Will Elon Musk’s Tesla disrupt Indian EV market? | CA Rachana Ranade

[@CARachanaRanade]

✔️ Invest in Knowledge: link.rachanaranade.com/CourseStore ✔️Kickstart your Investment Journey: link.rachanaranade.com/Zerodha

[@eotoz]

plz reply🙏🙏 I join a whatsup group from this acc

[@kishanbhise4733]

Tata Motors is a threat for Tesla in India😂

[@tabzzahmed2801]

💯💯💯

[@anandswarupnigam361]

👌🏻

[@AlexRichardmicheals]

Coming to stock and option I will always be grateful and thankful to Mr Ronal’ for giving me the knowledge and helping me recover my loss from the market 💯

[@AlexRichardmicheals]

he’s mostly on Telegrams, using the user.

[@AlexRichardmicheals]

@R o n a l f x 2.

[@charleymogus5080]

Thank you Ronal’ for your TA 💯. I'm excited how my trading is going so far. I'm on $1m challenge right now. Already earning $35k weekly

[@leenamili3901]

His technical analysis is excellent and his interpretation/projections of the market are so accurate’ The point is Ronal’ is the perfect trader to follow for advice and guidance

[@prashantkanha2103]

Ronal’ strategy has normalized winning trades for me and it's a huge milestone for me looking back to how it all started.

[@ladeharshavardhan8579]

tata is a king no one can beat them

[@Mayapu]

Made in India by Indian will never stop. We all Indians must and should use TATA/ Mahindra made in Articles.. if we love India.. and expect Indian Prosperity.

[@Santallo-t9s]

the problem is undia does not need tesla. tata is better than tesla

[@Mayapu]

@@Santallo-t9s That buyer decides as some have Lamborghini Aventador, RR cars in their garages!! As a whole when we see progressive countries, like I look at Japan .. I see 99% cars made by Japan are on their road..They import most of the raw materials and makes valuable high quality products and insists their people to use. Many electronic items are made in Japan though we think they feel proud to use but they have policies in place to resource.We are democratic agree but should feel nation first to live in better place.. I can’t say I love India living in other country!! It’s as simple as that.

[@areen3.093]

🤣🤣 Tesla is way better than average electric cars in india in every aspect..... grow up kids ....why you buy bmw mercedes when you can buy tata ...😂😂

[@Ishanth788]

I believe Tesla will be targeting the high end market, sales of JLR might get impacted due to this and not the mid segment or lower end. Correct me if I am wrong.

[@tabzzahmed2801]

i think the same

[@aviralkedia]

Best part at 11:11 timestamp , “chinese manufacturer haina mujhe bhi nai pata number” so sweetly said😊

[@sudhirn344]

Is this really called as 'research' ? You cannot provide numbers on World Number 2 EV company BYD ? Check out AutoCarPro India professional for numbers ? Though TATA Vs Tesla overall analysis is correct. Also giving numbers on fictional model 2 ( which no one has ever seen) ? check out VAHAN data.

[@IOSALive]

CA Rachana Phadke Ranade, Your videos always make me happy, so I subscribed!

[@udayk19]

Does this import duty 15% is not applicable for BYD , Volvo, BmW ? Then how come competition exists for Tesla

[@manickamrm7251]

Thanks for explaining business deal in layman terms, Its easy to understand and add a value alot

[@aadeshjain8878]

Like For TATA ❤

[@kanakswondercrafts.2261]

Thanks a ton for explaining the government policy in detail. I have a doubt : As you said in the above Tesla can be a competition for premium car or luxury cars so in that case won't it affect a little on Tata's JLR business as it contributes a major part in Tata motors revenue?

[@anviagarwal3230]

Mam from where do u source all these data ?

[@Smoky930]

Tata is the Best ❤

[@arunkul6889]

very good analysis to judge threat vs potential for indian cars

[@ronyboylive6934]

Love how all the reasons r explained along with facts 👍

[@CARachanaRanade]

Thank you!

[@dharmarao4634]

very well explained madam. your expression and body language is very interesting. you hv selected a very interesting topic. keep it up. all the best

[@suchirao8543]

so much knowledge from you thank you Rachna Mam keep rocking girls

[@Reddylion]

Tata ev , tesla ev both good, both important now.

[@pavanmanda7195]

Any discount on yearly membership?

[@Sacchh]

Thumbnail was a click bait.. Both are operating in different price segments and hence no impact

[@mandarsamel6223]

Market for Tesla cars is shrinking in the US and other developed countries. Mcap of Tesla has come down from 120000 $ to 55000$ in one year. Sold 10% less cars this quarter. So coming to India to expand his market in India.

[@KarpagamNarayanan-sq2tk]

Mam, If BMW is going to get affected JLR is also get affected right ? Was that missed in the video or please correct me if I'm wrong here.

[@abhakalsi1409]

Rachana, but what about the cars Tesla plans to manufacture in India? They may target the range between 15-45lakhs... What are your views?

[@adaikkappanct]

Tata owns jlr and landrover, this revenue is approx 30%

[@sbgagan6808]

Yea exactly they are planning to make ev version of them

[@rajugopale4651]

As usual detail analysis...🙏🙏

[@CARachanaRanade]

Thank you!

[@subrahmanyampenjarla3596]

Nice video Rachana ji, but you missed jaguar and Land rover India numbers.. that part would impact Tata Motors right?

[@Karthikeyan-um6gt]

Your video is good as always. I agreed to the stats that you have mentioned in the video. However, I have a question in my mind that, Tata has JLR and JLR shares the major chunk in Tata moto's profit.

[@PhantomGaming-wk3sz]

ma'am can jsr ev can also be imported at 15% tax?

[@meenasobti1394]

Mam what you said it's 100% correct no one can beat Tata

[@orangecounty998]

Tesla have plans to come up with evs priced as low as 16 lakhs for Indian roads, I mean at the Indian manufacturing unit, obviously that will take at least 3 yrs to 4 yrs

[@mazamaharashtra7777]

Tesla is not only in evs they will be more into manufacturing batteries..so guys no need to worry .tata motors will be 1500 soon

[@Dr.NancyMBBS]

THANKS

[@NAG_UMA]

I feel nothing will happen tata madam India's trust is ratan tata sir

[@lakshnaramesh9733]

Even during 2018-2020, Mr. Ratan Tata was on charge for Tata Motors, but the stock fell over 70% to reach the low of around 60 rupees during covid crash, of course the stock very well recovered from there, but it is not coz of Mr.Ratan Tata alone, but also Tata Motor's EV play in India, but if there is any threat or any minor competitor, that could very well affect Tata Motors significantly, in this case it's not minor competitor, it's Tesla, worlds most valued automobile company, btw... It's experience in EV segment is crazy, people from Norway, Ireland, Australia, USA, Singapore are having soo much craze on Tesla cars like, Model Z, Model Y, Tesla Roadster etc... So, it's not gonna be a easy play for Tata Motors, not only for it but for the entire Indian Automobile industry which is into or abt to enter EV in India or international market

[@aanchalgupta922]

Once you’ve seen tesla cars you wont go to Tata

[@sambenk649]

​@@aanchalgupta922 its ok, once ive seen how much both of them charge just because these cars have a battery inside ill prob end up in a MS or hyundai showroom.

[@gskmurari1291]

Thanks ❤

[@Ayushkumar-hj3wz]

Actual video starts @ 7:55

[@kartikjadhav5044]

Not able to join KZbin Pro Investor Membership... Please help

[@aniketgupta4407]

Great explanation

[@CARachanaRanade]

Glad it was helpful!

[@Hows.the-josh_1]

Tata is a big king , no one can beat ...

[@sameerkumar3211]

Jaguar and landrover ka bhi tata ne factory dala under this scheme and investment of 1 billion dollars.. In my view if tesla comes to India it can Compete with JLR segment as both Belongs to premium segment cars.

[@BranislavB-hx9zy]

Tesla is recalling 3,878 Cybertrucks to fix an issue with the accelerator pedal 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@the_somebody_nobody]

Expensive Dustbin it is. IDK why but I feel like Indian Tesla's budget version will be worse than Tata Nano.

[@jonnavivek5368]

Hello I am holding small amount of stocks of GMR Infra purchased at 83rs can you please brief me about this stock and also about Vodafone idea and reliance power

[@saikumarshridhar156]

Tata = Trust they are pride of our nation over the decades...with tata brand the emotion is connected no one can gain it

[@vivanmunoyat7573]

Mam i hv shares of Bharti Hexacom. Cn u plz suggest for hold or sell?

[@suman2928]

Ma'am any news about wellness farmacy?

[@akshayrjain1599]

Will this not impact jaguar & land rover sales which forms up around 60% of tata motors revenue?

[@nitinwalgaonkar7299]

Tata motors is for all general Indian people and Tesla is for special purpose.....it is also important

[@Sarojani43268]

I as a person whose parents work in tata motors it is clear that tata motors is struggling...😓

[@ItsMeJoyBoy]

what is inheritance tax that Sam Pitroda ( congress manifestio advisor) talking about please explain madam ?

[@thakurtimmy8624]

Ratan tata matlab real bharat Ratan tata 😊👏✌👍

[@tyroneanderson5619]

Tesla will be beaten by Indian cars in India because of price undercutting by competitors, but indian cars will never beat Tesla outside of India. Perhaps people here should have a bit more of an international mindset.

[@ganeshrangala228]

Game started....!

[@PranjalDLuffy]

india is country which runs with emotions, Ntg can disrupt Tata ❤

[@aaratisavle]

Hi Rachana want to know ki tuze kahi what's aap groups pan aahet ka Karan tuzya naavane Ani tuza photo laun khup Vela mala ichha zali ki group join karava. Pan tyat kahi prashn vicharle jatat. Tevhach mala dought aala. Ani mag shevti Sagal kelay var mala group cha naav vichitra vatla. Thoda hya msg la reply kar please..

[@Passionate2411]

If Tesla is going to sell 8000 cars from existing share of 42000 cars, where is new market/business created? Tesla will give jobs but some other manufacturer will cut jobs due to reduction in his volume 🤔

[@unveilanything4036]

Elon ji was so lovely sentence in this video

[@sangramsangle7175]

Tesla would be a fancy toy for rich only. Their sales would only rise in beginning due to hype. But later on will decline due to challanges place by Indian company.

[@Kahhajjwjwjjwjw]

Tata ka Age koi bol sakta hai kya?

[@CPTasiwal]

Tata motors ke share kis kiske pas h

[@umangmota9214]

Different Target customers. Wont have any effect.

[@lakshnaramesh9733]

Any company can enter into any segment, just like Bajaj Auto which entered into heavyweight motorcycle along with Harley Davidson Btw, Tata Motors makes over 35% of its annual revenue from JLR (Jaguar, Land Rover ) segment, which has been completely ignored in this video, don't know why! JLR has higher OPM than any other cars that Tata Motors manufacturers in both domestic and international market, which is priced somewhere between 60 lakhs to even 5 crores or more, clearly direct competition will be Tesla, their cars are much much better & luxurious & good looking than Tata Motor's JLR as of Mid of 2024. Of course in future after 5-10 years JLR might be much better be it in term of looks, distance the car can travel after a single charge. Let's wait and see, the whether our Tata Motors from India can disrupt this EV space or not

[@umeshtilak]

Elon Musk has postponed his trip to India as per his latest Tweet so we have more time to think and guess what could be the outcome of his future visit. He said he will be planning a visit later this Year. Lets see.

[@bharathkallakuri927]

Tesla can’t sell at Tatas price😊

[@Kiran.Bhoir01]

JLR sold 4000 units in india

[@philipdsilva8517]

Tata motors is one of best & vibrant companies in India . Tesla cannot beat Tata motors . Despite stiff completion from Maruthi & other automobile companies, tat motors is still leading company. No other automobile can overtake Tata motors.

[@Freshbreweed]

Mam mi literally hech tumhala sangayla ikde comments section madhe ala hota😊 ki youtube war ads yet aahe tumcha pic use karun tips saathi

[@Mr.FcMobile1]

But HNIs dont use Indian cars they use Audi ,BMW, ,BENZ,ROLLS-ROYCE 😂😂😂😂

[@koushikvss7638]

Tesla doesn't even have a car named Model 2😂😂😂 Model 3 ex-showroom price will be around 30L eventually, when they import it will be around 42L

[@SenthilSenthil-yz6rr]

Madam....comment on jsw ..mg ...tie up

[@Passionate2411]

History has shown Indian don’t prefer American brand cars, all failed in India, Tesla is next…

[@AmanVhora-s1k]

No because India's per head income is very low and tesla never afford to sell there care in such very low price and this work is does only indian company ❤

[@hemantpatki6062]

TaMo is looking to bring JLR EVs in 15% duty scheme. You missed this point, Rachana!

[@kb8011]

Tesla will not survive long in indian market due to its costly cars

[@anjalikulkarni5613]

Madam please make vdobon FPO OF VI

[@nag975]

cheapest tesla car in US is $40,240 = Rs.33,55,378 .... Elon cannot compete on price.

[@Heman11-2]

No never. Tata is a step ahead. They are importing JLR cars and gonna make JLR ev in india. So no worries. Even tata evs sale slow Jlr evs will be hit.

[@kanhaiyagirgosavi4785]

RATAN Tata is not a company is an emotion of all 🇮🇳Indian

[@TechnoLogy-tb9ot]

Tata is made in India have competitive advantage over Tesla

[@manju6662]

Hi please update on yes bank it go up are down in in future madam

[@Machines99140]

TATA 🤝 Tesla - partnership

[@FunFact4321]

Pm Modi welcome Elon Musk for advertising election 2024 not for investment 😂

[@james_bond42]

Now affordable EV by Tesla??

[@shashankc.r7947]

MG Hector

[@brunoheggli2888]

Game over for Tesla!

[@shalinisaxena5619]

Ma'am aapki stock market education wali class mujhe join krna hai

[@breydasofiamaciasgonzalez3120]

Apparently the guy doesn’t know about the Eledator platform, where you can passively earn money on cryptocurrency

[@sanatandharmabhaktisag6546]

🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@rishab0329]

Make in India happening ... Where is German shepherd?? I think he's crying about it

[@shubham.kapote]

Tesla model 3 might cost around 1 crore

[@lakshnaramesh9733]

Even JLR cost 60L min to over 5.50 crores (high end 2024 model)

[@sunitamehta7628]

Unfortunately Elon musk is not coming to India, but video is very informative.

[@Radhykumar]

Tesla not going to sell EV Cars for cheap price. Only Elite can afford Tesla in India.

[@balajisharathkumar9753]

please kindly file an fiir on those fraudesteres

[@mehuljansari1919]

Only HNIs will purchase TESLA just to show off to their neighbours 😂😂

[@TusharTambe-bv1xd]

Tata is trust of India...Tesla will take 50+ yrs to build trust

[@TRADEWIN6]

Hindie kuchh hai madam

[@deeprajmewada351]

Hindi me bhi video banye 🎉

[@Irshadhind]

Very sorry to say this madam, but ur analysis is way wrong in regards to tesla. Tesla may not be a threat to Indian manufacturers at the present time, but as competition grows our indian members will defenitly be affected by outsiders. Maruti, tata, mahindra all will be affected. Once upon a time British looted our precious country for a long duration, the same is happening now in a digitalised form. Government should have stringent policies in regards to this or else we may likely suffer another few centuries.

[@mrunaldeshpande8972]

What do you think about inheritance tax and wealth redistribution? I am genuinely afraid of this congress narative. Need your opinion analytically.

[@spvsujesh]

Tatas profit comes from JLR , if tesla comes Tata will be in loss . All these Tiago, Nixon etc... are making marginal profits only. Also they ruin the name of TATA brand. Tesla 8s going to eat Tata for sometime from start. Read the percentage share of Tatas profit from vehicle business and create the video.

[@rookietheone]

As a young entrepreneur I love watching your videos and I admire you but I can't agree with your views on "Modi Ji" took this step to increase employment in India, That was complete BS. The only purpose of this scheme is to get that 500 Millions for their party. Modi Ji says a lot of things yet qualifed individuals are jobless.

[@omnamahshivay241]

Mam hindi mai banao jayda logo ke pas pauche ga

[@lakshnaramesh9733]

What abt those audience who don't understand Hindi? And ig there is one seperate channel specifically available on KZbin by CARR in Hindi language, and u r in the wrong place

[@omnamahshivay241]

@@lakshnaramesh9733 ok👍🏼