Wolff Responds: Biden's Student Debt Relief

WANT MORE PROF. WOLFF CONTENT? Check out / @democracyatwrk
In this Wolff Responds, Prof. Wolff critiques Biden's Student Loan Forgiveness Plan. He argues that the program is inadequate and doesn't solve anything. Higher education continues to be unaffordable for so many, and points out that the system is grossly unfair for students who have no choice but to borrow. Lastly, Wolff explores some of the social consequences that the debt relief plan are likely to yield.
Want to hear more about this topic? Let us know by answering our poll in the COMMUNITY TAB: • Post
Wolff Responds is a ‪@democracyatwrk‬ Production. We provide these videos free of ads. Please consider supporting our work. Visit our website democracyatwork.info/donate or join our growing Patreon community and support Global Capitalism Live Economic Update with Richard D. Wolff at / gcleu .
___________________________________________________________________________
Check out the NEW 2021 Hardcover edition of “Understanding Marxism,” with a new, lengthy introduction by Richard Wolff! Go to: www.lulu.com/en/us/shop/richa...
“Marxism always was the critical shadow of capitalism. Their interactions changed them both. Now Marxism is once again stepping into the light as capitalism shakes from its own excesses and confronts decline.”
Check out all of d@w’s books: "The Sickness is the System," "Understanding Socialism," by Richard D. Wolff, and “Stuck Nation” by Bob Hennelly at www.lulu.com/spotlight/democra...
___________________________________________________________________________
Follow Wolff ONLINE:
Patreon: / gcleu
Web: www.rdwolff.com
Twitter: / profwolff
Facebook: / economicupdate
/ richarddwolff
/ democracyatwrk
DailyMotion: www.dailymotion.com/democracy...
Subscribe to the EU podcast: economicupdate.libsyn.com
Shop for EU merchandise: democracy-at-work-shop.myshop...

[@richardscottcoleman7884]

This video explains many of the issues with student loan debt very well. But, please Professor Wolff continue to shine a spotlight on this major issue. We need loud voices speaking truth to power.

[@avolley711]

Those crumbs being thrown out by Biden do nothing but turn the money we’ve been priced gouged out of into a loan payment. From 2018’s Trump tariffs & the past two years of corporate greed under the guise of the pandemic, the increases on consumer goods, cars, rent and food, have easily cost the average american well over an extra 20k

[@Googlag]

I don't want to insult you. But the authorities know that they are robbing you. That's the point.Or are you so stupid and naive that you don't see what's going on around you?

[@laurasweeney2546]

Indentured servitude is criminal.

[@cageybee7221]

this almost reminds me of the Ancient World, especially the Roman Republic. Politicans would Cancel debts the poor had raked up during times of war and famine buying food and repairing their properties in order to get elected, but they would never change the systems that caused these famines and wars and put the poor into debt in the first place, because then they couldn't do it again.

[@TheMabes69]

THIS

[@laurasweeney2546]

Thanks for addressing this issue (student loans). This issue also impacts older adults.

[@matthewingerson]

My mom started college at 35yo and did nights and weekends for over 20 years to get her associate's, bachelor's, and master's degrees. She just retired at 70 years old with over $100K in student loan debt. But I've also witnessed what a moron she is with her finances, and I watched her rack up 6-figures in credit card debt over the last forty years. So I have little sympathy for her in that regard. I've also witnessed how 40+ years of doctor-enabled opioid addiction have ruined my mom in other ways. That is why she went to college in the first place -- so she could get a job with health insurance to fund her doctor-enabled opioid-addiction. Not to mention, her neglecting-absence on nights and weekends allowed the opportunities for me to be abused by other people. Anyway... I, and other people in her life, have tried to get her to stop taking opioids. We know she doesn't actually need them, because we know that her medical condition, for which she was originally prescribed opioids over 40 years ago, has modern-developed treatments. But, since the opioids are prescribed by a doctor (who gets financial kickbacks from the drug companies to keep people addicted), my mom doesn't think there's a problem. I, and other people in her life, have explained to her how miserable she is and how miserable she is to others. We've told her how people have cut her out of their lives because of her addiction and misery. But she doesn't care. And she isn't too ignorant to see the correlations between herself and a regular drug addict, but her addiction has turned her into a liar and a manipulator like a regular drug addict and she pretends not to understand. So I have very little sympathy for her in that regard, too. Unfortunately, my stupid mom, and millions like her, have voted for the right-wing hellscape in which we live. And even though I lack sympathy for well-paid, over-consuming, yet wasteful individuals like my mom, that doesn't mean that I don't have a disdain for the corrupt, wealthy-class right-wingers who have enabled and benefited from the collective suffering of working-class people who are better than my ignorant mom. Sorry for hijacking your comment with mostly-unrelated, and definitely unsolicited, material.

[@WilliamReynolds887]

WHEN IT COMES TO INVESTMENT, DIVERSIFICATION IS key. That is why I have my INTERESTS SET ON KEY SECTORS BASED ON PERFORMANCE AND PROJECTED GROWTH. THEY RANGE FROM THE EV SECTOR, RENEWABLE ENERGY, TECH, AND HEALTH.

[@mrs.LisaMarieMurphy8727]

Oh me too!!! I engage in various prolific Investments by compound interest & leveraging and as well operating with an Investment Professional Mrs. Pamela Kay Weaver So far I've attained returns of over $85K.

[@jade-lefebvre5910]

Trading with an expert is the best strategy for both beginners and investors who have little time or no time to monitor their trade

[@SaadiaDiVladimir]

she is legit and still trades with her since I am going to retire in my early 40s. having an expert broker. Mrs. Pamela managing my investments is heartwarming, Because I don't have to worry about a thing, I just sit down and earn profits every weekend

[@SaadiaDiVladimir]

Long-term investment with Mrs. . Pamela is the best, I invested $5,700 in April 2022, topping up my trades every week with $1450. Rn, I have over $88,200 on my dashboard. The long-term investment is the best...

[@VerneCopeland]

I met Expert Pamela last year for the first time at a conference in new york city, I invested $24,000 and traded in one month making close to $94,450, am happy that I took the step to success by trading with Pamela. You know Ignorance can be the worst thing and mistake that most people always do.

[@AndrewBryantPianoTuner]

Yes do a lot more of this highlighting the issues of living or being forced to live in a greed oriented society

[@ilyabm]

Please do more videos on this topic

[@dannyboy8850]

Affordable education is one of the many deficiencies in the US. Affordable healthcare, social program for the homeless as well as infrastructures that are in desperate need for repair should all be dealt with. A 10% reduction in our mility budget would generate $77B that would benefit for 50% of our population. 😭😭😭

[@plastictouch6796]

Infrastructure needs more than repair it needs to be expanded. 2 million people without working running water for example. Public transportation is non existent even though it could massively boost the economy to have it and to produce it.

[@dannyboy8850]

@@plastictouch6796 The basic physical and organizational structures and facilities (e.g. buildings, roads, power supplies) needed for the operation of our society. The lack of public transportation is another example that you mentioned is another example.

[@fuzzytop4746]

That would also take away a lot in jobs but also just reducing college to majors that actually have a positive ROI would almost completely remove debt

[@grizzlycharizard0017]

Or we just get arid of Capitalism as a whole.

[@adamvasques4816]

Okay I admit I have only listened to a small portion of this podcast by Mr Wolf all I heard is he speaks of education and a Band-Aids on open wounds .If you have a complete stupid ignorant populous that is going to without a doubt expand and have children continually more stupid and more dependant on our precious government . Who has convinced you that they're on your side and I'm your enemy I'm your neighbor I'm not a millionaire who never worked for nothing in my entire f****** life I'm not a Hollywood f****** actor piece of s*** whoever tells you that I'm your enemy you're my friend and whoever told you that they are the enemy of the both of us . Please people look in-between the lines sometimes.

[@johncalla2151]

Bring back the anti-usury laws.

[@missme3916]

You are AWESOME!!!! Love you Dr. Wolff!!!

[@dbarker7794]

And now the states are going to TAX the loan forgiveness as if it's income. We Americans via our elected officials are doing everything we can to keep everyday people from catching a break. Sick, sad society.

[@janebinkerd594]

Student debt needs to be forgiven now.

[@maxgatica5736]

The problem is neither Dems nor Repukeblicans will not DO IT

[@cev12]

Exactly. Ultimately, rich Americans are seeking a plutocracy in an undeveloped country (backwards, declining) for the US. Because an educated workforce is necessary for a developed country. So if they seek to withhold education from the non-rich, then they are also moving us towards being an undeveloped country. You can't have it both ways. But of course, the goal of the rich and powerful is an uneducated workforce that they can better control and deceive. And I think, as usual, they can't see the forest for the trees--the consequences of their short-sighted decisions.

[@ashleypello7532]

I think they're trying to destroy democracy. Rewrite the constitution and disarm us completely regardless of the state of Ed.

[@frankied1107]

Thank you for addressing this issue. I always look forward to your appearances on the Thom Hartmann radio show. And I vote "yes" on covering the issue of student debt and our problematic education system in greater detail. Take care.

[@blogintonblakley2708]

Why shouldn't businesses have to pay for the education of their employees?

[@blogintonblakley2708]

@@jvanleeuwenCdn Business should pay for preschool through college. But they don't. This is one of the external costs carried by the public that allow business to appear profitable when they are not. Business is a way for a few people to establish control of the resources everyone else needs to survive. It is my assertion that this is why market and economies are set up in the first place. To allow the greediest, most self interested and ruthless people in the world to control everyone else. I mean what else would you expect to happen?

[@eleidal]

Yes please, more aspects. Compounding interest would, I hope, be part of that? I think that needs to be explained, even if it seems obvious. Thank you.

[@loiswilcken1758]

I second that. I've been looking for an answer to that.

[@carolweiler9899]

More, please! We love and appreciate you and your work!

[@nicholaspeyton5460]

Spent the last 48hrs binge watching all your videos. Absolutely fascinating. I'm amazed how I my brain is re-wiring to understand things I'd previously never considered. Wish I could afford to give more.

[@RichardDWolff]

Thank you for your generosity!

[@ADHDnNOLA]

PLEASE do the hypocrisy of our student debt system video

[@bunnyisarider13]

Thanks professor! I'm interested in hearing more of your thoughts about this topic. I'm one of those poor students getting into debt for an education. I'm glad for any relief, but it's so tiny.

[@dewaldt8104]

Well what are you studying.

[@authenticallysuperficial9874]

You're right about a lot of the problems. Biden's student debt relief was a terrible solution though.

[@johnconnors4508]

Yes, Professor Wolff, I would like to hear more on the topic of student debt relief. Thank you!

[@YourDailyPoliticalFix]

love Richard Wolff!

[@prismatic.princess]

Please make another video on this!

[@eleanorpolchinski7919]

Yes I could and will be grateful for more videos about students debts

[@PoliticalEconomy101]

Wolff do a video on the Queen and the Monarchy

[@petekramer8381]

You don’t need to go to college to be a productive member of society. The only reason you should be in college (where the ROI makes sense) is if you want to be a lawyer, engineer, medical professional, or maybe a business professional (manager, accountant, etc.) Everyrhing else can be done at a two year college, trade school, or is just a joke. Too many kids were and are being told they have to go to college before they know what they want to do.

[@ousamaabdu794]

This is 110% facts

[@nacho-hp4um]

You can spend trillions paying off loans, but if you dont fix the problem from happening again, it s gona happen over and over as long as all these companys are pushing to have college degrees. Almost like the companies and states are working together. Go to that state school and give them 60,000 a year and we'll give you a job.

[@MAchannel2024]

And 0 guarantees you will get a job.

[@minhducnguyen9276]

@@MAchannel2024 And those who do better be grateful that they were given a job. Even if they are treated like shit. That's the rats race the US had become.

[@SpunkySpeaks100]

Yes sir thank you!!! Absolutely sharing

[@docholiday8029]

Thanks again Professor!

[@RichardDWolff]

My pleasure!

[@docholiday8029]

@@RichardDWolff ♥️🙏

[@Ted...youtubee]

I was listening to a USA radio/podcast. In it students would ring in and tell of their debt. In particular borrowing more money than for school costs to fund a lifestyle of fun. Should taxpayers pay all of the student debt!

[@mjaldrich7]

I agree Professor, please go into more detail

[@martinmomu9141]

I apluad you for putting this together! With everything going on right now, the best decision to be on any creative man's heart is having a profitable investment strategy.

[@waynes4369]

@arun_- The fluctuations of the market only affect those that hodl coins, but traders makes money on both sides, when it's bearish they go short when it's bullish they go long... The best strategy to use in trading crypto is to trade with a professional, like Fergus waylen he understand the market quite well, that way maximum profits are guaranteed.

[@leither-truth4414]

I'm honestly surprised that this name is being mentioned here, I stumbled upon one of his clients testimony last two months in CNBC world news and decided to try him out...I'm Expecting my third cashout in 2days

[@nissan38p69]

Oh I remember him, Mr Waylen, a brilliant market enthusiast with new strategies. I signed up on his platform some months back, it has been productive for me

[@Richardson238]

@a-gbasseyorn3261 Please how can I contact Mr fergus ? I really like what he has done for you, and I also want to benefit from it.

[@georgebasonathan4784]

I think he must be very good with crypto because he has been recommended by many KZbinrs to learn how to trade with him.

[@SEASCAT]

I am 70 years old. I started with $100 from the Kiwaniis Club which paid for one full term at the junior college. I paid for all the rest of my college education one class at a time and took forever to get through. but it was possible. For young people today, it's not possible to do it that way! Nothing worked out for me- my ADD was worse than my middle school special ed kids so I gave up teaching. After 5 years making minimum wage getting supervision in the mental health field- I found out that I was not getting credit as I was an MEd and all supervisors were MSW. (Lost my house and had to move out of the area) By then memories from my childhood came back to haunt me and I couldn't work anymore because of C-PTSD, DID, and ADD. By the time I felt I had enough recovery to go back to work, no one would hire me- gaps in employment and age-. How would I be paying for it if I had student loan debt?!?! Now???? the problem today is finding a doctor. There aren't any- just nurse practitioners who couldn't afford medical school. I know five people who had major heart problems from the NPs at one location. I recognized how they had messed up my prescriptions. The pharmacist wasn't going to fill the prescriptions until I convinced him that's not how I planned to take them. He agreed that I knew what I was doing and let me have them filled. People are dying because we can't get real medical doctors. So wrong. Can you imagine how an NP would feel learning about patients who have died because of the NPs lack of knowledge?

[@wisconsieee]

Thank you for yet another excellent video💙

[@PhD-JWT]

Yes, more please.

[@josephroling]

This "forgiveness" does nothing for me. I borrowed $80k (through to master's degree), have been paying monthly since the mid-90s, and now my balance is $116,000. So what if $10,000 comes off? It's all interest anyway. Plus, I have to pay taxes in my state on the "forgiveness" (which also doesn't make sense because it won't be "income" until the year of loan satisfaction. My month-to-month cash flow will not change by a penny. Ultimately, it's the loan guarantor who benefits and of course the state I live in. The borrower never sees this money. Only those close to paying their loans off will feel any benefit.

[@dorianphilotheates3769]

“...more fun to be part of” - that’s my favourite bit.

[@ItsRight2JoinTheRebellion]

Thanks for the education. I would like to learn the other aspects from you.

[@michaelc1063]

TRUTH HURTS!!

[@sage9453]

I think getting into the business of college, (provost salaries, lazy rivers on campus, etc.) the predatory lending aspect, and how much the government earns from defaulted loans would be an interesting topic.

[@JRBell]

All this shows is one thing that I have said a week ago: America Is Debt.

[@ThriftyPostcards]

I'd love to hear you talk more about, as you put it, "selective application of neediness". someone I know makes a similar argument when arguing that students shouldn't get free breakfast/lunch in public schools. I dont know how to articulate why selective application of neediness is bad

[@JSwift-jq3wn]

90% is compound interest. It is impossible to pay the compound interest. It is not working, education, medicare, hiusing, food, clothing all for profit.

[@johannsebastianbach3411]

I think I might have seen Prof. Wolff about two months ago in stuytown, I was tempted to go shake his hand, but then I was like "I don't wanna be that guy and go bother him." Was that really you sir? And as students, we really appreciate the fact that you are addressing this issue! Thanks for everything that you have taught us through your videos!

[@felixvelo]

Yes more people should go and get an education. But what we have failed to realize is it does not have to come in the form of a four-year degree.

[@cosmicmusicreynolds3266]

debt will , like corporate greed destroy capitaliism ! . capitaliism digging its own grave

[@benvanrensburg4261]

Best way, by far, to bring costs of education down, has two legs. (1) Phase out government involvement in education. The exorbitant cost of a university degree is the direct result of government subsidy. (2) Don't enrol if you can't afford it. It's called consumer boycott, and it literally forces prices down. "They have to borrow". In a free market system, nobody HAS to anything, least of all borrow. The video ignores the fact that a decision to borrow, is a decision that comes with a commitment. I get that Prof Wolff is dedicating his life to thinking of ways to have more fairness for everybody. Let me point out that forcing others to bear the brunt of your unwise commitments, can not be conceived as fair. As for Biden's make-believe 'solutions', I agree with the criticism in this video.

[@Artist1974CH]

Freemarket is for anyone who wears dirty , smelly underwear.

[@TheMabes69]

People are arguing over who should pay these outrageous costs instead of arguing that we shouldn't pay these outrageous costs in the first place. 😂

[@markhumble7608]

@Richard You can put a link so we can donate into your hard work.

[@mishy_mix]

His Patreon link is in the description

[@markhumble7608]

@@mishy_mix found it thanks

[@cdale93mike29]

Professor please cover in a future video how the banking community has been able to prosper by bringing this specific debt type into the capalist system.

[@tbagwell]

Get the government out of education and the business of loaning money to anyone

[@Name-ot3xw]

Just waving hi to the steelworker I pointed at you. Hi guy!

[@larrynavarro582]

Thank you for this video. I didnt expect much from Biden on this issue or any other matter of importance to the average American.

[@jazzmann1984]

Yes I would love for you do go more in depth. I would also like to expand on the two student scenarios that you briefly mentioned. There are at least three classifications of students; students who come from poverty and take out a majority of loans every year, those who receive scholarships of some sort, and those whose parents pay for their education. The student in poverty needs scholarships but they have to compete with other students also needed money. The result is a very few number of students actually get the scholarship they need. This is is what Dr. Dean Spade related to as Charity work, deciding which group of poor stude to help over others. Those if us who were outcompeted - other students poverty was worse than ours or grades were slightly better than ours - have to take out Pell Grants along with federal and direct unsubsidized loans. The student with the scholarship either doesn't have to pay as much - the average student taking out loans - or doesn't take loans out at all. This is f*cking nuts how we educate people. All this on top of the very real possibility of not finding work in our field for years and then being told to go back to school because we haven't had a job in the field. It's taken me almost 20 years to get two degrees due to poverty and two massive recessions. I finally earned two degrees at the same time in 2021 and have yet to be employed. All of my education was financed through Pell Grants, federal loans, and some (60k worth) of Sallie's debt trap. With Sallie taken care of (someone paid all of it off for me) I still owe $123,975 in federal loans, and no real possibility of getting into the field of Policy Afministration with a concentration in Applied Research Analytics (Data Science). What I would like to hear more from is why we tend to use the median when talking about income distributions, but we always use the average when discussing student loan debt. I've looked for the median indicator on student loan debt for months, no credible Institution is even trading the median and has no idea what the distribution of debt really is. If I could get into a Ph.D. program creating these I dictators I would but I can't. I'm broke, dorrodashing 12-14 hours a day and trying to pay off a $7,000 medical bill from being assaulted after a delivery. So please, Dr. Wolf, I think many of us would love for you to go deeper into our situation to bring a deeper understanding of what we truly face.

[@PDTRUMP]

Sir, your proof is 100 percent correct and I will show you the truth today

[@keithwielkiewicz7721]

This was the arguments of Stalin and Hitler.

[@BrianTracyOfficial.]

Thanks for viewing⬆️ and contributing 🙏, Tell Max To share some beneficial knowledge/profitable investment.♥♥..🤳above digit ⬆️

[@Sketcher93]

Let's cut to the quick Rick, when you throw crumbs to the needy... The needy are going to eat the crumbs. We are well aware it's not enough. But what do we do about it. Please answer.

[@boathemian7694]

Revolt

[@FleetaFleegalBuckFut]

Look at the French and follow their lead

[@Sketcher93]

@@FleetaFleegalBuckFut somebody needs to organize it. I can't just go outside and do it by myself. I'm not an organizer.

[@impeachbiden5003]

We should have you as president instead of Grandpa Joe. I finally get what you're saying and now I agree with some of your ideas!

[@BrianTracyOfficial.]

Thanks for viewing⬆️ and contributing 🙏, Tell Max To share some beneficial knowledge/profitable investment.♥♥..🤳above digit ⬆️

[@lonniejackson4225]

Prof Wolff never misses. Education is a basic human right bc learning is an inseparable part of living our lives. How are you supposed to know the difference between right and wrong if no one tells you? Going to college is volunteering time out of your day to learn what might contribute to the betterment of society. It's no one's fault for not knowing except the ones who don't try, and these students in debt tried. But what kind of world are we living in that doesn't recognize, but in fact overcharges you for trying? It's a self destructive and vicious cycle like everything else under capitalism. We only help the people who need it the least. And then give the responsibility for helping the poor to the people who benefitted from screwing them over in the first place.

[@stuckinthemud4352]

A right is something you have not something you are given. I have the right to bear arms the government doesn’t buy me a gun. You need to learn the difference between a right and a privilege

[@lonniejackson4225]

@@stuckinthemud4352 but you already have an education by virtue of the fact that you're learning in every interaction you have with the world. And if you're expected to live with other people you must be educated in how to be a part of that society as well. You don't earn it. It’s just a condition of living one's life. You'll learn one way or another. And a quality education is the best way to ensure that we don't learn wrongly and impose on each other's rights.

[@stuckinthemud4352]

@@lonniejackson4225 you are off your rocker if you think that makes sense. We are discussing formal education stop playing games.

[@stuckinthemud4352]

@@lonniejackson4225 my point still stands nobody pays for your gun I’ll pay for your education the day the government sends me a gun for free.

[@tiamarie1226]

Please cover all topics I could only pick one topic on the poll. My generation was sold a dream go to college and you'll have a good job. Many graduated after 2008 1st blow. Thus longer road to get to decent money (if you ever got there) at all . You cant file bankruptcy on it. If you default and try and get a home wont work even if no default if student loan is high you might not can get a loan at all ( high debt to income ratio) ...young ppl are wising up and realizing the lies the previous generation was sold and not doing school no cost benefit to them unless you're rich or scholarship and maybe thats where its headed education, buying a car, buying a home , affording meat will only be for the rich.

[@kellyray6683]

Stay safe kind sir. Keep getting loud, but please keep your head on a swivel. I always worry for the good people in our country who are just trying to help all of us.

[@yasseralsaidi1168]

Why Newsom has a grudge against me ? I still don't know how come that is but investing is on

[@loiswilcken1758]

Like another viewer below, I'd like to see compounding interest explained. I'm also interested in the comparison with universities abroad. How are their programs and students financed? I might add another unfairness. I'm a seventy-three-year-old, long past her student loans. It was easy for me to pay them off. Why should succeeding generations not have the same? Or better still, no loans at all!

[@carolweiler9899]

Would you address the issue of privatizing Medicare?

[@lonmorgan5260]

Yes,please go further in depth.

[@maxgatica5736]

In Nicaragua a title degree was around $7,000 cordobas in public University in five years. In a private University a degree over $50,000 see the difference the government help to keep it low, but not here why is that.

[@brianniegemann4788]

The very rich in America have tremendous political piwer, that's why.

[@yasseralsaidi1168]

Police must sign up on line for human Rights preservation and environmental protection wich include animals

[@rcmrcm3370]

👍✊

[@fallonstone408]

this argument he presents where he talks about the 'rich kid' who paid upfront for education and the 'not so rich kid' had to get a loan etc and "thats not fair he asserts". Well taking that approach one could also say that if all student debt loans are forgiven and the 'not so rich kid' has no more debt and he happens to be sitting on a bus next to a 'poor kid' whose family was too poor that the kid had to work just to help support his family and could not go to college . That "poor kid" could look at the "not so rich kid" and say "thats not fair" too I could go on and on and list many other unfair situations if student debt was forgiven.

[@HiddenAgendas]

govt should wipe the interests not the debt!

[@PDTRUMP]

My name is Robert and in 1990 I didn’t care my father is saying what you said verbatim. Shame on me.

[@silverrush3482]

?The prices of PG&E are increasing? Republicans in California are upset. Can you explain.

[@adams6412]

gee

[@lakshaynz]

is Community college also that expensive?

[@BrianTracyOfficial.]

ᴛʜᴀɴᴋs ғᴏʀ🔝 ᴡᴀᴛᴄʜɪɴɢ Tell Max I link you to him for a business investment that will change your financial life.. ⬆️

[@ousamaabdu794]

Community College is far cheaper than going to a four year college/university

[@EMan-cu5zo]

I would be all for paying back the loan but without the interest. It is already backed by the government so why are we paying interest? I finally paid my debt off after ten years. The interest alone could have paid a down payment for a home.

[@radekw708]

Not going to school is also a good option, we need those people too to work in trades. And those people also make a good living if they work hard and start their own businesses etc..

[@zdcyclops1lickley190]

Where would the President get the money? Discretionary spending is money formally approved by Congress and the President during the appropriations process each year. Mandatory spending, also known as direct spending, is mandated by existing laws. This type of spending includes funding for entitlement programs like Medicare and Social Security and other payments to people, businesses, and state and local governments. The president can't crap money and thus cannot spend monies that has not been allocated by Congress.

[@libyasolayman953]

What do you suggest as you only seem to have a loud expression on college being overly expensive for the lower class

[@Worldstreetphotos]

I would have went to Germany where education is free.

[@BrianTracyOfficial.]

Thanks for viewing⬆️ and contributing 🙏, Tell Max To share some beneficial knowledge/profitable investment.♥♥..🤳above digit ⬆️

[@maxgatica5736]

Higher education is OUT OF REACH

[@michaelvance1118]

The ONLY THING OUR DOLLAR IS BACKED BY IS THE CREATION OF DEBT AND TACKING INTEREST ON THAT DEBT!! HOW SICK AND WRONG IS THAT!!!?

[@ronaldturner4849]

Ricardo, Smith and Marx dismissed contractual rents vs. "rents on land". Perquois, lumah, why?

[@PDTRUMP]

I am a ironworker in the Union

[@dorianphilotheates3769]

I have a few hundred thousands in student debt - but that’s o.k., I have no intention of ever repaying it: I’m Greek...

[@BrianTracyOfficial.]

Thanks for viewing⬆️ and contributing 🙏, Tell Max To share some beneficial knowledge/profitable investment.♥♥..🤳above digit ♥

[@kseniaeugene7177]

The terms and conditions of each loan are known ahead of time. Your argument can also apply to mortgage. One person buys a house for cash and doesn't pay anything in interest, another person has to take a 30y mortgage and ends up paying X4 times more for THE SAME HOUSE. how is it different from student loans ?

[@stuckinthemud4352]

Because if you default on a home loan the bank can sell your home and recoup the loss. You can’t repo an education.

[@kseniaeugene7177]

@@stuckinthemud4352 it's nice that you are so worried for the bank.. if you default on the mortgage you lose the house and are left with nothing. Education is something you have for life, cannot be taken from you whether you paid the student loan or not.

[@stuckinthemud4352]

@@kseniaeugene7177 lol I’m telling you how things work you are way to far gone to debate morality lol

[@dorianphilotheates3769]

But making the poor pay more than the rich for an education- and everything else - is what capitalism is all about: anything different would just be un-American.

[@thespacecowboy420]

What do you think now that he has basically done nothing since?

[@yasseralsaidi1168]

لا تفا قم الأوضاع

[@yasseralsaidi1168]

Help police navigate a certain case sure no problems

[@fiddlepants5947]

So what if I don't wanna go to college? You still gonna pay me? Lol. Just a rhetorical question, btw. I actually got my master's degree in engineering years ago.

[@lakshaynz]

1:40

[@TheOuterDrive]

. Republicans need to get out of the way so we can make progress...

[@user-wl2xl5hm7k]

Can all in left-YT please start educating people about both: (1) the difference between right-authoritarian vs. right-libertarian; & (2) the difference between left-authoritarian vs left-libertarian? It’s long overdue. People aren’t cattle or sheep: They will understand if we educate them. Though we need to educate (& learn) about all the nuance.

[@blogintonblakley2708]

Go ahead. I'm willing to listen.

[@Sketcher93]

These aren't the divisions I would have made. Most of us on the left are not either authoritarian or libertarian. I call out the establishment on both sides. But I don't identify as libertarian. They have specific criteria that doesn't match most of us.

[@blogintonblakley2708]

@@Sketcher93 The thing I think libertarians get wrong is the idea that individualism somehow trumps the community. It's like the ranchers who gets almost all the stuff they need from cities... but figures they are independent and self sufficient. Sure as soon as they can build a fully functional pickup truck from raw resources with no reference to libraries or the internet. And even if they could they got that knowledge from where? The community of humans.

[@user-wl2xl5hm7k]

@@blogintonblakley2708 Glad you asked! The following next few comments will be even better than a video, so please read carefully:

[@user-wl2xl5hm7k]

@@blogintonblakley2708 First off, ggl the main terms I used and you’ll find the info to research this. You’ll find excellent sites that distinguish the four corners, and they list main texts from each of the four separate corners

[@comradeweismann6947]

Comments for the Algorithm

[@BrianTracyOfficial.]

ᴛʜᴀɴᴋs ғᴏʀ🔝 ᴡᴀᴛᴄʜɪɴɢ Tell Max I link you to him for a business investment that will change your financial life.. ⬆️

[@johnlucas9556]

很高兴能在我学习马克思主义的时候认识你

[@yasseralsaidi1168]

The system teach citizens to become lazy interesting fact ? And the past never occurred a customer dripping with real poop , it took me 3 hours to sterilize the cab all kinds of people running off with out paying not to mention harassment on the job very interesting but thy were non informants okay what ever you say

[@Aikidoman06]

It was government intervention into students loans that drove the price of school up, and fueled the proliferation of useless degrees. The idea of “fair” in his scenario of the poor kid paying more verses the kid who paid up front is ridiculous. College is a lifestyle choice. If you are poor and need money for school it’s out there free of charge if you have the academic background. Student loans provide opportunities to those who don’t have the money to pay up front. When you buy a car some have to finance it, some pay cash. Is that unfair? Some go on vacation and put it on their credit cards, some pay cash. I’m at a point in my life where I pay cash for everything. When I was younger I had to save or finance if I wanted to buy expensive things. Wolff is so full of crap. Why do people listen to him?

[@yasseralsaidi1168]

Thy want me to believe that informants were never sent to bother me or hassle me on the job then thy turn around and say " the system teaches ordinary men to be lazy" so no slogans fact 1 indeed all types of informants showd up to make my job so difficult sexual harassment ,intimidating,pulling runners all day how why who crimes but no criminal so interesting in a bad way

[@ramonching7772]

Higher education wasn't this expensive until the government started giving out loans. Education was flooded with almost free money. Even textbook's price was inflated because of excessive cash.

[@intuitionz1198]

there's nothing true about this statement. it is absolutely nothing to do with excessive cash and everything to do with deregulation.

[@ramonching7772]

@@intuitionz1198 Even if it is deregulated. If the students don't have money, higher prices won't happen.

[@ramonching7772]

@@intuitionz1198 It's the "free money" in the hands of young adults that caused the problem. A credit card in the hands of adult would also have the same effect.