yr the best • ashfur pmv • blood and tbc spoilers

[@SuperHeroTiger]

Whoa! The imagery of Ashfur using Bramble's pelt like a wolf in sheep's clothing is so amazing and unique!

[@thecattking]

I really like the idea of in the beginning Squirrelflights eyes are closed, making her look petite and beautiful while also showing how Ashfur is blind to the truth and how to properly express love. This changes at the fire scene where her eyes are wide open and clearly angered showing a more ragged and worn down appearance also expressing the truth: how Squirrelflightisn't just something for Ashfur to Obsess over. Just a little detail I like :)

[@NeatoDragons]

Thank you so much for noticing!!!

[@fleureaux]

This is criminally underrated

[@adeleyinfeifei]

So true

[@princeramblerose]

im losing it over the way you draw imposter bramble, and your art style goes so hard in this too

[@Basilthefirefly]

I love how the background changes. At first it was pink when Ashfur loved Squirrelflight. Then it turned gray-blue, when Ashfur changed and became evil. There’s so much attention to detail and I love it

[@walnutgrove221]

This song was MADE for ashfurs arc. The style of the animation was so wonderful - I love the way ashfur wears bramblestar’s pelt. I’ve seen a few people talk about the symbolism of bramble giving squirrelflight a squirrel/ holding a squirrel in his mouth. I think it’s maybe a brief visual of brambles own abuse of her? I thought it was a nice touch 🥰

[@NeatoDragons]

I’m glad you picked up on that!!!

[@julianalipira2991]

Its not abuse lol.

[@neofrxst]

@@julianalipira2991 it is abuse lol.

[@starudstfrin]

​@@julianalipira2991it's definitely abuse lmao

[@Grace-2010op]

​@@julianalipira2991bramblestar is definitely abusive lol

[@nichollle]

did you intentionally use yellow carnations to symbolize rejection? i love this

[@NeatoDragons]

I did not tbh, I just went “hehe flower”

[@whatshouldbemynamep3701]

I DIDNT KNOW THIS THANK YOU I WILL USE IT ONE DAY WHEN I CAN ANIMATE >:333

[@IDK098]

i thought it was yellow rosed which represent "friendship" and/or "jelousy" both work lol!

[@Lylaris_or_Garuk]

@@NeatoDragons flower

[@ready_s3tgo]

@@Lylaris_or_Garuk flow

[@aesyiia]

This has to be my top favorite design for imposter BrambleStar, I know it's small but the detail with his mouth showing just beneath the fake pelt when he puts down the flower is my favorite panel.

[@VyrewoIf]

There’s something so elegant about this style, like the eyes are gorgeous and even the blood looks pretty

[@baileychapman05]

Poor squirrelflight, she deserved better! Even though she didn’t love ashfur, she still showed friendship and affection towards him, though he wanted more. He needed to accept the fact that the world doesn’t orbit around him, and though he didn’t get exactly what he wanted, he got what he deserved, (love as a friend from Squirrelflight) and he should be happy about it. Okay ashfur, life sucks sometimes but you gotta suck it up and move on!!

[@glanier6218]

Didnt she love him for like, 3 hrs, then realized yknow, hes frikin trash?

[@jittercritter]

ASH WEARING BRAMBLE’S PELT WAS INCREDIBLE

[@bruh5547]

HC:i feel like ashfur honestly was lowkey attracted to Hawkfrost, which is how he got him to try and help kill firestar

[@pr3m1vm74]

I get this is like a theory but I’d like to point out (for those who don’t know) that Ash only helped to make Bramble look bad

[@bruh5547]

@@pr3m1vm74 this actually adds to my theory i kind of imagine that hawkfrost envied and despised brambleclaw like, tigerstar invited bramblclaw to come to shadowclan as an apprentice, but was dead before hawkfrost knew him and i feel he knew brambleclaw was going to wimp out on taking over all the clans, which grew his bitterness towards his halfbrother which then made him take advantage of ashfur to help make brambleclaw kill firestar after that didnt work, he was just tired of things not going his way and tried to kill brambleclaw

[@LmaoMeowz]

@@pr3m1vm74 it was also to hurt Squirrelflight not just Bramble

[@m_rceleen]

Wait BI ASHFUR???

[@dragonisms]

That moment when ur ex's bf's brother is kinda hot but then dies: _dammit_

[@una_vita]

I love the detail that bramble gave her a squirrel

[@louixie.]

THIS IS SO PHENOMENAL WOW! the style and tweening is so pretty, the details and symbolism are so well thought out and it all looks so visually pleasing! gorgeous work!

[@greenhousestudios7703]

WHERE I BEGIN THIS IS SO GOOOOOODDD My favorite detail is Firestar looking at Ashfur with disdain at "if you touch me lover" simply because thats how I always viewed that relationship Ugghh so niiice

[@kalestars5104]

I love how imposter bramble does the exact same moves as ashfur vs how bramble approached squirrelflight!!

[@brandonreyna7924]

ok BUT YOUR FIRESTAR DESIGN IS OUTSTANDIGN IM GONJNA CRY

[@gekko2908]

I thought the part of bramblestar and squilf where he has a squirrel in his mouth might symbolize something but my brain can't think of a good theory

[@charl113e34]

BrambleStar being abusive to her BrambleStar was extremely horrible to her in the books and treated her poorly, maybe thats what it means?

[@Cutelycommitstoasterbath]

It symbolizes him treating her as prey, and the moment he gave it to her was symbolizing when he acted like a good mate.

[@mcshell5872]

I love how you showed Bramblestar’s impostor! The way impostor Bramblestar circles Squirrelflight with flowers just like Ashfur did really portrays this! Squirrelflight notices it too, she’s pretty disturbed lol.

[@NorthBlight]

just a small detail I noticed, but Squirrelflight's eyes are supposedly closed up until the fire scene. I find this a great resemblance of her association with Ashfur, as it makes it seem like she finally "Opened her eyes" and saw Ashfur's true intentions in his final living moments before he'd ultimately possess Bramblestar.

[@bear_rrr]

**casually slips into best pmvs ever playlist**

[@liz-anne2432]

Everyone: Ashfur was a better bf than Bramble Ashfur: *tried to murder her kids,* *possesses her husband,* *exiles everyone,* *genuinely makes squilf sad,* "I'm the better guy!"

[@worm6142]

You also forgot he helped trying to kill her father

[@liz-anne2432]

@@worm6142 yeah! That's not how you get the girl bro😂

[@liz-anne2432]

@Viridiana EnriquezAntonio me too he was so sweet and just wanted to please everyone

[@thishuman1621]

I know, but that was after he got rejected. Before that, he was a genuinely nice guy with enough built up rage inside that one push of a button could make him explode. I think if Squilf did choose him, she might have numbed the pain. Maybe.

[@msbellebelle]

@@thishuman1621 yeah, honestly, he treated her so much better than bramble did at the time. I have no idea why she decided to go back to bramble when he was literally nothing but rude to her, meanwhile, ashfur was genuinely caring and nice.

[@ChikkiNoodles]

THAT POSSESSED BRAMBLE DESIGN IS SO CLEVER I LOVE THIS!! THE STYLE IS SO LOVELY TOO

[@Serashrimp]

( Mosura Here ) WAAAAAAH I LOVE THIS SO MUCH,, YOU'RE EXTREMELY TALENTED CAT!! IN LOVE WITH THE COLORS AND YOUR STYLE AND I ADORE THEIR DESIGNS ASWELL!!!! ALSO THE WAY YOU DREW IMPOSTER BRAMBLESTAR WAS GENIUS, ZOMBIE BOY, BUT FR I LOVE THIS SO MUCH AND ALL YOUR OTHER MWAH, KEEP UP THE FANTASTIC WORK CAT THIS IS GREAT I LOVE IT SM!!💖💞💘💝💕💗

[@theincrediblebreeb3030]

Imposter Bramblestar's design is frickin stellar

[@ethanj.3977]

GOD THIS IS SO LOVELY.... Your art style and the colors you chose for this are so lovely to look at and the concept was so good!!

[@RandomSunnyKinnie]

Omg. Finally a carpetgarden listener.

[@hauntedme6727]

The imposter brambleclaw design is really unique! I love your artstyle and coloring and design as well!

[@eeveefennecfox3704]

Dude Your art style is so refreshing- AND JRFIENFKKEFMOESIDN ASHFUR, BUDDIE- IMPOSTER BRAMBLE DESIGN LOOKS AMAZING

[@ShooneyToons]

THATS SUCH A COOL FIRESTAR DESIGN OMG

[@melmentomori]

I am LOVING your depiction of impostor Brambs as Ashfur wearing his pelt like a cloak, that is SO COOL dude

[@GeriStrawberry]

I love coming back to this, this was honestly a huge inspiration to my Digital Silence video.

[@lj2659]

I AM OBSESSED WITH YOUR ART STYLE!!! This is so well done omg I’m in love

[@vana4076]

Genuinely one of the best PMVs I've seen, ever, in this fandom.

[@Stormwolf4]

The designs of each cat is just blowing me away! And the lineless and very shaped art style is so amazing looking!

[@kiingdomkey3857]

USING BRAMBLESTAR’S COAT AS A DISGUISE IS SO COOL WTFFFF I LOVE THIS SM

[@LockandKeyHyena]

one of my favourite ashfur pmvs wow!! love your style and designs here

[@Godofbots01]

The style of this is amazing to me, it feels kinda like a children's book with a darker meaning.

[@fozzyspots]

oh i am OBSESSED with this. your art style, how perfect the song fits the entirety of ashfur's arc... it's so simple, so beautiful, so effective, so emotive in such a disconcertingly cute way, and i'm in love.

[@Strawberr1Milkshake]

Bramble bringing her a Squirrel that matches her pelt exactly.. ah, that's such a neat little subtle touch..! I don't read the books but I do like to watch animations and learn about the characters, and from what I'm aware of Bramble is quite the abusive mate to Squirrelflight? so that's such a nice subtle little detail. Even though the video focuses on Ashfur, it still subtly nods to the fact that she hasn't simply picked a kind man over a cruel one.. And there's so much more of that subtle symbolism in this video--the flowers Ashfur offers, for one, being wilted during the fire...

[@ship-wreck]

this pmv gives me a different happy feeling that hasn’t existed in me before

[@ship-wreck]

its been 2 years and i still come back to this

[@carolinec_8650]

I’ve watched this like 10 times today No regrets

[@alliemae9820]

still one of my fav warriors pmvs of all time its so good

[@tita6120]

Omg that firestar design is just so unique

[@peggycartwright5299]

Okay, I got this recommended to me and it’s the best thing ever, I adore the song choice, the art style and animation! Stunning work, subscribing and it’s such a shame this is underrated!!!

[@Redjay_Lee]

I love your art style so much! And woah, I didn’t expect him to use Bramble like that, amazing! (Not for bramble of course but that was really creative!)

[@ethanj.3977]

Also love possessed brambles design for this.. it’s so cool!! Really screams wolf in sheep’s clothing vibes

[@DirtyNoodless]

This style makes me feel soft but also on edge and I don’t know why, but I frickin love it

[@Frog12]

Ahhh this is so well done, I am obsessed with your imposter!Bramblestar design!!!

[@heatherleaf]

this is so beautiful??? all the colours go so well together and just,,,, mmm the flow of it all is absolutely amazing!!!

[@SunFeathers]

Here before you have 1k!! The line less style is really good and pulled off amazingly, that Ashfur design tho, it looks stunning.

[@bluesheep7]

Oh my, this is so pretty! I like your designs, PosessedBramble looks horrifying! Great work!

[@vynniev9611]

I love this artstyle so much. The pacing is phenomenal, as well... Wowowow

[@BasilKats]

THIS IS SO GOOD!!! I love your style sm and the imposter Bramble design slaps so hard!!! I'm absolutely in love with this pmv

[@badmood4806]

HOLYMOTHER THIS IS AMAYZING

[@skitterkitter2027]

This is amazing!! I love the design of everyone and I adore how you showed imposter bramblestar!! The end was sudden but in a good way!!

[@medelicityliu7934]

I love the art style, it’s so unique and brings a lot of character to the whole thing!

[@squishies4life123]

WOW the art style!! Hollyleaf leaping out of the fire!! The designs!! How well the lyrics match the scene wowowow!!!!

[@lagomortis8270]

your art style is gorgeous, i've rewatched this five times already

[@jelenavujacich2359]

I hate the fact this doesn’t have nearly enough attention for all the hard work to make this and the simple beauty of this PMV!

[@morningglory.2]

This is so pretty! I love line less styles. And Firestar’s design is so cool!!!

[@TheCherri306]

Oooh the song fits so well and the imagery of their story, loved it

[@vexnyth2074]

ooh! love this so much!!!!!!i love hawkfrost's design!!!!!

[@forestwhisker]

aaaa i keep coming back to watch this, it's fantastic

[@airbornemelody6156]

I JUST FINISHED READING THE LATEST BOOK AND OML THIS HITS HAAAAAARD-- amazing job you’re so underrated!!!!

[@cicada_wing36]

Bro this has been my all time favorite video since it was posted and i dont know why i never commented it. You introduced me to my current favorite song as well :D

[@Burnt_Pancak3]

I've watched this so many times now, this is definitely my favorite animation. The art style is absolutely amazing and the song fits so well with Ashfur!

[@crescent_foxx1014]

I absolutely love your designs and art style! I also love your design for imposter Bramblestar! It's such a cool and unique idea! ❤️❤️

[@milktooth4996]

i love tthis! it’s so awesome!! i and i like seeing the “ashfur using bramblestars’ pelt as a disguse” idea being used!!!! hope you have a good day!

[@neptune430]

This is beautiful! Though, I don’t know if anyone has yet animated Squilf and Bramble’s relationship.

[@NeatoDragons]

They have!

[@averyhungrypigeon9996]

Your art style is like no other,I don't even know how to put how much I adore it into words

[@rrammay]

This is wonderful! I adore the lineless style and the designs

[@chirp4979]

I cant get over this,, I've been re-watching it so much :')

[@fishystickys]

The tweening and colors are BEAUTIFUL! And the lineless designs!! Such great movement and style

[@klondii]

_holy cow this is amazing!! i especially love how you draw possessed bramble!! its so cool!!_

[@Bear_Song]

I love this so much! It’s super amazing I love your style, and the song really fits Ashfur. ❤️

[@SirEmotional1]

I LOVE YOUR ARTSTYLE!!! I finally found this again! This is absaloutely stunning ✨ you really inspire me man

[@Mak1Attack1]

Your imposter design is SO cool!

[@amarylily]

YOOOOOOOOOOOOO THIS IS AMAZING THE SONG FITS SO WELL

[@treeetooop]

Ooo I love the style on this!

[@ferretbutler1326]

This is now my favorite video of these 2 cats I know little about

[@duststyboi]

I’m in love with your art style omg!!!

[@eggnoggins]

ive been watching since u first posted this and i have loved it each and every rewatch

[@tangerinesrsophisticated]

woah, this style is stunning

[@Lykorice]

this gave me CHILLS omg its amazing

[@seramaple]

The style I- 🛐🛐🛐

[@kaminister]

Woooow the style and way everything goes together is just ✨✨

[@madc1568]

Carpetgarden AND warrior cats you are a master of taste and your art is gorgeous!

[@RebeAdventures]

I LOVE THIS SO MUCH!!! It's super good!

[@bitt6164]

THE DESIGNS THOO

[@B0nel3ss]

this is actually insane... AMAZING!!

[@asafupps]

This so gorgeous and creative!!

[@dejavuthewhat4817]

THİS İS SO GOOOODDD AAAA * imposter style looking so cool damnnnnnn

[@batcvltz_alt]

This is so cool!! I love your style so much :)

[@Angel-ky8me]

Just found this channel and OMG I AM ABSOLUTELY IN LOVE!! ✨ur art style is absolutely beautiful I adore it 🥰 The music really matches~

[@buggybug09]

I'm pretty sure there's been more ashfur maps and animatics than any other Cat. I love it

[@Peikkey]

I think ashfur is 2nd behind mapleshade

[@docdoc.4500]

New favorite Ashfur animatic,,

[@moved842]

Ow my gowd damnn ur so underraded! This is incredible! The art just everything so perfect ahhhhhh ,new sub! And btw what programs did u use lol ;)

[@NeatoDragons]

Cute cut Pro to tween and Autodesk sketchbook to draw!

[@mi_okz]

This is really creative and a nice art style! I love it

[@sedateddreams4254]

This is so beautiful!!! You did an amazing job!