XG-In The Rain (Japan Fansign)

[@ザックザック-l1x]

こういう場では生歌聞きたい気持ちもわかるけどこの半年間のスケジュールで普通に考えて一人もほぼ体調壊さずにきとること自体がすごいと思うな。3日後からはまた怒涛のヨーロッパ講演やで

[@sh09un1]

people complaining about the backtrack like it's not the industry standard to use them, especially in this setting. The backtrack saved Harvey from an embarrassing moment when she forgot to start singing at the beginning. That's why they use it, it's support for them to put out the best listening experience for the fan. Stop being weird and back seating their careers and choices. You don't know better then them, simon or any of the team with years of experience in this industry. The goal is to make them global superstars and they're doing that, just relax and enjoy the ride.

[@rosieposie5852]

Yes, it's the industry standard, and it's annoying when you can hear the processing sound of the pitch correction and you know what these girls are capable of. That moment of Harvey when she forgot to sing, wouldn't it be more embarrassing when she forgot to sing yet the backtrack was still playing like that than if she forgot to sing and there was no backtrack? I would even proudly say, "See? No voice coming out when she forgot to sing, that's the proof of live vocal" for the second case. Have you ever listened to Chisa's and Juria's live vocals for their solo performances, anyway? If I Were A Boy, I Have Nothing, Hello, Hero, to name a few? There were flats, sharps, sometimes they sounded heavy, but they sounded raw and glorious. Their pitch corrected vocals that were uploaded on their channel (Peaches, Nobody Love, Dear Name, etc) were nowhere close to their raw vocals; I'd choose their raw vocals every single day. I'm sure it would be the same with the other girls, they would sound much better with their own authentic voices. Backtrack, especially if it's pitch corrected, does not give the best listening experience to me. Back seating their careers and choices? You sound like you don't trust that these girls can sing live by relying on their own vocal cords when they are not dancing.

[@sh09un1]

@@rosieposie5852 let me get this straight, so you think when Harvey misses her cue it's better that there's a gap and no ones singing and she has to stumble into her verse part way rather then her hopping onto the back track that's already playing. You don't think that's more embarrassing and disrupts the entire performance for everyone else? That's crazy lol Too many people have too many opinions about things they don't understand. It's fine to have preferences, but don't come out here saying "they should do that they should do this" when you don't know there reasoning behind it. There's like 20 people in that room, it's not that serious.

[@micell826]

​@@sh09un1 Of course it would have been better if there had been a gap. Because that means it's a real performance. No gap means they're just standing there miming. Wasting everyone's time.

[@hotcaramelfudgesundae]

Maya and Cocona looking at each other when Maya forgot to sing her part lmaooo 😅 they still sound amazing though 💖

[@ザックザック-l1x]

I`m looking forward to hearing their beautiful voice and listen this song few days later in London. I can't wait it.

[@airolovely7892]

I hope they make MV for this song and Is This Love.

[@gaorinxin685]

yes

[@mu6762]

何かいろいろ言っている人いるけど、日本でのライブやイベントは、ファンカム禁止だから　この動画を見る事が出来てる事自体に感謝した方がいいよ。 新曲聞けただけでもありがたい。 XGARAXとXG 7人のファンサービスは、本当に素晴らしい。

[@takooyab2892]

@@mu6762 同意👍 あの場に居たALPHAZが言うならまだしも(言わないけど)好意でKZbinにUPされた動画を無料で視聴して文句言うとかね😅

[@castielvids1023]

I love this track so much! I'm excited to see more live of this song from them. LFG! XG

[@hoyymenoyy]

this is my favorite bside ever... i cry like im in the rain 😭

[@Ajari-r7u]

正直、被せだろうと気になりません彼女たちが歌姫揃いなのはわかっているので せっかく、うまいのに…という意見も理解はできますが これから大事なヨーロッパツアーに向かうわけで、くれぐれもお身体(喉も)大切に。という気持ちです

[@officezodiac]

0:28 のHarveyと 2:28 のMayaのうっかりかわいいwww🫶 CoconaがMayaにそっと「はい、あなたよ🫱」ってリードしてるの優しいwww In The RainはMVもコンサートでのパフォーマンスもまだ上がってないから、被せとか自分はどうでもいいwww thx!🐺🫶

[@takooyab2892]

バックトラックというよりファンサのため急遽パフォしたから、オケだけの音源がまだなくてCD音源そのまま流してるのかな？

[@eecorr]

Thanks for uploading ! Hinata looks again like a anime character

[@k3ionnn]

OMG HARVEY SINGING?!!!!😍😍😍

[@ml555ml5]

上手いのを知ってるからこそ完全生歌求めたいのもわかるけど、 馬鹿にされるのが悔しいから生歌で実力証明して欲しいって人は、喉を壊せば活動期間が短くなるの理解してる？ バックトラック有りでも上手いのは十分わかるし、何故被せと口パクの区別もつかないレベルの人達の批判がそんなに気になるのか

[@kobemoss]

Thanks for posting! This is so beautiful live!!!!

[@henlogarcia4988]

2:06 my juria

[@xokaponrxmt]

これだけハイペースで楽曲提供するグループも多くはないのでは※洋楽比べ　歌いこめばそれだけ上手くなる　まだまだ進化の途中　でも感動させてくれるレベル高いXGちゃんたちは唯一無二の魅力

[@inqlusion9283]

How do they sound so angelic using hand mics and on a makeshift stage at Tower Records with no acoustic enhancement? Answer: They are XG. And love the vocals from Jurin, Maya, Cocona and Harvey. Hope we see this on The First Take since they’re in Japan now they can do a taping

[@alexjone-q8e]

Thanks for your hard work and sharing👏👏👏

[@HelTra91]

YES!

[@pofkuv-nurvE8-capqyj]

チサちゃんとジュリンちゃんとココナちゃん口からCD音源すぎて被せであることで損してると思う..笑 マヤちゃんハヴィちゃんは持ち前の声量でいつも音源超えてくる ジュリアちゃんひーちゃんはいい意味でいつも音源とは違う味がある

[@enemynumber-zm3ug]

hinata youre the live version * marin * my dress up darling❤

[@St2dio21]

Girls, all that rain is just Alphaz’s tears of joy😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@masaki0hasegawa]

でもさ、もともと歌唱してるのは彼女たちだしXGの実力なんてALPHAZならみんなわかってる（まだまだ未知数だがw）なので色んな意見ありますが、最高、バチイケシャキシャキキャベツなので、暖かく見守っていただきたい、←何様？ それにこの日は多分地球言語の発声が、難しい日だったんです！！

[@XaiMartinezOfficialYT]

1:33 They are fighting the backtrack😭😭😭 Please can they just be given a more quieter backtrack and also there is no echo in the mics😢 Btw, I want to hear sing this at the First Take😊!

[@Ryan95255]

I wish they not using backtrack…because they vocal is so good

[@AdanRivera-s5u]

That is just like asking them to stop dancing and Focus on singing

[@Ryan95255]

⁠@@AdanRivera-s5uthey not dancing tho in this song…if they dancing they have using backtrack, thats completely ok

[@AdanRivera-s5u]

@@Ryan95255 You did'nt Say that in your previous coment, i though You're talking in general

[@ithoughtiwascishet1316]

i think their mics are just too quiet, and singing the song louder might mess up the relaxed vibe of the song. on stage for howling, the backtrack was loud, but their mics were also loud enough to hear them clearly + it's a louder song so they can be loud if they need to.

[@kepeliboy8987]

Probably with such a busy schedule and all the performances these last couple weeks before they hit the Europe leg of the tour, they're probably managing the vocals. As much as we would love to hear everything live, they got so much to do these last months before a small break. 🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺 👽👽👽👽👽👽👽

[@hotcaramelfudgesundae]

Wait literally the 1st here WTH

[@mumu11_1]

被せに対して言ってる人いるけど 喉や声帯少し休ませる為にも必要だと思うな。使いすぎると壊れちゃうよ

[@Ex-XG]

イベントの余興で歌っているのですから本気の生歌を求めなくていいのでは？😅

[@メインアカウント-h3y]

被せがあることってそんなに言われることなのか？イヤモニしてるのか分からないけど、まだ覚えきれてないならリードのためにもあったほうがいいわな。XGが生歌最高なのはわかってることだし。大舞台でない限りは温存も大事だろうな。

[@teat9142]

ハーヴィー「やべっ、やってもーた。バレバレやわ」（笑）

[@tututuolis]

音程外してもいいから完全生歌だとより嬉しい😭 少しでも音外したら切り取られるから一応対策って感じなのかな…

[@taki523]

被せよりもどんだけ失敗しても生歌のみが良いと思う。生歌を求める私が悪いのか。 実力があると思うだけに悔しい。

[@猫助-m5n]

私もそう思います。踊らないなら尚更。ファンとしてはどうせ口パクって言われるのは悔しいよ😭

[@miku-v1t]

あなた色んな動画で生歌かどうか被せがなんたらってずっと言ってますよね。すごく目に付く

[@ml555ml5]

気持ちはわかるけど、長く活躍して欲しいから過度に完全生歌を求めるのもどうかと思う 日数が少ないのもあるかもだけどHOWLINGでの活動は口パク無かったし、出来る範囲でやれる事はやってる

[@taki523]

@@miku-v1t あなたも私が目に付くほどファンですね。薄々生歌を求める事が悪いように思えてきてます。

[@taki523]

@@ml555ml5 ご意見ありがとうございます。生歌を求める私が悪いと感じてきてます。誰かが誰かをフォローしてでもその時の声が聞きたかった。私のように生歌を重要だと思う人が少ない事を知れました。

[@whatchahowsya8688]

Why does XG have backtracks? That's the one thing I wish Simon would stop doing. The girls are too talented to need backtrack.

[@michaeln3044]

Lol this is a fan sign man. They ain’t set up for no concert. It’s karaoke essentially

[@whatchahowsya8688]

​@@michaeln3044even at their concerts they use heavy backtracks.

[@michaeln3044]

@@whatchahowsya8688 I find this weird like people can distinguish between what’s their voice and what’s a backtrack pretty easy and yeah it’s kind of necessary on any choreo track. I don’t know any group that drops their backing vocals and does real choreo.

[@sh09un1]

That backtrack literally saved Harvey, she forgot to start singing lol

[@michaeln3044]

@ I like how they laughed it off loli

[@izonelover]

2:20 やっぱり信用できるボーカルはジュリアだけかな笑

[@abdgjtamtj]

こういう場でも、ダンスもないのに被せられると正直…。うーん。