Y'ALL ALREADY FORGOT⁉ Debating Aaron Rodgers or Joe Burrow | First Take

On First Take, Robert Griffin III, Mike Tannenbaum and Bart Scott get into a passionate debate over whether QB Aaron Rodgers or QB Joe Burrow will find more success this upcoming season and well into the future.
✔️Subscribe to ESPN+ espnplus.com/yo...
✔️ Get the ESPN App: www.espn.com/es...
✔️Subscribe to ESPN on KZbin: es.pn/SUBSCRIBE...
✔️ Subscribe to NBA on ESPN on KZbin: bit.ly/SUBSCRIB...
✔️ Watch ESPN on KZbin TV: es.pn/KZbinTV
#ESPN #NFL

[@Crow44music]

Bart is the same guy who said Ravens should put a bounty on Burrow btw

[@TripleG12398]

top tier bias lmao😂😂😂

[@ShinefortheCam]

Facts 😂😂😂

[@TheyCallMeGator]

He's a notorious Bengals hater. 😂😂

[@la7era1u54]

He always has negative opinions about any other team or player in the AFC North, except for the Ravens because he is a super-homer

[@tsmooth213]

Bart Scott is the same guy who said KC wasn’t gonna make the playoff and they ended up winning the SB. This was after they let Tyreek Hill go 😂😂

[@TripleG12398]

fr😂😂😂😂

[@dariusjohnson6013]

Dude is a joke frfr

[@la7era1u54]

Bart Scott is the biggest Ravens homer on the planet. Any time they talk about another AFC North team or player he will always be negative about them. I don't understand why they use him for this

[@michelletrimble4222]

Why ask him anything that has the Bengals involved? Everyone knows he hates them and would never say anything good about them.

[@TheyCallMeGator]

If anybody picks Rodgers over Burrow, you're either biased or don't know sh!t about football. 😂

[@hunterjurgensmier9070]

Wrong

[@TheyCallMeGator]

@@hunterjurgensmier9070 🤣😂🤣

[@randumo24]

Not even close, for one season why not? Burrow is easily the most overrated QB in the league. He has the best weapons in the entire league, he's NOT been good in the playoffs, and he's been injured 3 out of his 4 seasons included going onto the IR in 2 of those years.

[@justadude1065]

@@randumo24you lost all credibility by claiming he’s the “most overrated” people like you have smooth brains or are a burrow hater…usually it’s both.

[@paulkimble6223]

@@randumo24and rodgers played 4 snaps last year

[@grantamdal-barela8756]

Bengals over Jets

[@Thenostolgicdude]

Bart Scott is worse at his job than Kenny Pickett is at his 😂

[@thedude-nf1uf]

Bruh this is the same guy who called for a 'red dot' on burrow cause he beat the ravens. Don't believe me? The videos out there check it put

[@Thenostolgicdude]

@@thedude-nf1uf I know Bart Scott will always pick whatever the opposite of the Bengals choice is

[@Johnny55671]

He is right about what he’s saying.

[@danktunes3618]

Lol

[@juliuspryce8514]

😂 naw son​@@Johnny55671

[@TheyCallMeGator]

Wow... how surprising that the notorious Bengals hater on the panel chooses Rodgers over Burrow. Interesting. 😂

[@Bgizzzle6]

Bart be reaching 😂

[@joshk937]

This is actually one of the very few times I've agreed with RG111. Bart Scott is looking thru his Jets colored lenses and really trying to say a 40 yr old whoever coming off an achilles is better than Joe Burr? He is fugging delusional

[@dariusjohnson6013]

This is why understanding the segment is important. They didn’t ask who’s better they’re asking who has a better upside Aaron Rodgers coming off the Achilles tear or Joe despite him constantly being injured for whatever reason.

[@joshk937]

@@dariusjohnson6013 no they asked who was the better QB, nothing about upside. It was who is going to do better coming off injury last year. I watched it did you? I don't think you did

[@dariusjohnson6013]

@@joshk937 she did not ask who’s better. She said who would you have? It’s like y’all didn’t watch the video lmfao. She never once said who is better. I used the word upside cause they both coming off an injury🤦🏾‍♂️. Comprehending things isn’t your strong suit is it?

[@dariusjohnson6013]

@@joshk937 again cause you obviously suck at paying attention they never asked about who is better the question was who you would rather have🤣😂🤣💯. Thanks for showing us you didn’t watch the video.

[@TheyCallMeGator]

​@dariusjohnson6013 Clearly, you weren't paying attention to what they were talking about. 😂😂

[@Blake-pd3ci]

Bart is soooo bias against Burrow and the bengals since they laid that beat down on his ravens two years ago

[@Ilovewbd]

6:05 RG3 just shredded Bart's "soliloquy" and exposed his deep-rooted hatred for the Bengals.😂

[@davegardner6673]

“Aaron Rodger is the offensive coordinator of the jets.” Yeah, I guess that explains why the jets offense was molasses when Aaron Rodgers went down last year.

[@Etnieskid7]

I love that RG3 called out hater Bart. GET HIM OUT OF HERE!

[@mr.anderson3694]

His achilles felt really good in Egypt.

[@jawill24]

To be fair your feet does feel good in the sand

[@INISPod]

It’s amazing that when ESPN made their major cuts, the people overseeing it really sat back and said “yeah let’s keep Bart Scott” lol

[@milkmanproductions1837]

Joe shiesty always eat

[@DenzelDinero]

Never trust a black man named “Bart”

[@KyleNiccoloGooding]

Lmao

[@TheyCallMeGator]

Never!! 😂😂😂

[@Muzzlecrowe-li9kt]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@Ilovewbd]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@alexgomez4401]

With Burrow's injury history, I don't know if he'll play 14 more years.

[@Martial300]

Hold that up to 40 year old Aaron getting hurt week 1. Injury’s are a wash with these two but burrows been better more recently than A-rod

[@MrRobinson758]

@@Martial300That was an old Rodgers that got hurt in week 1. Burrow is still young and is hurt almost every year.

[@TheCapn23]

We ain't talking about 14 years, just next year. Taking a 40 year old off an achilles injury over Burrow is insane. Not to mention we're talking about the Jets here, they're just cursed as a franchise.

[@TeezyHadaBaby]

I think you forgot that QBs still take less punishment then anyone else, guys have been playing QB for 10 plus years since the 70s…..

[@MikkiChavez]

​@@TheCapn23how is it insane when Burrow can easily get hurt? You fools are trying to make it seem like AR is injury prone lol he's clearly shown he can move just fine. This is a point less topic. What I Burrow doing BETTER than Aaron except throwing to 3 elite WRs

[@DustyBottoms1021]

No secret that Fart Snot is a Bengals hater. He can’t put his emotions aside to give thought out answers.

[@skiena]

The question was "Which QB do you want" not "which team is better." Bart Scott just hears the name of a Bengals player and immediately figures out how to trash them and the team. Useless dude . . .

[@Zachary_35]

What? Bart Scott went against the bengals? No way! No one could’ve guessed this

[@rjv2395]

what a stupid topic.................................

[@TheCapn23]

Media needs to stop treating Rodgers like he's Tom Brady. Brady was a freak of nature, fanatical health nut. He was also focused on football 100% of the time. Rodgers isn't anything like that, he's a washed 40 year old.

[@MattnCam0408]

Brady sucks

[@connieq2811]

90 percent of the media absolutely hates Aaron. What are you even talking about

[@austinbatson1404]

Lmao Aaron Rodgers is a more talented QB plain and simple, Tom Brady had a better team around him more times than not

[@deonterector]

Most of the media were saying Rodgers just has to be better than Zach Wilson in order for the jets to have some success.I haven't heard anyone saying he's going to be Elite.

[@thatstheway2429]

@@austinbatson1404talent is nothing without work ethic and dedication. Aaron Rodgers is a massive waste of talent. Patrick Mahomes is everything Rodgers wishes he could be.

[@richs00n]

this guy really just chose Arod over JoeyBurrr🤦🏾‍♂️🤦🏾‍♂️

[@user-om9bj4rc1g]

Based off skill and injuries most would take Rodgers over Joe B

[@Him813]

What has burrow done other than lose the superbowl….

[@AlexRosner-v8t]

Burrow has much more talent than ridgersv

[@richs00n]

@@user-om9bj4rc1gso you taking a 40 year old that’s coming off an achilles injury on the leg he has to drop back & plant on over a 27 year that’s been to the super bowl recently ??

[@quentinchapman6987]

4x mvp over a guy with zero the fact you tho k it’s crazy is hilarious 😂

[@isadoregonzalez3016]

Whether Bart is right or wrong he is literally always entertaining and hilarious 🤣

[@dqniel1755]

"I can't project that Burrow will win 1 Super Bowl in the next 14 years or so... but I can project that Aaron Rodgers will in the next year or two" Bart Scott is either so dumb or such a troll.

[@rossdiddy29]

How does Bart still have a job there? Lol

[@AntonioTurner-c3e]

The year before last GB receivers led the league in drops. Christian Watson dropped his first play of his career which would’ve been a 70 yard TD

[@qaxcgyujm]

Jordan Loves core wasn't the same core Rodgers had the previous year too. Doubs, Watson and Toure(who was on the bench all year) were the only returning WRs so it wasn't the same core Rodgers had his last year.

[@mathewjones8886]

Last year KC led the league in drops, what's your point?

[@AntonioTurner-c3e]

@@mathewjones8886 so mahomes didn’t have his worst season statistically last year. Had HI’s most INTs and fewest TDs for a full season and his lowest yards.

[@mathewjones8886]

@@AntonioTurner-c3e He did yes but he still turned it on in the post season and led those players to a ring. The difference in approach was startling. Rodgers berated players for mistakes and froze them out of games if they messed up whereas Mahomes backed his teammates and gave them enough chances to redeem themselves and contribute to a SB win. KC won the lot with those circumstances whereas GB missed out on the post season all together.

[@MikkiChavez]

​@@qaxcgyujmthat's literally the same WR core 😂🤦🏾 don't come on here talkin bout 5th & 6th string WRs

[@LeakSpeak]

who writes these questions?

[@Zynsprucker]

Bart Scott eats crayons in the green room

[@notacat7127]

Bruh why yall doing this? Rodger’s is old and broken down and Joe is young and broken down

[@isambo400]

Gotta fluff the NY teams because markets

[@FlixMaker64]

Joe’s not broken down, he had bad luck and the worse offensive line. I don’t hear you or anybody saying Lamar is broken down, he’s been hurt two years too. People are just stupid and don’t know the game.

[@theinflluence]

@@FlixMaker64excuses lmao he’s injury prone let it go my guy lmfao

[@MikkiChavez]

​@@FlixMaker64Rodgers is definitely not broken down then. One injury & now Aaron is injury prone or broken down? But Joe has been injured 3x & will play 14 more years? Or be healthy? He can easily get hurt this year again.

[@notacat7127]

@@FlixMaker64 maybe Joe isn’t broken down but he sure isn’t a new 2024 Nissan kicks with 17 miles on it 😭

[@6gnarkill6]

How is this even a topic?. How do you compare a 40 year old man with a blown out ACL to a mid 20s qb with atleast 12 years left. Of course burrow has more upside. ESPN losing all credibility at this point

[@connieq2811]

The fact that you tried to make a point and don’t know a acl from an Achilles is wild

[@6gnarkill6]

@@connieq2811 the fact you tried to make a point and don’t know the proper use of an or a 🤡

[@connieq2811]

@@6gnarkill6 at least I know what a acl Injury is clown

[@6gnarkill6]

@@connieq2811 I know the difference you mental midget. I legitimately thought he tore his acl. Excuse me for mixing them up and correcting me cuz you are the grammar police. Get a life

[@randumo24]

It's talking about just this season, not about multiple. Burrow also happens to be the most overrated QB in the league.

[@azndude265]

I literally would take tua, dak, and baker over aaron right now. Let alone burrow.

[@neevchopra1215]

Love to here it

[@gabrielgarcia-ru6rb]

🤡

[@TheyCallMeGator]

Hmm... Bart Scott picking Rodgers, how surprising. 😂

[@SC0TTYM00N]

I didn’t realize it was a non contact wrist injury for Burrow. That’s rough.

[@Thewhiteclawoutlaw]

Agree with Bart all the way, if I’m picking a qb for this season it’s gonna be the guy who has a huge chip on his shoulder/the best thrower the league has ever seen

[@traytonerickson-paul4042]

celtics shaq

[@dft1]

mahomes is best thrower. rodgers gets hurt again

[@Martial300]

Rodger’s does not care about football he just wants the spotlight

[@alexmalt]

Yeah. Exactly. Burrow.

[@6gnarkill6]

Stupid people usually do agree with each other

[@Trizmonsta_of_Philly]

But wasn’t Rodger’s wideouts under performing because he didn’t practice with them 😒😏

[@TripleG12398]

😂

[@hrahal7]

When I see Bart Scott I immediately prepare myself to not take anything seriously

[@MattitudeMr15]

BART Scott roasted himself the moment he said the jets have to deal with such n such forgetting burrows is in the same division 😂

[@oz6893]

How does Bart Scott even have a job. What is wrong with you ESPN... are you guys that desperate for click bait you have to keep him around? I'm surprised he didn't say chiefs aren't going to make the playoffs this year again.... get this guy off the screen

[@jasonlarson9886]

The Jets roster is better, minus the OL, we’ll see, but the upside absolutely has to be in Burrow’s favor. Young, smart, great arm talent.

[@randumo24]

The Bengals could easily finish last in the AFC North without even underachieving. The Jets definitely have a better shot at winning a Super Bowl simply because of being in a weaker division whereas the Bengals play in the best division in the entire league. The Browns simply have a top 5 roster in the league. If Watson plays anything resembling a top 10 QB, they could be the best team in the league. We already know how good the Ravens are, that's a given. Both of those teams beat up on the Bengals head-to-head. The Steelers could actually get good QB play this year as well if Wilson gets back to form, so really the Bengals being anywhere near favorites to win the division is just ignoring how talented the division is.

[@trevorcoster2780]

Burrow has had 2 season ending injuries in 4 years Rodgers has had 2 in 16. How does nobody talk about this

[@MeloMVP100]

One is 40 and one is 27… 🤣🤣

[@hatchatarecker258]

Here comes Mr. Potato Head with another "hot take"

[@KinGxLos]

RG3 funko collection is wild, and I see you with dbz/dbs figures 👀

[@hypersonicshinylucky7525]

To be honest rodgers i think should retire.

[@la7era1u54]

Bart Scott is the biggest Ravens homer on the planet. Any time they talk about another AFC North team or player he will always be negative about them. I don't understand why they use him for this

[@GmmThLT]

How does Bart have a job? Dude always has the worst takes.

[@Relayer6a]

Aaron thinks he's cute throwing the trip to Egypt in there.

[@TheCapn23]

Scorched earth Aaron Rodgers? He skipped mandatory practice for a vacation to Egypt. If he was going 'scorched earth' it'd be 100% focus on football, not all these extracurriculars.

[@chadh.johnson3550]

So you really believe missing 2 practices in June is the end of the world?

[@mrawesomexyz]

It's not a debate show unless you got somebody who takes each side. But couldn't they take better questions than Burrow, a bona-fide top 5 QB, vs Rodgers, who hasn't had a 300 yard game since 2021

[@robertmclean3612]

Anyone who says Rodgers is having a laugh he’s got 1-2 seasons left at most . Borrow has 10 plus injury’s aside

[@Palekana5252]

BART Scott is terrible he is always wrong and always goes off track 🤦🏽‍♂️

[@Lockettnextdoor]

Bart just said Mahomes is Jordan & will prevent everyone from winning but somehow Aaron is going to steal one like the Pistons?? Get em off the air! 😆

[@MikkiChavez]

What's the problem?

[@darchocolate31]

People, for the love of god, let it go with Rodgers already. His last good season was 3 years ago AND he is coming of an achiles tear.

[@Wowowowowowowowowowowowow]

I mean I’d take a prime healthy Rodgers over the best Ive seen from Burrow. So the question is whether or not we think Rodgers can still be that guy. If it’s a going forward question it’s just obvious Burrow based on age alone. Even if Burrow only plays every other season due to injury.

[@HarrySatchelWhatsThatSmell]

Ok, Aaron. The Achilles is good. But what about the toe?

[@TripleG12398]

😂😂😂

[@billmurray4739]

BART is just a hater. Plain and simple

[@Kingmcnastylive]

BART getting fire in real life if he was a coach. If there was AR and Joey. To choose from and he choose AR. The GM getting him outta there.

[@tiberius677]

doesn't matter what it's about, Bart Scott would never pick anyone from the Bengals.

[@Jadkin69]

Both have playoff success

[@teamtakeover7317]

Ummmm Rodgers lasted 5 snaps last season. 4 football snaps and one Achilles snap.

[@thetruth3498]

y’all are forgetting burrow led his team to the super bowl in his first full season with a rookie wr. they only lost the SB because they decided to have Eli Apple cover Cooper Kupp

[@davidabbott1951]

Sh*tty phantom holding call against Logan Wilson was the difference.

[@jmanknows]

RG3 has to be a regular one First Take (just my opinion)

[@Truely28th]

Bart loves hating on Joey B 😆😆😆

[@lacarlomoore7121]

NYJ 7-10 all them will be gone by nxt yr😂guaranteed!!!

[@jakovkid07]

BART SCOTT will NEVER give the Bengals an ounce or credit or recognition.

[@devlincollins267]

Brett Farve left Aaron Rodgers a gift too if yaw going that far. But either Rodgers isn't doing nothing this season nor the playoffs.

[@deonterector]

Not a diss to Rodgers but he did hand the Packers a 3rd place schedule.

[@qaxcgyujm]

The WR core wasn't the same though last year, only carry overs from Rodgers final season were Doubs and Watson so Bart's actually inaccurate with that take. Jordan Love dealt with more rookies than Rodgers did and had the best year for a first year starter in Packers History. There's a reason their average age was so young it's because they completely turned over their offense besides the RB room and a portion of their offensive line.

[@tybeckham8098]

Great debate for Bart!

[@beardedtankgaming7630]

Bart has been sore ever since the Joey B put up 525 on the ravens

[@TripleG12398]

that's exactly what I said🤣

[@erek_awesome]

First Take is the male equivalent of The View 😂😂

[@heata4299]

It's not impossible that Aaron Rodgers has a great season. The odd's are better for Joe Burrow because he is 27 and his was a wrist compared to an achilles. I think the rosters between the 2 teams are pretty close in terms of talent. Bengals might be better on offense to the Jets having a better defense.

[@briangreenwood2386]

I'd be worried about Burrows wrist. If he's healthy obviously he's the pick over Rodgers. Idk if Arod is even good anymore at this point

[@swoesteban5570]

Spoken like a true Raven.

[@TheTippitytop]

Shady Red Dot Bart Scott

[@bigshys]

ALREADY KNOW BART GONNA BE BIAS AGAINST JB.... U GOTTA KEEP IT REAL SOMETIMES

[@MailmanAssassin]

This seems like one of those arguments where borh answers are correct. Its Rodger or Burrow

[@Fhill4801]

Washed QB + Worst OC in the NFL = disaster

[@MHBTeleVision]

Bart Scott hate Burrow. He'd pick a middle school quarterback over Burrow..

[@officialdonho]

Burrow

[@FrstPlyrShtr]

He said Burrow can do anything ARod can do 😂😂. Rodgers arm, accuracy, and ball protection is unprecedented. FOH 😂😂😂

[@not_from_here1972]

Facts

[@TripleG12398]

burrow has the highest completion percentage out of any quarterback in NFL history to throw 1,500 pass attempts. not to mention, aaron rodgers is 40 years old and burrow is 27 years old. at this point in their careers, burrow is the better passer and burrow probably hasn't reached his peak yet.

[@THEROOSTER92420]

Bart Scott just stays a clown I guess 🤡 😅😂

[@TripleG12398]

fr😂

[@ogbigblunts7280]

Bring the blonde back n replace Molly this how you control the conversation lol

[@rayzailzeno9164]

Based on the injuries this past season nd age I got burrow now if they was healthy healthy there serious comp there idk wah but sumn 😂

[@YT69542]

Aaron Rodgers gets too much credit for someone that hasn’t been winning playoff games

[@jamesbeachem2003]

Rodgers will not be considered one of the greatest unless he wins more SBs. I don't know if Burrow will win a SB, he has already met the quota of Bengals great QBs of last 50 years(one SB appearance and loss).

[@GrizzlyAlpha06]

Legendary glazing going on in this video…

[@legitdragon6202]

Both overrated to an extent right now. Many have Burrow as a top 2 or 3 based on beating Mahomes in playoff THREE SEASONS AGO. Guy is a constant injury risk. Rodgers we haven't seen play with the Jets. The Jets are still the Jets and a lot of the commentary has even been 'he doesn't have to be special for Jets to compete', but the Jets find ways to screw things up. It's been a few seasons since we've seen Aaron be elite, way too many people brush off time and act like he's still prime Rodgers.

[@bmess55]

Burrow is easily 2

[@rockallday0]

Who do you have #2 so we could all laugh?

[@Thenostolgicdude]

How many current starting quarterbacks have won a championship game and been to the Superbowl? After Mahomes it's only burrow, Rodgers, Russell Wilson, Mathew Stafford, jarred Geoff, Jalen hurts and Brock purdy.Rodgers, Wilson and Stafford are on their way out and hurts and purdy aren't better. I actually like Geoff and think he's underrated but he isn't better than burrow.

[@GMQuay]

Burrow is top 3 bro name 2 QBs better than him.

[@legitdragon6202]

I'd have Allen, has flaws certainly, but can't say he misses time or starts slow every year bc he's usually injured right out the gate. Also had played well in playoffs. Also, with Bengals paying Burrow and soon having to pay Chase, we're going to find out how much that team is going to fall off. That's why Bengals are clinging to dear life to Tee Higgins and lying about a long term deal. If they were smart they would have traded Higgins for peak value a couple seasons ago and kept building team around, Burrow should be able to make it work without him, right? Realize last part was a bit of a tangent, but if Bengals presumably are about to decline due to paying Chase and Burrow - we'll see what Burrow can do when he isn't on that rookie contract anymore and has to make things work.

[@malikxshabazz443]

Boy Rg3 gone keep them braids..I swear

[@Runmindrun]

What kind of dumbaxx question is this? This is exactly why I only watch ESPN when live sports are on. Smh.

[@paulbyrnes4242]

I WOULD DEFINITELY GO WITH JOE BURROW # 9

[@nofumbles]

💀💀Mike t brought up Jordan love with the same receiving core

[@austinp9348]

Who has more upside an under 25 qb or a 40 year old qb? Really? ESPN isn’t even trying anymore.

[@ethanpleiman5320]

Bart Scott is either insanely bias or insanely delusional

[@brianmeeker3058]

Jake browning for 1st and 2nd quarters.....joe b for 3rd and 4th quarters....end of story...each dude play 9 games....superbowl or bust

[@raiderz4life50]

Aaron Rodgers to the Raiders 🤔🏆 🔥🔥💯🏴‍☠️

[@YourHighness716]

Did Bart say a weak afc east ??? I know he didn’t fix his lips to say that !!!

[@legitdragon6202]

It is though

[@YourHighness716]

@@legitdragon6202 THE BILLS OWN THE AFC EAST !!!! Period !!! Old Aaron is doing nothing , the dolphins are trash , the patriots .. well lmaoooo … so I guess , I can agree that the division is weak

[@the1rooster1]

'Weakened.' I think he's referring to the loss of Diggs in Buffalo and Belichek leaving.

[@Kamisama23]

Did the dolphins and bills get weaker?

[@YourHighness716]

@@Kamisama23 Please tell me how the bills got weaker ??? Losing diggs ?? Poyer ?? Trey white ??? One thing about the bills ,they draft great !!! And Hyde maybe coming back sometime this season , the bills got stronger !!!!

[@Muricans1776]

A Aron will be good, RB, WR, TE, OL all good enough… Defense Great… Saleh and Hackett Bottom 5 in NFL.

[@clintwarner3008]

This shits funny...I cud care less, but they act like Rodgers forgot how to throw the football.