XG - WINTER WITHOUT YOU / THE FIRST TAKE | REACTION

[@TheYearOfJerome]

HINATA ARE YOU KIDDING ME OMG

[@c0ffeelatt3]

and Chisa too wth

[@MarkCalica]

@@c0ffeelatt3relax, we all know Chisa has a great vocals. We’re just saying Hinata deserves recognition too

[@c0ffeelatt3]

@@MarkCalica oh sorry, i didn't mean what you thinking. i mean hinata and chisa's voice are angelic

[@MarkCalica]

@@c0ffeelatt3 I hear ya

[@ChristianFranch]

SHE FINISHED ME. MY LORD, THINK OF A WOMAN I LOVE THE VOICE OF

[@ZioComposite]

Bruh, XG really said Studio, CD, live, don't matter we do it A1 FLAWLESS lmfao

[@HumbleSoul8087]

XG is definitely "THAT R&B GROUP" we've been longing for! Alphaz 🐺

[@酔ってるなジジィ]

叶うならば… この楽曲が『世界中の冬の定番ソング』になって欲しいと切に願う…

[@bennyboi620]

Live Vocals always hit different… especially with Xtraordinary Girls

[@Phantom_Silver8]

R&B Masterclass by XG

[@soliver25]

I'm pretty sure I like this version better than the studio version 😅 They are so so good at singing live, all that practice paying off!

[@pietroeros8308]

_Hinata-chan is my princess_ ❤

[@firavun8943]

MAYA HAVE IT ALLL LIKE WTF

[@yoshikoq5289]

Juria always makes me feel in heaven 🤍🩷🥺

[@nissan04]

the chills and tears i got when they first harmonized the chorus 😭😭

[@zerimas_]

bro Chisa’s voice is actually majestic 😭

[@kvideo9449]

Omg i love it more than the studio

[@kvideo9449]

They hit different

[@azs6597]

最後の音が無くなったハーモニーが綺麗すぎて感動でした😭

[@litanosuke8905]

毎回涙が出てしまう彼女たちの歌声。こんなに人々を涙させるアイドルグループ他に居ない。 ふと思い出したんだけど、Chisa、Juria、Mayaは、ギリギリまでなかなかデビューメンバー決定にならなかったんだよね…。今では全員が唯一無二で、1人1人の魅力がXGを作り出している。凄い化学反応。プロデュース陣の人選、プロデュース力に脱帽。

[@pgwrks4149]

Maya came through on this song like, Ion't just rap bro!! Put some respek on my name!! 💪💪💪

[@munagrg3486]

I really don't know what they are still hiding from us. Every time they come they leave me speechless and mesmerised. They are literally extraordinary. From rapping to vocals, visuals to dance everything about them is so perfect ❤❤❤ I LOVE XG SOOOO MUCH😭😭😭

[@OLD_DARK69]

Maya 🧨🧨🧨🧨🧨🧨🧨🧨🧨🧨🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

[@bisco5051]

他のコメントに、ココナちゃん、風邪で鼻声でありながら、このハーモニーはヤバいですね！ MAYAちゃんもラップも歌も素晴らしい❤ もはや天使のハーモニー❤❤❤

[@MarkCalica]

💯agree this version is better than the recording. It felt like there’s more emotion to it.

[@calvinmitchell1274]

XG💗

[@P0ch1ta]

woop! looking cute at every christmas party....👊👊👊

[@kaecee1991]

Chisa in this though. Wow just wow

[@NehaKunwar-t3u]

Chisa are you kidding me oh my gosh ❤❤❤

[@EdvinHubble]

Couldn't recognize Juria before this song, didn't really care about her i guess i just didn't notice her, but holy moly she might be my bias after this comeback, everything about her got me

[@pedroportalatin6751]

My favorite girl group of All time period ❤

[@AsuraCloudwalker]

I feel the same way; this live first take version sounds better than the studio version. Also, Jurin's aesthetics and fits in this are ❤‍🔥❤‍🔥❤‍🔥; can't expect any less from a model.

[@bambooranada]

Holy shit man this sounded better than the actual track in my opinion.

[@mariekandi6914]

👏👏👏i may like this more than the studio recording. we need more rnb xg!!!

[@naneungangaji]

after watching xtra xtra documentary, i even more more MORE proud of them 💖 they are so talented and amazing! i will support them forever 🐺💓

[@naneungangaji]

i am SO proud and touched whenever i watch their mvs/video content and listen to their music. i love them so much! 😭❣️

[@bobbycorwen-d6c]

I agree with everything u said 😆

[@domhur]

This is definitely better than the original release. They need to put this on streaming now.

[@defmeta]

Harvey really shone in this version. I mean they all killed it and ate this song up like mince pies in england...

[@GaryFry-c6d]

Once in a lifetime group, singing better live then the MV's. Love them so much. ❤ Wonderful reaction. Jurin 🦋 Chisa 🌞 Hinata 💠 Harvey 🦄 Juria 🧸 Maya 🐕Cocona 🍄 ALPHAZ 🐺

[@brindegivre]

XG has owned this year like crazy

[@KowareyasuiOkami]

#ohMAYAgod they are out of this world amazing!!

[@RudeMekanicals]

Regarding the members' facial expressions \ emotions on display and why it feels like this performance is better than the studio version, I believe we have to give it up for another genius Simon move. For those who might not know, for the shooting of the mv it was arranged to surprise the members with video messages from their family whom they haven't seen for while. As we can see in the mv and footage from the behind the scenes, the members had a very emotional reaction. What has been created for them is a very strong emotional moment that is directly linked with the song Winter Without You, allowing the members to access this emotional memory very eaily and thus imbue their performance of the song with this emotion. So in one move Simon took care of the members emotionally by giving them a link with their parents, created a memorable moment for the mv and bts, and gave the members an efficient and powerful performing tool. That is why legitimately no one is doing it like XG!!!!

[@tajsimms8976]

Sounds like hidden agenda of emotional manipulation for profit but that’s just me being blunt (I’ve watched too many music industry documentaries) but I agree he did a smart move😂

[@RudeMekanicals]

@@tajsimms8976 You're not wrong, if you look at it in a cynical way he is a CEO profiting from his employees' labor, but the genius move is the fact that it is also something that helps them be better performer and a healthy way of keeping a link between the members and their family when this whole industry usually causes families to become distant or worse... It is all those at once

[@cherra437]

I know im not the only one who notices that in the first chorus hinata voice is really deep there ❤

[@shortcake772]

chisa deserves more recognition ❤

[@Brrua]

Hinata harmonizing is different level..✨

[@user-maghiro]

👍🔥🔥🔥☃️🎄

[@ginamarieo789]

My reaction was the same. I prefer this to the studio version.

[@dakn617]

Love the reaction as always. Just wanted to let you know triples released a new song called “Just Do It” with four new members!

[@samhue4194]

straight outta park

[@davidgollinger7376]

I actually like the first take way way better than the actual music video, even though it's sick too

[@ancoromotti5053]

I love watching your reactions! It seems the XG reactor crew hasn't noticed this song. pleeease give it a listen. Chisa&Juria cover 【UR BEST FRIEND】 （There's no official music video, but there is a lyric video available.）

[@ChubbiCheekP]

They really got me listening to Christmas music In the summer time. I don’t even careeeeee lmaooo sooo bueno! 🫰🏽🔥

[@ruochenchen6190]

yo bro merry xmas

[@MattCheah1]

hinata need more singing part！🎉🎉🎉

[@leydarachadey465]

Pliss reacciona a TAEMIN RIZZNESS GUILTY .Un ARTISTA maravilloso SUPREMACIA de la industria 😊

[@LalaAndLewlew]

DUDE U LOOK LIKE MY COUSIN LIKE LITERALLY IDENTICAL

[@ひらひらりん-g8w]

ヒナタは過小評価されている。彼女はXGのボーカルラインに深みを与えている。素晴らしい👍再確認

[@黃盈憲]

🌹🇪🇺

[@yadisetiawan1549]

Simon clearly need to stop adding to much to harvey voice because she clearly better without the edit.

[@jonabelrevamonte]

Hi can i request can you reac pilipino singer. Like Morisitte Amon. I promise you I am sure that you will listen to all his songs even if you listen to one. Please now i subscribe you