Will Brighter Shores Have PVP? (New MMORPG By RuneScape Creator Andrew Gower)

This video showcases new discussion on Andrew Gowers upcoming MMORPG Brighter Shores, Should Brighter Shores Have PVP? Andrew Gower is the creator of Runescape / Old School Runescape and Runescape Classic and in this video we discuss whether PVP should be within Brighter Shores. This new MMORPG is launching in 2024.
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
4:30 Clan PVP?
6:00 Skillers Vs PVP?
About the game:
Brighter Shores is an all new adventure from award winning MMORPG designer Andrew Gower. It is an enchanting point-and-click style RPG with hundreds of hours of gameplay, set in a land of magic and mysteries, with a huge number of professions to try, and something new to find around every corner.
You will discover powerful magic sources and become one of the legendary classes of old: Cryoknight, Guardian or Hammermage. Which is fortunate, because something is corrupting the deepest reaches of the nearby Hopeforest, and only through the strength of your new-found powers will you be able to deal with it.

[@falloutguy8566]

Yes. Pvp is needed. And with the gower brothers I do believe pvp for sure will be in the game. Question is what type of system will it be

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

I agree people having the option to do PVP, but people should have the choice to opt out of it if they wish

[@falloutguy8566]

@BrighterShoresCentral yep I agree. Great minds think alike that's why I support your channel with notifications on. Got a good feeling you'll be the top brighter shores content creator.

[@andrewmazar4921]

As someone who does not like pking, I would prefer full loot pvp. However like you said, in a risk/reward way that doesn't lock progression behind those areas. That is to say, you get some benefit for doing things in those risky areas, but you could do those things in safety elsewhere, though with slower gains.

[@Khaltazar]

PvP should be a server type for sure. Forcing players to PvP is bad. For full/partial/no loot PvP, that could also be a server type.

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

Interesting idea

[@jensv874]

Im a fan of this. And then the anoying pvp guys can ruin there own server.

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

@@jensv874 good point haha

[@JAB227]

yes to pvp or i wont play

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

Yes, a good portion of players have said that they want PVP

[@projectbonsai8538]

Pvp in some forms would be beneficial for those who want it, why not, also, party dungeons would be amazing aswell, i hope we get to fight dragons in Brighter Shores >:)

[@alexgarland2747]

Not a deal breaker for me, but if it does I'd prefere full loot pvp in certain zones or rooms.

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

Certain zones make sense, so that people can opt in or out of pvp if they want

[@alexgarland2747]

@@BrighterShoresCentral Agree, a simple warning message would be enough, hand holding players to much is abit annoying i liked the old wilderness in around 2006 in runescape, showing my age now lol

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

@@alexgarland2747 Yeah I agree haha remember those days

[@ryans.8814]

I think players should want to go into the pvp zones like OSRS. They shouldn't have to risk their items (except the ones they obtain or bring to train with) but it's part of the charm. It should have risk and reward for skilling or training in the zone. Obviously there will be griefers, but what good MMO doesn't have that

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

Yes i agree,t hat way its also optional and you don't have to do it if you don't vibe with pvp

[@marisasob]

Imo every MMO needs a PvP part, but people that don't want to opt into this, shouldn't have to enter these zones or area's

[@12345eatacake]

Never been bothered by pvp in RS. So i would say no, mainly because in my opinion pvp encourage the more shaddy side of OSRS. I know some will not agree.

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

Yeah can understand sometimes pvp can get toxic, but i think risk vs reward systems could add some depth to the game

[@chief3796]

I dont think we know enough about brighter shores to say what should or shouldnt be in the game

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

a lot of information announced so far

[@ARealPain]

I like how everytime you say "pvp" or "pk" you then follow up with what it's short for. Like we're confused as to what you're saying.

[@user-yr9zs6sr9d]

just do what WoW does, have pvp realms, and pve realms

[@Onixoba]

Pvp should always be in an mmorpg, and it should always be full loot. (Areas of risk) and do not throw pvm stuff that also has massive rewards into the pvp areas. Therefore separate it within the game so those who want to can. Those who don't want to don't have to. That simple. Very easy, people who want to can, those who do not want to, do not have to? Why cut the throat of either one?

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

Yes, that makes sense

[@JellyfishButItHasAGun]

prolly not on release but a bit after 🤷

[@Joel-um8rk]

Never really been a fan of puting reasources in just to lure pvm/pve player in to pvp areas and i have played alot of both in diffrent mmos as pve player i feel its just an obsticle thats unnecessary and as a pvp player i feel thats a game mode thats abit harder to develop good content for and to opt for that route feels a bit cheap for example if i put in the hours to pvp its a lot diffrent then putting them in pve in pve u reaction is more about timming in an predicteable manor but in pvp u are reacting to another player knowing their class skills/combos/movement so when i played games where there has been a sort of freeforall sandbox pvp ive allways been disaponted as pvp player trying to look for chalange not saying there is no other pvpers but alot of peapole that has no buissnes being there so what i did in the end was like hiting a player with a combo and see how he react if he reacted like he/she did not know what they where doing i just moved on as i was looking for a fight that would chalange me atleast a litle bit couse at the end of the day both as pvp and as pve player want to evolve and they do so very diffrently

[@Joel-um8rk]

You actualy worded it good felling like a cat chasing a mouse maybe it fun for the first 100hours but when u invenst multiple 1000s of hours into learning a combat system in a game u dont want to do that u wanna see if u can beat the other cats maybe even two at a time😂

[@MeatTheGamer]

Think people needs to remember that this isnt Runescape. First focus on creating a well balanced game with lots of content. If they introduce pvp from the start. They need to balance gear and skills around it. So it will take away from the majority of players that dont care for pvp. Pvp should always be something that is something player can opt into. Not something thats forced on the player, unless the game is buildt around it(like Rust)

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

Great point, i agree it should be optional. Also gear balance needs to be considered thats another good point i should have brought up in the video.

[@MeatTheGamer]

@@BrighterShoresCentral easier to think about these things, when you arnt infront of a camera^^. Keep up the good work.

[@r0m988]

Don't really care for it, never did besides a few WoW battlegrounds way back in Vanilla. Not a deal breaker though. I manage around it in Osrs.

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

Yeah, so long as its optional think it'll be okay

[@Mariuspersem]

game is better without pvp

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

Why do you think this?

[@Mariuspersem]

@@BrighterShoresCentral The PVP community is much smaller than PvE community, its probably not worth the trouble balancing the game around a smaller group of players

[@ilbgentyl]

Imo the game looks really bad all around. Its a remake of runescape when runescape already does the job well.

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

What don't you like about it?

[@ilbgentyl]

@@BrighterShoresCentral Doesnt feel original mainly. It feels like its the same game/very similar just in a new engine. Hopefully some people like it and ill give it a try but it doesn't jump out at me.

[@clancymitchell9949]

This game looks overwhelmingly boring :(

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

why?

[@OutlawStradegyGaming]

i hate pvp.

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

Yeah, not for everyone I'll be mostly skilling

[@SubToJinx]

I am all for PvP as long as it isn't mandatory.

[@BrighterShoresCentral]

definitely, that's main point made here