Grief Seed - Madoka Bad Apple (Bad Apple audio)

[@Lightning3875]

Fun fact: Cristina Vee, the singer of the english cover of this song, is also the english voice actress for Homura!

[@Zedrinbot]

We don't talk about the dub

[@Lightning3875]

+Zedrin Why not? I really don't get why the majority of the fandom dislikes it.

[@Zedrinbot]

It leaves a lot to be desired. Didn't feel like there was any direction in the casting, nor a lot of voice direction in general.

[@stellacepttekai]

Hey I love dub! And really Homura?! That's awsome

[@natalyaepic7615]

I never knew that! That's crazy!

[@ゆう-e5i4m]

さや杏のところ鳥肌やばい

[@otyaduke01]

まえ 「白になる」 ここってあれですよね さや杏が一緒に死んじゃうやつだよね？

[@cyan9801]

1:50 鳥肌たちました

[@ゆめうさぎ-r9j]

泣きそうになりました…

[@豆大福-w5g]

こっち泣いちゃった

[@まい-z2s9y]

鳥肌と涙が自然に…(ガチめにうるっと来ました)

[@立石ミコノ]

まーた違和感がコンビニ行ったよ 素晴らしいとしか言えない ほんと技術がすごい

[@user-mh2tv7ct7u]

ミコノ提督 違和感「ファミチキください。」

[@懲戒職員な行]

「すみません違和感さん ファミチキ売り切れなんすよ」

[@user-mh2tv7ct7u]

違和感「じゃ、あんまんで」

[@懲戒職員な行]

「あんまん一つでよろしいでしょうか」

[@懲戒職員な行]

「あんまん一つで138円になりまーす」

[@Erias_immortal]

なんだこの違和感の無さは·······

[@クルリンパ-w5b]

杏子がりんご好きだからbad Appleにすごい合ってると思った。まさかbad Appleでまどマギを再現するとは。。。本当に素晴らしい👏

[@minori2799]

歌詞がなんとなく合ってる

[@orianacheney5823]

I love how similar the video is to the original Bad Apple shadow play, but still is perfectly independent and works with the theme of Madoka Magica.

[@shiyaku_micro]

まどマギのアニメの内容が全て詰まってる…(;_;)

[@iloveaftertherain2704]

マミさんあの性格があだになって ホーリーマミになったんかなー？

[@MrBronx819]

I love Sayaka's sinister smile at 0:55

[@thesaucypickle9866]

the reference made me sad

[@79raiiikakera]

it's pretty terrifying

[@ilyasbasuki3207]

This is the only Bad Apple animation that rivals the original. Great job!

[@lostspeller2055]

So fat this is a strong contender

[@lostspeller2055]

+I liek cats far*

[@alois9206]

Ilyas Basuki Indeed

[@avarixe1932]

Yeah as if. I'm still sticking with touhou project

[@elysium8131]

poor transitions, unoriginal song, lower fps as if

[@nina2761]

This is practically telling the entire story of Madoka Magica. How everyone became magical girls, and how Homura is a dark person forcing herself into the light, and how Madoka is pure person forcing herself into the darkness.

[@Ana-tq2if]

I don't know why Homura is a bad person and why she's forcing herself into the light

[@Riobjection]

@@Ana-tq2if I'm not sure at all but for me it means (for Homura): Y'know all the thing that she do to save Madoka, I think she's really sad and dessesperate (I think that's why she's dark) but want Madoka to live more than everybody (and I think this is why the background is white. It's kind of her only reason to live and the only thing that makes her determinate I think)

[@Ana-tq2if]

@@Riobjection ty for answer ;3

[@Riobjection]

@@Ana-tq2if you're welcome i guess? :,) x) (by the way, sorry if I made mistakes, I'm not english so yeah ^^' I try my best :,))

[@heartsfirstaidkit]

True!

[@焼きたまごちゃん]

超久々に見にきた！！！ 正直まどマギの物語細かくまで 思い出せないのに涙がぼろぼろでてくるのは 私の潜在意識の中にナニかが組み込まれてるのか……？

[@脚立星人]

最後のまどかとほむらのシーン まどかが黒のバックに白で自分の存在が消えてまってもほむらを救いたいという思い ほむらが白のバックに黒で魔女になることのない希望の世界の中、まどかを失った絶望なんかな… 追記　個人的に好きなのは１番の終わりくらいで手を伸ばしてた杏子とさやかは手を繋げたかわからないけど２番でしっかり繋いでたとこすこ

[@ラー油-t3j]

考察力の塊なの……？

[@灰島透夜]

まどマギをよく理解していらっしゃる

[@user-yw4lr1fu8v]

せんせぇぇぇぇぇぇぇー違和感くんが仕事サボってまぁぁぁぁぁす

[@salmon8292]

月島アイキ (先生)そうですねぇ違和感君にはあとで反省文を書くように言っておきます。

[@シルヴィーン聖羅]

秀音暗殺者 違和感くん）い、い、違和感しかなかったし！

[@tofidu]

Hi mark

[@hellodesutopia8865]

しょうがない。

[@闇風-z1d]

先生違和感君が息をしてません(´；ω；`)

[@user-qq2el8ot1x]

ヤバイさやかの「私は私それだけ」で鳥肌立ったw

[@0_0.bannou]

0:54かな？

[@지수영-c2o]

지수영 오늘 날씨 정말 좋네요 일 오전 서울 국회 귀빈식당에서 오늘 하루도

[@지수영-c2o]

지수영 했습니다 오늘 날씨 정말 좋다 좋아 좋아 좋아 너무 좋아 좋아 하는 것이 아니다 더 많이 와서 와서 좀 하고 살자 있는 것이 아닙니다 오늘 오늘 오늘

[@惠心Megumi]

I like how at the end, the Soul Gem falls into the hands of goddess Madoka, and the Grief Seed in Homura's hands, foreshadowing their fates.

[@湯香ユッカ]

何だコレ...クオリティやべえ

[@harumaki_kogorou]

まどマギへの愛が詰まってる……素敵

[@メアリー-c4c]

まどかに手を伸ばすほむらちゃん切ない…

[@虫さんが走る-o8h]

好きすぎる…最後アルまどとほむらのとこ感動した

[@こむぎ娘-c7g]

すごい！すごいです！ これで、バットアップルすきになっちゃいました

[@TheAdmiralAnnie]

Madoka Magica explained in a Bad Apple video...

[@keiko6939]

so true

[@yukisuki6765]

Ikr

[@ChimeraLotietheBunny]

Lovely work of stuff for the Madoka Magika version yes

[@CHoMu_AMeMe]

最後ほむほむの髪にまどかのリボンついてるのが原作に忠実でめっちゃ好きやわ

[@七須川美麻]

最初見たときに感動したけど､歌詞を見るとまさにまどマギぽくて さらに流れる歌詞とキャラがぴったりしてて… 私にとって神ユーザーです!!

[@熊之助-e8r]

｢知らないわ周りのことなど 私は私それだけ｣でさやかはピッタリ だな

[@闇風-z1d]

歌詞 考察 もし変えるなら白にする→ アルティメットまどかの願い全ての魔女、魔法少女を無かったことにする変えるから 全て壊すなら黒にする→ 悪魔ほむらのはんぎゃくの物語のあの行動みたいな感じだと・・・ 歌詞めっちゃ合ってますね

[@Twig_e13]

The very end where Madoka catches the Soul Gem and Homura gets the Grief Seed......WHY DO YOU PLAY WITH MY FEELS?! ;_;

[@Zedrinbot]

Because suffering ／人◕ ‿‿ ◕人＼

[@NomNombom]

​@@Zedrinbot Being Maguca was (?) suffering and the suffering has a high risk of spreading, correct?

[@MrPanda_Cake]

Watching this made me remember Kyoko really likes apples. :D

[@sultonaaa7643]

Darkgodaphex OMG your right! I never even thought of that! :D

[@darthutah6649]

L do you know? Kyoko loves apples.

[@sonnywijaya1112]

Yup, even a bad one! (A pun, a terrible one. Im sorry)

[@gamernanami914]

Which Kyoko Kyoko Sakura Or Kyoko Kirirgiri?

[@idontknowlogic7428]

gamer nanami Kyoko Sakura

[@ChisanaKitsune]

This is just beautiful v . v

[@フッキー-q5y]

今更ながらおすすめに出てきたので視聴 朝から見るもんじゃなかった…鳥肌やばい

[@monicazabolio7413]

I understand how hard this animation is to use and you did great good job :)

[@DeathsBestBitch]

1:05 Madoka's bitch walk really pissed me off for some reason. The animation is perfect (especially considering how hard MMD is) but holy fuck I just am mad.

[@melonii]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@Wondermimimi]

hahaaaa

[@hesperishere]

+DeathsBestBitch "bitch walk" IM LAUGHING MY ASS OFF X,DDDDD SHE LOOKS LIKE THAT ONE TITAN FROM AOT OMFG HAHAHA

[@annaxxbabaxxx8810]

OMG WTF XD

[@annaxxbabaxxx8810]

+Elly TheWeird Now I'm laughing even harder XD

[@Zedrinbot]

Thanks for the likes and comments! For those curious, there is a vocal accompaniment coming for this video, I've just been waiting on a few vocalists to get their recording issues sorted out, which has been taking longer than expected. I've had a few people asking if they could use my animation for their own lyrics, so (at least for now) I need to decline. The vocals version will feature some updates to the animations/sequences to buff out any of the errors I missed before, and enhance some of the shots. Once it's out, as it will be the original music/animation mixture, I'll be more open to letting others use my video for their own variations and derivations in lyrics. Madokami bless u all.

[@Zedrinbot]

Just a little update: Sorry it's been taking so long. Took longer than expected to get the audio, and by the time I got it another, more pressing project came up. I'm gonna be working on this again some time mid May. The audio's recorded and only a few scenes need to be fixed so it shouldn't take too long.

[@second_second_]

Wow, this song really fits, especially with Homura and Madoka. You're a genius in realizing this

[@無名名無し-x5i]

今まで見たやつの中で一番違和感ないし、合っててめっちゃいいな

[@user-zi2eh4bd4t]

THIS IS AMAZING! OH MY GOSH!!!

[@user-zi2eh4bd4t]

Madoka magica, its on netflix

[@shalqouirenchante5457]

What's netflix?? Lol.

[@user-zi2eh4bd4t]

Jordan Dogedrill netflix is....netflix

[@shalqouirenchante5457]

Lol.I knoq what it is.

[@Jacknom-u9v]

突然トップに出てきた。 なにこれ？スゴすぎ！ 影とストーリーが頭の中で同調して鳥肌立ちっぱなしだった

[@Zedrinbot]

Soon. A year late maybe, but soon.

[@HyperCobaltMax]

This is spectacular. Awe inspiring for the sheer detail of the art of this video. Also, this fits a lot to Homura and even more so that there is an English version of this song which was sang by her English VA herself.

[@kcn8896]

鳥肌たつた

[@starblue5369]

222 タツタ？

[@さなえ-l9p]

きっとわざとなんだよ…… たつたあげ的な

[@mikasan._.b]

@@さなえ-l9p いやネタじゃないでしょ

[@user-rw1yu8li5m]

ぼんしょ つまんな

[@田中-v1m7d]

美味しそう

[@madi4432]

AWESOMENESS FREAKING AWESOME EXPLOSIONS OVER HERE!!!

[@aranoyas]

ほむらがまどかに手をのばす時すげー鳥肌立った!

[@collectorsessentials]

This is RIDICULOUSLY AWESOME! :O Great job!

[@BreezeVideos]

this is really awesome! 0:53 my fav part!

[@fat8946]

SAME!!!!

[@bluelight454]

same here!!! I like how it's creepy

[@katiehradek8503]

Awesome. I love this.

[@Somnio64]

i dont think you understand how awesome this is to me. Puella Magi Madoka Magica is my favorite show and Bad Apple is my favorite song! thank you very much for one of the best music videos ever!!!

[@Zedrinbot]

Oh, I think I do understand, because I'm the same way. ;D Hence why I made the video.

[@kristinajones5223]

This really followed the plot of this whole show I liked it

[@yuuh1357]

とてもかっこいい！ 最後の２人のシーンが最高でした。

[@screamforicecream3]

I don't even have words to express how awesome this was. It's one of the best video's I've watched.

[@Admetrix]

This video was made so perfectly. The yin-yang at the end is exactly what MM was all about too. Props and a like to you sir!

[@kristinema6134]

OMG I LOVE MADOKA MAGICA AND BAD APPLE :O THIS IS AMAZING. BEST THING I'VE FOUND ALL DAY

[@中国スキ]

1:20 見覚えありすぎて(本家ed)辛い....。ほむらの悲しい声が聞こえてきそう。

[@blackrockshooterkuori6889]

very nicely done I love it

[@amalsoappickle]

I haven't seen medoka in a while so this brings back memories

[@dionbakerjr.8736]

Too beautiful for words.

[@百推し丸]

「知らないわ 周りのことなど 私は私それだけ 」のところで歯車を歩くほむらちゃん………。 いくつの時間軸を見捨てて(諦めて)来たんだよ…(´TωT｀)

[@AyaMatsuo]

Miss this song. My favourite

[@shadowstarblitz9379]

I loved the contrast of black and white, and that even though there weren't any colors you could still see a lot of their emotions. Awesome job!

[@bigakudou]

Be impressed! It is a wonderful video! I did not know that there is "Madoka ☆ Magica" version of this series. I am a fan of "Madoka ☆ Magica". I'm very happy.

[@codingpikachu3333]

3:19 Wow. Amazing portrayal of Madoka and Homura next to each other, yet in negative colour of each other...

[@ruru9809]

OhmygodtheFEELS!!! Aaaah this is so awezome!! I love it! Really good work!

[@sparkle1princess]

0:54 has got to be my favorite part of the whole video.

[@PhoenixPrime]

Yo, I had no idea you did this! I love this anime! Great job on this animation, Z! :D

[@BedrockSolid]

So I learned about Touhou over one year ago, then I watched Madoka Magica last week. This makes so much sense now compared to one year ago xD

[@かののんさん]

かっこよすぎませんか…？

[@fizzbee5137]

It is just Madoka Magica in a nutshell!

[@letrieuphong]

Speechless. This is pure gold!

[@julice22jw]

I like the video and the song ;D good job. The best scene is Kyoko extending her hand to sayaka :D

[@SangoProductions213]

holy cow..... very well done, and the outlines were done well enough that I could fairly easily tell which characters they were portraying despite only seeing it once, about a year ago. Well done.

[@galila6735]

I just realized that kyubey eats magical girls

[@salehakanwal2045]

O_o... what???

[@thesaucypickle9866]

just there souls

[@chibimysticaldragon4300]

*Sudden realization*

[@deimeh8464]

Welcome to Madoka Magica. Being meguca is suffering.

[@ladynoname3621]

@@thesaucypickle9866 noo the grief seeds the CONTAINS the magical girls' souls is eaten by Kyubey

[@빔빔-v1p]

아니...너무 잘만드셨는데 세상에..bbbbb

[@mn-zk6qd]

素晴らしいです！

[@GHAST_dayo]

｢全て壊すの｣って歌詞があるところで｢全ての魔女を産まれる前に消し去りたい｣と願ったまどかの姿が現れる所が好き

[@alexapeterjohn5505]

I love all of the Kyousayaness XD. Kyoko is my absolute favorite :D

[@霧雨魔理沙-k3o]

クールでかっこいい！聴いた瞬間鳥肌たちました。

[@まったりなふらん]

さやかと杏子はやはり神です

[@brandonkheang]

I couldn't help but smile like an idiot the whole time while watching. You sir, just made my day. This is too awesome.

[@西住まほ-v6e]

ｽｯ､ｽｹﾞｰ!!Σ(ﾟДﾟ ) まさに神業！！

[@れーみあ]

控えめに言って神 まどマギの内容によく合ってるし技術がすごい

[@-yusui5600]

いいねぇ

[@tenshibana]

Very well done ! PMMM is my favorite anime and I absolutly love Touhou, so I'm really pleased to see this :)

[@literallyasuka2996]

I'M HAPPY THAT THIS VIDEO WAS UPLOADED ON MY BIRTHDAY

[@nat6877]

Happy (Late) Birthday~!

[@literallyasuka2996]

@@nat6877 Thank you!

[@EddyCreations]

I have seen so many versions of this song and video and this has to be one of the most creative one I have seen at the moment

[@KazuhaEien]

Missed opportunity to use the English cover by Homura's dub actress... But still awesome! :D

[@Mauroevolution]

...Just beautiful!!

[@空見乃愛総合管理官]

凄すぎるんだが・・・!

[@StormsandSaugeye]

The use of negative space to really concentrate the focus, rotating and presenting action in a stylistic manner really is what makes these videos so perfectly done.

[@sunnymoon27]

watching this again actually made me cry (a bit). they really need a season two.

[@PJO_P]

No, they don't. If you've seen rebellion, you'd understand.

[@KamuiKunitsuna]

THEDEMONICCONDOM They could turn the other two manga series into anime though. Or at least Kazumi.

[@Zedrinbot]

Actually I think that Rebellion set things up for a subsequent season, so I think it's possible. Not that I wouldn't mind an anime adaptation of 'The Different Story' because that had an amazing plot.

[@ステラババア-b2q]

すげえな(語彙力)

[@VeilanYume]

This video describes all of Madoka in a nutshell...except for Rebellion. That's probably for the better, though, considering how screwed up I was after Rebellion.

[@PJO_P]

But rebellion was amazing!

[@VeilanYume]

Yes it was, all the way up until Homura's, erm, "transformation" into that new Mahou Shoujo form referred to as "Homucifer" by certain fans. Then I felt like my mind was getting screwed over.

[@PJO_P]

You know why she became that, right?

[@VeilanYume]

More or less.

[@PJO_P]

Well, to make it a little more clear. She wanted to keep Madoka's existing so she "dethroned" her and created a new world where they all exist together, and only Sayaka and partially Madoka remember anything. Basically she became the opposite of Madoka, who represented selfless love, and now Homura is the embodiment of selfish love or Homucifer, which is why she told Madoka that they are now "enemies."

[@asdfghjkl9532]

This is really cool and amazing!! I love it so much!!!

[@LimeyLassen]

This is really really cool. I'd say the lyrics are a better fit here than in Touhou. XD

[@anoekh8371]

You're right

[@matthewpatasnik2361]

That's definitely true. I'm starting to wonder if Madoka should have been first.

[@ohdudethatsepic9615]

It did? But in touhou you actually do wander around at night and it makes you ask when the day will come xD

[@Th3Sh1n1gam1]

You might not know enough Touhou. 0:30 Patchy, she lives inside a library, a place where time continues in a world whenever she reads the book containing that world and as she keep looking at it the characters dance round and round. 0:37 Remillia can't even see her own feelings even though her power is to "Control Destiny" because she can't decide what she wants for herself, she ends up not caring about what happens (after her incident) 0:47 Sakuya, she has her own story about not being able to control when she stops time sometimes. 0:52 Flandere for the first time in 500 years she was finally released from her room and she didn't care about anything but having fun for herself. 1:00 Youmu For the first time in her life she saw a normal human (marisa) enter the world of the dead and couldn't believe it. being half human herself she told marisa to go back to the living world but in the end it didn't matter. 1:04 Yuyuko She killed herself in order to seal the Saigyouji Ayakashi (the tree) because like herself, it possesed the power to kill people based on its will. Not wanting to deal with the sadness of her power to control death, she killed herself and sealed away the tree and lost her memories so that she wouldn't have any regrets for what she did, such as leaving behind her best friend yukari. 1:14 Komachi, very much known for slacking off on the job and not listening to her master, yama. 1:20 Yama, she knows the judgement of things without even having to try them in a hearing and can declare them as black or white. 1:30 Mokou, she is originally a human that turned immortal to exact revenge, but over time her revenge has lost its reason so it seems that she has no true purpose left. 1:36 Keine, she has a split personality during the time of the moon. 1:43 Eirin, the only person she can care for is Kaguya 1:48 Kaguya, she had a change of personality and is no longer the evil woman that mokou wanted to kill.(Hence mokou losing her reason to exact revenge) 2:11 Sanae (on the same lyrics as patchy) she came from a world where time flowed differently and when she finally came here, her reality changed to the fictitious realities she read inside books and saw within movies. 2:16 Suwako and Kanako were eternal enemies at some point but eventually none cared about the conflict about who became the goddess of the shrine. 2:25 Yukari, story suggests that all gap youkai that open gaps were originally humans that fell through a gap of time and through that gap they became able to open their own gaps(story suggests that she was maribelle). 2:28 Tenshi, literally doesn't care about anything, hence the incident of Touhou 10.5 scarlet weather where her presence literally caused the destruction of many locations through the weather. 2:38 Aya, she's a newsgirl that makes newspapers, but nobody ever reads them. 2:44 Suika, she's known for having multiple bad relationships, but acts as a cheerful character anyways while she drinks away her thoughts of those people (Such as Kasen) 2:53 Alice is known for always continuously moving her dolls, almost subconsciously and so it fits that her heart always seems to be somewhere else. 2:59 Nitori made a move to made the Fusion Reactor Core and Hissoutensoku and look at what happened. 3:06 Yuuka... don't mess with her flowers, she'd destroy it all for revenge. The rest, I actually don't know the th5 and older storylines... sooo~ But yeah... pssh, saying that the madoka characters matched it more than the touhou characters it was made for, you crazy, lol.

[@Zedrinbot]

Th3Sh1n1gam1 Plus if it didn't match Touhou more it'd defeat the purpose of the cover that's been in progress. xD

[@森のオオカミ]

完成度たけぇ…

[@Sakuralexis]

oh! really good animation! not likes we others fanmade who ad lazy animation, your's is really beautiful!

[@Zedrinbot]

be sure to watch the updated one btw :V kzbin.info/www/bejne/hJC9aWB-i716fdE i fixed up some errors and made it all a little smoother, and edited some scenes

[@coolcat889]

Nopenopenopenoepnope Ok then. Now that my feels are gone, let's crack down. I love the way you incorporated the music from Bad Apple, most of the ideas from the music video, but you still added a whole new screenplay. Well done.

[@aviona123]

omg sayaka's smile

[@cookie5377]

Oh my god this looks amazing! The animation is very smooth, well done! :D

[@PJO_P]

Holy shit this is awesome.