Yi 4K+ 4K/60fps Action Camera vs GoPro Hero 5 Black vs Sony FDR X3000 - In-depth Review [4K]

[@TonyAndChelsea]

Best review! We've been using the new Yi for a couple of weeks and I agree with everything you said, esp. regarding the screen, battery life, USB-C port cover. Despite the weaknesses, our A-cameras are now GH5s @ 4K/60p & the Yi 4K+ will definitely integrate better than dropping the framerate. Even at 30p, we love stretching video to 2x slo-mo for some cheap drama. Thanks again!

[@iPhonedo]

Thank you so much for this comment :) I'm very impressed with the fact that it didn't overheat. The quad-core Ambarella H2 is a great processor. I'm not sure why it didn't have slo-mo features like 1080p 180fps or 720p at 300fps because I'm sure it can deliver it.

[@ceprowow]

Used sensor IMX377 support maximum frame rate at 1080p - 120fps. (Spec from Sony website)

[@RA-yp2qt]

what's the title backsound from 4:05 to 7:00???

[@dagg497]

yay Tony & Chelsea!! Watched every episode of yours for a year. You lost me a little bit when you went for the the gray background studio and when tony looks so bronze orange from the color grading. And it was more fun when you and Chelsea were drinking wine together in the videos.

[@dagg497]

Tony & Chelsea and iPhonedo! You should get the Airdog ADii instead of your other DJI drones. I'm gonna get it and hack that cradle to house the FDR-X3000 :-) I also did alot of research and the Typhoons and GoPro karma is not a good replacement for the DJi. Maybe if i go DJI phantom 2 with the FDR-X3000 and a video link like the Boscam FPV video link system. Not for your prowork but for vlogging your trips. I just don't want to sponsor DJI with their damn battery and accessory pricing!

[@DeeLuxist]

I feel like "the door keeps opening like my ex's legs" isn't getting the laughs it should of 👏🏻

[@rockjano]

I just loved that sentence!!!!!! I was laughing loud! I subscribed...

[@vitalogypj]

I almost pee'd myself to that LMAO

[@rolo_061]

HAHAHAHA

[@danielloureiro2114]

Subscribed immediately after hearing that joke!!!!

[@KevinLe]

OMG YESSSSS!!! That was such a good line!

[@nswbodyboarding6671]

From 7:58 - 8:14 the background looks amazing!

[@Gorkab]

So you praise Sony's 3.5mm jack input but don't even try a USB-C to Jack 3.5mm that can do the same? You measure Yi's 4K/60 mode against 4K/30 modes of Sony's and GoPro's, and declare Yi dies first (obviously)? And finally, you don't even mention the prices?! The Sony is great alright, but it's price is DOUBLE the Yi 4K+… Talk about a fair review…

[@RangerAmateur]

I think you mistaken the Yi 4k price.. Yi 4k+ is $339

[@dashofawesome64]

Judson Zhao It's 170 in euro's. So yea that is not close at all.

[@jogijsegom981]

errr no it's not... the Yi 4K is but not the Yi 4K+

[@luckyluke97223]

Agreed.. A review from a pro-GoPro.. Personnally I prefer the Yi and enjoy the end of an imperialism..

[@GregHutto1]

i bought my sony for 329 on amazon as i already have the accessories....

[@maxcenevil]

you didn't talk about the fact that you can add external microphone to the Yi 4K Plus

[@DJJS7]

Discovered this channel last month and quickly became an instant favorite!

[@lukehero]

7:55 still using the GH5?

[@MrCristopher99]

exactly my thoughts :DDD

[@lukehero]

He's holding the rig (can be seen at 8:03), so it must be some other camera. The RX100 V wouldn't make that mistake.

[@TH4RG3]

He did mean GoPro Hero 5, he meant Panasonic GH5!

[@lukehero]

Yeah that's the camera I was referring to, the Panasonic. I see now how that could be confused as the (G)opro (H)ero 5 though.

[@knightwolf8877]

Yeh why the focusing issues? Is this the new Sony he got?

[@ifirexx5673]

As usual, appreciate the relevant comparisons. And the subtle humor...

[@udoheinl]

With the YI 4k + both with the recordings as well as the handling of the camera I was very satisfied. Annoyed me however the very difficult editing of the clips in the video cut program. To work well with it you need a very fast PC. The clips of the X3000 are easier to edit. This was my reason for testing the X3000. I have made many comparisons with both cameras. Also I have for my DJI Osmo Mobile for both the Sony X3000 and the YI 4k + adapter built. Both cameras work very well with the Osmo Mobile. With the exception of low-light recording, the X3000 in my opinion, not better than the YI 4k + When using the remote control via the iPhone, the video display on the display is not fluid. Every 2 seconds there is a dropout of about 0.5 seconds. This is very disturbing. I have now decided for the YI 4k +. Essential arguments compared to the Sony FDR-X3000 are the following in my opinion: - The YI 4k + is much easier to use - Easier and clearer in the setting of the parameters - offers more possibilities besides the normal film recordings (Time Lapse Video, Slow Motion, Time Lapse Photo, etc. - more settings for shutter, ISO, etc. - a very good working EIS (up to 4k 30p), almost as good as B.O.S.S. The X3000 -. Also very good adjustment of the lens distortion up to 4k 30p - 4k 60p - The housing design of the YI 4k + and the size are more suitable for me - the preparation of the camera up to the time of the recording takes longer with the X3000, I need 2 parts, the camera and the remote control - the display of the YI 4k + has a higher resolution than the remote control of the X3000 The disadvantage of the more difficult video processing of the clips I accept

[@streetthugza2531]

Jeez, This is the best review of anything I have ever seen. Well done

[@mryorkielover]

Great video. You are very entertaining. Keep up the good work bro

[@kvn2266]

Another great video man, thank you! Cheers from NYC!

[@JochyEstrella]

You’re the best, detailed and funny ... instant subscriber!

[@Swswimmop-7688]

your reviews are the best! enjoyed it!

[@karuneshkaushal]

which one is best

[@LionPlush]

Can you make a footage with Yi4K+ with different framerate? Very interest to see bitrate and details of 30, 60, 120, 240 fps. May be with compare Sony X3000

[@zoti]

Tell us more about your Ex's legs.

[@vitalogypj]

haha XD

[@leonwrch]

wrong website bro

[@noface24]

I can tell you....

[@agoniavr]

7:46 actually the Yi lasts WAY longer as pointed out in any review! For someone like you recording 4K/60fps only on the Yi and claiming itlasts less is quite a noobish mistake...should fix that with a note or something, in 4K/60fps and 1080/60fps the Yi lasts more!

[@eon5]

plus what matters is the picture quality, to my eye the yi is sharper than gopro and has much better image stabilisation. Saying that it is a worse camera because of the port cover being a bit loose is quite a BS argument.

[@agoniavr]

What's the video in the intro at 00:41 where it shows the bridge and water picture and its post production?

[@valentingochev8195]

Very thorough review, some humor thrown in too, thanks for the great video! Learned what I needed from it.

[@DrDronez]

Yi has just responded to my latest support ticket informing me that it will now be a 3rd month until we see Live Streaming which they boasted as a feature of the Yi 4k plus. this is the second full month delay. I don't think owners are going to see this feature anytime soon.

[@DanielTanacsTNX]

Man, you are the best on youtube. Period.

[@ClimbingTV]

Hello, great video. Can you tell me which settings are you recommending on yi 4k+ for lowlight? My lowlight videos are grainy. What settings are you using and why (specially metering mode, shutter speed, wb, iso, color) Thank you!

[@zentet3738]

Your my favorite tech reviewer...your style is very different and puts a smile on my face. Very informational too.

[@Todd.P]

How long does the battery last on the X3000? Also, is there any way to connect the view screen to the X3000, or do you have to carry around 2 things? Thanks!

[@vidualisefilms745]

x3000 is great. Battery life is around 2 hours, but I have 2 extra batteries for it with me. View screen connects to the grip, very nicely!

[@WORTHITORNOT]

I'm so glad I passed on the Yi 4k+. Love my Sony FDR-X3000. Thanks for the review.

[@freddylooger7320]

WORTH IT OR NOT? Its the only 60fps 4K camera, though.

[@WORTHITORNOT]

Freddy Looger : Yes it is but as you saw from his review that's not always a plus.

[@RichardsWorld]

I just got it and I'm quite happy with it and I don't have that door problem. If you don't care about 4K 60fps, then the Sony would be OK if you don't mind the shape of it. I bought it so I can add a 4K 60fps camera to my travel gear list.

[@limasami]

From what i saw, Yi is much better, but not from what he said..

[@MuahMan]

Glad someone said something about the shape of the Sony. I have the 1000 and the 3000 and I love the video but the shape sucks and makes it stick out and harder to use.

[@MrF1dget]

Hey. And what do you know about the new gopro? And when will it be released?

[@odesoftami]

можно ли эту камеру использовать в автомобиле ? вместо YI DVR пишет ли она покругу на карту памяти ?

[@josh8490]

You earned a new subscriber. Loved this video full of details and very comical. Good job

[@comment.highlighted]

Great review. Very entertaining all the way through 👽

[@avinashmurthy9437]

What did you shoot this on ? I'm guessing a Sony because I didn't even bother trying to focus from 7:45.

[@mystarsandplanets3164]

This was by far the best review for this Camera! Going to have to go buy one now!

[@HomesteadExpert]

Dude, you are really good! Thanks for the great reviews!

[@rilverado101980]

I've followed​ iPhonedo for a while and watch his channel videos even when it's something I have no plan to buy or even try. He's just very entertaining and comical and tells it how it is, without selling out. Great job again

[@seanPar]

I feel the same Jon. Watching other websites reviews on this sort of stuff it just seems odd sometimes. I watched a video review of these three camera on some video website and the guy literally said "if picture quality, image stabilization and stabilized at 4k isn't what you need then get the hero 5 black....." What? Really, why wouldn't you want that in your camera. Love this website.

[@MultiKatrin26]

Did somebody used or tested the external microphone on the YI 4K+ already?! And what microphone would be best for it?

[@timnevellphotography]

I purchased Yi 4K+ just from watching your NAB vlog - testing it in the Maldives in a few weeks time, but 60fps & 135mbps was my reasons behind the purchase, especially when editing with PP 2017, the flat colour profile with no sharpening is better than GoPro IMOA. Thanks for the continued great channel, Im sure the missus has tuned you up since this vlog :)

[@willtran6624]

Nice review. Very concise and thorough. You filming Griffith has me itching to book another flight to LA. Thanks for sharing.

[@MaidenKostas]

I find your points invalid a little bit. Yi 4K+ is a GoPro killer. Here is why: You din't like the Yis' screen but you didn't bother that the Sony doesn't even have one and for the GoPros' screen many users say that the touch isn't working properly many times. You didn't like too much the Yis' stabilization but GoPro doesn't even have one, so is useless without a gyro gimbal. The internal mic on all of them isn't excellent for a really good video result, an external mic is necessary anyway. So the Yi 4K+ looks fully featured than the others to me. Golden ratio with less money. For the usb cover I have no words, it's not a point to be worst camera.

[@camranh_royal]

If you wanna look and feel like a Pro' go for the good brands, but if you wanna feel and look cheap always go for the chinese brands. Let's be honest but there is always a down side with chinese "cheaper" brands.. Stolen tech, cut corners, spying software, bad user interfaces._+

[@vegasstacker3857]

@@camranh_royal Stolen tech lol, don't you think GoPro would have sued their ass off for that? Why is it still on Amazon? Stop reading the "fake" news. LOL

[@metatron2332]

you are the best! thumbs up! yi can do medium fov without loosing quality by 4k 30p right? sonetines the wideangle is too much for me so that would be great if medium fov can be enabled in 4k by the 4k+

[@JohnChereson]

Informative & Entertaining Great Video!!

[@hkknd.digital]

Another great review...i like it! Greetings from Germany!

[@kamakazitv574]

what's your take on the fitfort action camera. Just bought it off of Amazon for 67$$.

[@yellowsuzuki06]

I have an older custom quad that has a gopro gimble that does not work with gopro 5.. how does it compare size and weight to a hero 4?

[@Brazord]

Best tech reviews on the internet! Lol also so funny! I love that guy!!

[@gbarb18]

What is your main camera? It seems like focus was struggling.

[@eeeericlin]

Have you try the "raw mode" of yi4k plus? Thx

[@leelemon007]

Love your work! I am looking for an action cam can’t decide between gopro 5 /sonyfdr x3000/and the YI 4k+. There does not seem to be any youtube videos comparing the cameras from DJI Phantom/ Mavic COMPARED to the top action cameras? What is your opinion of comparison? Which action camera would complement my fleet of drones (phantoms and Mavic)

[@declantiberiuskelly1263]

I really like your blogs. Your funny in a good way.

[@m4ryou5h]

thank you for that, great video, great comparison

[@ThisIsTenou]

Hey, I would absolutely love to see a comparison between the 4K+, FDR-X3000 and Garmin Virb 30. At daylight AND especially at low light conditions. Please. I don't have the money to buy all three of them and try them out myself

[@udoheinl]

Very well done the comparison. I chose the YI 4k +. The best result with regard to stabilization certainly supplies the Sony with the optical image stabilizer, since the electronic yes can not come along. But - Camera costs almost twice, (329€/529€) - no comparable good display, - unfavorable design, ?? - no 50 / 60p at 4k - less adjustment possibilities The FDR-X3000 was synonymous with me in the narrow choice, but then I have decided for the YI 4K + and my decision so far not regret. Another advantage for the YI 4k + is the DJI Osmo Mobile, which I use for my iPhone 6s +. With a modified adapter, I can also use the YI 4k +, that would be with the Sony not possible. Supplement FDR-X3000 is also suitable for DJI Osmo Mobile. The biggest advantage for me, however, is the smooth playback of the 4k video clips of the X3000 in the video editing program Edius. The clips of the YI 4k + I can not play without stakes on the Timeline. For this I need a new PC.I ordered the FDR-X3000. In a few days I can compare the two cameras myself

[@eugeniomuraro4150]

What were you using to pan? Some kind of remote? 6:00

[@RichardsWorld]

That looks like the remote for Zhiyun gimbals,

[@Amiro1990]

That's really depend on what your mounting this cameras . So I didn't got fully understand if I want to mount it on my helmet how it's going to inflict on my audio . does it has an audio plug ? How much time I can use that camera for recording ? if I have vlogs or something please I would like to know with a simple replay.. tnx ;)

[@PiDsPagePrototypes]

Great review, loads of useful samples. Did you try adjusting the Yi4K+ audio to get less peaking? The big advantage of the Yi over the Sony, is being able to use all the gopro form factor add-ons, like lens filters and mounts and especially, gimbals that people already own from older cameras.

[@Kost_Jobusch]

but I read that u can connect a mic over the usb c Port to the Yi4k+

[@thebuzzmeade]

What do you use for mounts on the Sony? I'm using my old GoPro connectors and they arent holding steady. Thanks!

[@Manly_Mike]

Do they make a gimbal attachment for the DJI Osmo Mobile for this camera yet?

[@elcajoia619]

Bought the Yi 4k+ because of this review, thanks.

[@cranialwavesaudioproductions]

Hey these action camera comparison videos are really helpful. Do you notice any differences in the quality or size of the Sony's FDR-X3000's footage at 4K30p vs. 4K24p?

[@volepadni]

i just love when you say "look what i have here"... and btw what camera did you use to record 11:34 ?

[@DistrictDRIVE]

lolyaaaa probably his Panasonic GH5

[@keepingupwiththeas2921]

Enjoy your videos. Funny and informative. Thumbs up

[@tehdreamer]

You must have been unlucky with the USB-C door, on mine I have a problem opening it since its so tightly shut...

[@dddbx]

Do you have the overheat issues with Sony when keep record 4K video?

[@felix120369]

Very god job, like your chanel alot! Is there a water proof gimbal for the Sony FDR X3000?

[@HiFiInsider]

thanks for another great review.

[@Rajeshkumarrio]

I always love your content!! make more and make review of Olympus the tracker

[@lunartsfilms]

which gimbal do.you recommend for the sony fdr3000?

[@MrKdr500]

i have two Yi 4k's and one Yi 4k+ also two Sony FDR X3000's and the cameras that impress me every time are the Yi's! (Yi uses Sony sensor and lens elements) i sold all of my Go Pro garbage, the hero 5 is absolute junk! Go Pro still corrupt the last video file if the battery goes flat while recording while all other camera's don't. If your going to carry an external screen for the sony then just use your phone for the Yi.

[@SamiLuo]

Yes MrKdr500 thumbs up!

[@IdreesKotawala]

Lol

[@xXadambXx]

i bought my first action cam (first use is vacation trip), first i bought yi 4k+ but this colors and WB... i was not happy with it so i return it and buy x3000. videos from it is really great: colors and boss, but i miss the a lot of manual settings which give 4k+, the low light video is really noisy (from sony).no cam is perfect, the best is your set x3000 and yi 4k+ IMO. about the screen. yi have dark screen :( but sony have small screen and not build in is a bit annoying. i have to think where can i put in to comfort use :D. i hope next yi improve WB and colors to x3000 level, add OIS, get brighter screen and put normal jack for mic :P , then this cam will be perfect IMO.

[@smitthone]

did u use the "lens protector" glass on the gopro?

[@EggY079]

Is there any news available yet about a successor from Yi Technolgy for the Yi 4K+? I'm thinking about buying the Yi 4k+, but I want to be sure that they don't release an even better action camera this year :)

[@errigas]

did someone see a Yellow halo on the display left corner up? when is black in a low light situation many people and me saw this problem... thanks for video and congratulation for the channel!

[@ArmchairAnimalActivist]

Sony FDR X3000 is almost £500 notes! I'd rather have either 2 original Yi's or a Yi plus and the Gimbal.

[@DigitalAshTCG]

does the 4k+ use the same battery as the 4k? I'm going to be ordering one and want to get some extra batteries, but all I see is batteries for the regular 4k

[@idrinkforbadges6018]

it uses the same battery as the original Yi 4K

[@DigitalAshTCG]

Thank you!

[@suavAerials]

Hey man, change your ad settings. Unskippable ads are no bueno.

[@br1ann88]

The yi 4k+ is $200, and is $150 with the $50 coupon. Amazon sometimes has a $50 coupon, and also, the batteries on the yi 4k are good imo

[@smrutisahu71]

what camera have you used for the video indoor?

[@KUBBI7488]

im looking to update my sj7000 for newer one but not sure which one???

[@HundredPercentSteve]

I love your review great job nice video.

[@PrettyLady7282]

because of your outro :) liked - subscribed :) thanks for the review. I think i'm going to get Yi 4k+ thu!

[@aserdaser2601]

I'm not some freak fan of Yi, even that i got one, but i'm always surprised why almost no one making review about it, brings up it's exclusive feature of all action cameras on the market - live streaming. For me it was the reason why i bought it, cause i love livestreaming my climbing adventures on FB for friends, and i'm sure it would be reason for others aswell to buy one.

[@panagiotiskalpakis]

Just a quick question. Which one I should buy for indoors 4k videos? Tell me two. One relatively cheap and one you think is best value for money. Thank you.

[@someguysomewhere100]

That flappy USB door is a canary in the coalmine for the overall build quality

[@Hitman-ho1yl]

I love this comparison but plz help me to find out dslr or mirrorless which is good and which sony mirrorless camera is good but in budhet :D

[@Lmartinss10]

HEY I WAS WONDERING WHAT CAMERA DO YOU USE LIKE NOT THE ACTIONS CAMERA'S BUT LIKE THE NORMAL THAT YOU USE TO RECORD THE REVIEW!

[@Ashmodai]

8:50 WTH? You always use the right arrow to go to the next thing... on basically every device ever!

[@WestrnMan]

*LOVE YOUR VIDEOS*

[@DiegoHernandezLikesBikes]

First video I have watched. Very well done. I am testing the Yi 4K+ with Gimbal and Selfie Stick and Remote. So far the door on the side stays shut but the Remote fails to connect to the device. I have previous models of the Gopro and I can see some short comings in the Yi 4K+. The LCD screen is terrible. You cannot see a damn thing outside unless it is pitch dark. I have felt the temperature rise on the Yi 4k+ by light use on a hot day 100degrees outside in the shade. I am a tad concerned what will happen when I take the camera out on near or 100+ degree temperatures while cycling or hiking. The verdict for me isn't in, but the price point and the offer price (especially the gimbal) have peeked my interest.

[@DangQuangAuto]

What camera are you filming?

[@quinmarais9068]

Your SONY RX100 footage is out of focus, as usual, 8:00 ; focused on the background. Does the Yi4+ have live FPV out? for the price of the Sony/screen 3000 seems i can purchase a Xiaomi Mi Drone with it's 4k camera and gimbal, 2 batteries.

[@Rcschim]

ha, I found you here :) I was surprised that the batterylife of the YI isnt as high as expected. in my tests with the last yi4k (non plus) the batterylife was amazing. way better than gopro5.

[@AirRoboTech]

IphoneDo has a great presentation style - and good data - learn from him - ha. GoPro v5 battery life is much improved since the v2.0 firmware update April 2017 ; especially when you record short clips through a whole day - as i like to do when i am out riding. Also much better if you charge it and dont use it for a week - i.e. better deep sleep battery saving. I don't have a new Sony 3000 but my older Sony optical stabilisation is very good on a ZMKII fast wing, which makes me interested in FDRX3000 except for the OTT Sony price ! So i am looking for a cheaper alternative for bike action and drone filming of the bike in action for a lower $ outlay so Mi Drone 4K is very cheap now. But hard to find a good quality comparison.

[@SamiLuo]

I have the exact same doubt about that of the battery lol

[@SamiLuo]

It supports. It has CVBS output

[@mitchellejuadom]

i know it's 3 months late of a reply bt... Iphondo shot the Yi+ at 4k/60fps while the rest at 4k/30fps... welp as far as i saw it.

[@Adventuregrapher]

Great review and it's nice that you don't only concentrate on the specs but real world usablity! For me the ability to shoot 4K at 60fps is so huge that despite the weaknesses of the camera I see myself using it a lot more than my Hero 5. Have been quite impressed with the 4K+ after using it for a week now.

[@astromanastrology3379]

yes, I want to see your review on hero 6 when it comes out 👍

[@amanieux]

when comparing 4k image detail at t=4m04s-4m16s , was the yi4k+ in 60fps ?of 30fps like the 2 other cameras ? thanks

[@amanieux]

it is video because when at 800% we clearly see video noise. usually for a given resolution the higher the frame rate the lower the image quality (even in good lighting)

[@zenowaleye]

Which camera did you use to record this video?

[@yauheenwai9880]

Will u review gopro hero 6?

[@biketike7829]

chip and best action camera konsa hoga

[@recordhk]

where did u take this video? what a nice place~

[@ardadogukan_]

Artık altyazı eklemeyecekmisin iPhonedo beyciğim :(

[@ndako]

Arda Doğukan eklemez hanım köylü oldu o.. 😜

[@ardadogukan_]

Yok canım bence vakit bulamıyordur değilmi +iPhonedo beyciğim ;)

[@justdapper]

I've not tried out the Sony FDR yet, but the YI 4K+ is awesome and I say if you're serious about getting some good footage it's a great camera for the adventurous types!

[@damiencole4294]

Hey first off good video reviews. I am new to all this. My budget is 150$ i need a camera that i can use for anything and everything. Day and night. What is an action camera that you personally would recommend for my price range. Features, sound, video/still, accessories, battery life are very essential...

[@RVDL]

Great review thanks