YSL Defense Addresses 'Extra' Comments Made by Witness, State in Young Thug Trial

[@NiqueatNite]

Lying saying you didn’t hear it is diabolical

[@CrysG.]

She’s so blatantly rude to certain defense lawyers.

[@NiqueatNite]

@@CrysG. before it was called out I commented on the live like wow did she just say horrible so I know for a fact the judge and prosecutor heard it too they are flat out lying

[@brownsweetie]

I’m not even there and I heard it 😆

[@TheBronco58]

Love WANTS jury to hear AND see her!! It is quite intentional, and very unprofessional. Also, for a Police officer to address a lawyer (Steel) so dishonestly,and rudely just to NOT answer the way Love wants her to should be considered perjury. I know, I know, it won’t happen.

[@isisbarron203]

It’s crazy!!!!

[@AllHailKingRose]

I heard her say it. The judge shouldn’t just assume the jury will disregard it and that it’ll make the prosecution look bad. She’s not a mind reader.

[@Shyer08]

We all heard it and they made a point to let her know it’s on live tv which tells me them boys about take some action against love and that court

[@anni610]

Heard it too! Seriously get this trial under control or call mistrial! Never wanted suspects guilty of crimes to be set free as an appeal will rip trial apart!

[@angelvoid6828]

I heard it too

[@TheBronco58]

Ahaha at “mind reader” … I would have loved to hear another objection after her, with your exact words!

[@iAintSayDat]

This case is possibly the most flagrant example of prosecutorial and judicial misconduct in a criminal trial by a state government in 100 years.

[@adrianrobertson1910]

Well said

[@Bugsy0333]

I agree 100% !

[@ibe310]

NAW, THEY DID WORST TO R KELLY AND TRYING TO DO IT DIDDY. PEOPLE ARE BRINGING UP THEIR FEELINGS INSTEAD OF GOING BY THE LAW.

[@shay90574]

… that we know of!

[@samxakinyemi]

Easily

[@Chunky101-w2v]

This judge is awful. Prosecutor too!

[@already_taken_00]

Judge always cuts off the defense attorneys but let's love take 10 business days to finish a thought.

[@Shyer08]

I hate that and I hope the defense file whatever paperwork need to be filed against the conduct of that court judge and love she’s the main one

[@nikki901]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@brittanywade5312]

That is true

[@ChrissyBeTalking]

10 business days during a holiday season at that!

[@andrewtesta5944]

What a 🎪

[@IZA_Grey]

So everyone watching online and in the court hears it except the judge and Love

[@sexychevy]

Right

[@Shyer08]

One of the defense attorneys said it’s on live tv and judge act like she didn’t care. In other words he’s telling you smarty pants we have proof of all this miss conduct

[@angelvoid6828]

Right. Wow

[@MrOdlee01]

WOW!!! WE ALL HEARD HER SAY HORRIBLE!!!!! I’M SICK OF THIS JOKE OF A TRIAL AND BIAS JUDGES!

[@madisonmum1031]

We the people heard the witness say Horrible‼️

[@angelvoid6828]

I definitely heard horrible too.

[@scorpichella]

The judge does not want to deal with any issue that gets her out of her comfort zone.

[@JuryJudy731]

Lol 😂

[@qianashaw8167]

I agree.

[@TheRealVeeBee]

And she’s too freakin sarcastic.. do your job!

[@crystalbet4540]

And Ms. Unlove muttered “why you still talking then” also during Shardt cross while he was speaking to the judge. Disgusting!

[@Shyer08]

I hope they get her I know the court reporter got it I’m sure

[@victoriouslee1218]

I heard her say that too!!! Disgusting behavior

[@queenv3]

Since when does a judge not tell a witness to only answer the questions. We all heard her say it.

[@TrevorPeckinpah]

It’s ridiculous. Absolutely ridiculous.

[@Babysuggs-holy]

The question is not what you heard. The question is what the jury heard. And clearly the broadcast is picking up things that the jury and courtroom can’t hear

[@queenv3]

​@@Babysuggs-holygood point, however we won't know if any of the jurors heard it.

[@tischashaircaresecrets8310]

Guess The Judge Never Saw Ms Love Rolling Her Eyes At Her Either 🙄

[@aftertheheadlines]

Rockin’ and bobbin’ her head and sighs.

[@alexanderalexander6134]

Rolling her eyes! The neck the rolling! Love is the definition of attitude! It’s so tacky!

[@catrinawilliamson5488]

I saw that too😂😂

[@riorio-88]

She always talks down to the judge saying rhetorical and told her play the video yourself and we will see

[@setsbytati4773]

Get this judge removed too

[@stephaniewilliams5846]

Immediately she is a awful judge and don't care about this case and it's as plain as day!!!

[@Fee-Fee50]

@@stephaniewilliams5846horrible!

[@imperialprincess1465]

She is so biased, it’s making my skin crawl.

[@nayakiabates8814]

Exactly, wow is this an in accurate depiction of judges in Georgia because this will be the second judge removed from this case?

[@joelewis4336]

should be held in contempt as a witness of the courts

[@samanthapowell3988]

For calling them horrible ? 😂 Did start not call love gross ? Both sides do it

[@amorgan1975]

Shardt called her actions gross. He was admonished and it was striken.

[@battlerudee]

@@samanthapowell3988Even if…that was a witness…

[@stringa01]

This wasn’t even the worst part. Gaither refused to answer Steeles last question and was waiting for Love to object until the judge told her she’s not in control and must answer

[@HellavaLive]

This dude is horrible. She said it several time. Love also spoke into her live mic "is he still talking" about Shartd. It's very clearly heard. Nevermind Gaither saying sever comments that were just crazy. Love you are absolutely unprofessional and should lose your bar card.

[@Shyer08]

Absolutely I wish I could report her

[@Rob89139]

Something I've noticed about this judge is she tends to ALWAYS cutoff the defense lawyers mid sentence when they are trying to communicate a point thus keeping them from completing an argument. She lets the state ramble on and on but interrupts the defense. I agree with a lot of the commenters that she is awful. What I believe is she doesn't believe the defendants are innocent but also realizes the state isn't making a case so she's allowing the craziness in hopes the state comes up with something that has a chance

[@Shyer08]

They are playing dirty for the whole world to see they will and should be in a lot of trouble

[@SCULLZY1]

I heard mutterings. Yesterday she said this ain’t never gonna end

[@harlzNY]

Sure did

[@carmelookc7014]

Yup and said mad Maxx was horrible after he finished questioning her

[@lenaely6146]

We all heard it... Paige is drunk, bored , sleeping, distracted or disinterested to not hear it or pull the transcript and Livestream

[@kierralavixx]

We all heard it. We were right here watching when she said it.

[@rackaddictbdoe1978]

If she didn't hear it then what trial is she listening to?

[@pray2b1]

Judge hears it. Judge stop lying. Ms. Love needs to quit. Love makes gestures that are just awful. Look at the tapes. MISTRIAL PLEASE

[@highatruthart]

Judge play it back and check the Transcript It was said .These issues need to stop 🛑🛑🛑

[@aftertheheadlines]

She doesn’t want to do it because she knows it there. Like Sgt Gaither’s hard drive was really erased when the department was hacked. The Judge is covering for their department’s incompetence. I was a detective and we never left hard drives attached to computers because we had to keep them secured - locked up.

[@thelandkids2156]

It was loud and clear. I'm not understanding this judge at all

[@derrick42df]

I think she’s worse than the first judge.. especially with all that laughing!!!

[@angelvoid6828]

I know. I heard is before I watched this video.

[@angelvoid6828]

​@derrick42df no she is better than that first judge. She hates Love, and always calls her out

[@Babysuggs-holy]

The broadcast heard things the court and jury do not

[@barbiedoll5766]

Why won't this judge tell Gaither and Love, to knock it off?

[@TheBronco58]

This is great! There are a LOT more from Ms. Love… she even murmured after Judge got on her… Whitaker said to Love “so, no answer?, ok”. And Love murmurs “I thought.. it.. was rhetorical “ (snarky). I was waiting for Whitaker to say: “WHAT DID YOU JUST SAY?” But apparently, only the Jury hears Love mumbling!

[@Imdatqueen409]

The judge needs a hearing aid😅 and a 🧠

[@nofacade100]

I definitely heard her twice say horrible. I thought it was Love the first time

[@nataliaarmstrong7790]

Why didn’t the Judge asked Gaither to see if she would lie, if she would lie about that than she’s a lair

[@870weezie]

My thought

[@Cportfinest912]

She said “this dude is horrible” about Steele

[@Luxxpro674]

not a lie lol

[@kaedenjohnson4743]

@@Luxxpro674how so huh?? What about him and his behavior/demeanor is horrible??

[@angelvoid6828]

I heard horrible too before I watch this.

[@fishcooks]

30 minutes to an hour talking about microphones. This case will never be over😂

[@MsJazzy101-f4r]

Judge should have re read the transcript or played it back . Even if you didn’t hear it, don’t mean it didn’t happen . love how Steele still treated with respect even after that

[@Benjiizus]

Love is extremely manipulative and a terrible liar. The point isn't the prosecution's table's mic picking up them talking, it's the witness muttering negative comments about the defense in her mic...

[@angelvoid6828]

Exactly

[@reneefox6064]

It’s lucky it’s televised your honor because the nation sees the prosecutorial misconduct and the bias of the court!

[@Trash-Beats]

We here in Zimbabwe heard it loud and clear how come some of u in USA didn’t hear it😢

[@adriennem7927]

😊

[@notfamouschristopher]

😂😂😂😂 in kenya 🇰🇪 and I heard it ... 😳 👀 😅

[@Truecrimewatcher]

😂😂

[@LittleMsSunflower]

Only lying love and the corrupt judge didn't hear it 🙄 we heard her muttering and breathing heavy all day on the stand

[@Trash-Beats]

@@notfamouschristopher so true young man

[@jensinedeanda]

State keeps shaking her head and rolling her eyes towards witness gaither leading her answers we all have watched her do that

[@Shyer08]

All the time a dirty dog

[@bobbiedeleon4845]

Darth Gaither said "Horrible" under her breath!

[@Shyer08]

More than once

[@angelvoid6828]

I heard horrible too. Love is a liar

[@Gigi_T_1045]

They should play back loves comments to her face and have her explain herself to the court and the jury

[@Shyer08]

Baby it will be this time next year after she try to lie her way out of it

[@kenginger8051]

The Judge missed the point. The attorneys brought up the livestream because the DA was denying it happened!

[@shelbyallan4184]

Wow! Our Justice system is getting bad! Sad 😞

[@maryallen9657]

that is a reflection on your court and you know it!!

[@JD0586]

Of course the state hasn't heard any "mutterings"

[@ShellySmall]

You're lying you know she said horrible everybody knows it

[@MsDouble07]

This exactly why thereis no court until next week. When court resumes they will skip over this. 😂

[@Shakanakeandria]

Exactly

[@theogatticusfinch]

theres no court because of the High Holidays

[@Shyer08]

This need to be addressed and the defense need to file paperwork to whoever they need to get the problem resolved

[@ritamckinney7797]

Ask the court reporter

[@Shyer08]

I know she heard it and got it on record

[@nataliewood8160]

Ms. Gather just said "This Dude is Horrible"

[@KianaLeon22]

EXACTLY!!!!

[@LIVENLETLIV]

She also made a comment just be the break on yesterday about the trail.

[@crabarita8516]

Mr. Gaither that is...

[@MysticRose24]

I thought she said “Steel is horrible”

[@MysticRose24]

@@crabarita8516😂😂😂

[@jensinedeanda]

She says “this dude is horrible”

[@kimscott1223]

Wait ... The judge beefed about someone eating a Banana, talking about courtroom decorum, but it's ok for a witness to make derogatory comments towards the lawyers? Wow, she needs to step down.

[@qianashaw8167]

That's Judge Miss Paige...

[@Lawandordernyc]

We all heard it

[@scorpichella]

They are now resorting to personal jibes on a hot-mic because its even obvious and frustrating to them now that they have nothing on Williams et Al.

[@angelvoid6828]

Listen, I was so unbiased until that judge got fired. Now Im like they have nothing so far. Absolutely nothing.

[@tischashaircaresecrets8310]

The Jury Also Sees That Ms Love Has No Respect For You Judge

[@angelvoid6828]

And the judge has no respect for either. She hates Love.

[@TheBronco58]

Hey Paige… ask Love when she mumbled after you barked at Love about no answer? And Love mumbles “I thought it was rhetorical”.

[@angelvoid6828]

Yes, Loves to talk under her breath too. I have heard her several times

[@thickandgood16]

They talking about they did not hear this

[@CrysG.]

Not only did they absolutely hear it. They actually DID it, too. Love says (why are you still talking then) while Max is speaking to the judge. The media didn’t get an apology for the prosecutor showing the witness.

[@GhostofTez]

lol I heard it first watch or listen or whatever

[@TrevorPeckinpah]

I can’t believe the judge is okay with that behavior from a witness. Any other judge would let the witness have it and correct that behavior.

[@Shyer08]

Seems to me all the judges are there just to collect a check and don’t care how people behave in the court room

[@loveshangover5062]

Throw the whole judge away, we already know where she is leaning now.

[@kiad]

I cannot wait until this is case is appealed cuz its gonna be overturned

[@essentialdarkness1245]

This entire trial should be on a skit on SNL, or if the Chapelle show was still on Dave woulda nailed it🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@ArronNeubauer-bj2bl]

The judge and the da need locking up what an absolute disgrace this case has become it boils my blood watching it now!

[@BIGVYOPINION]

This is sad that this really going inside a courtroom

[@susanglover1972]

I have definitely heard words like horrible from the witnesses and the state.

[@skewedlines]

Judge whittaker is too busy giggling to hear these things. She's trying to take the reins of this court but she loses the plot and starts laughing at everything And making a joke of everything.

[@kingpaw2426]

This is crazy work

[@Maeve_Puffs]

The live went hard around this time! 💪🏾

[@BornOnASaturday]

I couldn’t imagine being on the jury for this trial lol

[@gustotrustno2118]

Judge didn’t hear because she hardly pay attention anyway

[@Shakanakeandria]

Exactly

[@qianashaw8167]

This is true...

[@therealmsmillionaireforeve8848]

These so-called attorneys act like hurt little girls..

[@gcwmn1961]

What does lawyers acts like hurt little girls mean?

[@BarbieDoll-ih2fy]

Why because the Judge is obviously biased, you must be blind or deaf! This BS she let's love go on and on. The jury couldn't find them guilty! And I would sue this is shyt show!

[@nestle68]

Gaither said also "This Never Going End" when Shardt started 😂

[@gerrenkeith]

I’m an audio engineer. There is no way that podium microphone could pick up a whisper conversation at the prosecution’s table without it being a conversation, that is loud enough to be heard by anyone else in the courtroom.

[@Addictedkicks]

I heard it loud and clear

[@momango2201]

How long is this trial? Like when is the sentencing?

[@BeaudrinBaronette]

This jury must have money for them to be here that long

[@stephaniehawkins57]

I think they get like $25 a day smh

[@Nico-vn8uq]

They definitely will when it’s over cause I will buy the first book one of them writes about this mess. They will have lots of interviews also. That is the only reason I could think of why they didn’t say they couldn’t unhear woody testimony just to get out of there

[@Shyer08]

They not paying them enough for this foolishness. How many of them have lost jobs behind this mistrial

[@angelawalker7582]

Man, end this case already . Next month will be a freaking year,smh

[@Lawandordernyc]

And love making faces

[@lauralee9694]

Day after day year after year and the guys are still in jail, what a travesty.

[@catdish2]

by the judge not directly and sternly responding, the jury might assume that, SINCE the judge obviously heard it as well, she condones it! this is disgusting. judge whitaker should take action immediately; if not, she will be known as just as crooked as the disgraced ex-judge in this ridiculous case.

[@tracyhara3821]

Omg these lawyers are full of it muttering but they don’t know what was said laughable

[@jennifersuzuki]

Can’t wait for this weeks ‘The Regular’ podcast!!!

[@yslslimerichy7674]

She said steel is horrible

[@kellig]

She said it multiple times.

[@PatriceDMV]

Yes, she did it 3 times that I heard. Hopefully they'll post them along with Love also making comments and nodding yes to Gaither.

[@bigwigmoney]

Why didn’t the defense ask the court reporter if she documented it?

[@realjftm1]

The attorney said that this is horrible. All they got to do is play it for that the judge

[@YumYumDelishNSip]

We all heard her say: “This is never gonna end.” Then.. “This dude is horrible.” “Mr. Steel is horrible.” WE HEARD IT TOO!

[@sabrinaortiz3311]

Love is always rolling her eyes

[@shawnatwood4653]

Again! This judge is either a liar or deaf or just ROTTEN!

[@leawhite6658]

They all worked together in the state attorney’s office until Paige became a judge

[@jessicaanderson35]

DA LOVE needs to shut it……she has been caught on microphone snickering, laughing. Now her witness is saying things……DA LOVE is an embarrassment to the profession and her office!!!!

[@eljohnson2117]

Max schardt was making faces as well when questioning the witness.

[@KerenszH]

But were you able to see the way the witness was looking at him?

[@eljohnson2117]

@@KerenszH you couldn't see the witness

[@KerenszH]

@@eljohnson2117 Exactly, and I'm sure she was making faces. So, the attorney's face was a reaction to hers.

[@eljohnson2117]

Doesn't matter who first or second he did it.

[@KerenszH]

@@eljohnson2117 Cause and effects always matter.

[@thickandgood16]

Then on top of that before all of that happened, I think she said something about being sick of somebody or she was sick🤦🏾‍♀️ I was just over here she know what she was doing. That’s why she was breathing into their might like that.😂

[@foxxybrown36]

We All Heard Her Say That!-.

[@_paige_me8037]

There’s a lot of corruption going on and someone needs to get to the bottom of it! The times the witness/detective made those comments were conveniently times the defense was nailing her coffin. How many jurors over the years have you tainted? She took their focus off the facts both lawyers pointed out she illegally manipulated and coerced the inmate into snitching! Y’all gotta watch the live feed!! It appears the detectives promised the inmate reduced sentence- mistrial . The case isn’t Valid since his information led to the progression of the investigation!

[@glock3090]

FREE JEFF

[@prissray326]

We all heard the witness say that. We've watched Love has been making faces and she mutters everyday like when she said "we'll see" after the judge made a statement.

[@clowd9yne]

I'm still trying to figure out why she didn't ask the detective RIGHT THERE on the spot, she would say yes and look crazy or lie under oath and look crazy

[@uggggggghhhhh]

The judge: If I dont notice it, it doesnt exist and if it exists, its not my problem..

[@shadowfox8425]

This judge's ire towards the media is disturbing

[@SuddenExistentialDismissal]

I agree. The entire "case" is horrible.

[@AHannon821]

When does trial resume streaming?

[@SuperLISSHA]

She said it

[@winskids6341]

The only reason Paige Whitaker couldn’t hear the comments made is because her head is buried in the sand after being punked by Fanni Willis for scolding Love the other day.

[@sweetjanejonez]

Fani isn't the judge's boss. Wth?! 😂😂😂

[@shantaagee8824]

I heard it too

[@matchmyfly9873]

No end in site. Never heard of anything like this for a trial

[@carmensampson3337]

Love you are a liar. That detective said horrible. I heard her. The judge is a lie.