香港行會召集人葉劉淑儀專訪：2019年示威者試圖推翻政府

香港行會召集人葉劉淑儀專訪：2019年示威者試圖推翻政府－ BBC News 中文 |

Рет қаралды 449,449

5 ай бұрын

多年來，北京一直在加強對香港的控制。從民主活動、政治反對派到新聞自由均受到限制。那麽香港的未來會如何呢？
BBC HARDtalk欄目主持史蒂文·薩克爾（Stephen Sackur）連線香港行政會議召集人葉劉淑儀，就香港國安法、港人移民潮及資金外流等問題進行對談。#葉劉淑儀 #香港國安法 #香港時事 #香港社會
00:06 開場
01:14 為什麼香港將要實行《基本法》第23條
09:00 回應香港政府緝捕8位流亡海外的民主派人士
10:29 香港立法會參選資格限制
12:44 黎智英事件
18:33 為何香港人想離開
20:37 外資企業遷出香港
22:00 香港依賴中國
23:13 除了香港的國際地位，中國是否更關心香港的穩定和服從
BBC News 中文: www.bbc.com/zhongwen
訂閱BBC News 中文 KZbin：bit.ly/1wkHh5T
BBC News 中文 Facebook - / bbcchinese
BBC News 中文 Twitter - / bbcchinese
BBC News 中文 Instagram - / bbcchinese

Пікірлер: 2 100

@tonichen9970 5 ай бұрын

Their talking just like two Parallel space。他們的對談宛如兩個平行世界。

@user-ew8xb3gd6t 5 ай бұрын

认知不同本身就没法沟通！就像你认为地球是方的，我认为地球是圆！那怎么沟通？除非咱俩一起飞出地球看看地球到底是什么形状的！

@tim055006101 5 ай бұрын

不在一個頻道上😂

@user-ew8xb3gd6t 5 ай бұрын

@@tim055006101 那能在一个频道上吗？在一个频道上不就不用冲突了吗？现在是敌我矛盾！

@Mr.Agumon 5 ай бұрын

說給認知不同的受眾聽當然就平衡宇宙。

@user-ew8xb3gd6t 5 ай бұрын

@@Mr.Agumon但是这是英国平台！英国的目的是让香港官员在英国节目上出丑！所以他才会那么多咄咄逼人，诱导攻击性输出！

@hikeithwong 5 ай бұрын

“We know they are lying, they know they are lying, they know we know they are lying, we know they know we know they are lying, but they are still lying.” Aleksandr Isayevich Solzhenitsyn - Also voices from Hong Kongers... 😥

@brounlee8458 5 ай бұрын

葉劉林鄭等人都是成長受教育受薪在英治的香港而且他們也清楚了解中國內地人民的苦難歷史和現狀當今人類社會已經擺脫野蠻愚昧天理可以得到昭彰深深祝福他們得到應得的報應

@MuLi-rv2is 5 ай бұрын

@@brounlee8458 祈祷管用还要军队干什么

@panke216 5 ай бұрын

Yes, BBC does it all the time!

@Wenshengzhai 5 ай бұрын

你不看频道中怎么说的吗？实际上英治时期根本就没有选举议员，港督是英国指派的，议员是港督指派的，他们比你更了解以前的香港与现在的香港的差异。@@brounlee8458

@linay9960 5 ай бұрын

U r talking about big liar BBC rude host!

@yyykkkei 5 ай бұрын

Don’t touch her, DO NOT TOUCH HER! You are not the same age.

@KdramaCdramaOST 5 ай бұрын

age has nothing to do with it tho'. Their basic mindsets and world views are worlds apart.

@Jnakajin 5 ай бұрын

DR K

@berniethekiwidragon4382 5 ай бұрын

@@KdramaCdramaOST I am thinking you have no idea what this is referencing.

@bosszola 5 ай бұрын

In other words, She can only be touched by people of the same age. 😂😂

@jpnmystic5208 5 ай бұрын

@@KdramaCdramaOST its Dr.K meme go check it LUL

@yvonneso1015 5 ай бұрын

姐姐真係一件好盡責嘅反駁隊隊員👍🏻每一句開頭都是：you are totally wrong. This is incorrect. You breached the contract. You grabbed our doctors. It's your fault. 繼續說好香港故事靠姐姐喇👍🏻

@JamesChin-vq1sr 5 ай бұрын

你系黄絲还是蓝絲？？？

@Universal_Holy_Consciousness 5 ай бұрын

@@JamesChin-vq1sr黃藍已達成一致，現在只有攬炒絲。

@Ritzrfx 5 ай бұрын

梗係啦,唔係咁易比個行會召集人個位比你做,佢想好似689咁,做完召集人跟手做特首,佢恨咗個位好耐㗎啦,屆屆佢都想選

@JamesChin-vq1sr 5 ай бұрын

@@Universal_Holy_Consciousness 何謂「黃藍已達成一致」？黄絲仇陆依旧，蓝絲堅持原则，你告我「達成一致」？點解你偷换概念呢？？？🤔

@lomondliverpool 5 ай бұрын

你是誰?! 細作嗎?!

@jckapparel 5 ай бұрын

To destroy a big city, it doesn't have to be the sky Disasters can also be man-made disasters. Man-made disasters are not necessarily wars. A few words and ignorant actions of a few people can completely kill a big city.

@ghrosthelman3273 5 ай бұрын

As Robespierre said, the losses caused by the 2019 Hong Kong riots can be repaid in just one year, but the losses caused by the oppression of authoritarianism (whether it is the British government or the revisionist CCP) cannot be fully repaid by the entire Chinese people!

@jizifeng 5 ай бұрын

hongkong still a big finance city,and even IPO more than New york o london...destroy?who says/

@vc8230 5 ай бұрын

So well said.

@berniethekiwidragon4382 5 ай бұрын

@@ghrosthelman3273He's not wrong there. People will only invest if they feel comfortable and safe. Hong Kong is no longer safe, because of the draconian laws that threaten people's freedoms and thus lives. Say one word wrong, and you are in a heap of disproportionate trouble courtesy of nobody but this bully government.

@tonyatgoogle6076 5 ай бұрын

HKGers demonstrated against the HK govt in order to stop HKG govt from deporting a murderer who killed his pregnant girlfriend to Taiwan to face justice. The murder walks free in HK, that is the legacy of the freedom protest in HK

@ronyau761 5 ай бұрын

When Ms Yip responded with facts or truth answer that are not favor to the expectation from Stephen Sackur/BBC or BBC does not want you to know the fact, she's interrupted. She could not finish her talk and her voices were covered by Stephen Sackur. Ms Yip should not let it be, and should have continued to finishing her views/voices, and not be taken over by the interviewer.

@gorgorchannel 5 ай бұрын

人在做天在看，一切報應只是時間問題。

@wjxjxhwang-ov3kh 4 ай бұрын

看BBC没笑，看到你头像，我是真的笑了

@Autumn-cool 4 ай бұрын

嗯社会上生活中干什么都用你的信念做下去吧

@joe3223 5 ай бұрын

算了吧，你永遠叫不醒裝睡的人，那怕心底亦清楚明白卻要出賣靈魂。

@JamesChin-vq1sr 5 ай бұрын

你说的是那个英国主持人和你自己吧🤣

@sansnom9688 5 ай бұрын

@@JamesChin-vq1sr你問葉太佢個女喺邊度讀書？而家住喺邊？

@lee-is3uv 5 ай бұрын

你也永远忽悠不了真正清醒的人

@Mr.Agumon 5 ай бұрын

@@JamesChin-vq1sr 美國駐華大使館的微博有很多說真話的中國人。😂

@michanel888 5 ай бұрын

⁠@@JamesChin-vq1sr哈佬，粉紅隊😊

@yindu_Weige888 5 ай бұрын

*多谢分享💓*

@laulaulau8084 4 ай бұрын

賣烏絲素個老闆係光頭佬!衹不個用錢揾廣告演員唱好成效釣水魚!!除左財經演員還有老千醫藥保健演員!!!他/她們的目的都是唱高股價和唱好產品成效散貨~ #沒有雙盲測試衹有戲(騙)子吹噓🔊🔊🔊🔊🔊🔊~ 大家知不知道凍齡和逆轉齡產品能否延長職業運動員的生涯嗎？大家知不知道抗頑英文是什麼?#大ka又知不知道藥物放入口賣廣告背後的勾結嗎**來自元朗過往在香港從事醫藥保健騙局的老千[李美英]L0uise lee mei ying[屬狗1982年)現居住在英國諾定咸(edwalton)!大家要留意!#她的右眼眼白裡有黑點在天水圍張煊昌中學畢業她有一個被她操控的小男人老公名叫(horace tin田福偉)還有兩個三角形眼睛(12月12日2013年)十歲孖女名叫田芷逸Carina tin和田芷悅Cadence tin就讀於rosecliffe spencer academy#老千李美英即使被侵犯私隱也不會向私隱專員公署舉報 Faceb00k雙生兒逸悅在英倫 Faceb00k雙生兒逸悅在英倫 Faceb00k雙生兒逸悅在英倫 Faceb00k雙生兒逸悅在英倫 #大家小心這個騙局年代

@moniqueq8399 5 ай бұрын

This man is very rude. When someone speaks about something that is not advantageous to his position, he will cut off the conversation.

@cqyan191 5 ай бұрын

He is. Very very rude.

@user-ww5xl8ho7t 5 ай бұрын

The man n BBC is a mouth piece of USA 🇺🇸 and we normal hk people know there was millions funded £££$$$$ for the roits! But ask the main question why the west so interested in a small city affairs like hk ? To GET to China! Simple

@terrenceoon4056 5 ай бұрын

yes, and they call their rude and disrespectful the free speech or hardtalk.

@ourskydc3251 4 ай бұрын

Always rude and impolite, not just this time

@user-ww5xl8ho7t 4 ай бұрын

@ourskydc3251 n BBC give multi interviews for the trouble makers n rioters a voice to spread the cool in hk but not the normal people in hk who was held against their will in their home! Or interview the CIA ,nsa who help n funded the roits !

@user-uz4bh8wl3v 5 ай бұрын

葉太真正愛國愛港香港人😂👍

@kaisangsum4291 5 ай бұрын

她更愛自己的權力，成日都想做凸手，可惜眼高手底，

@user-uz4bh8wl3v 5 ай бұрын

@@kaisangsum4291 無可厚非邊個唔想做阿一😀

@user-uv6et9cj8z 5 ай бұрын

@@kaisangsum4291 妳本人又如何？

@hilarylau6840 5 ай бұрын

最後佢既人都冇資格選舉，成為一個condom

@IshmaelDoe 4 ай бұрын

你唔得左打 s/

@bruceevangelismandrevelati841 5 ай бұрын

I really liked the content. Keep supplying us. Thank you for sharing with us. ❤✌😘🥀🍀

@Gemini73883 5 ай бұрын

The Brits have a harsher national security law (Sacker didn't protest when Regina pointed it out) but Sacker then says it is in the implementation. Is Mr Sacker an MP who can represent the British Government. Or is he wishing for slack policing of said law. I suppose it is his job to do what he is doing.

@user-xq4pu5uc2h 5 ай бұрын

British have universal suffrage.

@wilsonku3964 5 ай бұрын

●●葉劉淑儀=你這個共匪喉舌，為了保官位，不得不胡說八道。自欺又欺共匪土包子。英國及蘇聯的中國共產黨=都是外來政權，香港交給英國管理比被共匪奪取，好100倍。香港國安法=共匪政權保衛法，防備被人民推翻。

@user-oe9pu5hh3e 5 ай бұрын

愚蠢的猴子😂

@shaocoyle3161 5 ай бұрын

how many did the brits arrest and torture?

@Vitam2047 5 ай бұрын

One point I must agree with her is that in comparison with what Hong Kong was 200 hundred years ago, there is already a great leap in the prosperity of the place and the welfare of its inhabitants. Hong Kong people didn't have stuffs like cellphone back then and guess what, Hongkongers now have Huawei and Xiaomi cellphones! Thanks to the motherland and also Ms Ip. NSL have brought so much improvements to the life of Hongkongers. Well done !

@hegehypo5914 5 ай бұрын

Well done Regina for rebuking all the false statements and invalid accusations by Sackur on HK law and national secuirty. As expected Sackur again followed the same playbook of Anglo Saxon (US/UK) tactics of smearing and instigating instability of China. The fact of the matter is HK since 2020 passing of the law ammendment is very peaceful and no more 2019 riot events which is not what US/UK wanted to see

@IshmaelDoe 4 ай бұрын

what are you and at least 52 other genius are smoking? Xi's fart?

@user-hu1ce6up8r Ай бұрын

@@IshmaelDoe SB

@IshmaelDoe Ай бұрын

@@user-hu1ce6up8r yes, that's your name

@gkmail8718 5 ай бұрын

A good interviewer would allow the interviewee to speak their mind freely instead of interrupting. Very disappointing from a man talks so much about freedom of speech.

@hygogc1685 5 ай бұрын

thx

@user-gc6gj2bz2o 5 ай бұрын

This host is biased, vicious, and rude. He often interrupts Ip Lau Suk-yee's speeches rudely.

@eugene9661 5 ай бұрын

He is vicious because he doesn't support china? Interruption is necessary because she evades and lies.

@flyingzone356 5 ай бұрын

Was this the first time you watched Hard Talk???

@bosszola 5 ай бұрын

Ms ip is just a reading machine, she just keep evading and doesn’t answer questions.

@killerj0905 5 ай бұрын

i see u like ccp a lot

@user-er7vb4ro9f 5 ай бұрын

You can never change the behavior of randomly interrupting others and think it is disrespectful to others.

@w94vm 5 ай бұрын

在某種情況下，身為主持人需要把來賓的談話拉回來，以避免對話失焦。

@cqyan191 5 ай бұрын

Such a rude man! Such a so called famous host. God save him. Can anyone be more rude? !

@laulaulau8084 4 ай бұрын

@IshmaelDoe 4 ай бұрын

@@cqyan191 I suppose you forgot to type /s at the end?

@yctai6151 5 ай бұрын

Hello UK, how's the NI situation?

@sourcecode999 5 ай бұрын

嘥氣啦，正常人都唔敢受訪啦，敢上去係咩料你知我知啦

@ngsam3362 5 ай бұрын

正常做左特手特腳啦。一把年紀仲日日說故事? 好L野。

@user-ji9ou1hh7t 5 ай бұрын

那你倒是想想办法呀，把驻港部队赶走

@sourcecode999 5 ай бұрын

@@user-ji9ou1hh7t 你煽動，第一次警告

@jpnmystic5208 5 ай бұрын

都咁既年紀仲想做大外孫 😉

@MichaelLi-ms1on 5 ай бұрын

Sounds more like an interrogation than an interview to me. The host keeps asserting ideas, opinions and even predictions to the interviewee and wishes to see she would back down and become submissive. If one hadn't known better, it's easy to confuse those two figures. Who has been working as a politician for many decades and who has been a TV show presenter. But the guest today just won't give in. Will done! Regina.

@dougsilent4341 5 ай бұрын

White people think they are the lord. That is the mentality. Some Hong Kongers indeed regard white people as lord.

@wangjim5839 5 ай бұрын

The host is absolutely preconceived and bias. And rude too by cutting in when the guest is still speaking

@Yinyinlaw 5 ай бұрын

香港以前是好地地👍卻比這些奴才玩死香港😢

@mplai7838 5 ай бұрын

喺囉所謂官逼民反啲罪“葉瘤”獨毒官自己整啲sup9政策專嚟整人批鬥落底搞到人哋要制裁翻你唔知邊個先喺策劃策動國安法的罪魁禍首呢！？🤔😚😁😏

@user-em4yb1lo4v 5 ай бұрын

当你预设立场和你观点不同的就是奴才，别人当然也有权利还以颜色，you think you're superior than you fellows, which is so arrogant and disrespectful.

@eugene9661 5 ай бұрын

那不就是中共的目的

@jacktsui7667 5 ай бұрын

以前都是女王的奴才😂

@user-xq4pu5uc2h 5 ай бұрын

奴才該死不可饒恕但最大責任始終是聖上，千古不易。

@MrRyanyungtl 5 ай бұрын

Thank you BBC for powerful question❤

@kerwinhuang3319 5 ай бұрын

Hard questions that don't allow the guest to answer fully.

@jameschao8212 5 ай бұрын

那干吗老打断别人的回答

@wkwoo5333 5 ай бұрын

all biased questions!

@soeswanto1 5 ай бұрын

Powerful for the headlines he created. but it shows that he has not researched the topics as thoroughly as a professional should. I get the feeling that he was reading off a script. He was he is oblivious to the current happenings in Hong Kong. He to keep repeating "78" year old man to siphon sympathy just don't work these days. Jimmy Lai's is just a treacherous and greedy old man. Money laundering for American politicians is the job. But nothing to do with democracy nor freedom of speech. But of course non of the anglophile media will ever carry the full content nor context of the trial.

@sisitang9698 4 ай бұрын

Stupid questions based on unsubstantiated lies, BBC is skilled at tricking viewers.

@yiaplengwee5909 5 ай бұрын

Well said, all those arrested had caused destruction and injuries, same as what other countries would do....so why asked the obvious questions hoping for different answers?

@anguschoi9122 5 ай бұрын

葉劉淑儀說得好！

@COTTONFrank-zg9cq 5 ай бұрын

葉劉淑儀，thank you very much🌹🌹🌹

@eugene9661 5 ай бұрын

謝謝！讓我看清中國的險惡。👍👍👍👍👍👍

@mtlkwan2611 5 ай бұрын

@@eugene9661 早就看清了, 也不需要等到今日.

@kellyy5834 5 ай бұрын

How dare you not letting us meddle in your country’s internal affairs😅

@henryeng668 5 ай бұрын

BBC News reporter ask nonsense question, Hong Kong aways has freedom of protest, but not violent protest, Hong Kong riotes said, "fight for freedom " Hong Kong riotes themselves were against freedom, when people have different express with riotes and riotes use fuel to light up people. HONG KONG riotes violent rebeled from 2018 to 2020 and none riotes shot to death. But in the U.S protest at less shot 6 people to death and many protester put in jail for long term. BBC SHOULD ask U.S why protest go shot, but No in Hong Kong, as you see Hong Kong has more freedom than U.S.

@Edisonchung954 5 ай бұрын

其实叶刘真係答得几好

@YanYanyan-hl2ue 5 ай бұрын

主持多次粗暴打断嘉宾发言极没礼貌，他不是不了解情況，只是明目張胆地扭曲事实，攻擊。看了节目后对其不顾事實的立場与基本礼儀都失望，不过是他的工作罢了，工具人。

@tokaitrading8335 5 ай бұрын

主持人就是要打断被访问者想法嘛， Biased Bullshit broadcasting ( BBC ) 我从 1975 就开始听了它们的谎言 😅😅

@xuemingzeng2094 3 ай бұрын

叶：国安法并没有比uk严格主持人：你们执行国安法肯定有问题。笑死了，没道理的时候就攻击无法证明的执行。香港警察执法能力，人性化在全球拍前三好不好。

@xuemingzeng2094 3 ай бұрын

指责国安法的西方国家从来不敢正面回应为什么西方国家的国安法更严格

@DuSir666 Ай бұрын

盎撒媒体的一贯作风。😂

@WNX276 5 ай бұрын

She said a lot of people supported her. I doubt what “a lot” means here. Why didn’t she advocate holding a referendum in HK to prove it?

@boyansheng7091 5 ай бұрын

当初如果支持她。也不会像今天这样。如果没有像后来的分裂势力捣乱，没有后来泛民的越走越远，说不定都快普选了。大家都是爱国的不分裂。选谁都可以！

@paulwong5798 5 ай бұрын

Unfortunately this host seemed very superficial on nationalsecurity laws in the world in general, the privileges and responsibilities of Democracy, China, US, Aukus, ups and downs in economies....! He's a day to day public layman who is easily swayed by one sided info. BBC and any station, large and small, cannot afford such a low Calibre anchor! A Channel can only earn more following by hiring broadcasters who prepare comprehensively and produce quality shows and not just superficial shows to please the already biased minority readers!

@user-nb9eb9gc9e 5 ай бұрын

他們唯一任務就是反中！😂一個和平穩定發展的中國是他們的威脅？中國強大了，他們再也不能象以前那樣到處開槍開炮了，再也不能去中國搶劫那些古玩寶物了，再也不能去中國設立殖民地了。😂😂😂中國強大了，他們連去非洲搶劫都困難了。😂😂😂

@korris 5 ай бұрын

雞同鴨講。。。TALKING BETWEEN CHICKEN AND DUCK EVEN THOUGH THEY WERE NOT BEING IN THE SAME SPACE.🙃

@zhaoyin590 5 ай бұрын

支持BBC，支持香港，BBC中文的痴汉纪录片太好看了，比美剧还精彩，大家可以去看看

@LafayetteLi 5 ай бұрын

痴汉纪录片是啥

@carl7664 5 ай бұрын

kzbin.info/www/bejne/e3qWaXihq8eZqNUsi=uCzS5zgGsk3IbyUM@@LafayetteLi

@tokaitrading8335 5 ай бұрын

British had never allow Hongkong residents to choose their Chief Executive through democratic manner ? For past 100 years Hongkong Governor was appointed by Britain monarch dictator. After 1997 British trying to dictate , manipulate , enslave and exploit Hongkong using “ fake Democracy “ as context to continue disturb Hongkong peoples , please stop lying through your Bullshit Biased Broadcasting. Are you fooling yourself or are you a moron yourself ?

@tokaitrading8335 5 ай бұрын

这些西方媒体无时无刻想尽办法妖魔化丑化其他国家阴谋就是搞颠覆继续奴化其他人最终目的就是掠夺你们的资源包挂掠夺你的人力资源去发展它们的回家，所谓民主人权只是它们管用的伎俩罢了。只有愚蠢至极又高傲自大狂的笨蛋才会继续被邪恶的昂傻民族摆布与操控。

@chrismok1663 5 ай бұрын

@@LafayetteLi大概是那個調查在日本等多地進行癡漢行為，還拍片並進行販賣的集團，發現那個集團首腦以至骨幹成員都是中國人的紀錄片

@solomonkok1539 5 ай бұрын

Market doing well?

@user-ww5xl8ho7t 5 ай бұрын

The guys know how to twist the questions n answers!!

@ltk4366 5 ай бұрын

姐姐係咪開始做緊「反駁隊」嘅工作 😂😂😂

@KdramaCdramaOST 5 ай бұрын

yup she seems well prepared. her answers are true or not.. we dont know.

@terrytong8665 29 күн бұрын

佢唔做反駁隊仲有咩工作 ?

@MLFY8888 5 ай бұрын

The host is very rude; he always cuts in when his interviewee is talking and does not let her finish her thoughts

@bobevans9996 5 ай бұрын

british colonial master

@uruur4243 5 ай бұрын

有理有据

@gegu2749 5 ай бұрын

一派胡言

@brounlee8458 5 ай бұрын

厚顏無恥

@hjMagic-ud5wx 5 ай бұрын

@@gegu2749要不照搬英国9部国安法😊

@gocolago33 5 ай бұрын

UK and USA talk a lot about free speech but holds Julian assange in maximum prison.

@youtubenil2496 5 ай бұрын

that is full of ridiculous interview, the man Stephen Sackur obviously has bias on question to Ms. Ip. All countries have national security law to protect themselves from other unfriendly act or even seditious behavior, why Hong Kong has this law is a problem? I live in Hong Kong over 50 years, I was sorry to refuse Regina proposed the act of 23 according to basic law in 2002, if the act of 23 has been setup that time then I believe Hong Kong would not have serious offensive problem and damage in 2019, the year apparently has intervention from US and UK.

@prettywoman8888 5 ай бұрын

人長大了，有更多時間去留意世界事態發展，會𢤦得思巧。凡事要客觀兩面睇，沒有全對或全錯，有了立場就有如瞎子摸象。

@user-kw9fk6gi9f 5 ай бұрын

繼續說好香港故事靠反駁隊隊員

@ClaireDeLuneLin 5 ай бұрын

MAY GLORY BE TO HONG KONG.🇭🇰

@andaordos 5 ай бұрын

香港已死

@冰-Cheng 5 ай бұрын

正确，但被殖民前谈不上荣耀！

@kevin_sai 5 ай бұрын

反送中變反政府，一個佳佳就要全港人都有機送大陸的條例變了反政府，真係你講哂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 誰反對就是反國家反對黨😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

@linay9960 5 ай бұрын

What freedom of Speach? Trump- US President had been banded from social media! Give me a break! Double standards! Where is Edward Snowden? What happened to Wikileaks?

@theduck72 5 ай бұрын

Why UK can have NSL and not HK? Hypocrisy by BBSit

@nixcryleon 5 ай бұрын

足够努力了，别人没法比，点赞！

@illuminatiehmful 5 ай бұрын

Good answers to an biased press. Western double standards are very clear. Colonialism is already a thing of the past and won't be back forever. Check the UK security laws and compare it with that of Hongkong before you BARK.

@bobevans9996 5 ай бұрын

hk was never a demoncrazy hk then was colony slave hk now is china - communist master 50yrs agreement was void by the riots funded n trained by cia to mess china n to get tsai ingwen elected - they use propaganda to mess up world they use rohinga ulghur tibet ... rohinga muslims gang raped n killed a burmese buddhist nun that started it all rohinga r not burmese they r bangaladeshi - immigrate back home to bangaladesh ulghur muslims must immigrate back home to turkey don't occupy myanmar n china - where is burmese chinese human rights - it's their home countries - go back to u r own home countries china free tibet of dali lama religious oppression poverty n illiteracy n if china doesn't control tibet india will n the 7 countries downstream from tibet will have to buy water from india - by the drop🤣

@jayji9891 4 ай бұрын

The British invaded China a hundred years ago, leaving behind a mess, yet now they arrogantly criticize China. It's a really ridiculous scene.

@belledgeable 5 ай бұрын

Don’t forget China’s economy was poor in the 80’s, however they have done well since then. China not only improved life of her people but financially they are doing better if not great. Please accept the new kid on the block coming out to compete within the open arena of the world. China has her own rules on how to compete against other countries - that’s “we prospect together”. Certainly HK being a major financial hub, China, like the investment corporations of other countries, can too make used of HK’s international standing.

@Failures_epic 5 ай бұрын

Well china has been using the advantages that Hong Kong have to grow but the development of Hong Kong actually stopped since "reunion" China. I guess Hong Kong could rule itself better without China. If China is really that great, why many people decided to leave when Hong Kong is going back to China's hug.

@cheonglaipeng6241 5 ай бұрын

葉刘淑仪講的非常好，我好敬佩這位香港行政官員。一位星加坡公民

@teren- 5 ай бұрын

Please answer to the questions.

@user-jc6pm7tl9b 4 ай бұрын

i think she answered the questions quite well, especially compared with many so called protesters from HK.

@nandehutu2194 5 ай бұрын

她说苹果日报鼓励人民进行暴力，香港是和平示威，何来的暴力？

@RS-ff1cv 5 ай бұрын

你眼睛瞎了？

@sa2680 5 ай бұрын

Even a Legislative Council (LEGCO) member, Mr. Paul Tse, has been cautioned by the Chief Executive (CE) that he may have potentially violated the national security law. In Hong Kong, nobody can confidently claim innocence under this expansive law, as its boundaries are undefined and its descriptions are imprecise.

@tokaitrading8335 5 ай бұрын

Any local Hongkong resident been appointed as Governor by British queen for past 100 years ??? Don’t lie using fake democracy and fake human rights then utilize “ noble prize “ as bait to deceive others , thank you 😅😅😅

@hjMagic-ud5wx 5 ай бұрын

那我们照搬英国美国的国安法如何😊

@sa2680 5 ай бұрын

@@hjMagic-ud5wx 有3權分立再講，冇制衡乜野法律都可以成為惡法。你話英美國安法更加嚴麻，你試下去華盛頓反拜登，去倫敦反查理斯，再去天安門反習，你睇下邊樣會比人拉，唔好講廢話喇。

@wilsonku3964 5 ай бұрын

@teranyeung 5 ай бұрын

駁嘴隊組長

@shihtzuview7186 4 ай бұрын

She is great and he acts like a dictator of democracy

@derektong2206 5 ай бұрын

You simply can’t wake a person who pretends to be asleep

@mistake2492 5 ай бұрын

建制派出卖良心睁着眼睛说瞎话😅8:20

@aiwong339 5 ай бұрын

"Soft resistance" means you cannot say any things that the government does not like and you will be jailed if doing so.

@jotong9413 5 ай бұрын

我大陆人都看不过眼，软对抗是指，在网上召集大家去整破坏，你说你在美国英国这样去召集看看可以不，早被他们国安人道毁灭了！别那么天真好不……

@wilsonku3964 5 ай бұрын

@vc6327 5 ай бұрын

That’s certainly an overstatement

@aiwong339 5 ай бұрын

@@vc6327 You mean my work is an overstatement?Then, what is the real you think?

@berniethekiwidragon4382 5 ай бұрын

It's not just that. It is anything the government deems it to be. Protesting is now hard resistance, so you restrict yourself to expressing opions. Then, dissent is soft resistance, so you remain silent... until the government says you aren't expressing support, and so are engaging in soft resistance. So you start making some noise... And then the government accuses you again, this time because you weren't making enough noise. Basically, nothing short of the fever-pitch devotion as seen in the Cultural Revolution will suffice in the eyes of the government, eventually. This is incredibly dangerous. This government is NOT fit to rule.

@Bulashite 5 ай бұрын

Democracy？😂freedom of speech ？🤣Why not ask Snowden? Why not ask the Jews？

@dre6229 5 ай бұрын

hardtalk on99

@Pietrofs75 5 ай бұрын

英国有14部国安法律，谈法律严苛程度，英国人会被自己打脸。伦敦警方仅2023年11月的一次支持巴勒斯坦游行就抓捕126人，随后禁止此类游行。英国人自己都明白毫无理由质疑香港立法，这也就是这个主持人总是打断叶女士讲话的原因。不损坏国家利益这是基本要求。黎智英如果真被发现和外国勾结，干预香港事务，那他就该接受惩罚。这不是普通的政治自由问题，勾连外国干预本国本区内政，在哪都该是重罪。

@Wenshengzhai 5 ай бұрын

中国人最狠汉#奸

@thankyouamitabha 5 ай бұрын

你認識英國國安法嗎？起碼他們不會將異見人士逮捕，而且極其尊重群眾遊行示威的權利。市民批評政策和官員，除非涉及恐嚇，否則是永遠不會被請去喝茶的

@Pietrofs75 5 ай бұрын

@@thankyouamitabha 香港就算2019，2022年大乱2年，被起诉的按照这个主持人数据也就是200多人，暴乱期间也没被警察打死过一人。英国呢？英国对付异己：英国国安法的条文，与独裁者无异。根据新生效的英国国安法，英国法院可基于保障国家安全的需要，不进行公开审讯。英国国安法列明，“外国干预”首度被定义为刑事罪。何谓“外国干预”呢？条文中并未有清晰的定义。即是如果你从外国汇款至英国的家人，家人把钱捐款给议员，就有可能被英国国安法入罪。英国国安法还加以限制了对涉案者的人权，在涉案人士缺席、未获通知、未被听取陈述的情况下，内政大臣可以采取预防和调查措施，例如可禁止涉案者离开住所、或强制于某一处所、或禁止某些指定行为，如不可使用电脑、手机等。英国内政大臣的权力，被国安法提升到可以任意禁锢任何涉案人士，以及限制涉案者用电子通讯器材与他人联系。

@Pietrofs75 5 ай бұрын

根据新生效的英国国安法，英国法院可基于保障国家安全的需要，不进行公开审讯。英国国安法列明，“外国干预”首度被定义为刑事罪。何谓“外国干预”呢？条文中并未有清晰的定义。即是如果你从外国汇款至英国的家人，家人把钱捐款给议员，就有可能被英国国安法入罪。英国国安法还加以限制了对涉案者的人权，在涉案人士缺席、未获通知、未被听取陈述的情况下，内政大臣可以采取预防和调查措施，例如可禁止涉案者离开住所、或强制于某一处所、或禁止某些指定行为，如不可使用电脑、手机等。英国内政大臣的权力，被国安法提升到可以任意禁锢任何涉案人士，以及限制涉案者用电子通讯器材与他人联系。英国国安法还特别强化警方的权力。针对外国势力威胁活动，英国警方可采取无证逮捕、羁押等强制措施，检控前羁押可达14天，其间可搜集指纹、DNA及进行测谎，还可限制涉案人士咨询律师。英国警方更可搜查和扣押机密材料，包括机密新闻。英国的警权因国安法的实施，而变得无限大。不单如此，英国警方更可对涉案的个人，施加预防及调查措施，包括禁止旅行、财产交易限制、指定居住地、禁止或限制进入指定区域、使用金融服务、从事某项工作或学习，英国警方可要求涉案者定时报告、约谈、对其作出监视、披露住处和测谎等。

@Pietrofs75 5 ай бұрын

@@thankyouamitabha 香港就算2019,2022年发生暴乱，期间也没被警察打死一人，而被起诉的即便按这个主持人说也就200多人。而光查尔斯三世加冕当日,52名抗议者就被逮捕。这些人在你眼里大概不算政治犯吗？！我们就不提英国人如何镇压北爱尔兰独立人士了！还要数据吗？

@dingli1900 5 ай бұрын

讲的好！

@leungchicheung8311 4 ай бұрын

你做得唔好人民武力推翻你有乜問題？成功嘅就係革命義士，失敗嘅就係叛國暴徒，古今中外每個朝代都係咁，你老共都係咁起家

@aprilwu6521 3 ай бұрын

是啊，最后还是成败论英雄，只是败了也没得说了，古今中外，革命失败也都是被处理了😂😂

@user-dn8sl2td4g 2 ай бұрын

有人拎英國龍獅旗出嚟舞跪求英國收留，咁叫革命真係羞家

@clementcho 5 ай бұрын

She is laughable. I'm sad for people living in HK right now.

@user-yh6kp5mw6r 5 ай бұрын

當香港市民要求民主自由，就等於分裂國家😎Don’t touch her😂😂

@cloudwithwind574 5 ай бұрын

看看你们黄丝的德性，真当别人是傻子？

@snowgame365 5 ай бұрын

當泛民反對「袋住先」時，我就猜到，他們會走到掀翻桌席這一步。在中國美國競爭的背景下，美國會在政治和經濟上或明或暗的做很多事，香港成為了棋子。我還是可惜，如果袋住先，慢慢改進選舉制度，同時壓製住極端的反香港政府或暴力打砸，並證明泛民不會謀求香港獨立，那麼今日香港會更好。

@user-em4yb1lo4v 5 ай бұрын

那是因为你们有些人的mindset中国和民主自由是对立的，于是通过反华乳化来展示自己的政治情绪，但是我的祖国China is democrating though it needs more time to be democrated

@yiquanbeat7703 5 ай бұрын

我个人的感觉是，没有香港人反对民主自由；但是当示威者霸占机场，到后来到处打砸抢烧的时候，破坏香港的法制，就已经不是自由民主了，而是破坏社会分裂国家了。我猜测在那些勇武者眼中，他们做的是正义之事，师出有名；但也有很多香港人，认为民生和法制同样重要，这种毁掉香港而胁迫港府和中央的方法不可取也没有希望。说一个简单的例子，美国国会山事件，最终被定性为叛国。香港立法会被占领，难道不是类似的性质么？

@yiquanbeat7703 5 ай бұрын

@@snowgame365同意，尤其是有天安门事件的前车之鉴，我实在想不出中央会与暴力示威妥协的可能性。我觉得这可能就是学生运动不理性不成熟的一面，他们不会去考虑务实的一面，只是一开始的一腔热血，只想着抗争就好了，但不去想如何结束运动达到自己的目标。最后五大诉求里要求不追究示威者犯下的罪行，更加体现了他们的软弱和没有担当。

@tingli9823 5 ай бұрын

Western people's talk about democracy and freedom is like a 2 headed snake. One head makes pep talk and the other circles around to bite.

@qifee1 5 ай бұрын

Tell me since when, the governor of Hong Kong was elected by its people?

@user-ks9kd3sh2m 5 ай бұрын

After "democratic colonial British" left

@jefflai6077 5 ай бұрын

Democratic and colonial can't be in the sentence.

@jilianghuang8431 5 ай бұрын

你要知道，现在最起码是中国人，不是洋人，洋人干嘛，来香港捞钱。你知道50/70年代的香港吗？蛇鼠一窝

@soeswanto1 5 ай бұрын

I think you need to know more and understand more b4 you can conduct a coherent interview.

@apogatsby5294 5 ай бұрын

她曾经是保安局局长！！保安局局长这个位置权力非常大的！过去真正的实权官员

@jpnmystic5208 5 ай бұрын

對, 想要推23條弄到自己得下台的局長, 對啊

@EmilyYip-ho7xx 5 ай бұрын

😂 I just wonder why the host keep interrupting the interviewee, preventing her to finish her word.

@IshmaelDoe 4 ай бұрын

Where not everyone has the iq to understand basic logic and basic human decency of not supporting CCP, a party which is worst than Nazi.

@guanshengpeng3444 3 ай бұрын

trash words. No audience want to here the same words

@user-jy8es9xb8g Ай бұрын

She is getting better at this. Bravo and you can see that she loves her country and her peoples. This is the kind of politician ❤we need for the country

@feiwong2766 5 ай бұрын

美国冲击国会的判刑了多少人？

@stopfartingplease 5 ай бұрын

中國共產黨判死了多少人？

@alicejlo 5 ай бұрын

Thank you BBC especially credit given to the host who conduct the interview.

@eugenewu2202 5 ай бұрын

I don't trust BBC.

@bnohkerruntouk 5 ай бұрын

Support BBC❤

@Patrick-ze9pc 5 ай бұрын

世界上許多國家已經制定了國家安全法。在維護國家安全方面的專門法律，例如：美國最少有20部[17]，英國最少有9部[18]，澳大利亞最少有4部[19]，加拿大最少有6部[20]，紐西蘭最少有2部[21]，而亞洲國家例如星加坡亦有《內部安全法》[22]。《香港國安法》所規管的罪行亦與其他國家的國家安全法律相近。

@caoeason9102 5 ай бұрын

批评政府在国外不等于分裂国家

@leedavid8941 5 ай бұрын

說謊！香港沒有真正民主選舉

@wilsonku3964 5 ай бұрын

@078percent4 5 ай бұрын

@@caoeason9102

@078percent4 5 ай бұрын

@@caoeason9102 You are right, so there were 100,000 people marching, but the government acted in accordance with the law and only arrested 260 people in the end because they broke the law to split the country and took money from the United Kingdom, the United States, and Taiwan.

@wenou1200 5 ай бұрын

答非所問！

@katechan9206 5 ай бұрын

21 years ago, I was the one of those who walked on the street and say no to the government when it was wanted to push the no.23 law in HK. 21 years later, HK is totally destroyed by CCP government. In fact, the ppl who is work for the government do not care about the international position HK is, they just care how to make the CCP happy and get how much benefit from the CCP. I am the one of the 1600K HKer now living in U.K. Thank you for BBC to report that news and let more ppl understand what is the happen in HK, and how CCP destroyed our home.

@everbeever 5 ай бұрын

That is actually pretty good right. You are finally in your dream land, UK where i hope you can protest like the people in HK did few years ago. I went to Hongkong last month, wasn't too much different than before Covid but more parks and more new buildings, same crowd as before. One thing improved i found is that much better mandarin speaking in the stores.

@oscarwong2464 5 ай бұрын

@@everbeever same crowded？Where did you go？The nights are much quiet than before. Earn the 50 cents from CCP🤣

@youtubenil2496 5 ай бұрын

I believe you are actually destroying our without making sense. You know what is democracy is? In HK just only idoit says yes to this question but nothing detail, like you😂😂

@everbeever 5 ай бұрын

@@oscarwong2464 a lot of places, i was there for 6 days. Sorry i have 2 kids with me no chance to go to the night club area. not sure how many 50 cents can help me buy round trip flight ticket from Dallas to Hongkong for 4 people round trip and stay in the hotel for 6 nights. If you have a way to earn that, i would love to know so that I can afford my wife's $1000+ Chanel makeup for Venlentines.....

@shineluvslambiel 5 ай бұрын

Cope harder little imperialist lap dog

@NgentotLuAnjingLu 5 ай бұрын

BBC : HARDtalk CCTV : CHEAPtalk

@JJ-ye3yr 5 ай бұрын

Off course, because what he said was not true, that’s their way to make up the story, what would expect her to answer? you would rather believe those media instead of your own people? Don’t be naive

@margaretliu3409 5 ай бұрын

Thank youuuuuu Mrs IP!!! 👍👍👏👏👏👏👏💪💪💪💪💪😍😍😍😍😍💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝

@2023tiger 5 ай бұрын

Mind your own UK business, homeless and crimes are f. . Every where.

@bigjik9384 5 ай бұрын

we should thank for Regina's indepth explanations .

@kamlunglam8269 5 ай бұрын

葉劉👍

@IshmaelDoe 4 ай бұрын

認同，十分ｏｎ９

@mrrubymrcapri37 5 ай бұрын

Market is doing really well and Evergrande just busted LMAO

@user-wd8sb7nz1g 5 ай бұрын

这个主持人我记得是反华势力的😂请这个人问问题真的可以保证能客观准确吗？😂

@mtlkwan2611 5 ай бұрын

反華勢力就不客觀，支持中共就是客觀？你們大陸人的邏輯真是奇葩！

@user-wd8sb7nz1g 5 ай бұрын

@@mtlkwan2611 嗯，你的逻辑确实挺奇葩的。第一，我不是大陆人，我同时还会用英语和日语。在一个评论大陆和香港的视频下使用简中可以让更多受众面能看懂我发的内容。你所谓用简体中文的就认定为大陆人又是什么逻辑？第二，我这句话内没说支持任何政党的成分。一个没有任何逻辑性的人在这这跟我说讨论政治并且说我没有逻辑不觉得很搞笑吗？

@Buble12138 5 ай бұрын

@@mtlkwan2611 为什么繁体字人总喜欢非此即彼，反华不客观=挺共客观？比赛只能有输赢不能有平局？你的逻辑才是真的奇葩。

@thomaswang2811 5 ай бұрын

@@user-wd8sb7nz1g中国臭不臭不要紧，共产党万岁就完事了

@owenpkpk 3 ай бұрын

@@user-wd8sb7nz1g所以你覺得支持中共很失禮你嗎😂

@user-mo7vb1sn9q 5 ай бұрын

这位女士在香港很有名气？她在撒谎，内地博客删帖封号很严重，其它平台都一样

@ChrisClark-oi3xy 5 ай бұрын

那是当然啦，你“只能发出正确的、一致的”声音，其它的杂音统统都要被精选被屏蔽，党国的评论区容不下一粒砂子

@dougsilent4341 5 ай бұрын

好像灯塔国不删一样。蠢，川普的号都给封了。

@冰-Cheng 5 ай бұрын

废话，你会让你身上的毒瘤与你自由的共存吗？

@wyz9815 5 ай бұрын

自媒体时代，既可以让人们有更多的渠道去了解世界，让人的视野更加开阔，更容易打破西方媒体的舆论独裁，但另一方面也会更容易建起信息茧房，媒体更容易利用绝大多数人的无知, 思维懒惰，缺乏思辨，容易被情绪煽动的特点，把民众成为乌合之众，变成助纣为虐的力量。舆论宣传可以是激励大众参与社会进步的正面力量也可以成为无形的杀人刀，媒体及媒体人必须被监管和规范！但如何规范，规范原则，界限在哪里，不会引发矛盾和社会冲突的实际操作的方式, 如何引导民众，如何教育大众识别不良舆论的各种话术和逻辑陷阱，如何防范和应对外界敌意的舆论攻击.... 都是新课题！大学应该设立宣传学，尤其要好好研究昂撒洗脑术，要破解它们的宣传攻势，就必须对它们的各种招数了如指掌。有好辩传统的西方人的舆论操纵术之精湛绝伦，之无与伦比，之杀人于无形，是讷言而重行的中国人,还有亚洲人无法想象的! 教育大众才是防范媒体轻易煽动的根本。

@chaochao712 5 ай бұрын

脸书推特INS删帖封号也很严重，就不要五十步笑百步了

5 ай бұрын

駁咀隊長表現好好

@damingchan3840 5 ай бұрын

Let’s thank BBC for providing a platform for Regina to channel what’s truly happening in Hong Kong. A stark contrast of biased, hostile interviewing questions vs fact based, logically layered responses! Bravo Regina! It is a joy to see her debating every time.

@wkwoo5333 5 ай бұрын

well said. so difficult to answer ignorant and deeply biased questions.what does it matter to you, intervening the business in hong kong!mind your own business and take care of your own people first!

@phatc168 5 ай бұрын

Oh well look at Hong Kong now day. Tell it all. Sad.

@SangLe-ju8br 5 ай бұрын

Don’t think the other side of the mountain is greener. Come to San Francisco to take a look, it really tells. Even sad

@modelanswer4466 5 ай бұрын

BBC 這個中文辦公為什麼不容許轉換成英文字幕？能夠更容易理解對話的原意

@kllee9 5 ай бұрын

Regarding freedom of speech, here’s the truth. Recently, some citizens tested the plastic bags designated for garbage levy testing and found that the plastic bags were of poor quality and easily torn. However, the Environmental Protection Department immediately issued a statement, claiming that the test was slanderous and threatening to ask the police to conduct a criminal investigation. The Environmental Protection Department later conducted its own tests on designated plastic bags and came to the same result: plastic bags are easily damaged. Yes, in Hong Kong you have freedom of speech, but the government has the freedom to press charges.

@wilsonku3964 5 ай бұрын

@frankqin2991 5 ай бұрын

Stephen完全带有偏见的态度，粗暴打断受访者的行为，让我异常反感，相反，叶小姐不卑不亢，有理有据的受访态度，让人敬佩

@DK-jz6cn 5 ай бұрын

傻逼粉蛆起来做核酸了😅

@ChrisClark-oi3xy 5 ай бұрын

其实都是拿对己方有利的一面的词语出来讲，所以根本就是你讲你爱讲的，我只管讲我的

@soeswanto1 5 ай бұрын

But who are the people taking to the streets.

@Feu7331 5 ай бұрын

Motherland? 問問香港各高官的子女在那個motherland?

@eugene9661 5 ай бұрын

會講motherland 就讓我笑死了。還一直辯護motherland 多偉大。真是不要臉的女人。自由的地方不會一直把motherland 掛在嘴邊。 Motherland 是要照顧人民，不是強姦人民。

@eeyore345 5 ай бұрын

Even her own daughter is not living in motherland. Shame on her.

@lemonchan2782 5 ай бұрын

✌️✌️💪💪🙏

@tigerwong4307 5 ай бұрын

葉劉淑儀真的是世纪大人才啊，怎么没有选她做特首？太牛了，相信在她的带领下，香港很快可以比肩天津了

@AeoliaStudios 5 ай бұрын

您已经暴露了天津人的基因，把我快笑死了，佩服

@everage7 5 ай бұрын

When we were young, we felt when our motherland was strong, no one would dare to bully us. When we grew up, we realized that no one would dare to help us after our motherland became stronger.

@wanchaihui2661 5 ай бұрын

when we were young, our motherland was weak!!!! now stronger and stronger!

@orchidoutdoor648 5 ай бұрын

The west just don't welcome the fact that China is much more stronger than a lot of them, they can not withstand the fact that they are losing superiority, stay poor and you will have their mercy.

@smliu86 5 ай бұрын

Why do you think you would need the help of foreign countries, when you don't agree with some polices of your motherland? Do you really think it is your motherland, to which you belong and need to find ways to cooperate just like family members. Personally, I think it is this mentality of resorting to foreign help that makes the reconciliation impossible, which is bad for both Chinese central government and Hongkong people.

@sarronsin 5 ай бұрын

@@smliu86你對中國好似無認識喎，香港本土思唯同處事方式，與外國彼此認同咪有計傾，你係未香港人嚟㗎

@KdramaCdramaOST 5 ай бұрын

@@wanchaihui2661 omg u must be pretty old now. 😳😳