.

[@BirdTrainingClub]

He can I received a lot of unintended negative reinforcement as a kid

[@zsahe21]

[@snuckyr]

Haz, how do we punish our dogs effectively? Or is they not something you’re allowed to teach on the u tubes?

[@lukeryuzaki2328]

Go watch the first Reactivity session video uploaded few days ago for example. That should be unless you have hard dog with serious aggressiveness issue (which is rare).

[@lukeryuzaki2328]

Blue haired force free Karen 🤣

[@john-draftanimal]

Don't be an anti-vsxer. That is stupid. Also, an intact male can be a greater issue. But we deal with it because 1. we may breed, 2. I prefer the development intact males get. And yes, when needed we use 'adverse' training and punishments when needed (often enough). Also we have made mistakes that way and had to repair unintended results when he takes the wrong message (alt behavio) or level was inappropriate for that individual( dog doesn't link the punishment with the bad behavior but only remembers the punishment causing fear etc). Really liked your wipe board comparison of P vs -R. Great way to think about it.

[@niklaswerthner1349]

He‘s talking about the pain of the needle

[@AnimaTriste]

He is not antiwaxer. But both castrations (an unneeded process, which serves only a veterinary wallet) and vaccination bring pain to the dog for the sake of "maybe." Using aversives is using them in context, so it's not "maybe" anymore. He points to double standards and hypocrisy.

[@toni19292]

He isn’t. You missed the point. He was saying they are okay with making the dog uncomfortable, fearful, or in pain in their preferred situations only (surgeries and vaccines) but scream animal abuse at a correction.

[@luisdariodavilamartinez5538]

man I can resonate with everything you say, but being against vaccination is brain roth to me.. its studied science, check the papers and look at the stats.

[@ZooBeHi5]

România 6.12.2024 R.I.P democracy

[@katpild3825]

Im not in favour of castration, nor forced vaccinations, but i also only use positive reinforcement. There can be overlap.

[@Iamam313]

I didn't understand much...if you don't give examples on what each thing means the whole video is kinda pointless for beginners

[@vivienleigh4640]

Blue is not your color

[@stevenpringle7813]

Blue hair ..... where's your mask.

[@andreww8055]

cool you explain the difference but don't show the theory in practice xD all you want to do is sell your course

[@positivehotdogs]

you must be stupid lol

[@ItsLukeDude]

Dont you need negative reinforcement to get to punishment and cant get there without it, and the main difference is that punishment stops completely. They are the same thing other than one stops the dog temporarily and one stops it completely. So basically keep negatively reinforcing until the dog learns and then the dog will permanently stop. The way its explained isn't great as its luck on how the dog reacts.

[@BIGBEN9999999]

Nope. Reinforcement is to get More of the same result. Always. Positive or negative. Punishment is to get Less of the same result. Always. Positive or negative.

[@shieldk9]

Nope

[@ItsLukeDude]

@@BIGBEN9999999 That doesn't make sense, you would never punish a positive behaviour from a dog. The way he described it was a tug on the lead to stop the behaviour and if it stops it then its punishment and if it doesnt then its negative reinforcement. This doesnt make sense as the correct way is to tug on the lead as he teaches in his paid courses. Its contradcting and confusing.

[@ItsLukeDude]

@@shieldk9 Why not? Its what you said in the video.

[@BIGBEN9999999]

@@shieldk9 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Please, start learning your fundamentals before lecturing people

[@gabrielcox7348]

Never heard so much drivel in my life. 🤦 Punishment doesn't work.

[@positivehotdogs]

very low IQ lol

[@trendingtigers]

alternative of spay and neuter for population control? The over flooding of shelters and the abuse and cruelty that happens to an overpopulated canine population

[@shieldk9]

Alternative? Control your dog and train him 😂.

[@kulan9379]

Stop lie about what serten type of training can do and educate about good training system that is quick. They are there (shelter) beacuse of their behavior due to lack of knowledge of their owners. Its not beacuse of the dogs its beacuse the owners. (99% of the cases)

[@1packatak]

@@kulan9379 absolutely!!

[@1packatak]

You can do a vasectomy on a dog and a tubal ligation on a female. It preserves the important hormones, but prevents pregnancy. It’s really not hard to own an intact dog and not have it get pregnant. I know many people who do just that.

[@trendingtigers]

@@shieldk9 My dog is controlled and trained. Im talking about the general population that arent always monitored. I know you agree with breeding dogs and buying from breeders, so Im not really interested in your opinion regarding this