유희열의 스케치북 - 티파니 - Heartbreak Hotel + I Just Wanna Dance.20160624

[@Wind123move]

her mistake just proving that this is 100% live and she sounds really good , who said she can't sing again ?

[@luqrexia]

I used to hate her but damn she's proof it that she work hard

[@aumboonn1749]

+Lucrecia mcck same and I love her now

[@luqrexia]

+Noppawan Prakopdee Yas girll!!

[@trustm3100]

+Lucrecia mcck thanks omg I'm bawling 😭

[@trustm3100]

+Noppawan Prakopdee thank youuu

[@sunshineyrainbows13]

In America, we call her sound on that high note "gravelly", and it's actually a pretty difficult technique to pull off, and it's seen as a sexy punk rock type of thing here. Sounded perfectly normal to me. Are we sure she didn't mean to do it? She looked pretty confident about it.

[@nosananolife9894]

I honestly didn’t notice anything, it sounded so perfect to me. Could you please timestamp the “gravelly” part?

[@summera7144]

@@nosananolife9894 parts where the notes sound gritty like 1:58 & 2:02

[@K-Choi]

So that’s the term for rough high notes, I always hear that during Winter’s live audio recording for Black Mamba

[@ganqiling]

Honestly I don't understand how someone can hate this girl. She's so tired after every schedule but she is still so cheerful and smiles brightly whenever she sees her fans. She tries her best and aims to do well for each performance. Yet this girl is seen as 'fake' or 'can't sing'.. Like HOW

[@sugarshaz7854]

Coming from America myself, I think she has an incredible voice. It must be a Korean thing where they expect a certain kind of vocal. But this girl has amazing texture in her voice. I'm in love with it.

[@yudhaadjipangestu4739]

Agreed

[@yullovelevolluy]

Agree so much. I am always in love with this kind of husky vocal. But she definitely needs rest.

[@sandramoviestar2494]

I'M FROM SWEDEN WHICH IS BETTER THAN BARAK OBAMA

[@orangeissoftpower]

I think it is because America values uniqueness and individuality. As long as you and your song are good and stand out and you can handle your songs, you get popular. In Korea there are lots more demands: you have to have good vocal, good techniques, pretty voice, can sing pretty much everything, you have to be pleasant to look at, you have to have good concept, not weird or slutty but not repetitive, you have to stand out but not too much etc etc. (ikr....) The problem with Tiffany or any girlgroup member is their group songs don't necessarily fit them so they can't show their potential so if they suck at their group songs, people judge them even though their solo are brilliant. This is another cultural difference: there are more girlgroups in Korea than in the US.

[@trustm3100]

Jan Waldolf yeah but twice and bts don't fit with your opinions above.

[@velvetyluna5020]

Tiffany is so talented.. She don't deserve the hate she is getting.. She's working so hard this year yet haters always find the stupidest reason to hate this perfect angel.

[@imarah5562]

guys! lets make taeyeon starlight MV get 3M in one day!

[@nanaya1532]

true😒 i dont undestand why they hate our baby girl

[@luqrexia]

true tho. Well there always pros and cons haha

[@ptm0722]

You should know that not everyone could please every one. Despite your talents. No matter how excellent you are in singing or in dancing or in any way. Real talk thou

[@tippahae8802]

+SONE Forever why u guys only think of taeyeon. taeyeon every where and some ppl say snsd without taeyeon nothing I am sorry I stars hate taeyeon bcuz of that I don't want to hate her but the fans make me really mad why u don't do for Tiffany like this....

[@jihyoommaslapblackpink9771]

Why is Tiffany is the most hated member in SNSD? She's a talented and friendly person she doesn't deserve the hate

[@rosemoon605]

Jihyo omma slap blackpink You're answering your own question 🙁

[@saffyesperas2278]

Jihyo omma slap blackpink , I don't know why, but I love her, Jessica, and Sooyoung.

[@haroldoi8962]

Because she is known 'the fakest snsd member'

[@snsd2764]

It's because toxic jessica stans think she make Jessica leave so that they comment everywhere and spread rumours, not only taeyeon, but also all members.

[@iduncareu]

haters are just a bunch of depressed, emo, negative and pessimistic losers. of course they are triggered with fany's cheerful, positive, optimistic, passionate, sweet, adorable, friendly and hardworking personality.

[@dmswl409]

다시봐도… 매력있는 티파니 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ 한국어로 솔로앨범 또 내주면 좋겠음 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@Dosbaka]

Heartbreak hotel ㄹㅇ 명곡 약간 셀레나 고메즈 느낌 남

[@AlexBsSecret]

Tiffany is a great vocalist and as much as I enjoy IJWD, which is a fun summer bop, she sounds absolutely amazing on Heartbreak Hotel: rough, edgy, dark. She should explore her lower vocal range, its sexy and gives more goosebumps than any whistle note she reaches

[@aurora_ww]

She' being continuing her concerts, recording for unnies, she needs to rest her voice, she's even touched her neck after singing the high notes, it must be kinda hurt because her voice is hoarse. But she is Tiffany. A person who will always tried her best on stage, an eventhough she's not on her best condition and for her little mistake(who i find it cute) she still slayin😊

[@Kiirze]

Yes, her condition is not the best right now. :/

[@summerblair89]

Yes because it's Tiffany,a girl who alwaysss gives her 200% and yet still try to give moreee for us! She's soo precious 😭😭💖

[@aurora_ww]

And she even got operation for her vocal nodules back then...😞😞

[@esther1281]

ikr!!!!! and she's so sweet like even witj crazy schedules she apologised to the unnies slam dunk members that she couldnt prepare much but like the cast was welcoming her?? hais the girl needs rest

[@aurora_ww]

sigh...srsly, haters have no chill...don't they have another work to do other than messing with her life? -_-

[@danielapazccc2684]

that cute mistake she made proofs she's singing life, proud to be fanytastic

[@shainamielbautista9705]

Huh? What part?

[@shainamielbautista9705]

Huh? What part?

[@cutievelvets]

+Shaina Miel Bautista 1:20

[@realimad]

+Shaina Miel Bautista 1:20

[@shelleytang1232]

When she made a mistake

[@miriamsuen]

haters where are you??? as usual, tiffany eats the CDs

[@mintamimiomar5389]

MAMAMOO is goddes of CD

[@fuckery276]

+Min Tamimi Omar they do well tes but don't bring them up

[@mintamimiomar5389]

+perfect girl btw she is my bias & this my fav song

[@fuckery276]

+Min Tamimi Omar okay goood

[@munxox]

Min Tamimi Omar no one asked for those racist rats

[@iPartynauseous]

Sketchbook always has my favorite performances and this one is no exception!

[@clearsky.flying]

WHY IF UR BIAS MALE MAKE LIPSYNC OR MISTAKE U WILL SAY "omg oppa ur so cute" "omo oppa u must have some rest" "oppa u keep look cool, i luv u", but when tiffany do mistake or lipsync all of u will bash her too much... idk why all of u hate tiffany, but remember again, she is human like us, can make mistake anytime and anywhere, i know she is member of legendary girlgruop, but think again bruh, she is only human. and i really curious why all of u don't bash ur bias like u bash tiffany mistake? LOL

[@aniecovlogz]

your comment is my favorite. I totally agree if one of our guy biases made a mistake, some would say "Oh how cute. they messed up" and throw a bunch of heart emojis. I honestly think Tiffany has a great voice. people are just jealous and bitter.

[@kermitque3065]

+Stephanie Alexander Robles It's the fact that SM gave Tiffany more lines than Jessica (when she was still part of the group). And for some odd reason girl groups and female idols get a lot more hate than boy groups and male idols. It's the sad truth....I honestly don't see why people hate Tiffany so much. I doubt she would ask SM to give her more lines than Jessica. I also doubt that they would listen to her.

[@albinorat4411]

Agree , all of them would be like omo oppa you're so cute ,please take care of yourself but when it's a female idol nooo they have to bash her , khra ga3din ki zbel

[@fuckery276]

yas thank you !! eff the double standards

[@kermitque3065]

+mi na It really annoys me too. For example, Exo just had a comeback and I watched a performance. Sehun seemed so awkward dancing and missed a lot of the moves. And when Sunny had an injured knee during SNSD comeback. Sehun got comments like, "Aigoo our little Sehun is so cute when he messes up :)" And Sunny got, "Sunny is ruining the performance with her lazy dancing." Like wtf?

[@trustm3100]

Even with her hoarseness she still got all those high notes, and her low notes in HBH verse is gold, it's so ugh!! You know like it feels really nice to your ears, oh also that cute lil mistake tho. Tiffany jjang!! Pls continue to make good music, I know your passion in music is bigger than everyone thoght, show em more of yours. Seems your hard work all this time has been resulting a good fruit!! Fighting ppany nunaaa yaa!!

[@apriliansyahmuhammad348]

yes the low note tho... tiff's speciality is lownote tbh... but her headvoice isn't bad too

[@apriliansyahmuhammad348]

yes the low note tho... tiff's speciality is lownote tbh... but her headvoice isn't bad too

[@NSONE232]

Yess! Agree all the way. All the best Tiffany~ :D

[@jessicationg7775]

If Tiffany has good rest, her head voice is actually pretty solid. She's a good singer, but not a smart singer.

[@itgetsworse601]

she needs to sing this kind of songs it suits her better her low notes are literally GOLD

[@Lee-uz3ox]

티파니 감성 ㄴ사랑해....😘

[@bunnyluna01]

1:20 SHE MADE A MISTAKE AUWWW TIFFANYY U STILL SLAYYY

[@luqrexia]

but she don't even seems like she made a mistake. Damn She slay!!

[@sya993]

that mistake can be use as a proof if haters still saying she lipsync

[@bunnyluna01]

non stuck yeah!! it proves that our fany can sing live~~

[@aurora_ww]

Yes. And sketchbook doesn't allow lipsync too i guess.

[@dreamerbh7966]

hahhahahha😂😂😂😂

[@Biapark96]

와 ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ 역시 소녀시대가 실력파라는걸 파니가 증명하네요

[@DameBau]

My baby has been going and doing things non-stop she needs a break 😩

[@najaemin.00liners]

Yes i agree , i think she has lose weight so much , you see she is so thin now 😔😔 and look her eyes i think she need more sleep too 😕

[@judehuppert9422]

와 보컬 탄탄하다 역시 소녀시대 짬밥은 무시할 수 없는듯..

[@sakura95107]

heartbreak hotel now is my favorite song of tiffany is so cool

[@victoriarufino5427]

I still don't understand how can someone hate this woman. I love, you girl!! Great artist!!!!

[@dianacasados7780]

She got emotional while singing Heartbreak Hotel, her eyes were watery. OKAY WHO HURT MY GIRL?

[@lhl9852]

I just wanna dance 정말 좋아하는 노래였음!! 티파니 목소리 분위기 넘넘 멋지고 고혹적이었음!!

[@sss3593]

이 노래 너무 좋아용❤

[@sehatfarma9933]

Tiffany ❤❤❤

[@Haaa_Poom]

일명 맴찢호텔 파니 아저댄 이랑 이걸로 솔로활동 으로 많은 모습을 보여줄 수 있어서 좋았음

[@bunny_12bunny]

맴찢호텔ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 아 티파니 맴찢호텔 컨셉 너무 좋아용

[@SwiftieCatLover]

Take that haters! And she sounds great all things considered. Sounding this great with her schedule is incredible. But it also makes me wonder how much better she could sound with a little more training from JYP.

[@velvetyluna5020]

I think SMent is the best for vocal training,even the least singer in a group still sound good and stable.

[@LaquetaHodge]

Oh no, we don't want vocal training from JYP lol Let's be happy he hasn't ruined Baek Ah Yeon & 15&

[@SwiftieCatLover]

+Laqueta Hodge you do know JY Park doesn't really do much producing for his artists anymore? He just sort of helps guide them and stuff, but other than that he's just like any other JYP artist. He isn't the CEO anymore and hasn't been for years. Baek Ah Yeon writes her own stuff and has been doing very well. I don't pay much attention to 15& though.

[@LaquetaHodge]

Subin Kim I know all of that and my comment still stands.

[@SwiftieCatLover]

***** Thats because unlike SM, JYP's main focus is on putting emotion and feelings into your singing instead of just technique. JYP isn't the only company that has people train for a long time. The reason some people train for that long is because they aren't ready. Look at Baek Ayeon for example. JYP rushed her debut and it tanked, but after that they took their time and now her career is going very well. And Jihyo sounds great, just because you aren't a fan of her vocals doesn't mean she's a terrible singer. She's actually a very talented vocal.

[@May-qq4cv]

Tiffany used to look like the foreign member who is cool but that's it. Now she looks like the very pretty singer everyone is going crazy about. I'm loving how she morphed from just singing to fill in her part in a song to wholeheartedly delivering a good music.

[@skyleaf2902]

Agree

[@AndreaRodriguez-nf2ff]

te amo tiffany

[@estherlimpeleh4263]

Heartbreak hotel is a heartbreaking song but it's sexy in the same time

[@Lissimm04]

2:10 Omg Her Voice Sounds Raspy But She Still Amazed Me With It. I Love This Part ... And The Whole Performance Of Course!

[@mic-shellcrackson3800]

Seo Ju-Hyun she was sick that time

[@fafaidris1949]

the high note part in heartbreak hotel is so pleasing to ear. i love the huskiness added make it sound bit of rock.

[@z._z3077]

This performance was literally perfection. Like everything was so on point. Her vocals, dance and her outfit too !!!

[@96jessielee]

I'm surprise her microphone is not pink lol

[@catherinefelicitas8523]

Because it doesn't suit for the theme of Heartbreak Hotel hahahahaha.

[@minicornOnly5]

Falling in love with her again and again T___T I love you Fany

[@xualifanai7280]

her solo is just my type. TOTAL POP 💜

[@mariafernandarodriguezboni2205]

Her voice sounds so steady and clear in this live perf. You can tell YHY Sketchbook has quality music equipment unlike the other music shows. I remember Taeyeon made a public complain about Music Bank while Ryeowook made a tweet about Music Core.

[@nguyeninhhai3274]

Performance of Tiffany is perfect. Very good. Amazing voice 😘😘😘

[@Password9141]

CANT STILL GET ENOUGH OF HER ELEGANT BEAUTY!!! One of the most beautiful female artist within in the industry

[@ravenndei7442]

haven't even finished spazzing over starlight and i had to move on to sketchbook to support tiff! hahaha crazy friday for sones but i'm not complaining!

[@RaperaaFly]

She's not a bad singer. I love her voice. Her problem is that she isn't that good using her voice. For me, a bad singer is the person who does not have musicality in its vocals... Just that. I'd love Tiffany debuting in the US, there, everyone would like her better!

[@SwiftieCatLover]

The reason she sounds like this is because her schedule is jam packed. She had to do the Phantasia thing with SNSD at the same time l she was shooting Unnies Slam Dunk. She would have to fly back and forth to rehearse for the Slam Dunk girl group. She also has her own solo career now.

[@gabrieljesusatin136]

you guys are too hard with her, don´t you see all the music shows shes into right now? beside the fact all the performances shes been doing promoting this 2 singles. She definitely need to rest.

[@mypearlb5208]

Not really though

[@Kiirze]

Her solo activites affected her voice as it gets easily damaged. She just needs a lot of rest.

[@krystalle3119]

She does have a great voice and I find that her head voice sound great too but sometimes when she sings high notes with her chest voice it sound not so pleasant even if she is in her normal condition. She worked hard and improved her vocal a lot more so Fighting 💪💪💪 unnie you're my star

[@hageyangha7238]

Tiffany is gold😚

[@karen9398]

Tiffany is such a cutie with a kind heart and a wonderful voice, I don't think she deserves any hate

[@TranLe-ug3zv]

oh dear finally Heartbreak Hotel have live ㅠㅠ i hope i can see Tiffany and Ssam D on stage together ~~

[@cindynguyen3125]

I watched sister slam dunk and episode 9 or 10 and tiffany was really sick. is this the same when she is performing this? either she did well :) I like her performance in moon and sunrise

[@cutievelvets]

Is there any Eng subs for 7-10 so far I keep on looking but still can't find them, I really feel like I'm falling behind lol, I mean I could watch it with out but not the same satisfaction

[@cindynguyen3125]

MrsMarie Orton they only have it in Korean xD the English sub didn't come out yet! :3 just wait for a week or two. It would be out then xD

[@moochachax3]

+MrsMarie Orton there's eng sub for ep 7 atm on kshowonline! But that's it arm :(

[@jbmusic2000]

Heartbreak Hotel is still that song. One of Tiffany's best. ❤️

[@SnottyQ]

the last high note :(( pls take some rest

[@fiorentinephillips252]

strained a lot

[@syakirtaeyeon1308]

+Paradox 11 how can you call that strain , that's a perfect highnote using a head voice plus falsetto

[@esther1281]

+Syakir Taeyeon // i think the person meant it sounded like tiffany strained her voice for that note bc it does sound kimda strained. but tiff does a grea job either way :))

[@esther1281]

+Syakir Taeyeon // and i think the high note was the "heartbreak" one at the end

[@stephaniejumi2386]

I feel it too. :')

[@vminjjp6762]

i'm so proud of my queen

[@verenisefarro]

She ate the CD or what? She improve a lot!! Fanny Fighting!!!

[@MosPrasertpong]

OMG!! She's amazing. Her voice is really good in this show.

[@고온-g9u]

아저워댄나오고 바로 맴찢호텔 나와서 진짜 좋았는데 지금봐도 좋아

[@snowflake0606]

맴찢호텔 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@user-dz8ypio9tzm]

티파니처럼 자유분방한 젊은 여성이 60-70년대 뉴욕 밤거리를 춤추며 걷는 영화 한편 떠오르는 느낌! 티파니 감성보컬 굿

[@monniques9442]

This woman already debuted in America 😍😍😍😍

[@santagurl283]

Wow Tiffany so pretty and all her songs are my favorite so good 😱😱😍😍😍👏👍👍👍👍👍

[@angelboyangelboy7190]

I'm really proud because i'm a Sone, i love Tiffany 💖

[@rizzx445]

i am really proud and happy that tiffany is my bias in snsd . keep on making good music . we support you fany

[@lucasxyz100]

with a charming look won me over.

[@alvagies7071]

The best solo debut ever from an idol. LEGEND

[@yohanaw6751]

Such a great performance, tiff! Hwaiting ❤️

[@Mov239]

Tbh.... Korea didn’t deserve her. They way they just exiled her after her Snapchat post controversy. I’m glad she found some success in the US

[@taeyeonssmirk5211]

Watching this again. Her voice at 2:10 and 4:28 ugh i'm in love

[@AnnySoprano]

My princess looks so skinny :'( I wish she eats better

[@SwiftieCatLover]

I guess you don't know Fany that well. She eats SO much! That's why they call her Pink Pig!

[@gyuriousjang563]

yeah but shes also working so much lately. I hope she rest well :(

[@AnnySoprano]

Subin Kim No, she lost weight for her solo debut... Once she said that when she makes diet she doesn´t eat breakfast..

[@SwiftieCatLover]

+Anny, 애니 , アニー I never eat breakfast, but that doesn't constitute what I eat the rest of the day. There are A LOT of people who skip breakfast.

[@AnnySoprano]

Subin Kim skip breakfast is really bad.. just search it.. I have been in treatments with dieticians since I was ten..

[@Sunshine-fl7wo]

See? She had a mistake means she is not doing lipsync. She is just singing with some backtracks but it doesnt mean that she is a bad singer

[@menchiebondoc1501]

as much as i just wanna dance with tiffany, I also wanna slap this to haters' faces. says who that tiffany can't sing? 😛😏

[@catdogis]

Watching this and so confused about the comments on her voice...she literally ate this up. This is Tiffany’s vocal styling and you don’t need to defend it...although I’m sure by now with her solo work you all can tell.

[@NiallHoranXX1]

tiffany has and always had an amazing voice 💫 to those who had repeatedly doubted her singing capability, her mistake proves this is totally live and hence she CAN sing, and really well in fact!! 😍 I'm so proud of you, tiffany 💓 hope she gets enough rEST! ☹

[@xyz094]

your so gorgeous tiffany with a husky voice

[@jpstaeg7196]

Queen of pop

[@danitha98]

I don't care what others said about her voice, but i love her voice. She has a unique voice, a little highpitch, and a little smooth.

[@emiliaaezmin7817]

Tiffany you soo pretty😍😍😍😍😍

[@whitelily_2366]

Omg Tiffany looks so beautiful~❤

[@iamjj123]

her low note is such a blessing to the ear

[@ggayo1113]

Beautiful...💓💓

[@epxan1764]

that husky highnote so attractive, if i tell ya... i love it, if i sing in that voice, it will sound amazing for them

[@That.Capricorn]

Tiffany = Perfection.. Fighting unnie..

[@frankenlamb]

she's gorgeous... I still can't get over that..

[@kharismalutfi6579]

Omg tiffany is so beautifull

[@diegohann1413]

티파니 💞

[@lynn9527]

ahhh i wish she'd sing the entire of heartbreak hotel live it's so ?? good ???? and suits her vocal range ????? and her low voice is like . holy shit !! need more of this man

[@phanhoangminhthu1929]

Love the way she tried her best on slaying the high notes

[@rinawatidewi8579]

your voice is awesome Tiff😍

[@forever1803]

wow this was really really good. i mean honestly speaking though she is a good singer, i was never really impressed by her live singing. But this performance just proves that everybody is wrong about her not being able to sing live. Love you Tiffany. a sone forever

[@eurekashieldtheark5359]

It is sad.. her bad performance got more views than her good performance.. people just wanna hate..

[@darthhwang8382]

She looks absolutely stunning...

[@it34santiagomariadenises.22]

I like her vocals in this performance 💞😍

[@jmmini6708]

Amazing performance. You did well Fany fany Tiffany!!! 👏👏👏

[@andersonlira1106]

I live for her, she is so amazing.

[@BriskSundew-cl4ug]

one of the best station songs.

[@loving_mads]

her husky voice,,,

[@szewan1301]

Tiffany so beautiful✨😍💕

[@t_wicej5500]

yay Tiffany unnie us the best!

[@kimyoungwon7891]

Forever love Tiffany( 티파니 )

[@xyz094]

Tiffany you deserve an international career. Hope you can penetrate western. Just keep it up🤗

[@KiKi-bd8gu]

Her backup dancers were feeling it! love the passionate dancing from them all.

[@ralffrankie1]

Very like Tiffany voice,she performance charm every stage , she has style ,make me come her world , anyway , she is one of the good Korea female singer now after taeyeon and come from snsd , and then , next week taeyeon comeback , wow

[@iduncareu]

although i love all of her solos but heartbreak hotel remains as my favourite song ever. you can hear she sings the song so raw, husky, full of emotions and passions like i can really feel her heartbreak yo.

[@jenniferlee4295]

Watch her other live performance of Moon and Sunrise.She slayed it 😘😘😘😘

[@gabrieljesusatin136]

Tiffany is gorgeous i love her!

[@saraholiveira5004]

omg high notes