XR650 vs DR650 In-depth New Owner Comparison + KLR650 Comparisons

Have you been looking at the three 650cc class dual sport motorcycles and scratching your head? Are they all the same? How are they different? Will your expectations & the specs align? Strap in and we'll test it all on my new 2023 XR650L & 2018 DR650S!
TRANSPARANCY NOTICE: The SWANKY CAT Channel does not accept monetary payments for promoting products. However, we do often accept promotional products for review purposes, in order to provide YOU, the viewer, with our brutality honest opinion!
Links to my gear & parts!
(If you click these and make a purchase on the sites I earn a small commission, which goes towards more videos like this!)
Riding Gear
ADV Helmet: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/ri...
Xplorer Coat: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/ri...
Xplorer Pants: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/ri...
Boots: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/ri...
Base Layer Shirt: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/ri...
Base Layer Pants: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/ri...
Tires
Tusk Waypoint Tires: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/ti...
Tusk D-Sport Tires: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/ti...
Tubes: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/ti...
Bike Parts
Tusk Tank Bag (Large): www.rockymountainatvmc.com/pa...
Bars (Moto Bend): www.rockymountainatvmc.com/pa...
Tusk Risers: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/pa...
Rox Offset Risers: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/pa...
Handguards: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/pa...
Grips: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/pa...
Camera Stuff
Helmet Camera: amzn.to/36BHqdM
Mic (requires adapter or media mod): amzn.to/3qEW4Ia
Hero9 Media Mod: amzn.to/3JLLF4O
Power Bank for GoPro: amzn.to/3iCxanZ
Power Cable: amzn.to/36rxlQT
Helmet Camera Mount: amzn.to/49ls34q
360 Camera: www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08...
360 Selfie Stick: amzn.to/3SOaQK4
Clamps For Holding Selfie Sticks: www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07...
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @swankycatproductions
Buy Me A Beer: paypal.me/SwankyCatBeerMoney
Patreon: / swankycat
T-Shirts & Sweatshirts: teespring.com/stores/swanky-c...
Sources:
DR650 HP/Torque Specs: www.dirtrider.com/story/tests...
XR650 HP/Torque Specs: www.dirtrider.com/tests/honda...
Other Honda XR Specs & Info: powersports.honda.com/motorcy...
Other Suzuki DR650 Specs & Info: suzukicycles.com/dualsport/20...
Stay Swanky my Friends!

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Correction @ 9:00 - The XR, DR, & KLR all have 5 speeds, but the DR & XR* both have a much taller 5th gear than the KLR. Meaning the DR & XR are smoother and more capable at highway speeds.

[@donniebaker5984]

Some day you learn that is much easier to take an XR650R and make it street legal than it will ever be to do what you did by taking an XR650L that's already more than street legal and then make it handle off road as good as an off road bike does naturally .. Especially someone like you who has access to everything to do it with... And probably off the top of your head can name more things and more places than I can doing research to make the necessary mod. In other words I would say in a race to build the best you could win with your knowledge and experience of the subjects because that's what you do.... But I can tell you this the ultimate XR600R of a 1996 model overall is the best Bare Bones racer to put a license plate on first of all it's Bare Bones weight dry is 260 lb that's thing you call an extra l is well over 300 closer to 400 lb I rest my case

[@matthunter1667]

Ehh I have to disagree I can ride my klr 650 at 75mph for a 50-60 mile trip with zero issues I ride my buddies xr like that on the highway and the more motocross style sitting position is crippling and the vibration in the bars at those speeds literally had my hands cramping up within a half an hour... Those klr's are just crazy comfortable and vibrate less when on the freeway in my opinion.

[@slalomking]

I agree with matthunter, the KLR is the best street ride of these three.

[@adv_moto_dan948]

I have a 2018 DR.... 32,000miles. Several trips across country, several BDR's, several states of the TAT. It has NEVER left me stranded. I'd get on it and do it all again without worry. Very reliable bike! I think a good comparison of those bikes are...... XR=60/40 dirt to street..... DR=60/40 street to dirt. Having ridden both bikes fully upgraded..... The DR is by far the better all around bike. I wish that you could ride mine and see the difference between a stock DR and a built DR.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Nice! Yeah, as much as I like the XR, I'd definitely agree that the DR makes way more sense and probably requires less to do way more.

[@davidpaduano753]

Sounds To me like the main issue with the XR is the height, everything else is better. Can't wait to see what happens when you lower it. I'm definitely in the market. I currently have a Pan-America, but the thing is just too heavy to off-road. Looking for something lighter.

[@crypticreality8484]

​@@davidpaduano753the DR-Z 400 is a badass bike

[@stickrudder4332]

Just purchased a new DR. Very happy with it.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Glad to hear that, and not at all surprised!

[@eugenebarron692]

I just purchased a 2024 DR I’m happy with it I’m 57 and well over 300lbs I haven’t had off road bike since my teens, I’ve had several street bikes trying my luck with the duel sports my wife’s not real excited about my decision lol, can’t wait for my concept seat to deliver good comparison video these videos helped me to make my decision.

[@jonpeters5194]

where the DR really excels is in urban environments. It is a great city bike for rough roads, oil cooler for slow speed traffic, handles very well and great visibility being slightly tall.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

100%. The DR would be much more fun in the city, and is definitely better on gravel!

[@andrewdunlop9930]

This is true. I commute with mine and it's great in city traffic and the short stretches of highway I do.

[@user-fk2mp5xh4s]

I watched the ads, in gratitude for all your hard work.

[@colinwiddis8530]

Ive owned a 98 XT 350...KLR 650...WR250R...T700...KLX300, and now having done a BDR and 12,000 kms on my DR 650, i feel its got the most power, yet easy to ride thing going ,out of the bunch. I love the simplicity. I feel its probably the most bullet proof. But they really are all amazing bikes.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I'd, agree. DR is pretty hard to beat!

[@davidl546]

The Best comparison video I've seen in years! You cover some really good points between the two bikes without any loud music drowning you out.

[@tomhengel7244]

Glad to see I'm not the only one that doesn't enjoy the music in a lot of these videos

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Thank you!!! I'm pretty happy with how it turned out as well. It was probably the most fun video I've filmed in a while as well!

[@michiganmoto7687]

Couldn’t agree more! If I want music videos I search for those but motorcycle videos shouldn’t be filled with music. I like the sound of the bike, the hum of the tires, the crunch of gravel and other ambient sounds even if the creator isn’t talking. But if they have a bad mic setup that records nothing but wind noise, forget it, I won’t even watch it.

[@jabawocki9462]

Was about to google the specs of the XR650, and then you had it right there on screen, much appreciated.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

😉 gotcha covered!

[@Eric-Red]

I have the DR650, lots of mods and I really think it can do anything but enduro/hard off road. In my 50's, I think it's be best all around bike you can get.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I'd agree with that!

[@robbieandbeckie]

Yes, except maybe a Gen1 KLR. I have both and love both.

[@pfcokelly]

Where was this video two years ago when i was going back and forth between the two. Great comparison!!!, love my XR and can't wait to see your video on lowering it. 2 years in and I still get uncontrolable laughter on it.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Ha ha oh no! Sorry man! Sounds like your enjoying your XR just as much as I do though 🤣. She's a real beast!!! I kinda can't wait to lower it now!

[@Hanky_Bannist8r]

I have a slightly modded 1994 Xr650L with 12k miles on it. I don't think they've changed alot through the years. Once you "de-smog" them and rejet they're a different machine entirely. I'm 6'1 165 I definitely prefer the taller bike. It all comes down to preference and purpose I think both bikes are great but need upgrades and changes to make them personal. I'm really enjoying this comparison.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I'm glad to hear that! Thanks! Yep I believe they are about the same, and I cannot wait to do a few mods to get some of its originally designed "snap" back!

[@dennismartin1783]

Love my DR. Taken mine some crazy places off road. Takes it all as long as you can! Both are awesome bikes!

[@ArcticJeff]

I really like the 'pop up video' style of this one, Swanky. I hope you incorporate this again on future videos. Tip: I'm sure most folks watch your video's on computers or devices, but if viewed on a TV, the pop-ups can get cut off along the bottom or at the sides due to the overlapping that happens on TV's. They just need to be placed a tad higher and not quite as wide with some of the longer pop-ups. I think you like that XR so much because you are a true dirt-biker at heart.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

A little VH1 through back for ya! Haha. I got started adding a few notes and then couldn't stop! I really like the way it turned out too and I'll definitely do it more often. Works out well since I usually forget important bits of info while riding too lol. I'll definitely make sure they're more reliable on all screens next time though, I appreciate the info!!!

[@dennismccullough638]

I think I’d be leaning dr for sure, for me it’s all about overall practicality. Kind of like a one bike to rule them all. Commuter, gravel, highway, single track. What will do them most in the best ways for the right money.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

100% agree with that, the XR is AWESOME, but not nearly as practical and well rounded as the DR. Makes more sense as a dual sport/ADV bike too since they're a little less high maintenance.

[@swamp033127]

Less high maintenance?🤣🤣🤣 literally the only maintenance I have done on my xr is changing oil and tires.

[@crypticreality8484]

Yea. The bike if you can only afford or have room for one. That's what it is for me and I chose a Suzuki DR-Z 400.

[@tomhengel7244]

Great video just got the dr last night after watching a ton of videos on all kinda bikes of this sort and think I'll enjoy it for the type of riding I'll be doing.. with all the doom and gloom in this world this will be my escape.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Nice! I've always loved dual sports for that. Everything is much more peaceful in the woods!

[@bwnco]

Do a follow up as im flipping coins on which also. Also watched hours! of videos. Im not that experienced either so let us know what you think on the DR

[@mikerichards3248]

Great video! Hope you keep both bikes and keep showing us your experience with them. At the end of the vid with the bikes parked nose to nose, the visual difference was really striking. I want to ride them both!

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Thanks Mike!!! Haha yeah for some reason seeing them on camera like that helps me focus on their individual differences as well. Maybe it's just that slightly lower than eye level vantage point? Shows off their curves a little better maybe? IDK! It sure is fun running them side by side like this! Really glad to hear you're enjoying it as well!

[@insatiable_mind]

Excellent video brother! I love where you’re taking this channel.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Thank you!!!

[@chiptaxfree]

I've been looking forward to this.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Me too!

[@colinwiddis8530]

Currently loving my DR. Have always been interested in the XR. So great to see all the differences. I think the conclusion for me is whatever you end up on, you're going to very happy. Two legendary machines.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Yes, 100%. As different as they are, they both also have a lot in common, and that's all the stuff that makes them so versatile and awesome!

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Hey yall! Thanks for joining me for this experiment. If you're doing some shopping, please consider supporting my content though these affiliate links. It makes a huge difference for us! Rocky Mountain ATV: www.rockymountainatvmc.com/?ref=1042& Amazon Link: amzn.to/3Jfbfkn MotoCampNerd: motocampnerd.com/?ref=rAQ-OX06xBU2aq 10% Off First MotoCamp Purchase Code: SwankyCat

[@toomanytoys09]

Sold my 2019 DR & bought a new leftover "23" XR this year..I go back & forth with lowering it, but ultimately probably wil,l just to make it that much easier to climb on to..Only mods so far are a rack, some Nelson Rigg bags & a handlebar bag to carry some things..Will probably do the foot pegs & front sprocket upgrade real soon, but otherwise just lovin the bike & look forward to putting some miles on it..Nice comparison review..Thanks!

[@cinnreds18]

Dr all the way, if you’re looking for a bike you can live off while riding the BDR (somewhere) light to medium trail work. The engine on the dr runs cooler and “dare I say” form all available evidence lasts longer.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

As much as I like the XR, I don't doubt any of that one bit!

[@scottk.8494]

I have Carmichael bend bars on my DR and XT250. I real like the feeling of that bend on and off road. I also recommend lowered and solid mount pegs on the DR. They're comfortable on the knees, and the feel of shifting improved since the left peg isn't absorbing some off the energy put into shifting. I don't feel anymore vibration with the solid pegs. I installed Zeta solid mounts for my handlebars and that was an improvement also.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Lots of good mod suggestions there, thank you! I felt the same way about the floppy pegs on my KLR, seems like all they do is allow them to move around 🤣

[@caseyf8054]

Great video Ben!

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Thank you!

[@clvrswine]

Another great video.

[@majorlee1]

I have a DR650. I ride with guys that have XR650s. They definitely are not as comfortable as I am on the highway. The DR 75mph all day. With stiffer springs and the carb re jetted going off road I have no issues. The XR is better in dirt and has a bit more dirt oriented power but the DR is more of an all around machine. 👍😎ride on!

[@davidruggles996]

Nice work Ben. I am very excited to see where you go with this series!... And I ride a damn Victory Vision 😂😂😂

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Haha, hey man any bike is a good bike if you can ride it! Glad to hear you're enjoying the videos!!!

[@andrewdunlop9930]

The DR vibration you mention is a funny thing. I find it comes and goes in different conditions on different days. I think temperature may be part of it. But usually it's pretty minimal.

[@DriftlessMoto]

The vibes from the DR are nothing compared to my DRZ. I going to ask my dentist to make me a mouth guard, so my teeth wont rattle out riding the DRZ 🤣

[@justinstiff5641]

I'm literally going to look at these two bikes this morning

[@SwankyCatProductions]

No way! Let me know what you think of them!

[@justinstiff5641]

I'm 6'3 and 300lbs so pretty sure the obvious choice already will be the XR

[@pederhalverson2591]

XR650L all the way!

[@SwankyCatProductions]

She's a BEAST!

[@pederhalverson2591]

@@SwankyCatProductionsAbsolutely!

[@pederhalverson2591]

@@SwankyCatProductions you might want to look at Hemisphere Off-road. They make a bombproof front fork brace for the XR.

[@matthewfrost1657]

I have a 2018 XR, bought new, and it made it 27k miles in three years when it dropped an exhaust valve seat. It hasn't been a priority, so I'm still rebuilding the top end, but had so much fun on it. Did some 350 mile days on the stock seat and lived, haha. Camped off of it a lot, and did singletrack.

[@spacetruckin6555]

2018 DRZ bought new, 35,000 miles on the clock. I've got the top end off of mine too. One day the bike wouldn't start, and a compression test showed 60PSI. The second compression ring was stuck in the groove on the piston and the exhaust valve guides are wore out of spec. Know any good cylinder head people?

[@matthewfrost1657]

@@spacetruckin6555 I bought a new head with the valves installed from crfsonly. There was pitting on the original head, as well as the cam shaft lobes. It was pretty close in cost just to have them assemble new vs rebuilding the original head. Just need to order the cam and put it all together now.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Awesome data point, thank you!!!! Did you have an oil cooler? How often do you change oil? Thank you!!!

[@matthewfrost1657]

@@SwankyCatProductions 2018 Honda XR650L bought 5/9/2020, new in crate. 5/16/20 tusk pannier rack and top rack 5/17/20 wider front sprocket & ricochet skid plate 5/22/20 513 miles, oil & filter, cleaned screen, Honda filter & Pro Honda HP4 10w-40 oil 5/24/20 653 miles adjust valves, all a few thou loose, adjusted to intake 0.004 and exhaust 0.005, installed Clarke 4.7 gal tank 5/31/20 903 miles, UFX front fender 6/29/20 1,924 miles, oil change (same Honda oil from here on our) 6/30/20 1,924 miles, rear tire, Bridgestone trail wing 302 7/9/20 2,719 miles, Oxford heated grips, acerbis hand guards 7/18/20 3,168 miles, JNS engineering LED headlight 7/24/20 3,501 miles, oil & filter 7/27/20 3,659 miles, valves, all about 0.001 loose, adjusted, new rear tire D606 8/19/20 5,000 miles, oil 9/19/20 6,000 miles, front tire, Bridgestone trail wing 10/11/20 6,500 miles, oil & filter 12/29/20 7,791 miles, sprockets & chain, RK520exw-ring 1/1/21 7,811 miles, NGK DPR8EIX-9 spark plug, valves, intake and exhaust were loose 0.001 on right side, oil, new air filter OEM Honda 3/21/21 8,503 miles, tusk D sport adventure rear tire 4/25/21 9,126 miles, cleaned spark arrestor 5/18/21 9,616 miles, oil & filter 7/2/21 10,217 miles, tusk D sport adventure front tire 7/30/21 10,947 miles, oil 9/26/21 12,440 miles, oil & filter, valves left in and ex loose 0.001 10/31/21 13,441 miles, tusk D sport adventure rear 12/4/21 14,169 miles, oil & filter 12/20/21 14,588 miles, pirelli MT21 rallycross front 12/30/21 14,721 miles, air filter Honda OEM, small tail light conversion 2/5/22 15,522 miles, oil 2/25/22 15,931 miles, valves all tight 0.001, spark plug NGK DPR8EIX-9 3/20/22 16,619 miles, chain & sprockets RK520exw-ring, fritzco max spline contact, rear JT steel 3/23/22 16,716 miles, rear brake pads EBC 3/27/22 16,927 miles, oil & filter, front brake pads EBC 5/29/22 18,488 miles, oil 6/4/22 18,738 miles, D606 rear, tried 130 width, Pirelli MT21 front, swapped front wheel from last XR because front wheel bearings had some grit 6/24/22 19,290 miles, rear tail light bulb 6/27/2022 19,395 miles, oil & filter, valves intake both 0.001 loose 7/13/22 20,606 miles, oil & filter, air filter Honda OEM 7/27/22 21,026 miles, new front wheel bearings for original wheel and seals 8/19/22 22,019 miles, oil & filter, cleaned screen 9/30/22 23,572 miles, oil and filter, Denali auxiliary lights 10/8/22 23,810 miles, valves right exhaust tight 0.001 10/10/22 23,869 miles, chain & sprockets same 1/17/23 24,759 miles, pirelli MT21 back on original front wheel 1/29/23 25,016 miles, oil & filter 2/12/23 25,084 miles, D606 on previous XR rear wheel 5/6/23 26,517 miles, oil & filter, spark plug NGK DPR8EIX-9 5/19/23 27,000 miles....loud ticking noise coming from the top end, dropped valve seat.

[@spacetruckin6555]

@@matthewfrost1657 WOW. You"re like my brother, he keeps meticulous notes on his old Pontiacs like that too.

[@johnshropshire3399]

Great video 👍👍

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Thank you!!!

[@theempowermentproject3636]

Put 10k mi on an XT250 before buying my first DR 4 months ago (already put on 2500 mi, having taken a few weeks off for a broken wrist) 😅. The perfect bike for full time life on the road. Yesterday I cruized into town with the trunk box to grab groceries. Today I ripped 40 miles through CO mountain pass dirt/gravel roads. Mikuni carb and slip on exhaust make a big difference from stock. Love the DR. Haven't had the chance to ride an XR yet. Great video, thanks 👍

[@l1qu1dm3t4lIV]

You mentioned, you don't know who would be ripping around on a big thumper. Well, there's a guy in Australia that absolutely rips on his near-stock DR650; he's called Skids n Stuff here on KZbin and his riding on that behemoth can be inspirational, check it out sometime if you ever get down time.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Will do! I'm hoping I can test the limits of mine on some gnarly stuff this summer as well. Should be a good time, I think these bikes are much more capable than a lot of people think!

[@michiganmoto7687]

I love that guys channel. The way he throws his DR over huge logs like it’s a mountain bike makes me feel incredibly inferior 😂😂😂 But it’s a great example of what these bikes are capable of in the right hands. Makes me plenty confident it will do and go anywhere I would ever take it. ✌️

[@dantrimble2495]

Thanks for the gravel comparison. That is mostly what I ride my Klx 300 on. Thinking of getting a 650.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Gravel road cruising is pretty hard to beat! Definitely a nice escape from the busy city streets. I'm pretty excited to try a KLX300 actually! I'd be interested to see how it compares to the DR and XR for that matter!

[@dantrimble2495]

I am no expert but any means. Had the 22 klx300 for a couple years. It is great on gravel. Can pretty much ride it as hard as you want. I did turn the clickers to soften the front forks from the factory setting. Seems to like that softer setup on the grave.

[@colinwiddis8530]

I also loved my KLX 300 it was so easy to ride...perfect seat hight. But the DR just has it beat on highway, with its power. I think you'll Love the DR if you love the KLX

[@johnhigginbotham8317]

I only have experience on my XR 650. Love it. She’s tall. Got mine new this year and have noticed the suspension has kinda worn in. Sits just a bit lower than when brand new. Only about 400 miles mostly rough forestry roads rock to rock rut to rut.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Nice! Yeah it's definitely tall, but sure is fun!

[@MotorcyclesOffroad]

I definitely need to get me an XR650L, I must also ride them back to back. I would have guessed you would have liked the XR more offload, it seems to be more of a big dirtbike. Also with your experience on those 450lb motorcycles would make the XR feel like a dream. I feel like the DR is more of a universal adventure bike, also its much more approachable for many people with the low seat setting.

[@ar1stippus739]

I will probably never give up my gen 1 klr I've got it set up almost perfectly with 12 inches of ground clearance now but man, the more I see you tearing it up on the Xr650 the more I want to buy one

[@bradh74]

I appreciate the comparison video, I believe you did a good job at giving people the info they need to make an informed choice when buying one of these bikes. Thanks for the specs, HP and Torque . The DR still stands out for the bike a guy buys to putt around on the weekend and last for a long time, it's a practical choice, with lower maintainace costs and easy upgrades. The XR has been the more off road capable but for some reason Aussies still chose the DR650. Not sure if you've ridden the DRZ400 but many say it's basically in the same category but more off road capable and nimble. Great video!

[@user-hq7rb5hv7s]

So many bikes...so little time....will be interesting watching the mods. I wish the Honda was still available in Canada. Garth

[@dukegnarley]

I've ridden and modified a DR extensively. Give it an aftermarket muffler to save some weight and open up the air box. Upgrade the suspension, and drop the front sprocket 1 tooth. Replace the handlebars with something closer to a woods bend, lower the pegs. After that it's a great bike. The size of the bike makes it very manageable and easy to live with. Very reliable. It will take you anywhere, but you will sometimes be searching for that non-existent 6th gear.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I've got the bars now, definitely an improvement! Pegs will be next and then eventually performance mods! Probably going to do a fork upgrade at some point too and definitely going to test out a 14 tooth!

[@2007srv]

Hey cool video I've never road any of those bikes only the xr650l and a 84 xl250 I had in 85' . So I don't think you changed the teeth size on front Xr ? thx my 14 is on the way :) .

[@Seeker887]

Had an 02 dr, same time as my 94 xr . Both 650’s . Both great, son inherited dr I’m still enjoying my xr .

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Nice, that's awesome!!!

[@nseric1233]

I've always been a honda guy but at 5'8" I chose the dr650. With a bunch of mods the dr650 is just plain fun. It's hard to keep the front tire on the ground in first gear with a 14 tooth sprocket and jet kit, I'd do those mods asap. After you lower the xr, it's no better off road than the dr and not as good on the road with no cush drive or oil cooler. The rest of the mods I end up doing are the same on both bikes. Bars, pegs, guards, gearing, tires, jetting, I end up doing suspension work on everything because im heavy.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Nice! Yeah, even at my height the XR is a stretch, LITERALLY! I'm pretty excited to see how the DR does with a few free mods and a 14 tooth! I'll bet you right about the XR being lowered too. It's a really cool bike, but the DR is much more practical and better set up to be an adv bike!

[@stephanematis]

My purchase of a well priced 2013 DR fell through today, and now I might first grab a BMW G650 because of circumstances, but I want a DR 650 for long term. I like lighter bikes, like old school dirt bikes, which seems to have become a positive trend among riders of these mid/low-mid do-it-all motorbikes. What always surprises me the most of a "well balanced" motorbike is when I am not reaching for another gear. Love my TW200, but often I'm wanting to shift to 6th that doesn't exist. In the end, riding by sound and vibration alone, is how I grew up and wish I could enable with these larger 50/50-ish bikes. Maybe that is a pipe-dream.

[@underthedrone2735]

You might try to roll the handlebars forward on the DR. I did it on my DRZ and found it felt better. I still want taller bars but it was better until I do that mod.

[@erikeberstein6460]

Love your videos bro keep them up 👍I think u should sell the dr and get a xr650r, and compare the 650r to the 650l

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Thank you!!! Haha maybe some day!

[@2wheels.are.better.than4]

Owned a gen 1, 2005 KLR. It was completely stock, even the doohickey. Put 40k miles on and never had a problem. That being said, prior to this video, I would lean toward the DR, now I’m not so sure. A big plus of the XR, in addition to what you said, is the 18” rear wheel.

[@2007srv]

hey did U replace tires or ? What did U go with , alright man safe rides :)

[@gregweeks4980]

Good job on the review of the DR and the XR. Me, I have a 34 inch inseam and the XR still feels tippy... Turning around. You are correct about the DR stability on dirt and gravel roads, it's strangely amazing. But when the going gets really tough, the XR shines brighter and brighter. I am comfortable taking the XR anywhere I'd take one of my dirt bikes. The DR needs to be geared down and suspension tuned. My DR has the lowered pegs, different handlebars and handlebar risers. I put the warp 9 levers in the clutch and brake position. No more Lucy goosey lovers. You might check this fact because I'm not really sure, but it seems like the XR has less front fork rake than the DR. At least that's how it feels to me. The XR is precise in the trees and sketchy in the gravel. The DR is less precise in the trees and more stable in the gravel. THEY ARE BOTH GREAT FUN! Pick your bike and ride accordingly. Or pick your route and ride the correct bike. I like both of those bikes so much that I have multiples. One XR is stock and the other one is geared lower and suspension mods and power up mods. Not the best for Street riding. I truly enjoy you having both of these bikes and giving them a fair shot and testing them side-by-side... Awesome "Texas on the prairie" with a big grin

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I can definitely see the XR being much better when the going gets rough. Interesting that it's nervous on gravel, but I suppose when you're built for hard woods riding, you don't care about country roads! I believe you are correct about the rake on the forks, the XR has a degree or 2 less angle from what I remember. That angel and the resulting "trail" measurement, are partially why the two behaved so differently both on an off road. That's awesome you've got multiple set ups!!! I'll bet that's cool to see the differences!

[@Nine_883]

Nice job on the video. The DR sounds better for my purposes. I appreciate the info. I looked at and sat on a XR. In the shop I could barely touch the floor. I didn’t ride it. I am more street than dirt. I just go up trails and fire roads. I like the DRZ as well. I had a CRF300 and it was short on power and not very good for much. It was fun cruising the city streets like a scooter, but it’s a very weak motorcycle.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Sounds like the DR will suit you very well! Let me know how you like it!!!

[@Nine_883]

@@SwankyCatProductions I would love to have them all, but I am saving up for the T7 and that is going to be my last bike. I am going to mod the crap out of it and ride it until the day I die. I have a couple of street bikes I can ride when the T7 is being worked over.

[@DriftlessMoto]

I've ridden both bikes and heres some movie references that sum up the XR and DR in my opinion. The XR is like Roddy Piper in They Live. Its here to Kick ass and chew bubble gum and its all out of bubble gum. The DR is the motorcycle version of "The Dude" from Big Lebowski. The DRs motto is "The Dude abides".

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Very well said!!!

[@mikeh.4087]

Look up Skids and Stuff watch him take the DR over logs! I cant do that but the bike can. I have 15000 miles on my DR and love it. It just does what i need really well. I ride it to work or play on trails too. Key word PLAY. im no racer and dont ride that way. One thing i noticed is the cush drive is way too soft for a thumper. I wedged cut out spacers in there from a oil jug to compress the stock rubber spacers. I found that some of that shakey vibes you get at low rpm under loads have gone away and im running solid mount foot pegs. Of course it is a thumper and it is going to have vibes. They dont bother me at all. After stiffening up the forks the braking feels better as well. I really enjoy the bike. I am sure i would have liked the Honda too if that had been what i bought. Have a great day!

[@insatiable_mind]

I look forward the revisit after mods. Lowering the XR is cheap and easily reversible if you don’t like it. I’m curious which you would like better with a lowered XR and upgraded suspension on the DR. I’m still a DR fan but I could be turned.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I can't wait to do that test again after the mods!!! Should be pretty interesting!

[@joellikness2121]

I'm honestly a little surprised at how much better you liked the XR. I figured it would be DR bandwagon all the way. I'm still thinking the bike for me is a DR650 with some suspension mods. I'm "learning" dirt on my DR350, and have been leaning towards a light adv build for it, but the more I see your DR650 vids, the more I think I just need to sell this DR350, get a DR650, and it'll do everything I want it to.

[@fredclow9326]

XR650L is the better bike overall and is more off road oriented than the DR or KLR. Know that the XR Series bike did prove themselves in BAJA racing year after year. That Honda engine is affectionately referred to as the "ANVIL". If a XR is cared for and ridden conservatively 100,000 miles is attainable. I did modify mine into a light ADV and it has camped all across the states.

[@slalomking]

It’s not the same engine, internet myths

[@GlorifyGodInEverything]

"Xr's only" sells plates to delete your smog equipment for the L, makes the bike a lot more responsive (smog equipment is because of california regulations). Taking the baffle out of the exhaust helps a bit as well (regulations forces factory to put little welds on it). You just have to grind through the 2 little welded spots which takes 2 seconds, then your exhaust will be the way it was originally set up, hints the 2 bolts holding the baffle in. It also makes your bike sound like a dirt bike instead of some slave state bike. I believe the "spark arrestor" is built into the center of the muffler, not the baffle and I believe it's the same exhaust type that the xr600r uses. Also dyno jet makes a good stage 1 kit for the carb, this kit also allows you to remove the plug that blocks your mixture screw, which this is another slave state regulation. The xr650L is chained down and choked from factory, when the bike was originally created, it was setup without these restrictions during the build process, and it was built using the xr600r as a performance reference the entire way through. Almost no point in having the 650L unless you put the bike back into its original state of performance it was designed for in my opinion. After these simple fixes, the bike is absolutely awesome. No real work around for the CV carb though lol... Uses vacuum to lift the slider so there will always be a slight delay in throttle response unfortunately until you swap the carb.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Wow, lots of great info there. Thank you!!! I'll definitely look into doing all that at some point, I think I need to see if I can get the DR to have the same amount of take off power first, but after that... I'll bet the XR will be even more of a riot!!!

[@GlorifyGodInEverything]

@@SwankyCatProductions haha that's awesome. Yea man I love your channel. Super cool to watch, i'm glad someone is doing some vlog stuff on these super cool bikes. Keep up the good work man!

[@harryhawk6454]

Hey Swanky, Great Review, really am enjoying your Channel, both of these bikes are on my Radar for the next 🦄Bike, as i am still Riding my T7, Great bike but really too heavy for this old guy to pick up more than once, hope you don't mind if i poke a little fun, Am sure the MSR gear is Great stuff, but the Purple pants remind me of........... maybe Oompa Loompa?😂🤣

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Thank you!!! They're definitely much easier to maneuver than a Tenere, and should be much, much easier to pick up! Haha yeah I suppose they do almost look purple 😅. I think that's just my color grading though lol they're actually blue 🤣

[@chiptaxfree]

Cogent suspension, foot pegs, and handlebars will make that a completely new bike. My buddy had one and I thought it was fantastic after the suspension was done.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I'll bet! I can't wait!!!

[@wudntulike2no32]

When I was choosing an adventure bike the two top choices were the XR and DR. I chose the DR because the seat height was too high and the weight savings were not worth it on the XR.

[@tylermears480]

So its funny because my buddy has the white xr and I have a new dr both modded a bit. I think alot to do with the smoothness especially in the chugginess you were saying is jetting and exhaust. My dr jetted and pipe with 14 tooth front is much happier and smother up hi around 65 70mph then his jetted xr with 14 tooth front. Also throw some grade 8 bolts and washers slightly bigger then the peg bushings and they with be solid. I'm also running pro taper 3/4 riser with 1 1/8 fat bars definitely much nicer feeling. suspension when I have a moment to wrench haha. Great video man ill try to get a video of my dr and brake down

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Oh yeah? Haha that's awesome! Haha. Interesting about the jetting... I suppose a plugged up engine that can't breathe properly wouldn't sound as happy. It'll be interesting to see what happens after a few more mods!

[@tylermears480]

@@SwankyCatProductions procycle is your friend hahah I'm running breath easy kit with better needle on 3 slot with 150 main, lexx slip on wide open with top of air box cut out its completely diffrent animal little pull in third with no clutch it wheelies for days haha

[@smacnee3278]

Sweet

[@someguy325es]

Don’t get caught up trying to make these two bikes the same. They each have their own strengths, so play into those strengths rather than fighting them.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I assume you're referring to lowering the XR? That's definitely a good point and something I'll keep in mind. My main goal when I set out was to see how well I could make both fit my riding style (Everything from Single track to ADV camping mode in the hwy). So I'll see where that takes me, but will do my best not to over do it.

[@evr-mr3cp]

Cheaper to push a cush drive hub on the xr than make the dr suspension work as well as the xr

[@brianrahuba6919]

I keep telling you to check out the DR350s it's such a great bike . If one were to do the suspension, it just might be better than the XL ....

[@user-hu7vt5jp5c]

XR should be lowered to same as DR. Suspension upgrade required but not too firm. Increase tank capacity. XR will be difficult to compare afterwards. Great Video. Very resourceful. Looking forward to next videos.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Thank you!!!

[@packracer515]

You may think of using a GPS for your speed runs. I have a 23 DR650 and have found the GPS shows about a 6-7 mph difference on the slower side than the speedo shows. I was actually running around 53 mph while the bike showed 60 mph.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Is it that far off??? My gen3 KLR was too, until I put a slightly taller rear wheel on it (speed sensor was in the transmission). I'll definitely put some navigation on asap!

[@packracer515]

@@SwankyCatProductions Sadly it was that far off. I've heard as much as 10% difference, which I believe after running the test between the speedo and the GPS on my highway ride home from work. Always wondered why the speedo would say 80 and I was just pacing the traffic and not blowing by them when in reality I was doing between 72-73 mph.

[@nathanthornburg701]

I have a 96 dr350. Favorite bike ive ever ridden. 2nd gear is way more snappy than first and definitely my tallest. I can hit 50 in 2nd.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Wow! I keep getting about the DR350, seems like something I'll have to try!

[@elwood62]

This really is a fantastic comparison video. You hit on all the major points. It still surprises me that the consensus of the KLR being the better road bike isn’t necessarily true. Besides the stock range and wind protection these other two bikes actually perform better? They only come available once in a blue moon, but I think I’ve made up my mind to wait for a new XR. I could literally drive a new KLR or DR home tomorrow, but I’ll wait for what I really want. I can’t believe how much taller the XR is when you see them side by side. Interested to see what else you do with them.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed it and found it helpful! Similar to the KLR, I think the XR is not for everyone, but man it sure puts a smile on my face! Haha, I know! I still can't get over it. Kawasaki got the wind protection and tank size down, and the other guys got the power to weight ratio and transmission right. Got figure! 🙄

[@elwood62]

@@SwankyCatProductions bigger tank and a rally fairing should sort it out.

[@brianrahuba6919]

Don't forget that once you do the suspension, you can raise it by an inch .

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Huh, interesting... It would be neat to make them both the same exact seat height, that'd warrant a whole new comparison video!

[@SCORPi0N5150]

XR650R is the one to have...

[@SwankyCatProductions]

It sure is fun!

[@momoski68]

Ive owned both, on paper the XR wins but in real life I enjoy the DR more. Probably cuz Im an old fart lol

[@duncanwhitcombe4392]

Drop a set of Rycor intimidators into the DR forks . They control the break dive and turn the rod fork into something that behaves like a cartrage fork.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Really? Huh, interesting....

[@JanNaVylete]

Still taking my 1995 yamaha xt600 around the world 🤙😁

[@DieselSniffer3500]

I love my Xr. The only real complaint is how tall 2nd gear is

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I'm really interested to see how I feel about 1st & 2nd gear on my single track and ATV trails. I always felt like I was between the two on my gen2 KLR.

[@markwheat2668]

Got my XR650L used with 15 / 48 gearing with carb, airbox,air filter and desmog. Had bought a 42 t rear! It pulls the higher gear just fine though I'm 5 9 and 150 lbs. It gets a chance to stretch out in each gear.also installed a DG slip on.

[@patriot1294]

The XR650L will go forever if maintained. Bulletproof

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I'm looking forward to it!

[@stubabyfuora5280]

I have had both but didn’t keep DR long, the XR was s great bike, probably should have kept it. I think I may buy another DR in future as my street bike. I have other bikes for dirt and trails and this was where the XR shined. XR is the winner but DR is a pretty bike and great commuter bike, I personally will not ride it off road much if any.

[@brianrahuba6919]

This is tough . Two ironic bikes . I love both of these bikes . But for me, with my money . The XR650L .

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Indeed! Both are awesome, the XR is just such a beautiful beast.

[@brianrahuba6919]

@SwankyCatProductions Put a tune on it . There is more power to have S.C.

[@ftf1987]

Liked my DR, love my XR....but I wanted a dirtbike I could take on the road rather than a road bike I could take in the dirt.

[@javiermartinromo2361]

20 years with my XR650L no issue with CDI box

[@SwankyCatProductions]

No? Glad to hear that!

[@cranedaddy678]

I really considered these two bikes but I think I've decided on the DR-Z 400. Now, I just have to get rid of my KLX 250 and look for a DR-Z!

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Alongside a Strom, I'd say the DRZ is a great option!

[@robbieandbeckie]

DP sintered brake pads and a Warp9 front rotor made the brakes acceptable on the DR

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Nice! Is your Warp9 rotor oversized?

[@robbieandbeckie]

@SwankyCatProductions no it is standard size and is plenty of stopping power for me. Put new fork springs in!!!

[@johnniewade6504]

I need a 2025 xt 500. Is that possible swank. ??? THE klr is killer. Maybe a xt 572 retro ?? I was wheelie KING in 1985. Can I make a come back ?¿?? Thanks swank

[@wildcatoutdoors]

Seat height is the killer for me point blank, DR for the win.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Can't blame you there, my XR almost took me down twice already!

[@user-et5ti3yw2t]

The two motorcycles are a LEGEND STANDING IN 2024, such simple, good, durable and low-maintenance, motorcycles are no longer manufactured like this. I have a DR-650 amazing!

[@Shadow9091]

I want to use your affiliate link on Rocky Mountain, but whenever I click on one of your links, then to the main menu to order the stuff I want, the web address does not show you affiliate info anymore. Does it only apply to the items you have linked?

[@SwankyCatProductions]

When you click on any of my links that say affiliate somewhere in them it will show up for a second and then I believe it does disappear from the address. However, anything you order from that device, I think even hours after, will register as a commission sale. Thanks for checking and helping me to continue making videos!!!

[@Michael-qo8bs]

You had a typo in sub text....said dr650 wheelbase 48.7...actually 58.7 And for a given wheelbase a lower center of mass will make wheelies tougher... But it a good trade...generally lower is better for performance riding.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Ahhh man! Haha thanks for catching that! Yes that seems to be that case!

[@MeasureInGrains]

You're over in that direction...... do you know if SK Service still does the annual swap meet?

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I'm not sure, I think they may have brought it back at some point, but I didn't see anything this year.

[@billcotton1551]

Do they both have counter balanced engines, Ben?

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I'm not sure how that archive the smoothness, but I would assume they must have something similar to the KLR? Just a different design maybe? I'll have to look into it!

[@anthonymalfino1]

Ahh the chub bars

[@SwankyCatProductions]

My favorite!

[@sprancho669]

Great comparison video. A follow up comparison video after mods would be great. Another would be an adventure/ camping ride comparison such as luggage racks, ease of fixing a flat, picking up the bike after you lay it over, etc.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Thank you!!! Will do!

[@randywilliams4325]

Too bad you can’t find a plated xr650r for a test drive . . Very light . Mine had 50hp at the wheel and reved to 9000 rpm

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Ooooooo that sounds like a good time!!!

[@darrylpaterick3108]

I can't set my grips above medium (with gloves) even when the temp is at 0°C or they are too hot.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Ha ha yeah they're definitely impressive!!!

[@davidgraf3537]

What sprocket combo do you have on the xr?

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Still just stock sizes. I only switched the front so far so I'd have a larger spline area. The plan is to test both a 14 and 16 tooth though.

[@mikeschlup5279]

Dr with suspension is my choice...I rode a dr and it rode lighter..

[@Zt3v3]

You should add a 2008 KTM 690 enduro to the mix. You can find a 690 for the same price point, it's a worthy comparison.

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I've got a buddy with a 690! Maybe I'll ask if he wants to go out for a ride!

[@BrianSmith-ql5nj]

Interestingcomparison however a bit skewed comparing a clapped out dr to a new xr🤔

[@SwankyCatProductions]

I kept thinking that too. However, there's only 5,000 miles off. I'd hope you could get that many out of either of them before they deteriorated enough that it would be extremely noticeable.

[@alexmoreno384]

Tuve 3 . XR 600, XR 250 Y CRF 450 X , prefiero siempre una XR. Mi proxima moto va ser una KLR 650 aquí en Argentina están casi 17.000 dolares

[@bobkelly2447]

Another great video ! I think the main reason your butt hurt after the ride on the DR is because you have been on the bikes ALL DAY,,,, of course your butt is gunn'a hurt ! LOL I agree totally with your assessment of the XR's tallness you know me I lowered mine after the first ride ! and I lowered it a full 3 inches not counting the seat that I took off 2" at least ( infact I took off too much foam so my but hurts after an hour on the thing!) but it is alot lower.... I can flat foot it ! the DR is what I wanted to get because of the seat height and the mods on line you can make a DR a wheelie machine ! but sense their basically the same type of engine you can do the same things to the XR ! ... I've done Daves Mod to my bike all except the jet needle....and I think I should do that as well ! I did put on a 15T sprocket on the front ( wider one) which curbs much of the wheelie stuff but cruising at 75~80 mph is not a problem and it doesn't feel like your revving it too high..... I don't know about the Chub bars I just added bar risers to the stock bars and find that quite good enough by the end of the day.... yes I was hunched over with them in their stock set up and I am short !!!!!!! now I can stand comfortably on the XR as well... I have a Supertrapp after market muffler on mine... it's lowder and has a nice note but it's not too loud.... just right actually. I can blip the throttle and the people in cars with their windows rolled up can hear me ! without having to hit my horn ! people just do not look for motorcycles when they drive ! .... the horrible gas mileage on the XR is something I think we will have to get used to ! I have a 4.5gal Clark tank on mine so when it is dry I am well past ready for a stop ! LOL thanks for the comparison ! I think the DR needs suspension work and a major hop up !!!! the XR needs lowered (ALOT) and the Daves Mod and a new muffler ! foot pegs for the both of them... I got some wide and longer ones for mine and it made a big difference ! rubber suspension for the footpegs has no place !!! bolt them to the frame solidly !!! ... I want to see what you do with the high front fender on the XR ! it's ugly and needs to change don't you agree ? LOL

[@SwankyCatProductions]

Agreed, agree, and agreed!!! I think lowering the XR is going to be a must for me. If my seat was slippery, I might be able to deal with it, but I got caught mid seat (where I can't touch well) twice the other day, and couldn't slide over fast enough to get my foot down. Can't believe I didn't drop it... I'm pretty excited to see how lowering the center of gravity will affect the handling too though!

[@bobkelly2447]

@@SwankyCatProductions it will effect it only in a good way....that top heavy feeling of being on stilts will pirty much vanish ! gravel roads will no longer be something that causes a bit of concern...other than having the front wheel wash out on ya ! as LONG as you lower the front as much as you lower the rear there is no change in the steering geometry ....I have the front fork tubes coming up and are about 1/32" from touching the bottom of the handle bars..... with 2" rizers on the bars so they stick up past the tripple trees about 2.5" to 3" but that was necessary to do to keep the steering geometry correct. at first it looked strange but now it's normal to me and i don't notice it at all .....I still have about 8" of ground clearance too !!!.... where you really feel the difference in seat height is on lowering the rear suspension... as I said before I bought the adjustable 1"~2" lowering kit..... it is just a turnbuckle with berring eyes on each end for the bolts to go through it came from china ...I got it off Amazon...( I think I paid $35.00 for it) I am sure you've seen the things.... Termite offroad on youtube had one on his XR650L but took it off..... (big mistake in my book!) people do not realise how important touching the ground is untill they get on a XR650L !!!!!! and touching with the tippie toes is not good enough on the trail when your trying to push the bike back up hill on soft ground....not to mention a non slippery seat and you only remember at the last split second before you fall over.... the bolt on lowering link i bought did indeed lower the bike a long way..... I could touch fine but not flat footed ..so I cut the turnbuckle in half at the base of the threads and welded in a 1/2" piece of steel rod to give it more length...that lowered it a great deal so I had to adjust the turnbuckle back up to get it just right. I bet you'd be fine with the lowering link stock the way it comes ! ....your alot taller than I am... I'm 5'9".....5'10 with my boots on though ! LOL ! and you can take some of the tension out of the monoshock spring for a softer ride !

[@Nobikedave]

The DR is a more well balanced bike sounds like?

[@SwankyCatProductions]

It carries it's weight very low, so that mixed with the geometry of the forks/frame etc. make it feel much much lighter and there for less like it wants to fight you to the ground. The XR, I almost dropped several times already 🤣

[@Nobikedave]

I rode my friends XR, it’s a tall bike! Don’t care for that. My question is how would you compare the road manners between the DR vs T7?

[@johnniewade6504]

Xt 509 With airplane fuel will out preform any Honda