Workshop

[@mandypowell8793]

Over time the straw or hay will shrink from the weight that is on it and you don't have enough support from the wood to hold the walls up. I'm afraid that over a 2 years period that you will begin to have structural problems and the building eventually falling causing someone to get hurt.

[@jonaaal]

Hi Mandy, the walls were pre compressed with straps to mean there was very little shrinkage. The building was put up over 5 years ago now and it is still performing very nicely!

[@rudimunk7030]

The only thing holding up the roof is the bales. That means that if the straw starts to rot this house becomes a death trap. Although, from an engineering standpoint it probably already is.

[@jonaaal]

Hi Rudy, the walls are constructed above a air porous but capillary impermeable later so there is no dampness to allow rotting.

[@nopunintended5096]

why didn’t you use foam glass gravel for the bottom insulation?

[@jonaaal]

I actually looked into the embodied energy of the glass vs the insulation value and compared it to polystyrene. We would have needed over 300mm of glass vs 100mm poly and the embodied energy of glass is a lot more than poly. FOr the base of the walls we used the glass as there was greater load bearing on a small area and we also wanted breathability/rodent resistance there so we went with the material with the extra energy content as it had the perfect properties.

[@carolsolis8189]

Does a straw building need a drainage canal?

[@carolsolis8189]

Are these straw bales compressed?

[@ВадимКотович-л2ю]

Нужно было каждый тюк окунать в известковое молоко и между рядами проливать жидким глиняным раствором. А стены оббить дранкой и штукатурить глиняным раствором.

[@myldwinpierre3962]

How do you prevent the walls from racking with this type of construction?

[@arvindshukla8244]

That's also my Question

[@jonaaal]

Do you mean cracking?

[@jonaaal]

@Just think the walls are 450mm thick and 2600mm high, not so much of a problem really.

[@luigisollazzo6784]

Il tempo peggiore che ho sprecato nella mia vita è stato nel guardare questo video.

[@michawilczek3146]

Zajebiste a co na sciany od zewnątrz?

[@mirceaab]

120 cm of snow? did you consider the settlement of the walls as well, under such a large amount of snow?

[@jonaaal]

The walls were pre compressed with a load equal to the roof and it’s total load before the rendering of the bales.

[@jonaaal]

@Just think Why does the snow against the walls have any influence on the foundation or the roof structure?

[@jesteris25]

I remember a story from my child hood about someone building a house of straw and someone else blowing it over. All im saying be careful and being 5 years down the track how is it holding up?

[@jonaaal]

It is going great, full of machines making things out of metal, the big bad wolf hasn't been round!

[@mrmadness2699]

The 1st little pig didn't have a hay-bailing machine and the video didn't show the thick layer of plaster applied to inside and outside.

[@jonaaal]

@Just think Yep you're right. Some of the oldest buildings in the USA are straw, in Nevada there are some that are over 200 years old.

[@markcollett9500]

great work! and well done for taking the time to photograph it all. i look forward to the next part! x

[@heybulldog137]

You building a garage, or a fall out shelter? Holy shit, that's a bit stout.

[@miguelmarquez4192]

Lol in ks nm and az these have been used for homes since pioneer days. Super duper insulated. They just have an awesome feel to the rooms. Ever end up in those parts take a look. People are generally proud of them and happy to tell you alllll about them.

[@nuduo9255]

A flat roof? how are you gonna get rid of snow?

[@balloney2175]

Simple... just go up and catch the snow and throw them out of the roof.

[@jonaaal]

The roof has been calculated to take 120cm of snow load so we should be fine1

[@MrsMika]

Nice video but please don't speed it up so much. I slowed it down the most I could and it was still pretty fast to be able to really appreciate all the steps that were done. Thank you for sharing this information. :)

[@jonaaal]

The video was a bit of an experiment, so maybe next tiime I do a project I will have time to plan the video a bit more. The idea was really to give people some insight into how a straw bale building is made. If you have any questions please ask!

[@reynaldogarcia6815]

Siento que alguen tiene que explicar con detalle lo que esten aciendo

[@off-griddad720]

Awesome time laps!

[@DrengrMike]

Can you hippies stop putting polystyrene in the ground please

[@jonaaal]

What would you suggest for insulating underneath concrete?

[@DrengrMike]

@@jonaaal pearlite

[@nopunintended5096]

Jona Aal foam glass gravel

[@vanderzwan69]

what happened did the council tell you to take it down?

[@jonaaal]

It’s still here!

[@ОлегКозлов-д2о]

Монолит отдыхает,было бы охуенно,если бы ещё плиты перекрытия положили,супер,весёлый ролик

[@charmain121]

I dont understand... why would someone build a house with walls made of... wait...what? Straw?! With floors built so steadily and so firm...And a flat roof that is way to heavy for the straw walls to support... and what about the rain? And snow? Oh geez...do you have aspirin???

[@jonaaal]

aries, the floor is concrete to support heavy machine tools, a lathe, milling machine, radial drill etc. The roof is not too heavy for the walls, it is enough to take the snow load and it is covered in turf which mitigates a lot of rain run-off provides good sound and heat insulation and is blending in with the surroundings. Th straw walls are very strong in compression and are very good at insulating sound and heat.

[@vladimirtalizin514]

Отличный крематорий вышел

[@laoluu]

Sorry, what are the tires for?

[@jonaaal]

The tyres are the foundation for the bale walls, they are filled with foamed glass to insulate and prevent moisture from wicking up from the ground. They are also rodent proof

[@BallubaFishingChainsaws]

@@jonaaal to bad u didnt make more videous to the finished shop..i whas curiously for the roof...

[@terrybyrd5105]

Why would you pour a slab then use bail walls - with all that work and expense?

[@jonaaal]

The slab has to support heavy machines, it is a workshop not a house. The bale walls are good for noise and heat insulation and also cheap and low carbon

[@ПавелКоржуков-м2п]

Домик нуф-нуфа:) Солома поди спреет и сгниет. Для грызунов такие стены просто рай. Если только солому с цементом перемешать, но это уже совсем другая технология

[@imiy]

Вообще, её тщательно заштукатуривают. Похоже, видео не законченное.

[@Улугбек34]

И пришел волк к второму поросенку , начал дуть 😂😂😂

[@ballardstowingandoffroadre2367]

I just gotta ask ??? Why use Hay Bales ?? Why not just build regular Wood Walls ?? All the money and time invested seems like it would go to waste in a couple years !!????. Or sooner if a Spark catches the straw ?????. Please explain why you used the Straw Instead of Wood Walls ???. Other than, Very cool job !!

[@jonaaal]

The straw and tender was actually cheaper than timber and insulation separately. With bales you have structure and insulation in one building block. It is low carbon, a waste product and when it is plastered with clay it is much more fire resistant than timber and cladding

[@ggru1981]

....я не понял...НАХРЕНА? )))) Реально сделали ушп, нормальную крышу и все остальное.... Если речь об экономии, то из газосиликата положить стенки такой сарайчик встанет в три копейки. Если оценивать по труду и материалам процентов на 5 дороже итог будет.... Ну правда простоит лет 50 дольше ))))

[@andrejzuk7834]

Ниф-ниф или наф-наф?

[@martinswaine2140]

If you can work fast well when I get a plot of land you can billed me one to👍👏

[@АлександрКертман-ь5щ]

Сказка про трёх поросят ;)))))

[@rosigodoy5289]

Que bonita labor

[@Enchi.]

Усадка наверно 1м в год))

[@johnsode17]

I'm sorry, but I tried to keep an open mind on this. There are some basic structural integrity issues with this concept and that's simply a lot of effort to construct something that simply won't last in many climate conditions. Not sure if the goal was to just show a viable alternative building option or if someone is just trying to prove they can build a building out of straw based on a bar room bet. I don't know that I would waste my time on building a structure like this. More power to those who do this and have no issues, but sorry, I'm out!

[@jonaaal]

It’s lasted quite a few years now in my climate and is doing great!

[@МансурГайсин-ь5м]

Столько сил затрат на такую херню потрачено.

[@романплатонов-м7ц]

И денег

[@hazlotumismoazucarillo3.0]

Very gooddddd

[@Артем-щ6ю3ю]

Пожароопасный дом!!!!!!!!!

[@РизванАтаев-ж1ы]

Рай для мышей! 😁

[@marka.huller5993]

I want to see part two goddamn !!! ...

[@jonaaal]

Have a look at the rendering week video

[@hahzhzh6255]

когда нужно солома можно будет корову покормить

[@balloney2175]

The horse will eat this house.

[@andreapatriciamd4807]

nooo,horses eat hay,,id be worried about nesting rodents ,and b,b,Wolf ;) A serious question now ,are there alternatives to concrete flooring ?

[@quip59]

Andrea Sidnell rodents dont go in there if you have your details right... When the walls are plastered its closed and has a very good fire resistance. Strawbuilding is far beyond these simple problems

[@akaAlekseyS]

This is a good house for mouses..

[@jonaaal]

There are alternatives but this is a workshop with large metalwork tools, a milling machine and a lathe both weigh about a tonne so the floor has to be strong and flat

[@jonaaal]

The detail at the floor is the tyres. They are filled with foamed glass to insulate and also stop rodents. The walls are also plastered with clay and sand which rodents dont much like to eat.

[@kanatol1]

Мыши любят в соломе...!

[@zelenatorres7680]

Wow genial

[@БорисГодунов-р2й]

Домик для не курящих.

[@ИРИ-ф2ю]

Столько всего и итог саломеный дом

[@rifantonio3336]

G

[@РусланИсмаилов-ы8т]

Леее

[@ДмитрийКрупин-к5ь]

Живите сами в этом хлеву

[@hahzhzh6255]

Хороший курятник получился.

[@alexrussia930]

Поди кто то пересмотрел мультик про трёх поросят и волка 😀

[@nikoiayykovlevich125]

Про 3х поросят слыхали историю???

[@fatihkocak3952]

👍

[@heybulldog137]

Way over kill..

[@jonaaal]

What is overkill? I am interested to know your thoughts

[@ФанзильФагимович]

И на долго это хибара . До первого перекура.

[@СпартакКерашвили]

Дом Наф-Нафа

[@honda5897]

Мышиный дом

[@davidrobbins8941]

Building a house that will shine brightly among houses. Especially if it catches fire 🔥

[@jonaaal]

Hi David, the walls are plastered with clay and sand tender so will not catch fire. In fact the American government did some fire tests and they didn’t finish the destructive test because the walls lasted so long! Much longer than timber and gypsum dry lining

[@davidrobbins8941]

@@jonaaal that's good to know, hope it works well for you👍

[@solascriptura7882]

Duremary na kanikulax...

[@ivan-fakov]

Дом из говна и палок.

[@barmalei9927]

Three Little Pigs...

[@gulcankaya9891]

deli fare polulasyonu olur evde

[@gulsinakagarmanowa3990]

Ерунда получилось....

[@анатолийматышев]

Муде

[@oix.fmxxluho]

Exelent and poor

[@jonaaal]

Why poor?

[@oix.fmxxluho]

@@jonaaal sorry, easy and chip. That's what I meant

[@honda5897]

Машинный дом

[@Грозный202]

домик для мышей

[@skeets6060]

Not by the hair on my chinny chin chin